1 h 3 min · 6,227 words · 9 April 2015 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 64-minute session from April 2015, Venerable Thubten Dondrub teaches patience using Śāntideva’s Guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life, Chapter Six. He opens with motivation-setting practices—a Dakini prayer to remove obstacles and a mandala offering—then establishes why patience matters: it protects both ourselves and others from harm. The core teaching unfolds through Śāntideva’s logical arguments against anger: understanding karma, the law of cause and effect, and the recognition that those who harm us are driven by their own delusion and desperation. Venerable Thubten covers the mechanics of blame—that our own past actions created the conditions to meet those who harm us; that our body, not the enemy’s weapon alone, causes our suffering; and that harsh words have no inherent power to hurt unless our mind chooses to be wounded. He weaves in compassion as essential to patience, addresses the danger of self-blame, and emphasizes the role of humour and lightness in undermining the heaviness and false seriousness that fuel anger. The teaching is pitched at practitioners already engaged in Buddhist study.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Patience 5 2015 04 09.mp3
UUID: 18cc3776-824e-472e-b4da-6e536998b404
Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub
Collection: Patience (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Date: 2015-04-09
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 63.9 minutes
Words: ~6,222
So welcome everyone to our Thursday night class on this, and our topic is developing patience. So the main authority for this is Śāntideva’s wonderful text, The Guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life, And in chapter six that is dedicated to the topic of developing patience. So this is what I’ve been going through and we will continue to do so. Please turn your mobile phones off. Thank you.
But firstly, although we’re going through a great dharma text or a part of it, just listening to the dharma itself doesn’t make that a dharma action. It really depends on our motivation. So it’s really important to put some effort into cultivating the right motivation as possible and the best one we can cultivate is bodhicitta. Before that traditionally we do some practice to eliminate obstacles. So we start with the prayer of the lion-faced Dakini on page six.
I prostrate to the gathering of Dakinis and the three Chakras who abide in the holy yoga of using space. By your powers of clairvoyance and magical emanation, look after practitioners like a mother her child. Akrama Rāja Sadhara Samaya Hrīḥ. By the power of truth, may inner and outer hindrances be transformed, may they be dispelled, may they be pacified, may they be completely pacified, may all negative forces opposed to dharma be completely pacified, may the host of eighty thousand obstacles be pacified, may we be separated from problems and harmful conditions to Dharma, May all enjoyments be in accord with the Dharma and may there be auspiciousness and perfect happiness here right now. So then visualizing the Buddha in front of us, we offer a mandala of the universe as a way to request the teachings, thinking to offer the whole universe everything in it, especially everything most beautiful and what we’re attached to as a way of recognizing that in fact the Buddha’s teachings are far more precious than anything in the universe and actually everything in the universe combined doesn’t compare to the value of the Buddhadharma, which actually can’t be valued as priceless, because if we practice it, it can free us from all suffering and help us to be of perfect benefit to all things.
So as we continue to think of the Buddha in front of us, we now particularly think of all sentient beings surrounding us and particularly think of how we are connected to all these beings because they have been so immensely kind in every possible way. We cannot exist without them. And especially we depend on the kindness of sentient beings, particularly the kindness of the mother, and we’ve received this from every sentient being, countless times in beginningless saṃsāra. And all of these beings who have been so kind, are kind in this life, will be in the future, in future lives, are suffering in saṃsāra. So this is what we try to be aware of and to try and not only have awareness of it but really try to feel that suffering, how unbearable that is because these beings are completely helpless in their suffering and in their confusion creating the causes of more suffering, more saṃsāra.
So now, because we’ve found the precious human rebirth, have met the Dharma, especially the Mahāyāna teachings, have all the freedom to practice it, now we really have to seize this opportunity and make this decision that I have to use this in all my future lives to free my mind of all confusion, awaken all positive qualities so that I can achieve the enlightened state because it’s only as an enlightened being that I can completely, perfectly repay the kindness of mother sentient beings. And that’s the most meaningful thing I can possibly do. There’s no more beneficial, satisfying thing than to do that. So to achieve enlightenment, that involves following the path in following the path to enlightenment, then one has to experience many kinds of difficulties and constantly dealing with sentient beings, one’s own inner difficulties, the difficulties of practicing the Dharma. So in all these cases, one needs patience.
So for this reason I will study this subject not only in the sense of an academic study, but in a Buddhist context when we talk about studying something, it involves hearing teachings on it, reading about it, but also applying it, applying it, studying it in relation to our own mind, how our own mind can apply this understanding in daily life. So this is what I will do. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, Dharma, and the Supreme Assembly. By the merit I create through the teaching of the Dharma, May I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings. So thinking the Buddha is very pleased with our motivation, we imagine the Buddha coming to the crown of our head and then dissolving into light and that blissful golden light then pouring down into us, blessing our mind to be able to understand the teachings correctly, blessing our mind to be able to put them into practice properly, blessing our mind to eventually be able to gain a complete authentic undeceiving realisation of patience.
So then briefly doing the nine round breathing exercise or some other breathing meditation, you know, just to let the mind become a little bit more calm, clear, more concentrated so that we can use that mind to listen to and think about the Buddhist teachings tonight. Okay. Thank you. Apart apart from the obvious reasons as an ordinary just as a person living with other people in Samsāra, we need patience in that case, but especially as a Dharma practitioner, a dharma student, we need patience so that we don’t harm sentient beings, so we don’t harm ourselves, so that we can bear our own problems and difficulties, and especially so that we can bear the difficulties of serious Dharma practice. As I’ve mentioned, tried to mention and explain, there are many ways to develop patience, but basically we need to understand the disadvantages of anger for others and ourselves, not just personally but particularly from the point of view of trying to practise the dharma.
We need to understand the advantages of having patience. So that’s really fundamental in developing patience. We need to understand those two things very strongly, very deeply. And then on top of that, we need as other ways to develop patience, we need to understand the causes, which is basically our own underlying dissatisfaction. We need to we can develop patience through the power of familiarity and courage, training ourselves in courage by understanding the benefits of problems and difficulties, especially from a dharma point of view, a dharma perspective, and therefore also the benefits of having enemies.
We can develop patience by understanding dependent arising and how everything is empty. Lama Zopa Rinpoche says this is actually the best way to practice patience, to develop patience is by understanding emptiness, but of course that’s the most difficult thing. But in relation to that, when one checks the mind that is under the control of the wrong view that things inherently and truly exist from their own side and that I truly and inherently exist from my own side. We’re under the control of that all the time, but sometimes that control is really strong. And when one is really under the control of ignorance, then a feature of that is everything becomes very solid and very concrete and that is a very, what’s the word, powerful condition to get angry when we see the situation as very concrete, it is really, really, really like that.
This person is really bad. This situation is really bad. I am really suffering. Status is not being honored, know, this is really bad. It all becomes extremely heavy and solid.
If you check one aspect of that, one, what’s the word, symptom of that, symptom is in that situation we have lost all sense of humour. Yes. Right? So having a sense of humour really helps practising patience to lighten up, Yeah. To lighten up.
Yeah. We have an expert in humor here. We can all take classes in humour from Jan. Yeah. So, yeah, really, when we check, when we are angry, we are taking ourselves incredibly seriously, far too seriously.
Yeah. And we’re taking what’s being said so seriously, what’s happening so, so, so seriously. Śāntideva doesn’t deal with this and I’ve never heard any Tibetan lamas talk about this, but I think this is one aspect to look into and check up, check your own mind, try and catch that mind that is being so serious and that seriousness has got a heavy quality. The mind is very heavy in that situation. So we need to kind of make everything a bit lighter.
And when things are lighter, there’s some flexibility, there’s more possibilities, there’s more space. humour helps to do that, to make fun of one’s, not other people, but ourselves, yeah, more. To realise how ridiculous we are when because if you see other people fighting and arguing, in some ways it can be horrible and upsetting and whatever, but also it can look really kind of ridiculous. Know, these two people are fighting about something that no one else is bothered about because it’s become so serious for them or two groups. Everyone else, it’s it’s okay.
What’s then you look and it seems so ridiculous. Why are these two people screaming and yelling at each other or bashing each other up? But but trapped in that, it could we leave comments? Sorry. Because I I get very confused and distracted.
Too towards the end. Towards the end. It’s okay. Tea break time, question time. Right.
So I just wanted to make that point. These are some of the ways to practise patience, but also one practises it through compassion, although all of the ways of practising patience I’ve mentioned before really involve that, because when we understand the disadvantages of anger, if we have compassion for ourselves, we will try to subdue our anger because it’s harming us. If we have compassion for ourselves, we won’t want to harm ourselves. And if we have love for ourselves, will want to develop, seeing the advantages of patience, we will want to have it because patience brings peace and happiness to our mind. And if we have real love for ourselves rather than self-cherishing, then we will want to practise patience.
So compassion is an integral part of genuine patience. So then there are some very specific things one can think about to develop patience, which I was starting to talk about last time. So one way of what I was trying to say last week is that we can one of the reasons or one of the conditions that supports the arising of our anger is by focusing so much on what is happening to me rather than what is happening to person that we’re blaming for our anger. But if we could change the perspective, have a little bit, which is that compassionate attitude, then we could be more patient. We were talking last week how Śāntideva points out that sentient beings, for the sake of trying to be happy, end up are willing to do all sorts of harmful things to themselves.
They become completely obsessed by getting various things, and in order to get those things, people endure all sorts of suffering. They even end up committing suicide, many, many you know, harmful, disturbing things. So he was saying, if people are willing to do that to themselves, then it means they’re also willing to harm others, so we shouldn’t be surprised and therefore be angry. We should expect that. Because, yeah, because this is what we do too.
It’s not that just other sentient beings in their desperation to be happy and gain things actually harm themselves. Since we are just ordinary sentient beings, we are like that too. So we know this, so we shouldn’t be surprised when people harm us. If they’re willing to harm themselves, we shouldn’t be surprised that they harm other people, including myself. So by not being surprised, expecting it at some point, this will help us not to be angry, but just understanding the really strange nature of sentient beings, which includes ourselves.
We sentient beings are a strange lot. So we should have compassion, compassion, just like we should have compassion for ourselves and our delusions, we should really be compassionate to the uncontrolled behaviour of other sentient beings. So another way we can develop patience, which Śāntideva also talks about, is through understanding the law of cause and effect. This is again a very fundamental way to help us practice patience, And the more we have a genuine understanding of cause and effect and real faith in it, because what defines a Buddhist is someone who has taken refuge in the triple gem of Buddha, Dharma and Sangha and the essential refuge is the Dharma. The Dharma is the essential refuge for us.
Technically speaking, the actual refuge is the Buddha and the Dharma comes from the Buddha, but we’re not able to directly communicate with the Buddha at our level. Only Bodhisattvas can do that. So for us, the essential refuge is the Dharma. Not in some kind of weird mystical way, but it’s through practicing the Dharma. More faith we have in it, the more we will practice in it.
So that is our refuge, our protection, is our faith and practice of the Buddhadharma. And of all the teachings of the Buddha, the most essential teaching is the teaching on the law of cause and effect. That is the quintessential Dharma teaching. All of the Buddha’s teachings can be condensed into Three Principal Aspects, which is developing renunciation and developing wisdom and developing bodhicitta. There is nothing else in the Buddha’s teachings other than those three things.
So the Theravāda teachings have the teachings of renunciation and wisdom, the Mahāyāna teachings have the teachings on renunciation, wisdom and bodhicitta, but there’s nothing else. And tantra, you know, is only about those three things. It’s not something else, some completely different thing. It’s a different view of those things or a different way to practice them but it’s all about renunciation, wisdom and bodhicitta. And the law of cause and effect, if you investigate it, is about the renunciation, wisdom, bodhicitta.
To be able to develop renunciation, wisdom, bodhicitta, you have to understand and practice the law of cause and effect. So it’s the essential teaching to understand and the more faith in the law of cause and effect, then yeah, the more we’ll practice. All of the teachings are connected to it. So again, patience is such a crucial aspect of Dharma practice and to be able to practice patience, it really helps to know and have strong faith in the law of cause and effect, because the basic aspect of the teaching of the law of cause and effect is every effect we experience has a cause. It’s just that simple.
So all our suffering has causes, and those causes come from within ourselves ultimately. The root cause comes from ourself. This is what the law of cause and effect says. There needs to be outer conditions, but even those it gets more complicated, but even those outer conditions. Why do we meet those outer conditions?
Again, even that, we have to create the cause for. So if we have someone who we say is causing suffering to me, actually they’re just the condition. The fact that I meet someone who doesn’t like me and therefore criticises me, gives me problems, and maybe even physically harms me, even eventually kills me, that can only exist, that situation can only exist because I created the cause for It doesn’t happen by chance or for no reason. It’s just a chance that I meet this person that doesn’t like me. It’s not possible according to the Buddha.
We talk about accidents. Know, car we have a car accident, but there’s no such thing as a car accident in Buddhism. There’s just car karmas. There are car crashes in Buddhism, but not car accidents. It wasn’t an accident.
Car crash, ripening karmas. So if we really understood that, we really had faith in that teaching, then we wouldn’t be upset. Śāntideva says, Previously, I must have caused similar harm to other sentient beings. Therefore, it is right for this harm to be returned to me who is the cause of injury to others. So in a past life, I injured other people, so now in this life, people injure me with words, with deeds, and so on.
On. This is the Wheel of Sharp Weapons returning, as one of the texts says. We create the cause and then one of the results is the result similar to the cause is we get a similar experience later in this life or more likely in a future life. So why be angry with that person? They’re not the main cause of my problem, my suffering.
It’s my negative actions. This is what I need to remember. And if I really remember that and practise mindfulness of the teachings and based on actual faith of really believing it, then this will help me not to get angry, not to be upset. But we have to meditate on these things, think about them deeply and be convinced, of course. If we’re not convinced, it’s not gonna have much power.
If we think, oh, yeah, some things are karma, some things aren’t. This one isn’t. I can punch him. Śāntideva goes on to say, Both his weapon and my body are the causes of my suffering. So I’ve got a suffering body and if it gets hit, it suffers.
So he’s got the weapon, I’ve got the suffering body. But both, and so when he hits me, both of these things are involved in producing suffering. If body didn’t have the potential for suffering and it was hit, I wouldn’t suffer, but I’ve created the cause to have a body that suffers and he is the person hitting me. So since he gave rise to the weapon and I gave rise to the body, with whom should I be angry? Why just blame him?
Or her? See, if you hit the Buddha, the Buddha won’t be hurt because the Buddha hasn’t created the cause to have a suffering body. The Buddha’s created the cause to have a body of bliss, but we’ve created the cause to have a suffering body. And then if someone hits us, ouch. So why just blame him?
We have to blame ourselves as well, but we just put all the blame on that one. Śāntideva goes on to say, If in blind attachment I cling to this suffering abscess of a human form which cannot bear to be touched, with whom should I be angry when it is hurt? Shouldn’t I really be angry with myself for being so attached to this suffering body? And he goes on to say, Just like the guardians of the hell worlds and the forest of razor sharp leaves, so is this suffering produced by my actions. With whom therefore should I be angry?
So in this verse Śāntideva is referring to the traditional descriptions of the hell realms, And in some of the hell realms, it is said that there are these beings, you know, the guardians of the hells, which are karmically created beings. They’re not actually sentient beings, but they’re like karmically created beings that are projections of our own mind. So these beings, you know, torture one, you know, beings in the hells or appear to. But in fact, all of that is the is is our karma. We’ve created the cause to experience the hell realms and all these sufferings in the hell realms, including seeing these horrific monster like beings who torment us continuously.
And one of the what do they call them? There’s the actual and then there is the not the occasional hills, there are the other hills. It’s kind of like neighbouring hells, secondary ones. So one of them is the forest of razor sharp leaves where due to attachment, see some beautiful person at the top of this tree which is all made of all these, like, razor sharp leaves. And so you climb up to get to this beautiful desirable being.
And then, of course, as you climb up, you get ripped to shreds. When you get up the top, he, she is not there and it’s down the bottom. So you climb down and get ripped to shreds again. So you spend your life doing that. That’s one of the minor hell realms according to the teachings.
So this is all created by our mind. We created the cause for it. Śāntideva was saying, just as it is our actions that have created the cause to be tormented in the hell realms, in the same way we’ve created the cause while we’re in the human realm to have humans who cause us problems. So who should we be angry with? Actually, we created the cause for this.
You know, they’re not screaming at other people. They’re yelling at me. They’re angry with me. They’re upset with me. They’re blaming me.
They are trying to harm me, not other people. Me? Why? The the only answer according to the Buddha is because I created the cause. It can’t happen any other way.
There are so many stories of, unfortunately it happens all the time, of people who spend years and years in jail unjustly because they’ve been convicted of a crime that they actually didn’t do. Recently, there was a woman who was just in America released. She’d been in jail for over thirty years or more, maybe even much more for murder, and they then found out she hadn’t done it and was released. Yeah? So, you know, there’s a lot of talk about injustice and how terrible this is and this was an innocent person.
And from this life, it’s true. But from a karmic point of view, for someone to experience this injustice of being blamed for and punished for something they didn’t do, that itself is a karma that once created the cause for that in past lives. Possibly in a past I I don’t know the actual cause, but possibly it’s accusing someone of something they didn’t do, knowing they didn’t do it. You accuse someone, you pass the blame, maybe one does something terrible and then blames someone else and they suffer as a result. As a karmic result of that, at some point one gets accused of something one hasn’t done and suffers for it.
But the teaching says nothing can happen if one hasn’t created the cause. If we create the cause, we get the result. If we’ve got the result, we’ve created the cause. If we don’t have the result, it’s because we haven’t created the cause. Some people work incredibly hard in this life and get nothing as a result.
Some people work very hard and make lots of money and are very successful. From a Buddhist point of view, it’s not what you do in this life that actually produces the result, that’s just the condition. Some people hardly do anything in this life and they’re incredibly successful because they created the cause in the past. Just working very hard and doing lots of stuff in this life doesn’t mean that you’re creating you’re producing the result in this life. That’s just the condition.
Of course, you have to have the condition, but if you haven’t got the root cause, no matter how hard we work, no matter how much we try to do something, to have something, we won’t succeed if we haven’t created the root cause. But if we have and the conditions are there, wham, the result, good or bad, comes. So this is what we have to understand. So when the suffering comes, we have to remember this is a ripening result. So why be angry?
In fact, my anger is just creating is leading me to create causes of more suffering. So then Śāntideva says something really interesting that might freak you out. This is a very, you know, pretty special way. Because remember, Śāntideva was a great bodhisattva. This is written, much of this is written from the point of view of many great Buddhist masters write texts and they claim it was written just for them, just to remind them how to practice.
Of course, it was written for others because they’ve been practicing these things for a very long time and achieved the result, but much of this text is written from the point of view of Śāntideva sort of telling himself, this is what I should do. So he says, having been instigated by my own actions, those who cause me harm come into being, right? Because I’ve created negative actions, I’ve harmed sentient beings in the past, in this life, I meet the enemy. I have I come across people who want to harm me in some way or other. It doesn’t actually mean you actually create an enemy somehow, but one creates the cause to meet someone who dislikes you for various reasons.
If by these actions, meaning because of our karma we meet the enemy, so the enemy dislikes me and wants to harm me, so if by those actions of the enemy wanting and actually harming me, they, the enemy, should fall into hell, surely isn’t it I who am destroying them? So I shouldn’t be angry with them at all. I should be really compassionate because I’ve created the cause for this person to come along, get angry with me, and then their anger and negative behavior is throwing creating the cause for them to have a terrible rebirth. So actually, in a sense, I am creating the cause for them to go to hell. The point is one shouldn’t take this too concretely.
Right? Because, you know, their actions are creating the cause for them to go to hell, but I’m the condition. The reason to think like this is it is a valid way to think in order to subdue one’s anger. By reversing, rather than thinking about me, oh, this person is hurting me, insulting me, harming me, blah blah blah blah blah, One thinks, actually, by reversing it, having the more compassionate approach anyway, the less self-cherishing way of looking at it, this person is like, in a sense, magnetically drawn to me because of my karma, and they’re going to suffer. So if I get angry with them, this is gonna make it worse.
So and I’ve created the situation in the past. So, you know, this person in a sense is suffering because of me. So I, you know, they deserve my compassion, not my anger. And on top of that he goes on to say, in dependence upon them, I purify many evils by patiently accepting the harms they cause. So if I practise patience with this person, I’m able to purify a whole lot of stuff.
But in dependence on me, they’re going to experience suffering for an incredibly long time. So since I’m causing harm to them and they are benefiting me, why, unruly mind, do you become angry in such a mistaken manner? How about that? Now something you know, it’s really important to understand that argument properly because a lot of people, probably a lot of Westerners, will get completely neurotic and this self blaming attitude. Oh, I’m such a terrible person.
The bad people in the world because of me. I’m sending everyone to hell. Oh, woah. Woah. I better go and commit commit suicide.
You know? I’m terrible. It’s not like that. It’s just a way to think. Yeah?
But but it’s a valid way to think. Yeah? And it’s a very beneficial way to think, to cut one’s anger. It’s it’s not one doesn’t think like this to make oneself feel guilty, but to stop one’s anger, to undermine it, not repress it, suppress it, but to undermine it by thinking in a completely different way that one way justifies our anger and therefore it arises and continues. We need these other ways to think that are very powerful and undermine that negative way of thinking.
So then he goes on to say, If my mind has the noble quality of patience, I shall not go to hell. But although I am protecting myself in this way, how will it be so for them? Nevertheless, should I return the harm, it will not protect them either. By doing so, my conduct will deteriorate and hence this fortitude will be destroyed. So what Śāntideva is saying there is to counteract an argument that could think the clever mind, that could think Since the enemy harms Because the enemy is harming me, this is actually beneficial for me because it gives me the opportunity to practise patience.
Therefore, actually, if that’s the case, then I can harm the enemy because that will give them a chance to practise patience and benefit them. Right? But Śāntideva is saying, No, no, that argument is not correct. Any comments, questions? Sorry if I you have to be patient with me, but I just have to repeat this point I’ve said a million times already before.
So hopefully understood the point I tried to explain that Śāntideva made, and hopefully you agree with it and think, Oh, well that’s interesting and Oh, that’s good. Difficult, but good. But for that to be helpful, we have to reflect on it, we have to meditate on it strongly to make the imprint so that at some future time when anger may start to arise, then we can be mindful, we can remember this, we can remember this argument to undermine what we’re thinking at the time. But we won’t remember it, we won’t be able to be mindful of it if we haven’t thought strongly and deeply and also regularly about it in order to make a really strong conscious imprint in our mind, to make some real impression in our mind. It’s not enough just to understand something and agree.
We really do have to meditate on these things. So Śāntideva says now all Dharma texts really are meditation manuals. They’re not just bedtime reading or just a book to read once and that’s it. These are things that we need to reflect on over and over and over and over again. Okay.
I’ll keep going if you don’t say anything. Or Śāntideva will. Anyway, so one argument an argument for not getting angry when we are being physically harmed is that is that although maybe our body is being of course, our body is being harmed, but the enemy or disease or whatever is causing harm to us that may lead us to become angry, That cannot harm the mind. Śāntideva says, Since my mind is not physical, in no way can anyone destroy it. But through it’s being greatly attached to my body, meaning because my mind is greatly attached to my body, it is caused harm by physical suffering.
So my mind, because my mind is attached to my body, I’m very attached to my body and if my body is harmed, then my mind gets agitated, so it’s harmed in that way. So it’s disturbed, but one can’t actually harm the mind. The mind is indestructible. It’s formless. No one can really hurt the mind.
And that’s the main thing to protect. In any situation, as the ideal dharma practitioner, the most important thing to protect in any situation is our mind. For the worldly person, which probably most of us still are, but we try to become dharma practitioners, but certainly for the worldly person in any situation, what is most important is their body protecting their body, protecting our reputation, protecting our possessions, protecting our this, that, the other. But in protecting all those things, we harm our mind. But what we really need to understand is the most important thing to protect is our mind, to protect our mind from creating negative actions, generating for the disturbing thoughts to arise and following them.
And one of the most important harmful negative minds we need to protect ourselves from is anger. So even if someone is harming our body, the most important thing is not to worry about that so much, but what’s happening to our mind. And actually, if we’re being killed, then it’s even more the case that if that is happening, what we need to do is protect our mind. Because our mind is if we’re being killed, our mind is going to leave the body and go into the next state. So we need to especially take care of the mind at that stage.
So no reason to be angry. No justification. Again, it doesn’t mean we can’t try to stop the person harming our body, killing us, this or that, but to avoid doing it with an angry mind because that is really causing more harm than what we’re trying to avoid. So in the case of actual physical harm being done to our body, Śāntideva is saying, really there’s no justification, no reason to be angry. And especially, he goes on to say, in the case of speech, there’s no point to get angry when someone uses unpleasant words to us.
He says, since disrespect, harsh speech, and unpleasant words do not cause any harm to my body, why mind do you become so angry? You know? Words can’t harm our body, so why be upset by them? And actually, if if we although Śāntideva doesn’t talk about this here, if if we check up, only can words obviously words can’t harm our body, but also words actually can’t harm our mind. They seem to.
If someone insults us, we get upset, but those, if you check, if we investigate, the words themselves have no power from their side to hurt us. How they hurt us, if you investigate, is our mind decides those words are hurtful. Check. Really? I mean according to our culture, in different cultures, so in our culture there are certain words or ways of saying things which we recognize, Oh, this is designed to hurt me.
This person is insulting me. They are saying rude words or using various expressions or the way they’re saying things or the sound of their speech. All of this is designed to hurt me, right? But we don’t have to be hurt by it. We actually choose to be due to our self-cherishing.
Because I think if you check, we possibly have all had experiences where someone has insulted us and we know they’re insulting us, but it doesn’t bother us for some reasons. Oh, this person’s an idiot. He can say whatever he likes and it’s not a very good reason not to get angry, but we don’t get upset with him. But someone else says it, we’re really upset. So we have the ability to hear insulting words and not be bothered by them, but sometimes we’re bothered.
And again that goes back to remember why do we get angry? It’s because of the discontent in our mind. Something underlying, some underlying attachment and discontentment or expectation. But then because of that, we choose to be upset. But then we say, You made me unhappy.
But it’s our way of thinking about words and people’s expressions, behaviour and how we think of ourselves. It’s all of that network of perceptions, conceptions, and ideas about me, this, him, her, blah blah blah, all of that together, and we get upset. We can’t bear it. And then we blame the other person for all of that, but it’s all it’s it’s our process of thought which we don’t have to follow. I mean, will take us time and effort to stop that process, but we can.
It’s not like just overnight, straight away, one can suddenly become incredibly patient with someone who’s annoyed us for a long period of time doing the same old things, but we can learn to through the power of familiarity. And having a little bit of humor about ourselves. So you reckon, oh, here he goes again. Here I go again, getting angry, getting upset. Sometime sometimes we can catch ourselves.
Alright. I’m gonna stop. There’s an awful lot of this book to go through still. We’ve only got one class left. Okay.
No more questions? Any questions, comments, disagreements? Okay. Thank you very much. Tea break.
What? What time is it? It’s the old time. Oh, this is the old weak coffee with lots of milk and sugar. One sugar.
One sugar and weak coffee. Right? Yeah. Weak. Yes.
Thank you. You have, this one? No. Yeah. It’s a weak coffee once you get.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- mandala khyil khor (Tib)
- A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
- ripening result
- One of the four ways we can experience the results of an action; the ripening result is the actual realm we are born into when we take rebirth. LYWA
- samaya dam tsig (Tib)
- Sacred word of honor; the pledges and commitments made by a disciple at an initiation to keep tantric vows for life or to perform certain practices connected with the deity, such as daily sadhana recitation... LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
- A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.