Awakening Heart — 2012-04-29

Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart — 2012-04-29
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2012-04-29 – KR.mp3

UUID: 76266a93-a995-452c-b37a-56eeabcf338c

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)

Date: 2012-04-29

Duration: 1h 29m

Words: 3,318

Satvacharyavatara, all suffering comes from the mind likewise all happiness comes from the mind. This famous quote was commented by a great Indian pundit, a scholar who probably Kantorian Geshela thinks was not a Buddhist but he was nonetheless an impartial objective scholar and his holiness the Dalai Lama asked him to write a commentary on Bodhisattva Charyavatara and His Holiness actually asked him to oppose his signature inside His Holiness’s copy of Bodhisattva Charyavatara as the endorsement of a scholar to another scholar. And therefore Shantideva says, I prostrate to that bodhicitta in the mind of whomsoever it dwells leads to the forgiveness of those who are harmful. When Shantideva says I prostrate to that bodhicitta, he indicates clearly the importance of bodhicitta as Kensure Rinpoche has taught here over and again. It is critical for our practice to train in these three principles of the path which are definite emergence, bodhicitta and the correct view of emptiness.

And this is not just a matter of studying the mere words which we all at present know. It is a matter of practice and even more importantly of experience. In other words, of blending or mixing our mind with the three principles of the path. Of these three principles of the path, foremost is altruism or bodhicitta. If we are able to generate a fully qualified state of bodhicitta within our mind stream, all the better.

If it is not possible, at least we should try to generate as much of a state of bodhicitta as we can. The following verse in Shantideva’s bodhisattvacharya vatha reads, in the mind of whom it dwells, it leads to forgiveness of harm. One who has generated bodhicitta within his mind stream irrespective of the harm which is inflicted upon him by evil doers will only pray for the well-being of these evildoers and the harm inflicted becomes a cause for an ever greater increase in bodhicitta. Therefore, at this point, when we want to generate the motivation to listen to these teachings, we should ideally generate a motivation of altruism or bodhicitta but even if we are not able to generate a complete motivation of altruism or bodhicitta, we should try to generate as much of such a motivation as is possible for two minutes or so. There are several types of actually in the light of this we will now explain Bodhicitta.

There are several types of commentaries on the Lamrim. They include the commentary of experience, the experiential commentary, the raw guidance and the explanatory commentary. The first category, the commentary of experience is a commentary where for instance when renunciation or definite emergence is explained, the guru explains one topic in detail and after explaining that topic does not explain any further topics until the student has gained realizations of the explained topic. This is actually how one should practice. So for instance, if we take the path of the being of building scope, key points of the path of the being of building scope would be explained and then the teacher would wait until the students has realizations before explaining the path of the being of great scope.

Whether the teacher from his own side has or does not have the realizations of the topics he explained, we do not know. We can assume he does because of the efforts made but we have no access to this. Now from our own side, to gain such realizations is only possible if we have very strong karmic imprints in this direction. Otherwise, it is difficult to gain them in this life. And therefore, the practices of the being small scope have been explained in the context of mind training as the rays of the sun and the practices of the beings of middling scope.

At present, Gishan, I would explain the practices of the being of great scope. And therefore, we have to understand as was explained clearly many times that true experience can only be obtained after preliminary study. Otherwise, it is very difficult to obtain true experience. Now in the context of the mind which is striving for liberation, such a mind can only be generated independence on a full realization of the sufferings of cyclic existence. This force is difficult to generate since we do not remember the countless sufferings we have experienced in past lives.

The number of times we have been reborn as children and as children experienced the suffering of the first breath, Then the suffering of crying and screaming when we were spanked or scolded by our parents. Then the suffering of old age sickness and death which we experienced over and again. This we neither recollect nor are able to control. We are powerless in the matter and it is this we must meditate upon to generate a strong sense of the importance of getting immutable happiness, immutable bliss. This is what we must obtain.

As Je Tsongkhapa says clearly in the Three Principles of the Path, in such a way, meditating in such a way when through meditation an attraction to the marvels of cyclic existence does not arise, then day and night it can be said we have generated true renunciation. Generally speaking if one is ordained whether one is a monk or a nun, what can be said with certainty is that one has the opportunity for practice. Unfortunately, it cannot be said with certainty whether one has either the understanding or whether one does practice. This cannot be said. As a matter of fact, it is possible that many of us practice more than those who are ordained.

It is impossible to say whether this is the case or not. What can be said however is that ordination gives the opportunity for practice and therefore the levels of practice whether for monks or for lay people are open but the levels they have attained are unknown to us. And therefore, both Geshela and Anila Jampa Tenzin are ordained and therefore they have the exterior signs of practitioners. Whether from their side they practice or not is something which it is impossible for us to know. All we can say is that they have the exterior signs of practitioners.

This is why Thogme Sangbo, the great bodhisattva said it is the practice of bodhisattvas to put efforts in their own practice. This is a verse which is repeatedly quoted by his holiness the Dalai Lama and Geshela would encourage us to reflect on it as well. And therefore, one can say without any doubt that it is indispensable initially to generate the minds striving for welfare in future lives before being able to generate the mind striving for liberation from cyclic existence. This mind striving for liberation from cyclic existence arises therefore on the foundation of the mind striving for well-being in future lives. Now regarding the verse in the three principles of the path, when the mind striving for liberation arises day and night, it can be said that definite emergence is well generated.

It is difficult for us, certainly it is difficult for Geshela himself who is not a practitioner to know precisely what this means. He cannot say for the students whether they are practitioners or not, some may be, but it is difficult for him to assess the full meaning of this verse which is evident only to someone who has experience. Probably, when such a mind striving for liberation arises, one can be said to have entered the path. At this point, there are two roads which one can follow. The first, as Geshela has explained is the Hinayana and the second is the Mahayana.

If at this point when the mind striving for liberation has arisen day and night spontaneously, the indolence and the laziness of which Shantideva speaks in his Bodhisattva Acharyavatara arise, that spiritual indolence and laziness which says, it is very difficult to work for the sake of others, they don’t benefit, they are slack, I will focus on my own benefit. At that point, at that point alone, one has entered the Hinayana and one’s focus will be on meditating on selflessness with the Hinayana motivation. On the other side, if one focuses at that juncture on others, then one will enter the Mahayana. Generally speaking, we will be covering at present the Mahayana. Now within the Mahayana, speak of self cherishing.

However, the self cherishing which is referred to in this context is slightly different from the self cherishing referred to in the context of the Hinayana. Now in our cases, most of us in this room study the Mahayana. We study both the Sutra and the Tantrayana. However, we have to be very clear regarding the fact that we are not yet Mahayana beings. We are merely studying these topics and implanting within our minds karmic imprints regarding these topics which will come to fruition later on.

So we can see this for instance in the context of a dharma center such as this one. There are some students who are of great benefit to others. They volunteer systematically and they have a broader scope. Other students on the other hand are here only for their own sake. This corresponds to the difference in the scope or the outlook of the students.

Now in the case of the difference between the Mahayana and the Hinayana, the Mahayana has the broadest scope. The Hinayana has the smallest scope. Just as to give an example in a democracy for instance, it is the difference between the majority and the minority which determines the future of the country with greater importance given to the majority. It is important to understand that the difference between engaging in the Mahayana and engaging in the Hinayana is not a difference in terms of the extent of the work one does, the extent of the effort one performs. For instance, it would be inappropriate to say that engaging in the Mahayana is akin to building a house while engaging in the Hinayana is akin to doing something small and local.

The difference is exclusively in terms of the motivation and it is in terms of this vast or small motivation, this motivation to benefit all beings or the motivation to focus only on one’s own self that the difference is positive. Here as Arya Nagarjuna says in the Ratnavali, the precious garland in this world foremost of causes for full enlightenment is bodhicitta. Therefore, this state of full enlightenment which we are striving for at present in the context of the Mahayana has as its cause bodhicitta and this is therefore what we from our side must strive to generate. And the cause of bodhicitta is great compassion which is related closely to empathy. Now there are various types of empathy, partial and non partial empathy.

The empathy which is related to or which is talked about here is that wish to free all sentient beings from suffering and within the threefold subdivision of suffering into the suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and all pervasive suffering, it is the wish to free beings from all pervasive suffering. Therefore, Dharma Kirti says in Pramana Vartika, it is in this way that one accomplishes all goals through meditation. Meditation is therefore an indispensable preliminary. And the cause of great compassion is none other than love. Here, there is something quite odd which occurs because basically all sentient beings actually have both love and compassion.

Animals have love and compassion. But they have partial love or compassion. This is love, compassion or empathy for those who are close to them and who have helped them. It goes hand in hand with animosity towards those who are distant from them or who have harmed them. Geshela for himself can say that he has love, compassion and empathy of the partial type.

As for you, he doesn’t know. And the only way to expand the scope of these partial loves and empathy is through study. For instance, Sylvia definitely has love and compassion for her child. And this is why His Holiness have said many times that all if we reflect on bodhicitta and great compassion, they will arise relatively easily because we have some sort of connection with them. It is a very different matter for the view of selflessness.

And for this reason, when His Holiness taught the commentary on the Mughal Madhya Makakarika at Drepul Monastery one and a half years ago, he pointed out that without prior habituation it is very difficult to reflect on the view of the subtle selflessness of persons which is shared by the schools of tenets beneath the Pasangika School of Tenet which is a subtle selflessness of persons which is an emptiness of the person being an autonomous substantial existent. In the context of the Lamrim, naturally the view which is espoused is the Prasangika or consequentialist view. As His Holiness has said many times, Paul, it is easier to generate bodhicitta in the case of emptiness. It is impossible to generate emptiness without a union of a Samatha and a Viparshana. In other words, a single pointed concentration and an insight which are single pointedly focused on emptiness.

This can only be generated in dependence on a Samatha which has been trained in previously. Therefore, without Samatha it is impossible to gain direct insight in emptiness. This is why His Holiness has sponsored retreats of numerous meditators above the Dharam Sala. Some of whom have attained the fifth, the sixth, the eighth or the ninth levels leading up to calm abiding and some of whom for sure have attained calm abiding. And therefore, to generate bodhicitta, we have to expand vastly the love, the compassion and the empathy which are pre existent within our minds and through expanding it vastly eventually we can give rise to bodhicitta.

It is not the case of engaging in some vast deeds or some vast activities, building a house or something like that, but to take the case of Sylvia’s love for her child, that is a love which is pre existent in the mother and which just has to be expanded in its scope. And therefore in the context of mind training as a rays of the sun, we have a presentation of the training of love as a preliminary to the training in compassion and this entails wishing that all sentient beings have all of the vestments, all of the requisites which they wish for. And it is for this reason that it is said in Mind Training Like the Rays of the Sun quoting the Samadhi Raja Sutra, the King of Concentration Sutra that greater merit is accrued through generating a love which wishes to benefit all sentient beings then through making offerings for countless eons to the totality of the Buddhas. For the simple reason that the totality of the Buddhas need nothing from us and therefore these offerings are of no benefit to them whereas sentient beings do need our help. Likewise, it is said in a Sutra that far greater merit is accrued through meditating on a love which wishes to give happiness to all sentient beings in the impure lands in which we live at present than to meditate on such a love once one has been reborn in the pure lands.

Generally speaking, the Pure Lands are not accepted by the Hinayana, in other words by the Vaibhashika and the Sauthantika schools, but they are accepted by the Mahayana schools. Many beings in these Pure Lands dwell in the infinite bliss of meditative equipoise on the truth of cessation. And in such pure lands, all beings are equal in being free of obvious suffering. Therefore, the meditations on the generation of love and compassion for that reason give rise to less merit when one meditates or engages in them in the pure lands than when one engages in them in the impure lands. It is for this reason that there is a great prayer in the Bodhisattvacharyavatara to learn how to use one’s body properly as a servant for one’s practice.

And for this reason, also Shantideva prays that his body can become as vast as the three kilocalcosm, the universe, or as vast as space for the sake of sentient beings. And for this reason likewise, Shantideva prays that his body be of benefit to beings until they have attained the state of full enlightenment. So in the context of donating one’s body for the sake of others, at present it is a visualized or imagined practice. There are beings who practice in reality donating their body parts for the sake of others such as giving their eyes. And the majority of these practices within the Mahayana are visualized practices.

The actual giving of body and such is rare. The best is to give instructions on the great vehicle and the stages of generation of bodhicitta motivated oneself by a motivation of bodhicitta of great compassion or of love and empathy. This is not to say that beings such as Shavakas or Prateka Buddhas, hearers or solitary realizers have no altruism whatsoever but their main focus is on their own practice. And therefore the motivation in which we engage in something is critical. We will stop here and if you have questions, Gishna will take them at present.

So study is critical because we are trying to follow in the paths of Buddha Shakyamuni, of Aryanagarjuna and so forth. For this reason, we should study their works and inspire ourselves from them. Otherwise, if we rely on our own sense of things, there is a very big risk we will end somewhere else altogether. If we do not study these great texts and we rely on ourselves, we have all sorts of private fantasies, private conceptions. There are many cases of people who do tremendous or engage in tremendous efforts and yet gain no results, no realizations.

Engaging in the wrong paths. Are there other questions? Yes please. So it is through realizing that all we ourselves at present wish to place all sentient beings in a state of stable happiness, we lack the capacity to do so that we strive to attain the state of full enlightenment in which we will have this capacity. As Shantideva said, if at present even in a dream we do not wish to do this for ourselves, how can we pretend to wish to do it for other beings?

So once we ourselves have transformed our mind in this way and our mind comes under the power of this wish to attain full enlightenment so as to place all sentient beings in that state and our mind is completely mixed with that, At that point, fully characterized bodhicitta has been generated. Are there other questions? So the foundations of Madhyamika are to be found in and it is this which has to be studied as explained by Chandra Kirti in his Madhyamaka Vatara. However, to understand the Prasangika view which is the supreme view, one has to build up to this view and one must study initially the view of the lower vehicles, and eventually Madhyamika views. It is only in this way that one can eventually exceed to the Prasangika view.

Now for us to exceed directly to this view is almost impossible. It is only someone with very powerful karmic imprints such as His Holiness the Dalai Lama who can enter directly into a reflection on the Pasangika view. One has to have a very powerful mind, very powerful imprints and a very swift mind to do this. The study of the four schools of tenets, the Vaibhashika, Sotrandikachita, Mantra and Madhyamika school is extremely important. Specifically from the standpoint of their differentiated presentation of the views leading to liberation.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top