21 min · 1,154 words · 8 May 1989 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 21.5-minute commentary on the Bodhisattvacaryāvatāra, Kyabje Rinpoche explains how every action produces three distinct types of effects that return to the actor. He begins by clarifying that until Buddhahood, we can only offer others temporary help—food, ethical instruction, compassion—not ultimate transformation. He then systematically unfolds the three effects: the ripening effect, a feeling of happiness or suffering experienced only by the doer; the effect similar to the cause, manifesting as behavioral tendency and experiential consequence (kill, and your own life shortens; practice generosity, you gain prosperity); and the environmental effect, the circumstances surrounding you. Through concrete examples—patience producing a beautiful body, anger producing an ugly face—he demonstrates how this law of cause and effect operates with precision, always returning consequences to the actor.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 1989-05-08 – 7A – Patience – KR.mp3
UUID: d3f8039f-f4a7-4d04-a9f6-eee1fbb6df05
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Bodhisattvacaryāvatāra
Date: 1989-05-08
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~1,149
There’s no question that we cannot help others before we attain Buddhahood. It’s just a matter of degree that until we achieve Buddhahood we can only be of temporal occasional benefit to others in a temporal sense. And but it’s only upon achieving Buddhahood that we can be of complete help to others in trying to, you know, bring bring them some kind of complete happiness. So we can help others, but only in a very temporal sense. We cannot bring in any ultimate happiness.
So, you know, we can bring people a temporary benefit temporal benefit such that, you know, we can give them food, clothing, things like this. We’ll we’ll bring them some kind of temporary happiness. Happiness. You know, we can definitely we can definitely involve ourselves in this. We can even go on to, you know, give instructions on how to cultivate compassion, which is going to bring them eventual happiness in the future.
So these are, you know, methods of temporally benefiting others. If you were to advise someone to that they should quit killing, that they should, you know, practice patience, ethics, things of this nature, and they took this to heart and they actually engaged themselves in these practices, then they would experience as a result of these actions happiness in the future. So this would be a way of helping someone in a temporal sense. Not affecting the rocks and the trees around you. Other people by your actions and your anger.
Does that mean Yeah. I didn’t say that fact. The the stone the earth and the stone, they don’t experience They don’t experience. The happiness or suffering. They don’t experience happiness.
Okay. Yeah. Go ahead. Okay. But I’m do animals?
Oh, do animals experience the results of their actions from the past? The result for instance, does Is he saying that things aren’t affected because it’s not permanent? Or is it just our effects on our environment and on those around us So the what what is it meant was that other than oneself, the ripening effect is not experienced by others, of one’s actions. The ripening effect, the happiness and unhappiness of one’s own actions is only experienced for oneself. So if we take an example of, you know, someone’s hungry, so you give them some food and they experience happiness.
So that happiness arose from them from the factor of the food, not from your generous intention. The result of your generous intention will have a ripening effect which only yourself will experience. They’re not experiencing the effect of your generous intention, only they experience happiness that depends upon the factor of that food. So we have to it would have to be a little more refined in the sense that they you you’re giving them this food, in general, we say, results in their happiness. But here, we’re talking about the ripening effect of your giving that food is only experienced for yourself.
There there are three types of effects of skillful actions. The first is the ripening effect, and this is the feeling which arises as a result of an action, and this is only experienced by oneself, it’s not experienced by others. The second is the cause which is the effect which is similar to the cause. The effect which is similar to the cause. And the third is the environmental effect.
And this is, for example, the place that you live in, your home, the food, the things that you have around you are the environmental effect of your actions that you created. So so this this first effect, the ripening effect, is experienced by the individual, only the individual himself as a feeling either of suffering or happiness. And and as a consequence of unskillful actions, one experiences suffering. As a consequence of of skillful actions, one experiences happiness. This is the main the main effect of action.
So if we take an example of killing, the consequences, the ripening effect of killing is only suffering, the feeling of suffering. With respect to the cause which is with the effect which is similar to the cause, there are two types. There is the effect which is similar to the cause the point of view of behavior and from the point of view of experience. From the point of view of behavior, the effect which is similar to the cause will be that one will have a natural inclination or liking to kill in the future. Having killed in the past, there will be this repetitive pattern which will be similar and one will have predisposition, a tendency, a liking to kill again.
The experience which is, from the point of view of the experience, which is similar to the effect which is similar to the cause, killed others, that is to say having shortened their life, one’s self will experience a shorter life. One will die very quickly. No matter what you might do to prevent it, your life will be very short as a consequence of having shortened the life of others. This is the effect which is similar to the cause from the point of view of experience. So, in this way we can can make you revert use of the reverse process if we, in fact, we want a long life, we should engage in actions which are just the opposite.
That is to say, you know, animals which are, for example, in the case of animals, there is a, say, saving life, is a means of lengthening our life. For example, animals which are about to be killed, you know, that’s quite often the case where they’re going to the slaughterhouse and perhaps the next, next day they’re going to be killed. That if you were to buy this animal and allow it to, in a situation where it could continue to live out its natural life, you would be as if lengthening that sentient beings life and this would have the experiential effect of lengthening one’s own life. So, you know, the these actions are going to always return to ourselves and by lengthening the life of others, we in the future will have a longer life. By giving practicing generosity to others, we ourselves will have lots of material prosperity.
By being patient with others, you will in the future have a beautiful body. This is the way the law of cause and effect operates. For every action, there’s a a reaction. If in in shortening the life of others, killing others, our own life in the future will be shortened. And stealing, taking others’ possessions that we in the future will have very few possessions.
We’ll we’ll be a beggar, for example. By expressing having an angry expression on our face, getting angry at others, we will be born with an ugly face in the future.