Awareness and Knowledge

1 h 16 min · 3,463 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Awareness and Knowledge (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awareness and Knowledge (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awareness and Knowledge
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 77-minute analysis of Chitamatra (Mind-Only) philosophy, Kyabje Rinpoche examines the Alāyavijñāna—the subtle mind that stores karmic imprints—and resolves a central puzzle: where does it fit within Buddhist philosophy’s sevenfold division of consciousness? Using the example of falling asleep and remembering breakfast plans the next morning, he shows why sensory consciousnesses cannot account for memory, requiring an eighth consciousness to preserve imprints. He carefully analyzes whether the Alāyavijñāna is a valid cognizer, an inference, doubt, or inattentive awareness—concluding it is an inattentive mind to which objects appear but are not ascertained. The teaching emphasizes the need for rigorous reasoning and personal reflection beyond textual study.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Cittamantra – KR.mp3

UUID: c16476ee-4bed-403d-afb7-47bd24a1c0b6

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Awareness and Knowledge

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~3,464

So regarding the establishment of the view, one normally would teach all four systems of tenets in sequence to one person, beginning with the Vaibhāṣika system of tenets, and then moving up to the Sautrāntika and Chitamatra and eventually Mādhyamika system of tenets. There is however no definiteness, it is not necessary in general to have studied the lower views like Vaibhāṣika or Sautrāntika to study the higher views such as Mādhyamika. Everything depends on the constituents and the outlook of the trainee. So what exactly does Chitamatra mind only teach? Chitamatra mind only teaches that exterior physical phenomena arise necessarily in dependence on a mind.

They therefore do not have an uncommon mode of abiding. This is the teaching of Chitamatra. Chitamatra teaches that physical phenomena depend on the mind. It is the mode of dependence on the mind which is open to question. And this outlook is of great benefit to understand the Prāsaṇgika view according to which phenomena are mere conceptual imputations out there.

Then both permanent and impermanent phenomena exist. But what do we mean when we say they exist? From a Buddhist standpoint, this means that since the definition of existence is what is observed by a valid cognizer, that they are observed by a valid cognizer, in other words that they are understood or known. This means that existence is contingent on the mind. There is no existence without mental perception.

Of course, you know. Therefore, for Chitamatra or phenomena established as being merely of the nature of mind, whereas for Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, all phenomena are mere conceptual imputations. The distinction is one which is very profound and difficult to understand and there’s no time to go with it. But this is something one should broach through personal reflection. Obviously, beginners like ourselves must initially look or study these great texts, But unfortunately, when we have closed the book more often than not, whatever knowledge we had is gone.

So we must reflect over and again on the material. Then initially, obviously, as beginners, we must read, we must study, but that is not sufficient. If we were only to read texts and we’re not to reflect by ourselves, we would not reap the benefits. So after studying or reading, we must think deeply about these topics. So the distinction is very clear if we analyze the process of perception.

Let us take the visual consciousness perceiving the color blue. According to both Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika, the color blue and the visual consciousness perceiving the color blue are in a causal relationship. The visual consciousness perceiving the color blue arises after the color blue of which it is the of the condition of observation. According to Chitamatra, however, these two are not in a causal relationship. They are simultaneous.

Then from the standpoint of Chitamatra, the question which arises is when we speak of the color blue in the lower schools, before it is perceived by the visual consciousness of one observer, it exists. It must therefore have been perceived by someone else. By who? So last time, I mentioned to you that the mind basis of all, Alāyavijñāna was subtle, and the issue was which arose of what was precisely this subtleness meant. It is best understood if we compare the understanding of the sensory consciousnesses.

The sensory sensory consciousnesses are self evident. However, if we set the sensory consciousnesses aside, we understand the existence of other states of mind such as the Alāyavijñāna through reasoning. For that reason, they are said to be more subtle. So if you reflect on what would happen if you eliminated the object of sensory consciousnesses, You will get a sense of why we must have an Alāyavijñāna. Can you therefore give me an object of knowledge once we have evacuated the objects perceived by the sensory consciousnesses?

Other? Kishila wants something from your experience, not from books. Friends. So precisely in our cases, because we are so overwhelmingly dependent on sensory consciousnesses, we naturally believe that that which is not an object of a sensory consciousness does not exist. So we have to try to put sensory consciousness aside, and then ask ourselves what other objects are they?

And we can see that there’s quite a few. So the Alaya Vajnana actually is established both by means of logic or reasoning and scriptural sources. Now it is a little bit odd to say it’s a to scriptural sources, because frankly if we analyze scriptural sources themselves, overwhelmingly are rooted in logic. Someone at some point analyzed carefully, and after careful analysis wrote a book or work, and this became a scriptural source. It’s important not to oppose reasoning and scriptural quotations, because when we say established by reasoning, well who actually established it?

A scholar, and that establishment eventually leads to scripture quotation. So let us take an example which will make this clear. Most of us tonight before going to sleep, will start thinking what we will have for breakfast tomorrow morning. We might have bread, but we might have fried eggs. Some of mischief would be nice.

Then after thinking about all of this, we go asleep. We go to sleep. But tomorrow morning when we wake up, we will know about this. Now how is this possible? It is due to the fact that a potency, a karmic imprint, what you yourself choose to call a memory, is deposited in the mind.

Other words, this depends on the mind. So let us analyze carefully what happens when we go to sleep. When we go to sleep, the five sensory consciousnesses cease. There is no sleep if any of these sensory consciousnesses is operational. In addition, at least according to Asaṇga, the mental consciousness ceases.

However, when we wake up, we remember the plans we made the night before for breakfast. How is such a memory possible? The sensory consciousnesses have ceased, the mental consciousness at moments of the night has ceased. So what happens is that this memory in the morning is connected to the potency, the karmic imprints, the memories if you prefer, deposited the night before. Where?

In the ālaya vijnana. So if you think about this carefully, you will see that it’s quite potent. Therefore the mind basis of all is continually present within our continuum. What is the meaning or the definition of the Alāyavijñāna in Jinaputra Chökyi Gyaltsen’s tenets? The Alāyavijñāna is a mind which does not depend on the six collections of mind, in other words the five collections plus the mental consciousness, and in addition whose controlling condition is not the mental consciousness.

And therefore, the mind basis of all passes from life to life, from countless past reincarnations, and according to Chitamatra, it is truly established. So within our mental continuum, each one of us has a mind basis of all, an Alāyavijñāna. And in addition, this mind basis of all, which is one of the eight collections of consciousness, is a main mind. So in Buddhist epistemology, awareness, knowledge, and consciousness are synonymous. And it is asserted that all awarenesses can be included within the sevenfold division of awareness and knowledge or logic.

Now actually this is debatable. One can come up with examples which seem difficult to fit in. Then it is very important to understand thoroughly the sevenfold division of mind and awareness. Do you know it? Which one?

Who knows? Okay. Six. Yeah. Conviction.

Conviction is What are you reading the book for? You. So at present, since you’ve explained it a bit, I have the right to explain to you how it is. The sevenfold division of my of knowledge and awareness is first subdivided into two. Minds which are valid cognizers and minds which are not valid cognizers.

The minds which are valid cognizers are twofold. The minds which are not valid cognizers are fivefold. So we take the topic of the subject, the mind basis of all, where does it fit within the sevenfold division of mind and awareness? Now the sevenfold subdivision is, as we said, sort of divided into two, valid cognizers and non valid cognizers. Valid cognizers are subdivided into two, direct valid cognizers and inferential valid cognizers. So where does the Alāyavijñāna fit within the sevenfold division?

Is the ālaya viznana a direct valid cognizer? No. Because to put it very simply, a valid cognizer knows its object in an unobstructed fashion. A valid cognizer is able to induce definiteness or certainty regarding its object. The Alāyavijñāna is not able to induce definiteness or certainty regarding its object.

So if we take examples of direct valid cognizers, most of the majority of visual perceptions or auditory perceptions would be direct valid cognizers. Then is the Alāyavijñāna an inferential valid cognizer. What is an inferential valid cognizer? It is a valid cognizer, a concept which is conceptual and understands by means of a correct reason. Let us take an example.

If we have a schoolboy, let’s say eight, nine, or 10 years old, and that schoolboy is very subdued in his physical and verbal behavior and seems to have mental qualities, and based on that, we will say, this is something we all do in daily life, he must have good parents or a good teacher. That’s an inference. And then based on that, we might also infer that he probably has mental qualities. Then our inference or inferential valid cognizer induces definiteness by means of reliance on a valid reason. The Alāyavijñāna, the mind basis of all, cannot do this.

It is therefore not an inferential valid cognizer. So we since the Alāyavijñāna is neither a direct valid cognizer nor an inferential valid cognizer, It is not a mind from the category of valid cognizers. Then if the mind basis of all is a mind which is a nonvalid cognizer, which of the five minds is it? The first of these is subsequent cognition, the second is conviction, the third is doubt, the fourth is an inattentive mind, and the fifth is a wrong consciousness. So is the mind basis of all a subsequent cognizer?

No. The main subsequent cognizers are memories. We say at present, we remember something from the past. It is a subsequent cognizer. The mind basis of all cannot remember.

Then is the mind basis of all the next non valid cognizer, which is conviction. No. Convictions are minds which arise in dependence on reasonings, valid or invalid. Then for instance, when we have discussion after the class, we generate convictions. We are talking about the mind basis of all.

No one really understands what they’re talking about. Then is the mind basis of all this? No. So an example will make this clearer. If we take this building for instance, its coarse impermanence is something we understand.

Its subtle impermanence is something we assert. We say this building changes instant by instant. But we actually do not understand the mode of instantaneous disintegration of this building. So we are convinced of this. We have faith in this, but we do not understand this.

However, this conviction is concorded with the actual mode of reality, the mode of existence of the building. So in our own cases, even though verbally we assert that phenomena disintegrate instant by instant, it is mere talk. It is very difficult to understand subtle impermanence. So in the case of this house, for instance, its coarse impermanence is self evident. However, its subtle impermanence, which is actually the foundation of its coarse impermanence, since without the momentary disintegration of this building, it could never eventually collapse.

That’s something which we do not understand. It is something which we accept and we pay lip service to. Now when we pay lip service to something and that which we pay lip service to is in keeping with reality, then that is a conviction. Then moving on to the fourth mental, the fourth mind, which is a non valid cognizer doubt, is the mind basis of all doubt. No.

I mean, our whole process of reflection on the mind basis of all now is doubt. We are asking ourselves is the mind basis of all this or that or something else. We are not quite sure. That is doubt. But the mind, basis of all itself, is unable to do this.

It is not a doubtful state of mind. Then although this is unclear in the root text, the Alāyavijñāna is probably non conceptual. This precludes its being doubt since doubt by definition is conceptual. Now is the mind basis of all a wrong consciousness? What exactly is a wrong consciousness?

Let us take for instance this table. Then it is evident if we analyze carefully that yesterday’s table and today’s table are not the same. They are different. But if we were to assert unilaterally that they are one and the same, that they are exactly identical and not just related, then that would be the wrong view of grasping at permanence. And the mind basis of all is not a wrong view.

However, the mind basis of all does have an object. It is a mind. This is explicitly stated in your root text in which it is said that apart from the yes. Here we are. Page three.

As the apprehended factor of basis of all, it is apprehended by the five consciousnesses, and since it is imputed terminologically by the sixth, it is definite in both realms. So what is it? Within these seven subdivisions of mind and awareness, what is the mind basis of all? However, there is no explicit statement to this effect. Therefore, it is something we must infer through analysis after trying to place it within the sevenfold subdivision of mind and awareness.

So let us take an example to understand what an inattentive mind, literally a mind which phenomena appear but are not definite is. If we take the example of a football match, when we’re watching a football match, we naturally tend to focus on the star player, the best player. Then we know exactly what the star player is doing. The other players appear to our visual consciousness, but we are not concentrating on them, and we are not actually aware of the details of their movement. We perceive them as an inattentive consciousness.

So if we continue with the example of a football match, it could be any other sport like cricket, there are numerous sports. Obviously, we’re focusing on the star player. So we know everything the star player did and is doing. He came from here. He played in that way.

He’s going there. But what the other players are doing, we’re not mindful of. And so it is an inattentive mind with respect to them. The mind basis of all is a mind to which the five sense objects appear just as the five sense organs, but it is an inattentive mind with respect to them. Because if it were an attentive mind, if it were a valid cognizer, then the being within whose continuous consciousness the Alāyavijñāna was would be aware of them.

Then I would like to ask you to memorize the definitions of the seven subdivisions of mind and awareness, and to recite them every day, we’ll bring them up in class. They are you can find them in English in Elizabeth Napper’s Mind in Tibetan Buddhism. Then let us meditate during a couple minutes on the sevenfold subdivision of mind and awareness, and the place of the Alāyavijñāna within it. Page one. I will take at present some questions.

Okay. So So Alāyavijñāna is the repository of imprints such as, deciding what you want to eat for breakfast the night before according to Chitamatra. But, so what does the mental consciousness do according to Chitamatra? Because my understanding of the mental consciousness, for example from Prāsaṇgika and Mādhyamika would be that it would be the the consciousness that would decide what to have for breakfast the next morning. So not quite.

In Prāsaṇgika, it’s not the mental consciousness, which is a depository of memories or karmic imprints. It’s the I. Isha, this is about the relationship between the afflicted mind and the Alāyavijñāna. The karmic imprints, negative karma, for example, or positive for that matter generated in the afflicted mind, do they somehow get deposited from there into the mind bases of all? And how is that done?

How do those two consciousnesses relate to each other? The mode of depositing of the karmic imprints in the mind basis of all and the afflicted mind are the same. Now we’ll be talking of the afflicted mind later, but in brief for Chitamatra, the afflicted mind is the locus of the imprints which arise from the view of the disintegrating composite. So whenever afflictions such as anger arise, they arise because of the absence of this view, and they are deposited then in the afflicted mind. Your thoughts are very good ones.

The key here is to understand that for all Buddhist schools of tenets without exception, the locus or the place where karmic imprints are implanted is the person. Then when they try to identify what the person actually is, difficulties arise. For Chitamatra, for instance, the person ultimately is the mind basis of all. This is what they point at for the person. Mhmm.

Very important, you know. Does the Alāyavijñāna remain an inattentive mind within the mind of a Buddha? It wouldn’t seem that a Buddha could have an inattentive mind. So what does a Buddha do to move it from that division into another division? It’s a good doubt there is no mind basis of all within the mental continuum of a Buddha.

The mind basis of all ceases upon that mental continuum upon the attainment of full enlightenment. It becomes what is known as the mirror like wisdom, which is omniscience, is therefore necessarily a valid cognizer. In our own cases, we are unable to use at present the Alāyavijñāna, and we know of its existence only through lines of reasoning. But upon the attainment of full enlightenment, a fully enlightened being can use what used to be the Alāyavijñāna. It becomes a mirror like wisdom.

So think carefully about what the Cittamātra school means by the Alāyavijñāna. They say it is a subtle mind, and they say it is truly established. I don’t know if I’ll be able to say this very clearly, but tonight you were saying that it’s an inattentive mind so an awareness that to which the object appears but is not ascertained And in the text it says it’s a cognition that doesn’t know that x is x and y is y. But also in the fourfold subdivision In which text? Excuse me.

And what is that? And then in the fourfold subdivision, we learned last week that the five omnipresent mental factors are the fourth subdivision. And I thought, sorry if this is convoluted, but I thought perception involved differentiation, discrimination, seeing difference. So how is it that perception is part of the Alāyavijñāna? So I’d say that since the mind basis of all is an inattentive mind, discrimination is on strike.

Does it have a lot of work to do? All. That isn’t really. Let’s put it. Yes.

Really. Yeah. It’s very good. Okay. So I’m just struggling to understand why the Cittamatras believe they need So if, can we argue therefore, for computer memories, are they mind bases of all?

The reason being that from my understanding there’s an issue Cittamatras have with sleep because that leads to other mental conscious not being stable. So the thing is I can switch off my computer, switch it on in the morning and it still knows what it was doing before. So to me that seems to be a direct contradiction to the need to have this mind basis to begin with. So I explained to Geshe-la in terms of what is understood as a function of the brain in Western physiology. He said from the standpoint of Chitamatra, the brain has no function in subtle minds.

Okay. Is it an inattentive mind, is it pure or not pure or neither or depend on the standpoint or Inattentive mind. Inattentive mind. Inattentive. Yeah.

You mean virtuous by pure? There are virtuous inattentive minds. You can posit virtue on the basis of an inattentive mind. What do you What is your doubt? What do you mean by pure minds?

So now during discussion or debate, please discuss the meaning of the mind basis of all, the Alāyavijñāna, and where it fits within the seven categories of mind and awareness. Cliff?

Key terms in this teaching

Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
omnipresent mental factors sarvatraga-chaitta (Skt); sem jung kun dro (Tib)
One of the six groups of mental factors, these accompany every main mind. There are five: feeling, discrimination, intention, mental engagement and contact. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top