1 h 40 min · 11,045 words · 25 May 2014 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 100-minute public talk, Ven Thubten Dondrub continues his three-part introduction to Buddhism by focusing on developing insight and wisdom. After reviewing the first two talks on mind and compassion, he explains how Buddhist understanding differs from theistic and materialist worldviews: the mind is formless, non-physical, and the true source of both suffering and happiness. Drawing on the Four Noble Truths, he walks through how ignorance and disturbing thoughts generate suffering, how everything depends on our mental perception rather than external conditions alone, and why developing wisdom to see the truth—especially impermanence and the illusory permanence we grasp at—liberates us from suffering. He addresses meditation not as a pleasant experience but as insight training, discusses how ethical discipline and a simple lifestyle support wisdom, and invites listeners to investigate these teachings through their own intelligence and direct experience rather than mere belief.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 08 2014 05 25 Sunday Talks.mp3
UUID: 575b5bd8-5670-4d4d-95b9-08dd8361dfb2
Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub
Collection: Public and Sunday Talks (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Date: 2014-05-25
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 100.3 minutes
Words: ~11,041
The introduction didn’t know who I am. Yes. Okay. So for those people who weren’t at either of the previous talks, just very quickly, what I’ve been trying to do is just in these three talks talk about some of the basic ideas of Buddhism especially how it’s understood in the Tibetan Buddhist tradition which is really the only Buddhist tradition that I have any significant familiarity with. I want to talk the first talk I talked a little bit about the mind.
The second one I talked about developing a good heart. And today I particularly want to talk about developing insight and wisdom. But just briefly to go to do a super quick review of things. What what is the the purpose or meaning of life? You know, everyone has tried to answer this and all the theistic religions answer this around the view of there is a God who has created everything and there is a soul.
Those who don’t believe in the creator, there are the scientific materialists who basically argue around the idea of Big Bang and the brain. And then there is the Buddhist view. And the Buddhist view it all revolves around central significance of our mind. From a Buddhist point of view, there isn’t a creator, there isn’t a soul, which sounds a bit depressing because souls sound very nice things. But from a Buddhist point of view everything can be explained by the existence of mind.
And the mind and the heart and soul can all be understood as the same thing. There are some philosophical differences but everything good about what we think of as the soul is understood as being possessed by the mind. The mind, sorry to bother people who have heard this now a couple of times, the mind is not the brain. From the Buddhist point of view the mind is not the brain. It is not a byproduct of the brain.
It is its own unique thing and it is something completely non physical. It is formless like space, but it does the most important thing of all which is to know, experience, and feel. And it’s only the mind that does that. And since the mind is formless, from a Buddhist understanding how the Buddha perceived the mind, the mind is something without, quite literally, without any beginning. There is no first cause of anything.
Things never started from a Buddhist point of view. Things have always been going on. Constantly changing, the mind has always existed and because it is formless, it is something completely indestructible. It will always go on. And the nature of our mind is pure and perfect and blissful, but that pure nature of our mind which is referred to as our Buddha potential or our Buddha nature, that has always been obscured and that’s why we suffer.
And the whole Buddhist path is about removing those obscurations from our mind and not creating more obscurations. And so the more we do that, we free our minds. The more we free our mind, we have more peace, contentment, happiness, well-being. And also we’re in a position as we free our mind to cause less suffering to others and be of actual genuine benefit to them. And this is especially the purpose of Mahāyāna teachings of the Buddha.
There are two main systems of Buddha’s teachings, those which are now preserved by the Theravāda tradition, emphasizes achieving freedom from suffering for oneself. And then the Mahāyāna teachings, which Tibetan Buddhism is an example of, which emphasizes not only freeing oneself from suffering but achieving the state of Buddhahood to help every sentient being become free of suffering. And not just free of suffering but to be able to achieve peerless, everlasting happiness. So as I tried to emphasize last week, one of the essential views of Buddhism based on the understanding of the mind is that the real source of our suffering doesn’t lie in the external world but within our mind. And the source of our suffering, every kind of suffering, originates from our own disturbing thoughts, particularly afflicted desire, attachment and anger.
But because of those we have all sorts of other disturbing thoughts such as pride and jealousies, all sorts of fears, worries and so on. And all of all of those disturbing thoughts arise exist because there is this basic disturbing thought which is called ignorance, And what that is and what it does is like the essential teaching of the Buddha but the most difficult and profound. Most profound teaching, most difficult to understand. I’m probably not going to try and talk about it today. I probably might say a bit about it.
But anyway So the Buddhist view is that it is really our disturbing thoughts that are the source of all our suffering now and in the future. Why we’re suffering now is the result of our disturbing thoughts from the past, either earlier in this life or even more importantly from past lives. And also the Buddhist view is that the real source of our happiness, every kind of happiness, contentment, well-being are the virtuous or positive states of mind that we have. And particularly the states of mind or mental factors of loving kindness, compassion and a sense of generosity. But also wisdom is one of the key virtuous states of mind.
So of course, as I tried to say last week, there are conditions for happiness and suffering in the external world. Buddhism certainly doesn’t deny that. But Buddhism says what we think of as the causes of happiness and suffering are just the conditions. The real cause, the real seed of our suffering and happiness lies within our mind. The source of our suffering are our disturbing thoughts.
The real source of happiness are our positive states of mind, our virtuous states of mind. So one could say in a very simple way, basic way, in a completely valid way that Buddhism is about working with cultivating our mind, protecting our mind from the disturbing thoughts as much as possible and cultivating the positive thoughts because everything beneficial comes from doing that. So even if you don’t believe in future lives, even if you don’t believe in the Buddhist view of the mind, everyone understands, accepts that we have thoughts. So the Buddhist view is that those thoughts are an aspect of our mind. They are a part of our mind.
They’re not the totality of our mind, but our thoughts are a very significant certainly the the main way we experience our mind now. So I would ask you to consider because we all want happiness, right? And we don’t want suffering. So even if you believe so not you don’t believe in future lives, don’t believe in the mind, only believe in the brain. And even if you believe contrary to the Buddhist view that even if you believe that the source of suffering exists outside you, the source of happiness exists outside of you, even if you believe all those things, still I think much of what Buddhism is saying and the methods it presents are extremely useful to know and understand and practice because we all do have thoughts.
And I would ask you to consider that even if you have in this life, you manage throughout all your life to have good health, you’re good looking or at least some people think you’re good looking. The right people think you’re good looking and you have all sort of success. You have a nice family, nice job. What else? Anyway, those basic things: success, health, family, friends, possessions, money, blah blah blah, even if you have all those things or manage to get them in your life, I would ask, suggest that even if you have all or most of those things, if you have a disturbed mind, a mind that falls under the control even sometimes of anger, pride, jealousy, fear, worry, attachment, craving, desire, then, which all of us do, all of us, then those states of mind, those thoughts are going to prevent us enjoying our good health, good looks, success, family, friends, possessions, etcetera.
We won’t be able to enjoy them as much as we can because those disturbing thoughts will get in the way. Sometimes having all these things, good looks, success, health, blah blah blah, actually does that more to the mind? Check up. Really. Because again a fundamental emphasis in Buddhist teachings is that it is possible to be happy but it depends on creating the right causes.
There are causes for happiness, and one has to be able to engage in the right causes. Happiness doesn’t just come about mysteriously just by luck, chance, praying for it, or whatever. There are causes and one has to create the appropriate causes. Similarly with suffering, the Buddhist view is that suffering doesn’t just happen because of bad luck by chance, by someone up there, you know, sending thunderbolts or whatever, or just by for no no reason whatsoever, there are causes. There are causes for it.
Very specific causes. So and what the Buddha is saying is that the causes lie within our own mind. And if that’s true, in one way it’s a bit threatening, but if causes of our happiness and suffering lie within our mind, it is a very hopeful situation because we have control or we can learn at the moment we don’t have much control of our mind because we don’t listen to our mind, we don’t pay attention to it consciously. Unconsciously we do all the time. So we can learn to master our mind, which means we can control the causes of suffering and happiness.
Alright. Okay. I think I’m wandering off my topic. I’m not sure I have to what am I trying to say? Yeah.
So we need to work with our mind. Whether you believe the mind is the brain or not, whether you believe in future lives or not, even if you want only believe in this life, then even in that case, to have less suffering, more happiness, we really need to take care of our mind. But especially if you start to consider the possibility that the mind does exist the way Buddhism teaches and that there are future lives, then taking care of the mind is even more vital. Incredibly much more significant. All of us experience dissatisfaction, problems, fears, worries, difficulties with other people, and suffering in general.
We’re all suffering in various ways. We have physical sufferings, mental sufferings, and they change from time to time. Sometimes there can be periods when everything seems to be going well, sometimes periods when nothing seems to be going right at all and then there are periods when there is a bit of a mixture. From a Buddhist point of view that applies at a larger scale that some lives are only suffering, some lives are quite joyful, and then there are lives which are mixtures but it just goes on and on and on. But we all want to be free of suffering and we all want happiness and more happiness.
The very first teaching the Buddha gave is called the teaching on the four noble truths or the four truths that noble beings perceive. A noble being refers to someone who has purified their minds, that their mind is unobscured and they are able to see, perceive things as they are without any projections or mistakes. So for people who have achieved that level of mind, there are four things that are undeniably true. And the first of these, the first thing the Buddha taught is that ordinary existence is in its nature suffering, unsatisfying. Ordinary existence refers to what we have, having a mind that’s controlled by delusion and karma that is obscured, which is also called saṃsāra or samsaric mind.
We have we we are in saṃsāra. Samsāra isn’t Adelaide or Australia or the world. Samsāra is our mind controlled by delusion and karma. And that mind is in its nature suffering. Nothing is perfect when we have a mind controlled by delusion and karma.
We can have happiness, pleasures, entertainment, all sorts of interesting things, but they never last, they’re never perfect, they’re never complete, they’re never fully satisfied. Within that there’s also all sorts of obvious suffering. The obvious suffering of sickness, of dying, all sorts of problems. So the Buddha said the second noble truth is that there is a cause for all our suffering And it is basically our mind. Our mind is the source of all our suffering.
Particularly it’s our disturbing the direct cause of our suffering is the ripening of the negative imprints in our mind. As I think I mentioned last week, if you want to have a tomato bush you have to have a tomato seed and then you need all the conditions the soil, the right fertilizer, temperature, moisture and all of these things. When all of those things come together a tomato bush or the seed sprouts, grows into a bush, you get the fruit. So there are the conditions and the seeds. So there are outer conditions for our suffering, outer conditions for our happiness, but the real seed lies within our mind.
So and once those negative seeds are in our mind, just like the seeds in the ground, such like the seeds in a desert, which can remain there for years and years and then suddenly the rain comes and suddenly the desert blooms. In the same way we can have negative imprints in our mind that last for lifetimes and then the conditions come together. The right amount of soil, moisture, heat, fertility in that other example. And then the seed ripens and suffering occurs. Why do we have these negative imprints?
They are the result of following our disturbing thoughts, desire, attachment, anger and so on. Why do we have these disturbing thoughts? The answer, the Buddha said, discovered the very root of all our problems is this fundamental disturbing thought called ignorance. Ignorance is a is a a mental factor obscuring our mind, forcing our mind to experience ourself and everything in a false way. It creates an illusion of things existing in a particular way, and we grasp that that illusion is the truth, is reality.
And it’s only because of that that we we we have desire afflicted desires, craving, attachment, angers, pride, jealousy, and everything else. Those disturbing thoughts are painful as we experience them, and Buddhist view is the nature of the cause determines the nature of the effect. If I want to have the effect of experiencing this water as hot, I have to create a cause that will make this water hot. I just can’t wait for it to turn hot, pray for it to turn hot. There has to be a specific cause.
And the only kind of cause that will make this water hot is a hot cause, is heat. Putting it putting it on some ice is not gonna make it hot. Putting it on something of the same temperature isn’t going to make it hot. You need the right cause. If the heat is there and the water is there, you’re not going to get hot water.
There has to be this direct relationship between the cause and the effect. And since the effect is experienced by our mind, everything we are experiencing, even external things, is experienced through our mind. If we didn’t have a mind, no external thing would exist for us. It’s just a you know, an academic debate whether something is out there or not if we can’t experience it with our mind. If we don’t have a mind, nothing is there, nothing exists.
But because we have a mind, things exist. They exist depending on our mind. The way we experience those things also depends the mere fact that they exist depends on our mind. And then the way they exist for us as good, bad, beautiful, ugly, this or that is also dependent on our mind. And what causes that?
The only thing that can cause our mind to experience things, for the mind to change, to experience happiness, suffering, this or that, is the mind itself. Because the only thing directly connected to our mind is a previous moment or the continuum of our mind. Just like for this to be hot water, the water has to be directly connected to the cause. The only thing that can make our mind change is the mind itself. So there are outer conditions for problems, but there has to be the inner cause.
Anyway, that’s a simple explanation of karma. It’s a very, very profound subject. And to really understand it, we have to understand or try to understand more and more how everything depends on our mind. That for example, this room, how does it exist for us? The only way it exists is depending on our mind knowing it, experiencing it.
As we sit here in some very unconscious way, we are all assuming unquestionably that we’re all sitting in the same room. But we’re not. We’re not sitting in the same room at all. We’re all sitting in a room that is quite similar to each other’s room, but the room I’m sitting in totally depends on my mind. And how I experience this room as pleasant, beautiful, strange, this or that depends totally on my mind.
And the room you’re sitting in is created by your mind. I mean, there is a room here, but for your mind to create that room, you know, it there has to be something, but it’s your mind experiencing this room and everything in it. We all think we’re living on the same planet, but we’re not. We’re all living in our own little bubble, our own karmic bubble. But since we have similar karma as human beings, we all share to some extent.
We all agree this is a hope. This is a flower. Right? It’s not an elephant. We all agree it’s a flower because we all have the karma to experience it that way.
But then there are things that we experience completely uniquely. But even the way I am experiencing this is unique to me. There may be ninety nine percent similarities with other people, but it is a unique experience of myself. You cannot say that the way I am experiencing this is exactly the way you are. Or you can say it, but maybe not be true.
You don’t know how I’m experiencing this. Right? Check up. But, anyway, the point I’m trying to make is actually that we live what our part of what our ignorance does because it’s because it’s a very difficult subject to talk now I’m talking about it. I said I wouldn’t.
Ignorance creates the illusion that the world is just out there separate from our mind. Doesn’t depend on our mind. And we’re just a neutral independent observer. If that was true, then karma doesn’t make any sense at all. It’s just rubbish.
But if it’s not true and actually the world out there isn’t out there the way it appears, but in fact, it’s something arising moment by moment depending on our mind, then karma starts to make incredible sense. Maybe one way to get some idea of this is for example, if you’ve ever experienced being very sad or depressed or grieving about someone who’s died or something like that, in that very low state of mind, where the mind is really sad or depressed and very unhappy, then the whole world tends to look dark. It’s very difficult to enjoy things in that state of mind. The things that one enjoyed and saw as beautiful when one wasn’t in that state, they’re still there, they haven’t changed, but we don’t experience them the same way anymore. Why?
Because our mind has changed. The things haven’t in a sense because other people see them the same way, but now our mind has changed, and we can’t experience them the same way. Even, like, when you yeah. Even eating food may not taste the same. Your favorite food doesn’t give any pleasure anymore.
Same food. Didn’t change. What changed was the mind. So one’s world changes. When the mind changes, the world changes.
And that’s what it’s really all about. Because when we change our mind radically, our world will radically change. If our mind change radically, changes radically for the worse, our our world will radically change for the worse. If our mind radically changes for the better, our world will radically change for the better. And one could argue as Buddhists do or not argue in a nasty way because we Buddhists are always wonderful all the time.
I can’t understand why more people aren’t Buddhists. Everyone says, oh, you Buddhists are all blah blah, but they never want to become Buddhists. Anyway, now I’ve lost my point. Where am I? Oh, I’ve lost it.
Everything depends on the mind. Oh yes, thank you. This not only applies individually but I think the Buddhist interpretation of what is happening to our world now with global warming and all these kinds of things is that as people’s minds get more obscured and more negative and more self-cherishing then the world becomes an uglier, more difficult place, and you have so much violence and terrorism. You know? It’s our karma to experience that.
I think you may have heard about it. What is it? The the view what is it? The hundred monkeys? Whole theory?
If, you know, first one monkey learns to do something and then slow eventually, somehow oh. More and more more pick it up and then everything everyone becomes like that. So if, you know, one person gets really negative, it influences another more and more until eventually become everyone becomes extremely negative. What we’re trying to do in following the spiritual path is to become a more positive, virtuous person, more people, eventually everyone. One person becomes enlightened, eventually everyone will.
But anyway, that really everything depends on our mind. One day a person is a friend and then just like that they can become an enemy. Yeah. Just like that. Because the mind changes.
Best friend. Next moment, worst enemy. It all depends on the mind. You know, you think of the the things you liked. Oh, this is just a ridiculous example.
When you were a little kid, the things you most loved. When we were super little, we probably had some kind of rattle that we, you know, either mum, dad or we shut you know, rattled, and we giggle with joy and delight. Do you still have your rattle? Does it still make you know, when you get unhappy, you just rattle? No.
Doesn’t work anymore. Why? Because the mind’s changed. We need many more rattles to make us happy and much more expensive rattles. Anyway, check up.
It all depends on our mind. It’s not out there like we think that this is really good. This is really bad. This person is wonderful. This person is horrible.
Everything is not so or anywhere near as concrete and fixed as we think because it really all depends on our mind. Anyway, I I got a bit carried away there. So it’s all about I’m trying to make my point. Sorry. So the second noble truth is that there is a cause of our suffering which is ignorance.
Because of that we have our disturbing thoughts and then we engage in negative karma so all suffering arises. So the solution is, the answer is really to be able to see the truth. To be able to to know the truth, to experience the truth, all aspects, all levels of the truth more and more, more and more clearly, more and completely. That in a simple way is the Buddhist answer. Our answer as deluded people, how do we try to be happy or solve our suffering, our problems with suffering is we either deny it as much as possible, we deny it, we suppress it, we try and suppress it in some way, and mainly we try and distract ourselves.
That is the main way. We distract ourselves. We try and entertain ourselves with various things. Some of which are kind of okay, some are quite dangerous and really negative. But we distract ourselves with money and possessions, reputation, friends, just doing stuff.
And if if we work, we think those things are good, wonderful, we get attached to them and we follow that more and more. And even when people have a lot of suffering and maybe look for a spiritual answer, the trouble is often that attitude comes in there and rather than using the teachings the way they’re meant to be used, they are used as kind of entertainment. And I think this is a big problem with Tibetan Buddhism because Tibetan Buddhism has the reputation of being very mystical because there’s all sorts of supposed magic things happening in Tibetan Buddhism and whatever that the Lama’s can fly. I’ve never actually seen a Lama fly, and so on. So all of that can be very, very entertaining.
But that’s not what it’s about. And also within, for example, Buddhism, a key element is practicing meditation. But meditation can also become a form of entertainment where you do it just to have a nice feeling. Of course, there’s nothing wrong with having nice feelings, you know, blissing out, but that’s not the purpose. So you can meditate.
Some people I I I can’t do this, unfortunately, so it may be just a case of jealousy. But some people can meditate, and when they’re meditating, they have this incredibly blissful experience and go off floating away. Very nice. So that’s okay, but that’s not going to solve the problem because it’s not getting to the causes. Just having a nice experience isn’t removing the causes.
It’s just temporarily suppressing them. Right? It’s just a fancier way of what we do, of distracting ourselves. Sex, drugs, and rock and roll. Or the the fancier version is is romance, expensive wines, and classical music.
Sorry. All nice things, but they only work a little bit. So what the Buddha is saying, what we really need to do is allow ourselves to know what is truth. The truth is going to set us free. Not entertainment, not just having some kind of blissful meditation experience, but discovering the truth about ourselves and everything.
All the different levels of truth. I always give some silly examples maybe but if you are having a cup of tea or coffee and you want to put some sugar in it and by mistake you put some salt in it, one’s going to suffer. So by not seeing the truth of the salt and thinking it’s something else, we suffer. And if we go through a red light thinking it’s a green light, we’ve made a mistake, we can suffer. In our relationships with other people, if we misjudge people and think this is a nice person when in fact they’re actually not such a nice person, we suffer.
If we think this person is an honest person and they’re a thief, we suffer. We think this is a good doctor, but they’re a terrible doctor, we suffer. We think this is a good investment and it’s a bad investment, we suffer. We think this is a good job to do and it’s a lousy job to do, we suffer. Every mistake we make when we see things, experience things in a false way, we fail to see the truth of them, we suffer.
So the Buddha is saying, we need to allow our mind to be able to experience things as they are, and the mind can do that. The mind has the the mind is that which knows right now. You know, we always assume that our mind is knowing correctly most of the time. We just something happens, we see something, hear something, smell something, taste something, touch something, think about something, have a concept about something. We just assume that what that what we’re doing, what we’re experiencing, what we’re knowing is the truth.
But maybe it isn’t. We just grasp that something arises in our experience and we grasp, yes, that’s it. But the Buddha is telling us that we constantly are making fundamental mistakes. But we can change, we can purify our mind, we can clean our clean up our mind so that we can see the the truth of things more and more clearly, more and more completely. And that’s what’s going to free us from suffering.
So we need to develop our wisdom, our ability to investigate things, to know things. The mind is what knows. If we let it, it will know more and more, more totally, more completely, more accurately. Yeah. I’m not quite sure where your question is going really but conventionally, yeah well the Buddhist view is that everyone in their nature is pure, perfect.
No one is ultimately inherently a bad person. But conventionally there are because conventionally everyone’s minds are obscured, some people’s minds are more obscured and so they act in very negative ways. So of course we should recognize that, but as a Buddhist one tries to also recognize that that is not their true nature, they have this other potential. So the point is trying not to direct one’s negative thoughts to that person because one sees they have negative qualities but instead to have compassion for them. But also one has to have the wisdom to protect oneself from whatever negative behavior or whatever that person is directing towards us.
But what we tend to do as obscure people is to think that the only way to protect ourselves from negative people is to get negative ourselves, getting angry and this and that. But the Buddhist view, it is possible to protect oneself without getting angry. No. No. Why is that putting up a wall?
Why why should you not be protected? Denying what? Denying the negative view. But I just said you don’t deny that. You you say this person is very negative.
Yeah. Of because it’s true. Well, I mean, presumably, it’s true in this case because we can make mistakes. But there are conventionally people who are very negative or you know or at least for you know in this in this situation they’re in a very negative state doing negative things. There’s nothing wrong with seeing one should see that.
What? Putting up a wall? Yes. Yes. But, also, you’re denying the truth of that person because the truth is that that person at that moment is in a negative state doing negative things.
Yes. That’s what I was trying to say. Right. Where am I? No.
Does that make some sense? Yeah. Alright. Right. I know certain meditation teachers talk about, like, not expecting anything and, of course, at one level one tries to avoid that.
But, of course, in practicing the spiritual path, there is a goal. One is trying to achieve things, which is freedom from suffering and eliminating the causes of suffering, achieving enlightenment. But anyway, what Buddhist meditation practiced properly is trying to achieve is not just as one is meditating a pleasant feeling or in some exceptional feeling, but one is trying to develop insight into what one is now. You know, one is trying to see the the negative aspects of one’s mind and see how they are causing suffering. You know, the teachings say this.
The teachings say, for example, your one’s one’s own anger is causing you suffering. That that’s what you know and the Buddha says that’s absolutely true. Check my he says I found that out but you check it out. So then the idea is to check. So one looks at one’s anger you know, try to recognize, oh, this is anger, my anger, and you see, is it painful or not?
And when you start to see that actually, even when we get angry to protect ourselves, you know, thinking this is the way I’m going to protect myself, one starts to see, feel, know in a deeper way that actually being angry is really horrible and painful. And then you combine that with what the Buddha said is that actually negative states of mind can only bring more suffering. So then you start to have, you know, one is creating some what my one of my teachers, Lama Yeshe, would call some wisdom energy that enables us to want to abandon anger, to let go of it. And on the other hand, one checks up good qualities and how these actually bring some peace and contentment. So one gets to there’s a there are two aspects.
One is understanding the Buddha’s teachings. Meditation is for the purpose of getting insight into what the teachings really mean because we can hear them and think we’ve understood them. But we’re trying to really understand what the Buddha taught and to see all its implications, but then apply it to one’s actual experience so that what is just like at first a separate truth, you integrate that into one’s life. So one’s not trying to am I explaining help? Yeah.
One’s not trying to have a nice experience in meditation. That’s not the point. I mean one may have one but that’s not the purpose of it. I mean the ultimate purpose is it has the best experience of all which is freedom from suffering and to experience ultimately the true blissful enlightened nature of one’s mind. But for that to happen the aim is not to have these little pleasant experiences but to develop more and more understanding you know, that leads to a deeper, more authentic experiences.
We’re trying to get to the truth of the teachings which are really about ourselves anyway. And so we’re trying to use meditation to understand and experience the teachings more and more so that we can apply them more and more to our own reality, own situation. For example, maybe an answer, one of the things I was going to mention like the Buddhist so Buddha is trying to tell us that we’re experiencing many things in a false way, but we believe the opposite. We don’t know, we don’t understand that what we’re experiencing is false. We think it’s true.
And because of that, we suffer. So the Buddha says this you know, you you think things are like this, they’re like that, but this is what I’ve the Buddha says this is what I’ve discovered is true. You check out. The Buddhist didn’t say I I’m I’m wrong. The Buddha definitely believed he was completely right, not because he was arrogant, but because he’d purified his mind.
But he said, don’t believe just what what because I said it, you check up. Because if you check up, the truth becomes incredibly powerful. It’s not just something you believe, it’s something you know. Yeah. One of the problems in our reality, our reality appears to be that things, our self, our possessions, family, friends, the external world, all seems to be quite permanent, static, fixed.
That things are just going to always stay like this, be permanent, unchanging. The reality is that actually everything that we experience there are some you know, anyway, that everything is impermanent. Everything is changing moment by moment. One meditation teacher once said, every time you open your eyes, the world is different. A little bit different.
Actually the Buddha said that everything that depends on causes and conditions is impermanent, meaning it changes moment by moment. But we don’t live our life without understanding or experience. We tend to experience the world as being permanent. And because of that, we suffer. Because one of the main reasons we get attached to things and desire to desire them and get attached to them is because we believe they’re permanent.
Because, like, this is beautiful. Again, this is just an example. Beautiful object. So it makes me happy now. We grasp that this object will be always like that, permanently beautiful, permanently fresh, and therefore is a source of permanent happiness.
But it’s not. Within a week, no one will want this vase of flowers in their room because it will stink absolutely disgusting. These will all have wilted and dropped in a big mess. Yeah. But, you know, we do know about impermanence, but we constantly deny it.
And of course, when things that we’re attached to, we don’t want to think they’ll change. And of course, when they do, we we don’t expect it. We’re completely shocked. And then we suffer because this was going to be permanent. But it can’t be because it’s it’s very nature is it’s changing uncontrollably.
But we suffer because we deny the truth. And the more we deny it, the more we believe this thing, this person, this situation, whatever it is, is permanent, the more we suffer. We suffer because we get attached to the good permanent things or what we think are the good permanent things. And and we suffer with the negative permanent things because the negative permanent things are unbearable, so we get really upset and angry. You know, I can’t bear this situation because it feels like it’s gonna last forever.
So we get really upset. Alright? Check up. And, of course, we can tell ourselves it’s impermanent. It’s gonna change, but we don’t believe it because there’s that emotional grasping.
There’s that emotional grasping. That and that’s what meditation is about is you one can intellectually understand impermanence, but there’s still that emotional grasping that things are permanent because we want the good things to be permanent. And and it’s all a habit. So meditation is about breaking down those habits to get to the truth, And that takes time. It’s not about having a nice experience.
The experience actually may not really good meditation I probably shouldn’t say this. Gonna lose more people to the cause. But but real meditation could be actually quite painful and unpleasant because one is discovering a truth that one doesn’t want to know. Because we want to think the world is like this, But it’s not. And it can’t be.
This will never be permanent. We can’t make things permanent. Can’t. Even the Buddha can’t. Nobody can.
If it’s created, if it comes into existence depending on causes and conditions, it has to change. It can’t support itself to be it lasts just for one moment like that. In one moment things come together due to causes and conditions and they become, you know, there’s something and in the next moment those causes and conditions themselves change so the thing changes, you know, all the time. That is reality but we don’t see that even when we see it because we see, you know, like it’s winter. So all the trees, you know, the leaves are are decaying, falling off.
But we don’t get it. We don’t get it that actually everything is like that. You know, we know people die, but then someone dies and we’re shocked. Completely shocked. And so it shouldn’t have happened that this person will never die, and we’re completely upset.
But that’s reality. So it’s about accepting, really knowing and accepting the truth. That will free us from suffering. It doesn’t mean when someone dies, think, oh, don’t care. It’s just we won’t be it we will be sad.
We will miss this person, etcetera, etcetera. But in experiencing the loss of people we care for and whatever or the loss of things that we like and they break and whatever, within a genuine context of understanding impermanence, we don’t suffer in the same we don’t suffer, yeah, and make mistakes as a result. It it’s it’s a type of freedom. The truth liberates us. There’s the great liberation, you know, from all suffering, but every little bit of truth is it may be painful to come to it and acknowledge it, but once we accept it, every kind of truth liberates us from something, from some confusion, limitation, suffering.
This is the Buddhist message. So that’s what we’re trying to do, not have jolly jolly but have insight, real understanding. And, of course, like the more we understand ourselves, we can understand other people. And the more we can understand our own limitations and faults, we can and accept them, understanding that they’re not our true nature, then the more we, you know, do that, we can be kind and compassionate and forgiving with other people. Right?
So that’s what it’s about, not knowing the truth. Should we when when’s the break? Now? Well, quickly, I never actually got in. Well, the third noble truth is that it is possible to eliminate suffering.
There is a true cessation of suffering because scientific materialism doesn’t says there isn’t. You just get real and accept that life is miserable. But the Buddhist view is many people say Buddhism is like a really depressing religion because it’s always talking about suffering. But it talks about suffering in order to so that we can be free of it. Because the essential message of the Buddha is that we can experience peerless everlasting happiness.
Everyone has the potential for that. Right? That that is a pretty great message. It’s best message of all. And that’s why the Buddha taught emphasized the very first thing he taught was the the our ordinary existence of suffering.
He never said when he first achieved I’m a Buddha, I’m enlightened, I’m having a terrific time enlightened. Is this, this and this? When you’re enlightened you can do this, this and this. He never talked about that. The first thing he said is, You’re miserable.
You’re suffering. Oh, he never did it like that. Sorry. He was kind of kind, know. But he he made it very general.
He said, ordinary existence is in its nature suffering. Meaning not that it has suffering, the very fabric of our life is suffering. Not necessarily painful no. Don’t get too depressed. Not necessarily suffering in that every moment is totally miserable, but it’s unfulfilling, incomplete, imperfect, unsatisfying.
Ordinary existence. And the Buddha taught that so that, like, the more we see that and realize there’s something more. The the Buddha’s teaching the four noble truths were taught in the context that one can be a Buddha, one can be blissful all the time. Right? But to get to that point one first has to acknowledge, yes, right now I’m a limited suffering being.
If we don’t acknowledge that, we’re not going to progress. We have to acknowledge that. To get rid of our suffering, we have to first acknowledge it. And then the second truth is that there is a cause of our suffering. Third truth is that those causes can be completely eliminated and in a way that they will never come back.
And the fourth noble truth is that there is a method to follow. There is a path one can follow So that all the causes can be eliminated, all the causes of suffering can be eliminated, all the causes for peerless everlasting happiness can be accumulated and enlightenment can be achieved. And that path is basically a path of developing a good heart and wisdom. Wisdom is gonna get yeah. Wisdom is gonna get us out of saṃsāra.
Wisdom is gonna help us achieve enlightenment, and the good heart is gonna motivate us to do that for our own sake, for the sake of others. And while we are suffering and others are suffering, the good heart will enable us to be able to bear that. So another thing so we tend to see and experience the world as permanent when actually it’s impermanent. We need to develop this wisdom that sees that more and more, not only just intellectually understands it, but really knows it, knows it, experiences it more and more. So that is very, very liberating.
And particularly, just to get into a little depressing topic, the ultimate so we are impermanent. We’ve come into existence depending on causes and conditions. This means we are changing moment by moment which means we are decaying moment by moment which another word for that is aging. We are aging moment by moment and the end result of aging is death. So we are definitely going to die.
So to understand the teachings on impermanence are, I think, unbelievably helpful in being able to deal with this essential truth of life that we’re all going to die. Because many people, they face either their own death or the death of loved ones, are so upset, so shocked that this has happened. It shouldn’t happen. But it it it should happen in a sense. It is completely natural.
Most people think of death as something that should not happen. It’s unnatural. It’s wrong. And a person dying without any understanding sees, oh, everyone’s alive and, you know, enjoying life, and I’m dying. How terrible.
Life is unfair. What’s wrong with me? I am being punished. So the person can die really angry inside because it’s not fair. Everyone else is alive, going to live, and I’m not.
But everyone is dying. We’re all dying. That is life. That is reality. Denying that is suffering and brings more suffering.
The mind that is open to see the truth of that is liberating. It is genuinely liberating. To have even just a little experience or just a little acceptance of impermanence, our own impermanence, the impermanence of our family, friends, everything. It doesn’t stop feeling sad when, you know, we lose things and friends or family pass away. But it’s a different kind of thing than this mind that is so shocked and possibly angry and totally confused and this is unfair.
This, you know, shouldn’t happen, etcetera, etcetera. So the truth is liberating. This is the Buddhist message. Not denying it, but knowing it, experiencing it more and more deeply. The Buddhist teachings are impermanent.
They’re not going to last forever. And they also degenerate with time. And the people practicing them also. You see, when the Buddha first appeared, he taught the four noble truths to five people. There was just five people listening to him and when they heard that the Buddha said he gave that little teaching, the teaching on the four noble truths.
I’m not sure how long the teaching lasted, but let’s say one hour. Okay. Let’s say three hours. At the end of it, all those five people became arhats. Their mind became completely free of all the obscurations through the power of hearing the Buddha speak the truth.
This doesn’t happen to us because we’re a teeny bit more deluded. Our minds are more obscured. So we have to hear these things over and over and over again, even just to understand them. And then we have to meditate on them to make it really, you know, touch the heart, move the heart. Before I depress people more, maybe we should have a break.
So there is some tea coffee refreshments, please enjoy. Of things, we grasp that that is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth. So one thing that we can try to do in our daily life is to be mindful and to be wise in the sense that as we are experiencing things, whatever we see, hear, smell, taste, hear about, think about, that that rather than grasping to be one hundred percent the truth, to have that mindfulness, that that is just how things are at this moment appearing to my mind. And just because they’re appearing to my mind that way, it doesn’t mean that is the truth. That can be extremely helpful.
Not easy to do, but if we can train our mind to to be aware that this is just an appearance to my mind, it’s arising depending on my mind, And it may not be the truth. It could be, but it’s not necessarily the truth. So we should try as much as possible to withhold oh, no. Yeah. That’s right.
Try as much as possible to withhold our judgment on things and people and situations, to have that space to recognize that it could change, my mind could change, that I’ve perceived things in a false way, and maybe because of all sorts of projections and past histories and due to past karma and all sorts of things, I’m seeing things this way, but it doesn’t mean they are that way. That’s a good question. I should what could one say? Well of course Buddhism that’s a very tricky question. It has a very complicated answer.
I’m probably not capable of really answering properly. Buddhism talks about that there are two levels of truth. There is the ultimate truth and then there is the conventional truth of things. And the ultimate truth refers to the way things actually do exist. That all things, every single thing that does validly exist, all exist in the same way.
So that that is the ultimate truth and that applies to everything. And and in in in Sanskrit language that ultimate truth, the way things exist is contained, is referred to in the word Śūnyatā or Śūnyatā which in English is translated as emptiness or voidness that things are empty of inherent existence. So all things that exist exist as being empty of true of of inherent existence. Don’t ask me to explain what that means because it’s too complicated. So that’s the ultimate truth.
So you could say that there is the one ultimate truth about everything. But in terms of the conventional truth, that is that is is changing for sure. You can’t say there’s one again maybe there’s different ways of looking at it but Well, everything that depends on causes and conditions is impermanent. That’s a conventional truth. But that truth doesn’t change.
In that everything that the Buddha is saying, any anything and everything that depends on causes and conditions for its existence is impermanent. And that will always be the case. Yeah. The way things exist. Yeah.
The truth of how things are existing. Yeah. Yes. Yeah, sure. Sure.
Yeah. But that that particularly applies, I think, to the conventional truth that that’s what we can do in relation to the conventional truth to understand the ultimate truth which is what is which we need that wisdom that understands the ultimate truth to free us from suffering. That is a very profound, complex process that requires very specific meditational training. But letting go of the knee jerk reaction, as you say, to our grasping things straight away about the conventional truth, the more we can modify that, that is creating some space for us to be able to eventually understand the ultimate truth of things, the final truth of things. Good question.
Glad you asked that. Well I think the answer is both because think I tried to say in the previous talks that Buddhism is about working with the mind and the most direct way of working with the mind is meditation. But it’s not the only way. Many people make the mistake of thinking that meditation is the be all and end all of everything. But meditation the term I think I mentioned the Tibetan term which is translated as meditation is gom, and that word gom literally means habituation or familiarity.
So meditation is about habituating the mind with what is virtuous and true, basically. And at the same time what’s implied is de habituating, if there is such a word, the mind which is which is familiar with that which is non virtuous and not true. So to be able to meditate properly, one meditates on on you have an object that you meditate on. You think about things in in a controlled focused way. And that can only be done in the context of knowing the teachings.
Because if you don’t know if you don’t understand properly what you’re meditating on, you’re only just going to instead of imprinting a positive understanding in your mind, you’re going to imprint a wrong understanding in your mind. So all the Buddhist the whole purpose of the Buddhist teachings is that they are raw material for meditation. They are the the topics, the objects of meditation. So for the for example, the Buddha taught about went into details about impermanence. So that wasn’t just to entertain people or whatever.
That is the the reason for teaching it is to go away and meditate on to think about that. So the more teachings one has about this, that and the other, the more material you have to meditate on. And all the teachings are about us. When we meet Buddhism for the first time it may appear very exotic and this and that. But it’s really all about the mind.
Whose mind? Not somebody’s mind three thousand years ago from some other country and culture. It’s about our it applies totally to our mind now. So we need we need to know the teachings because they’re helping us to they’re giving us a map to travel through our mind away from suffering towards happiness. So in dealing with our suffering from a Buddhist perspective, we study the teachings, meditate on them, but then there are things we need to do in our life which are related to those teachings and the meditations, practical things to do.
It’s not just, you know, yeah, abstract. So just a very simple example, like in developing a good heart, I think I tried to say last week about how developing generosity was of spirit was is really important. It breaks down our self-cherishing and was was I talking about that last week here or somewhere else? Yeah. Oh, good.
Someone remembers. And and it’s a way it’s it’s an expression of love and compassion. So you hear the teachings and try and see, analyze, oh, does this make sense or not? You meditate on them. But the the idea is then you try and practice generosity.
Yeah. You have to apply it. And just also just simple things, you know, there are teachings on on about the nature of anger, what anger and attachment and desire and pride and jealousy. Then you meditate on those things to help you recognize one’s own disturbing thoughts and how they’ve brought suffering in one’s life. And then in one’s daily life the idea is to try to be mindful of when one gets angry.
Why one is why am I getting angry now? Who you know, what is making me angry? And to try and see how and to try and be aware that, you know, this is you know, don’t get angry. Don’t suppress it, but apply the teachings to pacify it. Does does that help?
Yeah. Yeah. We all have. This is not the point. Know Buddhism does talk about huge periods of time and we all we have all these terrible delusions and it’s going to take a long time blah blah blah many lifetimes.
So what there’s again, this is also connected with wisdom. My teacher once said, Lama Zopa Rinpoche once said, one way of looking at things, one way of thinking about things brings every kind of happiness and one way of thinking about things brings every kind of suffering. So the wise person thinks about things in the right way. The wrong way is to think, I’ve got a long way to go. It’s very long.
It’s very hard. Why bother? You know? Because that’s you know, the self-cherishing can say, conclusion, very long, very hard, lot of time, don’t do it. The wise way of thinking is, I am so lucky I’ve met this method.
I never had this method before. Now and I’ve got the chance to use it. So even if I use it a little bit, I’ll be that much better off. Aren’t I lucky? Terrific.
And also other people will benefit as well. If we are a happier, less unhappy person, without doing anything, other people benefit from that. It’s not about how, you know, hard and how long. It’s just doing it because the mere doing of it even a little bit is good. And no one does it well straight away.
Everyone makes mistakes, everyone does it imperfectly, everyone does it with the wrong motivation. We may think we’re doing it with the right, it’s just slowly, slowly all changes. It improves, it develops. Because everything is impermanent. Because if it was permanent we would never be able to improve, but because our mind is impermanent it can change, it can develop.
So just very quickly another example of our wrong views that we need to overcome to see the truth is that there’s so much in life that we believe to be happiness, but which actually is not happiness, it’s a subtle kind of suffering. There are many ways and there’s whole teachings on this which one can listen to and meditate on. But just very simply, because this is just an introduction, all of the things that we label as happiness and therefore we grasp that as being give them this ultimate value and, you know, crave for them and get attached to them and then get angry if we can’t get them or angry if someone threatens, you know, our happiness and so on. One way to see that all of that happiness is not real happiness because real happiness is pure, perfect and lasting like we established last week or the first week. Right?
One way we can see that what we think of as happiness is a type of suffering is it simply doesn’t last. It itself is impermanent. That everything that we experience as happiness arises depending on causes and conditions. And so it can’t last. It may last quite a while, it may last all this life, but it doesn’t last.
So it doesn’t bring lasting satisfaction. So if we could really understand that, that would liberate us. It would not totally, but it would free our mind to be able to put our energy into working on things that will bring lasting happiness. The simple reason why we’re not experiencing perfect lasting happiness is because we haven’t put our energy into creating the causes. And the reason we haven’t put our energy into creating the causes for perfect lasting happiness is because we’ve put our energy into creating the causes of short lasting happiness.
Because we thought it would it would last. We thought it was going to make us permanently happy or we hoped it did. And we’ve done that all this life and all our mostly throughout all our previous lives. We’ve put most of our energy into chasing after stuff that is just a bubble of happiness. Yeah.
Because we didn’t see the truth. We saw an illusion and thought the illusion was true. But the Buddha saw through the illusions and said, Rubbish, this this is the truth. Go this way. So we have to check up.
We have to use our intelligence, use our wisdom. And we do have wisdom. Basic wisdom is intelligence, the ability to check and distinguish this from that, right from wrong, beneficial from non beneficial, meaningful from meaningless. And intelligence, real intelligence, is not something fixed. I’m not quite sure but I think in modern education the idea of intelligence of people is quite a fixed thing pretty much.
That you are born with a certain IQ and that’s it. This is not the Buddhist view at all. Intelligence is a completely flexible thing. It’s impermanent. So if you use your intelligence, it will increase if you use it in the right way.
If one makes the right decisions, if one checks up and analyzes, investigates rather than just grasping at things and wanting to believe this, really using one’s intelligence, then, the more we do that, the more our intelligence grows, the more we will make the right decisions until we reach a point where it’s not possible to make the wrong decision, to make a mistake. So the highest form of that intelligence is wisdom where we are perceiving the truth completely, directly, unmistakenly. Alright. So in in in developing wisdom, It’s about using our intelligence, the right decisions and to be able to do that more and more understanding the teachings is really helpful. And also as we were talking about practicing meditation is incredibly helpful.
Learning to train the mind to look into things more carefully, more clearly because in meditation just simply I think I mentioned that especially in the first talk that we have an eye consciousness and ear consciousness, nose, tongue, body consciousness and then there is the mental consciousness itself which is the most important aspect of the mind. So meditation involves working just with the mental consciousness. What one is trying to do well, when we go to sleep at night, what happens is that our five sense consciousnesses shut down at some point. And what is left is just the mental consciousness. And the mental consciousness focuses on darkness and we’re asleep.
Meditation is something like going to sleep but in another way it’s completely different. It’s similar in that what one is trying to do in meditation is allow the five sense consciousnesses to shut down as much as possible. So you don’t look at things, you don’t spend your time smelling things, hearing things. It’s nice to have it quiet and so on. You don’t eat while you’re meditating and so on.
That as much as possible all that information stops and all that is left is the mental consciousness. But unlike in sleep where the mental consciousness just becomes unconscious, the idea in meditation is that the mental consciousness now has a chance to really waken up. Because it’s the mental consciousness that has this unlimited ability to know and to know directly. Right now our mental consciousness is knowing things indirectly through concepts. We have concepts about stuff.
But the mental consciousness has the ability, the potential to know things directly as percepts, as perception not conception. That’s what we’re trying to do. Ultimately prepare the mind to be able to directly perceive the truth. Firstly, we have correct well, one can start with wrong concepts about the truth, then one can develop correct concepts about the truth, and then one can directly perceive it. So that’s ultimately what we’re trying to do.
Yes. Yes, it’s a total, complete, direct, vivid, unmistaken knowing, spontaneous. And you know you know. You know you’re knowing the truth. Right now we just think we know the truth.
Anyway, a final point. In developing wisdom we have to work with our mind so that involves what helps work with our mind are listening to the teachings about the mind. The Buddhist teachings are all about the mind Training in meditation, but also it’s about our lifestyle, the way we live our life. So it’s important to live a life based on ethical discipline, a moral life, of not harming, benefiting others. So that is really important.
I don’t have time to go into that, but the more we live an ethical life of morality, this itself is a wise thing to do because negative behavior is a cause of suffering. Virtuous behavior is a cause of happiness. So just doing that is a wise thing. So it’s leading us to be able to experience the highest wisdom. And and also, it’s really important to try as much as possible, which seems to be getting more and more difficult in the world at the moment, to live a a simple life where we’re not rushing around like lunatics doing lots and lots and lots of things because even if those things are good things, if you do lots and lots and lots, you know, the mind is just so speedy and agitated.
And the speedy, agitated, stressed mind can make lots of mistakes. So and I’ve I’ve I’ve been a monk now for thirty seven years, and just in that time, it’s just amazing how much busier life seems to become for people. Even monks have busier, stressful lives and stuff than before, but everyone is so incredibly busy doing stuff. But do we really need to do all that stuff? Is it really helping us?
It’s really up to us to make the decisions, the right decisions, to be wise in making the right decisions because if we make the wrong decisions, we get the result. We will get the result. If we make the right decisions, we will also get the result. So it’s really important. This is really the crucial thing, you know, the four noble truths.
Is it true that there is suffering? Yeah? Then is there a cause? Is there an actual cause? Can that cause be removed?
And if so, is there a way to remove the cause? And the Buddha says, yes. Life is suffering. There is an actual cause, because I found it, and it can be removed because I removed it. And there is a way, there is a method, a methodology, a system, a path that one can follow to remove the causes of suffering and achieve peerless, everlasting happiness.
So if we are wise, we should check this out. Thank you very much.
Key terms in this teaching
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
- As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
- A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.