15 min · 924 words · 25 October 1988
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In a question and answer exchange on emptiness, the teaching explains that after realizing emptiness, phenomena such as flowers and people appear as illusions while conventional appearance remains. It states that seeing oneself as not separate from other phenomena is a mistaken consciousness. The self (I) is described as imputed upon the aggregates, which engage in actions and collect karma.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 15 min
UUID: f18a6f96-87f4-4f91-bdd1-9b00cec512e4
Date: 1988-10-25
Words: 920
Talk to. So when we talk in in this when we say the truth, we’re talking about emptiness. Now, for example, when a Buddha realizes emptiness, for him to become one with that emptiness, he would have to become permanent, since emptiness is permanent. He became emptiness. But he does not become permanent.
So there’s no way he can become permanent. There’s no way no way anything can become permanent. He didn’t as an entity, but Maybe think about think about him. Annette? I know what you mean.
I think you’re making a slight fault. I’m afraid. Do you cease to see things the way you thought that you saw before you understood the emptiness, or do you actually see them the way I see them now because I don’t understand emptiness as well as What do you mean by see? Understand? Understand.
Yeah. Okay. So she’s saying, can you say conventional truth and ultimate truth simultaneous? Yeah. Oh, thank you.
That’s not quite what Well, sort what you say. Anyway, anyway, so that’s is that will that satisfy you? Will we answer that question? If can you see the two truths simultaneously? Okay.
So, you know, for us, when we look at all the various objects like flowers, etcetera, they appear to us to be true. They appear to us as truth. But once we have realized emptiness, then we realize then they appear to us as false. And by false, what we mean by when they appear to us false is if they begin to appear as an illusion. Therefore, we begin to see things, objects, as illusions.
The individual existence of a flower as an illusion, then it’s the same with people. And that’s what I’m well, that’s false, then you know what I mean? It’s kind of yeah. No. It’s go ahead.
Do you know what I mean? You you you make it very clear for yourself. Well, then I suppose you see when you see people, they’re it’s an an it’s an illusion that they’re not separate. So if they’re not separate, it’s all could could you see it as all being the the one the one reality? If people are if people are illusions, then they’re not separate.
Therefore, they’re they’re all one. No. No? Confused. But well, if if you can see that flower is an illusion, then it should be the same for for people and for everything Yeah.
In this world. Yeah. And? Well, ask him if that’s right, if he thinks that’s right. If the flower can appear as illusion, then then what?
All phenomena can appear. Well, isn’t that what he’s supposed to be getting at? That’s Is that that what you’re is that what this sort of meditation is supposed to lead to? That everything is you see everything is illusion because it’s transient and it’s came out of you know, it’s all dependent on everything else. So there’s just really this one truth.
Okay. What’s your You can condense that if you like. Well, I mean, I can make up my own question about what may what maybe you mean. But it it won’t do it won’t do you any good. Well, isn’t this meditation meditation on emptiness?
Yeah. If you can see a flower as an illusion, he said something about apply it to the flower then to yourself. See yourself as non ex not existing in that in that way. What way? As a separate entity.
Never said that. Has he? No. Well, perhaps you could ask him what he did say again. No.
What what he along those lines. Doesn’t mean So whether, you know, whether we have realized emptiness or whether we haven’t realized emptiness, oneself is individual and separate from other phenomena. These things still appear that way because that’s the way in fact they exist. But whether we have an empty understand emptiness or do not understand emptiness. And to see oneself as not being separate from other things, other phenomena other than yourself is a wrong consciousness.
It’s a mistake. It’s a mistake. I want to see yourself as Separate individual from other phenomena. See yourself as separate, is it? To not separate, excuse me.
To see yourself as not separate or not individual from other phenomena than yourself would be a wrong would be mistaken in wrong consciousness. It would. Yeah. What would be the right consciousness? With respect to what?
To have. What would be the right idea to have? With respect to? Yourself. As in am I is this is this true or false?
Is this this you? I? Well, this the outer you that acts in the world. Is that false? Is that Yes.
What would be the right consciousness to have about the outer you that acts in the world as opposed to the inner, you know, you? It. So, we talk about the self, the I, we’re talking something which is imputed to the aggregates. The aggregates. You know, this self, it engages in various actions.
It goes and comes. It collects negative karma. It collects positive karma. And it depends upon all these various activities or work that it does. We impute the self or the I upon this, this, that which is aggregates which are engaging in these various actions.
And this is the self. This is the I. So anyway, say, I am sitting, I am going, I am working. This is the I, the self that we are talking about.
Key terms in this teaching
- conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
- As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.