Bodhisattvacaryavatara — 1989-05-08

2 h 2 min · 6,962 words · 8 May 1989 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Bodhisattvacaryavatara (Khensur Rinpoche)
Bodhisattvacaryavatara (Khensur Rinpoche)
Bodhisattvacaryavatara — 1989-05-08
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 122-minute commentary on the sixth chapter of Śāntideva’s guide to the bodhisattva’s way, Kyabje Rinpoche teaches a counterintuitive principle: those who harm us are essential objects for practicing patience, as necessary as a farmer’s field or a beggar for generosity. He walks through Śāntideva’s debate with skeptics—if we respect Dharma (which has no intention to benefit us), why not our harmers, who provide essential conditions for cultivating patience? Drawing on the Buddha-field analogy, narratives like Śākyamūni’s gift of his body to a starving tigress and Milarepa’s trials, and an analysis of karma’s three ripening effects, Rinpoche develops the thesis that harmers accelerate us toward Buddhahood. The session closes with Q&A on whether to avoid harmful people and how karma operates across species. For practitioners grounded in Tibetan Buddhism.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 1989-05-08 – Patience – KR.mp3

UUID: 7f836182-df8e-41dc-b9a8-a513ab2b1b96

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Bodhisattvacaryāvatāra

Date: 1989-05-08

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~6,959

Initially we should seek to adjust our motivation in order to develop a kind heart, the awakening heart of bodhicitta, as a motivation for listening to this teaching on the profound great vehicle, as a means to put into practice those methods which we are listening to, as a means to achieve perfect complete Buddhahood and thereby be able to establish all sentient beings equal to space in complete bliss and happiness. So, in order to make the teaching, the teaching of the great vehicle, Mahāyāna, then the motivation for listening and the motivation for teaching must be of the great vehicle and that is the kind heart or the awakening heart of bodhicitta. And if we’re able to do this then it’s going to be extremely beneficial, it’s going to have great results and great blessings. So, we’re looking at the text by Śāntideva Engaging in the Bodhisattva Deeds and especially the sixth chapter which is in the chapter on tolerance of patience. And he’s going through the methods and the necessity for the development of patience or tolerance explaining the various methods and procedures for generating patience.

So those who are seeking to put in the practice the great vehicle, And it’s extremely important that we don’t allow ourselves to generate anger, hatred, because anger and hatred are the exact opposite of the qualities of mind that we’re seeking to engender. That is the awakening heart. The hatred and anger will actually destroy any awakening heart or the mind of enlightenment which you are developing. So in trying to put into practice the great vehicle, it’s necessary that we begin to look upon all sentient beings as our parents. That is, regard them with the understanding that they have treated us with the same kindness, the same caring as our parents of this life, our mother and father of this life.

That in past lives they have brought us this same exact kindness. And then that they had benefited us in the same way as our parents of this life. And therefore as a response to this great kindness to seek to foster thoughts of love and caring toward them and never to respond with anger. So, anger is never an appropriate response, no matter what the situation might be. But still, at times we’re in stressful situations when we’re overcome by afflictive emotions, then there is the opportunity for anger and hatred to arise.

And therefore it is upon these times that we have on these occasions that we have to cultivate the quality of patience and tolerance. So in general we can talk about three types of tolerance for patience. One is the patience or forbearance. Forbearance in responding to the harm, in not responding or not returning harm for harm directed toward yourself. Not responding with harm to harm which has been directed toward yourself.

Not returning harm. That’s the first tolerance. And the second is the tolerance of accepting the suffering of others upon yourself, being able to tolerate that. The difficulty of taking on the sufferings of others’ problems. And the third is the tolerance of patience in pursuing one’s Dharma practice.

So of these three types of tolerance, we’re mainly dealing with the first of these, that is not returning harm for harm. So the way we can begin to cultivate tolerance in return for harm is to understand whatever harm is brought to us, no matter whether it’s to physical harm or mental harm that, for example, in the case of someone speaks harsh words to us, then understanding that this is simply a reaction to the harm that we’ve caused this person in previous lifetime. And this is the harm is simply coming back to us and therefore it’s inappropriate to again create the same reactive pattern and return harm. Understanding that we should try to understand the benefits of not returning harm in such a situation. If we practice patience, then we are developing, building up a great store of positive potential, self power, personal power.

So in understanding the value of the practice of patience, we have to begin to appreciate the situation where we’re able to practice patience. If in fact we simply return harm for harm, then we’re never going to develop the power, positive potential which can be derived from the practice of patience. That without this harm, then we never this harm is to be seen as a cause of our practice of patience. Without this harm, we would not have the opportunity to practice patience. So in such a situation, understanding that the harm brought to us by others is a cause giving us an opportunity to practice patience and therefore an understanding of value of patience and the positive potential, the personal power that is built up through patience, really being happy with a situation which gives us the opportunity to practice.

On the other hand, if we simply return anger for harm then we are creating negative actions. There’s no practice of patience, and we’ve lost a great opportunity. We’ve lost a great profit, the possibility of profit. So then the text goes on to explain the necessity of the cause in order to achieve the result. And just in general we can say that if we don’t have the cause then the effect, the result doesn’t arise.

If we don’t have a seed then the plant doesn’t arise. If we don’t have fire then smoke doesn’t arise. It’s necessary to have the cause in order to achieve the results. On the other hand, if we have the cause, then the result will rise. If we plant the seed, then the plant is going to rise.

If we have a fire, then smoke will rise from the fire. Likewise, in the case of the practice of patience, without the cause, without someone harming us, then we don’t have the opportunity. The results which arise from practicing patience will never come about. But if we have someone who’s harming us, then we combine it with our practice of patience and we get the results of the practice of patience. So the harmer becomes the source or the cause of our practice and the development of all this positive potential.

So, the harmer can in no way prevent us from practicing patience. It is only our own anger which does. So the harmer is therefore the unique cause of our practice of patience. In the same way, you’re using some analogies, thinking that it would be quite useful to practice generosity. One has a motivation to, a generous motivation wishing to give and in fact one has some offering substance, you know, some money or etcetera, once one has something to give, then we need an object in order to fulfill this practice and that would be a beggar for example, someone who asks us for help, someone who is in need.

Without this person in need, then we cannot put into practice even though we might be motivated to, we could not put into practice our generosity. There would be nothing to give to. So the beggar becomes the source of our practice of generosity. And the beggar in no way prevents us from practicing generosity. He aids us or she aids us in practicing generosity.

Likewise, the abbot or master, or the spiritual community, the monastic community who give us ordination, They in no way, you know, desiring to become ordained, they in no way prevent us from becoming ordained. In fact, without them we could not fulfill our motivation to become ordained. Likewise, it is the harmer who fulfills our practice of motivated seeking to practice patience. Without this person as an object, then there would be no possibility for enacting the practice of patience. And therefore, rather than responding with anger, we should respond with great happiness that we have this opportunity, that we have the cause for the practice of patience.

So another analogy would be Rinpoche is teaching the Dharma and from your side that you act as the possibility by your listening for him to give a teaching. Therefore, you will in no way prevent him from giving a teaching but allow for the opportunity for him to teach. So as a result of the aggregation of these proper conditions, there’s the Dharma which is to be taught, there’s a teacher teaching the Dharma, and there are students listening to the Dharma. Only in combination with these three factors coming together does the actual teaching arise itself. So, you know, If we take India as an example, in India, when you travel in India and you live in India, the place is lousy with beggars.

They’re all over the place. So if one had the motivation to practice generosity, then there are many opportunities. There are many objects for us, for our practice, for us to engage in such a type of practice. Not only that, for us not to engage in that type of practice when being asked to give for those who are trying to develop an awakened heart. Would, not to give anything, would diminish the force of our awakening heart, the force of our kindness.

We should at least give a little bit. So we have many opportunities to give a little bit in India. They’re lined up along the streets, the beggars. On the other hand, the number of objects for us to practice patience. For example, in Australia there are a few beggars.

Rinpoche says he hasn’t seen any beggars on the street. So there aren’t that many opportunities to practice generosity as there are in India. On the other hand, just in general in the world, there aren’t that many objects for us to practice patience upon. Therefore, the opportunities there are quite rare. In India, if you go to, for example, Calcutta, the place is full of beggars.

Live in extreme poverty, they have many children, they live a very difficult life. So, in India there’s a great many objects to which we are able to engage in the practice of generosity. In general, there are two types of objects that we can practice generosity. There are, for example, making offerings to the Buddhas and Bodhisattvas. But in addition, there’s the other type and those types of lesser beings, our mother sentient beings who should be the objects of our generosity.

So there are many objects in the world which offers a place or a site to practice generosity. On the other hand, there are very few objects which act as a site or an opportunity for us to practice patience because there aren’t that many people who bring us harm. There’s a difference in the quality between these two objects in the sense that people harm us as a reaction of us having harmed them in the past. And we simply haven’t harmed all that many people in the past. Isn’t going There are very few people who are going to harm us as a reactor, in reaction, in return to our harm, where this isn’t true of generosity.

So the number of people who harm us and therefore the opportunities for practicing patience are extremely rare. So those who act as an opportunity to practice patience are extremely rare. And not only that, but we don’t even have to go to any trouble to find them. They arise from their own side. These people will give us difficulties.

That it’s in the same way that if in our home one day there suddenly appeared without our having to do anything, without any of our effort, a great treasury with jewels and gold, and who wouldn’t be happy? And one would say, Oh, that’s very good, very good. That’s really wonderful. We’d all be happy. We didn’t have to make any effort whatsoever and just out of thin air this great treasury arose and appeared in our house.

Likewise, in such a situation who wouldn’t be happy? Likewise, for those who act as an opportunity for us to practice patience, they appear without our effort, out of thin air from their own side, and who shouldn’t be happy at such an opportunity? The awakening warrior, the bodhisattva, is seeking to achieve buddhahood as quickly as possible. And therefore, in order to the method for achieving Buddhahood is the practice of the six perfections. That is the practice of generosity, ethics, patience, effort, meditative concentration and wisdom.

So since he’s trying to complete, he’s trying to achieve Buddhahood as quickly as possible, he’s trying to bring to completion all of the practices of the six perfections. And among these, he appreciates the fact when he has an opportunity to cultivate patience because the more he’s able to practice patience, the quicker he’s going to arrive at his goal of Buddhahood. Therefore, people who act as objects of his anger, that is possible places where objects which anger could arise, he would not have any opportunity to practice his patience, to cultivate patience, and therefore no opportunity to achieve Buddhahood. Therefore, the bodhisattva looks upon all these beings who treat him with harm, which there is a possibility for the arising of anger toward them as actually assisting him in achieving his goal of Buddhahood. That the more they harm him, the more frequently they harm him, the quicker he’s going to achieve Buddhahood by bringing to completion his practice of patience.

And therefore, he looks upon these beings who force him to practice patience, act as an object of cultivating patience as being extremely kind to him, as being very good. This isn’t just meaningless talk. He actually sees them as helping him or her to achieve their goal, allowing them the opportunity to practice, to bring fulfillment. If for example, we went to work and there was no electricity, we might have a holiday that day but we would never accomplish whatever object of our work might be. We’d just sit there, we’d go home.

Wouldn’t complete our work. And likewise without these opportunities of angering some people, those types of people who we might normally become angry at as an opportunity to practice patience, then the bodhisattva is never going to finish his work, achieve his goal of Buddhahood. Therefore he really is appreciative of such types of people, such types of opportunities. He actually thanks them for this opportunity because they’re bringing him nearer and nearer to his goal of Buddhahood. So in India, normally it’s quite difficult to get around to travel.

So this situation might exist where you had to reach a place very quickly in order to accomplish some great tasks and you had some work that needed to be done very quickly that was very important. And so in such a situation, if you were able to obtain a plane ticket, which you aren’t able to, you would be very happy. You you can accomplish whatever it is you were setting out to do. On the other hand, obviously if you couldn’t obtain a ticket, then your work would be lost. Your goal couldn’t be accomplished.

Likewise, without those who become angry at us, those who act as an opportunity for practicing patience, they help us to attain our goal. Without them, there would be no way that we could accomplish our task that we’re seeking to cultivate through patience. So, it is the harmer who allows us to, gives us the opportunity to practice patience. If the situation were to arise, for example, in India, where wanting to leave the country, you have to attain a pass from the Indian government. And this is quite often very difficult to get.

So if someone in trying to, you know, you wanted to leave the country, you needed your pass. If someone were to assist you to help you out to get the pass, then you’d be very appreciative of all the benefit that they exerted on your behalf and mindful of their great kindness that you’d probably give them some kind of present to show your appreciation. Likewise, it is the harmer which gives us the opportunity to practice patience. Patience is the cause which will ultimately bring the result of Buddhahood. It allows us to quickly complete all the necessary perfection in order to achieve Buddhahood.

So understanding that this person, this harmer, is in fact assisting us in achieving our great goal of Buddhahood and appreciating their kindness in helping us, then we should share the first fruits of having achieved our goal and in this way give them the present of Buddhahood. So, previous to Śākyamūni Buddha achieving enlightenment when he was a bodhisattva practicing along the path, there are many stories about his, the deeds that he performed as a means for achieving enlightenment. And one of these was that in India he came upon a place where there was a starving tigress, a mother tiger, along with her five cubs. She had no food and she was about to die. Out of his great compassion, decided to feed his body to the tigress in order to save her and her five cubs.

And so he cut himself in such a way that because she couldn’t rise up, that she was able to drink some of the blood. And then having been nourished slightly, she went on to eat the bodhisattva and thereby nourish herself and able to feed her cubs. In the future existence when the bodhisattvas finally attained enlightenment, Śākyamūni Buddha, the very first teaching that he gave was at Varanasi. And the very first circle of disciples who he talked to were the five ascetics, who were the reincarnation of these five cubs. So this would show an instance of the operation of the law of cause and effect.

So perhaps, you know, when you visit India next time, if you go on pilgrimage, that you can visit this spot where Buddha offered his body to the tigress. So, we’re trying to develop the attitude that the harmer is giving us the opportunity to practice patience and therefore is extremely kind, it’s extremely beneficial to ourselves. We come to this type of understanding. But the text goes on to where a debater or someone is arguing against such a position. He says that this person who’s doing this harm to us has no intention to benefit us.

Now, since they only have the intention to bring us harm, to bring us difficulty. You are simply, that they can become a method for cultivating patience, which is very good, but the person themselves is not worthy of our respect, is not worthy of our homage or veneration because they have no intention to benefit us. They only have intention to harm us. So, this person who harms us has no beneficial attitude towards us. Out of this situation that we for ourselves create the causes for the creation of skillful actions.

We are self creating the situation, molding the situation into a cause for creating skillful action. That this person, this harmer doesn’t have any beneficial intention towards us and therefore is in no way to be held in any type of high regard in any way to be venerated. So this is the argumenter, the arguer that is arguing this situation. And so Śāntideva answers back, Well, now, if that’s the case then holy Dharma, the sacred Dharma, is itself is not to be held in high regard. It’s not to be venerated because in dependence upon the Dharma we simply from our own side mold the conditions to create skillful actions for our own development, for our own happiness.

But the holy Dharma has no intention of benefiting us. Therefore, if the only things that you’re going to venerate, if the only things that you’re going to hold in high regard are those things which have intention to benefit you, then there’s no sense in venerating or holding in high regard the Dharma. It doesn’t have any intention to benefit you. So they’re arguing back and forth, the person says that Śāntideva is saying that neither that other person who harms you nor the holy Dharma has the intention to benefit you. But since the opportunity to create skillful actions to accomplish your goals is brought about through them, why do you, in both cases, why do you venerate or hold in high regard the Dharma and not the harmer?

So the other person answers back, Well, they aren’t similar. You can’t hold them as being the same case because the other person has the attitude of trying to harm me And the Dharma doesn’t have that attitude. It’s not trying to harm me. So these aren’t similar cases. But you don’t understand the situation.

That only in dependence upon others who are seeking to bring us harm can the opportunity to practice patience arise. If everyone only sought to benefit us, or if everyone only had a beneficial intention to us, then we would never have the opportunity to practice patience and thereby to achieve our goal. If everyone, for example, treated us as a doctor and gave us medicine to make us better, We would never necessarily have to practice patience with respect to someone who’s always trying to benefit us. Therefore, we would never have the opportunity to realize the goal which arises out of patience. It’s only with respect to those who are seeking to harm us, can we ever hope to practice patience.

And it’s only in this way that we can begin to appreciate the person who’s seeking to do his harm and their great kindness in helping us to achieve our goal, which other types of individuals, those who seek to benefit us, don’t offer the opportunity. So with respect to individuals such as those who treat us as a doctor seeking to help us, to benefit us, they don’t offer us the chance to practice patience. It’s only those who possess a harmful intention toward us and bringing harm to us who allow us to practice patience. Therefore, in achieving our goal, that we have to create the causes to achieve that goal. And the cause of patience is the harmful intention of others.

And therefore, just as we have that we hold in high regard the Buddha and the Dharma, since they facilitate achieving our goal. Likewise, we should hold in high regard those who have harmful intentions since they likewise help us to achieve our goal. So the Buddha, just as the basis for growing crops is a field, The Buddha says that as the field of sentient beings are similar to a Buddha field. That in holding in high regard sentient beings, they act as a foundation giving rise or the field giving rise to our ultimate attainment of Buddhahood. So just as a farmer appreciates his field, he understands that and he develops a very caring relationship toward his field appreciating and holding in high regard and high value since he understands that it is the source, it is the foundation or the place which he depends upon to raise his crops.

In dependence upon that he gains his livelihood, provides him with food, with clothing, with all of his expenses and therefore he appreciates his land, his field which is the source of his prosperity. Likewise, the Buddha has said that sentient beings are like the field which give rise to all the qualities of our own Buddhahood. All the qualities, excellent qualities that we may be able to develop arise from the field or the foundation of sentient beings, and therefore we should appreciate them in the same way a farmer appreciates its field. So, in general, anyone who benefits us or shows us kindness, we naturally have a high regard. We appreciate them.

We are happy with them. We like them. In dependence upon sentient beings that we are able to engage in the various practice to cultivate the various attitudes and thereby there is all the qualities of complete Buddhahood which fulfills our own purpose as well as the purpose of others. It depends upon sentient beings. Accumulating two collections of positive potential and wisdom, we are able to bring to completion the practices of patience, that we can generate love and compassion without sentient beings, none of these practices would be possible.

We would not be able to achieve Buddhahood. So all our own happiness is dependent upon the kindness of others. Śāntideva asks, he asks us the question, understanding that our Buddhahood, our ultimate goal is accomplished, in dependence upon both sentient beings and the Buddhas. That if we understand that if we understand that the share of the benefit in arriving at our goal of Buddhahood, we depend half upon sentient beings and half upon the Buddhas. That they are both equal in their kindness to us, that is the sentient beings and the Buddhas, equal in their kindness, equal in their benefit.

In bringing us Buddhahood, they’re exactly the same. But when we say, Oh, I go for refuge to the Buddha. And we have tremendous faith and respect for the Buddhas since they help we think, Well, they’re going to help me attain my spiritual goal of Buddhahood. Therefore, I’m going to respect them. I’m going to venerate them.

Why don’t we venerate sentient beings in the same way since they are in no way different than the Buddhas? Because they also act as the in dependence upon them, we will also achieve our spiritual growth or Buddhahood. Why don’t we venerate them in the same way? There is a difference. It’s not to say that there’s no difference between Buddhas and ordinary sentient beings.

That the Buddhas have completed all the excellent qualities, whereas the sentient beings do not have all of these qualities gathered within them. But from our own side, in order to achieve Buddhahood, we have to rely on them equally, both on the Buddhas and ordinary sentient beings. Therefore, we should treat them with equal regard, hold them in equal regard, hold them as equally high since our final goal from our own side is equally achieved, is achieved equally in dependence upon both of them. Therefore, we should have the same high regard as for the other. There are two objects in dependence upon which we will achieve the spiritual goal of Buddhahood.

There is the object of the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. In this way, we hold them in high regard, that we make offerings, we venerate the Buddha, Dharma and the Sangha. In doing so, we create a great deal of positive potential. In dependence upon the Buddha Dharma and the Sangha, we accumulate the two collections of positive potential and wisdom necessary to achieve Buddhahood. But likewise, there’s a second object, and that is mother sentient beings.

And dependence upon mother sentient beings acting as the object of our practice, we engage in the various practices of generosity, ethics, patience. Develop love, compassion, and finally the awakening heart. And it is these which act as a means for developing the two accumulations of positive potential and wisdom. Therefore, in order to achieve Buddhahood, we have to complete the two collections. And we depend upon, in completing the two collections, upon both the objects of the Buddhadharma and the Sangha on the one hand and Mother Sentient Beings on the other.

Such objects as the houses, earth, water, fire, these do not act as objects for us to accumulate two collections. We cannot make The earth cannot be an object of an offering and of generosity, for example. Therefore, they are not to be held in the same regard as these two objects. Just as in the same way that we hold as precious, the Buddha’s, the Dharma and the Sangha, since they help us to achieve our ultimate goal of Buddhahood. Likewise, since it is necessary to depend upon the sentient beings in exactly the same way to achieve our same goal, we should hold sentient beings as precious also.

We generally respect the Buddhas because we’re mindful of their great kindness and also their great qualities, their kindness in helping us to advance in our spiritual practice and of their great qualities from their side. In developing and thinking about the Buddha qualities, we develop faith. And as a response to this faith in holding the in venerating the Buddhas, We make various types of offerings, prostrations, we go for refuge to the Buddha Dharma, to the Buddha. But such actions on our part are of no benefit to the Buddhas themselves. They’ve already achieved their final goal.

Therefore, you know, whatever we might do, whether we make offerings, etc, are only for our own benefit. That the Buddhas themselves, for example, live on the food of meditative stabilization. They don’t need our food offerings, for example. But these offerings that we make, these prostrations, venerations, etc, are means of accumulating two collections of positive potential and wisdom. Likewise, in the same way sentient beings, though we are able, they act as objects for us to create the two collections, accumulate the two collections of positive potential and wisdom.

That in dependence upon them that we can engage in generosity, ethics, patience, generate love, compassion, and ultimately the awakening heart. But in fact, these may in fact not directly benefit the sentient beings themselves. We are seeking to accumulate the two collections of positive potential and wisdom in order to quickly attain Buddhahood. It’s for our own benefit, our own individual benefit that we are seeking to carry out these practices in the same way that the generation of love may not benefit other sentient beings, but it benefits oneself since it brings you that much closer to Buddhahood. So we’re practicing the Dharma in order to find future happiness and the various activities, practices that we engage in, for example, love, compassion, making offerings, veneration, etcetera, are a means for us to in the future experience happiness without any type of suffering.

That the physical happiness and mental happiness that we experience cannot be of direct benefit to others. That it’s a quality that we experience for ourselves. So the Buddha said that results which are going to be experienced will only ripen upon the creator of the action themselves. That the results of our actions do not ripen on, for example, they don’t ripen upon the earth. The earth doesn’t experience the happiness or suffering that we created the actions, the results of our actions.

The stones don’t experience this, but only the continuity of the aggregates which have been involved in the creation of these actions. They themselves will experience the result of the karma, the actions that they have created. Likewise, with respect to unskillful actions that we create, the results are going to be experienced not by things outside of ourselves, not by earth, not by the stones, not by other people. That those results of the actions that we create are going to be experienced within the continuity of ourselves, whether it’s over a number of eventually over a series of rebirths, that we’re going to experience the result of all the actions that we’ve created. Nothing outside of our self will experience these results.

So we should consider this fact that we ourselves will only experience the results of the actions that we create and that the experiences that we go through are created by ourselves. Understanding that if we abandon unskillful actions, destructive actions, we begin to cultivate skillful, constructive actions, then the result will be that we will experience no suffering. That in fact we will only experience happiness throughout all our lives. And therefore thinking about this way, beginning to implement in our daily practice the adoption of constructive actions and beginning to reject negative actions as a means to have future experiences of only happiness. So, we’ve finished the time, but if you have any doubts or qualms, any questions, we can discuss those.

Do we have any questions? Skillful actions. If we, see a person, coming, we know he’s got harmful intentions. Himself is it a skillful action to avoid that person? Rather than confront the person and have to go through the business of having to practice patience if we just avoid it’s probably then.

Is it better to avoid or practice patience? Well, it is better to practice patience. But I just wonder if there’s a skillful action, my circumstances would arise, perhaps in time would make it better, the opportunity is not quite right now to practice patience. Let’s let’s get out of it. I’ll make that up.

I’ve already answered. Let’s come back to another one. How did Milarepa practice patience? Actually in Milarepa’s life, he went through a great deal of harm by others, harmed by others. Many of his relatives tried to harm him, brought him a great deal of harm.

And he was also always constantly disturbed by demons and all kinds of spirits like that. So he had many opportunities to practice patience. So Milarepa, his main teacher was Marpa. Marpa used to call Milarepa, Abdu was just the family name, but Thöpa means having great power. Previously, Milarepa had undergone a great deal of suffering due to his relatives.

Through the practice of black magic and using mantra, he brought down a hailstorm on many of his relatives and he actually killed many of his relatives. He was very kind of person when he was young. So, this would not be appropriate for someone who is trying to develop an awakening heart. The bodhicitta that he’s trying to develop love and compassion as a means to ultimately bring about the liberation of all sentient beings. That is to say for the purpose of others.

But he’s also aiming for his or her own purposes of eliminating one’s own suffering. So for the purpose of liberating others and to eliminate one’s own suffering one engages in the practice of developing love and compassion. So the bodhisattva is very mindful of the kindness of other sentient beings and wishes to repay their great kindness and therefore wants to bring them complete happiness. Not just a little bit of happiness, but complete happiness. And he understands that or she understands that this capacity can only be achieved once he or she has attained Buddhahood, that this is in the best position to actually bring about the complete happiness of others.

If first one attains Buddhahood, then one can engage in teaching the Dharma, instructing people on what is to be adopted, what is to be rejected and thereby actually bringing about and helping them to implement the methods for achieving their own happiness. And this can only be brought about when one has the capacity having first achieved Buddhahood. So the motivation behind practicing cultivating love and compassion is to accumulate the collection of positive potential and wisdom to quickly achieve Buddhahood and thereby as a means to bring about the happiness of others. So one is cultivating it in order to achieve the true accumulation. Cannot help others before we attain Buddhahood.

It’s just a matter of degree that until we achieve Buddhahood we can only be of temporal, occasional benefit to others in a temporal sense. But it’s only upon achieving Buddhahood that we can be of complete help to others and trying to bring them some kind of complete happiness. So we can help others but only in a very temporal sense. We cannot bring in any ultimate happiness. So, you know, we can bring people a temporary benefit, temporal benefit such that, you know, we can give them food, clothing, things like this.

We’ll bring them some kind of temporary happiness. You know, we can definitely involve ourselves in this. We can even go on to give instructions on how to cultivate compassion which is going to bring them eventual happiness in the future. So these are methods of temporally benefiting others. If you were to advise advise someone that they should quit killing, that they should practice patience, ethics, things of this nature, and they took this to heart and they actually engaged themselves in these practices, then they would experience as a result of these actions happiness in the future.

Would be a way of helping someone in a temporal sense. Does that mean Yeah, didn’t say that fact. The stone, the earth and the stone, they don’t experience the happiness or suffering. They don’t experience happiness. Okay.

Yeah. Go ahead. Okay. But do animals? Do animals experience the results of their actions in the past?

Affected because it’s not permanent? Or is it is our effect on our environment and on those around us not an effect because it doesn’t last? So, what it meant was that other than oneself, the ripening effect is not experienced by others, of one’s actions. The ripening effect, the happiness and unhappiness of one’s own action is only experienced for oneself. So if we take an example of someone’s hungry, so you give them some food and they experience happiness.

So that happiness arose from them from the factor of the food, not from your generous intention. The result of your generous intention will have a ripening effect which only yourself will experience. They’re not experiencing the effect of your generous intention, only they experience happiness that depends upon the factor of that food. So we have to, it would have to be a little more refined in the sense that you’re giving them this food in general we say results in their happiness. But here we’re talking about the ripening effect of your giving that food is only experienced for yourself.

There are three types of effects of skillful actions. The first is the ripening effect, and this is the feeling which arises as a result of an action and this is only experienced by oneself, it’s not experienced by others. The second is the cause which is the effect which is similar to the cause. The effect which is similar to the cause. And the third is the environmental effect.

And this is for example, the place that you live in, your home, the food, the things that you have around you are the environmental effect of your actions that you’ve created. So this first effect, the ripening effect, is experienced by the individual, only the individual himself as a feeling either of suffering or happiness. As a consequence of unskillful actions, one experiences suffering. As a consequence of skillful actions, one experiences happiness. This is the main effect of actions.

So if we take an example of killing, the consequences, the ripening effect of killing is only suffering, the feeling of suffering. With respect to the which is, with the effect which is similar to the cause, there are two types. There is the effect which is similar to the cause from the point of view of behavior and from the point of view of experience. From the point of view of behavior, the effect which is similar to the cause will be that one will have a natural inclination or liking to kill in the future. Having killed in the past, there will be this repetitive pattern which will be similar and one will have predisposition, a tendency, a liking to kill again.

The experience which is from the point of view of the experience which is similar to the effect which is similar to the cause, having killed others, that is to say having shortened their life, one’s self will experience a shorter life. One will die very quickly. No matter what you might do to prevent it, your life will be very short as a consequence of having shortened the life. Rather, this is the effect which is similar to the cause from the point of view of experience. So in this way we can make use of the reverse process.

If we in fact we want a long life, we should engage in actions which are just the opposite. That is to say, which are, for example in the case of animals, saving life is a means of lengthening our life. For example, animals which are about to be killed, you know that’s quite often the case where they’re going to the slaughterhouse and perhaps the next day they’re going to be killed. That if you were to buy this animal and allow it to in a situation where it could continue to live out its natural life, you would be as if lengthening that sentient being’s life and this would have the experiential effect of lengthening one’s own life. So these actions are going to always return to ourselves and by lengthening the life of others, we in the future will have a longer life.

Practicing generosity to others, we ourselves will have lots of material prosperity. By being patient with others, you will in the future have a beautiful body. This is the way the law of cause and effect operates. For every action there’s a reaction. If In shortening the life of others, killing others, our own life in the future will be shortened.

In stealing, taking others possessions that we in the future will have very few possessions, we’ll be a beggar for example. By expressing and having an angry expression on our face getting angry at others, we will be born with an ugly face in the future.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
buddha field buddhakshetra (Skt); sang gye kyi zhing (Tib)
In some ways synonymous with pure land, although it can also mean any pure environment, seen as a manifestation of wisdom. LYWA
Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
two accumulations sambharadvaya (Skt); tsog nyi (Tib)
Also called the two collections or two types of merit, they are: the merit of virtue, which develops the method side of the path by practicing generosity and so forth, and the merit of (transcendental) wisdom... LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top