1 h 17 min · 3,807 words · 16 September 2012 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 77-minute teaching from the Mind Training Like the Rays of the Sun commentary, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen explores the philosophical foundations and practical methods for cultivating bodhicitta, the awakened heart dedicated to benefiting all beings. He distinguishes between two approaches: the seven-point cause and effect method and the practice of exchanging self for others. Through patient investigation, practitioners learn to revalue themselves and others by recognizing an exaggerated, self-cherishing mindset and deliberately shifting that value outward. He explains how this conceptual work enables the giving and taking meditation, a breathing-based practice where practitioners visualize sending happiness and virtue on the exhale while drawing in the sufferings of all beings on the inhale, thereby extinguishing self-centeredness and cultivating genuine compassion. Geshe-la emphasizes that such cultivation requires consistent effort over time and that even a sincere moment of loving compassion generates far greater virtue than material offerings.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2012-09-16 – KR.mp3
UUID: 408b16ff-a9f9-4f77-9f83-aad7d499f459
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Awakening Heart
Date: 2012-09-16
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,809
So today we continue with the text ‘Mind Training Like the Rays of the Sun’. We understand that the core meaning of this text relates to the generation of bodhicitta, the mind of enlightenment. And we know that this mind of enlightenment or bodhicitta is characterized by the desire to bring benefit to other living beings. Now in Buddhism, it is of of great importance. It is a central topic of Buddhism that we try to cultivate this mind of enlightenment, this bodhicitta, and therefore, is of extreme importance.
Now bodhicitta has two aspects to it. The first is that in a world where it is inhabited by billions, maybe 7,000,000,000 people, all living beings that exist on in this world, we have the aim, the aspiration that somehow we will be able to bring benefit to all of those living beings. So we understand that by our aspiration to bring benefit to all living beings, it requires that secondly, we have make a keen and careful investigation as to the needs of sentient beings and how it is that we would be able to bring about this great benefit that we are aiming to achieve. So if we think about the two methods in which we are able to cultivate bodhicitta or the mind of enlightenment, we know that there have been two explicit methods that practitioners have been able to rely on. The seven point cause and effect tradition that has been referred to, repeatedly in the text and exchanging self for others.
Now in this text we know that Geshe Chekawa has made reference to the fact that we are making this aspiration to bring benefit to all living beings And we need somehow to devise a method whereby we are able to cultivate the qualities within our mind that will enable us to bring benefit to all living beings. And this is in the exchanging self and others technique as as referenced in this text, Light Rays text. Before I caution, because And just from the previous bit, one bit that I missed was that where one part of the method that was referred to in Geshe Chekawa was this trying to aim whereby we’re able to bring others, distant others, closest to our closer to our domain of concern, thereby having the wish and the desire to benefit other living beings based on a sense of their nearness and value to us. And therefore, it goes into the practice of exchanging self for others. So now when we are able to Oh, that’s right.
That’s right. And so when we come now to actually investigate the nature of exchanging self for others, we may well ask what it is in fact that we are exchanging. What what are we actually exchanging when it comes to this practice of exchanging self for others. So this is a question that Geshe-la has for you. What do you believe that we’re exchanging?
You know? Yeah. What is that? What does the man eat? What does man eat?
What does it mean? What does that mean? Yeah. So transforming one’s own your own experience of suffering into something that Mark. So just clarify something that we need to understand to be a bit clearer on this.
When we were when we ask about exchanging self for others and talk about Tonglen, this the practice of exchanging self for others. So there there is first a distinction that Geshe-la wants to make that in order to be able to practice this technique, the technique of exchanging self for others, the Tonglen practice that everyone under understands that is of taking suffering and giving away, virtue and so forth. Before we actually engage in that practice, we need to have a better understanding of the concepts of exchanging self for others. So if we recall if we main keep referring to the actual practice of Tonglen, the giving and taking practice, that comes after we have a better conceptual understanding of what it means to exchange self for others. So there is a way that we need to investigate exchanging self for others, and understanding of that gives rise to this practice of giving and taking.
So now when it comes to explaining the when it comes to explaining the philosophical position of exchanging self for others, not to be confused with the Tonglen, giving and taking practice. Okay? What we are trying to understand through this concept of exchanging self for others is that normally we habituated to an idea of our exaggerated sense of self and we harbor it, we obsess about it. It is central to all the the thoughts and actions that we engage in. Okay?
Now to truly understand this exaggerated sense of self as opposed to just a normal sense of self. This exaggerated sense of self and how we cherish it. It requires a lot of personal investigation and introspection to come to a clear a clear sense of how it is operating within our mind. And it is something that takes time and it takes thorough investigation to come to an understanding of. When we come to a very clear understanding of this cherishing of our exaggerated sense of self, we know that it is something that we need to abandon, that we need to evict from our consciousness.
Is a state of mind. It is a way of existing that we must totally free ourselves from. Okay. So this is where we believe we overvalue our sense of self and believe it to have a superior value to any other possible consideration. It is the primary focus of every aspect of one’s existence.
This is what we’re trying to eliminate from our minds. In order to have such an exaggerated sense of self, it requires us to diminish the value of others. It is one that exaggerating the quality of one diminishes the value of another. You can’t have place a high value on the worth of others if you have an exaggerated value on your own sense of self your own exaggerated self. Okay?
What we are trying to do when it comes to making this changing, this exchanging, we are trying to remove the value, the excess value we have placed on our own exaggerated self and take that value and exchange it so that it now resides with others. So that suddenly the exchange rate has become has been turned upside down. Where once we had an overvalued self, they had an undervalued self. Now we are to make the ledger even again, need to have overvalued the others again. We need to create a greater value on for the other.
By doing that, by being able to do that, we know that we can’t possibly be maintaining self-cherishing at the same time. The effect of that valuing of the other will minimise our habit at overvaluing our own sense of self. So part of the way that we go about increasing the value of others to our sense of who we are and how we live in the world is by imagining drawing them nearer to us. If we believe that they are somehow connected to us and important to us, then we naturally assign value to them. And this is a way that we are able to engage in the thought processes of continually increasing apportioning greater value to others.
If we imagine them drawing closer and being more important for our own welfare then naturally the value we assign to them rises. So on the basis of making that investigation and, readjusting your economics, then you can start to practice the meditation technique of giving and taking. Meditation technique of giving and taking isn’t going to work or be have any power without it being without it coming after this initial revaluate revaluation? So if we are able to repeatedly make this investigation and this reassigning of value then eventually we’ll begin to see that just as we put a very high value on our children, our parents, our pet, loved one, whoever it is that is our most nearest and dearest. Just as we we know what the value we place, we assign to them.
Well, if you’re able to do this process, you’ll begin to assign that same value to to all living beings. Okay? So the ability to assign value to nearest and dearest is good, but it is limited to a very tight circle of other living beings. When we’re able to have that exact feeling for all living beings, then we know that we have accomplished. We have made ground in reevaluating the value of others and it gives rise to then engaging in very successful giving and taking meditation exercise.
So the meditation exercise of giving and taking then comes about on a very firm basis and will have great success. Okay. So we remember that we’ve been talking about generating bodhicitta by virtue of two possible methods. The seven point cause and effect method and exchanging self for others method. Now if we now consider that we’ve made this journey whereby we are assigning this great value, this prized value normally constrained to our nearest and dearest.
We are now assigning that to all living beings. We now begin to see that we have through this exchanging self for others in fact started to tick off a number of the steps in the seven point cause and effect method. Now the seven point cause and effect method we remember has six causes and one effect. The effect being, the attainment of bodhicitta. We know or we hopefully we remember that they are recognising all sentient beings as mother, remembering their kindness and wishing to reciprocate that kindness.
Now if we were working through on the seven point cause and effect method that they’re the steps that we would be taking to try and accomplish those three points. Now we’ve been doing the exchanging self and others method. But through the exchanging self and others method we have in fact accomplished the first three points of the seven point cause and effect. So you can see how these two methods are producing similar results. The method by which we are following is exchanging self for others.
We’ve gone through this reassigning of value to all other living beings. We’ve drawn them nearer into our circle of concern. Thereby, we have accomplished the first three of the six causes within the seven point cause and effect method. So now having come to this understanding and this re evaluation, we begin to practise the meditation technique of giving and taking. So when we do this practise as we spoke about last week, The technique depends on our, focus and awareness on our breath, on our breathing in and out.
And we understand that when we breathe out, with our focus being on the process of this exhaling this breath as it leaves us, we imagine it is taking with the breath riding on the breath is all the possible happinesses that we could impart on another living being. We imagine that these great pleasures and happinesses and virtues ride out on the breath as we exhale. And then as we inhale, imagine that as with again with our focus on this breath as it draws back into us, we imagine it is drawing back into us all possible sufferings from all living beings. And as this breath comes into our bodies, we imagine that it is extinguishing, obliterating this core self-cherishing that we are harbouring. So this breath comes in with it is all possible sufferings and the causes of suffering that exist for other sentient beings comes into us and it extinguishes our self-cherishing.
And in doing this giving and taking practice, are cultivating the love and compassion to strengthen and to rise most profoundly within our mind. So now once we’re able to successfully perform this practice and we are cultivating within us this strengthened ability for love and compassion, eventually, what is arising within us is this supreme intention or this supreme sincerity to bring benefit to others. Okay? Now if we again go back to the seven point cause and effect, we know that it was the sixth of the six causes remembering that there’s six causes and one effect, the effect is bodhicitta. The sixth cause is generating this mind of sincere intention.
Okay? And that’s what arises within the practice, the stages of practice within seven point cause and effect. So once again in our own practice here of exchanging self for others, we reach the point where we have similarly attained this mental state of having this supreme altruistic intention to bring benefit to others. So we come to setting our motivation for today. We focus on having this complete understanding and transformation that is required of us in exchanging self for others in as we’ve explained in terms of revaluing self and others.
On the basis of that we then step into being able to perform the giving and taking meditation successfully. And on the basis of that we’re able to enrich our ability to experience this superior intention, this superior altruistic intention of wanting to bring benefit to other living beings. So we can set ourselves this determination that we will engage in the study, the listening and the study, in order to increase our capacity to successfully understand and incorporate exchanging self for others and then the giving and taking technique in order to acquire ultimately this superior altruistic intention. And this is the meditation the motivation that we can set now for today. So did you did your meditation what?
Did your meditation did you meditation everybody this morning? Really? Did you finish? Tanya? This is him.
Yeah. Good. Thank you so very much. Mark? Thank you.
Justin? Yeah. Good. Thank you. I don’t, what is your name?
Edda. Edda. Edda. Good. And you?
Really? Oh. And Anne? Really? Good.
And Julie? Anne? Is your name? I forget. I’m sorry.
Yeah. Glenys. Glenys. Glenys. Glenys.
Glenys. Glenys. Oh, yeah. Yeah. And Bill?
Bill. Bill. And you? Good. How long?
Pardon? Good. Good one. Good Good one. Really?
This is the because today is holiday. On holiday, Edward. Today is on holiday. And Christy? Hey.
Why? Why? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
You’re joking. And Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And the sample?
Good. Good. And how long? One? One.
Please again. One. What’s the other one say? Oh, good. Very long, long, long.
And oh, yeah. Aaron? So if we now we understand, if we go about it in such a way where first we focus on this exchanging self for others, others. Then that leads to the giving and taking meditation, which then leads to this generation within our minds of loving kindness and great compassion. Now if we go if we’re able to sustain our practice whereby we’re able to do it in such with such a methodology, we most definitely will experience the most extraordinary results.
But these results will not be perceptible to us immediately and we will not have any great, results coming in the short term. It is a technique that requires consistent and continual effort And on the basis of that effort over time, then the most extraordinary results will eventually be experienced. Now as the Buddha himself has said, the benefits of this generation of the mind of enlightenment will bring extraordinary benefit to us and our well-being, and it is something that we must sincerely strive to attain. Now when it comes to topics such as emptiness and meditating on emptiness, this is a topic that we will come to later. But for the moment, we should direct our full and undivided attention and energy towards this cultivation of bodhicitta through process that we’ve outlined.
And we will most definitely have the most extraordinary of results and feel immense benefit from it. And this is intended to come anew then. And so now let us just do two minutes, to set ourselves for today. So we come to an understanding of renunciation whereby we know that one day by concerted effort and attention, we hope that one day this renunciation will most certainly arise within our mind. And even by devoting our small ability towards this, to attaining this state of renunciation, it enables us to enter into the path of liberation.
So renunciation is of extreme importance to us. It requires to really practice renunciation, requires an enormous amount of not just energy, of energy, but of courage and a sense of profound responsibility. When it comes to thinking solely of our own concerns, it’s something that is easily done and and it requires taking on very little responsibility. When we begin to privilege the welfare of others and believe that we are taking on a personal responsibility in order to bring benefit to others, it requires this courage, conviction and this sense of a profound sense of responsibility. If we are to continue to do nothing but allow ourselves to be driven by personal concern, then we are in fact living our lives no different than say for example an ant who goes about its business solely to perform its own functions for its own existence, for its own survival.
So if we seek to have a more profound understanding and a more profound existence, then we should take this self centeredness out of the equation and focus instead on a sense of responsibility for bringing welfare to others. And in so doing, we truly begin to enter the path of liberation whereby we have cultivated this sense of, renunciation and keen awareness to the welfare of others. So when it comes to these thoughts that are inspired by this great compassion and concern for others we begin to think of there are two aspects that we need to be keenly aware of. One is that firstly we have this desire to bring great benefit to all other living beings. This is our aim and this is our intention.
The second point is that we really need to in order to fulfill that ambition, need to have certain qualities that enable us to actually engage in such a thing. So the second point is how do we go about cultivating these qualities that actually enable us to fulfil our aim of bringing benefit to others? Because as it stands right now, as we may well have this very deep aspiration to want to benefit others, but we simply do not have the qualities that enable us to bring a very meaningful benefit to other living beings. Now we know that the bodhisattvas and the arhats do have enormous power to be able to bring benefit to other living beings. But even they do not have the power that a Buddha has to be able to bring benefit to other living beings.
Recognising this and recognising the capacity of a Buddha to bring benefit to others, must be our sincere intention to attain Buddhahood. It must be a very determined goal that we have. We must determine that this goal is the most important goal that we are striving for. This ultimate state of Buddhahood because it is then in that state of Buddhahood we would have the qualities. We would have cultivated the qualities that enable us to fulfil that initial aim.
So one, the aim is there to bring benefit to others, but we must somehow cultivate the qualities that will bring that benefit. And those qualities are embodied in the state of Buddhahood. So we know that this cultivation of loving compassion within our minds gives rise to an enormous capacity for generating virtue. Okay? So we know that loving kindness and compassion results in enormous virtue being generated within us.
And in order to be able to truly, benefit others, we are trying to cultivate the virtue that enables us to have the power to do so. Now if we are trying to think of ways that we are able to increase this virtue, We might imagine as the text refers to that there if we were to make offerings, we would be able to increase our virtue. Let’s imagine that we were able to, let’s imagine all the various kinds of precious substances or precious things that we could amass as part of an offering that we would be offering to the Buddhas. Imagine that we were having the most, extensive richness of offerings. Now we would imagine that that would somehow enable some virtue to be accomplished within our minds.
Well, if it is said that if we can truly generate this feeling of loving compassion whereby we are trying to cultivate loving compassion in order to benefit other living beings, Even a moment of this sincere intention within our minds draws far more benefit, far more virtue than if we were to make this grand offering of grand material offerings of incredible value. So even a moment of generating this loving compassion that is, that is based on wanting to benefit others creates more virtue within our mind than even the most vast offering we could possibly make. All right. Today, stop. All right.
Today, stop. Start away. I will finish here today. So the section that we were referencing then was on page 80 of the Light Rays text where we’re under the topic of the process of cultivating the awakened mind concerned with attaining the fully awakened state of being. And, what Geshe-la was referring to there you can see referenced in the quote from the text at the bottom of page 80.
And so that’s where we that’s the part of the text that Geshe-la referenced today. And that’s where we leave the text for today. So we finished that and we will come up when we begin next week, we will begin at the heading that says instructions concerning the five precepts that are factors of the training. Which is of course a very important section of the text. There’s five precepts of training.
And that’s what will be the basis of next week’s class. That’s page 81 instructions concerning the five precepts page 81. So in the seven point cause and effect, So Geshe-la was saying that you might say that it’s stronger, but the point is that in exchange in self and others it is a far quicker way of getting to that point. So you might infer from that that it’s stronger but it’s just it gets you to that point quicker. Alright.
Finish. Good. Good time. Good time. Good time.
Just one hour.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
- The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.