46 min · 2,576 words · 14 March 1989
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk begins the explanation of the higher training in wisdom, arguing that wisdom is needed to know what to adopt and reject and to remove ignorance. It distinguishes conventional wisdom, covered by the five sciences, from ultimate wisdom, the realization of emptiness and selflessness. It then introduces a reasoning method from Shantarakshita for an initial inferential understanding of selflessness, using a flower as the example and the reasons of being neither inherently one nor inherently many.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 46 min
UUID: 5dd3f956-860c-4a74-8f8b-607e30ecbd52
Date: 1989-03-14
Words: 2,572
Yeah. That dog. You hear me? Oh, Come on. So we should initially develop the proper motivation for listening to this profound teaching on a great vehicle in order to put us put into practice in what we hear, whereby we might be able to attain attain peerless, complete, precious Buddhahood, whereby to be able to place all sentient beings equal to space in in complete happiness and bliss.
So if we’re able to generate the great vehicle motivation, then the Dharma becomes the great vehicle Dharma. So amongst the three higher trainings, we have completed the explanations of the the first two, that is ethics, higher training in ethics, and higher training in meditative stabilization. We’ll begin the explanation of the third higher training, the higher training in wisdom. So the great master Vasubandhu said it’s necessary in order to be liberated from cyclic existence to develop the thoroughly discriminating wisdom with respect to the all phenomena. And this is necessary in order that we, it’s in order to remove the obscuration of ignorance whereby we are able to understand what is to be adopted and what is to be rejected.
Without understanding what is to be adopted and rejected, then we’re going to enter into various types of engaging various types of actions creating karma, and the cyclic existence will be perpetuated. So by way of analogy, in the case of someone who is walking down a path, If this person were blind, then he would not know whether this what the nature of the path was, whether there were obstacles, whether there was danger involved in walking down the path. He could there was the danger of him falling down. So likewise, not not understanding the nature of the path, where where it is we’re going, we could easily without this discrimination as to the nature of the path, we could easily take a wrong path. And therefore, and there to be the danger of falling in in in this fall into we could ex easily experience great suffering.
And likewise, in the traveling the spiritual path to Buddhahood for liberation without the discriminate without the discrimination of wisdom, then we do not know what is to be what are the various practices to be adopted and what are those things to be rejected. And in this way, we create engage in various types of unskillful actions and experience suffering. So wisdom is that mental factor which discriminates the nature of phenomena both as to its goodness and badness with the various types of phenomena which are to be adopted and rejected and to their ultimate nature. When this factor mental factor of wisdom is brought to its to its culmination, to its final brought brought to a culmination, then this is the at the the mental factor of wisdom is brought to its finest final culmination at the ground of Buddhahood, and then it becomes transcendental wisdom. So there are two principal types of wisdom.
There is the conventional wisdom understanding conventionalities and the ultimate wisdom understanding the ultimate, that is emptiness. So with respect to the first type of wisdom, that is the conventional wisdom, understanding conventionalities. This is encompassed within the wisdom of the five sciences and these five sciences are linguistics, one, logic and epistemology, two, the arts, three, medicine, four, and inner sciences, five, the fifth, the five sciences. So we’ll take the the arts first. I won’t take I gave them in different order.
Arts, this would be involved in the having the knowledge and the ability to to draw the various meditational deities along with their mandalas. This art this artistic understanding. Then the science of medicine, this would involve understanding the various illnesses, being able to diagnose and compound the medicines for the treatment, understanding the various elements and constituents of the body, etcetera. Then there is the logic and epistemology and this has its source in the understanding of the text Pramānavārttika, Dharmakīrti’s commentary to Dignāgā’s Compendium of Valid Cognition in which it develops the understanding of what is a correct reason and sets out the reasoning establishing the proof of selflessness, of setting out the reasoning for what is to be abandoned, this cyclic existence which is to be abandoned and the liberation which is to be attained, the various reasoning setting these out. So then the linguistics and this mainly involves the understanding of the Sanskrit language but it also entails an understanding of various individual national languages and languages of various countries.
This would involve the understanding of the grammar, expression, the relationships, how the relationships between the words, the way the, what would you say, perhaps the conjugation, the the poetics, in general the grammar of the language. Then the the last is inner sciences. And this inner sciences only found at the ground of Buddhahood and this involves the understanding of selflessness, the understanding of the 16 aspects of the four noble truths, awarenesses of compassion, love, the mode of engaging in the path of liberation, the paths and grounds of both the lesser and greater vehicles. So the sciences of arts and medicines are to be known in order to lead disciples, as a means of leading disciples and the sciences of logic, epistemology as one and linguistics as the second are to be are to be known as a means of eliminating perverse consciousnesses, wrong wrong consciousnesses. And the principal subject of study amongst these five sciences is the last, that is inner sciences.
And this is the actual method where the most important is this actual method for abandon suffering. The the means that whereby we can attain liberation in Buddhahood. So the these five sciences are the conventional wisdom conventionalities. Then with respect to the second type principle type of wisdom that is the ultimate wisdom understanding the ultimate. This is the realization of emptiness.
So the the conventional wisdom is the method to in order to generate ultimate wisdom. Previously we spoke about the union of calm abiding and special insight and discussing that we said there were two types of special insight. There is special insight observing conventionalities and special insight observing ultimates. Now, when we talk about the special insight observing ultimates, we’re talking about this third higher training in wisdom. That is the ultimate wisdom understanding ultimates emptiness.
And one can attain the conventional wisdom, understanding conventionalities and dependence upon non-Buddhist texts and teachings, but it’s only dependence upon the Buddhist texts and teachings that one can develop the ultimate wisdom understanding the ultimate that is emptiness. So with respect to the these two types of special insight, ultimate special insight and conventional insight, there are two types of ultimate special insight. There is the special the ultimate special insight which which realizes the selflessness of persons and that which realizes the selflessness of phenomena phenomena. So the Candrakīrti in in talking about the special insight which realizes the self as a person says the following, has the following quote from the following quote, Seeing with their mind that all afflictions and defects arise from the view of the transitory collection of mind and body as inherently existing I and mine,. Yogis upon realizing that the self is the object of this view refute self inherent existence.
So what does this quote mean? When we when we studied the we were studying in awareness and knowledge, the the six principal afflicted mental factors and among those was afflicted view and the first of the afflicted views was the view of the transitory collection as being inherently I or mine and this is the conception which conceives as the conception observing the I as the conception, observing the I and conceiving of it as inherently existent is the view of the transitory collection. The conception observing the I and conceiving of it to exist inherently, right? Existent. So this, you know, if having previously explained what we mean by the view here in the sense that an afflicted view is a wrong awareness.
It misconceives the nature of the object. Here it’s conceiving of the nature of the I to be truly existent, inherently existent. So it’s a wrong consciousness. It is and the reverse or the opposite of this wrong consciousness would be is a correct consciousness, a type of consciousness which is in accordance with the way things actually exist and this is the wisdom consciousness understanding selflessness. So this misconception conceiving of an inherently existing I and the wisdom realizing selflessness are mutually contradictory, mutually at odds with one another.
So it is in dependence as as it states here in in this verse that that all the various afflictive emotions arise in dependence upon this misconceived view. That is the view of the transitory collection to be an inherently existent I or mine. In dependence upon this misconception then all the various afflictive emotions arise such as anger, desire, and confusion. In dependence upon these afflictive emotions, then we engage in unskillful actions. We create karma.
In dependence upon creating the various types of karma, we experience suffering. So it is the misconception with respect to the nature of the self that is the source of all our problems, our suffering. The only thing which is able to eliminate this misconception is the wisdom realizing selflessness. This is the only antidote which is able to eliminate the source of all our problems. Without developing the wisdom, understanding, selflessness, there’s no way to go beyond our problems or As Dharmakīrti said, without realizing the nonexistence of the object of observation of the misconception, conceiving of truly existent self, then there is Without realizing the nonexistence of the the conception of the true existence of self then there is no way to eliminate the ego grasping or the conception, the misconception, conceiving of the self.
And that which is able to get rid of, eliminate the misconception with respect to the self is the wisdom, understanding, and selflessness. So in in the as a means of developing the wisdom, realizing selflessness. The Master, Shāntarakshita, has the following quotation. These things propounded by ourselves and others because of lacking in reality, and nature of oneness or manyness do not inherently exist like a reflection. So this this quotation is explaining the reasoning whereby to generate an inference an inferential understanding realizing selflessness.
So, you know, we have not we we haven’t realized selflessness. So, how do we initially what is the method for us to initially realize selflessness the first time? When we talked previously about valid cognitions, prime valid cognitions, we said there were two types. There is inferential valid cognition and direct valid cognition. So the initial the initial understanding of selflessness alright, is a between the two of the two types of valid cognitions, inferential valid cognition.
So how are we going to develop an inferential valid cognition of selflessness? We rely on the method. The method for generating the initial cognition that is inferential valid cognition is relying on reasoning. We have to rely on reasoning. So there are many types, there are many reasonings which we could rely on in order to generate this initial inferential understanding of selflessness.
Here, the type which Shāntarakshita is putting forth is So amongst all the various types of reasons that we could rely on to generate our initial understanding of selflessness, This one presented by Shāntarakshita is probably the best since it’s readily understood. So all the various teachings on the graduated path state that this particular method of reasoning is the best for the initial understanding of selflessness. So in presenting this reasoning, we to settle the meaning of the four points. There are four points which will settle the meaning of selflessness. So the four points which settle the meaning of selflessness are as follows: The essential of ascertaining the object of negation.
The essential, so these are the four essential points. The first is the essential of ascertaining the object of negation, the essential of ascertaining the object of negation. The second is the essential of ascertaining the entailment, essential of ascertaining the entailment, another word, another translation is pervasion rather than entailment using the word pervasion. That’s the second. Third is the essential of ascertaining the lack of oneness, the lack of oneness.
And the fourth essential is the essential of ascertaining the lack of difference, the lack of difference. Those are the four essential points. So we use an example, analogous example to begin with as an to approach the subject. And we’re going to present a syllogism a syllogism. So you you you must write this down.
So when you meditate on emptiness, you can think you can sit down and think about it, what this syllogism means. So we write down a syllogism, three parts, okay? The first part is the subject or use flower. Flower as the subject, remember that? Flower as the subject.
It is is it it lacks inherent existence. It it it follows that it lacks inherent existence or it follows that it’s not inherently existent, whatever words are easiest for you, the same translation. It follows that it lacks inherent existence or it follows it’s not inherently existent. And then the reason, because is neither inherently existent, one or inherently existent the many. And then, for example, like a reflection.
For example, like a ref like a like a reflection. Okay? That’s the syllogism. So, okay, let’s let’s look at this syllogism. So we take the flower.
The the flower, we’re taking it as the basis of our discussion. The the the basis of our discussion, we’re gonna use the flower. And now the flower is not inherently existent. So the middle way consequence school says the flower lacks inherent existence. The flower is not inherently existent.
And the Middle Way Consequence school says that the flower lacks inherent existence. The flower is not inherently existent. The other schools, the Great Exposition, Sūtra, Mind Only, and Rangtong. And all and also middle way autonomy school. All the schools except for the consequence school say that the flower is in fact inherently existent.
It inherently exists. The middle way consequence school says the flower is not established inherently. It’s not inherently existent. So what reason does the Middle Way consequent school give for for for establishing, for proving that the flower lacks inherent existence, that the flower is not inherently existent. They say that the flower is not inherently existent because it is neither inherently existent one or inherently existent many.
Now, okay, I’ll give you some other translations for this term. It’s neither inherently existently identical or many or different. Many, different, identical, unitary, same. Okay? Different possible translation.
Why? Because it’s So the flower is not inherently existing because it’s not inherently existent as one or inherently existent as many. Now maybe so I gave you those synonyms of these different terms and I think it will become clear why it’s necessary at different times to use the different synonyms. The the why is not why isn’t the flower inherently existent in one? And here I think the word unitary might be best.
Inherently existent as unitary? Because it has parts. It’s not inherently existent as one unitary because it has parts. It has the different directional parts, northern part, southern part.
Key terms in this teaching
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- ego-grasping dagdzin (Tib)
- The ignorant compulsion to regard one's self, or I, as permanent, self-existent, and independent of all other phenomena. LYWA
- five sciences
- Within Tibetan Buddhist education, they are: grammar, logic, medicine, arts and crafts, and religious philosophy. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- three higher trainings lhagpäi lab pa sum (Tib)
- The three higher trainings of ethics, concentration and wisdom when conjoined with refuge in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.