1 h 59 min · 6,924 words · 27 February 2013 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Kyabje Rinpoche grounds this 119-minute calm abiding teaching in bodhicitta motivation, then systematically unpacks how afflictions like anger arise from mistaken views, detailing nine specific causes. He establishes urgency through teachings on death and impermanence before presenting calm abiding and insight as inseparable through the sharp axe and steady hand metaphor. The core instruction provides detailed practical guidance: explicit meditation posture alignment, room setup, diet, and sleep rhythm. A closing Q&A addresses real obstacles—vegetarianism, sequencing equanimity and compassion, self-directed anger—making the teaching immediately applicable. Suited to practitioners preparing for retreat.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2013-02-27 – KR.mp3
UUID: e915abb5-328d-406b-b1fc-be8fe0e3ba28
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Calm Abiding
Date: 2013-02-27
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~6,923
So initially, before attending teaching, the motivation must be generated. Whether we engage in Dharma activities or mundane activities, in either case, the motivation is extremely important. Since we are at present studying a most important treatise and moreover a treatise of the Mahāyāna, this motivation must be correctly generated. It is when the motivation is held by bodhicitta that the practices we engage in become of the Mahāyāna. There is a quote from Je Tsongkhapa in which he said, says, it is not appropriate to refer to a given Dharma practice as of the Mahāyāna, so much so as to refer to whatever practice is engaged in by a being whose motivation is held by bodhicitta as a practice of the Mahāyāna.
And therefore it is not sufficient for the Dharma which is taught or the practice to be counted among Mahāyāna practices, the being himself must be a Mahāyānist. And whether a being is reckoned as a Mahāyānist or not is contingent on whether bodhicitta is present in his or her continuum or not. Likewise, being counted as a Buddhist or assessed as a Buddhist or not is contingent on whether or not refuge is present within one’s mind stream. Likewise, if bodhicitta is present within the continuum of a being, such a being is considered to be a Mahāyānist. If bodhicitta is not present, such a being cannot be a Mahāyānist.
So the stages in which bodhicitta is generated have been explained in great detail and it is up to ourselves to assess whether or not we have reached such a level and if not to do so. Since we are beginners at this practice, obviously there will be some difficulties in generating bodhicitta within our mind stream. However, by putting effort at these practices relying on the instructions from the great treatises, it is definitely possible. bodhicitta is critically important because if we consider the three types of practitioners, Shravakas or hearers, Pratyekabuddha or solitary realizers, and Bodhisattvas, they are all similar from the standpoint of the view. Pratyekabuddha and Bodhisattvas all are similar with respect to the view of emptiness.
The main difference between them is the difference of the motivation. Because the Shravakas and the Pratyekabuddha lack bodhicitta, they cannot attain full enlightenment, whereas because bodhisattvas have it, they will attain full enlightenment. In addition, because we are followers of Buddha Śākyamūni, the teacher, we must definitely generate compassion and bodhicitta. As Dignāgā says in the Pramānavārttika, I prostrate to the being who is a valid cognizer, to the Pramānavārttika. Buddha Śākyamūni was not a being who was a Pramāna being originally, a Pramāna sattva originally.
He became so through training in compassion and in bodhicitta. Initially, Buddha Śākyamūni was not an enlightened being. He was an ordinary being just like us. But through training in renunciation in bodhicitta and in the correct view of emptiness, eventually, he attained the state of the four bodies and became a Pramanasattva, a being who is a valid cognizer. Since we ourselves are followers of Buddha Śākyamūni, then we should follow in the path which he has opened.
And the goal which has been set to us is that of full enlightenment. Any being who puts effort at such a goal will be able to accomplish it. As Dignāgā says in the Pramānavārttika, he is rich in pramāna. Rich in pramāna here refers to the fact that previously, he did not or he was not a pramāna being, but he became a pramāna sattva. And therefore, bodhicitta is extremely important and if we have a bit of time, it would be extremely helpful for us to reflect on it.
If upon waking, upon rising in the morning, we can generate bodhicitta, then all our activities during the day will be held by this motivation and will become Mahāyāna activities. And if we are able to do this not just for one day but consistently for every day, then most definitely we will generate bodhicitta. His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, has said that when he travels to numerous countries to teach, he always generates bodhicitta while traveling on the plane, and this creates an uncommon feeling. Then Geshe-la said, In dependence on this advice and his holiness, he himself tried to generate bodhicitta on the way over to Australia, but wasn’t very successful and basically generated a lot of fear. The main problem was that Geshe-la had not been on a plane previously.
Then if you kept wondering, this is going on for terribly long time, are we arriving anytime soon? And therefore, it is extremely important for us to reflect on bodhicitta. Then some of us experience numerous mental difficulties. Most definitely, bodhicitta will help in dispelling these. And therefore, today, the motivation for listening to these teachings should be the motivation, may I attain the state of full enlightenment so as to lead all sentient beings as vast as space to such a state.
Geshe-la is fully aware that most of us in this room work during the day and come here in the evening because we consider this a special time, a privileged period. And during such a privileged period, we should generate a pure motivation of bodhicitta so that these teachings become a pure practice of Mahāyāna. Let us meditate. As Acharya Vasubandhu says, our minds are pervaded with the afflictions. Even though we wish for happiness and we wish to abandon suffering, nonetheless, we generate the causes for suffering, which are the afflictions continuously.
Therefore, to attain a state of stable happiness which is free of suffering, we must abandon the causes of suffering which are the afflictions. And in turn, to abandon the afflictions which cause suffering, we must abandon the cause of the afflictions. And these three causes according to Vasubandhu which give rise to suffering are first, the non abandonment of the afflictions. Secondly, being attached to those to one to whom one is close. And thirdly, being under the sway of wrong conceptions.
We can see for ourselves that irrespective of the affliction, whether it is desire, envy, or whatever, it arises with respect to those to whom we are close. We can see for ourselves living at present in Australia that anger, desire, or jealousy does not arise towards someone whom we have never met living in America. So the afflictions arise for those who are in our entourage, in our surroundings. Geshe-la has frequently explained this to his students at Sera. The afflictions such as anger do not arise towards Westerners whom one never meets.
They arise towards what other monks within the same monastery in which one is. This is why Geshe-la says to them, you must be very careful, very wary because afflictions such as anger arise towards those who live in the same monastery as you, who live inside the same, the same house of a given area, within that who live who are of the same class, and within that who are students of the same teacher of Buddhist philosophy. Likewise, probably in your state, afflictions arise towards those who are in Australia with you, for that matter, who are in Adelaide, for that matter, who are within your close entourage in Adelaide. And clearly, one of the causes of the afflictions is one’s own mistaken conceptuality, one’s own wrong conceptuality. Numerous afflictions such as anger, desire, jealousy and so forth arise from the mental misapprehension of the actual mode of existing of something on the outside.
This is one of the first cause. Clearly, the second is that not having abandoned the afflictions, one of the major causes for the afflictions is just not having abandoned them. In addition, each one of us has his or her own individual conditions for the arising of the afflictions. For instance, for someone who has a lot of lust or desire within his or her mind, it is important to meditate on ugliness. For someone who has a lot of anger within his or her mind stream, it is important to meditate on love and compassion as an antidote.
So it is said that when anger arises, there are nine causes for anger. The first three causes are this person has harmed me in the past. This person will harm me in the present, is harming me in the present, and this person will harm me in the future. The second set of three causes is this person has harmed one of my friends, is harming one of my friends, or will harm one of my friends. And the final three causes are this person has in the past helped one of my enemies, is helping in the present, one of my enemies, or will help one of my enemies in the future.
It’s In dependence on these nine causes that typically anger arises. And therefore, whichever of the afflictions is dominant within one’s mind stream is the one we should counter. And whatever is the dominant affliction within our mind stream, we should resolve from today onwards to eliminate its cause. If we do not do it from today onwards, we must reflect on the fact that there is no certainty regarding our life. As is said in the Essence of Nectar Lamrim, there are those who do not exist the next day whereas they had lived the previous day.
There are those who although present in the morning are no longer there in the afternoon. And there are those who although present right now will no longer be there within an instance time. And therefore, our life is impermanent and transitory. It changes instant by instant. Let alone the fact that our life is transitory and fleeting.
In addition, the causes for death are numerous, and the causes for life, the conditions for life are few. As the essence of nectarr Lamrim says, numerous other causes of death such as the collapse of a house, a horse, and so forth. These were causes of death in previous days. Nowadays, it would be car accidents, motor bicycle accidents, and so forth. I won’t explain in detail the conditions or the causes for death.
We know from our own experience these causes. On the other hand, the causes for life are very few. For this reason, it is important to actualize Dharma today. A holy being of yore said, a human life is spent thus. During the first twenty years, one doesn’t realize there is a Dharma to practice.
During the following twenty years, one thinks, I will, I will practice later on. During the last twenty years, one thinks, I really should have practiced. I really should have practiced. This is how sixty years pass. That is rather similar to the way things are, isn’t it?
This is why in the Lamrim, the certainty of death is first explained. This is something we all know. In addition, the Lamrim teaches that the time of death is uncertain. And finally, the Lamrim teaches that at the time of death, nothing is of benefit apart from Dharma. Friends and relatives are of no benefit, wealth is of no benefit, and so forth.
This is, these are the teachings which have been transmitted by Buddha Śākyamūni downwards through Ārya Nāgārjuna and his son Āryadeva and have been ascertained by all of the great beings of the path. Therefore, I consider this period today during which we are practicing Dharma as critically important. And after all of this, we shall now start studying the text. So as you remember last time, Geshe-la explained how to train in calm abiding and the six causes which were necessary to or the six preliminary conditions necessary for calm abiding. It is said that if these six preconditions are carefully assembled, it is possible to attain calm abiding within six months.
We explained or Geshe-la explained in detail how to train in calm abiding, but the crux of the matter is that calm abiding means enabling one’s mind to stay for a long period of time continuously on its object. So Geshe-la often says jokingly to his students at the monastery, it is rather difficult, I suspect, to attain calm abiding at Sera because when you are not going for pujas, you’re going for debate. And when you’re not going for debate, you’re going to get some food. It is said in the Lamrim Chenmo that one should focus exclusively on the practice of calm abiding with the exception of the time spent on eating and sleeping. So there may be some difficulty with time, isn’t it?
It is precisely for this reason that the great practitioners who train in calm abiding or in insight retire on a mountain hermitage so as not to encounter any difficulties of this time. However, even though you don’t have a lot of time, if you have an empty moment, please train in Samādhi. However, please don’t train in calm abiding while you’re walking on the street. You might be hit by a car. Likewise, to generate insight within one’s mind stream, three conditions are necessary. The first is to rely on a holy being who is able to explain clearly the practice.
Then one needs much experience in hearing the teachings on the instructions from the treatises. And finally, after hearing the instructions, one must have experience in their dawning to the mind. And then after training in this way, one must engage in much analysis. For this reason, it is said that one needs much hearing, much study in other words. And whatever one has heard, one has listened to, in turn, one must have this arise clearly within one’s mind.
These will be explained in detail individually. The being one must listen to must have four qualities. He must have heard numerous teachings. And he must clearly understand the distinction between the words and the meaning of these teachings. He must also have profound love and compassion for the trainees who are receiving these teachings.
And must be ready to engage in whatever hardship is necessary for the sake of the trainees. Is on a holy being with those qualities that one must rely. This is the first condition. The second is to rely on much hearing of the treatises. This is a case because the Buddha explained countless countless treatises for the sake of beings of various constitutions and dispositions.
And one therefore needs the capacity to distinguish clearly between those teachings which are of interpretable meaning and those which are of definite meaning. Those teachings which are of interpretable meaning are teachings whose topic is actually at odds with the actual mode of existence of phenomena, whereas those which are of definitive meaning are those whose topics is in concordance with the actual mode of existence of phenomena. In brief, one must listen with full awareness of the great purpose for which the Buddha has taught these treatises to beings. And it is for this reason that it is said in the Saṃdhinirmocana Sūtra, that if one does not practice in accordance with the intent of Buddha Śākyamūni, this is a main obstacle to the generation of insight. And the reason for this is explained in one of Buddha’s sutras.
And it is a case because it is taught that insight is a wisdom which is arisen from meditation. For a wisdom arisen from meditation to arise, first the minds arisen from thinking must have arisen. And for these to arise, first, the minds arisen from hearing must have arisen. This is also taught by Buddha in the Buddhist Sutras. In which it is said that the wisdom of insight arises through having heard numerous treatises.
And once one is endowed with insight, it is possible to eliminate all of the afflictions. And therefore, it is indispensable to eliminate afflictions from the root to have that wisdom which has arisen from insight. Generally speaking, from the standpoint of the object, there is an insight which is possessed by non-Buddhist outsiders, the Tīrthikas. But here we are referring to that insight whose object is emptiness. And the reason for this is that the root cause of all of the afflictions such as desire, anger, and so forth is that benighted ignorance.
It is called ignorance because it is a non knowledge, a nescience of its object. That mind which realizes the ultimate status of phenomena is a mind which realizes subtle selflessness. It is that ignorance which misapprehends the selflessness of phenomena which gives rise to all of the afflictions such as desire and so forth. And the mind which counters that fog, that mental fog, is the wisdom which realizes insight. Therefore, insight is extremely important.
Then we will start with insight. And for this, one must first study in-depth all of the teachings taught by the Buddha, then analyze them carefully using reasoning, and finally ascertain them definitely. Then if one does not do this and remains in a state of doubt, one is akin to someone at a crossroads who doesn’t know where to go. Then clearly, if you’re at a crossroads and don’t know where to go, there are few chances of getting to your goal. In my case, when I go for a walk, there’s only one road I take.
Because otherwise, it’s a very great risk of not finding my way back to the center. And therefore, these three conditions are indispensable to give rise to insight within one’s mind stream. Then many of the yogis who train in calm abiding and insight will also abandon the consumption of meat and fish. However, specifically, the Buddha made or gave specific instructions regarding flesh for which regarding which the three ascertainments are not definite. The it is possible to eat meat if one is sure that this meat has not been killed or the this animal has not been killed for oneself and one has not heard or seen any evidence indicating that it would have been killed for oneself?
It should be okay to enjoy or to eat meat which fulfills those characteristics. And in addition, it is important for the yogi to eat in moderation. This eating in moderation is extremely important. If one eats tasty food in an immoderate or intemperate fashion, there is a risk of indigestion or even diarrhea. Or alternatively, one is bloated, cannot concentrate well and falls asleep.
Therefore, measure in food is extremely important. In addition, one should also be mindful of the time of sleeping. It is said that one should not sleep late in the morning nor should one go to bed early at night. And in between, one should practice meditation. Then it is very risky for those of you who sleep late until nine or 10:00 in the morning.
You might miss out on breakfast. The yogis, however, don’t encounter this difficulty. Therefore, the practice of concentration, it is very important to rise early in the morning. Then I used to get up early at Sera. Here, it is a different situation.
And therefore, before engaging in training and concentration, whatever prerequisites are necessary, we should engage in. And therefore, before engaging in meditation, whatever one needs, one should collect. And, obviously, if one has to close the door of one’s room, one does that before starting to meditate. And, clearly, if you sit down, on your meditation cushion and after one or two minutes have to head out to take a leak, the chance of generating concentration is very limited. Likewise, if after sitting down to meditate, you then notice that there are people passing in front of the window or the door and have to stand up to close the window or the door, this prevents attaining concentration.
Likewise, it is extremely important to clean carefully the room in which one meditates. And if one does clean indeed one’s house, then the Buddhas, the Bodhisattvas, and the Dakinis will come. Then if it is dirty, they don’t come. For instance, if you’re receiving a high official award or someone of that stature, clearly, you would want to clean your house first, wouldn’t you? It is similar to that.
And therefore, without being disturbed by any sounds or clatter, one should be seated on one’s cushion and train in concentration. However, before training in concentration, one should generate the motivation first. And this motivation has to be the compassion which wishes to free all sentient beings from suffering in addition to the bodhicitta which wishes to place all sentient beings in a state of full enlightenment. This pure motivation must be first. And then after generating This such a motivation, pure motivation must one should invite all of the Buddhas and Bodhisattvas from the 10 directions and to make offerings.
Specifically, prostrate with the five limbs or the five branches. This refers to a prostration where the forehead, the two hands, and the two knees touch the ground. Then if these five points do not touch the ground, it’s not a fully qualified prostration. Then if one performs a prostration in this way or thinking that numberless Buddhas and Bodhisattvas are present, it will be a fully qualified prostration. Then if one has one, it is very good to set up either a statue or a representation of the Buddhas and the Bodhisattvas.
Then if one wants to do things really carefully, one would make these prostrations and offerings first to the guru, then to the Yidams, then to the Buddhas, then to the Bodhisattvas, then to the Dakinis, and so forth. Some because of the potency of the protectors give them pride of place on their altar in their practice. It is said this is a sign of degeneration of refuge. Likewise, some give pride of place on their altar to the statues which are made of precious substances such as gold, silver, and so forth, and put in a corner those which are made of humble or base substances such as wood or earth. This leads to the collapse of one’s merit and of one’s refuge.
And there’s a lot to be thought about here. So think of the order in a non mistaken way. Then after setting one’s order out correctly, one should make praises and make offerings. And offer whatever one can. Then once this has been completed, one should confess one’s sins.
And for this one must generate a powerful sense of contrition. After this, one must rejoice in both one’s own virtue and that of others. Then if one practices in this way, all seven limbs will have been led to conclusion. At present, we shall explain how to actually train in concentration. First, one needs an extremely comfortable cushion, which is higher in the back and lower in the front.
And one should sit on this in the full posture, in full Vajrasanā, the posture of Vairocana, or if that is impossible, in half Vajrasanā. And then once seated in Vajrasanā, which is basically the opposite of what we know as a lotus position, one puts one’s right hand on top of one’s left hand and one joins the thumbs. At the level or in front of one’s navel. And one’s eyelids should neither be too open nor tightly shut, but slightly open. The eye should neither be completely open nor completely shut and should be focused on the tip of one’s nose, specifically on the two sides of one’s nose.
Not shutting one’s eyes is helpful to prevent sinking from arising. And because one’s eyes are not wide open, agitation does not arise easily. And therefore one should stay or meditate with one’s eyes focused on the tip of one’s nose. One should be straight, neither leaning backwards nor curved forwards. Then one shouldn’t be staring in space.
Instead, one’s head should be slightly bent. If one’s body is straight in turn, the energy channels within the body will be straight and the winds will move easily within the energy channels. This is of benefit for one’s thinking processes. One’s shoulders should be level and one’s head should not incline to the left or to the right. Then the line from the tip of one’s nose to one’s hands should be a straight line.
One’s mouth should neither be tightly closed nor loosely open. It should remain in its usual level of opening. Then the tip of one’s tongue should lie directly behind one’s upper teeth. The benefit of this is that when one meditates or practices concentration for long, one will not become thirsty. Finally, one’s breath should not be audible either during inhalation or during exhalation.
It should be, as usual, a very relaxed breath. This is how one should meditate or train concentration. This is known as the sevenfold posture of Vairocana. And it is in this posture that one should meditate continuously training in Samādhi. The first step to train in concentration of Samādhi is calm abiding.
Without attaining calm abiding, there’s no attainment of insight. So first, one must realize calm abiding. What is calm abiding? At present, our mind is distracted outwards. Calm abiding refers to placing the mind on its object of observation single pointedly and continuously.
Specifically, once the mind can be focused on whatever object one chooses to focus it upon for as long as one chooses to do so, and a specific feeling of happiness arises, what is known as physical and mental pliancy, then one will have attained calm abiding. In brief, somebody who wants to train in calm abiding must be a rather intense person. In our case, if we wish to focus on an object, let alone one minute, probably we can’t focus for one second on the object. Those of you who’ve tried meditating know whether this is true or not. And, therefore, someone who wishes to train in calm abiding must focus on an object intensely and forcefully.
Must be a rather forceful person who prevents the mind from going outside. Then training in this way for one minute, for five minutes, for ten minutes, for half an hour, for one hour, one improves progressively one’s concentration. And then once one has attained abiding, one’s mind can be set on an object of observation for however long one chooses to set it upon it. Therefore, having attained calm abiding, one’s mind is very stably set on the object of observation. However, before doing this, one must decide when to get out of calm abiding.
Then within the context of calm abiding, it is possible to train in wisdom. Then when such a being within the context of calm abiding trains in analysis and a particular happiness arises as a result of this, one can say that insight has been generated. Then insight is what severs the root of cyclic existence. To sever the root of cyclic existence, calm abiding and insight must be inseparable. For instance, if one wishes to cut a tree, one needs both a firm arm and a sharp axe.
If the axe is not sharp, however many times one strikes a tree, one would be unable to cut it. Then if one doesn’t have a strong and stable hand, even if one’s axe is sharp, sometimes one strikes above, sometimes one strikes above, sometimes one misses the tree. So there is very serious risk to train in this that you need many years. For this reason, one needs the inseparable union of a sharp axe and a stable, firm hand. And therefore, to sever cyclic existence, one needs the sharp axe of insight with the firm hand of calm abiding.
And therefore, as Buddha Śākyamūni said, calm abiding focuses on a topic, while insight analyzes that topic. Likewise, Buddha said in the Saṃdhinirmocana Sūtra that initially one must generate calm abiding and on that basis generate insight. The reason for this statement is that Ārya Maitreya asked the Buddha initially in this sūtra, the Saṃdhinirmocana Sūtra, why is it the case that initially one should generate calm abiding before becoming skilled in insight? And answering this question of Bodhisattva Maitreya, Buddha said, Maitreya, Buddha said all of the teachings I gave to beings can be subdivided into the 12 limbs of scripture.
The 12 limbs of scripture are sutras, melodious praise, prophecies, verses, specific teachings, introductions, parables, legends, the Jatakas, the extensive teachings, marvelous dharmas, and ascertained teachings. These are the numerous types of teachings the Buddha gave to the bodhisattvas. And the Buddha instructed his disciples initially to listen carefully to these treatises then to retain them well, in other words, to memorize them, and then to put them into practice. And he advised his disciples after analyzing carefully and well the meaning of these treatises to realize them. And then after analyzing them well to retire in a lonely place, a hermitage to realize them.
As Je Tsongkhapa says in the final stanza of these three principles of the path, Therefore, after having realized the three principles of the path, retire in a lonely hermitage and accomplish your permanent goal or your permanent wish. And then after focusing on the meaning of the 12 limbs of scripture, when as a result of concentration, either bodily or physical or mental pliancy arise, one will be said to have realized calm abiding. What is meant here by physical and mental pliancy? Physical pliancy refers to a happiness which arises spontaneously whenever we turn our body to virtuous activities, whereas mental pliancy refers to a happiness which arises spontaneously whenever we turn our minds to virtuous activities. And therefore, the Bodhisattva must practice withdrawing his mind from exterior distractions and focusing it single pointedly on the object of observation to attain calm abiding.
And then after this, the object of observation of calm abiding can be examined or analyzed by wisdom. And an analysis which realizes that the object of observation of concentration does not exist as it appears to exist, but exists as a reflection will arise. When that capacity of analysis arises, we are speaking of insight. Bodhisattvas are most skilled in such a calm abiding and insight. Therefore, if we wish to train in calm abiding and insight initially, we must listen extensively to these 12 branches of the Buddhist scriptures.
All of the Buddha’s sutras, all of the Buddha’s scriptures either explicitly or implicitly teach emptiness. In one of these subdivisions, the presentation of the aggregates, sources and the constituents is most elaborate. And therefore, object we choose to train in for attaining calm abiding, after having attained calm abiding, we generate insight on that basis. However, among all the objects, focusing on the Buddha’s body is particularly beneficial. Geshe-la will explain the next time the specific benefits of such an object of observation.
There is a quote from the Samādhi Rāja Sūtra to this effect. In which it is said, engage in calm abiding on an object of observation akin to the beautiful body, golden body of the Buddha, the lord of this world. We will stop here for today. If you have questions, please ask your questions. Yes, please.
In before I I’m a vegetarian, but I heard they said something about meat and when when it was okay to eat meat. Could could you explain that a little bit more? Are you a vegetarian? Yes. Generally speaking, if one can give up the consumption of meat, that is absolutely excellent since one is no is in no way associated to any harm inflicted to animals.
The reason for which the Buddha allowed the consumption of meat, which fulfills the three criteria to his disciples who were ordained is because if they abstain completely from the consumption of meat, they would probably lack strength in their training in virtue and so forth. This was the only reason. I don’t think I need this, Carol. Thank you. That if the animal is not killed specifically for oneself’s consumption, one can take take part of that meat.
I don’t sort of quite understand that. If it’s gonna be killed, then we’re all going to eat it. So here what is referred to the so called three certainties or the three criteria. Someone who is ordained must have before consuming meat, which is that the he he or she must be sure that he has not seen the animal being killed for him, heard that the animal, has been killed for him, or have any doubts with this respect, then in this case, the person who is ordained does not incur a fault when he or she eats meat. But this is obviously not compulsory.
Okay. It says it’s a little bit like the fact that the Buddha Śākyamūni instructed the monks to abstain from beer obviously alcohol, and monks abstain from alcohol. He didn’t say anything to this effect to lay people in general. And as a result, the monks are not terribly fond of the idea of others drinking beer. Lily, please.
Thank you, Geshe-la. With regards to developing equanimity and loving kindness and then compassion, should one, incorporate all these in one session or in a group of closely linked sessions? Or should one focus first on equanimity until one has until it is dawned on one one’s mind and then move on to the next topic. It’s a very good question. Really, the way to go about it would be first to meditate on equanimity.
When one has some type of realization of equanimity to move on to love, then when we have some type of realization to move on to compassion. But we ourselves enjoy meditating on everything at once. So we just mix it all in one session. So while this is what most people do, really the best way to go about it is first to meditate on equanimity. And when one has some type of experience of equanimity, then to start meditating on love.
And then when one has some type of experience of love, then to meditate on compassion. Yes. Oh, yes, please. Oh, Jim. Oh, Natalie.
My apologies. I have the microphone. Sorry. I just wanted to Geshe-la described Buddha Śākyamūni as a pramāna sattva. I haven’t heard that expression before.
A what? Pramāna sattva? Yes. Yes. Yes.
Could he translate that specifically? So when Dignāgā refers to the Buddha as a pramāna being or a being who is a valid cognizer, valid cognizer in this context means a being who is incontrovertible. This means that the Buddha has attained omniscience and actually understands phenomena as they are and is able to teach the four noble truths to others as they are. Did that answer your question? Okay.
Generally speaking, valid cognizers or pramanas are subdivided into three. Minds which are valid cognizers, speech which is a valid cognizer and beings or persons which are valid cognizers. I had a question that just followed on from Lily’s. I wanted to ask when you were discussing meditating on first equanimity followed by loving kindness and then compassion, and to do the training in that particular order, does that mean that each of those in turn would be a good target for calm abiding training? Or are they a little bit too abstract for that kind of single pointed concentration?
Not really. To gain any type of experience of calm abiding, excuse me, of equanimity or love, actually we need calm abiding and insight first. So to gain an experience of natural or spontaneous bodhicitta or equanimity, it is indispensable to have calm abiding. It is however possible without calm abiding to meditate on equanimity and so forth. Geshele, you mentioned the nine causes of anger.
It just seems that in the West, a lot of people are very angry with themselves and engage in harmful behaviors to themselves. And I wonder, in your opinion, what is the way we can help them, those sort of people? So the first step to counter anger, in this case, anger towards one’s own self or towards one’s own body is to understand what the cause, the reason of this anger towards oneself is. Once one has understood what the cause of this anger towards oneself is, it is possible to eliminate it. So for instance, if one is angry with oneself because let us say one’s body is ugly and one is unhappy with the ugliness of one’s body, then it might be helpful to meditate on the beauty of one’s body.
Was that clear? Yes. It was just though if someone really thinks their body is ugly, how does someone else convince them that it isn’t? You know, it’s the problem that of low self esteem that so many people have. Yeah.
If you know it yourself, then you can do it. But if if you’re trying to help someone else Actually, the anger which takes oneself as an object will abate if we train our minds in love and compassion. Then naturally, this anger will be reduced. Since love and compassion are general antidotes to anger, then even if it is anger to oneself, which we are talking about, when we meditate on love and compassion, that anger also will decrease. Yes, too.
Geshe-la said earlier, first study in-depth the teachings then analyze using reasoning then ascertain them definitely. Could he elaborate a bit on ascertain them definitely and what that the meaning of that is, please? So what is referred to here is first listening to teachings and giving rise to the mind which has arisen from listening. And then after this reflecting on them over and again and giving rise to the mind which has arisen from reflecting or thinking. And then after this, one starts at this point in dependence on that mind to meditate.
And one gives rise to the mind which has arisen from meditation. This is what is meant here by ascertainment. Meditation here means to become accustomed as much as possible to the object. This can either mean in the case of impermanence or emptiness to become accustomed to the concepts of impermanence and emptiness through repeated familiarity or in the case of states of mind such as love and compassion to actually generate these states of mind within one’s mind stream and become accustomed to the generation of the state of mind. One more quick question.
Thank you, Geshe-la, for that answer. If you can attain abiding on one object, can is it can you then automatically attain calm abiding on any object, any other object? First, think calm abiding on one object, and then can you transfer it to others is your question. Actually, when one trains in calm abiding, initially, one does not change the object at all. And one cannot change the object until one has attained calm abiding.
After this, one can focus that mind of calm abiding on any object. However, this is something which Geshe-la will explain next time and will put great effort into. Things have gone very well in the presentation of calm abiding. Could I clarify, something from last week’s teaching? The story about King Ajatasattu who killed his father.
About who? The king was it King Ajatasattu who killed his father? And I wrote down that Buddha said, you do not need to feel so much remorse. And I was I had a you know, I couldn’t understand that, why he would not need to feel so much remorse seeing that’s a fairly serious crime. So what Buddha Śākyamūni said to King Ajatasattu was you should kill father and mother.
Then, obviously, this was said with a very specific reason because of the background of King Ajatasatu. This is not something Buddha would say to other beings. And then in dependence on this instruction of Buddha Śākyamūni, actually King Ajatasattu became an Arhat. It’s a bit odd. You see, it’s the same thing as some beings who even though phenomena are said to be non truly existent consider phenomena to be truly existent.
Then teachings are given to these beings in function of their state or their condition. These are not general teachings for all beings. Now there are numerous cases in the Buddhist teachings where the teachings are either in accordance with his true state of affairs with reality or at odds with reality. This is the reason for which the Buddha said to his disciples, you must accept those teachings of mine which are in accordance with reason after analysis and the others you should reject. You should not accept teachings on the basis of the reason I am your teacher.
To give you an example, there are probably a couple among you who don’t accept the existence of past and future lives in the lower realms. Then for the sake of teaching those beings, it may be necessary to say to them, are there no past and future lives and there are no lower realms. Even though that’s not the case. Otherwise, if you tell to them that there are such things, there’s no benefit to them. They don’t accept it of anyway.
Then they will not have used this opportunity of the Dharma teachings correctly if that happens? So for those who would like to continue the conversation, living the path is an informal and excellent opportunity for beginners and experienced students alike which is
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- definitive meaning nitartha (Skt); ngedön (Tib)
- One of two main ways of understanding a Dharma teaching, this one is where the content is be taken literally and not open for interpretation, as opposed to the interpretive meaning. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
When developing equanimity, loving kindness and compassion, should they all be practised in one session or in a series of closely linked sessions?
The best way is to meditate on equanimity first. Once you have some type of realization or experience of equanimity, move on to meditating on love. Once you have some type of experience of love, then meditate on compassion. Each stage is taken up only after the previous one has been experienced to some degree. Many people enjoy meditating on all of them at once and mix them together in a single session, and this is what most people do. But the best approach is still to go through them one after another, in the order of equanimity, then love, then compassion.