Awareness and Knowledge — 2018-01-30

1 h 31 min · 3,669 words · 30 January 2018 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Awareness and Knowledge (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awareness and Knowledge (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awareness and Knowledge — 2018-01-30
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 91-minute session, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen introduces a systematic study of consciousness, awareness, and cognition drawn from classical Buddhist epistemology. The main focus is establishing what consciousness is through lived experience rather than scriptural proof alone—particularly through the reality of pleasant and painful sensations that all beings with minds possess. He walks through the fundamental Buddhist division of phenomena into matter and consciousness, then explores three key subdivisions of consciousness: sensory versus mental, conceptual versus non-conceptual, and primary minds versus mental factors. The central portion examines sensory consciousness in depth through extended dialogue with students, exploring how visual, auditory, and other sensory awarenesses actually function and whether they are material or non-material. The teaching concludes with Geshe-la emphasizing that mental consciousness—accessible through direct experience—can be scrutinized to demonstrate that negative emotional patterns like anger and desire are adventitious overlays, not the intrinsic nature of mind. This prepares students for a planned two-month teaching sequence leading into Buddha nature teachings. Suited for serious practitioners with some philosophical training in Buddhist logic.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2018-01-30 – Lorig & Buddha Nature – KR.mp3

UUID: 922f662b-9fb7-4d46-935a-d4ee924e3d31

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Awareness and Knowledge

Date: 2018-01-30

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~3,667

Okay. So Geshe-la will be teaching the topic of Lorig. In other words, awareness, cognition, and consciousness. Then he had already taught this topic here based on the Yongzin Lorig one and a half or two years ago. Then this year, the plan was to teach Lorig, in other words, awareness and cognition, for two months or so, and to follow this by the topic of the Buddha lineage or sometimes known as Buddha nature.

Then the subdivisions of the topic will be first, the subdivision into matter and consciousness, is fundamental. Then the subdivisions of consciousness, which are threefold. Consciousness can be subdivided into sensory and mental consciousnesses, number one, into conceptual and non conceptual consciousnesses, number two, and into main minds and mental factors, number three. Do you understand? Then this presentation in four chapters is drawn from Jangchub Rinpoche’s Lorig, but Geshe-la will not follow the Lorig text in detail because we risk to get confused.

Instead, he will draw on definitions punctually and explain them. So this is the plan. So as far as mind or consciousness is concerned, we must reflect about it. Mind and consciousness are very different from form and matter. Form and matter can be observed visually.

They can be touched. We can have tactile experience. This is not the case for mind or consciousness which is intangible. Then how precisely should we proceed? The best approach is to gain experience.

Then as far as the sensory consciousnesses, also known as the consciousnesses of the five doors are concerned, the issue is difficult. How precisely do we gain experience of these sensory consciousnesses? We can’t say we gain experience of them through looking at matter. Now even though there are numerous scriptural quotes corroborating the fact that certain sensory consciousnesses are non material, that they are not formed, but that they are consciousnesses. Nonetheless, it is very difficult to establish it on this basis.

It is also difficult to apply at first sight the definition or the meaning of consciousness to sensory consciousnesses. We can accumulate gradually experience of consciousness awareness and cognition, even though there are numerous various aspects of consciousness. For instance, the subdivision of consciousness into virtuous and non virtuous components. Now regarding states of mind such as bodhicitta, great compassion, love or the wisdom realizing emptiness. Although probably none of us has any experience of these states of mind, nonetheless, through familiarity with the great texts and reflection, we can gain an understanding.

The situation is different regarding mental consciousness. Gradually, we can gain an understanding of mental consciousness. So then as far as you know, for instance, you know, when we speak of bodhicitta, we are speaking of fully characterized bodhicitta. True bodhicitta generated within one’s mind stream. Then the instance given in Tibet was that of Momos.

Yeah. Seen So it’s a little bit like seeing Momo’s with pane of glass. You cannot taste them. Right? Now regarding mental consciousness, it is not difficult to gain this experience.

There are numerous divisions or chapters of mental consciousness, such as a distinction between valid cognizers and non valid cognizers, inferential valid cognition, conviction, and so forth. But the difficulty lies in the designation, not in the experience. For instance, it’s a little bit as when we go downtown to the market and we wander here and there from store to store looking at things. And then when we get back home, someone, one of our acquaintances says, well, what precisely were you up to? What did you do?

And you say, well, I went here and I went there and I did this and I did that. Then as far as consciousness is concerned, the main issue we are dealing with is that of the variety of designations of states of consciousness. Then as far as consciousness is concerned, it is difficult to gain an understanding of consciousness based on the great commentaries and instructions. One really needs personal experience, in other words, meditation. Then at present, let us generate as motivation a good worthy mind.

In other words, let us generate bodhicitta as best we can and after this, we will do the recitations. Please open the prayer book, page one. One b, refugee in the bodhicitta. Page five, Mandala offering. Do you understand in English?

So the existence of consciousness is not to be established based on scripture quotes or on reasoning, but on experience. It is what happens when we ask someone, are you conscious? Are you aware of this? Do you understand this? So consciousness therefore, consciousness’s existence cannot be proved through reasoning nor established through scriptural quotes, but through experience.

For instance, the experience of pleasant and painful sensations, which is an experience all beings with minds have. So therefore, we will establish the existence of consciousness based on the existence of pleasant and painful sensations. For instance, a table does not have pleasant or painful sensations. So you have the famous syllogism. This subject is conscious, but it experiences pleasant and painful sensations.

Animals, for instance, experience pleasant and suffering sensations. And it is based on this experience, this sensation of pleasure and suffering that Geshe-la will explain consciousness. Now we know for instance that some leaves when you tap them or you blow on them will retract. Yet can we say that leaves have pleasant and unpleasant sensations? So our topic is not the explanation, however, of pleasant and unpleasant sensations, but the explanation of consciousness whose existence is established in dependence on the existence of pleasant and unpleasant sensations.

Then here, obviously, one refers to mental consciousness. Physical consciousness is much more complicated to account for. This is Geshe-la’s own view. Just may, you know, cause a problem, wonder. So this is Geshe-la’s personal doubt.

It seems to him easy to explain and justify the existence of mental consciousness. When you come to sensory consciousnesses, where precisely they arise from and how that is difficult? And you? The same. So obviously, is not how sensory consciousnesses are studied in the great monasteries.

In the great monasteries, one memorizes the definition of a sensory consciousness which arises in dependence on an uncommon controlling factor. Then one goes through the list of the five sensory consciousnesses beginning with the visual consciousness and so forth. But when it comes to the reality, Geshe-la himself doesn’t know. He wonders. That’s how it is.

So this is for awareness, consciousness, and cognition. Now what is the purpose or the reason for the explanation of these topics? We have to understand it. What’s the purpose? What’s the reason?

What is therefore the purpose, the reason, or if you wish, the rationale for the explanation of mental consciousness? It is to demonstrate that mental consciousness is not of one nature, of one entity. In other words, is not blended with the afflictions, and therefore, that the afflictions are adventitious and can be separated from mental consciousness. If this were not the case, and if mental consciousness was blended with the afflictions, then there would be no point in all these studies such as Lorig. This must be understood.

So in other words, consciousness or the mind proceeds uninterruptedly. Then consciousness contains numerous components such as, for instance, anger and desire. If we take the case of anger and we investigate anger, we can see that we must distinguish between subject and object from the standpoint of the consciousness. And the issue which arises is whether when we investigate the object of anger, this this object of anger is identified correctly or not. If it is identified correctly, then anger is a valid state of mind and there is no point in applying any antidote.

This is the way things are in reality. But we find in our investigation that the object of anger is misapprehended. Anger is mistaken. It is wrong with respect to its object. Then one can apply antidotes to eliminate it.

So it is not the person which gives rise to anger, which is anger. It said it is the mind perceiving that person. Likewise, no one says that the person giving rise to desire or craving is desire or craving, or that the person giving rise to pride is pride. Instead, it is the mind misapprehending, apprehending that person wrongly, which is called desire or pride. So this is the purpose or the rationale for the explanation of Lorig.

Now generally speaking, in Buddhist philosophy, when one explains functioning things or entities, they are subdivided into three, matter consciousness and so called non associated compositional phenomena. Then let us set the third category, non associated compositional phenomena aside, and look at the two first categories, matter and consciousness. Where precisely do sensory consciousnesses reside? So matter and consciousness are the components of a person. But if we take matter, you understand what matter is.

Matter is this building, this table. It is basically the objects of the five sensory consciousnesses. What is, however, the meaning of matter? Then we also have to give a meaning to the term consciousness. This is not easy to do.

It’s actually quite straightforward to give a definition of consciousness, But the actual meaning of consciousness is difficult to understand. And once we have understood the meanings of matter and consciousness, then persons which are in the third category, non associated compositional phenomena and are composed of both of these are easy to understand. Do you understand? In Buddhist treatises, the meaning of matter is that which is composed of particles. Other words, that which arises from the concatenation, the assembly of particles.

Do you understand? Do you understand the definition of matter that which is composed of particles? So what instance would you give of matter? Example. Table, the table is you know Table is matter.

Right? Probably okay. What instance will you give of consciousness? Example of consciousness. Now in Buddhist treatises, consciousness is defined as that which is clear and cognitive.

Now although consciousness is defined as that which is clear and cognitive, when we apply the definition of consciousness to the affliction surrounding anger, instance, things get a bit awkward. Then this definition of consciousness as that which is clear and cognitive seems mainly to refer to very subtle consciousnesses such as for instance, the Alaya Vijñāna whose existence is taught in Cittamātra, which is indeed clear and cognitive. Then Geshe-la wonders whether it is because coarse consciousnesses can be said to derive or to arise out of very subtle consciousnesses that by derivation, these coarse consciousnesses can be termed clear and cognitive. Then there is a passage in sūtra, in the Tathāgatagarbha Sūtra, which refers to the clear light nature of mind, and another passage which states the obscurations are adventitious. The nature of the mind is clear light.

Then this would seem to indicate that the definition clear and cognitive refers to the fundamental nature of mind out of which coarse minds derive. Then this was the definition of consciousness which had to be explained as far as examples are concerned. It’s much more straightforward since we have direct experience. The good and bad thoughts, in other words, the good and bad motivations, meditating, thinking, and so forth, all of this is consciousness. Now within consciousness, we will focus on mental consciousness and take examples of mental consciousness.

So sensory consciousness are difficult, however. There’s no real point in explaining them from Buddhist text. We’ll try to explain them from experience. So when Geshe-la sees your bodies, what does he see? He sees forms and colors, various colors.

What sees? What sees is the person, Geshe-la. So where is the sensory consciousness? So some are tall, some are short, some are fat, some are thin. Then the seer is obviously the person.

To say that the sensory consciousness is the seeing, the act of seeing is a bit awkward. So where exactly do we locate? How can we identify the sensory consciousness? So the way to look at it is that what is being seen is variegated. We have the bodies of the persons, tall and short, fat and thin, the various colors, and what sees is a conglomerate including the person and the sensory consciousnesses.

So where do we posit sensory consciousnesses? So, just to make things clear, there’s no debate in Buddhist texts or Buddhist scriptures that sensory consciousnesses are consciousnesses in non material. That’s not what Geshe-la is asking you. But based on your experience, are sensory consciousnesses consciousness or matter? So let’s take one precise example, the visual consciousness.

How do you identify or where do you identify the visual consciousness? What is it? It for me, it appears to arise at the intersection between my sense organ and my mental consciousness. So basically, in between the visual organ and the mental consciousness at the junction. Okay.

Proceeding in this way is very helpful because it’s the way to accumulate experience. The job of this central of the the job of the eyes is to, hang on. Let’s let’s do the ear. The job of the ear is to hear. So I would say that that’s where the consciousness is and is in the act of hearing.

You have a lot of subjects and objects in general relationship. You have the hearer. Then you have the object of that hearer, which is sound, obviously. First thing is to apprehend. What we call sound.

The sound is a label. That consciousness. Comes from Okay. Okay. Please tell me, you know, so above.

Visual consciousness. Please keep stick to the example I’m of the visual not sure. Not sure? Okay. I’m not sure because this is an interesting question.

But unfortunately I have another one which is if, could the coarse mind itself be considered adventitious? Because if it derives its clear and knowing nature from subtler minds, then is the coarse mind adventitious? In which case, we might be able to locate a series of areas where sensory consciousness is activated, but it’s nowhere. So Geshe-la, I would like to ask you to identify the visual cortex. Okay.

That’s okay. So my experience of visual consciousness would be, if I was describing it, is some sort of connection of some aspect of mental consciousness, my eye and matter, the matter that my I is perceiving. Do you accept that sensory and mental consciousnesses are separate? Separate and the same? Separate.

This is the beginning. Obviously, sensory consciousnesses exist. So let’s go back to the visual consciousness. Okay. Please.

Visual visual consciousness. How do you identify it? I’m probably oversimplifying it, Geshe-la, but I thought it was the sense power in the the the organ, in the sense organ. So it’s in the eye. Because only the eye consciousness can perceive shape and form and the ear consciousness is in the ear.

Okay. Yes, For visual consciousness, you have the eye but inside the brain is dark. For the person to see, the mind has to interpret the information coming from the eye organ in order to be able to actually apprehend anything. So is it partly a mental consciousness apprehending the information from the eye organ? You said that inside the brain is dark.

What do you mean? The eyes aren’t windows, they actually send messages to the brain that interprets as vision. Okay. Beautiful. Asking him, you know, what about So Geshe-la asked me in my opinion, what were the chances of the sensory consciousness is being material, non material.

I personally suspect there’s an eighty percent chance that sensory consciousness is all material because if you take the cases of visual consciousness, is the best studied in neurophysiology, it is well known that if you destroy the, what is known as a primary visual cortex at the back of the brain, then even though the eyes, the retina and the optical nerve is completely intact, the person is blind. And the same thing is true for the areas of the brain controlling hearing, smell, taste and tactile sensations. Then it becomes difficult to posit a sensory consciousness apart from brain operation. This is my private opinion. Ilya, that’s I’ve been reading all of it.

People born blind who have the near death experience and can see and that’s been verified during that state of out of body experience. I don’t know what’s happening there, that’s, I’ll just throw that into the. The question here is whether sensory consciousness is a material or non material conscious. And whether visual consciousness is matter or consciousness. I’ve heard stories of people who can look at something very briefly and then close their eyes and continue to look at the object and discover more details that they did not apprehend when they seeing it with their eyes, it makes me reason that the visual consciousness is mental.

Oh, sorry, non material, I mean, sorry, the visual consciousness is non material. What is the rationale, why? If it was material, if visual consciousness was material, then when they shut their eyes they would no longer be able to bring to mind the objects that they had seen. But because in their mind’s eye, they can continue to see, therefore that is not an object of matter, it’s an object of the mind. Okay three, three, so I think who is the first, Judy.

Yeah yeah. I was talking to a blind man the other day and we’re talking about how does he see and he says he sees with his mind. So we talked about that for a while, he said he certainly sees with his mind. I think that it’s a combination of material and non material. I like Andrew’s example of that happening because I’ve had that experience myself And there’d be no point in having eyes if there were any kind of visual consciousness if there was no matter to be perceived.

So it has to be a combination of material and non material. Okay. Okay. Yeah. Mark.

Posit the possibility of coarse and subtle sense consciousness in this for the reason that if remote viewing and clairaudience aren’t necessarily the mental consciousness, then we could then posit a subtle sense consciousness. But otherwise I think that of coarse mental consciousness is as you said highly dependent on matter and basically doesn’t function without it. Okay. This is actually the Vaibhāṣika view, to be honest with you. The Vaibhāṣikas teach that the mental organ is cognition.

And therefore, this mental organ is clear and cognitive. It is matter as well, and it is also a valid cognizer. So there is a connection with Vaibhāṣika. The Vaibhāṣikas say that the mental organ is a pure form, which is cognition. And this pure form sees objects, objects appear to it, it apprehends objects.

Therefore, it is cognition. So Geshe-la thinks that this pure form, which is a visual organ, would correspond to the retina, which is at the back of the eye, which is the visual organ. Do you understand? But consciousness and matter strictly contradictory and incompatible, and not only in Buddhist scriptures, but in daily life, in the world, in worldly affairs. When we meet someone that he say, we say, he’s an absolute clod.

It’s a piece of matter. There’s not a thought in his head. We imply that these two are contradictory. Then both from a mundane standpoint and in Buddhist scriptures, matter and consciousness are contradictory. So if if the visual consciousness is material, it cannot be consciousness.

If it is consciousness, it cannot be material because these two are strictly contradictory. There’s no common locus. Ask your questions, one question. Okay, two questions. Okay, okay.

Just wondering a couple of times that, just thinking about the Cittamātra view in which matter is consciousness. So then the sense organ is also consciousness and the sense object is also consciousness. Just wondering what school this view of the opposition of matter and consciousness is coming from. No. Both arise simultaneously from the awakening of one karmic imprint, which is their substantial cause.

Okay. Your turn. That’s good that you bring it up. We talked about these topics a lot. Geshe-la, my question is about, sensory consciousnesses and objects existing prior to the sensory consciousness observing them, perceiving them.

So my question is for example Prāsaṇgika, how do they specifically say the object exists prior to the object if we take the visual conscious, prior to the visual consciousness perceiving it? Do you understand my question? The relation is one of subject and object, isn’t it? Prāsaṇgika accepts the existence of exterior objects, but not in the sense in which Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika teach the existence of exterior objects. And Prāsaṇgika does state that blue establishes the consciousness realizing blue.

So the relation between these two is that of subject and object with on the side of the subject motivation and so forth. All of this is required. So with the pink flower, the eye would see the pink, but also the shape, which to me kind of implies flowers existing there over there. Prāsaṇgika says that this flower is indeed an exterior object. Mhmm.

But they do not understand exterior object in the sense in which Vaibhāṣika or Sautrāntika understand it. Mhmm. Okay. Alright. I’ll stop here tonight.

Thank you. Then Geshe-la would like to ask us to think carefully about sensory consciousnesses and investigate them. Scientists have done a lot of research using mechanical means to investigate sensory sensory consciousnesses. We should try to become aware of this research. So in the case of mental consciousness, we have private personal experience of mental consciousness and can examine it.

But in the case of sensory consciousness, the thing is situation is very awkward. Is it matter or is it consciousness? When we state it is consciousness, why do we say this? Okay. Thank you.

Please open the page nine, Mandala offering.

Key terms in this teaching

buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
clear light ö sel (Tib)
The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
lorig
Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
mandala khyil khor (Tib)
A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
mandala offering
The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top