Wheel of Life Easter Retreat – 11 WoL 1991 03 24

44 min · 2,363 words · 24 March 1991

Wheel of Life Easter Retreat (Khensur Rinpoche)
Wheel of Life Easter Retreat (Khensur Rinpoche)
Wheel of Life Easter Retreat - 11 WoL 1991 03 24
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains dependent arising as the key to understanding emptiness, distinguishing external and internal phenomena and the factors that propel one within cyclic existence from those that lead to liberation. It rejects the idea of a creator deity and presents the twelve links of dependent origination as the basis for developing renunciation, a determination to be free from cyclic existence.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 1991-03-24

Duration: 44 min

UUID: c0b382db-3c82-402c-9fe3-00848875804c

Words: 2,359

We we should begin by rejoicing in the fact that we’ve achieved this wonderful human life, which possesses a special capacity that is, it has the potential whereby we can eliminate all our suffering and achieve complete happiness. Though we now possess this capacity in terms of our human life whereby to achieve happiness and to eliminate our suffering, if we have to make use of it because it’s impermanent, it’s definitely going to become non existent. So how can we best make use of our human life? It is in terms of developing healthy attitudes. And this is expressed within our motivation, our conduct, and also within our various studies that we in our practice.

And this training that we are seeking to work within, if it’s going to be a benefit, a vast benefit, then it must be a type of training which is not simply to serve our own needs only, but in order to bring about happiness for not only ourselves but also for all sentient beings, whereby to eliminate the suffering and bring the complete happiness to all sentient beings and be able to lead all sentient beings in a type of happiness completely bereft of all suffering. In order to actually establish both oneself and others in complete happiness, then it is necessary that I myself eliminate my various faults and bring to consummation my excellent qualities. Otherwise, there’s no way that I can lead others to such a state. Therefore, to such an end, in order to develop all of my excellent qualities, in order to eliminate my various faults, I am going to proceed in training my mind. So, in order to actually eliminate our various faults and bring into consummation our excellent qualities, we must understand the various methods and procedures for ridding ourselves of faults and developing our excellent qualities.

And once understanding that, then we can actually bring it about in fact. And therefore, with the to benefit with a vast motivation to benefit others and by means of in order to achieve that and to eliminate my thoughts and to bring to consummation all my excellent qualities, to develop such a kind hearted attitude for the as a motivation for listening to this present teaching. We are going to cultivate the awakening heart for the next three minutes. So the Buddha in a discourse called Dependent Arising said that whoever sees dependent arising, understands dependent arising, realizes dependent arising, sees, understands, and realizes emptiness. The dependent arising is extremely important for us to understand that in understanding dependent arising, we will understand that all phenomena whatsoever are established in reliance upon other factors than themselves.

In understanding dependent arising, we will understand that all phenomena whatsoever arise dependent upon their parts, in dependence upon their basis of imputation or designation, and by means of terms and concepts. In realizing dependent arising, we will understand that nothing realizing this, then we will understand that nothing independently exists. And by means of this realization of emptiness, when as in the case of the bodhisattva, the practice is as a union of method and wisdom, then by through the power of this practice, then all our various faults will be eliminated and we can bring to consummation all our qualities. So an individual who has, through the means of a union of method and wisdom, has eliminated all their various faults and brought to consummation all their excellent qualities is then termed a Buddha. And a Buddha is a Sanskrit word.

In Tibetan, it is Sangye. English, it’s Buddha. Or sometimes, if we were to translate it very literally, it would be Clearly Evolved One. By an individual who has eliminated all their various faults and consummation all their excellent qualities is able to understand the dispositions, the desires, the qualities in mind of others.

And thereby is able to fit the teaching in accordance with their dispositions. Just like a doctor will, upon examining the patient, prescribe a medicine in accordance with the illness. Likewise, an individual who has eliminated their various faults and brought their consummation of their excellent qualities is able to prescribe a particular dharma as a means to cure the ills of suffering of each individual and lead them to happiness. So it is said that the understanding of dependence arising is the main method whereby we can understand emptiness. Quoting from a verse by Nāgārjuna when he is discussing dependent arising. In which he said, There is no phenomena which is not a dependent arising, that all phenomena whatsoever are established through relying upon other. Therefore, nothing is truly existent. Nothing inherently exists. Therefore, there is no phenomenon which is not empty of true existence, of inherent existence.

That everything which exists whatsoever is a dependent arising. So, all can be classified into either of two categories. The first is those phenomena which arise dependent upon causes and conditions, and those phenomena which are established not relying upon causes and conditions. So, all phenomena whatsoever are either established in dependence upon causes and conditions or established not dependent upon causes and conditions. These two types of categories.

Examples of this latter category of phenomena which do not depend upon causes and conditions would be vacancy within this room, the space within this room, the vacuity, the space, emptiness, Also, unconditioned space. Space in general. So these are called unconditioned phenomena. They are unproduced phenomena in the sense that they do not arise dependent upon causes and conditions. The vacancy, the vacuity within this room, the emptiness itself, but also space, unconditioned space, does not rely upon causes and conditions.

And then phenomena which arise in dependence upon cause and conditions would be, for example, earth, water, fire, air, this room, trees, sound, people. That all of these are termed compounded phenomena. They are compounded out of causes and conditions, whereas the others are uncompounded phenomena. They are not compounded out of causes and conditions. With respect to compounded phenomena, there are again two categories.

There are the there are those phenomena compounded phenomena which are included within the continuum of sentient beings, that is the internal phenomena, and phenomena which are not included within the continuum of sentient beings external phenomena. Examples of this latter category, that is to say, compounded phenomena which are not included within the continuum of sentient beings or persons. We can just say the environment, the place, sounds, table, this room. These are not included within the continuum of persons. Why is that?

Because when these are in any way contacted, no feelings arise either of pleasure or displeasure. For example, if we hit the table with a hammer, no feelings arise, either of pleasure or displeasure. And therefore, for this reason, it is not connected to feelings, therefore it is called an external phenomena. So with respect to the dependent arising of external phenomena, we can cite various examples in which these arise dependent upon other. For example, plant rises in dependence upon a seed.

Smoke arises in dependence upon a fire. Far arises in dependence upon near. Long arises in dependence upon short. The color white arises in dependence upon the color red. And with respect to internal phenomena, as we said, these are phenomena which are connected which are included within the continuum of the being.

And the way in which this is established is that the phenomenon must be connected with the feelings of the being. For example, if we were to cut our finger, we would experience pain. Therefore, the finger is included within the continuum of the being. So, if we were to treat ourselves very gently, we would experience pleasurable feelings. If we were to treat our hand, for example, harshly, we would experience displeasurable feelings.

So, therefore, our hand is concluded within the continuum of the being because it’s connected with feelings. So this is the way in which we distinguish between external and internal phenomena as to whether they are connected with feelings. If they are connected with feelings according to the quality of the experience, we will have a corresponding pleasurable or displeasurable feeling arise from it. We cut our hair, there’s no we do not experience any feeling. Therefore, hair is categorized as an external phenomenon.

Likewise, when we clip our fingernails, we don’t experience any feeling. It doesn’t hurt us. Therefore, it’s an external phenomenon. But if we get down to the cuticle, then it becomes painful. And that, therefore, is considered an internal phenomenon.

So, we talked briefly about the dependent arising of externals. Now, we’re going to it’s extremely important that we understand the dependent arising of internal phenomena. Within the within internal phenomena and in the context of dependent arising, we can again make a core categorization of two types of factors. Those factors which serve to propel one within cyclic existence. For example, out of afflictive emotions we engage in various actions.

As a consequence of these actions, we experience suffering. So, these are factors which serve to promote or propel, keep us circling within cyclic existence. Then there are other internal factors which serve as aids to liberation, which serve to free us from suffering, whereby to achieve a bliss of liberation. So, Buddha distinguished between these two types of inner factors in terms of dependent arising. Those dependent arisings which serve to propel one in cyclic existence, and those types of dependent arisings which serve to free one from cyclic existence.

So, how the determining quality of these two types of dependent arisings is in terms of the quality of our activities whether these factors are constructive or destructive. So previously in India, there were non Buddhists who a religious sect of non Buddhists who worshipped a particular deity Ishvara. And this particular religion, they asserted the existence of cyclic existence and liberation. But their, that which propelled one within cyclic existence and that which helped to free one from cyclic existence, that is to attain liberation, was dependent upon the caprice of Ishvara. That was to say, depending on how Ishvara viewed you, that he could either keep you in suffering or send you to liberation.

If, for example, Ishvara thought of someone as being quite a nice person, then he could, by his desire, send you to liberation. If he didn’t like you, he could keep you in cyclic existence and keep you suffering. It was in his power. So, within this particular religion, they asserted what is called the primal substance. And Ishvara, by the power of Ishvara, he could create whatever he desired out of this primal substance.

If he thought well, then a very positive type of he could create something very positive. If he didn’t if he was in a bad mood, he could create a very negative type of creation out of this primal substance. So everything was in the hands whatever was produced was in the hands of Ishvara. But the Buddha did not accept this. He rejected this.

He said that the quality of one’s existence was completely in terms of one’s own activities and with respect to the quality of one’s actions or karma. Out of one’s own activities, the way one acted, the actions one created would determine the positive or negative quality of one’s experiences. So in describing the way in which our various experiences arise, the Buddha set forth the mechanism whereby we are continually turning within cyclic existence. And this was the teaching on the twelve links of dependent origination. This the you know, within the Lam Rim or the graduated path to Awakening, there are the three levels of capacity.

The being of small, middling, and great capacity. And this teaching on dependent origination, setting forth the mechanism by which we are bound to the continuance of our suffering, but also shows us the method whereby we can be liberated from this continuation of our suffering is mainly an object of cultivation of the understanding of the being a middling capacity. But still this teaching on the twelve links of dependent origination is said to be the essence of the Buddhist Dharma. Its practice is extremely profound. It’s very vast and it’s a great benefit to understand it.

Why is it so important? Because this practice of the twelve links of dependent origination is also an integral practice of the being of small capacity, middling capacity, and great capacity. It is related to all levels of practice. Therefore, it is of prime importance. Why is the understanding of the twelve links of dependent origination so important?

Through the cultivation of the understanding of the twelve links, the most important result is the arising of a determination to be free, that is to say renunciation. One develops a longing to be free from cyclic existence. And this is the first of the three principal aspects of the path, the determination to be free, or renunciation. Without cultivating an understanding of the twelve links of dependent origination, and understanding the nature of the four noble truths, then one cannot develop renunciation. Without this longing to be liberated from cyclic existence, there will be no liberation.

So, it is designed as a means to develop renunciation or a determination to be free. So the actual literal translation of the word which is often times translated as a renunciation, where I usually call it determination to be free, is definite arising. And it is the attitude of mind which seeks to definitely arise out of cyclic existence. And this it does by deeply understanding the faults and disadvantages of cyclic existence. One simply cannot, no longer wishes to remain within cyclic existence.

One develops a longing to be liberated from cyclic existence. And this is the beneficial result to be derived out of the cultivation of the understanding of the twelve links of dependent origination. That is this determination to arise, this definite arising. One sees the faults of cyclic existence and sees one can no longer stand cyclic existence and develops a great longing to be free from it.

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
compounded phenomena samskrta (Skt); du jä kyi chö (Tib)
Phenomena that arise due to causes and conditions. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
graduated path lamrim (Tib)
A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA
twelve links of dependent origination pratitya samutpada (Skt); ten drel yen lag chu nyi (Tib)
Also called the twelve dependent-related limbs or branches; the twelve steps in the evolution of cyclic existence: 1) ignorance; 2) karmic formation; 3) consciousness; 4) name and form; 5) sensory fields; 6) contact; 7) feelings; 8) craving; 9) grasping... LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top