Calm Abiding — 2013-03-06

1 h 51 min · 6,005 words · 6 March 2013 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Calm Abiding (Khensur Rinpoche)
Calm Abiding (Khensur Rinpoche)
Calm Abiding — 2013-03-06
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 111-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche opens with a patient facing six months to live, framing why Buddhist practice cannot wait. He introduces bodhicitta—the altruistic aspiration to benefit all beings—as essential preparation. The core explains calm abiding (śamatha): the nine mental stages of concentration, five faults (laziness, forgetting instructions, sinking, agitation, untimely antidotes) and eight antidotes. Practical instructions cover maintaining focus on an object, handling mental obscurations through reflection on impermanence and suffering, and taming the mind like an elephant through recollection and vigilance. Rinpoche emphasizes that calm abiding alone cannot free us; insight into emptiness—the selflessness of persons and phenomena—must follow for liberation. A final Q&A addresses visualization, effort versus wisdom, and consciousness. For practitioners with prior meditation experience.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2013-03-06 – KR.mp3

UUID: 9b401f4f-ceaf-4874-a4bd-aa0046a8bdde

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Calm Abiding

Date: 2013-03-06

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~6,010

As well as dispelling suffering in both present and future lives. Although there are numerous Buddhist treatises which teach means to attain happiness and to eliminate suffering, we shall at present focus on the explanations in Kamalaśīla’s Bhāvanākrama or stages of meditation. And if in addition to attending the teachings we are able to put in practice whatever we have heard, there will be definite benefit. However, if we do not put the teachings into practice and merely study them in the same way as we’d receive an education, it will be difficult for them to yield benefit. And therefore, whenever you have time during the day, definitely take a break and try to meditate.

And for this, it is important to be in good health and to have a healthy and healthy body. As Candrakīrti says in the Madhyamakāvatāra, it is at present when we have obtained a state of good fortune that we should put effort otherwise in the future, it will be difficult for us to do so. The meaning of this passage is that at present, when we have obtained a human rebirth, is the time we should put effort in our practice in the future. When this may no longer be the case, it will be difficult to do so. To give an example to illustrate this, when we are walking on the side of a steep cliff, we have to be very careful not to fall off the cliff into the underlying ravine.

Because once we have fallen into the ravine, it will be very difficult to get out of it. Tanzin and Geshe-la received a telephone call from the hospital from a patient who wished to see them. This patient had just been told by his doctor he had no more than six months to live. And precisely because he had only six months, he or she had only six months left to live, this person fully aware of the limited amount of time at his disposal was ready to do whatever it took to transform his mind during that period. And he therefore asked Geshe-la to explain to him how to eliminate suffering at present during the six months left for him to live and how to avoid them in the future.

And while it was possible for Geshe-la to give him some advice on how to reduce his short term suffering. It is very difficult to do anything to relieve the long-term suffering of a person since this depends mainly on one’s own practice. Then he requested for some information on how to get a higher rebirth and to be free from suffering. Then I said to him there is no other means to do this except taking refuge, generating renunciation and bodhicitta within the mind stream. Then at first, when I met him, he was unable to speak because of his tremendous inner turmoil and suffering and kept sobbing while he was talking.

Then I said to him, apart from what I have said to you, there is nothing else I can do. Much of the great inner turmoil and suffering he was experiencing came from the awareness that he had not spent well the time leading up to then. It is impossible for any one of us in this room to say that he or she will not die before this man, in other words, before six months’ time, nor can we say with certainty that we will die after him. We have complete uncertainty regarding the time of our own death. And therefore, keeping within our mind the realization that our death is definite, it is certain, it has already been decided, and that the time of our death is totally unknown will be of tremendous benefit for impelling us towards practice.

The main factor for being happy at the time of death is to have become accustomed during one’s life to the practice of virtue so that one can recollect it and train in virtue in the death process. Then if we are able to die in a virtuous state of mind, there is no doubt that we will have a happy rebirth. And therefore I gave this patient advice on how to generate these virtuous states of mind and there seems to have been some benefit in the short term. However, in reality, to be able to have such a virtuous state of mind at death, one must train for it while one is healthy. However, in dependence on the mere advice which I gave him, it will be difficult for him to generate a virtuous state of mind at the time of death.

And therefore the great difficulties which you are undergoing in coming to the Center for Teachings after work during a period where you are hale and hearty will definitely be of benefit at the time of your death. And Buddha Śākyamūni explained clearly the nature of the afflictions which trouble, which deluged, and which cause the mind to be hallucinated. For this reason, so that our minds not be troubled at the time of death, it is important for us at present to study carefully the Buddhist teachings. This is, what I wish for at least. All of us are the same in this matter.

Specifically for the teachings which will be explained today, they are of extensive benefit if they are held with the mind of bodhicitta. And this is a motivation which thinks I will be engaging in practice in these teachings with the goal or with the reason of setting all sentient beings in the state of full enlightenment. bodhicitta is therefore a state of mind which relinquishes oneself and cherishes others. There is tremendous benefit in relinquishing or discarding oneself and cherishing others. Buddha Śākyamūni at his inception was similar to us.

However, through relinquishing himself and through cherishing others, he eventually became a being who had abandoned all faults and actualized all qualities. self-cherishing or egoism is the foremost cause for all of the suffering we experience. Cherishing others or altruism is the main cause for all of our qualities. As is said in the stanza of the Guru Puja, the Lama Chöpa, egoism is the door or the gateway of all thoughts. All altruism is the root of all qualities.

Therefore, through egoism all thoughts arise, whereas through altruism all qualities arise. It is because of egoism. It is because of self-cherishing which has arisen within our mind that we engage in the non virtues such as slaying others and so forth. Likewise, the powerful mental conceptions which arise when we reflect about the wealth or the prosperity of others. These come mainly from egoism.

On the other hand, through altruism, through a mind which, for instance, cherishes the life of other beings, numerous benefits in turn accrue for ourselves. And in dependence on such an altruism, let alone one’s wealth, it is one’s very body which one is ready to donate for the sake of others. In brief, altruism is our best friend. It is that which best takes care of our interests, whereas egoism is our worst foe. And let us therefore meditate at present for one minute on generating a bodhicitta which wishes to benefit all beings through relinquishing egoism and training in altruism.

What was explained in the previous sessions were the means of engaging in meditation on both calm abiding and on insight as well as the prerequisites for these meditations and the so called sevenfold posture of Vairochana. It is when these prerequisites are assembled that we can attain calm abiding. When we speak of attaining calm abiding, we are mainly speaking of training in concentration. Concentration is naturally present in all our minds. It is through enhancing the naturally present concentration in the mind that eventually calm abiding can arise.

And when one trains concentration so that eventually it transforms into calm abiding, there are nine mental stages which occur. These nine mental stages are the nine stages during which the factor of concentration increases. They have no other specific meaning. And to train through these nine mental stages, one must eliminate the five so called faults by means of the eight antidotes. The first of the five faults is laziness.

Unfortunately, we have been practicing laziness extensively and it arises whenever we wish to meditate on concentration as a systematic reticence to engage in concentration. Laziness is a particularly problematic opponent because not only does it prevent us from starting to train in concentration, but once we have started, it hinders our progress. The second fault is forgetting the instructions. It is very problematical because to train in concentration, we must recollect the instructions of our guru, of our teacher. And when we start training in concentration, this thought of forgetting the instructions causes us to forget them.

Specifically, the loss of the object of observation of concentration which amounts to forgetting the instructions of the spiritual teacher is known as forgetting the instructions. The third fault is sinking and agitation together. When we are training in concentration and the object of observation loses its clarity, lethargy sets in and one even is at the point of falling asleep, this is a clear sign of the presence of sinking. And this is a big problem when one studies at work because when one studies difficult topics, eventually one’s mind wanders away from the topic, thinking sets in and one actually sinks on the text one is studying. Apart from having contact with the text with your forehead, there’s no realization.

And therefore, when sinking increases, lethargy becomes present in the mind and one must counter both sinking and lethargy. Sinking specifically is an impediment in which the factor of abiding of the object of observation is present, but the factor of clarity is not fully present. Agitation, on the other hand, is that outwards movement of the mind which is distracted towards a previously ascertained object of desire. For instance, if we observe when we were walking along the road something beautiful which gave rise to desire within our mind, then after that when we meditate and train in Samādhi in concentration, the mind leaves the object of observation and wanders away towards that object of desire. This is agitation.

We need a sentinel which is able to ascertain whether or not sinking or agitation occur. This sentinel is vigilance, in Tibetan. Then as soon as the sentinel of vigilance realizes that either sinking or agitation is occurring, it immediately applies the requisite antidote. The fourth fault is the non application of such an antidote. The fifth fault is the intemperate application of the antidote which occurs when one has attained a stable state of concentration in which it is unnecessary to apply the antidotes and yet one applies them intemperately.

These five faults are countered by the eight antidotes. The antidotes to the first fault laziness are fourfold. Whereas the remaining four of the five faults each has one antidote, which makes eight. However, we will enter into great detail into this presentation during the remaining three teachings. Geshe-la plans to do this very elaborately.

Then Geshe-la must continue with the actual body of the text. Otherwise, would be very odd if he left the body of the text to focus on something later on. The first step in training in concentration is once one has selected an object of observation to focus the mind on that object of observation and no longer to abandon it. For beginners such as ourselves, Geshe-la in his own case, it is difficult to place the mind on its object of observation for more than a minute or so. Then when the mind wanders away, one has to bring it back to the object of observation.

And then progressively over time, the mind is more and more focused on its object of observation and eventually one attains calm abiding. The non-Buddhist yogis can attain calm abiding on objects such as twigs or other exterior objects. However, Je Tsongkhapa has taught that there is uncommon purpose in focusing on a representation of the Buddha. The advantages are twofold. The first is that through training in concentration on a representation of the Buddha, one accumulates merit.

And the second advantage is that in so doing, later on, one sets down the prerequisites for training in the visualization practices of tantra. When focusing the mind on such an object of observation through the power of vigilance, one systematically must check whether sinking or agitation occurs with respect to the object. When one notices through the power of vigilance that a lack of clarity has set in leading to lethargy and even to sleep. This is a sign that the fault of sinking has arisen and one must at this point apply the antidote to sinking which is either to reflect on the qualities of the Buddhas or on something which uplifts the mind. Sinking entails a drop in the height or if you wish, the energy level of the mind.

And one therefore must elevate the height or the energy level of the mind through, for instance, reflecting on the fact that one has a precious human rebirth or a something which causes happiness. If we feel during our practice of concentration as someone who is blind, someone who is squinting in the dark or who can barely see, this is clearly the sign of the appearance of sinking. And since sinking is an obstruction to the attainment of calm abiding, to relinquish it, we must reflect on something which causes happiness or uplifts the mind. On the other hand, when the mind is attracted outwards to objects of distraction, for instance, to movies or to shows, then this is a clear sign that agitation has occurred. When the mind is scattered outwards, the best way to bring it back is to reflect that the attractive object towards which it is attracted is impermanent and transitory, changing instant by instant.

Or to reflect that these objects, these outer objects of desire towards which our mind is attracted are of the nature of suffering. Reflecting on impermanence and suffering is of tremendous benefit to relinquish desire. We can see for ourselves that at first when we buy a brand new car, there is tremendous desire in our mind for this car. Then as the car ages gradually and loses its luster, the desire for it within our mind fades. Likewise, when we have just bought a brand new house, tremendous desire is present in our mind for the house.

Then over time, we can see that as the house changes and needs repairs, that desire is going to disappear. Then there is very great risk at first that with a brand new car and a brand new house, we would want to keep them locked up in a safe. However, just as persons, are impermanent and transitory, they do not remain and progressively disappear. And therefore, reflect when you are assailed by desire for objects or persons that they are impermanent and transitory, changing by instant by instant, and that they are of the nature of suffering since they arise from impure causes. And then through vigilance, checking whether the mind which is attempting to focus on its object of observation is beset either by sinking or by agitation.

Should either of these be present, the force of reconnection then reconnects the mind to its object of observation and thus one trains in concentration. In the self same way as a crazed elephant must be restrained by the hook of the mahut. And therefore tying the elephant to the post of the object of concentration with the rope of both recollection and vigilance. A mind is akin to the elephant. And the object of observation is the post to which the elephant is tied.

Then tying the elephant to this post, he cannot wander away from it. Likewise, if the mind is fastened to the post of the object of observation by the rope of recollection and of vigilance, it cannot wander away from it. Recollection is that powerful force in the mind which holds the object of observation. Once through these both sinking and agitation have been dispelled, the mind can focus well on the object of observation. Then at this point, the mind remains on the object of observation in a relaxed fashion since sinking and agitation have been dispelled.

And it remains on the object of observation for however long we wish it to do so. Even if you can do it only for one minute, please do it for one minute. However, if one wishes it to stay on the object of observation for one hour, one day, or one week, it does so. Then training in this way, eventually one attains both physical and mental pliancy and calm abiding. And when the mind is focused in this way for however long one wishes it to do so on the object of observation, a feeling of both physical and mental bliss, physical and mental pliancy arises.

Then calm abiding has been obtained. Then having obtained calm abiding, one should meditate on insight. In the context of this treatise, when we speak of insight, we are speaking of an insight focused on the selflessness of persons and the selflessness of phenomena. Such an insight focused on emptiness is important, otherwise we cannot abandon cyclic existence. Therefore, we should put effort in training in such an insight.

Whatever the Buddha taught to beings, either explicitly or implicitly, was intended to lead them to an insight realizing emptiness. Whenever such an insight which is focused on emptiness is generated within the mind stream, it is possible to abandon the door of sufferings to cyclic existence. However, merely through meditating on calm abiding, it is neither possible to abandon suffering nor to abandon the root of suffering. Through meditating therefore in this way on insight, it is possible to abandon all of the obscurations without exception and to attain the state of omniscience. And therefore, that wisdom which has become of the nature of an insight realizing emptiness abandons the obscurations and thereby through insight one attains omniscience.

And therefore, one should not be satisfied with merely attaining calm abiding thinking I will train in calm abiding until I attain it. Instead, one should view it as a prerequisite to the attainment of insight. Now in general, there is an insight which is shared or common with the non-Buddhist outsiders. In this context, we are referring to an insight which is not shared with non-Buddhist outsiders, which is uncommon in terms of its object. Generally speaking, the insight which is shared with the non-Buddhist outsiders, non-Buddhist yogis of India is an insight which arises within the context of having trained in calm abiding and which is able to differentiate the specific features of its object of observation.

Here, the uncommon insight which is referred to is an insight focused on an extremely subtle object, emptiness. The emptiness which is referred to here is the emptiness of self, of persons, and the emptiness of self, of phenomena. It is an insight which is focused on these two, which is to be trained in. This was taught by Buddha Śākyamūni in the Samdhinirmochana Sūtra. In this section of the Samdhinirmochana Sūtra, Ārya Avalokiteśvara asked Buddha Śākyamūni in which Dharma beings should train to be able to attain the state of full enlightenment, and Buddha answered they should train in insight.

And therefore, we should not be satisfied with merely obtaining calm abiding, thinking this is sufficient for us to attain happiness. Instead, we should after this train in insight. And therefore, Geshe-la will give some explanations on emptiness at present. There is no such thing as a person which exists independently of its aggregates, of its sources and of its constituents. Is there such a thing as a person which can be posited apart from its aggregates.

There is no such thing. This treatise Bhāvanākrama was composed by Acharya Kamalaśīla, who was a Svatāntrika Mādhyamika. There are slight differences between his presentation and that of From Kamalaśīla’s standpoint, there is a meeting of both the imputation of personhood upon the aggregates and the aggregates which are the basis on which this imputation occurs. It is on the basis of this collection that the person arises. And he posits as the main source within these five aggregates, the fifth aggregate, the aggregate of consciousness.

And therefore, from one’s own side, one imputes the term person on the five aggregates and specifically the aggregate of consciousness. And from the side of the aggregate of consciousness, there is the capacity to perform the activities of a person. The meeting of these two gives rise to a person. On the other hand, the non-Buddhist outsiders, the non-Buddhist outsiders assert that the person and the aggregates are different. The aggregates are transitory and change instant by instant.

The person on the other hand passes from life to life unchanged and therefore is permanent and unlike the aggregates cannot be subdivided into numerous parts. And therefore, they assert that the person and the aggregates are of different natures. There is no other way to present a person of a different nature than the aggregates. However, we can clearly see for ourselves that when we say I, there is an I which seems to be separate from the aggregates and which has power over the aggregates which dawns to the mind. Likewise, when we refer to someone called Trashi, we have the mental experience of a Trashi which is actually different from the aggregates which constitute Trashi.

These two are cases of the mind apprehending the inherent existence of things and are mistaken states of mind. Now regarding the selflessness of phenomena, Kamalaśīla asserts that mainly phenomena are none other than the factor of appearance of the mind. So when we refer to phenomena here, we are referring to what was mentioned previously, the five aggregates, the 12 sources and the 18 constituents. And to assert that they exist from their own side is inappropriate. They only exist as the appearing factor of the mind. And therefore they are only posited as the appearing factor of the mind whether we are speaking of forms, of sounds, of of smells and so forth.

Should there be a phenomenon which does not arise as the appearance factor of one’s interior mind, such a phenomenon would be characterized by the self of phenomena. This is precisely what does not exist. For instance, this is called a table. This table seems to exist from its own side in dependence on its own characteristics. But actually, it only exists at the meeting point of those characteristics which enable it to be a table and that mind as well as that visual consciousness which impute tableness on it.

Otherwise, if one tries to find table within the parts of table, it is unfindable. Therefore, the mode of existence of table overwhelmingly depends on the mind. Even though this table lacks existence This table actually seems to exist from its own side, and we have powerful conceptions to this effect. However, this table does not exist in the slightest from its own side. In the same way as horses and elephants which are seen within our dreams seem to exist as horses and elephants but do not exist in the way in which they appear to exist.

Likewise, the table appears to exist independently of the mind yet does not exist independently of the mind. For instance, you can see for yourselves if you try to observe Geshe-la’s table from a great distance that you will not see it in the way it actually exists. Right or not? Actually, this table in front of Geshe-la only exists from the standpoint of its relation to your own mind perceiving it and does not exist apart from it. Let alone the fact that forms and so forth are merely the appearing factor of the mind, the mind itself does not exist independently of mind.

And this is why Buddha Śākyamūni said, all three realms are of the nature or are mere mind. In other words, there is nothing which is not of the nature of mind. And therefore, one should reflect that all phenomena are merely the appearing factor of the mind, are merely of the nature of the mind. So one must analyze carefully here. Let alone forms not being established as a self of phenomena.

Likewise, the mind is not established as a self of phenomena. Since forms do not exist in the way in which they appear, they are said to be deceptive in as much as they do not exist in the way they appear. And since the mind is mistaken in apprehending differently the mode of existence and the mode of appearance of phenomena, the mind as well is said to be deceived. And since they do not exist in the way in which they appear, they can neither be truly one nor truly different. Likewise, our mind is not established as truly one nor truly different since its mode of abiding and of appearance are different.

Therefore, both the mental components are none other than of the nature of an illusion. They are called illusion like since in the same way as in a show or in a movie, the elephant or the horse which appear do not exist in the way in which they seem to appear. They are therefore illusion like. All phenomena which are not emptiness are akin to the elephant or the horse in a movie in that they are illusion like and their mode of existence and their mode of appearances are different. And therefore, it will become very clear when we analyze or we investigate carefully the mode of existence of conventional phenomena such as forms or minds that their modes of existence and their modes of appearance are different and that their mode of appearance does not exist in the slightest.

And therefore, it is said that a situation in which the mode of abiding and the mode of appearance of phenomena is identical, exists neither within ourselves nor on the outside nor within both. Likewise, there is no such situation in the mind in the past, the present or the future. Likewise, when the mind is first created, its mode of appearance and its mode of existence are not identical. Likewise, when the mind ceases, its mode of appearance and its mode of existence are not identical either. The mind therefore lacks an identity of its mode of appearance and its mode of abiding or existence and in addition is non material.

And Bodhisattva also therefore said, just as visible phenomena are but of the nature of the mind, likewise, non visible phenomena and non forms are but of the nature of the mind. This was said to the bodhisattva also. And when this Bodhisattva, Bodhisattva Visheshachinti asked the Buddha, how is this the case, the Buddha said that there is no situation in which the mind’s mode of appearance and the mind’s mode of abiding are found to be the same. And since there is no case in which the mode of abiding and the mode of appearance of the mind are found to be the same likewise, there is no case in which the mode of appearance of the object of the mind and the mode of abiding of the object of the mind are found to be the same. And the Buddha extensively taught that there is no occurrence within the past, the present or the future in which the mode of appearance and the mode of abiding of objects are concordant or identical.

And therefore it is said that in the beginning, the mind does not abide in a situation in which its mode of appearance and its mode of existence are identical. At the end, it does not abide in a situation in which its mode of appearance and its mode of existence are identical nor does it do so in the middle. And therefore, since our mind itself does not abide in a situation in which its mode of existence or its mode of abiding and its mode of appearance are identical, how could it be that whatever appears to the mind is in a situation in which its mode of existence and its mode of appearing are identical? And this is the case for all of the afflictions, the conception afflictions, anger, fear and so forth. It is the statements of the Buddha which Acharya Kamalaśīla interpreted.

There is no thought or no interpretation from my side. Very good. We will stop here for today. Please ask your questions. Well, if you want to attain calm abiding as was explained in the treatise, you have to set aside six months of your life continuously?

It’s a very short period of time. And taking those six months and excluding the time which is spent sleeping, eating and taking care of one’s bodily functions, the rest of the time must be exclusively dedicated to concentration. You can think today, you know, I’ll practice, but tomorrow is Sunday, so I’ll take a break. You’ve got to give up vacations. Yes, Judy, please.

Different. Generally speaking, Acharya Kamalaśīla accepts a mind-only view. However, his ultimate view is somewhat more subtle than that. Yogachara or the Cittamātra view as far as most of the designations were concerned. Yogachara and Cittamātra, mind only, are synonymous.

Thank you, Geshe-la. My question is regarding the five aggregates. And, it has come about because of my investigation into, a kind of being that could posit a self and a kind of being that couldn’t. For example, plants. My question is, regarding the five aggregates, it seems to be that modern science says that plants have form, feeling, and recognition.

It’s difficult for me to see how they could have compositional factors or consciousness. Now regarding the imputation of the self, is it this is it the comp compositional factors and the consciousness that are the sort of mechanism by which the self is imputed. I don’t know if that makes any sense at all. Don’t understand your question. Is your question about plants or about imputation?

It’s about it’s about imputation, but it came about because of doing some research into what plants can and can’t do. And it seems that well, they definitely have form. It seems they have feeling and it seems they have discrimination. So I thought that it must be the other two aggregates that enabled the self to be imputed. So Geshe-la is not quite sure how scientists establish that plants have feelings.

He suspect they probably ask them. But from his own side, he does not accept that plants have feelings. You know yours last week. I go to us. And he apologizes.

So Geshe-la does not have any experience in science in this matter, but according to the Buddhist treatises, plants do not have feelings, discrimination and so forth. However, in the same way as Vasubandhu asserted the existence of Mount Meru in the Abhidharmakośa and a scientific investigation has established beyond doubt that there is no such thing, and therefore we have rejected the existence of Mount Meru. Likewise, should it be established beyond doubt by scientists, not just as a theory, but beyond any possible doubt that plants have feeling and recognition, then we will be delighted to accept them among sentient beings. Okay. So how did that rotten piece of cactus say please, please to you?

Disregarding calm abiding and the object of observation, given that we’re taught to regard our root guru as the Buddha, is there the same benefits to visualizing our root guru as there are of the Buddha at the time of death? What exactly are you asking? Is it of the same benefit to visualize a guru while training in calm abiding or at the time of death? The my understanding is that one of the benefits of using the Buddha as the object of observation for calm abiding is that you can recall that the Buddha clearly at the time of death, which has, certain benefits. So would those be the same benefits if one was to be using the root guru as the object of observation?

Let alone it is the same. It is excellent. It is excellent. It was reported in the Science Today that the eucalypt changes the odor that it emanates in accordance with the predators that are in its vicinity. So it must have some means of discrimination.

Whether it can actually talk, I don’t know. But that is After making close connections with scientists, would investigate the phenomenon. Sorry. Yes, Molly. In which context did that happen?

So the mind in general has no end until it reaches full enlightenment. However, non virtuous states of mind do have an end when the antidotes to them are applied. Virtuous states of mind are forever on the increase. And this appearing factor of mind is what was referred to here. In our mind there are numerous mistaken understandings.

When the antidotes to these mistaken understandings are applied, they disappear. Then progressively the mind itself turns into the fully enlightened mind. Yes, definitely. All beings have a naturally existing wisdom. But in some cases, this wisdom is mistaken.

In other cases, it is merely a seed of wisdom. For instance, the five wrong views, the view of the disintegrating composite, the view of permanence actually are wisdoms but they are mistaken wisdoms. Geshe-la mentioned that independent to achieve vipaśyanā, it had to be based on calm abiding. So once you have vipaśyanā on the object of emptiness, this is the only way that can be achieved, the understanding, the wisdom. So independent of his response to Natalie’s question in that wisdom is inherent within us, I would posit that perhaps it could arise spontaneously and wouldn’t have to go to such efforts.

It’s a very Australian question. How could that be possible? It is only possible through putting effort. To give you an example, it’s the same thing as sowing a seed of barley. Then having sown the seed of barley, it is in the ground.

But if one doesn’t water it, one doesn’t put manure, there is no sunlight, then how could it ever give rise to a sprout? However, if you sow the seed in the ground and you water it, you put manure, you take good care of it, then eventually you have good hope there will be numerous sprouts. Likewise, it is through putting effort that the concentration or the wisdom which are present in small amounts in our mind can be enhanced and eventually lead to insight or to calm abiding. I don’t know if I wrote it down correctly, but I’ve got here all of three realms are merely of the nature of the mind. Can Geshe-la tell me which three realms and why?

So the three realms are the realm which we live in, which is called the realm of desire, the desire realm. The two realms of the gods, are known as the form realm and the formless realm. The formless realm is a realm in which there are gods which have no form, no shape. And when it is said in this quote, the three realms are of the nature of merely mind. It is not being said that they are actually mind, that would be inappropriate.

What is being said is that they are of the nature of mind. In other words, everything which exists within these three realms is necessarily of the nature of mind. Thank you very much. This was very pleasant.

Key terms in this teaching

Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
Mount Meru
The mythical center of the universe in Buddhist cosmology. LYWA
selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
three realms traidhatu (Skt); kham sum (Tib)
The desire, form and formless realms. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Which three realms are said to be merely of the nature of mind, and what does that statement mean?

The three realms are the desire realm, which is the realm we live in, and the two god realms, the form realm and the formless realm. The formless realm is a realm of gods who have no form and no shape. When the quote says the three realms are "of the nature of merely mind," it does not mean that they are actually mind, which would be inappropriate. It means that they are of the nature of mind. In other words, everything that exists within these three realms is necessarily of the nature of mind.

Scroll to Top