Awareness and Knowledge – 1989-03-28 – 15B – Opening The Eye – KR

45 min · 2,626 words · 28 March 1989

Awareness and Knowledge (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awareness and Knowledge (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awareness and Knowledge - 1989-03-28 - 15B - Opening The Eye - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains the realization of emptiness of a naturally existent self, using the analogy of searching for a cow in two pastures to show that a self which is neither the same as nor different from the aggregates cannot exist. It describes a non-affirming negation, the meditative habituation to emptiness, and the supports needed (guru blessings, purification, study, accumulating merit). It also outlines the graded tenet system, moving from coarse to subtle selflessness of persons and phenomena.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 45 min

UUID: 155458b6-3601-453a-902a-69b74fafc4e2

Date: 1989-03-28

Words: 2,622

So we’re we’re discussing a self, an I, which is unrelatedely different to the aggregates. The self which does not rely on the aggregates. Such a type of self, if in fact it did exist, it would have to be permanent. And the word permanent here means unchanging. That it would not undergo anything which any type of activity which was related to the aggregates.

It would not undergo birth, aging, dying. It would not undergo production, disintegration. It would not undergo any sickness. It would not create any karma. All these faults would accrue if the I or the Self, if the being, the I, the Self, these are all synonymous terms, The person existed not relying on their aggregates.

So this is I, which is does not rely on causes or conditions, does not rely on name or designation. If it in fact exists, it must exist either the same or different than the aggregates. It does not, and there is no way that this naturally existent I exists as the same as aggregates, there is no way that it exists different than aggregates, therefore it cannot exist. It must be either the same or different and it’s not the same or different, therefore it does not exist at all. One must come to that firm determination that the naturally existent I does not in fact exist at all.

So if by way of example, analogy, if one thought there was a cow and and that went up the mountain. Up this mountain, were only two possible paths that it could take, and therefore, there were only two pastures in which it could be. There were no other paths. It’s a very narrow climb. It’s a very narrow path.

And there are only two possible places that this cow could be. And you really think this cow is up there. Almost certain it’s up there. And so but you and you go actually to search for the cow. And you go to the one pasture and you look thoroughly, you know, you search thoroughly, examine thoroughly the pasture and you don’t find it.

It’s not there. And you go over to the to the other pasture and you look in that look in that pasture, examine it thoroughly, investigate it, search it throughout. It’s not there. And then there were the cow which had appeared to your mind before that you thought was up there. That then becomes the the nonexistence of that cow will now appear to your mind.

You come you firmly determine, ah, that cow. It simply does not exist up the mountain. That cow does not exist. The cow which appeared to you so vividly before, it will now appear the non existence of that cow. And this determination comes, appears to your awareness, just your mind.

Likewise, the naturally existent I, so vividly appears to you, if in fact it exists, it must be either the same or different than the aggregates, the place where we see it. Upon examining that place, we examine that it’s not the same. And then we examine it’s not different. And there’s no other place it can exist. There’s no other possibility.

So there appears to our mind the nonexistence of the naturally existent I. And this is the realization of the emptiness of the I. So you went searching for this cow, this cow which you appeared so vividly before you in your mind that upon searching the only two possible places that it could exist, there then arose the determination in your mind of the non existence of that cow. There, there’s the factor of, of the non existence of the cow appears to your mind. The factor of the non existence of the cow appears to your mind.

This is is called a non affirming negation, a non affirming negation. Now, if we apply this to the example of the self or the I, we have been habituated to and a naturally existent I appearing to us. You know again and again this naturally existent I appears to us, habitually appears to us. If this I exists then we’re going to, it must exist at the place where it appears, that is the aggregates. It must be either the same or different.

We search throughout the aggregates, whether it’s the same, then we see that it’s not the same. We search whether it’s different, it cannot be different. Therefore, there now appears to our mind a non affirming negation, which is the factor of the nonexistence of the naturally existent I. We come to this determination, ah, that I which I so vividly appeared to me before does not exist at all. This determination, there appears the non existence of the naturally existing I.

There appears this emptiness of I, of nonexistence of the naturally existing I. This is in our meditative process. We abide in this determination, in this understanding when this factor of the nonexistence of the naturally existent I or the emptiness of the naturally existent I arises in our mind, we simply abide and accustom our mind to that determination, to this factor which appears to our mind. So the the Buddha said that not that none that not seen is the best seen. And what he meant by this is that the I which is the object of negation, that is the I which appears to it, which has habitually appeared to us, which we already see.

That is the I which is not reliant upon causes and conditions or names or designation. This is the I that we normally see, that we usually see, which is usually appearing to us. But upon examination through reasoning, we are able to refute that this I in fact exists, that this object of negation does not exist at all, and the object of negation no longer appears to us, we no longer see that I and this not seen is the seeing of emptiness and this is the best seeing and this is the realization of emptiness. It’s not sufficient to come to an understanding of emptiness a single time.

We have to realize, we have to understand emptiness again and again. We have to understand it many times. And that in this developing, in this process of cultivating the realization of emptiness. But additionally, we have to make requests to our spiritual teacher, our Lama, for their blessings. And additionally, in the intermediate periods outside of our meditation we should practice the methods of purification in the collection of the various accumulations.

Additionally, we should study the various texts which explain emptiness. That we have to employ a variety of practices to make use of both method and wisdom. Coming to an understanding of emptiness, it is not simply that alone which is sufficient. We have to have assistants. We have to have the assistance of collecting positive potential.

We have to have the assistance of the blessings of our spiritual teacher. We have to make use of the study of various texts. We have to make use of a variety of methods. And in this way, through meditation, we will day by day improve the power of our mind, the strength of our realization will grow day by day. Our realization, our understanding of emptiness will become more and more subtle.

And at last we will gain realization of emptiness. And with this, you know, even if we weren’t to gain realization of emptiness, just through thinking and hearing about emptiness, developing a conviction in the existence of emptiness is, has unimaginable, produces unimaginable positive potential, unimaginable results. It’s just simply the conviction or the belief that emptiness exists. So, you know, that we cannot come to realization of emptiness only by meditating on emptiness. That we need many complementary conditions.

We need many assistants. This is even, you know, if in the case of worldly activities, if we are undergoing undertaking some very difficult type of activities and type of work that it’s it’s necessary that to to seek to develop the skills in doing the work, but not only that, to seek others’ help, to seek their advice, to it may be necessary to pay others, to assist us, that we have to in accomplishing even a worldly activity it’s necessary to gather together all kinds of supports in order to bring about the success of that activity. And what to say of something as with such great meaning as the realization of emptiness. Likewise, we have to bring together a variety of supports in order to be successful. We cannot only engage in the meditation on emptiness alone.

So that’s the the way of meditating on selflessness of persons. If you have any questions, we can talk about that. So it’s very difficult. Tony. So, this, you know, and it’s difficult for the object, the basis of designation of phenomena to appear to our mind, as Rinpoche said, in connection with the glass.

The basis of designation of the glass, it’s very difficult for that to appear to our mind. Whereas the basis of designation of person can appear to our mind easily. That is to say that the basis of designation of the person is the five aggregates. Upon the five aggregates the person is designated. And understanding the non existence of the self which does not rely upon those five aggregates, we can come to, easily come to a rough understanding of the object of negation.

In dependence upon understanding the rough object or coarse object of negation, we can understand the subtle object of negation. We simply cannot jump in and come to any real understanding of the subtle object of negation. We have to work towards that. So we’re talking about the ease of generating the appearance to the mind. The ease of generating the appearance to the mind.

If we take another analogy of the emptiness of a person, reflection of of a face in a mirror is easier to understand than the emptiness of persons. You know, even even even, what do you say, unlettered unlettered persons, worldly persons can understand that that that the appearance of a face in a mirror is not established the way it appears. It’s merely an appearance. It’s not really a face. You know, even worldly people can understand that.

So this this type of it’s empty of being an actual person. The reflection of a face in a mirror. This is easier to understand than the emptiness of person. There’s this order of ease of the appearance of generating the appearance to the mind. So there’s no special there’s no special words.

No special text to quote. You can it’s would be good just to think of that to think about the non-true existence, that things do not truly exist. Things do not truly exist. So you can, you know, in any activity you can in connection with any activity, can meditate on emptiness. But, you know, when you’re walking, you can think about the non true existence of the walker, when you get up think about the non true existence of the getter upper, when you’re eating think about the non true existence of the eater.

So all these, all activities you can find the non-true existence of that particular being who is engaged in that activity. If you study logic then you understand what pervasion means. You know, the book, this book uses the word entailment. I don’t know why they use the word entailment. I use the word pervasion.

Yeah, pervasion. So I think it entails this. Entails this. If it is this, then it must be this. So if something is a product it is pervaded by being impermanent.

Something is a product it is pervaded by being impermanent, product entails impermanent. If it is this then it must be this, It is pervaded by being this. This entails this. If it is a, it is pervaded by being b. It must be b.

It follows. It’s necessarily b. If it’s a, it’s necessarily b. So so the the Tibetan word for flower is, The Tibetan word for flower is, so if something is a, it’s pervaded by being a flower. If necessary, it’s a flower.

It has to be a flower. If something is a metok, if an object is a metok, it is pervaded by being a flower. Why? Because there is nothing which is a metok which is not a flower. There’s nothing which is a metok which is not a flower.

It must be a flower. It follows, entails, it’s pervaded by. If something exists, it must be either the same or different. If something exists, it is pervaded by either being the same or different. Why?

Because there is nothing which is the same and is not the same or different. If something exists, it must be either the same or different. Entails, existence entails either being the same or different, is pervaded by either being the same or different. To understand emptiness or or enlightenment or both? Yeah.

So there are many ways of positing the graded process of becoming to the realization. There’s the process where coming, you know, the various tenets, the four tenets, coming to an understanding of the lower tenets, what they mean by selflessness as a means of understanding what the higher tenets, understanding their course understanding of selflessness and serving as a understanding of higher levels of tenets. Also, know, first as said that first we have to understand selflessness of persons before we understand selflessness of phenomena. Before we understand selflessness of persons, we have to understand subtle impermanence. Before subtle impermanence, we have to understand coarse impermanence.

So there’s this gradual process of understanding. So when the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school talks about the selflessness of the person, they’re talking about the subtle selflessness of the person. Whereas when any of the lower tenets, that is the Autonomy Middle Way school down, talk about the selflessness of a person, they’re talking about the coarse selflessness of the person. And likewise for selflessness of phenomena. The Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school talks about when they say selflessness of phenomena, what they’re referring to is the subtle selflessness of phenomena.

And when the lower schools talk about the selflessness of phenomena, they’re talking about the coarse selflessness of phenomena. So the object of negation within the selflessness of persons, So the object of negation of the within with the selflessness of persons according to the autonomy middle way school is the person exists independently without relying on the collection or the continuum of the aggregates? The person which exists independently without relying on either the collection or the continuum of the aggregates.

Is the object of negation within selflessness of persons according to the Autonomy Middle Way school? And then according to the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school as was explained that the object of negation is the person which is established independently without relying on parts, name or designation is the object of negation. So, you know, we have to go through the real the understandings of the four tenets. There’s a there’s a degree of graduation and a degree of subtlety of the presentation of the realization of the self as you move up through the tenets. The lower tenets are coarse, have a coarse understanding, it is only the highest school which has the most subtle realization.

So the method, we have to understand the lower tenets before we can understand the higher tenets. So that is the method of gaining the realization is working through the tenets into their presentations.

Key terms in this teaching

Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
tenet system drubtha(Tib)
A general term for a religious and/or philosophical system, whether Buddhist or non-Buddhist. It is often used as shorthand to refer to the four major Buddhist tenet systems that emerged from India. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top