1 h 9 min · 2,877 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 69-minute teaching, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen provides a detailed exposition of the Buddhist philosophical classification of awareness and knowledge, following his ongoing commentary on classical logic. He systematically covers four types of direct perceivers: sense consciousness, mental consciousness, reflexive consciousness, and yogic direct perception. For reflexive consciousness, he explains how awareness has both an objective aspect and a self-aware component, using the example of remembering not just a perceived color but the act of perceiving it, and discusses how this model accounts for dream recollection. He then explores yogic direct perceivers—the non-conceptual, unmistaken wisdom that arises in advanced practitioners through combining calm abiding and insight meditation, illustrated through examples of how such minds naturally sustain engagement without requiring continuous effort. Throughout, he addresses subtle philosophical distinctions between schools, debates about omniscient minds, and the technical definition of valid cognizers. Pitched at serious practitioners with background in Buddhist epistemology.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Line in 0223.mp3
UUID: 9c33db13-2552-4920-ab5a-af7e1f270503
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Awareness and Knowledge
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~2,867
So as usual, we will generate the motivation to listen to these teachings. And since progressing upwards on the path is contingent on training the mind and understanding the nature of the mind, we should listen to these teachings with the wish to attain full enlightenment, the state of perfection for the benefit of all. So last time, Geshe-la explained the two first divisions of direct perceivers, which are sense direct perceivers and mental direct perceivers and pointed out that mental direct perceivers in the continuum of ordinary beings cannot be perceived by ordinary beings. They are inattentive minds. And at present, we are now approaching on page 16 of your English translation what is called, in your translation, self perception, which is better translated as reflexive perception.
And then moving on with with your text, I will translate directly. Thirdly, regarding direct reflexive consciousness. So as you remember, there was a fourfold division of valid cognizers, and we also have an easy to understand fourfold division of direct perceivers, which, can be understand understood in the light of the the former. So regarding, direct reflexive consciousnesses, there is a twofold subdivision into definitions and divisions. Regarding the first, in other words, the definition of a direct reflexive consciousness, it is that which apprehends the aspect.
So that which apprehends here, zi in Tibetan, refers actually to the consciousness aspect, the actual subject in the context of a reflexive consciousness. As you remember, if we took the example of a consciousness apprehending the color blue, there are two aspects to this consciousness. There is the object aspect, which is the color blue, which is apprehended by the consciousness, and there is the subject aspect, which is the consciousness apprehending itself the color blue. That self aware component of the consciousness is what is referred to here.
So regarding the Buddhist schools which accept the existence of reflexive consciousnesses, the mechanism which is postulated and its reasons are as follow. If we take the example of an eye consciousness perceiving the color blue, we not only remember the color blue, we remember actually having perceived the color blue. In other words, we remember the eye consciousness perceiving the color blue. Therefore, are two streams of remembrance. There’s a remembrance of the color blue, and there is a remembrance of the consciousness perceiving the color blue.
This implies for those schools which accept the existence of reflexive consciousness that within the eye consciousness perceiving the color blue, there is not only an aspect which perceives the color blue, but there is a reflexive aspect which perceives itself. And that this is what gives rise to these two streams of recollections or memories. So obviously, if one did not postulate merely one reflexive consciousness, then we would have a where you would have reflexive consciousnesses, perceiving reflexive consciousnesses, perceiving reflexive consciousnesses. So to avoid this, only one reflexive consciousness is perceived and it recollects that very consciousness perceiving the color blue. Now for instance, if we were to take such a conscious consciousness, it can be said that it both explicitly realizes some aspects of the phenomenon it is perceiving and implicitly or indirectly realizes other aspects.
And, one of the justifications which is given by the schools which accept the existence of reflexive consciousnesses for its existence is the experience of dreams. So in a dream, for instance, if we dream of a country we know well, let’s say our homeland, and we see, let’s say, a horse in a dream, this horse appears to us in the dream as a fully qualified horse. In other words, it’s a real horse, which most obviously it is not. It is not a real real horse. Dream appearances do not exist in the way they appear, but they do appear to do so.
And upon waking up, we actually remember the dream and we remember the dream horse. So the schools which accept the existence of reflexive consciousnesses say that this recollection of a dream, which is a recollection of a mere consciousness and which is an objectless consciousness, in the context of a real object demonstrates the existence of reflexive consciousnesses. Then moving onwards, with our text. The definition of, a reflexive consciousness which is a direct perceiver is a, perceiver of an aspect which is non mistaken and which is free from conceptuality. Secondly, with regards to the divisions, there are three subdivisions into, valid cognizers which are reflexive consciousnesses which are direct perceivers, subsequent consciousnesses which are, reflexive consciousnesses which are direct perceivers, and inattentive minds which are reflexive consciousnesses which are direct perceivers which are reflexive consciousnesses.
An instance of the first would be, for instance, the first instant of a direct directly perceiving reflexive consciousness which experiences an eye consciousness. This an instance of the second would be the second instance of such a consciousness. And an instance of the third, and three different examples are given here, would be the, reflexive consciousness direct perceiver which experiences happiness as a consciousness within the mind of a Sāṃkhya. So the Sankhyas do not accept, Geshe la says, that happiness is a consciousness. Or the reflexive consciousness direct perceiver which experiences happiness as a consciousness in the mind of a Vaisheshika.
This is another Indian school of philosophy which does not accept that happiness is consciousness. Or alternatively, the reflexive consciousness which realizes or which experiences something which is not a an inferential valid cognizer in the mental continuum of a Lokāyata, of a nihilist. So Geshe la says even though Lokayatas do indeed have inferential valid cognizers, they do not acknowledge their existence. And therefore, they would the reflexive consciousness experiencing that in their mind stream would be an inattentive mind. And then moving moving onwards with the Lorig text translation, your text, you should be somewhere in the middle.
You’re in the middle of page 16. Fourthly, the definition of a yogic direct perceiver and its divisions are presented regarding the first. In other words, the definition of a yogic direct perceiver. It is the a wisdom which is another perceiver in the continuum of an ārya being, which is unmistaken and non conceptual and which arises in dependence on the Samādhi, which is the inseparable union of Samatha and Vipassana, which acts as its uncommon controlling condition. Now generally speaking, Geshe-la says within the Sautrāntika school, there are three possible objects on the basis of which a yogic direct perceiver can arise.
This is coarse impermanence, the— excuse me— subtle impermanence, the coarse selflessness of persons, and the subtle selflessness of persons. Subtle impermanence is the momentary transitoriness of phenomena. The coarse selflessness of persons refers to persons being empty, of being permanent, one, and independent, whereas the subtle selflessness of persons refers to persons being empty of being an autonomous substantial entity. And the way a yogic direct perceiver is generated in dependence on these is that at first an inferential valid cognizer is generated, which for instance, realizes subtle impermanence. And then the continuum of that inferential valid cognizer gives rise in turns to subsequent cognizers through repeated habituation with the subsequent cognizers.
Eventually, a mind of Samatha, which is a Samādhi, which is a concentration is generated. Then this mind of Samatha is conjoined with a mind of Vipassana, which represents the wisdom component of this uncommon controlling condition. And in dependence on this as a substantial cause, a yogic direct perceiver of subtle impermanence is generated. And the other part of the definition of a yogic direct perceiver is that it is a wisdom which is an other cognizer within the continuum of an ārya being which is unmistaken and nonconceptual. So it’s being unmistaken and non conceptual is shared with the other direct perceivers.
However, the fact that it is a wisdom which is an other perceiver refers to the fact that as an other perceiver, it is not a reflex ive consciousness. In other words, it’s a consciousness which is not a reflexive consciousness, and it is a consciousness within the continuum of an ārya being because at that very instant way yogic direct perceiver is generated within the mind stream, one enters the path of seeing from within the five paths of the path of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation, and no more learning. And from that point onwards, one is said to be superior to ordinary beings, and this is the etymological meaning of the term ārya. And in the case of a yogic direct perceiver, the reason for which such consciousnesses are superior consciousnesses, it is not merely in terms of their object, which may be subtle impermanence or the coarse or subtle selflessness of persons, but
Also objects such as, for instance, great compassion, love, and so forth. But also because, as is said in a text of Jamyang Sheyba, these consciousnesses which because they are associated with all of the conditions of habituation through meditation give rise to great clear appearance of the object of meditation and through leading this to its ultimate conclusion, are consciousnesses which arise within the mind with respect to the object of meditation without any effort on the basis of their foundation. The meaning of this passage, Geshe la says, is that these consciousnesses once generated can then arise without any additional effort. This is one of the uncommon characteristics of mind in general. And yogic direct cognizers, cognizing an object such as subtle impermanence or the selflessness of persons, are minds which naturally, once they are applied to their object, engage the object and increase spontaneously.
Therefore, they are said to be objects of a stable basis or a stable foundation. This is exactly the opposite of, for instance, Geshe la says, from a worldly standpoint, a pot full of boiling water. As long as heat is applied to a pot full of boiling water, the water will boil. But the moment the energy input ceases, the water will progressively cool. It cannot retain its ebullient state indefinitely.
Or for instance, a long jumper who jumps a certain distance must nonetheless, every time he wants to jump again, put effort into jumping a distance, greater or at least equal to the one he has, jumped before. In every single case, effort is required on input of energy. In the case of these yogic direct perceivers, no. Once the mind is focused on the object, it naturally engages it and increases progressively over time. And regarding the divisions of yogic direct cognizers, yogic direct cognizers are either valid cognizers or subsequent consciousnesses.
There’s only a twofold division. There are no yogic direct, cognizers which are inattentive minds because inattentive minds only exist within the mental continuum of ordinary beings. Moreover, with respect to yogic direct cognizers, it is actually referring to them that Dharmakīrti said the intelligent will understand all aspects of phenomena. The intelligent here refers specifically to beings who have yogic direct cognizers. In other words, to ārya beings.
And then reading onwards with our text, if a mind is a yogic direct perceiver, it necessarily is a mind which ascertains its object of ascertainment. So this is the reason, the foremost reason given for the fact that such a mind cannot be an inattentive mind. And jumping the quote from which we have translated, although there exist subsequent cognizers which become yogic direct perceivers, the second instant of an omniscient mind is not a subsequent cognizer because everything which is an omniscient mind is necessarily a valid cognizer. As is said in Gyaltsab Je’s Talam Selje, expounding or clarifying the path to liberation. Although one might think that they are turned inwards, omniscient wisdoms are not pervaded by not being new.
Gyaltsab Rinpoche was a foremost disciple of Tsongkhapa, And, as a foremost disciple of Je Tsongkhapa, he wrote a major treatise on logic called Thar Lam Sel Je in which his position is held to be the definitive position of Je Tsongkhapa. So generally speaking, Geshe la says there is some doubt regarding omniscient minds. Some have tried to say that the second instance of the an omniscient mind, is a subsequent cognizer. This is not the case, precisely because all of the instance of omniscient minds cognize the totality of phenomena. And then there are some debates regarding the sense consciousnesses of a fully enlightened being, whether the sense consciousnesses of a fully enlightened being are omniscient consciousnesses or not.
The positions of the textbook author of Sera Je Monastery, Kelsang Chökyi Gyaltsen, and of textbook authors of other monasteries differ on this rather delicate point. And as is said in dispelling the darkness of the mind regarding pramāna, which was probably written by the other great disciple of Tsongkhapa, Khedrup Je. If it were the case that through merely having been apprehended by a former valid cognizer, it would become a subsequent cognizer. All of the instance following the second instant of the wisdom of omniscience would necessarily become subsequent cognizers, which would entail immeasurable thoughts. I will expound on this later on.
So Khedrupje here is clearly rejecting the view that the second and subsequent moments of an omniscient mind, are subsequent cognizers and endorsing the view of Gyaltsab Rinpoche that every moment of an omniscient mind is necessarily a valid cognizer. So we have finished the presentation of the fourfold division of direct perceivers. And direct perceivers were presented first and a general definition of valid cognizers was presented. And at present, presents the definition of direct perceivers which are valid cognizers. So fusing these two concepts, which should be quite straightforward.
The definition of such is a an incontrovertible and new mind, which is non conceptual. So we should be on page 17 of your English translation. And here, all of the non conceptual component is shared with the definition of direct perceivers in general. What is new is that these minds are new and incontrovertible, and this is to ensure that they are valid cognizers or pramāna. It is no longer adequate or sufficient for them to be merely non mistaken.
And the division of direct valid cognizers is fourfold. They are divided into a reflexive consciousnesses which are direct, valid cognizers, sense consciousnesses which are direct, cognizers, mental direct, valid cognizers, and yogic direct, valid cognizers. The definition of reflexive direct valid cognizers is more elaborate than that given merely for reflexive consciousnesses which are direct perceivers because it provides some additional explanations. And the definition is an incontrovertible and new nonconceptual mind which is turned inwards and which does not move beyond an apprehension. The fact that it is turned inwards refers to the fact that it is an interior consciousness.
It is a consciousness which is actually perceiving another mind. The fact that it does not move beyond being an apprehension refers to the fact that unlike minds and mental factors, it does not share with the mind it is
Apprehending the five factors which or the five aspects which minds and mental factors share. And the definition of direct valid cognizers, which are sense consciousnesses, consciousnesses which are new and unmistaken as well as nonconceptual and which arise in dependence upon a material sense organ, which is their uncommon controlling condition. So as you remember, Geshe la says, we covered the three types of conditions, the, referent condition, the controlling conditions, common and uncommon, and the immediately preceding conditions when we talked of sense consciousnesses. And this is in turn divided into five, the five sense consciousnesses which are direct valid cognizers. And then gives the definition definition of a mental sense consciousness, which is a direct valid cognizer.
This is an unmistaken and new consciousness, which is non conceptual and which arises in dependence upon a mental sense organ, which is its uncommon controlling condition. Generally speaking, as you remember, mental consciousnesses in the minds of ordinary beings are inattentive minds. However, there are mental consciousnesses in the minds of ordinary beings which are valid cognizers, and instances of such mental consciousnesses would be, for instance, the five clairvoyances. So this is a rather delicate point, Geshe la says, because it is important to understand that the overwhelming majority of mental consciousnesses in the minds of ordinary beings are inattentive minds. And the best way to think of mental consciousnesses in the minds of ordinary beings is to think of them as that one instant of mental consciousness which is inattentive at the end of a continuum of sense consciousness.
However, here, to eliminate wrong views, The author of this particular presentation of Lorig has chosen to present mental consciousnesses in the context of the fourfold division of direct perceivers and in the context of the fourfold direct division of direct perceivers which are valid cognizers. This is with a very specific goal in mind and in no way represents for that matter the majority opinion of textbook authors. So Geshe-la thinks, from his personal standpoint, it is best to think of mental consciousnesses as inattentive minds within the mind stream of ordinary beings. Thank you very much. So we have a five minute break, and then a mere twenty five.
Key terms in this teaching
- five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
- The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- lorig
- Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- Samkhya drang chen pa (Tib)
- Early non-Buddhist philosophical school; the so-called "enumerators," because they advocate a definite enumeration of the causes that produce existents. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.