Awakening Heart — 2013-10-23

2 h 3 min · 6,157 words · 23 October 2013 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart — 2013-10-23
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this two-hour teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche uses Atisha’s observation—that we prepare for tomorrow but not the next life—to build an argument for cultivating bodhicitta, the awakening heart. He covers the Four Noble Truths and emptiness, then focuses on generating the stable wish to attain full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. Genuine bodhicitta, he explains, arises from a mind unified by calm abiding and takes three forms: the king-like, shepherd-like, and ferryman-like. The bulk of the teaching explores the “interchange of self and others,” the practice of exchanging egoism for altruism, mounted on the breath in tonglen (giving and taking). A substantial Q&A probes why this was kept secret and how it functions during meditation on emptiness. For serious practitioners with foundational Buddhist study.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2013-10-23 – KR.mp3

UUID: 3c22091d-b608-44df-b8b9-3b018b4045b6

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Awakening Heart

Date: 2013-10-23

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~6,165

As Atisha said, unaware of whether today or the next life will come first, Striving today we may discover we have already landed in the next life. And the meaning of this famous quote is that we have no way of knowing whether tomorrow or the next life will come first. However, if we look at our behavior, we see that we prepare for tomorrow but do not prepare for the next life. Really, we should make no preparations for tomorrow and should make extensive preparations for future lives. Even if we make no preparations whatsoever for tomorrow, tomorrow will take care of itself.

If we ask for help, others will help us. We manage to get food, we manage to get something to drink and so forth. On the other hand, it is really for future lives that we should make preparations since future lives are far more important than tomorrow and whether we ask for help or not for future lives, none will be forthcoming. We are alone in the matter. We all like that, at least I am like that.

I think of tomorrow or after tomorrow make plans for next year and in a couple of years, but actually it is for future lives that we should be making plans and putting effort. Regarding how to prepare for future lives, there are two different sets of preparations. What one should abandon and what one should engage in. Regarding what is to be abandoned foremost are the 10 non virtuous deeds. If we are able to abandon the 10 non virtuous deeds, future lives will take care of themselves.

And then if on the basis of this we can engage in an ethics which abandons non-virtues and in addition to this engage in practices such as generosity, forbearance and so forth, then we will obtain higher status, a higher rebirth in future lives. This is not easy. Since these practices must be conjoined with stainless unpolluted prayers. Unpolluted by what? Unpolluted by the worldly concerns.

All the prayers which you make in which some aspect of this life is involved are polluted by worldly concerns and are not stainless And therefore for us to engage in stainless prayers is very difficult. However, if we are unable to engage in them but merely engage in an ethics which abandons 10 non virtues, we will obtain a mere human rebirth. Clearly, if in addition to merely protecting ethics, we engage in generosity and forbearance and conjoin these with stainless unpolluted prayers, we will obtain a perfect human rebirth. However, even if we obtain such a rebirth, it will not be different from the present one. It is in no way a stable form of happiness.

And then even a divine rebirth, rebirth as a God is in no way a permanent form of happiness since one must fall from that state and therefore makes more sense to aim for a human rebirth like this one and life after life to train in definite emergence or renunciation and in bodhicitta so that one can move upwards evermore. And then on such a basis, we can obtain higher rebirth after higher rebirth. None of these however represents a stable form of happiness. For that, we must gain liberation from cyclic existence. And for liberation from cyclic existence, one must engage in the three trainings and one must understand the 16 aspects of the four noble truths and so forth.

It is not easy to engage in the three trainings, the training of ethics of Śīla, of concentration of Samādhi and of wisdom of Prajñā since they entail the direct realization of emptiness. And for this as a preliminary, one must understand fully the four noble truths. And within the four truths, one must understand the truth which are to be abandoned, the truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering and the truth which are to be practiced and realized, the truth of cessation and the truth of the path. This is not easy. Regarding emptiness, this is particularly difficult to understand since huge collections of merit are required to engage in a study of emptiness and profound study.

It is hard to acquire. The talk is easy. They are empty of inherent existence. They are empty of being established by their own characteristics. But this talk is basically meaningless, since we must strike that boundary between the extreme of existence and the extreme of non existence between asserting on the one hand that phenomena exist in the way in which they appear or denying on the other hand any existence whatsoever to phenomena.

This is very difficult. Then without emptiness there is no liberation since it is the wisdom realizing emptiness which severs ignorance which is at the root of cyclic existence. From ignorance arises the afflictions. If we are able to sever ignorance the afflictions do not arise otherwise if ignorance is present the afflictions will automatically arise. Then once we have actually realized emptiness and once we have attained liberation, this will be extraordinarily happy as a state since there will be no suffering whatsoever left.

Then if we think about it, it is a little bit odd because one would have attained a state of liberation in which one experiences no suffering whatsoever, and yet one would be surrounded by sentient beings experiencing all the modalities of suffering. Then it is difficult to see how this will be this will be comfortable as as a state of affairs for oneself. Frankly, one could think that one would be ashamed of being oneself happy and free from suffering while others are suffering. Then one might be tempted to just try to attain liberation from suffering for one’s own sake. But if one reflects on the fact that the beings which surround us suffer, this is difficult to envision.

For that matter, which one of us would be comfortable while his or her mother is suffering torment by his or her side? It’s difficult to see. And therefore instead of this, we should generate the mindset which thinks I will take the responsibility, I will take the burden of setting not one but all sentient beings in the state of full enlightenment and for this I myself will initially attain the state of full enlightenment. This is what we should meditate upon. And therefore, we should train the mind in bodhicitta, having trained it in bodhicitta once bodhicitta arises in a spontaneous and uncontrived fashion then one will experience the 10 benefits which Geshe-la explained last time.

Therefore, let us meditate for one or two minutes minutes thinking we shall at present study the graduated stages of the path, the Lamrim with the motivation of attaining ourselves for enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings without exception. So last time Geshe-la explained the 10 benefits of generating bodhicitta within the context of a commentary on stanza 17 of Concise Meaning of the Stages of the Path. Generating the mind as the central column of the path of the supreme vehicle. It is the foundation and basis of great waves of conduct akin to the elixir of transportation into gold for the two collections, a treasure of merit which include millions of collections of virtue. At present, we must comment on the following two lines of stanza 17 understanding this the scions of the conquerors hold the supreme precious mind as the center of their vow.

This refers to the actual generation of bodhicitta. Regarding the generation of bodhicitta, there are two main procedures or methods for generating bodhicitta. However before explaining these, one must explain the basis on which bodhicitta is generated. There are two such bases, a physical basis and a mental basis. The physical basis refers to a rebirth among one of the migrators of the six realms. These six realms refer to the three lower realms of the hell beings, the pretas or the hungry ghosts and the animals, and the three higher realms of humans, demigods and gods.

Beings are similar in the six realms in experiencing a mixture of suffering and happiness. However, within the hell realms, the experience is overwhelmingly suffering to such a degree that it is only exceptional that a being in the hell realms could hope to generate bodhicitta since there is not even an instant for practice. When Buddha Śākyamūni before attaining full enlightenment was reborn as a hell being, he and another fellow hell being were being tormented in the hell realms by the guards of Yama. And one of them struck this fellow hell being with an iron rod at which point he shrieked in pain. His shriek of pain caused instantaneous compassion to arise within the mind of the Buddha as a result of the Buddha to be familiarization with compassion.

As a result of this compassion, he instantaneously died in other words the hell rebirth ceased. And this is the case by extension for beings reborn in the other realms. As a result of powerful previous karmic imprints, it is possible for a being reborn in any of the six realms to give rise to great compassion when the necessary circumstances for its arising occur. At this point, great compassion can act as the cause for bodhicitta. Nonetheless from within the six realms it is taught that the best rebirth, the best basis in other words for generating bodhicitta is the human rebirth since bodhicitta generated in this rebirth on this base is the most stable of all.

And therefore there is no doubt that any one of us can generate great compassion and bodhicitta since it is theoretically possible for beings in any of the six realms to do so. And therefore, we should put continuous effort in generating this wish to set all sentient beings in the state of full enlightenment. And then if one trains the mind continually whenever one encounters a sentient being thinking I will set the sentient being in the state of full enlightenment then eventually even upon seeing an insect the state of mind arises spontaneously. Then for sure this human rebirth will be a meaningful human rebirth. So regarding the physical basis for bodhicitta, this is what there is to be taught.

Now regarding the mental basis, the situation is much more difficult. Two components are necessary for the mental basis. The first is a great compassion. The second is a close approximation of Dhyāna. This refers ideally to the union of calm abiding and of insight.

But at the very least, it refers to calm abiding. This is therefore very difficult to obtain. It is taught in the monastic textbooks that whatever is a thoroughly purified truth is necessarily a union of calm abiding and of insight. Then in as much as bodhicitta is a thoroughly purified truth, it is necessarily a union of calm abiding and of insight. It is therefore impossible to generate true conventional bodhicitta without having attained calm abiding previously?

Then in our cases, most of us probably believe that when we pray intently and recite the prayer may attain full enlightenment for the sake of every sentient being, we have actually generated bodhicitta within our mind stream. This is not even close to the nature of bodhicitta which is not to say that it is not beneficial, it is. This is a case because bodhicitta is unmovable, it does not fluctuate just as calm abiding is unmovable, it does not fluctuate because it is a close approximation. It is actually the, when we speak of a mental base, we are referring to the fact that the mind which is a mental base is actually transformed in terms of its nature into what one wishes to produce. In this case, one is transforming an unmovable mind, the mind of calm abiding into the result one wishes to attain which is bodhicitta.

This is only possible because calm abiding is actually a mind connected to the higher realms. It is a close approximation of Dhyāna. In other words, calm abiding acts to put it bluntly as the substantial cause for bodhicitta. What is the mind which wishes to attain full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings without that characteristic of single pointedness and unmovability is not conventional bodhicitta. It can nonetheless be called the generation of the Mahāyāna, the generation of the mind of the Mahāyāna.

Just as for instance, when a hearer gives rise to the wish to attain liberation for his own, his or her own sake, he or she has generated the generation of a hearer’s mind. And just as a Pratyeka Buddha, a solitary realizer, when he generates the mind to attain his own liberation, would have generated a mind which aspires for a Pratyeka Buddha’s liberation. Therefore conventional bodhicitta arises on the basis of calm abiding and it is referred to in the monastic textbooks as a special mind. The term special here counters the notion that conventional bodhicitta is akin to our coarse minds. So this is regarding the nature of conventional bodhicitta.

Regarding the divisions of bodhicitta, there are numerous subdivisions of bodhicitta. The famous 22 fold subdivision of bodhicitta taught in Maitreya’s Abhisamayālamkāra which presents among others earth like bodhicitta, fire like bodhicitta, king like bodhicitta and so forth, but which is too extensive for a presentation here and the two fold subdivision of bodhicitta. So for instance, the first of the 22 fold subdivisions of bodhicitta, earth like bodhicitta refers to the characteristics of the first of the five paths of the Bodhisattva Yana, the path of accumulation which is said to be akin to the earth or to a field since as a result of the downpour which issues from the cloud of compassion of the Buddhas, it is possible to give rise to the crop of subdued trainees. Each of the remaining 21 metaphors of bodhicitta is also interpreted in a similar fashion. So we shall set aside the 22 fold subdivision of bodhicitta which is too complex for this setting and present a three fold subdivision of bodhicitta into king like bodhicitta, shepherd like bodhicitta and ferryman like bodhicitta.

So we should focus therefore on this threefold subdivision of bodhicitta which is more relevant to our practice. And the first type of bodhicitta as mentioned was king like bodhicitta. It is called king like bodhicitta because it is a bodhicitta which is akin to the attitude of a king which is solely preoccupied with the welfare of his subjects and thinks I should dedicate myself to my subjects. Such a bodhicitta is a good one. So the first bodhicitta which will be presented is a shepherd like bodhicitta.

Shepherd like bodhicitta is a bodhicitta which is akin to the behavior of a shepherd which wishes to take care of his flock and therefore leads all his flock to their destination before getting there himself. Likewise, someone with shepherd like bodhicitta wishes to set all sentient beings in the state of full enlightenment before attaining it himself. The second bodhicitta is as was mentioned is king like bodhicitta and the third category of bodhicitta is ferryman or ferryman like bodhicitta. This is a bodhicitta whose attitude is akin to that of a ferryman who is the pilot of a ferry or in contemporary terms, a car driver driving a car in which the bodhisattva wishes to attain enlightenment with all sentient beings, in other words, with all his or her passengers. In addition, there is a fourfold subdivision of bodhicitta into bodhicitta with an object, Supreme bodhicitta, aspectless bodhicitta and obstructionless bodhicitta.

bodhicitta with an object refers to a bodhicitta which is still present within ordinary sentient beings. In this context, bodhicitta present within ordinary beings refers to bodhicitta present within practitioners on the Pāramitāyāna who are on the path of accumulation or of preparation and therefore whose bodhicitta is still focused upon an object. The second subdivision of bodhicitta, supreme bodhicitta refers to the bodhicitta which is generated within the mind stream of Pāramitāyāna or Mahāyāna practitioners who are on the impure grounds. In other words, the first seven grounds from the first to the seventh ground. In these cases, the bodhicitta is referred to as supreme bodhicitta because it functions to purify the obstructions which are present within the mind streams of these beings.

Then the third subdivision of bodhicitta, aspectless bodhicitta refers to bodhicitta which is generated within the context of the three pure grounds. These are the eighth, ninth and tenth ground. Such a bodhicitta is known as aspectless because it is a bodhicitta which is generated when one is very close to full enlightenment. The fourth subdivision of bodhicitta, the bodhicitta abandoning obstructions is only present at the level of the state of full enlightenment. So it is since it is only at the level of full enlightenment that both obstructions, Kleśa Avarana, Jneya Avarana are abandoned.

Then having attained full enlightenment, the doubt arises after full enlightenment is bodhicitta still present since after all bodhicitta is that mind which is wishing for full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. Then this having attained oneself for enlightenment conventional bodhicitta is still present since the actual goal of conventional bodhicitta has not been fulfilled. The actual goal of conventional bodhicitta is not attaining full enlightenment in and of itself but attaining full enlightenment for the sake of leading all sentient beings to that state. Leading all sentient beings to that state has not occurred therefore conventional bodhicitta will be present until that point. Otherwise, the mindset which is aiming for full enlightenment for one’s own sake without any particular preoccupation with other sentient beings has nothing to do with bodhicitta.

It is actually the mind aiming for liberation. There is an additional two fold subdivision of bodhicitta from the standpoint of nature between longing, sometimes known as aspiring bodhicitta, and engaging bodhicitta. Then in our cases we do generate longing bodhicitta albeit not a fully characterized longing bodhicitta when we wish to attain full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. This non fully characterized longing bodhicitta will become a fully characterized bodhicitta, a conventional bodhicitta once we attain calm abiding. Engaging bodhicitta in turn arises when one engages in the activities of the six perfections such as ethics, generosity, forbearance, enthusiasm, concentration and wisdom and these activities are held or apprehended by the mind which wishes to attain full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings.

And therefore, all of the activities one engages in from the path of accumulation onwards which are held by the mind which wishes to attain full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings are said to be engaging bodhicitta. Clearly, when one meditates single pointedly on emptiness, at that point conventional bodhicitta becomes latent and therefore one can still speak of a mind which is held by bodhicitta but one can no longer say that this bodhicitta is explicit. And therefore, when one engages in direct meditation on emptiness, although engaging bodhicitta is present, it is nonetheless latent. Likewise, when one emerges from direct meditation on emptiness, both aspiring and engaging bodhicitta are present. There are numerous debates about this between the scholars of Drepung Loseling monastery and Sera Je monastery.

As it is said that in Pänchen Lobsang Chökyi Gyaltsen’s text, it is taught that engaging bodhicitta is absent during direct meditation on emptiness since there is no way to demonstrate its presence. Whereas the Sera Je monastic textbooks composed by Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen teaches that engaging bodhicitta is present during direct meditation on emptiness albeit in a latent fashion. Think I feel that the meaning in terms of meaning basically this is the same thing. Since the Sera Je monastic textbooks teach that it is present in a latent form and Pänchen seems to be saying that it might be present in a latent form but there would be no way to establish this. This is therefore a terminological debate more than a debate about meaning.

Then a simile is or an example is given for the difference between aspiring or longing and engaging bodhicitta. Longing bodhicitta is akin to someone who is planning to go on a trip and is thinking of setting out walking whereas engaging bodhicitta is akin to someone setting out on his trip. Then regarding the methods of generation of bodhicitta, there are two methods, the seven fold cause and effect generation of bodhicitta and the interchange of self and others. I will not explain the sevenfold cause and effect generation of Bodhicitta since it has been taught many times here in the past, but will explain the interchange of self and others briefly. Generally speaking there is no difference in the quality of the bodhicitta generated by these two methods.

bodhicitta can be generated through the sevenfold cause and effect method or through the interchange of self and others. However, there will be a difference in the quality of the bodhicitta generated for an individual practitioner in a function of his or her own constitution. The interchange of self and others is taught in Śāntideva’s Bodhisattvacharyavatara in the stanza which says, the interchange of self and others is a profound practice. Engage in it in secrecy. The reason for which Śāntideva instructs one to engage in this practice in secrecy is because it is an extremely profound practice which therefore will not elicit conviction from many auditors.

If it is not going to elicit conviction, it is preferable not to teach it. Then in this matter, there is a doubt since even though Śāntideva instructs one to keep this practice secret, the Bodhisattvacharyavatara was publicly taught and was publicly taught from Śāntideva’s period up to the present day. Then in Tibet, the practice of the interchange of self and others was kept secret from Atisha all the way to Geshe Chekawa, who for the first time made it public again. So the exact meaning of secrecy here is something one has to investigate. So perhaps if one were to say that in India the teaching was public but that in Tibet from Atisha to Chekawa it was private or secret, that might be appropriate.

So there are four subdivisions in the presentation of the interchange of self and others which begins with identifying the faults of self-cherishing, identifying the qualities of cherishing others, interchanging self and others and placing this practice on the mount of the breath in other words. The first two outlines are best understood through the verse in the Lama Chopa, the Guru Puja which reads self-cherishing is the root of all faults whereas cherishing others altruism is the foundation of all qualities. Understanding this one understands that it is necessary to exchange self-cherishing and other cherishing In other words, to exchange egoism and altruism. Here there is a misunderstanding one must dispel. When one refers to the interchange of self and others one is not referring to putting oneself in the place of others and putting others in one’s own place.

One is instead referring to the interchange of self-cherishing and other cherishing or the interchange of egoism and altruism. And by the interchange of egoism and altruism, what one actually means is to expel egoism completely and instead to take on board altruism. We can see that up to the present time most of the actions we engaged in have been engaged in under the Lordship of egoism, under the rule of egoism. From now onwards we must engage in deeds motivated or under the Lordship of altruism. This calls for careful thought.

Does the approach we have adopted so far which views ourselves as number one and tries to eliminate our own sufferings by finding means to dispel our sufferings work or not. We can see that however much happiness we have, we are never content. Contentment seems to elude us. On the other hand the slightest suffering causes us desperately to find means to eliminate it. What is this rooted in?

It is rooted in the sense of I. It is in I that it is rooted. We engage in all our activities under the sway of I. It is for the I that we work. Then all of us view the world like this, don’t we?

We focus on ourselves and others don’t matter at all, do they? Let us check for ourselves. For instance, if we have little or nothing to eat and we are presented with a fancy meal, we take care of number one. We serve ourselves first and others come as an afterthought, don’t they? Then we basically feel that the more comes our way the better and we leave a couple of crumbs for the other party so that he or she does not get too upset.

So we can see with this example of a meal that out of greed motivated by the sense of I, we stuff our faces and then we are sick. Now the very self same attitude extends to all of the activities we engage in. In all of the activities we engage in, we act under the sway of this overwhelming sense of I. Likewise, when someone we know throws us an angry hard look, we immediately react and say, this terrible person has just thrown me an angry look. Who on earth does he think he is?

Yet, if we examine this person threw us an angry angry look as a result of our own behavior, yet we never say that our own behavior is at fault. We always accuse the other party. Isn’t that so? And therefore the I is responsible for all of the sufferings we experience. No happiness comes as a result of such an I.

Yet we go through life blaming the outside world for all of the unhappiness we experience. If we are sick, it is the fault of some other party, not the fact that we remained in an unhealthy environment and didn’t dress well enough and so forth. And therefore, when we speak of the interchange of self and others, we refer to switching the position of egoism and altruism and instead of being focused on our own well-being at any cost from now onwards to be focused on the well-being of others at any cost. Everything in this life without exception occurs in dependence and through the kindness of others. For instance, whether we need food to eat, money or a job, all of this occurs through the kindness of others, not through our own kindness.

Likewise, as a little child, as an infant, it is through the kindness of our mother and her kindness alone that we were fed and learned how to speak. By extension, it is through the kindness of others and through their kindness alone that the attainment of states such as liberation or full enlightenment is attained. Switching therefore the positions of egoism and altruism of self-cherishing and cherishing others is what is meant by the interchange of self and others. And with this in our mindset, we then strive to attain full enlightenment not for our own sake but for the sake of others and to work for the benefit of others. And after reflecting on the meaning of the interchange of self and others, then one engages in the practice of Tonglen or giving and taking where this practice of expelling egoism and engaging or attracting altruism is mounted on the breath on inhalation and on exhalation. One must completely expel eliminate egoism from one’s mind stream and instead dedicate oneself wholeheartedly to the sake of others.

And this is in a nutshell what is meant by the interchange of self and others. One should meditate on this but to meditate on this initially one must identify what is meant by self and what is meant by others. And then realize that up to now we have acted exclusively under the sway of egoism. Then quite frankly, it doesn’t work, does it? And therefore from today onwards let us eliminate self-cherishing from our mind stream and let us try to act for the sake of others under the sway of altruism.

This is what is meant by the interchange of self and others to strive ceaselessly for the sake of others and to strive ceaselessly to attain full enlightenment for their sake. We shall stop here for now and the next time Geshe-la will start explaining the perfection of generosity. Yeah. Do you have questions? Thank you, Geshe-la.

Could you just re explain because I don’t think I’ve got the full meaning of why Tonglen was a secret practice? The reason for which this practice was said to be secret is because or the practice of mounting the interchange of self and others on the breath involves expelling self-cherishing with exhalation and inhaling altruism with inhalation and this is a practice which we do not understand and which does not resonate with us. For this reason, it was not taught publicly and was said to be secret. Who do we know who sacrifices himself or herself entirely for others and does not think at all about himself or herself even when he or she is sick or is in need and for that matter gives his or her body totally for the sake of others. Someone who engages in these practices discards completely any thought about himself or herself and focuses exclusively on realizing the happiness and the welfare of others.

Such a person, for instance, instead like us of being ready to sacrifice the body of others for his or her welfare is instead ready to sacrifice his or her own body for that of others. For this reason, since this practice is so alien to us, was kept secret. Then since at present we are unable to practice the interchange of self and others and we are unable to dislodge egoism or self-cherishing from its place within our mind stream, then why would such a practice have been taught? Then this is a practice which the bodhisattvas engage in progressing upwards ever more until the attainment of the state of full enlightenment. It is a practice we do not engage in which one of us actually meditates ten or fifteen days.

We think we would die if we get to meditate ten or fifteen days. We won’t. However, through practice such an experience becomes easier and easier. Thanks, Geshe-la. My question is in the same vein.

It seems the degeneration of the Buddhist teachings in India coincided with less secrecy in the teachings and the degeneration perhaps in Tibet also coincided with less secrecy in the teachings particularly of tantra and other practices such as Tonglen. Maybe it’s a bit of a chicken and egg scenario but is it the wide dissemination of these secret teachings that can cause degeneration or is the wide dissemination of these teachings just a symptom of the degeneration of the teachings? There is nothing we can do about that merely as as they say, stay at ease and comfortable. After Atisha’s time and after Geshe Chekawa’s time, the teachings on Tonglen were kept secret but this secrecy was lifted after Chekawa’s time because of the few number of practitioners who were seriously interested in training in bodhicitta. There are even fewer nowadays and basically most practitioners nowadays merely pray.

There was probably great benefit at the period in making these teachings public. Generally speaking, teachings are kept secret for a purpose. The purpose is simply that these teachings are of no benefit if they are taught to the party concerned. Let alone this, in some cases, they can actually harm the person which gives rise to wrong views regarding full enlightenment and so forth. So there are reasons both for maintaining teaching secret and for making teachings public.

Just regarding the threefold subdivision of the shepherd like bodhicitta, how they wish to lead the flock to full enlightenment before getting fully enlightened themselves. If you haven’t achieved full enlightenment, how can you lead others to full enlightenment? So the answer is that the shepherd like bodhicitta is not a realistic form of bodhicitta since one must initially oneself have attained full enlightenment before one is able to lead others to that state. Someone who sincerely practiced the shepherd like bodhicitta would initially have to train in practices such as for instance sacrificing his or her own body and so forth. However, the reason for which the shepherd like bodhicitta is taught is because it is an extremely powerful means to counter self cherish.

Just on those same three subdivisions, is it possible to aim or have the motivation to attain a particular type of bodhicitta such as shepherd like or king like? Most definitely. For instance, it is said that Ārya Avalokiteśvara had generated the shepherd like bodhicitta as his main practice. But he attained full enlightenment very quickly. So it is said that of these three forms of bodhicitta, this is the most powerful.

Just in regards to the debate between Sera Je Monastery and the other one, whose name I forgot. Okay. Just in relation to the debate that when one is meditating on emptiness, engaged bodhicitta is considered to be latent, at least by Sera Je. Is that in relation to a Mahāyāna practitioner or does that also include Hīnayāna practitioners who are meditating on emptiness? Now obviously, how could a Śrāvaka or a Pratyeka Buddha have engaging bodhicitta even in a latent form?

However, when a Śrāvaka or a Pratyeka Buddha is engaged in single pointed meditation on emptiness, then the mind which is aspiring for liberation is latent. So it’s exactly, it is symmetrical if you wish with the situation of Bodhisattvas which have direct perception of emptiness. For Bodhisattvas with direct perception of emptiness, the engaging bodhicitta is latent. Likewise, for hearers and solitary realizers with direct realization of emptiness, the mind striving for liberation is latent. Is this the importance therefore of setting the motivation because if one was to sit to meditate on emptiness with the desire for this to be a cause for enlightenment, then doing the practice, does that mean that the bodhicitta is latent?

Would that be the reasoning behind the Sera Je argument? It is not possible to attain the state of full enlightenment without both collections, the collection of merit and the collection of wisdom. Through engaging in training in bodhicitta, one actually fosters the development of the collection of merit. Through on the other hand, meditating on emptiness, one fosters the increase in the collection of wisdom. With these two, one progresses towards full enlightenment.

In one continuum, these minds which focus on wisdom and method cannot be present simultaneously. In other words, when the mind which focuses on method and which is for instance striving for the attainment of full enlightenment is present, then the wisdom component is latent, it is not manifest. Likewise, when the mind focusing single pointedly on emptiness is present, then the method component is not manifest. It is latent. These two cannot be present simultaneously within the same mind stream.

What we can say is that both cannot be present in a manifest form. If one is present in a manifest form, the other can only be present latently and reciprocally. For instance, when one performs offerings to accumulate merit, the mind which realizes emptiness is latent. Likewise, when one meditates single pointedly on emptiness, the mind focused on the accumulation of method is latent. Therefore, these two alternate just as the direct perception of emptiness and subsequent attainment alternate.

They alternate. To give an example, it is similar to walking. If you walk you need two feet however when one foot is extended walking the other by definition cannot be moving and must remain fixed. Likewise when the other foot is rooted in the ground, the first foot is extended moving. They alternate in this fashion.

Is that also the meaning of in liberation in the palm of your hand, Pabongka Rinpoche says, cannot sew with a two pronged needle. No, no that is used in a different context. What is the meaning of the example in Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand is that one cannot simultaneously be focused on the welfare of this life and that of future lives. Likewise, one cannot simultaneously aspire for liberation and for full enlightenment. Once again Geshe-la referred to the importance of calm abiding and this Saturday Ilia will be giving another of his very illuminating seminars at 02:00 between two and four on calm abiding.

You are very welcome to attend and have a quick cup of tea before you go. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

dhyana samten (Tib)
An advanced form of concentration meditation after realizing shamatha (calm abiding). LYWA
higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
Paramitayana Pharchin thegpa (Tib)
The Perfection Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
six realms
The general way that Buddhism divides the whole of cyclic existence; there are three lower realms (hell, hungry ghost and animal) and three upper realms (human, demigod and god). LYWA
taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Why was the practice of tonglen (giving and taking) traditionally kept secret?

Tonglen mounts the interchange of self and others on the breath: self-cherishing is expelled with the exhalation and altruism is taken in with the inhalation. This is a practice we do not understand and which does not resonate with us, so it was not taught publicly and was called secret. It is alien to us because it is the practice of someone who gives up thought of themselves and even sacrifices their own body for others, whereas we are ready to sacrifice others for our own welfare. It is a practice the bodhisattvas engage in, progressing until full enlightenment.

Scroll to Top