47 min · 2,112 words · 18 October 1988
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains emptiness of true existence through a sequence of faults showing why an awareness realizing emptiness must serve as the antidote to apprehending true existence. It explains that non-true existence and emptiness are the same in the Prasangika Madhyamaka view and differ in lower tenet schools, and that the two truths are the only possible categories of knowable objects. It closes with the image of planting a seed of understanding through hearing teachings on emptiness.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 47 min
UUID: 03ecc35e-0750-40b8-b778-b39e2d344af2
Date: 1988-10-18
Words: 2,108
Okay. The the first fault which would accrue is that the that the flower’s non true existence would would not be the flower’s emptiness. The flower’s non true existence would not be the emptiness of the flower. So that’s the first. So, okay, so we established, on the first fault, we established that the the first fault is, you know, we’re depending upon understanding the first fault when we come to understand the second fault.
That is, it’s not the, the non true existence of the flower is not the emptiness of the flower. This is what we learned from the first fault. Taking that into the, we now come to the second fault, would accrue is that the awareness realizing emptiness would not serve as an antidote to the conception apprehending the true existence of the flower. The awareness, the awareness realizing the emptiness of the flower would not serve as an antidote to the conception apprehending the non true existence of the flower. So, okay, now, depending upon that, we just learned that if the awareness realizing emptiness is not an antidote to conception apprehending the non true existence of the flower, then it becomes meaningless for the yogi to cultivate higher paths and dependence upon developing this awareness realizing emptiness.
So so it depends upon what we learned on in the third fault, in the that it would be meaningless for the yogi to cultivate the awareness realizing emptiness, since it is not an antidote, then there would be no way that he could rise higher and higher through the paths of realization. Therefore, the Buddha could never have attained the elimination of all faults and arising of all excellent qualities. So the difficult one to understand is the second one. The second thought which you create, that is to say, the awareness realizing emptiness of the flower is not an antidote to the conception apprehending the true existence of the flower. This is the one that’s difficult to understand.
The awareness realizing the non true existence of the flower is an antidote to the conception apprehending the true existence of the flower. The awareness realizing the non true existence of the flower is an antidote to the conception apprehending the true existence of the flower. If the awareness realizing the non true existence of the flower is not an awareness which is realizing the emptiness of the flower, then the awareness realizing the emptiness of the flower does not serve as an antidote to the conception apprehending the true existence of the flower. The conception apprehending the true existence of the flower. For example, the awareness realizing the existence of the flower and the conception apprehending the non existence of the flower are in conflict.
They’re contradictory. The awareness apprehending the existence of the flower and the awareness apprehending the nonexistence of the flower, they’re in conflict. They’re contradictory. Likewise, the awareness realizing the non true existence of the flower and the awareness apprehending the true existence of the flower are likewise contradictory in conflict with each other. The awareness which apprehends the existence of that is true, The awareness which is apprehending the nonexistence of that flower is false.
Therefore, this awareness which is true, it has the ability to get rid of, to negate that awareness which apprehends the nonexistence of this flower since its false. So, likewise, the awareness realizing the non true existence of the flower is true. The awareness apprehending the true existence of the flower is false. Therefore, the awareness realizing the non true existence of the flower is able to negate or to get rid of completely from the root the apprehension, the awareness apprehending the true existence of the flower since it’s false. For example, if two people were having a dispute and one, was speaking the way things actually were, he was being straight, he was honest, and the other one was lying.
If they were to, you know, they both set forth their ideas and then they go actually check up the actual situation. What that this, since the, what one person was saying actually accords with, was correct, it accords he was telling the truth as it is, this would have the power to, eliminate or negate the, what was set forth by this person who was false, who was telling a lie. So those with no positive potential are unable to realize emptiness. But those who, having some positive potential, are able to arouse a doubt with respect to the nature of reality. You know, are things really empty or not?
You know, is this the way they really exist or not? Those who are able to generate a profound doubt, even that profound doubt is able to eliminate, to shake the very foundations of cyclic existence. Rinpoche hopes that just our small examination that we’ve done here is able to begin to help us to emerge from cyclic existence. So this is a very difficult subject. Some of you probably have, some understanding.
Some of you probably have no understanding. So it would be useful if we, you know, carried on a dialogue with questions and answers and help, come to a better understanding. So if you have some questions. So explaining emptiness is very much like trying to explain someone the taste of brown sugar. It’s something you have to try for yourself to come to an understanding of it.
Your own, By actually putting it in your mouth and swallowing it, you get a taste of what actually brown sugar is. To explain it to someone else is extremely difficult. A little bit. Yeah. The the In general, are two types of meditation.
There’s analytic meditation and placement meditation. And without this, without going through this, this first type of meditation where we actually examine this subject analytically, then we can never move on to the fixative meditation where we stabilize or we fix ourselves on what we understand. This is the method we have to proceed with. First, analyzing, examining the object, and then fixing upon our understanding that arises from examination or analysis. If a delusion is empty of an inherent nature, so then it is not truly existent. So within the Middle Way school, all phenomena whatsoever are non true existent or lack or empty of inherent existence.
Yeah. So we take an example of fire. The definition of fire is that which is hot and burning. Now, there’s no other so the when we refer to hot and burning, there’s no other entity we’re referring to other than fire. And when we refer to fire, that that we’re the same entity that we’re referring to when we say fire is that which is hot and burning.
We’re not referring to some other entity aside from hot and burning when we refer to fire. When we refer to hot and burning or when we refer to fire, we’re not referring to something other than that which is hot and burning. When we refer to when we refer to hot and burning, we’re referring at something other than fire. I think I twisted it around now. So likewise, so they’re the same entity.
Likewise, when we refer to the two truths, we’re talking about they’re the same entity. Now, when we say false, when we say false, we mean the, that which is false. So the So the false is the entity of the of the emptiness of true existence. It is, so when we speak about, when we refer to the false, we’re talking about its emptiness of true existence. False, emptiness of true existence.
When we talk about the true existence, the emptiness of true existence, we’re talking about. And then when we talk about the emptiness of true existence, we’re talking about we’re referring to the entity of false existence. When we talk about that which is false, we’re referring to that which is empty of true existence. When we talk about emptiness of true existence, we’re talking about the entity which falsely exists. There we are.
Questions? Yeah. If I the person So, you know, the you know, we talked about these four tenets. And for example, the mind only school, they assert the true existence of phenomena, phenomena of true existence. And their realizations that attain are extremely high realizations.
But these realizations are rejected by the middle way school. They do not, since the middle way school says that nothing truly exists. So therefore, one can be highly realized, but in fact, what one is realizing may not be accepted by a higher school. Now, within the Middle Way School, they refer to a quotation by the Buddha where he says, If one does not properly discriminate the nature of things, there is no liberation. And in the text entitled Engaging in the Bodhisattva Deeds, It is said that there is no path of liberation for those There’s no Without realization without realizing emptiness, there is no attainment of the enlightenment of the hearers, of the solitary realizers, or the bodhisattvas.
So what Rinpoche has been explaining is in accordance with the highest of the tenet schools, the middle way school. The lower schools, as they assert their position, they do not need to realize They do not need to realize a non true existence of phenomena. I if enlightenment isn’t inherently existing, then that means we already are already enlightened and these mind and all sentient beings could be also So we’re Buddhas. We aren’t experiencing any suffering? According to the lower tenet schools, for example, mind only, etcetera, it’s not necessary to realize non true existence in order to attain enlightenment.
But what we’re saying is from the middle way school, it’s necessary in order to attain enlightenment, it’s necessary to realize the non true existence phenomena. Yes? Yeah. So that’s right. Non true existence and emptiness.
Same same meaning. Would you want to specify what type of non duality? You mean what? That and, emptiness, are they the same? Yeah.
Non-dual. Non-dual. Non-independent existence. Independent existence. So from the point of view of the very highest school, that is the consequence of middle way school, independent existence, the non independent existence, and emptiness exactly the same.
But all the lower, all the schools beneath the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka schools, such as the Autonomy Middle Way school, and those further down, say that things are independently existing, they do not assert that they’re the same thing. There’s a difference between independently existing, non independently existing, and emptiness. So for the Autonomy Middle Way school and below, non independent existence and emptiness are not the same. Non-inherent existence and emptiness are not the same. Non true existence and emptiness are not the same, but for the highest highest middle way school, Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school, all these are exactly the same.
They, there’s no difference. Yes? So in general, whatever objects of knowledge exists, there are no other than two truths. Why is that? Because with regard to ultimate truth, the way it appears and the way it exists are harmonious, are concordant.
And with regard to conventional truth, the way it appears and the way it exists are discordant, unharmonious. So if something exists, it either must be harmonious or unharmonious way, by, from the perspective of the way it exists and the way it appears, there’s no other third possibility. So, you know, what we’ve talked about this evening is extremely difficult. Emptiness is very difficult to understand and you’ve probably tired yourself out trying to understand it. But, you know, we have planted a seed in the field of your mind of the understanding of emptiness.
And you know, as you continue, then the sprout of realization will, will, come forth. So the glorious Candrakīrti, he talks about this planting seeds of understanding of emptiness. I can only paraphrase the quotation that Rinpoche gave. I cannot translate it word for word. You know, now we’ve heard a teaching on emptiness, and we’ve listened to it.
And this listening has planted a seed or a latency within our mind. Then later on, tomorrow or sometime in the future, again we can hear a teaching on emptiness. And really hearing the sound, emptiness, hearing the word emptiness, it can provide the conditions whereby tears will arise, will fall from our eyes, and the hair on our body will stand on end. This is a sign that we’ve had teachings in the past on emptiness, and this is a sign that are quickly gaining the understanding of emptiness. Did you understand well?
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
- As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.