1 h 7 min · 3,128 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 67-minute session, Kyabje Rinpoche guides students through the Cittamātra (Mind Only) school’s understanding of the Alaya Vijñāna (mind basis of all), focusing on the distinction between conceptual and non-conceptual consciousness. He examines whether the Alaya Vijñāna functions as sensory or mental consciousness, then explores the core teaching: how conceptual minds rely on generic images while non-conceptual minds perceive directly. Through dialogue, Rinpoche draws on concrete examples—your mother’s face appearing instantly, the color blue in a dream, impermanence of a table realized through meditation—to test students’ understanding and help them identify non-conceptual mental consciousness within their own experience. He probes the subtle boundary between memory, concept, and direct realization. Aimed at serious practitioners with prior Cittamātra study.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 27062017cittamatra – KR.mp3
UUID: fc3d0d37-b0ca-4edd-84e2-666f44911ec9
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Awareness and Knowledge
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,120
So as you remember the definition of the Alaya Vijñāna which was given is a neutral and unstained consciousness which is the base infused with the imprints and has an extremely stable continuum. This definition as you remember, as was explained last time has three components. The first component that the Alaya Vijñāna or the mind basis of all has an extremely stable continuum does not mean that the Alaya Vijñāna is permanent. Now, if you were to inquire whether the mind basis of all is a sensory consciousness or a mental consciousness, From the standpoint of Cittamātra, it is neither a sensory consciousness nor is it a mental consciousness. So, I have noticed that there are some new faces in the audience then this class will be easy for you because it is dedicated to the Chitamatra or the mind only school for within the four schools of tenets.
And we have been studying Chitamatra for two or three months and specifically the Alaya Vijñāna or the mind basis of all. So when we speak of the Cittamātra or mind only school, this is a school of propounders of Mahāyāna tenets and it is difficult to understand without a fair bit of habituation. So as was said, the Alaya Vijñāna is therefore neither a sensory consciousness nor a mental consciousness. At present, let us address the question of whether the Alaya Vijñāna is a conceptual or a non conceptual consciousness. In your opinion, is it conceptual or non conceptual?
Why? If something is neutral, it is not necessarily non conceptual. There’s no definiteness. In other words, Alaya Vijñāna itself is present as a neutral continuum of mind all the way until the attainment of full and utter enlightenment at which point it turns into a virtuous mind. I think it’s conceptual because it’s a non attentive mind.
Okay. I would I don’t know, but I would think not simply because it is not a fully functional mind. It cannot engage with objects. It does not engage with objects, and without engaging with objects, it cannot form a concept. Okay.
So we were just told before it was neither a mental or a sensory consciousness. So it can’t be conceptual if it’s not a mental consciousness. Because it is not a mental consciousness. Well, that’s what we were told. It it earlier, according to Chitamatra, it is neither a sensory nor a mental consciousness.
So from that definition, it cannot be conceptual mind. It cannot be. Nonetheless, we have no experience of it and we are unable to use it. It is only through repeated habituation through meditation that we will eventually become able to use the mind basis of all. Settlement, you know, is settlement, big settlement.
So it is an extremely subtle mind and this is a specific focus or mode of assertion of So the famous scholar who was the founder of the Jonangpa tradition asserted that the mind basis of all was truly established and consider that apart from the mind basis of all everything was falsely established. So now regarding the question whether the mind basis of all of the Alaya Vijñāna was a conceptual or a non conceptual consciousness, Geshela thinks it is preferable to view it as a non conceptual consciousness since conceptual consciousnesses tend to discriminate between their objects saying this is this or that is that and the Alaya Vijñāna is not able to do this. It sounds a bit awkward but I would say it’s a dull mind. So regarding therefore the non conceptuality of the Alaya Vijñāna, there is no clear scriptural source in the works of Je Tsongkhapa or his source which is Asaṇga and his half brother Vasubandhu indicating that the mind basis of all is non conceptual. Nonetheless, the scholars who debated this in the great monasteries tend to consider the Alaya Vijñāna as non conceptual.
So it is therefore preferable to view the Alaya Vijñāna as a non conceptual mind, and specifically as an inattentive mind. A mind to which phenomena appear but are not ascertained. Now, what precisely appears to the Alaya Vijñāna? What appears are form and the five sensory objects. And the reason for which it is not a conceptual mind is because conceptual minds perceive phenomena through relying on meaning generalities or generic images.
And there is no meaning generality apprehended by the Alaya Vijñāna. And the is not mental consciousness. Now in our own cases as ordinary beings and I think we can say everyone in this room is an ordinary being. We are or have direct experience both of conceptual minds which are typically mental consciousnesses and we have also experience of non conceptual minds which for ourselves are typically sensory consciousnesses. Now, all sensory consciousnesses are necessarily non conceptual.
This is not the case with mental consciousnesses which are not necessarily conceptual and therefore we must be able to posit an instance of a mental consciousness which is non conceptual. Within our own consciousnesses as ordinary beings, can you give an instance of a non conceptual mental consciousness? Do you understand? Yes. Sorry.
We were talking about this earlier and I I struggle to find an answer. I cannot find an answer. I cannot see how a dream can be a non conceptual consciousness. So what instance, what example can you give within our mind streams of non conceptual mental consciousness? States of meditation in which there is concentration and attention No, because when you meditate initially, you have to start with an object of observation with which you become familiar and the visualization of that object of observation is conceptualized on a meaning generality or a generic image.
No, so this is asking within our own continua. So within the mind stream of an ārya being you can give clearly direct yogic valid perceiver which is a non conceptual mental consciousness. Direct yogic cognizer. The question is within our mind streams. Is there or isn’t there?
In vision science we are taught that what some images have been already received by the retina, it is processed with higher cortical processing and one example is depth perception. Excuse me, higher cortical processing and after you said what? One example is depth perception. Depth perception. That’s not processed by the retina, that’s processed up in the brain.
By the cortical? Yes. The prefrontal cortex. Ignorance grasping at itself considered a non conceptual mental consciousness? So the ignorance grasping of the self is conceptual.
A direct valid cogniser. Which one? Yes, well I’m struggling to find a personal direct valid cognition. I was wondering if the moment at which you hear something and you cannot label it before it is labeled and you have a question in your mind, there’s no concept, but there’s a sense of questioning if that would be an example of a non conceptual So that’s exactly the answer given in Lorig, which is that when the continuum of sensory consciousness is perceiving any of the five sense objects ceases, before it induces a conceptual consciousness, there is one instant of mental consciousness, which is non conceptual. So let us take the example of one’s mother.
Now, I think all of us would we think of our mother, but instantaneously there’s very clear image of our mother’s face which appears. It’s clearly not a sensory consciousness, but Geshela thinks it is perhaps not a conceptual consciousness either because it doesn’t seem to rely on a meaning generality or a generic image. That would be an instance of a non conceptual mental consciousness. So clearly, appearance of one’s mother’s face when one’s in one’s mind’s eye, if you wish, when one thinks of her is not due to a sensory consciousness. However, it does not seem either to be a conceptual consciousness because of the great clarity and instantaneous appearance of one’s mother’s face when one thinks of her.
And this is why Geshela thinks it does not rely on a generic image or a meaning generality. The image, the instance given for non conceptual mental consciousnesses in Lorig are the clear appearance of the color blue in a dream. And the key point here is a term clear. The only reason why we all have the idea of mother in whatever image it was in our minds was because you said our mother. And that itself is a concept.
Nothing would have would have come to my mind if you hadn’t said your mother. So if we take the example of the appearance of the face of our mother to our mind, there is no particular reason it should be conceptual because it doesn’t seem to rely on a meaning generality or generic image. When phenomena appear to a conceptual mind and they rely on a meaning generality or a generic image, they are typically a bit nebulous and unclear. Whereas in this case, our mother’s face appears with perfect clarity. Chris.
If the example in Lorig, the clear appearance of the color blue in a dream, would it not apply to any clear appearance within a dream, meaning that the dream name is an example of a non conceptual mind? No. Because in the in a dream, there are numerous types of consciousness and the example given in Lorig is that of the clear appearance of the color blue in a dream. Emphasis on clear here. Not everything in the dream is clear.
Isn’t it also reliant on memory? What, Anita? Well your mother’s face is a memory so that’s a concept. There is no definiteness that everything which is a memory is necessarily conceptual. The classic example given is memories of previous lives.
Was just going to ask the reasons that you’re giving for the mother’s face not being conceptual were the same reasons I was thinking of as to why the ignorance grasping of the self would be non conceptual because the self would seem to be so instantaneous and so clear that it would not necessarily rely on mental image or meaning generality. If you can identify clearly the object of the ignorance grasping at a self, then I’ll agree, but does it appear clearly to you? So let us take another example. Let us take the case of the little table in front of Geshela. Then we would all agree verbally that the table is impermanent.
This is very different affair, however, to gain a realization of the impermanence of table for which we must rely on scriptural sources, on reasons, and on logic. And proceeding in this way, we get this sense. So for this, we must rely on a meaning generality. Now, when you came into the temple tonight, and you saw this table the first time tonight, if at that instant, without any effort, naturally and spontaneously, the realization this table is impermanent arose, then that would probably qualify as a non conceptual mental consciousness realizing the impermanence of the table. Whereas most probably when you entered the temple and you saw the table, due to self grasping within our minds, we all thought this table is permanent.
It’s the same table as yesterday. Yeah, I think but not sure, you know. So we must meditate to generate this non conceptual realization of the impermanence of table which then becomes spontaneous. So it’s obvious that we do not have this realization yet because we need numerous lines of reasoning to convince ourselves that the table is impermanent and it might take at the very least five minutes. That brings us back to the image of our mother.
Our mother’s image in our minds is very familiar, because we have seen her over and over and over and over again. And in order to attain the realization of the impermanence of the table, you have to meditate over and over and over again before you get a realization, a non conceptual realization of the table. Isn’t it just a function of realization the concept becomes something else, becomes a non concept? Definitely, this is it is the case for mental non conceptual realization which rely on experience. However, obviously not for sensory consciousnesses which perceive things in the present non conceptually.
Okay. So you have done very well on these topics. This is an important issue, the distinction between conceptual and non conceptual consciousnesses. You clearly understand that sensory consciousnesses are non conceptual and that mental consciousnesses can be conceptual or non conceptual and you are able to distinguish them. So returning at present to the basis of all, as you remember in the definition of the mind basis of all, it is said that this is a consciousness which is the base of infusion of the imprints.
Generally speaking, the basis of all is subdivided into two. The supporting basis of all and the supported basis of all. The supporting basis of all or the mind basis of all is the actual or the fully characterized Alaya Vijñāna. At present, we will pass to the second subdivision which is the supported basis of all or the imprints. We’ve come to the imprints.
We’ll be talking of imprints, seeds and potencies. So at present, the karmic imprints are what is awakened, what arises. The mind basis of all is the basis of infusion. The karmic imprints are awakened or activated by the seven remaining mental collections. So you know what the eight collections of consciousness are.
These are the five sensory consciousnesses, the mental consciousness, the afflicted mind, and the mind bases of all. So we will talk about the mode of implantation or positing of the imprints later on. Geshela would like to emphasize this distinction between conceptual and non conceptual minds, which is so important. Now taking the desire the case of desire and setting aside desire associated with the visual consciousness, broadly speaking, desire is conceptual. So I would really like to focus on three afflictions, desire, pride and anger.
Now conceptions rely on meaning generalities or generic images. There is no such thing as a conception which is not linked to a meaning generality. Let us at present meditate during a couple of minutes on the distinction between conceptual and non conceptual minds. Over the prayer book, page one, we recite one b two three four. Page five, number six, mandala three.
First one and three. Regarding Mark’s question on the non conceptual nature of the ignorance grasping at itself, I suspect it comes from the difficulty we have in distinguishing between the ignorance on the one side and its object, this I which is apprehended, is very difficult to understand clearly. I think, you know, I think I’m not sure. I suspect that your question arises from the issue of how ignorance apprehends its object of observation, which is the I. Because independence on its apprehension of the object of observation, then a series of processes are initiated.
And the other issue is obviously the distinction between grasping at a self and self cherishing then obviously the texts say that they are different but it’s difficult to posit the difference. Grasping at itself. Okay, have you questions? Few? Quick, please.
Just a quick one back to the definition. In the definition given, it speaks about which is the main mind which is posited as being as being the basis for the karmic imprints. Why partially? So it’s a difficult topic, I won’t enter into it in detail. It is linked to the presence or the absence of the Alaya Vijñāna in the continuum of an Arhat and on the three Pure Grounds.
Obviously, when you want to enter into this level of detail, you must debate on these topics for months on end and then it’s really worth it. Very good way to look at it. Is the Alaya Vijñāna inherently existent given that it transmigrates from life to life? Inherently existent. In Cittamātra it is definitely inherently It is truly established, it is established on the basis of its own mode of abiding and it is inherently established.
With the four schools of Tibet and the four main schools in Tibetan Buddhism, do any of those adhere to the Cittamātra ahead of the Madhyamaka? Actually, when Je Tsongkhapa was studying with his main teacher, they seem to have focused mainly on the Cittamātra view. Now regarding whether any of the four schools in Tibet relies on Cittamātra, probably not. Probably they rely on Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka, everything depends on the individual practitioner and the individual practitioners understanding of his experiences. So the way to proceed is to think and to investigate carefully over time oneself and whatever system of tenets one ends up with, that is a system tenet of tenets one should adopt.
Last week, we were investigating the issue of how the mind basis of all can be impermanent. Why is it not permanent? And according to the Yogachara, it’s as you just said, that it’s inherently existent, truly established. Even if it is if the Yogachara posit that it’s impermanent because of its momentariness, moment by moment by moment by moment, there’s a gap between each of those moments. And why is that any different from the gap in deep sleep in consciousness?
It seems that unless the Alaya Vijñāna is permanent, it’s not momentary, then it doesn’t really solve the problem of of the lack of consciousness and deep sleep. Does are you following what I’m saying? Is what I’m saying clear at all? Up to the last 20%. Up to the what?
Last 20% was very clear. Last 20. Okay. Okay. How does the Alaya Vijñāna how did the Yogachara justify So one is perfectly entitled to investigate whether the Alaya Vijñāna is permanent or impermanent.
However, according to Cittamātra, it is impermanent and the reason given is it is it is the base infused with the virtuous and non virtuous karmic imprints that is considered sufficient to establish it as impermanent. In addition, the Alaya Vijñāna is a very subtle state of mind. Now just as the person can proceed from the coarser to the more subtle, Likewise, minds can proceed from the coarser to the more subtle, the ever more subtle. And at present, when we think of impermanence, we’re thinking of impermanence with coarse minds and coarse persons in a very coarse and primitive way like boom boom boom things change. Now this is not what is happening with the Alaya Vijñāna.
Then Geshela would like you to debate tonight about the distinction between conceptual and non conceptual consciousnesses and why conceptual consciousnesses rely on a generic image or a meaning generality. Okay. Please. Quick. Not have time, no more.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- lorig
- Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.