Mind Training — 2014-03-20

1 h 48 min · 3,808 words · 20 March 2014 · Buddha House Adelaide

Mind Training (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Mind Training (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Mind Training — 2014-03-20
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 108-minute teaching on mind training, Ven Thubten Dondrub offers an in-depth analysis of how to determine the selflessness of the person and phenomena as taught in classical Buddhist philosophy. Starting from page 119 of the root text, he examines why realizing the absence of a truly existing self in the person is foundational and easier than recognizing emptiness in external objects. He walks through the four philosophical schools’ competing definitions of what constitutes the “basis of person” — the aggregates, the mind, or the mental consciousness — before presenting the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika view, which asserts that the self is merely imputed onto the aggregates and cannot be found upon investigation. He then introduces the seven-point analysis, a logical technique for investigating whether an inherently existing self could be identical with or separate from the five aggregates, showing both options lead to absurd consequences. Throughout, he emphasizes the necessity of identifying the object of negation clearly before meditation can undermine the false grasping that sustains ordinary misperception. Intended for serious practitioners already engaged with classical Buddhist epistemology.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2014 03 20 Mind Training.mp3

UUID: 42659769-f68e-4651-a690-e11dc9c920cb

Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub

Collection: Mind Training (Ven Thubten Dondrub)

Date: 2014-03-20

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 108.2 minutes

Words: ~3,810

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:00:00-00:01:35] introductory prayers, if you’d like to join me, starting out with the primitive mirror. On page 5, prostrate at the gathering of the dakinis in the three chakras who are dying in the holy yoga of losing space. By the powers of their brains and magic elimination, look after practitioners like Amara Chai. By the teachings of the three supreme jewels possessing the power of truth, may inner and outer influences be transformed. May they be distilled, may they be classified, may all negative forces opposed to Dharma be completely classified, may the host of 80,000 obstacles be pacified, may we be separated from problems and harmful conditions to Dharma. [end unchecked]

Forces opposed to Dharma be completely passed by. May the host of eighty thousand obstacles be passed by. May we be separated from problems and harmful conditions to Dharma. May all enjoyments be in accord with Dharma, and may there be auspiciousness and perfect

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:01:35-00:07:16] May all enjoyments be in accord with the Dharma, and may there be auspiciousness and perfect atmosphere. Obeisances to my Guru and Protector Manjushri, who holds to this higher scriptural text symbolically seeing all things as they are, whose understanding shines forth as the sun, unclouded by defilements or traces of ignorance, who teaches in sixty ways with the patient love of the father for his only child. All creatures caught in the prison of samsara, confused in the darkness of their ignorance, overwhelmed by their suffering. You, whose dragon-thunder proclamation of the Dharma, arouses us from the stoop of our delusions, and frees us from the iron chains of our karma, whose powerful sword of wisdom hews down suffering wherever its frowns appear, clearing away the darkness of all the urns. I entreat you, O Manjushri, which brings the body as a bond with one hundred and twelve marks of the Buddha, who has completed the ten stages, achieving the highest perfection of the Bodhisattva, who has been pure from the beginning. O Manjushri, all loving one, with the brilliance of your wisdom, illuminate the darkness in closing my mind, enlighten my intelligence and wisdom, so that I may gain insight into Buddha’s words and the texts that explain them. positionising Shakyamuni Buddha in front of us as a source of refuge and guidance, the embodiment of all our perfect teachers of the past, present and future. We offer a number of the universe as a way to request the teachings, to free our mind of hindrances to understanding and practising the teachings, especially on this extremely difficult topic, but on the ultimate nature of reality, and also to accumulate the merit that helps us. to understand and recognize the truth focusing on non-centered beings around you starting with our public side trying to do as much as possible generating the effort for bodhichitta motivation wishing to achieve enlightenment in order to repay the kindness of all other simple beings feeling how immensely kind they are, have been, will be, how I’m totally dependent on their kindness, especially the kindness of Mother, so particularly when I depend on this, while I remain in samsara, but especially to get out of cyclic existence, I’m totally dependent on the kindness of Mother, and also to achieve enlightenment. And all these kind beings are open selves, trapped in cyclic existence. most experiencing the worst suffering, self-existence right now, and help this feeling, whether you’re truly trying to be free of suffering, in fact, most of the time, are just simply creating causes of more self-existence, feeling of suffering. It’s a feeling how unbearable, trying to feel more deeply, how really unbearable that situation is. I must use this all future lives to free my mind with all self-cherishing, all disturbing thoughts. And they’ve got all its basis, which is the self-grasping mind, awaken all positive qualities, especially the wisdom of realizing the true nature of all dreams and the mind that cherishes others more than self. so that I can perfectly repay the promise of all men and simply. So, to achieve that enlightenment state, that depends on following the path, and that path involves overcoming self-cherishing and cherishing others more than self. Overcoming agents and placing perfect wisdom. And so, since this text is about these topics. I will study these tapes. [end unchecked]

happiness. I go for refuge until I enlighten to the Buddha, Dharma, and the supreme assembly by the merits I create through this.

May I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings? So we can think that Buddha is pleased with our motivation, and visualise this by now approaching the crown of our head and directly above our crown, you know, the Buddha dissolves into us. So we

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:11:04-00:11:31] The main part of the text, which is about training the mind, the mind training associated with developing and enhancing the conventional quality to the mind-sync humanisement. And now we’re on to the last section of the text, which is covered up in a seven-point mind training by distinct four minds, which is about developing and being… [end unchecked]

started. We’re on

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:11:50-00:12:33] So, so far what we’ve covered is dealing with very, very, very briefly the views of the other Buddhist schools. of a self-specific person. And now we’re onto the imaginary view of it, a self-specific person. And our author, Horton Munkapel, has emphasized that, firstly, what is most important is that we have to be able to identify the object that we refuted, and then we’re moving into how to refute that object. [end unchecked]

page one hundred and nineteen. Hundred and nineteen. That’s what we finished. Oh, top of No.

We’ve hundred and twenty. We’re on page a hundred and twenty, the way. The way to determine the selflessness. Yeah. So so keep going down.

It’s, you know, that’s it. The order for establishing the two selflessnesses. So the two selflessnesses are the selflessness of the person, selflessness of the phenomenon. So it says, firstly, as explained, although there is not the slightest difference in subtlety regarding the self, which does not exist, whether the the basis is the person or the mental and physical aggregates, because of the difference in subtlety in the basis of engaging, there is a difference of ease in ascertaining the view. It is like so then what explains this.

So it says, it is like this. In order for a person such as the person, the other one gets mentioned. I don’t know why they use him because he was such a nice character. Maybe because he was such a nice character, but since the person was very strong. Anyway, in order for a person such as Devadatta to appear as an object to our minds, we have to depend on on his aggregates.

So his imputed existence can be established through reason. Thus, there is not a slightest difference. Actually, this is that’s different in the following. Anyway, However, because it is easy for some basis of negation to appear to our minds, such as our own persons compared to other phenomena, it is correspondingly easier or more difficult to ascertain selflessness. A person, then the selflessness of phenomena.

Even though the selflessness is exactly the same, it’s not a different kind of emptiness. It’s exactly the same. The person is is empty in exactly the same way as in phenomena is empty. It’s easier to recognize the selflessness of the person because the basis of negation sorry. The basis of imputation is is is is easier to recognize than the basis of the the basis of imputation of phenomenon.

If if you remember, I was making this point that when we look at a flower, a flower or a bunch of flowers

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:16:31-00:17:01] There is a flower here. The flower that does exist is the merely imputed, dependently of rising flower, which arises depending on causes and conditions, the parts, and the merely label. But that flower we are not perceiving. The flower that we are experiencing now is [end unchecked]

, So there is a flower here which is imputed, and the flower, it does exist and only exist because there is a basis for the flower. And but right now, we cannot distinguish unless one is quite quite realized. The average person, so more than the average person, we can’t separate the merely label flower from the basis. But because the basis yeah. So that’s it’s tricky to be able to recognize the basis.

Whereas for the basis of the merely imputed self on fire. Anyway, that’s easy to recognize. Easy to recognize. Sorry? Maybe academically.

Well, that’s what they say. It’s it’s not easy it’s not easy to recognize, but it’s easier to recognize than with phenomena

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:18:35-00:19:04] once one is at that level. They say it’s easy to explain selflessness of phenomena first, but the realisation comes academically, as you say, it’s easy to explain the selflessness of phenomena first, with some idea of what this is all about, but in realising it, it’s easier to realise the selflessness of the person, because the basis of his imagination is easier. [end unchecked]

. So that’s basically what what that’s saying. But and and and what what it goes on to say on the top page, a hundred and twenty one, where it says, just as you understand selflessness in yourself, understand it similarly in all sentient beings. So once we’ve realized the selfless our own selflessness, it is a it is very easy to realize the selflessness of all other things because it’s exactly the same.

And just as you understand selflessness of all sentient beings, understand the selflessness in all phenomena. So once we have the emptiness of our of our own person, then it it is much easier to then begin to recognize that actually all phenomena are empty. But in in in stages of the path of realizing emptiness, we don’t work on trying to realize the emptiness of phenomena first. We try and realize the emptiness in our own self, our own person first because it’s easier. So it goes on the the actual techniques of establishing a view of selflessness is three aspects, but how to determine selflessness of the person.

So that’s the first. Secondly, how to determine the selflessness in phenomena. And thirdly, how dependent arisings of persons and phenomena appear like illusions. As I’ve tried to say now that before, the that are appearing to us now as truly existing. And what we see here is is a truly existing flower.

So that is an illusion. So how to determine the selflessness of the To begin with, this concerns recognition of what the basis of person is. So in other words, to be able to, as you determine the selflessness of the person, first, we have to know what the person is. We have to recognize the basis of the person. So on the basis of an I, the innate wrong conception of an I is the person.

We don’t we don’t develop this wrong view of self on the basis of something else. It is generated by experiencing a person in a false way. That’s why you get this wrong sense of I. We don’t get a wrong sense of I by experiencing a jar of water in the wrong mind. It’s by experiencing personal.

For some, such as the the followers of the Vaibhāṣika tradition. So that’s So such a you talked about the particulars, which is the. The focal object of the conception of the person is the five mental and physical aggregates. In other words, the Vaibhāṣikas say that the person that does exist is the five aggregates. The five aggregates of form, feeling, discrimination, compositional factors, and the six primary consciousnesses

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:23:36-00:24:10] say that the person that does exist is the five aggregates. The five aggregates of form, feeling, code, discrimination, compositional factors, and the six primary consciousnesses. These five aggregates are the person. Of course, the academic doesn’t mean to say that’s wrong. The five aggregates are the person. The five achievements say the five aggregates are the person. [end unchecked]

. For others, the person is only the mind.

All, you know, all, such as the Cittamātra school. So the proponents of mind only or of mere consciousness who assert the existence of the mind basis of all, take the mind basis of all as the basis in relation to the thought of I as the basis in relation to which the thought of I arises when the disturbed mind focuses on it. So we have to go back a little bit. Remember, we’re talking about the four philosophical schools, the Vaibhāṣikas, the Sautrantikas, the Cittamātra, and the Madhyamikas. So the the Chitamatrans school is unique.

So the Vaibhāṣikas, the Sautrantikas, and the Madhyamikas all agree that there are six consciousnesses. Whereas the Chitamata school is unique in in in various ways. One one way is that they talk not about six types of consciousnesses, but eight. So when you talk about the six all. And the other one, I forgot what was going.

Anyway sorry. Anyway, the key thing basic just to say here, you know, this is just an introduction to all this. The Cittamātra has talked about there are eight consciousnesses, One of which is the mind, it’s a simple one, which in Sanskrit is called the consciousness. So you’ll often hear about that. If you read about zen, they talk about that.

Because as I’ve mentioned

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:26:37-00:27:21] because as I’ve mentioned, the Zen school, it has a Chittamatra view. So the Chittamatrains are saying the mind basis of all is the person. Again, of course, the mind you need is saying that’s not true, that’s not true. There is a sub-school report, and there’s always complications. I would vote on to say, the proponents of mere consciousness who do not assert the… [end unchecked]

, There is a subsequent caveat. There’s always complications. I would go on to say, the proponents of mere consciousness who do not assert the collection of eight consciousnesses. So there is a mind’s only school that is it’s kind of a rebel group, so they don’t they don’t accept the eight consciousnesses. Just the six.

Anyway, so that group and the followers of the master, Bhāvaviveka. So Bhāvaviveka was the founder of the Mādhyamika Svatāntrika school, which are called in English the autonomous reasoners because they believe in inherent existence, as well as the sūtra followers posit the sixth consciousness, the sixth consciousness, the stream of mental consciousness as the person. Okay? So we’ve got the two, the Vaibhāṣikas say that the person is the five aggregates. The the Cittamātra is talking about the eight consciousnesses say that the mind basis of all is the person, then the middle way the the Mādhyamika Svatantrikas and the Sautrantikas, which are the lower schools,, they say that the mental consciousness is the person.

Okay? So now we’re getting to what does it mean to self. Also, all of them assert that person is a mere imputation imputed to the mental physical aggregates, and so on. And that and that its referent must be something substantially existing. Okay?

So they do say it’s imputed, but even though it’s imputed, it substantially exists. This is because when its existence is being posited by a valid cognition and the imputed object is sought, it must be findable. For if it does not exist due to its own characteristics, it cannot exist at all. In other words, these schools all argue that even though something is imputed, to impute something, there has to be something there from inside from with its own characteristics substantially. Which all seems logical.

You’d like to put it very simply to to impute something that is good, Why? It seems logical that why you impute something good or useful in something is because from its side, there is something good. That seems to make whole lot. It’s yeah. It’s a it’s a mindful.

Yeah. It’s the wrong view. Yeah. It’s not the nice view. It’s a little bit on that on that.

They wouldn’t say that No. I don’t know. But the the present is the same. So now it goes on to say our own system. Our own system because we’re all present.

Right? Our own system comes from the words of the master Candrakīrti. So Candrakīrti is the big hero of the. I I would say, of Tibetan Buddhists in general, but especially of the. The master Candrakīrti in his Supplement to the Middle Way.

That’s the

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:32:08-00:32:57] which is a commentary on magic humanist text in a way that makes it much more accessible. But in the Galupa school, it is the Chandrakirtis Manjulinda Abhattara that is used as a basis for understanding the positive. So our own system comes from the words of the master Chandrakirti in the sacrament of Abhattara, thoroughly rejects the premise. [end unchecked]

Candrakīrti thoroughly rejects the premise that the focal object this term focal object is not a very good translation. So the present need to say, to have the wrong view of truly existing self, or the I that doesn’t exist, grasping it as truly existing,, you have to So most of the other schools, just to sum up just summarize quickly, easily, are saying that it’s either one or all of the aggregates, which is the basis of imputing the thought I this is not correct. In his commentary to the Sūtra, by saying that the mere I itself is the focal object, he implies that the thought of an I must arise naturally in relation to it. So what this is saying is that what do we what do we I’ll just use the term see because I can’t come to the correct philosophical word to do it. But when or look at what do we look at in order to get like, in order to get.

Right now, we are looking at this object. And instead of instead of seeing a merely labeled flower, we see a truly existing flower. So what what are we looking at in order to see a truly existing flower? What are we actually looking at? No.

No. Well, if I just look here, can I see a flower? No. Something that we’ve

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:36:32-00:37:06] of something. Because remember the truly existing flower doesn’t exist. I think I’m seeing, like we all think we’re seeing a truly existing flower or a truly existing bunch of flowers. But in order to see how that false rule of inherently existing flowers, there has to be some kind of flower there, because there’s none there. So we’re not seeing any inherently existing flowers. Here we’ve seen some inherently existing flowers. [end unchecked]

labeled

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:37:07-00:38:34] Why? Because there’s some merely-labeled flowers. There are flowers there. There aren’t any appearances there. There are merely-labeled, conventional flowers there. So the basis of having a wrong view is the mirror. It’s the mirror. Yes, the correct object. The one that actually does it to this. which is the medium label. Invention of a rising flower, that is the basis of having the wrong view. In order to get the wrong view of a snake, there has to be something there. It isn’t a snake. It’s a rope. So in order to get the wrong view of the inherent existence, the basis is actually the medium label, [end unchecked]

. Basis of the wrong is the wrong.

And so this is what it’s saying here about

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:38:35-00:40:33] rising which does exist. That’s really interesting. The basis of the wrong view is in the wrong view. And so this is what it’s saying here about the basis of having the wrong view of self is actually not the five aggregates because the five aggregates are in self. The basis of the wrong view of self is the mere I, the merely labeled I, the I that does exist. which arises when merely labelled by the mind of independence on the right end. So the mere eye, which does exist, the right dimension, the mere eye is what is merely labelled by the mind on the right end. So that mere eye does exist. So that mere eye is like the right end. So the mere eye that does exist, doesn’t inherently exist, doesn’t truly exist. that doesn’t substantially exist. And that is the basis for, because of ignorance, to generate an inherent existence in a perception of an eye, a truly existing. The basis of it is the mere eye. So the mere eye does exist. And ignorance comes along and experiences that mere eye as [end unchecked]

So with regard to such things as the mere I, the thought of I naturally arises, as you may remember I’ve said many times that and I don’t think this is a contradiction. But because of the there there are many levels of that. At the moment

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:42:03-00:44:05] Because there are many levels of outlines, so at the moment, and I’ve tried to say that to actually identify the actual very subtle object in the beauty, this is one of the most difficult things to do. So at our level now, when we try to identify the object to what the spine is, we do, I think, eyes. But that’s just a very gross level. of our confusion. We do identify that I am my God, or I am my name. But that’s only grossly. But deep down, the very, the object we refuted is the innate conception of I. That is based not on thinking about the five angles, but on the I does arise in it. a mere I that validly exists. I would say a bit more by saying, since we reject the aggregates as being of self, only the thought of mind can arise in relation to it. Only the thought of mind can arise in relation to any of the aggregates. The thought of I cannot do so because it arises as an imputation in the aggregates. This will become clear. [end unchecked]

, So it says, every person, whether man or woman, whether exalted or whether an ordinary individual, So every person within cyclic existence or liberated from it is designated in dependence upon the aggregates, which is

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:45:31-00:46:07] The mind designates I. I don’t know if I can explain this properly or confuse it, but this word, it’s really important to have some idea when we say the mind, the mere I, is what is designated for on-telling. So this clock is on-telling. But when we say the I, [end unchecked]

like a clock on the table — it can exist. It’s you know, it it has its qualities and because there’s a table there, it it which which, you know, has it is really existing and is supported by that

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:46:45-00:47:28] is supported by that. But it doesn’t mean that there is an I that is supported on the five agabas. What it means is simply because there are five agabas, the mind can then think of it. There is an I that can look somehow, as long as I’ve reached your seat. You can see as many times as an example. [end unchecked]

. So

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:47:29-00:48:12] that the only way we can talk about an I that is sitting right now here we are we can all think I am sitting here so there is an I sitting here but that’s that the I is sitting here right now we can only say that badly because the five elements are sitting here specifically the body is sitting here but because the body is sitting here [end unchecked]

anyway, so

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:48:12-00:51:40] and the mind is connected with it, and so we find that. And because of that, the mind, and only because of what the sitting and the mind generates the thought, we can’t find a separate. It’s not like there’s an I on the fact. It’s just because the fire, depending on the fact, the mind, and as soon as we stand up, the I or sitting doesn’t exist. It empirically exists. Your body could walk out of the room and get a cup of tea. It would be very convenient. You could sit here and continue to listen to me and walk out and your body could go out and get a cup of tea. But that’s not possible. It was inherently existing. But the eye, that eye is just an illusion. An I that can go out of the room and your body can go out of the room. That is an illusion. It does exist. The knowledge that you can relate to the one that’s sitting here is just something that comes into existence momentarily. due to the line, due to the fact that the five aggregates are building the two of them. And then the five aggregates do something else. And so the line on the inland exceeds the four of them. In this regard, neither the continuity of the assembly of the abrogates, nor the continuity of the assembly of the abrogates. So we say, when we look at the picture of the earth. [end unchecked]

in in this regard, neither the continuity of the assembly of the

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:51:40-00:52:20] a three-year-old baby, you say, oh, that’s when I was 30. But that body, you say, it’s my body, my baby body. Because there’s the continuity of the aggregates. They say, scientifically, I’ve been listening, every seven years, every atom of our body is replaced. The thing is, you get older, you get older, you have older atoms, crummy ones, someone else threw away or something that is linked with bodies, but anyway, they’re different. So anyway. [end unchecked]

aggregates nor the assembly itself, nor the parts of the assembly, nor the continuity of the

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:52:50-00:54:29] on the various parts such as the wheels none of its individual parts nor the collection of the parts is the chariot or is the car you investigate most people here probably own the car but if you investigate you can’t find this inheritance the parts are the car wheels all four wheels not one not one wheel of your car is your car the steering wheel is in your car the spare wheel is in your car The doors out of the car, the roof is in the car, the bumpers, and still there is a car. The car is what’s merely labeled by the mind on, not on the car, but in the car. Because there is a car, it’s possible for the mind to conceive. What is being referred to here is a process of analyzing. It’s called the seven-point analysis. [end unchecked]

assembly, So, yeah, what what has been referred to here is a process of analyzing.

This is called seven point analysis. So

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:54:29-00:55:55] So you only mention a subtle thing. But you check whether, you know, they always talk about a chariot. So you check whether the car is inherently one with the parts, inherently separate or different from the parts. If the car, if your car, was inherently different from the wheels of, a car inherently possess its parts, on its parts. Likewise, it was said in a sutra, just as we speak of a chariot, it’s human. [end unchecked]

we speak of person conventionally. Such a technique for determining the selflessness of a person is one of the best methods for cognizing the reality of things. Same reasoning should be applied to all phenomena. Well, not just this selflessness of the person.

For this reason, whether something is inherently dependent on its parts, separate from its parts and so on. This can be

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:56:38-00:57:20] person for this reason whether something was inherently dependent on its part separate from its part this can be applied to all phenomena conform up to the culture upon mission one in order to determine in such a way that there is no inherently existing person we establish that there is no inherently existing i and then that there is no inherently existing so firstly [end unchecked]

So firstly, when we generate the view of selflessness in our mental continuum through the force of logical reasoning, being free from

[Unchecked machine transcript 00:57:20-01:02:31] when we generate the view of selflessness in our mental continuum due to the faultless logical reasoning of being free from being inherently one or many, the connected object of true existence is not observed. So if we do this analysis correctly with a concentrated mind, use the new reasoning to see that the I is inherently free. The I is free from being inherently one or inherently the same as the basis. Firstly, when we generate the view of selflessness, due to the focused logical reasoning of being free from being inherently one or free from being inherently many, the connected object, true existence, is not observed, we start to realise its enemies. And through the reasoning, end of the horizon, the opposite of true existence is observed. Having examined our own continuum to begin with, the vital point is to recognize how the innate misconception of the self of a person consumes its object. This is already unexplained. Anyway, what he’s saying there in this last book is that we have to firstly recognize how the innate conception of grasping the true existence creates the illusion which we think is an illusion of an inherently existing I so we have to be able to identify that it is as possible so this is one of the most difficult things to do this is why we are And of course we have to rely on the effect teacher to explain all these things to the virus so that we can, at the end, develop some kind of concentration so that we don’t identify And unfortunately, this text here doesn’t really talk about in a very practical way how to do that, but it does explain in other texts. And basically, what one does is to, in meditation, what we try to do is what we think of a situation where, like the sense of I, is always with us. But most of the time, it’s not very strong. And we’re not really aware of the thought behind there. But there are certain situations in our life where the thought of I, the grasping of me, arises very, very strong. And of course, probably the most obvious example is when we get afraid. And when we become very afraid and being threatened by something or someone, then the thought comes. So what one does is we try to ignore them and try to recall the situation where such as when you just thought arising very strongly or another situation it depends on our personality and also what our experiences are also when we’re very embarrassed with the thought of art arising from astronomy we feel incredibly embarrassed or humiliated the thought of i was pretty strong also maybe when we’re very happy but maybe not [end unchecked]

elaborations. So the idea, the tricky thing is to

[Unchecked machine transcript 01:02:40-01:09:07] There was a situation when you were prayed, instead of thought of crying, arising to be extremely strong. Certainly when you were insulted, before you cried, then arise very strong. So the idea, the tricky thing, is to remember the incident. And you don’t want to remember an incident too far in the past, because one, especially when you were young, you can make it an incident when you were very afraid of the virus or this or that. when I was very young, although that was asked. So we were kind of different people. So we need to kind of remember an instant, not too far. So we try and remember that instant in order to try and put ourselves back into that feeling. But the tricky thing to avoid is to not get caught up in that instant and get distracted by the instant. So it’s not the point to just to remember it in order to help our lives to go into the feeling of life. And the idea is to not hold onto the incident, but to try to hold onto that feeling of life. And then the truth is to then hold on to that thought of I and then try and look at it and try and think, what did I believe that I was? How was that I, this I that was so frightened and embarrassed or happy or ashamed or in the United, what was that I? Was it my body? And the point, of course, is we’re not trying to tell ourselves what the Buddhist answer is. It’s what we’re trying to identify our wrong view. To get rid of the wrong view, one has to identify. We don’t get rid of the wrong view by just simply saying, oh, the right view is according to this. That won’t make us realize anything. identify the object to the future, the object to the future, this appearance of the real I that we believe in, this is you. So once one’s done that, then the analysis of applying the imaginary present human logic starts working because you have the wrong view, but then you apply the logic that says, yes. I look like this, I seem to exist in this, but that is when I’m doing a service, or Jamie Girtley’s service, or Amazon Baptist’s service, or my guru’s service, I couldn’t exist that way because it wasn’t there. If we do that enough times, with a very still, concentrated mind, eventually the harassment will just be done. Like I said, in a simple way, On the basis of seeing a rope, in my ignorance, the view of a snake, and I’ll ask that that view is true. But if someone in trust tells us it could not possibly have seen it as dark, because there are no snakes here, there never been any snakes, then why you saw a snake is because there was, you saw something which looked like a snake, and what made it look like a snake was because it was dark, and you knew anything, and you had no intention. And if one listens to that long enough, the grasping of one sort of snake will disappear. Grasping of a snake is very easy. But the grasping itself has been existing since during the period. So basically, what is happening here is the author is presenting a meditation technique, realising it into, it helps us realise it into this, called the four points analysis. [end unchecked]

So, basically, what what is happening here is the the author is presenting a meditation technique, realizing it helps us realize it

[Unchecked machine transcript 01:09:09-01:09:40] So some of you, probably not all of you, are familiar with this technique. So the four points of the four pointing notes are, firstly, finding the object. Unfortunately, the first part is the most difficult, but once one’s got that, in this really world situation, I’m sorry I keep emphasizing how difficult it is to actually find the object. [end unchecked]

is So even though I’m I’m sorry I keep emphasizing how difficult it used to to actually find the object of negation. Even though it’s difficult, the only way difficult things get started. That’s exactly what the Lamrim is all about. Do things step by step.

And so it’s always incredibly helpful, I think, and encouraging

[Unchecked machine transcript 01:10:11-01:11:01] of the mind, even the derivative sphere of mind, is that if you allow the mind to go through the power of familiarity, the mind can know and understand. The mind is that which knows. You remember knowing just doesn’t mean that there’s no experience of seeing. Understanding emptiness is something very difficult, but by familiarizing to it, I’d say the word open enough. [end unchecked]

All I’m just doing is a

[Unchecked machine transcript 01:11:02-01:12:18] by familiarizing man-self with the same thing, it becomes… So my point is we can try and do this now in a simple way, sort of sit down quietly and try and find the object by recalling different situations. I mean, in one session we should only really think of one situation or one situation and try. thinking about yourself at that time and trying to identify that. So in another meditation, you can think of another situation. I mean, oh, I can stay in the same situation. There’s a situation of being experienced to help us try and get that sense of self as much as possible. So that’s the first point of identifying the object of reputation. The second point of the thought [end unchecked]

simulation exercise to help us try and get that sense of self as much as possible. So that’s that’s the first point of identifying the object of negation. The sec second point of the four point analysis is is what is being referred to. It’s it’s mentioned in this next chapter, this next paragraph where we have to come to this definite conclusion, definite understanding in

[Unchecked machine transcript 01:12:50-01:13:56] this inherently existing I, which is a period of creation. So if that inherently existing I really did exist, then it could only exist in one or two ways. It would either have to be inherently oneness with the five neighborhoods, or it would have to be inherently separate to five. There are no other possibilities. only those two possibilities. So this is something that we have to really understand, because if we think there’s a third possibility or a fourth or fifth possibility of how we know that this could exist, we would continue to grasp that. But if we start to realise that it could only exist in these two ways, and then when we realise that those two could, then one goes on to do the analysis of the other two. [end unchecked]

in these two ways, and then when we realize that those two could not both be true, one goes on to do the analysis of the other two parts of the

[Unchecked machine transcript 01:13:57-01:14:40] Parts of the fourth ordinances are checking whether the I is inherently one or the other. We should come to the conclusion that’s impossible. Then we check, well, is the inherently existing I inherently separate? We have problems in the logic come to the understanding that that I can’t exist only. So then we derive the I inherently exist. But if we think there’s another, a third or a fourth possibility, [end unchecked]

analysis. There’s no middle — — either it has to exist this way or that way. Anyway, we’re going to that.

It says, in determining selflessness by means of the reasoning that things are free of existing truly as one or as truly distinct from the basis of imputation, were the person to exist inherently, it would have to exist invariably as one entity in the aggregates or as a different entity. These are the only two possibilities of how an inherently existing It has definitely no other mode of existence than these two. This is because, in general, whenever we prove that any phenomenon such as a vase has parts, its opposite, that it is partless, is refuted. So if if we if we prove to ourselves that a vase has parts, this also proves that vase can’t be partless. Right?

Like like, when we validly establish that a single object is partless, the opposite that it it has parts is refuted. So if we prove something is partless, we show it has parts; if it has parts, it means that it doesn’t have no parts. Actually, there’s no such thing as something as partless anyway. So that’s Everything’s got parts. Directional parts.

So as there is no way for something to exist apart from its either being the same as or different from something else, we should be convinced that there is no other mode of existence than these two. So either the eye we’re not talking about the eye that value exists. We’re talking about the object in the future inherently existing

[Unchecked machine transcript 01:17:41-01:18:59] If that inherently existing I really did exist, other than being an illusion, it does exist as an illusion, right? Just like the water, the mirage in the desert creates the illusion of water. The illusion of water exists. The water, basically. The illusion of an inherent is the problem. But if an inherently existing I existed, it can only be somehow oneness with these five aggregates, or it’s got to be something completely different. There’s no other possibility. It’s either connected with this meaning, this stuff, the five in the body and the mind, or it’s got nothing to do with the body. There’s no other alternative you can think of that’s possible. Can you? But anyway, [end unchecked]

. Possible. Can you?

But, anyway, we should be convinced that this is this is the case. Because if we’re not, then we will never get rid of the wrong people because we’ll think all the the the somehow, I could exist in some other way. But why? Okay. So If we think if if we if we find the object to be and we we might that that object to be viewed may appear as though are inherently one by way of their own characteristics.

The first concerns the fallacies of asserting yourself as such. So the way this is put here

[Unchecked machine transcript 01:20:36-01:21:08] puts it much more simply to that whole trial. And the Lam Rim actually gives many more examples, well, like Chandrakirti and so on, many, many examples of this here. This text is just giving a very, very condensed presentation of it, which makes it quite difficult. Anyway, it goes on to say, if the self and the aggregates were of one nature, [end unchecked]

which makes it quite difficult. Anyway, it goes on to say, if the self and the aggregates were of one nature, existing by way of their own characteristics, the cognition to which they appear as an object would be undistorted. This is because it would be a consciousness to which inherent existence appear as an object. When it goes on to say this will be similar to the view of

[Unchecked machine transcript 01:22:08-01:22:41] is meant to make it easier to understand the sentences above than actually. To explain those sentences is really critical, so we’ll just explain it as it doesn’t flow, so we’ll just stay with these sentences that we first sent out, the two sentences. If the self and aggregates were of one nature, existing by way of their own characteristics, the cognition to which they appeared as an object would be undistorted. [end unchecked]

that that those So this would be implying that the mind is perceiving the person existing

[Unchecked machine transcript 01:24:05-01:24:34] So it’s only when we have realized that the way things appear and the way they exist completely. So right now we are incapable of when we look and experience something, the way things appear to our consciousnesses, our higher consciousness and so on, is it doesn’t match the way they actually exist. [end unchecked]

.

We would be person would appear to our ordinary consciousnesses the way it appears. In other words, we would be an ordinary person would be realizing emptiness of things just automatically because their appearance and the way that exist match because if the person was exactly the same as the aggregates and we could perceive them directly, So it goes on to say, in this context, if self and the aggregates are of one nature, the final way in which the self and aggregates exist must be consistent with the way in which they appear to conceptual thought. In that case, they could not appear as two different things Because the way they appear to conceptuality and the way the two objects exist should be consistent, and the object’s mode of existence is held to be of one nature in terms of inherent existence. If that was so, these two would be one without the slightest distinction. And from that point of view, even their appearing separately to thought would be impossible.

So I think in a very simple gross form, what this means is if a person was inherently one with five aggregates, that’s not no. No. Don’t that’s a whole other thing. Don’t get into that one yet. Know?

Or I also would apply to yourself when you look at your own toe and think that’s me. Yes. And it goes on to say, since the aggregates are adopted at birth and discarded at death, to assert such a self, a self that was the same as the aggregates, would be meaningless because the self would be terminated as being merely a portion of the aggregates. So this is pertinent because it it would also mean if the I was the same as the aggregates, of course, there wouldn’t be rebirth. Of course, if we don’t have much strong belief in that that that would be very effective that if one has strong belief

[Unchecked machine transcript 01:30:15-01:30:44] very effective, that if one has strong belief, or even for some realized belief, some actual experience of past lives and so on, then this argument is very powerful. Because if I was the same as the aggregate existence, the aggregate has only come into existence in this life, that means I have only existed in this life. There’s no previous I. [end unchecked]

in past and future lives.

Of course, this is one of the reasons why people don’t believe find it difficult to believe in past and future lives because they do have this wrong view that I am the body

[Unchecked machine transcript 01:31:30-01:32:05] people should help you if there was an abortion and it was right to this thing and it’s not in the room it’s nothing so you know you can have an abortion because there’s not a person because somehow you know I don’t agree to this when you’ve been a person but if that went from this thing it becomes a person exactly I don’t know if people actually ever talk about that because actually people are talking about it and of course if you’re saying abortion is not [end unchecked]

. So the fundamental treatise called Wisdom, which is Nāgārjuna’s text says, there is no self apart from that designated upon the contaminated aggregates, meaning designated upon the contaminated aggregates. If when they act as such, the contaminated aggregates aggregates themselves and the self, your self will be nonexistent. In other words, that second sentence is saying, if the aggregates were somehow to mysteriously become yourself, then yourself would become nonexistent when you lose the aggregates.

Okay? None of this is just

[Unchecked machine transcript 01:33:43-01:34:32] which is dismissed by materialistic science. There’s just so many people who have had these experiences. I’m not one of them. There are so many people who are not heard. When you go further into this point, you can also think oneness with the aggregates, because there are five aggregates. So are you oneness with all of the five aggregates? [end unchecked]

completely In in when you go in further into this point, you can also one with the aggregates — because there are five aggregates, so are you one with all five aggregates, or four of them, three of them, two of them? Which one? Are you one with the body? Just

[Unchecked machine transcript 01:34:33-01:35:06] four of them, three of them, two of them, which one? One is called the body, just the body, or the mind, and then if you think. Because in trying to identify the object being refuted, again, like everything, it’s a mind ring, it’s a graduated path, so we can’t immediately sit in meditation with one session, then go, identify the object with refutation. It’s through purifying our mind. [end unchecked]

something to think about, that’s what I’m asking about.

It’s just, you know, a gross. It’s good to destroy that. But we may be grasping, thinking I am the body, but then am I all the body? Am I grasping that I’m all the body? Am I oneness with the whole body?

Or does it feel like I am in one part? So which

[Unchecked machine transcript 01:35:46-01:37:27] But then you think, if I’m just a body, then my mind is, you know, I don’t know how it deals with it, but for someone who’s very deep refuge and so on, like these masters, that argument that we are oneness with the activists. then it wouldn’t have existed before, or won’t exist in the future. That one is extremely convincing. For us, we can have such strong minds, etc., but we don’t have much experience, or any experience, that some kind of feel that’s the right, and we don’t have some logic to it, it’s not so strong, etc. But then it goes on to think about the consequences of the self in memory. So the second fallacy of the self-makers are one by nature. [end unchecked]

So the second fallacy of the self being one by nature is that it would follow there would be many selves

[Unchecked machine transcript 01:37:27-01:38:46] is that there would consequently be many selves, because there are many aggregates, and even the body, even if we think I’m oneness with the body, and since the body is made up in many parts, there’s the arms and the legs and the head, and also different substances, the skin and the blood, many, many different things, if I was inherently oneness, with the body. And since the body is many, they have many things, it really has to be many I’s. But we’re not grasping at it inherently, this isn’t many eyes, grasping at one. The object to be refuted, when it’s actually found, isn’t many eyes, it’s just right. And again, with our levels of ignorance, right now, we do, in a sense, grasp what we are. When someone says you’re beautiful, [end unchecked]

So

[Unchecked machine transcript 01:38:47-01:39:34] and someone says, you know, this looks stupid, honestly, and you’re so clever, and you’re this, like that. So people say things and grasp that, and our own minds tells us things and grasp those things. But despite all those things, and all those superficial I’s that we have, deep down, we’re still grasping, and essentially, there’s the real, there’s the superficial noise, there’s the real noise. [end unchecked]

the consequence so one of the crazy consequences — and remember, Prasanga means consequence. So they point out all the consequences of wrong views that the people who hold them, that is us, don’t think of, don’t realize. So one consequence of it follows from grasping that the self is the same as the aggregates is that it would follow that since there are there are many aggregates, there there will be many selves. Or the other way is that if if there’s if we call it as one self and that the one self is inseparably one with the aggregates.

It would have to follow that there’s only one aggregate. But actually, And each aggregate So either if if the self is one with the aggregates, it have to be lots of selves or only one aggregate. Neither of these makes any sense. So I can see this is causing a frown. This could be due to my very poor explanation, but I won’t accept that.

I would say it’s due to your confused mind. Same to me. So I’m just joking. But but, I mean, the point I’m trying to make here as a joke is something we can put. The mind that is understanding you is a pretty confused mind, which is supposed to be as well.

And we’ve all seen things that we’re trying to make sense of these things with a mind that doesn’t have a lot of merit, that isn’t purified, that is has, you know, ancient wrong views. So even if we intellectually understand, we start to understand

[Unchecked machine transcript 01:43:00-01:43:28] So it’s having very little impact on our own view. So that’s why we have to really think about these arguments again and again and reflect on them, analyze them, let them sink into our consciousness. Because then they will start to make some impact. We have to let them. This is the only way. [end unchecked]

You know, we have to really drive it into our consciousness and also into a consciousness that is more and more focused, clear, virtuous. Through the merits of these virtuous actions, now quickly attain the state of the all-knowing and lead all sentient beings without exception into that enlightened state. May the precious bodhichitta not yet born arise arise and flourish. May that born have no decline but increase forevermore.

The object of refuge of myself and all transmigration beings in all our lifetimes.

[Unchecked machine transcript 01:45:16-01:48:26] The Master, Padmasambhava, the Dharma, Kim, Songst and Gamble and Chichon Vetson, the Abbot, Shantra, Akshita, and the number of holy queens observed and spread through the Dharma and Tibet, and the Tibetan people who practiced and served Buddhism so faithfully for a thousand years, as well as those who along with many others died sacrificing their lives for Tibet and its holidays, may all their positive worship be put over the medium realm. Due to their limitless kindness, the sum of Tibetan Buddhism was known as in the West, which was a long way. But now that I have met the Dharma, I have received a perfect human rebirth, enabling me to live in the world. Our refuge and savior, the supreme one, his Holiness to the Dharma Dharma, and the Tibetan people with him, served on to us. Remembering this, we make the following dedicated prayer. May all his wholeness to the Dharma Dharma’s wishes be successful immediately. May the snow land together achieve good freedom, and develop the Buddha Dharma even more than before on his day. And may all mother transform your grace with the wisdom of the Buddha. [unclear, 6 s] So there is one announcement. [end unchecked]

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top