45 min · 3,059 words · 14 March 1989
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains how to ascertain the object of negation for inherent existence, using the flower as an example: an inherently existent thing would have to be either inherently one or inherently many, and it is neither. Analysing this leads to understanding emptiness, which is to be familiarised through meditation and combined with calm abiding and special insight. The speaker notes that such understanding cuts the root of ignorance, and that the reflection image of a face is used as an analogy for appearing inherently existent without being so.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 45 min
UUID: 84fcfb42-2bc7-4862-83c5-23bc43702440
Date: 1989-03-14
Words: 3,055
So if something is inherently existent, it must be either inherently existently unitary or inherently existently Diverse? Plurality? Unitary or plurality? It must be one of those. So we examine the first.
It’s not inherently existent in the unitary, or one, because it has parts. If something has parts, it’s not inherent in the unitary. One. If something is inherently existent in the unitary, then it cannot rely on any parts. Its existence such that must it in no way relies on parts if it’s inherently unitary.
But the flower relies on causes, it relies on conditions. It is dependently not inherently established. So it’s not inherently existently unitary. So if something is inherently existent it must be inherently existent in the unitary or inherently existently different or plurality. So if something is not inherently existently one or unitary, then it can’t be inherently existently different or plurality Because in order to have a plurality you must have at least two.
In order for something to be different you must have at least two. And if there’s no inherently existently one then there can’t be inherently existently many because we have to have at least two in order to have an inherently existent in plurality or many or difference and we don’t an inherently existent in one. So how can we have inherently existent in many? If we don’t have one, we can’t have a 100. If we don’t have one, we can’t have 10.
We have one, we have to have at least one in order to have 10 to have a 100. If we don’t have one, we can’t have any of these. So this brings us back to the first essential, the essential of ascertaining the object of negation. So Śāntideva says that without contacting the imagined existent, its nonexistent is not apprehended. Without contacting the imagined existent, its nonexistent is not apprehended.
So if we apply this to the case of the flower, there is the conception of the truly existent flower. There is the conception of the truly existent flower which is imputing, which is in superimposing the conception of the flower as being truly existent superimposes a true existence upon the flower. The flower is not truly existent but this conception superimposes a true existence upon the flower, an inherent existence without understanding that which is being imagined, that which is being superimposed upon the flower, then we cannot be aware of its non existence. Without contacting, coming to recognize that which is being superimposed upon the flower, we can never ascertain its nonexistence. To understand the lack of inherent existence, to understand the lack of inherent existence, we must ascertain what inherent existence is.
Without understanding what inherent existence is, we will never understand what the lack of inherent existence is. It’s as if in the case of one of the coordinator of Buddha House, his name is Doc, Doc White. Okay? If someone said, Is Doc in this room? Now, if we didn’t know who Doc was, we knew who Doc was, maybe we said, No, Doc’s not in this room.
That is we know, we understand who Doc is and we look around and we say no, Doc doesn’t exist in this room. If you didn’t know who Doc was, then you wouldn’t be able to answer yes or no. You wouldn’t know, couldn’t understand whether Doc was in this room or not because you don’t know Doc. You therefore, in order to understand the nonexistence of Doc, you have to understand Doc. So we have to be able to recognize doc’s features, you know, his facial features, his nose, his hair, etc.
And then, and dependence upon that, we what doc looks like and then we can ascertain whether the non existence of doc at a certain place. So we have to have the object of negation appear to our mind. Object of negation, what it is that we’re negating. It must appear to our mind. If we, in understanding what the inherently existent flower appears like, then we can then, upon investigation, we can come to understand that this, in fact, lacks inherent existence.
Without understanding the inherently existent flower, cannot understand the flower’s lack of inherent existence upon investigation. So it’s necessary initially to ascertain the object of negation. So, you know, what so we’re trying to understand what inherent existence having it appear to our mind. What does it look like? Gaining some understanding of what inherent might be.
What is inherent existence if we apply it to this flower? If the flower were inherently existent then it would not rely on causes, it would not rely on conditions, it would exist under its own power independently. If we were to ask, well, the flower the flower not exist does the flower not exist in relying upon causes and conditions and independently? And we would ask, Then we would say no, it does not exist that way. It relies on causes and conditions.
It does not exist independently. Then if we carry on our investigation of the flower further and we we begin to examine the flower. And we say, well, then what exactly is the flower? Or is the stem the flower? That’s not the flower.
Are the petals the flower? That’s not the flower. Are the stamen and corolla in the middle here? Is that the flower? That’s not the flower.
But where is the flower? Doesn’t the flower exist? The flower exists. The flower exists. The collection of all of these, the collection of the parts, the stem, the petals, the corolla, this collection is the basis of designating, the basis of designating the name flower.
That initially there was a giving of the name initially by a person. Someone called and said this is a flower. And dependence upon this collection of stem flower petals and stamen, he gave the name flower. in dependence upon that name, upon giving that name, flower came into existence. So the flower depends upon its name being designated.
Now when we say, so it’s established in dependence upon its name, And the flower which is conceived of to exist independent of its name, of its designation, is an inherently existent flower. Existing independently is is what we mean by inherently existing flower. So for the Middle Way Consequence School, they say that the flower does not inherently exist because if it inherently existed, it would either have to be an inherently existent singularity or plurality. Inherently existently one or many, whatever term you want to use. And it’s not inherently existently one and it’s not inherently existently many.
If something exists it must be one of these. It must be either, if something inherently exists it must be inherently existently one or it must be inherently existently many. There’s no other possibility. So they say it’s not inherently existent in one and it’s not inherently existent in many, therefore it’s not inherently existent. So this is the first essential.
So ascertaining the object of negation. The object of negation is that if something is inherently existent, it must be established without relying upon causes, conditions, or name. And when we analyze, can such a thing in fact exist? There appears to our mind, the thought appears to our mind, things can’t exist that way. There’s no way that things can exist that way independently or not relying upon causes and conditions and their name.
Therefore, there arises the thought, there appears to mind that such a way of existing is impossible. This is the ascertaining object of negation. Any object that exists, it must be either one or it must be two or more. It is, if it exists, it must be either one or it must be two or more. Two or more.
Then we have to come to the conviction that if something exists, it is pervaded by, it is necessarily either one or two or more. This is what is meant by the second of these essentials, that is ascertaining the entailment or pervasion. That if something exists and entails or necessarily is so, that it must be either one or it must be two or more. This is the pervasion. And then coming to the third point, that is the essential of ascertaining the lack of oneness.
So if something exists it must be either one or it must be many, it must be two or more. If something is inherently existent it must be inherently existent in one or it must be inherently existent in two or more. So we’re going to look at the first one. If something is inherently exist, if there is no object of knowledge, there is no phenomena which is inherently existent in one because to be inherently existent it wouldn’t necessarily have to be to not rely on anything outside of itself. It would be independent of all other factors and there is nothing, there is no object of knowledge which in the case of impermanent phenomena that they must rely on causes and conditions but all phenomena in general have to rely upon their name or designation.
So they always rely upon something, therefore they are not inherently existent in one. Why isn’t the flower inherently existently one? Because it has parts, it’s not inherently existently one. It has a spatial part. It has a directional part.
It has a it has a lower part, a top part, so it has various parts. So it lacks inherently existent oneness, but also with respect to the fourth point, the lack of difference, the lack of inherent and existent difference. Now if something is not inherently existently one, it cannot be inherently existent in many. In order to have many, we have to have more than one. If we don’t have one, we can’t have many.
If we don’t have one, we can’t have a 100. And if we don’t have an inherently existently one, we can’t have an inherently existent any different because we have to have at least two. If we don’t have an inherently existing one, we can’t have inherently existing two or more. So it’s because the flower is not inherently existing one, it can’t be inherently existing in many or two or more or multiplicity or plurality. Therefore, it’s not inherently So we go back to our original syllogism, we say the flower is the subject, it follows that it is not inherently existent because it is neither inherently existent one or inherently existent many or inherently existent same or inherently existently different.
And once there arises in the mind, depends upon this reason, that in fact come to a decision that in fact the flower is not inherently existent, then we meditate upon that state having come to this firm conviction upon deciding that it’s not inherently existent. So to use an analogy, if we have some precious, we have some valuable object and we think it must be one of we have two boxes. It must be in one of these two boxes. We’ve decided that we’ve convinced ourselves. This object must this valuable object must be in one of these two boxes.
And we look into the first box, it’s not there. And we look into the second box, it’s not there. So we understand that since we were convinced before that if this valuable object exists, it must be one of these two boxes. And upon looking in the boxes that object is not there, then in fact the object does not exist at all. This valuable object in fact does not exist at all and there arises in the mind the non existence of that valuable object because where it should have been is not there.
Cannot be anywhere else Therefore, it must not exist at all. Likewise, in coming to an understanding of the non inherent existence, we must ascertain that if something exists inherently, it must be either inherently existently one or inherently existent in many. And analyzing both of those positions, understanding that something cannot be inherently existent in one and it cannot be inherently existent in many, we then decide that in fact things are not inherently existent. There arises in the mind the understanding of the non inherent existence and this is the understanding of emptiness. And then having come to that, this having this appear to one’s mind, the non inherent existence, this understanding of emptiness, one meditates in equipoise for as long as possible in that state.
So we can’t, you know, it’s necessary to do this more than once. We have to keep repeating this, trying to develop, generate this understanding again and again and again and it keeps getting, we get a better understanding, a better understanding each time and this finally this will lead to actual realization of emptiness. So it’s one of the qualities of awareness of our minds that everything becomes easier upon familiarization, that it doesn’t become more difficult. This is one of the qualities of the nature of the mind that upon familiarization and habituation things actually always become easier. So it’s just like a little child when he’s first learning to write.
At first he’s very clumsy. He makes many mistakes. But as he practices more and more and becomes familiar with, cultivates this ability to write, then he can write much more. His writing becomes very beautiful and he’s able to write very quickly. Now, minds are the same.
So as Śāntideva says that all things become, all activities become easier upon familiarization, that things may be difficult initially, but through habituation then it’s the quality of the mind that they always become easier. So initially we are seeking to generate an inferential valid cognizer realizing emptiness. That is a thought consciousness, a thinking consciousness, understanding emptiness and then combining that with our calm abiding and developing special insight with respect to emptiness. And dependence upon that we are cultivating our understanding, realization, getting clear and clear understanding of emptiness and finally we gain a direct insight, a direct valid cognizer with respect to emptiness. And it’s this which actually has the ability to cut out the root of ignorance, the misconception of the nature of the self.
Once we cut at the root like this wisdom is like an axe cutting out the root of ignorance, Then once we remove the root, then all the various afflictive emotions which arise out of this root are completely eliminated and we no longer engage in karma. We no longer collect karma and engage in actions and therefore we eliminate all suffering and this is the method to attain liberation. If we can couple this mind, this wisdom, with the awakening heart, with compassion, then it will serve as the means to attain Buddhahood. So, you know, the various Three Jewels, for example the Buddha jewel, who is the shower of the path, the teacher. And there’s the jewel of Dharma, the jewel of Dharma.
And there are two Dharma jewels. So there are two Dharma jewels, if I’m not mistaken. Dharma jewel is the real refuge, is the actual refuge. It is the method whereby we can actualize the wisdom, understanding selflessness and thereby uproot the source of suffering to eliminate ignorance, cease the afflictive emotions, we no longer create karma and we attain liberation. Therefore it is the Dharma jewel which is the ultimate or the real refuge.
So this is such a teaching as this all comes about through the kindness of the Buddha. That the Buddha was skilled in speech and he showed his excellence of the doctrine. He was able to explain skillfully his excellent doctrine and showed an unerring path to liberation. So, you know, we’ve various other traditions have propounded methods for attaining miraculous abilities, attaining clairvoyances. But these in the end aren’t really worth all that much.
We’ve all had these experiences in the past and they didn’t do us any good. But such teachings as these that which can lead us unerringly along a path simply practicing as well as possible, planting the dispositions or the latencies such that in the future that upon their activation of these latencies that we can quickly gain the paths and realizations and attain complete happiness. So Śāntideva has said that we’ve all experienced unending suffering in the past, unending happiness in the past, but all of these sufferings and happinesses we experience ultimately did not accomplish either the purpose of others let alone our own purposes. Our own purpose let alone the purpose of others. So we should in practicing whatever types of discomfort that we may have to undergo that we voluntarily accept upon ourselves we should rejoice in this type of discomfort since it will ultimately accomplish not only our own purposes but the purposes of others, the welfare of ourselves and others.
So now we should make prayers that we will be able to come in contact and hear and be able to contemplate the great text explaining these teachings and that be we able to put them into practice. We should again and again make such types of prayer petitions. And to make prayers again and again praying that you will be in a position to hear and contemplate these texts for the benefit of others. And again and again making such types of prayer. So prayers are extremely important for our future welfare that we should again and again make such prayers that we’re able to hear and contemplate these texts.
So with respect to this initial syllogism that we were talking about, at the end it said, for example, like a reflection. And what does this word reflection mean? When we look into a mirror, a face appears to us. And it appears that it, this appearance appears that it is a face. What appears, It appears as if it is a face.
Appearance appears as if it is a face, but in fact it’s not a face. It’s a reflection of a face. It’s not really a face. Though it appears to be a face, it’s not really a face. Likewise, though this flower appears to be inherently existent, it’s not really inherently existent.
Key terms in this teaching
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.