Awareness and Knowledge – 1988-10-25 – 3B – Opening the Eye – KR

50 min · 3,016 words · 25 October 1988

Awareness and Knowledge (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awareness and Knowledge (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awareness and Knowledge - 1988-10-25 - 3B - Opening the Eye - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains the two truths: conventional truth, the appearances of things taken by the conception of true existence as truly existent, and ultimate truth, the emptiness of independent existence. Using the example of a flower and the speaker’s own dependence on causes and conditions, it argues that dependent arising shows things lack true existence. It then introduces the selflessness of persons and phenomena and the four divisions of emptiness, and ends by noting that emptiness itself is empty.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 51 min

UUID: 3247169d-603d-4001-ab04-5088e7d921d3

Date: 1988-10-25

Words: 3,012

So the the master Candrakīrti has said that the conventional truths are the methods. An ultimate truth arises out of these methods. Those who do not know either of these two, that is to say conventional truths and ultimate truths, will enter into a wrong path. So, Candrakīrti was emphasizing the fact that it’s extremely important that we know these two, that is to say, the conventional truth and ultimate truth, since they are the methods and that which arises from the methods by which we can attain liberation and ultimately Buddhahood. If we do not understand the correct presentation, then we are not engaged in a correct path.

In fact, we we will engage in a a inverted path or some type of wrong path, and we will not achieve our goal. So when we’re talking about the methods, you know, it’s as if we’re trying to climb to the top of, say the roof of a building. We’re going to use a ladder. And the various rungs of the ladder represent the method where whereby we’re ultimately going to achieve our goal, that is the getting on top of the roof. And just as in climbing the ladder, we have to we rely on a lower rung to step on up onto a higher rung.

Likewise, in coming to the our ultimate goal, we must rely on the methods of conventional truth, that is the various realizations of conventional truth, in order to, and dependence upon that, we will gain the realization of, what did I say, the lower realizations of understanding conventional truth, and then depend upon those, we will attain that which arises from the method, that is the realizations of ultimate truth. So it’s extremely important that we identify the two truths. That we come to recognize them. That we have an intimate understanding of them. You know, if ever going to develop a prime cognition, that is a realization of these truths which is necessary by which to achieve our goal.

Now, when we talk about what are conventional truths, these are simply all the appearances which appear normally to us. For example, this room, the table, money, all the various objects which appear to us are all conventional truths. So okay. We want to understand what we mean when we say conventional truth. There’s two words: conventional and truth.

Now, it’s necessary to, as I mentioned before, there’s various ways to translate this same word, depending upon its context. And so another translation, which we will have to use in this context, is truth for a concealer. Truth for a concealer or a deceiver. Now, so we’re talking about truth for a concealer. Now, what is the concealer?

The concealer is the conception of true existence. The conception of true existence. So, that is the concealer, is the conception of true existence. What do we mean by truth? We’re talking about the various objects which appear to this conception of true existence, to this deceiver, to this concealer, as being true.

In general, they aren’t true, but these objects appear to this deceiver as true. Therefore, we call these objects truth for concealers, or conventional truth, in other words. So those who are studying awareness and knowledge, that is to say, Lorig, the study of mind. In general, there’s two classifications of minds, that is conceptual and non conceptual. When we talk about the truth for concealer, the concealer, that is the conception of true existence, we’re talking specifically about a conceptual type of consciousness, that is a thought consciousness.

If we take the example of this type of thought consciousness, this conception which takes as its object of observation the flower. The conception of true existence which takes as its object of observation the flower. This flower appears to it not to be depending upon, for example, causes and conditions. The flower appears to this consciousness, to this conception, not to be depending upon causes and conditions. It appears to it to exist independently.

It appears to the conception of true existence to exist independently. So therefore, the conception of true existence is a wrong consciousness, in that the object appears to exist independently. It appears to exist objectively without depending upon any other factors. In fact, it does depend upon other factors. It depends upon causes and conditions for it to develop, but it doesn’t appear that way.

Therefore, conception of true existence is a wrong consciousness. So the flower is truth for a concealer or a conventional truth. But on top of that, in terms of that, on top of that, there is its ultimate truth of the flower. But we can’t we don’t see this ultimate truth with our eye, for example. So what do we mean when when we say the the the ultimate truth?

Now we know that the the flower is simply a conventional truth, but it appears to the conception of true existence to exist independent of causes and conditions. It appears to exist independently, objectively, from its own side. Now, that, the lack of that, that is the non existence of that way of existing, that is, emptiness of existing independent of causes and conditions. Its emptiness of being independently existent. Its absence of independent existence.

That is to say, the non existence of the object of apprehension of the conception of true existence. You know, the conception of true existence apprehends the flower as independently existing. That absence of that way of existing is what we mean by ultimate truth. This this ultimate truth is its final mode of being. So, you know, we’re talking about the flower, and now we can talk about on top of that flower, it has the quality of emptiness.

That is to say its ultimate truth. Now, flower appears to exist without relying upon other factors such as cause and effect, causes and conditions. It appears to us to exist independently of causes and conditions. But we know, we can understand, that in fact it is dependently existent. It depends upon causes and conditions for it to become established, for it to grow.

Therefore, this can act as a reason, understanding that it’s actually, in fact, though it appears to have independent existence, it actually relies on causes and conditions for its growth, for its existence. So let’s think about this. What do we think? Okay, the flower, does the flower exist independent of causes and conditions? Does it, what we say, naturally exist from its own side objectively?

Or in fact, does it rise independently? Is it reliant on causes and conditions for its existence? So what do you think? Does the flower exist independently of causes and conditions? Does it exist independently without relying on cause and conditions?

Or does it exist by way of depending upon cause and conditions? Depends on outside sources. I mean, the flower actually exists through many sources, through moisture, light, air, and it it does not exist in its own right. Could not have been So that’s right. The flower, you know, it depends upon the seed.

It depends upon water. It depends upon earth, fertilizer, light, and all those things that you said. So we can understand that. So when we say this, that the flower, that the flower which exists independently of causes and conditions, the flower which exists independently of causes and conditions does not exist. Doesn’t exist.

That nonexistence is the emptiness, which is in terms of the flower. The nonexistence of flower which does not depend upon causes and conditions is the flower’s emptiness. So we can understand that the flower does not naturally exist. That is to say that the flower does not exist independently of cause and conditions, and we can use as a reason because it exists independent in dependence upon causes and conditions. So this is the various types of causes and conditions that we listed.

So this reason is a way we can refute the independent or natural existence of the flower. So there’s a lot of debate within Buddhism on this even this point. For example, the three lower tenets, the tenets of the Great Exposition, Sūtra School, and the Mind Only School, they say that this very reason that the flower grows or develops in dependence upon cause and condition is the reason we can can use to prove that it truly exists. It truly exists because it develops in dependence upon causes and conditions. Whereas the highest of the tenet schools, that is Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school, says, The very fact that it arises in dependence upon causes and conditions is the reason we say it doesn’t truly exist.

So what do you think? Has said that the three lower schools who say that because the flower arises in dependence upon cause and conditions, therefore it must be truly existent, are like little children. They don’t quite understand the subject. Whereas the real experts who understand the subject understand that because things are dependent or because an object is dependent arising, it cannot be truly existent. So, you know, this we can apply this same reasoning to whatever object.

The great meditators, when they The yogis, they apply it to For example, when meditating on emptiness, they apply it to themselves. You know, I do not truly exist. I do not inherently exist because I depend upon my development, my growth, for my existence, on a variety of causes and conditions. So, you know, we can think about this just as we did the flower, in that we also, as individual individuals, exist on dependence upon various causes and conditions. For example, we depend upon our mother and father.

We depend the various elements of our body, our body itself. All these act as causes and conditions for our existence. So, you know, we understand quite readily that the flower exists in dependence upon causes and conditions. Can you use the same understanding with respect to yourself that you also exist in dependence upon various causes and conditions. Yes?

So, that’s right. We can apply the same type of reasoning to ourselves as individuals. Know, that our existence is dependent upon a variety of causes and conditions. And there are the flesh of our body, our blood, the sperm and ovum of our parents, our feelings. All these are five aggregates, the form aggregate, feeling aggregate, etcetera.

All the various parts. in dependence upon that, we exist in dependence upon all these various parts, all these various causes and conditions. Therefore, can state the reasoning like in a syllogism, that we do not naturally exist, we do not independently exist, because of the reason that we’re dependent arising. For example, like a flower. So, you know, we can apply this to all the various appearances which we see.

You know, for example, the book. The book is a dependent arising. It’s dependent upon various causes and conditions. It’s paper, the ink, the printers who printed it. So, you know, whatever, the building, all these various objects, we can think and reason in the same way, that they’re not inherently existent, they’re not independently existing because they’re dependent arisings.

So the master, Nāgārjuna, he was prophesized by the Buddha saying that there would arise a commentator on my teachings with respect to emptiness. And that he was a valid source of interpreting my teachings. And Nāgārjuna has said that there is nothing which does not arise, is nothing which is not dependent, There is nothing which is not empty. That is to say, you know, everything is dependent upon, that is, in the case of products, all products are dependent upon causes and conditions, and all phenomena in general are dependent upon their parts. So, you know, we can begin to this we can easily understand this, that in the case of, for for for example, the flower, that upon the collection of various causes and conditions, the flower comes into existence.

Therefore, it’s dependent. Like, but this also applies to permanent objects. By permanent, I mean, that which is not dependent upon cause and conditions. Various phenomena which are not dependent upon cause and condition, by which we mean by permanent. But they are also dependent existences because they rely on their parts.

Permanent objects depend upon their parts for their existence. Therefore, because they are dependent upon their parts, they are empty of being independently existing or independent they’re empty of natural existence. So the truth for concealers, that is conventional truths, are said to be false. Are said to be false. They’re merely true for a deceiver.

They not, in general, truths. In general, they are said to be false. Whereas, for example, the flower. Now, emptiness of the false way that it appears is its truth. That is to say its ultimate existence.

Not ultimate existence, ultimate truth. That is to say, it is its final, the ultimate truth is its final mode of being. This is how it actually exists, therefore it is said to be true. So conventional truths are false. Ultimate truths are true.

So last time we were discussing the two truths, and we said that though they’re they’re they’re not the same, they’re the same entity, but different isolates. So the the Buddha set forth his thought on emptiness in what is called the Mother Sutras. And there are three categories of Mother Sutras. There’s the abbreviated, middling, and extensive, or detailed Mother Sutras. Commentating on this, Candrakīrti sets forth the, in his text, sets forth the quotation.

In order to release transmigrators from the afflictive obstructions and the obstructions to omniscience, this selflessness was described as two types through a division into phenomena and persons. Therefore, the teacher spoke to his disciples frequently of these two selflessnesses, extensively in many ways. Having explained 16 emptinesses in the elaborate way, he again explained four in the brief way. These are described in the Great Vehicle. So there there are the various ways we can emptiness is presented.

Now, by realizing emptiness, we can be released completely from cyclic existence. By realization of emptiness has the ability to completely liberate us from all suffering. Within the discussion of what, this is the possibility of the realization of emptiness. Within the discussion of emptiness itself, there are the emptiness of persons and the emptiness of phenomena. So when we talk about the selflessness of phenomena, we’re talking about exactly what we have been explaining thus far, discussing thus far.

That is the non true existence of, for example, the flowers. The non true existence of the table, all the various phenomena that we see around us. Their non true existence is what we mean by the selflessness of phenomena. Then when we say selflessness of persons, now I’m using the word persons. Literally it’s just something like beings.

Any type of living. Being, right? But it’s simpler if we just use the term person. But you should understand that. When I say selflessness of persons, what we mean is those things which have life, those things which have mind, as opposed to those things which are mindless without any life.

So that which is mindless and lifeless we call phenomena. That which has mind, that which has life, we’re calling persons or beings, but we’re calling them persons. In terms of them, their emptiness is what are talking about when we talk about the selflessness of persons. The selflessness of persons is the emptiness of living beings, of their non true existence. So the The selflessness of phenomena is the emptiness of all the various objects aside from living beings.

The emptiness of all the various objects aside from living beings. Whereas the emptiness of living beings, persons, is the selflessness of persons. We’re calling selflessness of persons. All emptinesses can be included in these two, the selflessness of persons and the selflessness of phenomena. Now if we were to distinguish emptiness, this this is the abbreviated distinction of emptiness.

If we were to distinguish it in a middling way, we could divide it into four. That would be emptiness of functional things, emptiness of functional things, the emptiness of non functional things, the emptiness of nature, emptiness of nature, and the emptiness of an entity that is other. The emptiness of an entity that is other. These four emptinesses. So, you know, when we talk about these various emptinesses, the divisions of these emptinesses are made from the basis upon their emptiness.

The basis upon which the emptiness is established. You know, we can talk about the emptiness of a flower. We can talk about the emptiness of a book. The emptinesses are not different in themselves, They’re really being divided or distinguished from the point of view of the basis upon which they’re being posited? Upon the basis, in terms of particular bases, we divide up these emptiness, but the emptinesses themselves are not different.

For example, when we talk about the emptiness of functional things. By functional things, we mean those things which arise from causes and conditions. So their their emptiness of true existence is the emptiness of functional things. And we we talk about the emptiness of nonfunctional things. Nonfunctional phenomena.

We talk about the emptiness of nonfunctional phenomena. So there are phenomena which exist, but they do not arise in dependence upon causes and conditions. They do not depend upon causes and conditions. Therefore, we call them non functional phenomena. The emptiness, taking them as a basis, in terms of these objects, are what we mean, that is to say that the lack of true existence of non functional phenomena is the emptiness of non functional phenomena.

So all these various objects that we’ve listed so far, they have they’re empty of a fantasized way of existing. The now that emptiness itself, this emptiness of this way of existing also is empty. So when we talk about the natural emptiness, we’re talking about the emptiness of emptiness.

Key terms in this teaching

Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
lorig
Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top