1 h 45 min · 13,675 words · 9 November 2011
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teacher introduces healing disturbing emotions, distinguishing anger, which exaggerates faults and is based on self-grasping, from wrathful compassion. He explains karma as seeds ripened by emotion and encourages investigating the self that becomes angry. The talk closes with a short breathing meditation and the dedication prayer.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2011-11-09
Duration: 1h 46m
UUID: ea2c8ea5-ac72-4d91-9678-8cbaca310b16
Words: 13,671
Suffering. No matter what the form of the being, no matter how the being appears to me, whether it’s desirable or not, whether the being is angry or not, jealous of me or not, it doesn’t matter from my side. I want to liberate them. So we’re not depending on them to be kind to us. From our side, we’re being kind because this is who we are.
This is what we want to do. So we start out with that motivation. Then everything we do after that motivation is based on Bodhicitta, becomes the cause of enlightenment. And then we start. So I’m really jet lagged.
I might fall asleep in the middle. So if I fall asleep, then I can just pretend we’re meditating, and you can fall asleep too. So this is called healing disturbing emotions or destructive emotions, if you like. And before we start, you know, maybe we need to think about what are disturbing emotions. So we’re we’re talking about healing disturbing emotions.
So first of all, we need to know what are those disturbing emotions. Which emotions do we want to remove, and which emotions do we want to improve? Right? So we have two things. We have to remove something, and we have to improve something.
So Buddhism is very clear about delineating this, about saying, these are the emotions of the destructive. These are the emotions that are positive and beneficial. So like I said, Bodhicitta, the sense of I want to help others. I want to benefit others. That helps you and helps others.
This is an incredible motivation. Maybe behind us, maybe a bit too too much, a bit too, highfaluting or a bit too, in the future. But at least when we sit down to do something important like a meditation or a Dharma teaching, at least at that time we can say, that is what I would like to do. That’s who I would like to be. Now I will not be able to conceive of how, but you know what to say is going traveling.
So recently, I had to go to Nepal and then come back. If you don’t contact the travel agent, if you don’t call the travel agent and say, I need to get a plane from here to there, then you don’t go. You can sit and surf the net. You know? So you can sort of Google airlines go to Nepal, and then it says, oh, this one goes or this one goes.
But you don’t actually book the ticket. You keep talking about, oh, I’d really like to go to Nepal. One day I’ll go to Nepal, or one day, I’ll go to Kopan monastery, or one day, I’ll go up the mountains. But you never actually go. And in Buddhism, when we’re talking about Bodhicitta, this is what we call aspiring Bodhicitta.
There’s an aspirant. Somebody who sits and says, that sounds really great, but I just can’t do it at the moment. I don’t have that much power and energy to be able to do it. And that is the person who’s very determined and says, I’m gonna do it. So then which is the best airline?
Which is the cheapest fare? Are we concerned about the cheapest fare? The cheapest, but the best. Right? So I want the cheapest airfare, but the worst leg room, and the widest seat, and the best service.
Right? So you don’t just want cheap with a you know, it’s now which airline was it? I think Indian Airlines or Air India, where they used to give you the food in a box. You know, a little cardboard box, and it sort of virtually throws at you. Here, here, Lodge.
You know, you catch it? I open it, and it’s a sort of moldy sandwich, and you think, oh, and you close it. You know? I think I’ll wait. The flight’s not that long.
Or Aeroflot. I had a a friend of mine, Alain, flying with Aeroflot. She was flying to Germany from, I think, that time, Kathmandu. So I used to fly to Russia and then into Europe. And she’d said on her phone she wanted vegetarian food.
And so the meals come around and these women are being in their flat many times. They’re always very blurred, very bland and very pale. And they come around and they they sort of strut. Know? They come down the you know, like this.
And they put you know? And they put the food down. And they flew around and looked at it, there was a huge steak, you know, big piece of weight on a on a plate. This woman, you don’t talk to them, and you don’t argue with them. You just get what you’re given.
But this lady, was quite vegetarian. She said, excuse me, but I did say vegetarian. What? You want vegetarian? Oh, yes.
Yes. Please. I really want vegetarian. Do you have vegetarian? Duh.
She took with her fingers, took the steak off the plate, and said, vegetarian. So, you know, the ticket’s cheap. The service isn’t so good. You’re happy and alive. Right?
So that’s the whole thing about, you know, when you reset your travel, you’re thinking about you’re not cheap, you’re uncomfortable, but you want to arrive, you want to make sure you get to the destination. So the thing about privacy is that you’ve got this continuity of teachings from two thousand six hundred years ago. And you’ve got extraordinary people, except for me, but you can see extraordinary people. They all be highly. So there’s extraordinary people who have realizations who show us that these teachings do actually produce change.
It’s not a fantasy. We’re not saying, oh, maybe it’s possible. We’re saying, absolutely, it’s possible to change. And I can tell you from my own experience, not that I’ve changed, but the people I’ve teach, they change. And this is very inspiring.
But when I have courses and I have people write and they say, I’m less angry. I have less aggression. I’m happier. They all see that if you take all the teachings, they do actually benefit you. So, in our own realm, we are talking about the stages of the path to enlightenment from the beginning to the end, all the teachings.
The very beginning is guru devotion. Westerners go, oh, you know you know, who writes a guru? This is just too much trouble. Could cause a lot of problems for me. But, actually, what it was saying is, you’re the correct guide.
You need the right travel agent. You know, if you’re going to get to destination enlightenment, then just like you need a travel agent who says, this is a good airline, and you get good food, and the seats are wide, and you get this leg room, and blah blah blah blah. Just like that, you need the same thing for Bodhicitta and enlightenment. So you need the correct teachings. If you’re not getting the correct teachings, then you’re gonna assign these idea of teachings.
So that’s why in the Buddhist tradition, the I tradition was very important, that these teachings are passed on from teacher to student. The way student becomes the teacher, and then they pass them on to somebody else. So I don’t have to tell you this, but for some reason, it’s coming out. I think it’s very important to make sure that teachers are authentic. Because if they’re not authentic, what we’re caught up with is somebody’s idea of authentic.
And there is no certainty. There’s not a hundred percent guarantee that you’re going to get what you want to get. Because as they’re testing, you’re going to test it. Because it’s somebody’s idea, and you’re testing it out. And if it doesn’t work, you get disappointed, you lose faith, you develop doubt, and then you have more and more problems in your spiritual life.
So I look at people like his holiness, the Dalai Lama. Fifty years of negotiating with the Chinese. He’s still there already. He’s still the splitist. He’s the biggest problem that they have.
If only all our allies were like the Dalai Lama. You know? But when all our allies like the Dalai Lama, we have no allies. We have people who are a problem in our life. So for the Choles, he’s the enemy.
He’s the problem. And he keeps saying love, compassion. Let’s work together. You know, he says, split est. Enemy, you are like this.
And he doesn’t come like I say, you’re the bigger. You’re you’re the biggest split est. He just has compassion and peace. Let’s work for the benefit of all sentient beings. So he’s a very good example of having an enemy, and then what keeps coming back from him is not retaliation, but waiting to create more peace and more harmony.
What would we do? You know, this is where I find destructive or disturbing emotions. What would we do if somebody at Weir kept saying, I really don’t like you. You’re splitist. And he said, well, what’s a splitist?
You’re trying to create problems in this office. You’re trying to divide us, aren’t you? You’re making trouble. He said, I’m out. I’m not.
I talk about love and compassion. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I love you.
You know? What would I do? Year after year after year, would I work with that person for fifty years continually saying love and compassion? I doubt it. I first say to people, imagine giving gifts to somebody on their birthday and at Christmas every year, and you’ll never get a gift back, and you’ll never get thank you.
How long would you give gifts? One year, two years, would it go on? It’s like, you know, you’re hoping it’s my birthday this year? No. No no gift.
No phone call. Christmas. You know it’s Christmas, don’t you? You know, here’s the gift. Nothing back.
What you can tell you to give? So actually in Buddhism, we are talking about unconditional love, unconditional compassion. And where it starts is with ourselves. Because if we can’t give it to ourselves, how are we going to give it to somebody else? So in order for us to remove the disturbing emotions, we need to recognize them as disturbing.
But we also need to have an idea of what’s not disturbing. Right? So do you think is disturbing? Some people don’t. Some people think anger is power.
Anger is good. You know? I feel strongly I’m angry. Yeah. And then I feel the bosses of companies now telling me they need to be angry.
So they go to the office at nine o’clock, and say, I’m telling you people do it. And they go, ah, you know, and they run. And I say, think, well, you know, that’s over a nice short term, but what it means is you’re gonna have to burn the disc larger and harder each time because in a begin, you could just burn a little bit, and people get shocked. Right? But the shock wears off.
So to have the same effect over time, you’re gonna have to bang louder and shout louder. And what is going to happen to you over time? You take tablets to go to sleep. You take tablets to wake up. You take take tablets to keep calm.
You start drinking. You become like male executives who are dropping down with heart attacks. Do you want to repeat that? There must be another way. Is anger the other way?
So these are the things that we’re investigating. You know, I hope we’re all following you on the weekend. So I hope that through discussions, because you will discuss with each other, you’ll have discussion groups, and you’ll be able to talk these things over. Because I very much do believe in just giving out information like okay. I cook the food for you, and then I’m going to chew it for you.
And then, actually, it’s gonna be difficult for me to stop swallowing it. Yeah? Because it’s so delicious, I want to eat it. So do I eat for you? You have to eat for yourselves.
Right? In order for you to change your life, you have to personalize this. You have to listen, but then you have to think, so what am I going to do with this? How am I going to use this? So in order for that to happen, you need to be able to discuss amongst yourselves.
And you need to be able to say, we don’t understand it, or we don’t get it. We don’t understand how we’re going to put it into practice. And so we need to have that ability to be able to talk honestly. Not to say, oh, know, you’re so incredible. You explained it so well.
I get it. And you you have that puzzled look on your face. What’s the point? We just waste our time. Right?
So you have to be able to say, I don’t get it. So I hope that we can have that sort of honesty that between us, we can work on your destructive emotions. And that you’ll get a little enthusiasm for the positive emotions because there are positive emotions. When you become a Buddha, you don’t become erasureless. Oh, whatever.
You know? Like, if you’re fourteen these days. Whatever. I want you to clean your room. Whatever.
You know? Take the garbage out. Whatever. So this is the lottery, isn’t it? Whatever.
So, what do know about whatever? That terrible sufferer. Oh, whatever. You know? Africa, India, oh, whatever.
The other is, oh, whatever. You know? That’s not compassion. We have to engage. But if we only have compassion or we don’t have wisdom, we’re engaging but with only emotion.
You know? It’s like you’re gonna stab to a heart with the compassion. The compassion is really getting you up. It squares your heart. Without the wisdom, it’s only emotion.
So we’re going to have the balance of wisdom and emotion, the compassion, the love. We need the balance of the two. So before we can talk about wisdom and compassion, we have to go back further. What’s underlying? Where we are right now or what we’re experiencing right now?
It’s the disturbing emotions. If things go wrong, the disturbing emotions appear. Right? We can be pleasant as long as everything’s going along my way. As long as I have control over the switch on air conditioning, I’ll be happy, you know?
If I want it on twenty five, I’ll be happy. But the person who wants it on twenty seven and the person wants it on twenty three, we’ll be happy. My mother used to like the house like a hot house. You know? She was some sort of hot house creature, and she used to have we had a boiler with coal, you know, one of these old boilers, and she used to go out and pile the coal, and she used to have the the boiler sort of shaken.
You know? And the pipes were sort of rocking with the heat. I’d have the other windows open. You know? I used to sleep with the window wide open.
I would sort of be sweating a little of water. And I would have this belly going, you know, like this. And I’d gradually turn the dial down, you know, because I thought she’ll have a notice. So gradually, I’d go out, you know, I’d go to the bathroom one degree more less, one degree less. She had only, like, thirty degrees in the water.
So I’d gradually down, down, down, you know, like twenty three degrees or something. And she’d be sitting there, you know, like this. And she’s, I don’t know what to do with this. Know, it’s freezing cold over here. I’m also So, yeah, like that.
You can see that the the dial well, we’re our temperature. But the cars now, you have, if it’s an expensive car, this side and this side have individual heating. If you buy a Mercedes, they have individual heating on both sides. And you have hot seats. I was in Helsinki, and I got into a friend’s car, and my bum was getting really hot.
Now I I said I I was getting really uncomfortable, and I was thinking, you know, maybe I’ve got a a fever or something. I feel really hot. And I said to her, I don’t know if I should say this to you because it was a fairly new car. It was a Volvo. I said, I don’t know if I should say this to you, but I think there’s something wrong with this seat because it’s either the seat or it’s low because it gets you hotter and hotter.
And she said, I’ve never heard of heated seats. I mean, you go to elevation. You feel like you’re chicken on a on a spit or something. You know? Nowadays, we want all our pleasure, all our comforts, everything sorted out, don’t we?
But what that means is when problems happen, we’ll always have the resilience to be able to respond with love and compassion. And I think this could be frustrating in Buddhism because we’re always talking about love and compassion and wisdom. You know? And it’s like the destination, but where we actually are is dealing with anger, jealousy, hatred, irritability. This is the actual place where we are.
So then how do we change? How do we transform? How do we take our present situation and turn it into something much better and eventually something extraordinary? So if I say, how do we go from ordinary to extraordinary? Because what would you rather be?
Do you want to be ordinary? And ordinary is experiencing the delusions, the negative emotions. Or do you want to become extraordinary, which is even in very difficult situations, you’re still responding with loving-kindness and with compassion? So, yes, we have this ideal of love and compassion, but we have to deal with where we are, the imprints, the seeds of the negative emotions because otherwise, that becomes the automatic response. If we have the automatic response of irritability, anger, then we can’t just switch it off.
We can’t just say, stop. Because when I go to Buddhist teachers, I can’t be angry anymore. So just stop, you know, like a switch. That’s a suppression of negative emotions. And if you suppress negative emotions, sooner or later, they will reappear and in a very horrible way.
My mother used to say the the straw that breaks the camel’s back. I don’t know if you still have these sayings, but whatever fall and wake up, you know, happens to people in Nepal and India because they they ought to be nice people. You know? And I know Paul, Kathmandu particularly, it’s rickshaws that drive you mad. You want a rickshaw?
No, thank you. You want a rickshaw? No, thank you. And I keep asking, you know, different people, you want a rickshaw? You want a rickshaw?
You want a rickshaw? Or about drugs? You want drugs? You know? And it keeps happening over and over.
And at the end, people go completely berserk. Leave me alone. Know, I’m screwed. And then they come to Buddhist courses and say, I don’t know what happened. I’m the last person at home.
When I’m in Australia, I’m under control. I say, yeah, do have people asking me every five minutes. Do you want a rickshaw? No. I don’t get hassled like this in Australia.
Yeah. But in that country, this is their livelihood. You’re an ATM machine. You’re a walking cash machine because you’re Western. And so they have to keep asking you, do you wear something?
And they say, but you don’t get hassled, do you? I said, oh, of course I do. When I go down to Kathmandu wearing robes, they will say to me, psst, want drugs? And I say, no, thank you. Look at me.
Yeah. Because they they aren’t looking at you. You’re just a little westerner. And then look at me. And they look at me, you know, up or down, and they say, oh, sorry.
You’re a monk. You can’t get upset. That’s their life. That’s their mind, you know? So it shows you their delusion that the way they’re looking at you.
So if you see a rogue, the one must see the prostitute. If you see a lonely person, well, who’s not alone, drugs or rickshaw. This is part of the delusion cycle. So the more delusions you have, the the delusion leads to another one. And delusions ripen previous negative actions.
So what’s important to know is that you can have countless negative actions within your mindstream, countless negative actions which we call karma. Okay? For those of you who haven’t heard Buddhist teachings before, we do an action. We create what we call karma. And this is a potential.
It’s a seed that you’re planting in your garden. So if the seed is negative, you got angry and you said something negative. You’re the ugliest person I ever met in my life. You planted seeds that are negative. So you have two things.
You have the action, which is what we call karma. And it’s maybe better to leave it as the word karma because karma means more than just action. But in in a western way, we understand cause and effect. karma actually only means cause. It just means seed.
But cause and effect, because you’re planting a cause, you’re going to either experience that cause or you’re going to have to relieve it. There’s only two choices, relieve it or experience it. So this is like throwing a You know, if you want to take an Australian example, every time you do a negative action, you throw a ball ring. And that boomerang, result of it comes back. You experience what you created.
But it’s not just karma. It’s also with karma, there’s an emotion. An emotion is what moves you to do the action. Okay? Without the emotion, you might have the thought, but you won’t do anything about it.
You don’t move. It’s like thinking, I’d really like to go to Nepal, but there’s no feeling to go to Nepal. So therefore, you don’t book the ticket. You don’t actually go. There has to be a desire that you want to go.
Desire, attachment, grasping, whatever it is, attachment. Some emotion has moved you to go to Nepal. In a similar way, when you’re doing negative actions, there is always a negative emotion. So those two things are coming together. karma, action, planting of seeds, plus an emotion with that.
So if we’re completely removed oh my goodness. I feel there’s a message coming through from Buddha. Time for a drink. So if you only have action, the seeds, And in a motion, the seeds cannot ripen. The seeds are dormant until a motion, which is separate the water.
So the water or the self ripen the seeds. So the seeds will lay their dirt until you have the emotion, which then ripens the seeds. So the good thing is that if you can separate the action and the emotion, you will not experience the actual effect because you don’t have emotion. But we always have emotions. And the underlying emotion in Buddhism is ignorance, not understanding how things exist.
You know? My body exists. The friend attached to exists. We think like this. So I don’t want to get into emptiness and wisdom, but the underlying ignorance is always there, is always ever present.
You think I’m here, you think you’re here, and you think a real exists. Right? You think this is all true. And Buddha says, how do you know it’s true? How do you know you’re not sleeping dreaming that you’re here?
You say, because I’m awake. I heard you when you’re awake. You know? We’re sure, aren’t we, that we are awake. But what Buddhism likes to do is, shake your beliefs, your view of how it is.
It’s very important to have your view challenged. Because once we’ve settled down to a comfortable view, you’ve got your air conditioning, you’ve got your heating, and you’ve got your this and this and this. You have the comforts and the pleasures around us. We’ve got everything sorted out, but we’re not challenged. So Buddha’s ill definitely knows to challenge you.
It definitely knows to shake you and say, make sure that your view is a correct view. Because if it’s incorrect, based on your incorrect view, you are not seeing things in the right way. And because you’re not seeing things in the right way, you’re creating a negative karma, negative actions, and negative emotions. So what you’re doing is creating further causes of problems and suffering in the future. And his responsibility is this.
It’s not Buddha’s responsibility. It’s not society’s responsibility. It’s not my responsibility. I’m responsible for me. You’re responsible for you.
So we can’t think someone is to blame. You know, they’re to blame. Society is to blame. But in actual fact, the only person who can change you is you. And that’s why Buddha gave you all the tools.
Buddha said, I can’t change you. I can’t transform your life. I can only give you teachings so that you can transform yourself. So in that way, in that checking, you have to have a little bit of faith, I think. Because if you check for a lot of doubt, there will be void as more doubt.
So you might have some sense of maybe this works. Maybe it is real. Maybe it’s true. Because if you check-in from a sense of, no. I’m not sure about these people.
You know? Maybe they’re some sort of weird what do they call it? Sect. Not a sect. A cult.
Oh, yeah. Weird cult. Maybe they’re some sort of weird cult. And, you know, they’re gonna brainwash me, and I could turn into a good person. I could become more compassionate and loving, and there would my family say.
This is what we used to take in the seventies. You know, I’ve always watched us when we were riding circles at three o’clock in the morning, barrel drums. I just think, oh, I’m more than gonna shave my head and change my name. I’m what? I wear strange clothes.
Well, But I hope we used to really worry about the. A lot of the press come along, and they can really worry about the. So I think you have to have a sense of an. When you check it, you should check. Does this work for me?
But check from the from the point of being positive rather than from the point of being negative. Because those days, I think we can be cynical about things and we can think, you know, there’s something wrong with it and maybe you’re trying to get something out of me. But the way Buddha taught was to give you everything, was to give you all the keys to your own happiness, to relieve your own suffering. So that’s what we’re what we’re attempting to do here. So I think in our discussions and in our times when we’re asking questions, try not to begin the questions with but.
This doesn’t show something positive. But, blah blah blah. You know? I felt try to think, well, if I was putting this into practice, how? Which way?
You know? That’s the way to check. Oh, that’s valid. That’s the way that you should be checking. So what Buddha did was he challenged your view.
Not you particularly, but anybody that he was teaching. He changed the view and say, well, do you have a view that is producing complete happiness, total happiness? If you were completely totally happy, you wouldn’t be sitting here. You wouldn’t be wanting to know about disturbing emotions. Right?
So we’re not completely happy. We do have problems. And in those days, what we’re very concerned with is pleasure, which is actually not happiness. Right? Pleasure is temporary, and pleasure is an alleviation of suffering.
So that’s the first thing that you need to start thinking about. That we’re not totally happy, what we experience is pleasure, and then that pleasure goes away. And then what we experience again is the suffering that was always there, that was always pervasive. Okay? So we have the ability now this is the good news.
We have the ability to become enlightened, to be completely perfect because of our nature. Right? So we’re not negative by nature. We’re not bad by nature. We have the ability to become perfect because our mind has a nature, a potential within it of perfection.
The seed of perfection is there, if you like. But that seed needs to be nurtured and needs to be taken care of. So you need to do that on a daily basis, nurturing and taking care of that potential, pruning it when it’s necessary, you know, giving it water when it’s necessary. So So we need to be quite careful in the nurturing of our positive potential. So we have that potential, but surrounding it are those destructive emotions and those negative actions that we’ll do for a ridiculous time.
So what we keep coming up against is those habits of the disturbing emotions mixed up with the negative actions that we’ve done. And that’s what causes the suffering. That’s where the suffering comes from. Not our perfect potential, but from the negative actions and the destructive emotions surrounding that perfect potential. And the longer you do something, the more potential it becomes.
So for instance, if you get angry today and you repeat that anger later on the next day and the next day, the more habitual that anger becomes. The more we’re compassionate and loving, the more we can access that compassion and love. So it becomes a habit. It becomes our view. So what sort of view do we have of the world?
You know? Do we see it through irritable eyes, through jealous eyes, through angry eyes, or do I say it through loving compassionate eyes? And then sometimes we get anger, sometimes jealousy, sometimes hatred. So each one of us is experiencing our own problems in different degrees. Do you understand?
Who doesn’t? Who’s lost? Johanna put her hand up then. You can ask a question. Yes.
Well, that’s the wrong term because I what we’re going to do over this time because we’ve got, you know, this four weeks and then the weekend, I’m going to give you handouts about fear and anxiety. We’re going to talk about defining things because often they have the wrong word for the emotion. So anger is an exaggeration of something negative. Right? It’s an exaggeration.
So you take something, say cockroach. You know? In Mexico, this is a very popular example because they really don’t like cockroaches. I don’t know any country where people say whoopee cockroaches. So, you know, take a cockroach and put it in front of you.
It’s just a cockroach. It’s just a sentient being with the same potential that you have to become a Buddha. But we don’t think that. We think cockroach, dirty. You know?
Maybe I have to get I have to remove it from my kitchen, and then my kitchen will be clean. So you just have this object, and the mind exaggerates the desirability of the object. And if you exaggerate enough and you keep returning to that same exaggeration on that same object, doesn’t have to be that same cockroach. The cockroaches are bad, cockroaches are dirty, cockroaches are this, that, and the other. You keep adding to the story, the natural response, the automatic response becomes one of anger or irritability when we see the object.
I just interrupt you for a Yeah. I’m not sure you can, but you can try. I can try. I love my cockroaches. Discussion was whether one should get angry at this Rise.
Wrathful. Wrathful. Wrathful. I don’t know if you said anger because there’s another emotion which is wrathful. So there’s anger and wrathful.
And wrathful is the appearance of anger, but with compassion as the motivation. Yes. Yeah. It was totally compassion. Yeah.
The compassion was they wanted to prevent it. Yeah. So I felt in that example, his holiness was saying that there’s one way which would be you could get angry, which would be an exaggeration. It’s usually based on I, the sense of ego and self, and that self responds to that person’s action. As opposed to the other way, which would be wrathful, the total concern with the other person rather than oneself.
So anger is usually based on self. Wrathful is based on other, is based on compassion. And the motivation for wrathful is totally different from the motivation for anger. Anger is usually destructive. You know?
It’s never given as, something beneficial. It’s hard as, you know, maybe short term, you can get away with it, I think, to be angry about the environment or something like this. But if you keep continuing about anger, then because anger disturbs the world, you can’t have anger and compassion as opposed to wrathful. You can’t have anger and compassion or anger and love in the same mind. You can develop wrathful.
But but I also say to people, you have to be really careful that you don’t start cheating on yourself. You know? You go home and you get angry with their children. You know? And you start cheating at the children, and then you start afterwards, well, you know, wasn’t angry.
I was wrathful. You know? Because I’m a good person, and I only have your your benefit. I only want you to be happy. I think we can really bullshit ourselves and say, you know, oh, I’m really compassionate and I’m showing anger.
I think when we’re angry, right? Because we feel it down here. There’s a different feeling of tightness and power and strength coming up. Whereas with wrathful, you stay very calm. So you have a calmness, but what you’re shown is a different emotion.
It’s like these Japanese masks. Kabuki? Maybe kabuki? The wrathful deities. Yeah.
Yeah. It’s to show that we can manifest different emotions, but we’re we’re all up that emotion. Yeah. Yeah. The the ruffled deities.
Well, we have things like, you know, you have, a buffalo with holes and a bravil of fire and, you know, goodness gracious. What do Buddhists need this sort of painting for? But sometimes you add this sort of power and strength in order to change a situation, but without the anger. So can we be compassionately powerful? That’s very big.
Let’s use the word power instead of anger. Can we become passionately powerful in order to change the situation, in order to show, you know, this is not good enough. This must change. This must stop. I think at our level, we first need to deal with our anger.
We need to relieve the anger. Once we’ve removed the anger, then we’re on a way to relieving the self, the ego that experiences the anger. Because underlying that anger is I. I am angry. But is it anger?
Well, that’s the word that they used to. Yeah. But it but it but I think, you know, often when they’re trying to define things, they’re using orbital terminology for people to understand. Is it really anger in a Buddhist definition of an exaggeration, an exaggerated mind based on oneself? Usually, anger is about oneself.
Why would you be angry about somebody courteous suicide off a cliff? You would think. Right. That was wrathful. Well, that’s that’s a plain words.
No. It’s a diff it’s a definition of a different emotion. Anger is not compassionate. Anger is not compassionate. Anger is not love. The antidote to love is anger.
So if you tell me that you have anger about the person walking off the cliff, I’d say that why would you want to do something about that that person walking off the cliff because anger is the antidote to love. So how can I have animal love in that same time? Well, you wouldn’t. If you you’re just angry, you just say, I know I’m really angry about you walking off that cliff, and you’d let them walk off the cliff. Yeah.
Maybe. But but maybe if they see anger, they think it’s worth jumping. Yeah. But I, you know, I don’t like these things that are quoted, and then I haven’t actually if I had the quote in front of me, you could write it, and then I read it. But, you know, as I said, different people have different views and can also write things into this type of thing that accords with their own belief.
If you want to defend anger, then you go up against Buddha. You’ve got a big problem. You know? Because Buddha said earlier in most cases is extremely destructive. Maybe you can talk in one instance, it might be okay, or one instance, it might be okay.
But generally, if you’re talking about most cases, you would be better off relieving anger. And then so what can we replace it with? If you don’t have anger, what other emotion could you have that would produce change? This is where we need to go. Instead of holding onto anger, if we let go of anger, if we’re allowing anger, what would be an innovative force to produce change in these frustrating situations?
Because at the moment, we had the habit of accessing arrogance. We’re saying arrogance is the the one. Frightens me about anger? I don’t know if you read the Liberation Prison Project magazine. Every now and again, they produce a Liberation Prison Project magazine.
I read the interviews with people at death row. All of them killed. All of them murdered. And when they were doing meditation retreat, so they were honest. And they were asked, so why did you kill?
You know, Willam killed his wife and his children. So I just, you know, got a knife in the kitchen and stabbed them all to death. So I said, so why did you do that? And they said, because dinner was late. That’s anger.
You know? So when you defend anger, anger can reach the point where you can’t control the anger. And then you pick up the knife and kill because it says this is the cause of your happiness. Murder is the cause of your happiness based on anger. And then afterwards, when I ask, why?
You say, I don’t know. It just made me so angry, the only thing I could thought to do was kill. This is amazing. Incredible. When I read this, it’s incredible that the only cause of my happiness in that moment is killing or stealing or lying.
So how do we get this negative actions happen in our lives when we’re good people? You always say, we’re good people. This will never happen to you. Those people who murdered also said at one time, I’m a good person. I will never do that.
But because of irritability and anger over a period of time, it builds into a habit that then becomes your operating system. At one stage, one point, you will not be able to control it because so many causes and conditions come together. You feel you’re really tired. You’re hungry. Your boss has just sacked you.
Several things have gone wrong. The luggage is due. You’ve got no money. The children are crying. Your wife’s sick.
And I got home and I say, why is Dylan? And she said, well, why don’t you cook it? You know? And I go, you know, like this. And I said, like, psycho.
You know? And I thought, I would never do something like that. You watch these horror movies, and you think, I’d never do something like that. But when we have the habit of anger, it becomes possible. And that’s what Buddha said.
One moment of anger, not repeated, or a few moments of anger, in response to somebody doing something that seems irrational like fatal suicide. Okay. But if you kept repeating that same order over and over, you’re building these into a very powerful habit. How many people have you encountered about to commit suicide? Sorry.
How many people have you actually encountered about to commit suicide? No. That’s going well. How many people have I Yeah. Have you actually lies on on the edge of a cliff about to throw themselves off?
No. You have. Have. So you need to be realistic when you’re talking about all the emotions. Right?
It’s like people who say, but what happens when you’re on a plane and there’s a guy with a girl and he’s about to hijack the plane? Or what I I happen to have a girl and I happen to be the only one who can stop him from hijacking the plane. Should I kill him? Now, this is like fantasy world. If you talk about not taking your library book back or not paying your bus fare, this is more where we’re at.
If you talk about extraordinary things, which need extraordinary emotions, then you’re out of the realm of what we’re talking about. You’re talking about something extraordinary. In an extraordinary situation, what should you do? Allow yourself to train your mind so that in any situation, you can access the emotion that is necessary for that time. If anger is what you determine to be the best response, you’re angry.
That is not a problem. It’s not an exaggeration. In that time, it’s an appropriate emotion as a response where being very calm, very compassionate, and very kind could also be the response. It’s not an automatic response. It’s not I say somebody on the edge of the cliff, automatically I’m angry.
It’s in response to the individual, the situation, I give a response. That’s that’s Western. But you didn’t say that. Yeah. But that’s that’s but to for everybody to understand because we need to be really careful when we say, fear of mental anger is okay.
We’ve always said this. How many people in this room have problems with anger? Come on. Put your hands up. Right.
They have problems with anger. So we don’t need to defend anger. What we’ll need to do is get our anger under control, and then we can access anger as one of our potential emotions in different situations, isn’t it? Not just automatically unagree. So that’s where Buddha get where Buddha takes you.
He charges all these negative emotions, and then says, but actually, they’re not negative. At the moment, we need to say anger is negative. It’s destructive. Because if you don’t draw a line, then you just say that everything’s okay. Elations?
Whatever. You know? You can do anything. Whatever. It’s okay.
But, actually, Buddha drew the line and said, those emotions are destructive. Those emotions are helpful. Then my take and say, emotions are just energy. There is no problem with anger. In the tantric system, there’s no problem with anger at all.
We have yamantaka. We have the the ball the buffalo and the breathing fire, and it has just an energy. But at the moment, if we have a pattern of anger, you see the potential of it becoming uncontrolled, that’s when you need to do something about it. Why? Because you’re going to harm others.
And if you’re harming others, it can only harm yourself. So in the beginning, control your emotions in order to benefit others. Then you will have your emotions under control. Then you can start to work with using these emotions in order to benefit others. Any other questions?
Yeah. Well, very much you you feel when you’re angry that the self exists, doesn’t it? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
I’m a good person. Yeah. Yeah. Well, when I was thinking about this class, I thought, you know, we need to do some meditation because if we don’t meditate, we don’t become aware of the mind. And when we’re not aware of the mind, we’re not aware of what we’re producing from the basis, you know, what’s coming up from the mind.
We we I think I definitely have a stronger sense of I than Asians, you know, than, say, the Tibetans. But now that Tibetans have left Tibet and were growing up in India, they’re also developing a very strong sense of self. You know, I want an iPhone. I want I want I want, you know. We develop this sense of I around what we want, isn’t it?
You know, what we buy, where we live, the relationships we have, tell to a real force who are what we think we are. You know? So we’re friends with the people who are real force what I believe about myself. I’m a good person. Yes.
You’re a good person. I like you. You know? Like that. So, you know, that way, good friends are like a are, aren’t they?
They’re like a reflection. Well, everything you’re experiencing is written by your karma. Right? Then I think the difficulty is when we’re talking about self, then we start to think there’s there’s like a little person inside, you know, with a control room, and there’s a self, you know, pushing the buttons and pulling the levers. And there’s not that self, But we feel there is a self.
I think particularly when you have these destructive emotions and you feel, I am really angry. You know? This self righteous anger. I remember once in in India, the next door neighbor was about to cut down a tree, and I became real upset about this tree being cut down. And I very much felt this sense of, oh, I didn’t want the tree cut down.
It wasn’t don’t cut the tray, it was I don’t want the tree cut. And when you feel the sense of I, you’ve now got a double confusion. So you’ve got an I that doesn’t exist, but we think it exists. And then I’ve got the illusion, the anger, which is not going to connect me with you. So I’m not going to be able to negotiate and talk to you about the tree.
I’m going to distance myself from you because I’m exaggerating you as the enemy. And that’s what anger does. Generally, it says you’re the enemy, you know, cockroach, rat, spider, next door neighbor who mows the lawn at six o’clock in the morning, personally having had a party at three o’clock in the morning, enemy. And not only are you the enemy, you you have LMOS, Like Lochless, but it’s LMOS. You exist truly, independently, inherently as the enemy.
Not from your side, not from my projection, but from your side. And that’s what Buddha says is untrue. And so what we’re doing is we’re looking at things from two views now. Not just one view, my view, but we’re trying to look at it from a different point of view. Does the enemy really exist on the outside?
Can we find an enemy? But but we actually think it’s true. We actually think an enemy does exist. Right. No.
No. That’s right. So what your lad is doing is from previous negative karma and delusion, feeling of anger, irritability, jealousy, whatever it is, that emotion takes that previous negative karma, projects itself over to the person I see as the enemy, and then I see it in about way. And then when the anger dissipates, the enemy disappears. And then I have to come back with the story.
Well, you know, I really don’t like that n that enemy, that neighbor because blah blah blah blah. And then we have to coerce ourselves back into the view. This is the enemy. This is the person I don’t like. And they don’t exist from my side.
They exist from their side, which is untrue. This is what Buddha said. When I see the enemy, if I have wisdom, a glimmer of wisdom, can say, stop. Is there really an enemy there? Where is the enemy coming from?
Is it coming from me or them? If we could do that at the time where it starts to become become emotional, it takes away the ignorance, the confusion that we’re creating from our mind. But in actual fact, we don’t stop. We add more stories, You know? And then this and then this and then this.
And so what we’re doing is, karmically, we’re creating an enemy, which is now going to create suffering for me. Because when I have an enemy and I think enemy, I think I really don’t like that person. And automatically, I can get angry, have hatred. Right? Because I’m writing a story in my mind.
And then I hear that enemy just won the lottery. Twenty million dollars. And then, you know, I hate that. I hate him so much. Why did he win the lottery?
It’s not fair. I don’t know who I am, but it’s not fair. He’s such a bad person. So horrible because he mows the lawn at six o’clock in the morning. You know?
Or because he whistles when he goes past my house. Or because he looks at my flowers. You know? How dare I look at my flowers? We have this sense of, yeah, it’s my flowers.
It’s mine, my house, my dog, my place. And so that sense of ego is reinforcing itself in our environment. And when people come up against that, there’s that sense of I which responds to their in the way of anger, hatred. And so what that does is it reinforces our suffering because that suffering comes back to us again. You know, I respond I respond to my world in a suffering way, and then it comes back.
And so what we say is we don’t want suffering, but we’re we’re actually creating more and more suffering. You? Draw a theme. Draw a theme. Theme.
Realize there is no separation between self and other? In what steps do you take to get Well, by recognizing there is a self and there is another, instead of being asleep, you know, just responding, I don’t like you. You know, like that. So, there’s just a response, but where is the response coming from? So they will start to find the self.
And then if there’s a self, then there’s another. Right? So then you start to recognize, oh, there is a duality. So who’s creating the duality? Is it me?
Is it you? Maybe both of us. Is it society? Right? Right.
But what you’re doing is you’re building on your dharma experience to the point where you recognize that that self actually doesn’t exist. But first you need to realize the self exists. You know? You sort of because when we, era began, you know, when we enter dharma and we talk about ego, self, you know, this sort of thing. I think it’s an intellectual exercise.
You know, we’re just we’re just talking about it. I’m talking about you rather than talking about me. Like I said, people just make extraordinary things. You know, I’m on the plane with the gun. I I said, well, I wanted to get a gun on the plane.
And then we’re just stressed out. I know I I try that a lot. I could have made an appeal through this machine. But, you know, you got you got this gun that’s run this machine, and they’re telling me all these extraordinary stories. And I tell you sort of like a big made up story, and I say, stop.
Let’s talk about something that’s very basic. You know? Let’s let’s get real with our dharma. So in the beginning, I think it’s a little bit of a fantasy. I always start to become aware of what we’re really talking about, which is me.
And so who’s the controller? Are others the controller of my emotions or me? What I would rather say is you. You’re to blame. Right?
Because it’s easier to say you are to blame for my anger than to say I’m to blame, that I need to change myself. The problem with the thought transformation teachings is it’s not you to blame, it’s me. And he’s like, but hang on. There must be somebody to blame. You know, give me a break.
Just give me a little out. There is one little enemy somewhere, isn’t there? It’s my mother or my father or my boss, but there must be somebody who really exists as an irritable being. No. It’s all about me.
And so I think this is hard because it keeps coming back to I’m responsible. Only me. Right? So in the beginning, it’s like a fantasy. And then it becomes more realistic.
And then I start working with it and saying, so who’s responsible? Oh, I’m responsible. I’ll say, but this guy. Now I found an I that’s responsible. Right?
So now does that I really exist? Then we go into the duality, nonduality, which is why I must admit it at the end of all the teachings. Is that at the very end, when you have developed this love and this compassion based on me and you, then it says, and by the way, there is no me and there is no you. There’s only love and there’s only compassion, but no me, no you. Just love and compassion with emptiness.
You know? So I think our job as ordinary beings is we need to develop positive self esteem. We need to find that feeling of I can do it. You know? I can change.
I can remove my negative emotions, and I can develop positive emotions. And there is that strong sense of I able to do it. Don’t start too early with taking away the I. Because if you do, you end up with no no false. You know?
There’s no sense of I loving you to do something. So it’s like, if you say this is the I, you know? There’s my I. So it’s something tangible. For me to remove this from this room, I need to first void it.
Right? So in order to remove the I, first, we need to void it, and then we need to remove it. And what’s left is the positive emotions moving you in the right direction doing the right actions. But in the beginning, you need to be able to say, this is harmful. This is positive.
This is destructive. This is me. This is you. This is others, etcetera, etcetera, etcetera. And this establishes self I.
And then you start to say, but where is that I? How does that I exist? And then you think, my goodness. I thought it was there, but now I can’t find it. But you made an incredible amount of merit of good karma in order to have that realization.
And the realization doesn’t come unless you have with unless you have compassion. Right. Right. It’s you take away the self, and then there’s only action to remove the suffering without the I doing it. Right?
So it would be mother Teresa, you know, when she sees somebody lying on the street, she doesn’t think, now I’ve picked up fourteen today. You know? Maybe that’s enough. What mother Teresa think? It’s enough.
If you think of who and what she was, you know, how she lived her life. And what she think, I am picking up this person, or would she just think, person suffering, pick them up. That’s where you get the raw compassion. You know? Suffering being, I have the ability to help, pick them up.
And that’s what was saying about the suicide or the whatever situation you’re in. If you remove the I, you’ll have a whole range of emotions that you use in order to benefit others. Not from a point of view of I, but from a point of view of them. They’ll need help. And so I have this repertoire of emotions that I will use in order to benefit them.
Question. You should ask is what emotion you guys have them and them. Them. Yes. Because if it’s about me, it’s self-cherishing.
It’s coming from ignorance. With self-cherishing, the self-cherishing comes from self grasping. We’re grasping onto something. I exist. And as long as I exist, there’s a separation between me and you.
Right? And in order for me to feel your pain and your suffering, I need to dissolve that separation between me and you. Right? There needs to be a non duality instead of a duality. And so how do I dissolve that?
Not by immediately, you know, in a first class, you dissolve the ego and then you say, okay, nothing exists. And so who’s going to develop compassion? Who’s going to remove the anger? So my experience of Westerners is we need to first develop our positive self esteem. Our positive ego.
And then, we like to start working on the negative ego, the one that wants to harm, wants to hurt, or has negative thoughts. And then, we will have all of it. The negative, the positive ego, and all that’s left is the action, the loving action, the kind action, the compassionate action, the movement to remove the suffering. Not because it’s important for me, because it’s important for you. Then it’s unconditional love, unconditional compassion.
Conditional is, I did this for you, and now what are you gonna do for me? Isn’t it? You know, it’s Christmas. Christmas is coming, people. You know?
It’s definitely conditional. Right? I often give the example of you’re clutching your credit card. You are thinking, I’ve already I’m close to the limit, but I really want to buy a nice present for my friend. Right?
So how much can I spend now that I can go to the limit? Four hundred dollars. Anyway, it you know, I can pay it off over twenty years. The interest rate’s under twenty percent. It’ll be okay.
And so I clutch out my credit card. You go to the shops and you’re searching and searching and you buy the perfect gift for your friend. Now if it’s unconditional, you wrap it up, you give it to them, and they do say thank you, and they’ll never mention it ever again, ever sit in the house, no problem. If it’s conditional, you say, well, did you like it? Like what?
You know, the gift I gave you. Gift? You gave me a gift? Well and the real experience of Lama Zopa in the early days was you gave things to Lama Zopa, and the next person out the door was carrying your gift. This is a bit shocking.
You know, I just gave it and now there it goes. I never said thank you. You know? So, you know, if it’s something, you know, and you cut her and you talk and So isn’t that strange? We give a gift and we’re still possessing the gift.
Don’t think about that, that I gave it but actually I didn’t give it because it’s still me. My only gift is going to do. You know? I remember what this Lama Zopa said to me. I gave him a Tsa Tsa, a Buddha image made in clay, and he said to me, oh, he always asks the strangest of questions.
See, and they don’t have the answer. So he’s looking at this with fascination, you know, not the image, but the clay. It’s in Bodh Gaya. Right? So he’s looking at me and he said, oh, wow.
Where does this clay come from? I said, well, I don’t know. I just bought it at the local shop. And I said, this clay is really good. It would be very good if I could have this clay.
Oh, okay. It’s so good if I could have this clay. Oh, okay. So what do I do? I go all over Bodh Gaya, I had to bring another tsa tsa and showing it, you know.
Do know where this clay comes from? No idea. Shop after shop after shop after shop. No idea. So then, that same day when Rinpoche had said, oh, it’s so beautiful.
This clay, you know, blah blah blah. So I sat outside thinking, now where can I go to find out about this clay? And the next person coming out was carrying that Tsa Tsa. He liked it so much. More feeling of attachment.
The worst appropriate thing he could give to that next person was that thing that he had. No sense of mind, no sense of attachment, but this is beneficial for them, and he gives it, and it’s gone. Right? So could we do that? Do we have a sense of our possessions, our money, our house, our dog, our cat, our family, whatever it is?
We’re doing meditations on Buddhist courses where I say to people, you have your wallet and your money and your passport, And right now, it’s hidden in your underwear drawer, you know, where you think nobody’s gonna find it. Yeah. And somebody has just broken a lock on the door of your room, Royal India, where you don’t want to lose your passport. And they’re going through your underwear, which you don’t want anybody to touch. Right?
And they found your wallet, and they’re stealing all your money and your passport. And how do you feel? And people in the in the meditation is go, and so they get out of this, go back to the room and just check that everything is still there. So just you start to motion, you could lose your money and your passport, people start to panic. That’s how much we have an I attached to our possessions.
Right? And from that perspective, their emotions appear, don’t they? Because it’s my cup, my watch, my this, my this, my this. So we very much feel there is an I, a possessor. And that when we’re trying to find that possessor, that I that seems to exist, my watch, my eye, what is it?
And that we’re sure it exists. So this is the strange part about it. If we don’t think about it, we have ignorance. Ignorance is not understanding. Why don’t we understand?
Not because we’re stupid, because we never think about it. We just say, my watch, my car, my family, my house. But if we challenge it and we say, yeah, but not where’s the house or where’s the car, but where’s the I that possesses? Then once you challenge it, you start to think, that’s true. So where is it?
Are you getting angry? Are you upset? I’m irritable. You can’t say when a lorry hits your car. I’m irritable.
You very much feel that I is irritable. If you challenged it, then you’d start to say, but I’m not sure there is an I that’s irritable. Does it really exist? That is the beginning of the erosion of of a belief in something that doesn’t really exist. This is incredible.
From the beginning of this time, I believed an I exists, and yet, it never has existed, it never would exist, And that every single day, we use this so much I, me, mine. Every single day in relation to I, we have all these emotions, and then we have possessions. My body. Right? So when we die, is my body going off me?
Am I taking my body? So we have to leave the body behind. So the light is leaving. If there’s an I, there’s a way it’s that I that’s leaving. So it brings up more interesting questions.
So if it was time when you feel emotional, if you can just stop and say, hang on. If you and I drove out a car, Is it an eye getting angry? Is it a compassionate eye? Now the compassionate eye doesn’t cause a problem. If you’re working with compassion, it doesn’t cause a problem for others.
But the irritable, the angry, the the negative eye, that I causes a problem. So that’s why we say in the beginning, reduce the negative, improve the positive, and how to worry about what’s negative and positive because the negative produces harm. It doesn’t benefit others, and it doesn’t benefit the self. It does harm to others, and it does harm to the self so that we can say generally, these things are negative. So, you know, usually, we say killing, stealing, lying.
Are they negative or positive? So let’s say generally, in a society, we don’t kill because we don’t want to all be walking around sort of looking behind us. We don’t want to live life as a game, and actually live in a society where people are killing constantly or stealing constantly or lying constantly. So that’s why generally you say it’s not beneficial in society. But there are cases where it is beneficial.
Yeah. You’re lost. Yeah. Barely labeled me and only labeled you. I know how you do.
You should understand this very well. You have Ātman. What’s the definition of Ātman? Well, I think Ātman is yourself. Is it?
Your connection with God. Is that? Right. Yes. Yes.
So Buddhism goes one step further than that, and then he says, so that self that you thought existed, Does it it there is something existent. You see, once we start talking about this, I think there there’s always, a danger of confusion. When we talk about, wisdom or emptiness, the word empty starts to indicate, something like a roar. Are the people around or not? If there’s nobody around, the world is empty.
So without us, we’re not saying something like a container exists. We’re saying, do you have a person on a seat listening? This is you. A person on a seat listening. If we say there’s nothing there at all, you don’t exist at all, then put me on a straight jacket, and you take me away because this is a bit low.
Right? Because you you do exist. So we don’t say that existent. It’s an existent in a certain way. So in a conventional sense, you can say male, female, good, bad, high, low.
It’s unrelential to things, is it? It’s relative truth, conventional truth. So we can say red, blue, green. These are labels. And we have to be able to have labels because if we don’t have labels, we have to describe everything every time we want to do something.
So correlations have labels. Cup, water, tea, Rome, people. Right? But then, the other side of it, the untold truth, does it really exist without causes and conditions? So why it’s important to look for causes and conditions is, do you have suffering?
Do you have problems? Is there anybody with no suffering, no problems? I’m looking for the miracle baby. Anybody with no suffering, no problems. We all have suffering problems.
Right? So where Bob went wasn’t wasn’t to what created the cosmos. So, you know what? He didn’t wanna talk about that. What he wanted to talk about is the human situation.
Us, me, you. Aren’t you suffering? And if you are, if you accept that you are suffering, where are you suffering? Who’s creating that suffering? Is it coming from outside or inside?
And if it’s coming from inside, why and how? Which way? Who is creating that suffering? What’s creating the suffering? So suffering, must be something like poison.
Now if you draw poison, you get a lot of pain or you die. You create suffering. So suffering, the cause of suffering must be something like poison. Poisonous seeds. Who’s planting all seeds?
I am. Why am I planting all the seeds? Because in the past, I’ve done it before. Now I’ve got this habit of doing it, and there’s an emotion involved with it. So it’s not just planting your seeds, and how can I plant your seeds?
Why are they planting your seeds? There’s an emotion associated with it. So then on the ultimate level of understanding, it’s your actual self, an independent self. We need to be very careful in the terminology, I think. Independent, inherent unchanging self.
Now I think, Christianity would say, yes. The soul is created. Right? And it’s independent. There may be a Hinduism too.
They have soul. Isn’t it? I think a whole level of Hinduism, they they have soul. Yeah. But at at the older level, in some teachings, they have instead of Buddhism, we have different levels of teachings.
So some say, yes. This exists, and the later teachers say, no. It doesn’t exist. So if you’re looking at the ordinary level, does it exist? Is there an independent self that’s going angry, like a little person inside?
We would say, no. But there’s a label on the base. I am getting angry. Can you find that I? Is it somewhere within your aggregates?
Can’t find it. And yet, I feel it’s true. It exists. So that’s why we have the conventional and ultimate truth. Yes.
There’s somebody sitting on the cushion listening, but when we try to look for that I listening, can’t find it. Is that clearer? Yes. There’s an eye on the cushion, but when I look for it, the conventional I, but when I look for it, can’t find it. So the what is important is the I explains a a negative emotion.
I am getting angry. Well, find it. Well, the doctors aren’t clever enough either because they’ve done many autopsies, and they have never found a dollop of I. Right? Is the brain the eye?
Is the heart the eye? Where is this actual I that we think gets angry, has hatred? Well, from a Buddhist side, it doesn’t exist. Two thousand six hundred years doesn’t exist. Never existed.
There is not a lie. Never existed, will not exist, cannot be found. This is, the Buddha’s teaching. So this is very difficult because we’re very much feel I exist. Yeah?
There’s there is an I on the cushion. And the Buddha said, yes. I agree with that. No problem with that. I walk.
I talk. I cook. I sleep. No problem with that. But this eye getting angry, now we have a problem.
Why do you want to defend that eye? Why do you want to hold on and maintain that eye? Because that eye is destructive. That eye is going to cause trouble for you and for others. So that eye, we have to investigate.
But the other one, the conventional eye just doing ordinary things, whether you have a problem. You know? Eye listening, not causing a problem. Eyewitnessing, not causing a problem. But when this I has, the ownership of a negative emotion, then we have a problem.
So that time we need to start looking with wisdom. Does that I exist? It’s a continuation. It’s like drops of water make a river. Which drop of water is the river?
You say all of the drops. Right? So all of the the experiences that we have, we think of as I. But which experience is actually me? Am I the anger moment?
Am I the patient moment? Am I the loving moment? Am I the compassionate moment? Are all of those moments I label I? Right?
It’s all of the moments. Then we say I, but it’s not any one of those moments. I’m not I. I’m not angry I all the time, or I have compassionate I all the time. I have different moments of different emotions.
And when I say I is labeled on all of those all of those moments, like all the drops of water make the river. But, hopefully, this has gone too far. Okay. Any other questions? I got one.
Why not? I remember in the last teachings that you gave us, you gave us some homework. And the homework was someone cuts you off in the road. You, you know, on the first day you offer them, okay, may you have relief from suffering. The second day was it made you find happiness.
I’ve done that. Okay? And now I’ve got two two ways that actually it helps me relieve negative emotions. Yeah. The first way is to understand we’re all interconnected as we all understand.
Right. And that person’s actually me. Now why would I book name? Why would I cut off my nose to spite my face? That person is me.
Yeah. That person may why would I hate him? Yeah. That’s part of me. Yeah.
Because everyone’s interconnected. Yeah. However, there’s another thing that seems seems to work, and it’s based on psychology where where if I’m angry at that person cutting me off Yeah. It’s because I have feelings, and and feelings cause so much anxiety. I can’t take ownership of it.
Ah. And then I’ve transferred my hatred Oh, I see. Yes. Yes. You project it.
Yes. Yes. And then I’ve then it’s become projective identification. Yes. Now if I found that if I actually go and say to myself, I’m just projecting my feelings because it’s too uncomfortable to own.
Yes. My feelings don’t so much. Yes. The feelings aren’t gonna kill me. And if I take ownership of emotions, it’s it’s self soothes.
No. No. Time. You know, is the Freudian way of doing things incorrect, or can I do them both? I think within the Lamrim, you have the ability of saying, yes, I’m projecting onto the other person.
So, oh, feelings. There’s an I who’s getting angry. Like I said before about establishing this I found the I, you know? So you can’t negate it if you don’t find it. So you have to find a method to deal with the emotions.
Is it that we’re interconnected? I want you to be happy, you know, not to suffer. Is it that way? Or is it saying that I’m projecting the emotion onto the other person because I don’t want to own the emotion? So, actually, in Buddhism, you want to own the emotion.
So it’s good to see that you’re projecting the emotion onto the other person, but to come back to me, I projected the emotion, and it was from an eye. You know? And it’s a negative eye. And then later on in the teachings, then they will remove the I. You know?
But I think at this stage when we have emotions, it’s very good to see there’s an I projecting the emotions. So you do it step by step. You know? In analytical meditation, you see there’s a projector. There’s got to be a film running through the projector.
The film has to have images on it, which means karma, and then it has to be a screen on which it’s projected. So you’ve got the projector, you’ve got the film, you’ve got the electricity, the light, you’ve got the the scroll. If you play with any of those conditions, the image can disappear. Take away the screen, there’s no image. Or take away the electricity, there’s no image.
Take away the film, there’s no image. So it doesn’t matter which way you go at it, but go at it. You know? Don’t just sit back and say, oh, well, it’s okay. You know, you’re driving an automobile.
Oh, well, What to do? Deviate from it in some way. So what you’re doing is actually analyzing your mind in relation to irritability and finding something that works for you. Doesn’t matter where it comes from. What matters is you’re changing.
That means you’re you’re a dharma practitioner. So that’s okay for the moment, but that Sure. Change too. Sure. Good.
Everything is impermanent. Yes. So, yeah, you can’t let your to to one way as being their way. At the moment, that one way works for you. But then that one way may become a problem in itself, and then you need another way.
And this is this development of mind is that over time, you need different methods to develop the mind into into its perfection. But this is great, you know, to to look at the irritability and think, gosh, you know I’m sorry. I have to go back to the cockroach. He tried to get me off it, but I’m back on it. Yeah.
If you’ve got that cockroach in front of you, you can transfer all your anger and your hatred onto the cockroach and you’re feeling this is dirty. Right? But is it really dirty? It’s not. There’s no scientific proof at all that a cockroach is dirty.
In fact, they’re supposed to only inhabit clean kitchens. But it’s not what we think. And from a Buddhist perspective, we say, so why do we have such a strong negative emotion to cockroaches? Spiders, scorpions? Why?
Because they have such negative karma that they’ve created a form that generally we dislike. It’s interesting to think that a being creates a form from negative actions that then makes us experience generally dislike because of its negative actions. It has a black form that we find we don’t like. So then we we have this projection onto the object. Oh, I don’t I don’t like that.
But if you say, who’s who’s not liking that? What am I projecting from myself onto the object? I am projecting hatred, anger, aversion, and then that’s gonna come back on me. Imagine if I was being treated like that, not from the cockroach’s perspective, but somebody treats me with anger and aversion. Would I like it?
So, you know, what goes around comes around. You throw the ball around, and it comes back to you. Is this how you want to live your life? So this sense of ownership of your emotions gives you the ability to see that what you’re putting out is what you’re getting back. And what that, creature that we’re seeing in an undesirable way is experiencing is the result of its negative karma.
People seeing it and immediately hating it. So that’s not the life that we want to experience. If you look at somebody, allegedly, you dislike them or somebody nearly hits your car and, allegedly, you’re angry, is that the life that you want to experience in the future? So in order to not experience that, you are to own it. They’re not the cause of it.
I’m the cause of it. And this is the difficult part because we’re willing to believe there’s a bad driver. Right? Easier is to say, that’s a bad driver. Should get a license.
Don’t know where he learned to drive. You know? Like this. So we put it out there and we say their fault, their problem. Harder is to say it’s my fault, mine.
I own it. You know? So I think what you’re doing is good. Okay. Let’s finish with a few minutes of meditation.
How long have we got? I don’t want to stress you out too with too much meditation. So just, to let the thoughts go, we’ll just do two, three minutes of breathing, becoming aware of the sensation of the breath, breathing through your nostrils, breathing all the way down into the abdomen. Breathing in peace and breathing out thoughts. Slowly becoming aware of the room you’re sitting in, the cushion you’re sitting on, and the meditation we’ve just been doing.
In your own time, please finish your meditation. Page thirty two. If you have this big book, it’s, Śāntideva’s dedication. So we dedicate all the positive energy of what we’ve done this evening. We dedicate to others.
May all beings everywhere, plagued by sufferings of body and mind, obtain an ocean of happiness and joy by virtue of my merits. May the living creature suffer, commit evil, or ever fall ill. May none be afraid or belittled or weighed down by depression. May the blind see forms and the deaf hear sounds. May those whose bodies are worn with toil be restored on finding repose.
May the naked find clothing, the hungry find food. May the thirsty find water and delicious drinks. May the poor find wealth. Those weak with sorrow find joy. May the forlorn find hope, constant happiness, and prosperity.
May there be timely rains and bountiful harvest. May all medicines be effective and wholesome prayers bear fruit. May all who are sick and ill quickly be freed from their ailments. Whatever diseases are in the world, may they never occur again. May the frightened cease to be afraid and those bound be freed.
May the powerless find power and let people think of benefiting each other for as long as space remains, for as long as sentient beings remain until then may I too remain to dispel the miseries of the world. Thank you very much. So we’ve laid the groundwork. Then next week, we start to work on removing the I. We just work.
Okay? Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- atman dag (Tib)
- Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
- As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
- guru devotion
- After finding a fully qualified spiritual teacher and establishing a connection, the disciple trains in devotion using logical reasoning. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.