Mind Training — 2014-02-27

1 h 59 min · 10,894 words · 27 February 2014 · Buddha House Adelaide

Mind Training (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Mind Training (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Mind Training — 2014-02-27
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this nearly two-hour session, Ven Thubten Dondrub teaches on Mind Training, focusing on Buddhist philosophical schools and their interpretations of emptiness. After opening prayers and bodhicitta motivation, he walks through the four major Buddhist philosophical traditions—Vaibhāṣika, Sautrāntika, Cittamātra, and Mādhyamika—explaining how each school differently understands the selflessness of persons and phenomena. The core teaching compares the Mādhyamika Svatāntrika view, which holds that phenomena arise dependently yet inherently exist, against the Prāsaṇgika view that nothing inherently exists at all. Using examples like flowers, sandwiches, and rainbows, Dondrub explores how objects require a valid base and a labeling mind, and how our fundamental ignorance mistakes merely labeled phenomena for inherently existing things. He emphasizes identifying the actual object of negation through direct experience rather than intellectual understanding alone, and clarifies that labeling itself is not the problem—the problem is grasping phenomena as truly existing independent of mind. Aimed at serious practitioners with prior study of Buddhist philosophy and initiation background.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2014 02 27 Mind Training.mp3

UUID: e0689fe0-b8e2-47dd-a720-66f38ca7288c

Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub

Collection: Mind Training (Ven Thubten Dondrub)

Date: 2014-02-27

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 119.8 minutes

Words: ~10,891

The mind training like the rays of the sun. So this is about bodhicitta, the two kinds of bodhicitta. The conventional bodhicitta seeking to achieve enlightenment to benefit others, and the ultimate bodhicitta is the wisdom realizing the empty nature of self and phenomena so that is necessary to achieve enlightenment. So since this is our topic, we should try to have motivation that corresponds with the topic. So as much as possible, to generate the bodhicitta motivation for being here.

The basic ingredients of generating bodhicitta are having refuge in the triple gem which leads us to develop faith in our own Buddha nature, recognizing that we have the precious human rebirth, the optimum chance to realize our Buddha potential, and then being motivated to do so by recognizing as deeply as possible our connection with all sentient beings, how immensely kind they are in every way, and especially realizing more and more deeply how all these immensely kind beings who’ve all been our mothers many times, have been our fathers many times, are suffering in cyclic existence helplessly. And because of that, in their confusion, trying to be free of Samsāra or trying to be free of suffering they are actually over and over again creating the causes to perpetuate their own Samsāra, their own suffering. So then we can generate that thought that no matter what, I must use this in all future lives to overcome the self-cherishing thought that has harmed me since during beginningless time is the greatest obstacle to benefiting others. So I to dedicate to overcoming that and instead, developing the mind, cherishing others, more than self. And this way generating that intense determination to achieve enlightenment for the sake of all beings.

So to achieve enlightenment, we have to understand the essential causes of it which are generating the conventional bodhicitta and then realizing the ultimate bodhicitta. And since this text is about these topics, then for the sake of all sentient beings, I will study this text. So we oh, that was the motivation which I give later, isn’t it? Don’t forget it anyway. So before sorry.

So so before we focus on that, but before we lose sight of it, firstly, we do the preliminary prayers, freeing eliminating obstacles with a prayer to the lion-faced dakini. Page five. I prostrate to the gathering of dakinis and the three chakras who abide in the holy yoga of using space. By your powers of clairvoyance and magic illumination, look after practitioners like a mother her child. Om Ah Ra Pa Tsa Na Dhi, Gate, Pāragate, Parasamgate, bodhi Svāhā.

By the teachings of the three supreme jewels possessing the power of truth, may inner and outer hindrances be transformed. May they be dispelled. May they be pacified. May they be completely pacified. May all negative forces opposed to dharma be completely pacified, may the host of eighty thousand obstacles be pacified, may we be separated from problems and harmful conditions to dharma, may all enjoyments be in accord with the dharma, and may there be auspiciousness and perfect happiness here right now.

Obeisance to my guru and protector, Mañjuśrī, who holds to his scriptural text symbolic of his seeing all things as they are, whose understanding shines forth as the sun unclouded by defilements or traces of ignorance, who teaches in sixty ways with the patient love of a father for his only child, all creatures caught in the prison of Samsāra, confused in the darkness of their ignorance, overwhelmed by their suffering. You whose dragon thunder proclamation of the dharma arouses us from the stupor of our delusions and frees us from the iron chains of our karma, whose powerful sword of wisdom hews down suffering wherever its sprouts appear, clearing away the darkness of all ignorance. I entreat you, o Mañjuśrī, whose princely body is adorned with the one hundred and twelve marks of a Buddha who has completed the ten stages achieving the highest perfection of a bodhisattva, who has been pure from the beginning. O Mañjuśrī, o loving one, with the brilliance of your wisdom, illuminate the darkness enclosing my mind, enlighten my intelligence and wisdom so that I may gain insight into Buddha’s words and the text that explain them. So then particularly visualizing Śākyamūni Buddha in front of us as the embodiment of the Three Jewels of refuge and all their wonderful qualities, the embodiment of all our perfect teachers of the past, present, future.

We offer the mandala as a way to request the teachings, to eliminate obstacles, to understanding and practicing them, helping to accumulate the merit that enables us to gain the authentic realizations. So then, as we say, the prayer of refuge in bodhicitta that was composed by the great bodhisattva, Lama Atisha, then really trying to generate that bodhicitta motivation as much as possible, thinking of the Buddha in front of us and all sentient beings surrounding us. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, Dharma, and the supreme assembly. By the merits I create through listening to the Dharma, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings. So we can think that the Buddha is pleased with our motivation and shows this by now coming above the crown of our head.

And when directly above our crown, we imagine the Buddha then dissolving into golden light, that blissful light pouring down into us, blessing our mind so that we can really understand these teachings, blessing our mind to be able to put them into practice, blessing our mind so that we can, at some point, gain the authentic realizations. So then just briefly doing the the nine round breathing exercise to help that positive mind, to strengthen that and make it a little bit more calmer, clearer, more concentrated so that we can use that mind to listen to and think about the Buddha’s teachings tonight. Okay. Thank you very much. Why have we got that little thing there in the way?

Couldn’t don’t let go away. Okay. So I’m sorry that this is not very inspiring or encouraging or and and probably is very disconcerting for me to say at the very beginning. I’ve spent this afternoon racking my brain trying to understand this next section of the text. But I really can’t make head and tail of some of it really.

As I said before, I did receive a full commentary on this text, beautiful commentary, one of the nicest teachings I’ve ever received actually I think from Geshe Jampa Tegchok when he was the abbot of Nālānda monastery. So that that was fantastic. So we went through this text in quite a lot of detail. But I don’t have, like, absolute detailed notes of the on on this, so I just have to wing it as I go along. And, of course, one excuse is that when the Geshees teach these texts, they have another text which explains it, and they read they just read that out as and I don’t have that, you see.

So that’s my excuse. So and when when you’re trying to work out how another person is arguing something, it’s much more difficult than when you’re trying to oh, hi. Sorry. This is a very complicated subject we’re into here. When one is trying to work out the way another person is trying to present, is quite difficult.

And also, just as another excuse, that when Geshe Tegchok was going through this text, he did point out that there were errors in the translation. And some of the English here isn’t so great, so it’s it’s not really very clear. Anyway, we’ll try and make some sense of at least some of the essence of this. Because really the way this is presented I think I mentioned this at the very beginning of when we started this text which was a year ago now that the author of this text is Horton Namkha Pel who was a direct disciple of Lama So it is believed that actually this text is basically notes that Horton Namkha Pel took while he was receiving an oral commentary from Lama Tsongkhapa. So in a sense, this is really Lama Tsongkhapa explaining, commenting on the seven point mind training.

Just like, as some of you might know, Pabongka Rinpoche’s liberation in the palm of your hand, that that text is based on notes that he took when he was receiving an oral commentary from Trijang Rinpoche. No. No. No. No.

Sorry. Other way around. These are notes Trijang Rinpoche took when when he was receiving an oral commentary by Pabongka Rinpoche. Trijang Rinpoche, who was one of the great lamas of Gelugpa tradition and the junior tutor of his holiness, received these teachings from Pabongka Rinpoche, took notes, and that got transformed into this book called Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand, where the author is said to be Pabongka Rinpoche, but it was actually written down by Trijang Rinpoche. So in the same way, this has been written down by Horton Namkha Pel, but it’s notes that he took mostly from oral teachings from Lama Tsongkhapa.

And, of course, Lama Tsongkhapa would have been teaching monks in a monastery who would have been studying this topic in great detail. So this first part is really just summarizing for those people who already have a very clear knowledge of all these different four schools of Buddhist philosophy, etcetera, and all the fine details. So when we approach it, if we haven’t got that background, it is really, really very tricky. So we’ll just do a quick summary of what I tried to go through last week because I’m I’m not sure if you memorized it all and remember it all. Right.

So I I’m gonna have to do my stand up routine again, I think. Maybe I could go to the fringe and be with my stand up routine. Okay. So there are there are four schools of of of philosophy. Right?

So can anyone tell me what they are? First one, the simplest one is sorry? Buddhist philosophy. Sorry? Which one?

The first one? No. No. No. No.

The simplest one. The lowest level. Basic one. God. Wild guesses.

Wild guesses. It’s called the Vaibhāṣika. And then the second school is called. Yes. Sautrāntika.

Yeah. And then the so these two philosophical schools, which belong to which tradition or vehicle? Good, right. The Hīnayāna. Or the individual vehicle.

Oh, is that right? Yeah. Which, the only form of that, vehicle existing these days is the Theravāda. So then these other two philosophical schools are of the Mahāyāna. So the first one is the Cittamātra.

Which means mind only. Right? Mind only. So which school of Mahāyāna Buddhism particularly practices is based on this these days? Did mention last week.

Zen Buddhism Buddhism their view is on the first Cittamātra sutras. Alright. So these two schools are based on sutras of the well, oh, yes. Anyway. Let’s leave that.

And then the highest school is called what? Right. The Mādhyamika, which means middle way, and there are two divisions of it. All these schools have subdivisions, but we’re not going to go into those. Right?

But this one has two divisions. So the first one, the lower one, is called the Svatāntrika. Yes. Svatāntrika. And the other one is called the Prāsaṇgika.

Prāsaṇgika. Prāsaṇgika which means what? Prāsaṇgika means consequences. You’re not you’re you we have to have someone who the consequence school. And so this school represents it is argued. It represents the actual view of the Buddha about the nature of things, and this is the view that we have to develop eventually.

Firstly, we need an intellectual understanding of it. And by the and through that, we will be able to destroy ignorance and directly perceive the reality as it’s described conceptually in this school. But as I said, in order to get to this view, to really understand it, we firstly have to understand, this school first, get some idea of what it means. This will help us understand these views, then the Cittamātra, and then eventually the highest view to get to the real subtle aspect of what the Prāsaṇgika school is saying. So last week in the text, it was talking about the the four seals of of the four seals of Buddhism.

So these are four unique aspects of the Buddha’s teaching or the teach you know, the four teachings of the Buddha, four viewpoints which are completely unique to Buddhism. So do we little all good little Buddhists should know these. Right. All compounded phenomena are impermanent. So what does compounded mean?

Yes, brought together by causes and conditions. Impermanent what does impermanent mean? Yes. What does permanent mean? Never changing.

Yes, yes. So impermanent means changing. Right. And more specifically it means changing moment by moment. Moment by moment.

Right. So that’s the first one. Number two. Yes. All contaminated.

Phenomena are suffering meaning they act as a condition for us to experience suffering. All contaminated phenomena are suffering. That’s why just connecting to what we were talking about last week a lot of people who came last night were talking about the Pure Lands. When you’re born in the Pure Land, there are no contaminated phenomena. So there’s nothing there in that realm to bring suffering.

Everything there just encourages one to experience the Dharma, to realize the Dharma. But here we are getting to the main one related to our topic. Well, I went through all of this. Really important to try and especially if you are coming to this is your one dose of dharma for the week to try and really the expression is? Oh, yeah.

All phenomena are selfless. Yes. Ah, selfless. And the fourth one is Yeah. But why is nirvana peace?

And it means only nirvana is peace. That’s what’s implied. Only the state of nirvana is real peace. Nothing else is actual peace. Peace meaning total freedom from suffering, the experience which has no suffering whatsoever.

Pure bliss, joy. Yeah. Well, I mean, nirvana is where ignorance is totally eliminated. Right? So only that state is peace.

So I okay. So this is the key one with with we’re dealing with here. Often. So the four seals of Buddhism, all four schools accept these because these are the seals, defining features of Buddhist philosophy, the Buddhist view. So they all accept them, of course, unfortunately for us, they interpret them, especially this one, in different ways.

So how do these two lower schools interpret this? Anyone remember? What do they interpret that to mean? That all phenomena are selfless. Sorry?

Yes. Yes. Okay. Oh, no. The Buddha never had to do this.

I think he was able to project his voice forever. Yes. So how the how the two lower schools interpret all phenomena is because we can divide everything that exists into the self, the person, okay, the person and everything which is not the person which is phenomena. So the lower schools interpret that phenomena, all phenomena meaning everything, actually they just interpret it as the phenomena referring to the person that all persons are without a self. They don’t substantially exist.

They don’t truly exist. Right? But everything that is not the person, ordinary phenomena, our bodies, our, you know, the external world, they accept that. They they say that these things truly exist. The way they appear, that they’re really there the way they appeared to us.

Right? So the the the two Mahāyāna schools, they accept this literally that it means both person and phenomena are selfless. Okay, before we go on When we talk about the selflessness of the person, each of the four schools has a different view of what that means. And one interpretation that all of the four schools accept is that they reject the non-Buddhist view of the person. Which is?

The non Buddhists talk about an Ātman, the person. And what are the features of that person? What have I done with my book? I’ve put it over here, haven’t I? Does anyone any of them?

Yes. They say that there is a person or a self which is permanent partless and independent. So when especially the lower schools talk about the selflessness of a person, Their understanding of the selflessness of a person is a person there is a person that does exist but is not permanent, not partless, not independent. So there is that selflessness, the lacking of a a self that is permanent, partless, and independent. And very specifically, in this context, permanent means not subject to not subject to production and disintegration destruction.

In other words, this person hasn’t come into existence due to causes and conditions and it doesn’t go out of existence. It’s not subject to these things. So it’s permanent. It doesn’t change. Alright?

And it’s partless, and it has no parts. It’s just this one holistic thing this person, this Ātman and it’s independent meaning not subject to causes and conditions. So these lower schools argue, especially the lower schools argue, if one comes to a realization that the the person is is selfless, that is is lacking being permanent, partless, independent, when one truly realizes that completely, not just knows it or has an intellectual understanding of it, but when one directly realizes that, then that will destroy ignorance and one will one will be one will become an Arahant, one will achieve nirvana. But, of course, the upper schools say, no, it won’t. Because they because they say that is not the actual root, that that is not that view of a permanent, partless, and independent self.

It is a type of ignorance, but it isn’t the subtle ignorance that is the root cause of Samsāra. Remember we talked about or the text talked about I think I need to sit down. That in order to get rid of ignorance, one shouldn’t one has to find the object to be refuted. One has to identify the wrong view as it as we’re experiencing it. And one can make the danger make the mistake of refuting too much, saying nothing exists, or we can make the make the mistake of not refuting enough.

So what the Mādhyamika pras prasangika school is saying is that the non-Buddhist for sure and even the lower Buddhist philosophical schools or the followers of those schools, they don’t refute enough. They just refute this view, but that’s not the totality of the wrong view. It’s just one aspect. So just refuting a little bit of the wrong view isn’t going to destroy ignorance. It may harm it to some extent, but it’s not going to eliminate it.

And if you think about it, all of us right now have this kind of wrong view that we we tend to one aspect of our ignorance, not the deepest level, but one aspect of our ignorance grasps that there is a me that is a self, that the person me who has a name, whatever it is, that that person is is is permanent. It’s it’s partless. It’s not made up of different things. There’s this real me, the essential me. Right?

And it it’s it’s independent. It doesn’t depend on causes and conditions. For example, we grasp that I am not my I don’t depend on my body. A gross level of our ignorance right now is believing there is a real me that doesn’t exist depending on my body. I’m I’m independent of my body.

The real me is independent of my body and mind. Check up. Yeah. Yes. Yeah.

But yeah. But that’s just but that’s not yes. But that’s not the deep yeah. But it’s just a gross level of ignorance. It’s not the deepest level.

Level, but it’s very helpful to be able to identify that. That is why, you know, just to give some simple examples, we can do things like smoke lots of cigarettes and think, I won’t get sick. I won’t get cancer. You know, I I can drive through a red light, but I won’t have an accident. I I can take drugs, and I won’t become addicted.

I can eat whatever I like and won’t get fat. It’s because we think, I I’m separate from my body. There’s a a real me. And, especially, we make this major mistake that we think I can be happy without taking care of my mind. This is the big mistake of that gross ignorance because we think there’s a real I that is has got isn’t I mean, the average person certainly doesn’t doesn’t think about the mind and me.

But and they people live their life where the emphasis has got nothing to do with taking care of the mind. It’s all about taking care of our body, our reputation, taking care of our possessions, our money, our bank account, our appearance. It’s all about almost entirely about that. Because we think, you know, yeah, anyway, but not but somehow, I will be happy. Not taking care of my mind, having delusions, not doing anything about them, I’ll be fine, which shows we believe I am separate from the mind.

You know? Somehow the mind can be completely berserk like that, but I’ll be happy because there’s a real I, an independent I. But the I that does exist is something that only exists depending on the mind. It’s not something, you know, there’s the me that there’s the mind it’s complicated there’s the mind, and because there is the mind, there is a ‘me’ that is somehow separate but depends on it. But really, the ‘me’ that exists can only exist nominally because there is a mind and the mind is in a particular state.

So if the mind is angry, the only ‘I’ that can exist is an angry ‘I’. It’s a new ‘I’ and then when the mind calms down and it’s not angry, there’s another ‘I’ a not angry ‘I’ arising moment by moment. That’s the only ‘I’ that exists, that’s not permanent and not independent. Anyway, this is a gross view that We have to get rid of that one in order to be able to discover get to peel away the layers of ignorance, to be able to discover the the the the deepest aspect of ignorance, how it grasps that there is an I that inherently exists. Oh, I left my book over there.

Thanks. Any questions? Thanks. Yeah. That’s okay.

Right. Right. Yes. Yes. Yes.

Because in the different sutras, the Buddha taught different things. And so after the passing of the Buddha, then the different scholars and practitioners try to work out what the Buddha meant when he said this. So they came to the conclusion based on studying this you know, that Sūtra and and that Sūtra that actually this is what the Buddha meant. But then another group said, no. But the the Buddha said, you know, in in this other Sūtra, such and such, and that’s what he really meant.

And then the others said, no, but in these group of sutras, the Buddha said this, and that’s what he really, really meant. These other things are just provisional kind of teachings. And along came Nāgārjuna who says that the middle way view is the is the actual view of the Buddha. And many hundreds of years later, Lama Tsongkhapa, as I mentioned, wrote this text called the, in Tibetan, Legs Bshad Snying Po which means something like or that subheading is elucidating the definitive and interpretive teachings of the Buddha. Because some things the Buddha said are to be interpreted, and some things are definitive.

So they argue that all the the the first three schools of Buddhism are interpretive teachings and the sutras that express the Mādhyamika view are the actual definitive view. And Lama Tsongkhapa in that text, which is translated into English, is difficult to understand. He he through logic, by comparing different sutras, he says, yes, the Buddha does say this in this sūtra, but he says this in another sūtra and this in another sūtra. And by comparing all these things and presenting this very complex set of logic, Lama Tsongkhapa establishes logically that the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika view is the actual view that the Buddha has himself and wants sentient beings to realize. But because it is very subtle and difficult, not everyone is able to, you know, relate to it straight away, and it can turn people off.

So the Buddha didn’t teach just that view. And that’s one of the beauties of the Buddha’s teachings that the Buddha taught many different things for different people to suit their mind, but in a what a skillful way so that even though what the Buddha taught may not have been a hundred percent true, it it was it was that non truth was non harming and non deceptive. It was helpful for people, and it helps lead them to the highest truth eventually. So all of the of Tibetan Buddhism not Tibetan Buddhism, sorry. All of the schools except the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika, their view of the selflessness of the person is the same.

It is this the view that there is a person which is free of being permanent, partless, and independent. All of all of the the schools except the have that view of the selflessness of the person. So the the Vaibhāṣika have that view. The have that view. The Cittamātrins have the view that view.

But the difference between the Cittamātrins and the the lower schools is that they believe in the selflessness of phenomena as well, and their view of the selflessness of phenomena is, as I tried to explain last week, where it mentions in the text. If Peter, would you be able to go back just one paragraph, I think? I know. Hold it. Maybe it’s there.

No. It is there. Yeah. We write on that section. So it it says in that paragraph what it what it’s saying in that paragraph is that the the beings such as the the the Vaibhishikas and Sartantrikas and us who believe that phenomena truly exist, inherently exist, what that comes down to believing is that the the the object and the perceiver of the object, these two things have separate distinct entities.

There’s the object and the perceiver or the subject. So these two are distinct entities. So you have me, there’s a tree, and the perceiver of the tree. So these are two completely separate things. So what but what the the Cittamātrins are saying is that, actually, that the the subject and the perceiver, the subject and the object, are empty of being separate identities because their view is that everything is is mind.

There is no external phenomena at all. So that when when a karma ripens, it has two aspects. So this is good and bad karma. When it ripens, one aspect of the imprint ripens to produce the perceiver, the subject, you know, the person who is perceiving something, and the other aspect of the karmic imprint creates the illusion of the subject, the thing that is perceived. This one imprint in our mind ripens to produce the tree and the perceiver of the tree simultaneously.

So their understanding of the emptiness of phenomena is that phenomena are empty of existing separately from the perceiver. Well, I don’t think it’s necessary that we have to understand these things instantaneously. The thing is to get some imprint and think about it. Yeah. Well, you do.

But there’s a person perceiving that. Well, we do perceive many things. But you could say there’s the field of what we perceive, but there is an a karmic imprint that is producing both the the field of of of experience and the experience simultaneously. Whereas, generally, we live our life as ordinary people, if we were to think about it, which we don’t, that we we kind of assume there are things there out there in the world, and we come along, you know, oh, and see it because it’s just waiting to be seen. It’s waiting to be seen independently, separately from me.

Yeah. Right? But it’s not like according to the Cittamātrins, it’s not like that. That everything the the the tree and the the me me perceiving the tree, those two things arise simultaneously. Don’t ask me to explain that in any more detail.

One has to think about it, but that’s very roughly that could also be related to that maybe. Yes. Well, generally, that’s true anyway. Even the Mādhyamika accept that, generally, that what we’re experiencing is our karma. Yeah.

Well, that’s what we’re experiencing. See. No. I mean, no. Just you can use the term experience to cover, you know, what one sees, what one and what one sees, smells, taste, touch, but also the the feeling that goes with it, the thoughts, everything, the the the whole package.

But the Buddhist teachings are saying for there to be a result, there has to be a cause. So for us to come into contact with anything we come into contact with, good or bad, inanimate or animate, one could say that that is a result, a fruit. And so it has to have a cause. So as for us so for us to come in contact with something like this bowl of flowers, there has to be a cause because everything we experience does produce some kind of feeling. So there has to be a cause for that.

We can’t come in contact with something if we haven’t created the cause for it. Yes. But the Mādhyamika goes much more but much more than that. Because this is only this is only talking about the selflessness of the person. But even the the Mādhyamika view of the selflessness of the person is much deeper than just being, empty of being permanent, partless, and independent.

It is all of those things, but it’s something even much more than that. That’s just a gross view. So now we move on. Now that that is all clear, we go on for the inherent existers which is the Mādhyamika Svatantrikas. If we just read this, do we need to read it, or can I just try and summarize it?

Have you read it? I’ll read it. We’ll read it. For the inherent existers, the seal stating the self is nonexistent, the third seal. Refers to the two selflessnesses, both person and phenomena.

Their approach to the selflessness of the person is the same as the preceding two schools, the mind only school and the two hearer traditions, the particularists, which are the Vaibhāṣikas and the sūtra followers, the Sautrantikas. With regard to the selflessness of the phenomena, since it is stated in the blaze of reasoning by Bhāvaviveka, who’s one of the great Indian masters, the Svatāntrika school’s founder, that all sensory consciousnesses, which not being produced by fleeting or temporary causes of deception, take as their appearing objects characteristics, they assert inherent existence or existence due to its own characteristics posited by the force of a non conceptual thought, which is unmistaken with regards to its appearing object and conceptual thoughts unmistaken with regard to their referent objects. Because of this, the self to be negated now here comes the crunch. Believe I won’t comment on all that bit because don’t worry about it. So their view of the self to be negated or, in other words, that which does not exist in all phenomena such as the aggregates, elements, sources and so forth is the ultimate mode of existence which is not designated through the force of its appearance to an unmistaken consciousness.

Consequently, negation of this is asserted to be the selflessness of phenomena. Did you understand that? Right. This is very difficult, but this is coming to the crunch. Now, basically, what this means is can I try to explain?

Firstly, as most of us here know, the Madhyamaka say that the way things do exist, the way things validly exist is depending. They arise dependently. They’re not inherently existent. They’re not independent, partless, permanent, etcetera. They arise dependently on causes and conditions, parts, and the and the labeling mind.

So this is the very subtle aspect of the Mādhyamika Mādhyamika view that things depend on the labeling consciousness, that for an object to appear to our mind, it has to to to appear in a particular way. It depends on the labeling, and that labeling comes from our mind. As I was saying a couple of nights ago, Here is a phenomena. Right? So if we label this phenomena just a phenomena, that’s all it can appear to us as a phenomena.

But there’s billions of phenomena. Right? So we can label this, our mind can conceive of it, this phenomena, as vegetation. It’s it’s not plastic. It’s not inanimate.

It’s a a living vegetation. Right? Our mind puts our mind conceives this phenomena in that way, and only because of that can this phenomena appear back that way. This phenomena has no power from its own side to inform me I am vegetation. That comes from our mind.

But it when we experience it, it doesn’t appear as though we experience this thing as vegetation. Depending on our mind, it seems to be really vegetation from its side. But, actually, it’s only because we label it that, and that we only can label that depending on many, many factors. And so then we can label this this vegetation as a flower, and only when our mind projects flower onto this phenomena can it appear back to us as a flower? And then we can yeah.

Right? Does is that making some sense? And only when we our mind labels this flower a daisy? Oh, okay. Chrysanthemum.

Chrysanthemum. Okay. From its side to make me understand, see it, experience experience it as a chrysanthemum that is it it is arising depending on the mind labeling it that way, giving it that name. But labeling just doesn’t mean giving a name like coming up with a name. Labeling means conceiving, having a conception about something.

And, of course, why do we have conceptions about things? Because partly because of conditioning in this life, our cultural conditioning, our individual family conditioning, or our, you know, our cultural conditioning, our family conditioning, our own individual life experiences, many, many, many, many things. But also even more importantly is our karmic conditioning from past lives. We don’t have choices in a sense of why we like or some things, to some extent, we can can change our labeling and the way we see things. But much of what we experience, we just can’t change overnight the way we conceive things because the karmic history behind it is so strong.

We just grasp things that, oh, this is really good. This is really bad. This is delicious. This tastes horrible. Blah blah blah.

It’s not like we decide we choose to to think that this is good or bad. Our karma forces us to. And so, you know, forces us to experience it that way, to conceive things in a particular way or have the ability to because, you know, we have the karma. We have the ability, you as a human being, we have the karmic con conditioning so that we can appreciate this bit of vegetation as a beautiful flower, whereas a dog can’t. A dog doesn’t, you know, sort of think, oh, what a beautiful flower.

Oh, this a nice one. Where’s my vase? You know? They they don’t they don’t have that situation. Yes.

Well, it’s not that simple because, conventionally, there are good things, and conventionally, there are bad things. Conventionally, there is good and bad. There’s good karma and bad karma. That’s vital to you know? Because I think some people interpret Buddhism as believing that at some level, there’s no good or bad.

Everything’s you know? And and this is not the view. This is an example of refuting too much in a sense where one refutes all conventional realities. Things are not like that. Conventionally, things aren’t inherently good or inherently bad, but conventionally, there are things which are good and beneficial, and there are things conventionally which are harmful.

So one has to, you know, understand that and live accordingly. But for example, when we believe in inherently existing good and bad, what what one aspect of of that belief is that ignorance is it believes that things are permanently good and bad. Whereas one when one has some understanding of things of being just merely conventionally labeled good or bad, things are not necessarily you know, this thing which is good or bad is not necessarily permanently like that, and it all depends on the situation, the conditions. So everything can become much more flexible, spacious. Well, that’s we’re into another whole area because I’m just trying to I haven’t made my point yet, but and I don’t want to lose it.

But in that case, when a terrible thing happens to us, that is definitely, according to Buddhist understanding, the result of a negative action we’ve done in the past. But as a result of this terrible thing that happens to us, we may look at that experience. And because of the way we look at it, we can become a better person. I mean, is what mind training is about, Lojong, of transforming problems into the path of seeing the good aspects of a problem. But that mind that is able to interpret that bad experience or use that bad experience in a positive way, the mind able to do that is the result of some good karma.

Whereas someone can have, for example, you can be run over by a car. That’s the result of negative negligence of someone, but it’s due to negative one’s own negative karma ripening. And but as a result of being run over by a car, you remain embittered the rest of your life and you hate people because life you know, I know people are terrible and it should not have happened to me and blah blah blah blah blah blah blah. I hate the world because I was run over and I should never have been run over. Right?

And it destroys one’s life. So that that’s the running over was due to negative karma and then the mind interpreting that in a really negative way is also more negative karma ripening that just gets you know, just has a black view of everything. Whereas someone else gets run over, but so that’s the result of negative karma. But they think, oh, you know, many people have been run over how you know, you feel compassion for all the other people who’ve run over. One becomes and one decides to be a much better driver and more careful and blah blah blah.

So one one improves as a result of that, and but that ability to do so is due to the ripening of some good karma of being able to look at things in a positive way. Back sorry. I know we haven’t had tea break, but this we’re at the crucial, complicated point I’m trying to make, which is so the Mādhyamika view is that everything can only exist depending on causes and conditions, but especially the labeling mind. Depending on how you label something, which we’re not conscious that we’re doing this, it just through the force of instinct and karma, etcetera, etcetera, we conceive things in particular ways, and then they appear back that way. Right?

So what all this bit here was saying about the Mādhyamika Svatantrikas is they believe phenomena do not truly exist, but they inherently exist. They don’t truly exist because things depend on causes and conditions, parts, and the labeling mind. They accept all of that, that things depend on the labeling on causes and conditions, parts, and the labeling mind. But the so that’s why that things don’t truly exist. But they say phenomena inherently exist because in order for our mind to be able to label a flower as a flower To to label something anything, there has to be a base.

You know, I just can’t say, oh, look. There’s a flower. Or, you know, here’s a flower. Look at that flower. Here’s a flower.

You have to have a base. Well, firstly, you have to have a base. Just can’t point to space and say, oh, look, there’s a flower, there’s an elephant or whatever. And for one to exist there, you have to have a base. And you also have to have a correct base.

So, you know, flowers are kind of like that. Right? So this is like that. And look. But it’s not a flower.

It’s not the correct base for a flower. I can call this I can say, look my nice flower, but no one will see a flower. They’ll just think I’m a lunatic. In order for the mind to conceive of something as something, there has to be a base, and there has to be a valid base. It can’t be just anything.

You just can’t label anything what you like, and it will become that thing. Otherwise, we’d all be millionaires because we could look. I’ve got a million dollars. A million dollars. You like my million dollars?

We just can’t label things how we want and for them to become that. There has to be the valid base. Okay? So the Mādhyamika Svatantrikas say that thing this flower doesn’t truly exist because it depends on causes and conditions, parts, and the labeling mind, but the reason, the mind labels this a flower is because the base really is a flower. It’s inherently there there there’s something inherently about the base that causes the mind to label it a flower.

Otherwise, why would we do so? There is something inherently existing about the base that makes it the bay the the valid basis to be called a flower. Which seems fair enough, actually. That sounds like argument to me that there must be something about the base as opposed to this base. This isn’t a valid base to be called a flower, but this thing here is.

So there must be something really there about the base, which isn’t there for me, my mind to conceive this as a flower. So that’s why they say this flower doesn’t inherently exist, but no. Sorry. This flower doesn’t truly exist. It arises dependently, but it inherently exists.

Yes, everything. This is applying to all phenomena. I’m just giving an example. Right? Trying to.

Yeah. And that’s just my rough explanation of this point. The the subtle difference between because the Mādhyamika, Prāsaṇgika say there’s nothing there in the base. It itself, the base itself, doesn’t truly exist. It doesn’t inherently exist.

The base itself is arising depending on the mind, the parts, and the causes and conditions. There’s nothing true inherently existing in in anything. Nothing inherently exists. It’s all merely labeled. Just while I’ve got okay.

Think about that while you have a cup of tea. Are you drinking an inherently cup inherently existing cup of tea, a truly existing cup of tea, or what kind of cup of tea? And is it really delicious? Is it really hot? Really cold?

Really just right? What was it? What’s her name? Goldilocks just right? Okay.

Thank you. They say that phenomena don’t truly exist but they inherently exist. Whereas the two lower schools, the schools associated with the individual vehicle, they say that phenomena not only inherently exist, they also truly exist. Well, put it this way. For the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika school, all of those terms inherently truly existing from their own side, they all come down to the same thing.

Some the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika say, if if you’re saying something substantially exists exists self sufficiently, exists from its own side, it truly exists, it also means it inherently exists. So for the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika, truly existing and inherently existing mean the same thing. But as I’m trying to say, for the other schools, they don’t, they have a different meaning. Yes, the same term but Yeah. In a sense.

Yes. Yes. Yeah. So, you know, the the this is the the the the important difference to understand between the Mādhyamika Svatantrikas and the Prasangikas is that the Svatantrikas say that things don’t truly exist because they’re dependent arisings, because they depend on causes and conditions parts in the labeling mind, but nevertheless they inherently exist. Phenomena inherently exist.

Whereas Prasangikas say nothing inherently exists because they’re dependent arising, they don’t inherently exist at all. Everything is just nominally existing like a rainbow, just momentarily there, like, by the skin of its teeth. Well, we actually we can’t see it too much. Yeah. Yeah.

Yes. That’s just subtle impermanence, though. But that helps to understand the image. If if you if you understand things are impermanent, that can lead you to understand that things don’t truly exist and don’t inherently exist. But some schools See, for example, you know, the Mādhyamika schools say that things arise dependently.

They depend on causes and conditions, parts in the labelling mind. So Lama Tsongkhapa makes the point that if you understood, if we really, really understood that things depend on causes and conditions, we would understand that things don’t inherently exist. But, Lama Tsongkhapa says, for the ordinary person, us, when we are told that things arise depending on causes and conditions, that doesn’t become a proof that they don’t inherently exist. It becomes proof that they really do exist. Why?

Because like, for example, as I always give these people examples, if you go home tonight or tomorrow morning and you make a sandwich and you take a piece of bread and you put some butter or margarine on it, and then you put some cheese and tomato and some lettuce or something or whatever you like, and then another piece of bread. You’ve you’ve made a sandwich depending on causes and conditions, and you know it. But as soon as you put that last piece of bread on top, wow, there’s a real sandwich. It appears to be an inherently existing real sandwich. And how do you know it’s really there?

Because I just made it. Or you make a table. You know? Cut. Cut.

Cut. You know? Chop. Chop. Chop.

And there it’s there’s a real table there. And one knows I you know, it was made with causes and conditions, but it’s really there. It’s a real table. But actually if we really understood really understood actually understood the implication of causes and conditions, it means that there is not a real inherently existing table there. It’s just something that is arising depending on all of these things.

Because just to chop and change, one interesting thing to think about is this is getting, you know, down the track. But, anyway, talking about the lay in order to label something, you have to have the base. Right? And you have to have a valid base. So and the thing to understand is that the the label and the base are different.

They’re not the same thing. Right? If the if they were the same thing, you wouldn’t need the base. But in order to label something, to conceive something and for it to appear, to be experienced by ourselves, there has to be the base. And the the base has to come first.

First, there’s the base, and then you know, so in order to conceive something, you first, you have to have the base, and then your mind perceives it and labels it. And then it appears back as Lama Tsongkhapa says. It appears back as that thing. But the trouble due to because of ignorance, it doesn’t appear back as merely labeled. It appears back as truly inherently existing.

It doesn’t appear as though we’ve labeled it. It appears as though it’s just like that. But, anyway, the point I’m trying to make is you have to have a label sorry. You have to have a base. The base has to exist before you label it.

Right? You have to have the valid base. So a flower is not the base. A flower is what arises merely arises depending on causes and conditions, the labelling mind and the base. The base is the parts.

All the parts make up the base. But when if if you look at this flower I’m holding, I I am holding a flower, but Like, personally, and I think this must apply for you too, probably, but when I’m holding this flower, I can’t distinguish between the base and the label. And that, as Kyabje Tsong Rinpoche says, that is the object to be refuted when you realize that you can’t distinguish between the base and the label. They seem to be exactly the same thing. Can you see the difference between the flower I’m holding and the base for the flower I’m holding?

I can’t. But when you can, you’ve realized emptiness, I think. But Well, not not not that you it’s not that, like, you should be thinking like that. No. Don’t worry about what we should be seeing.

Worry about what we are seeing. Don’t put the cart before the the horse before the cart or the cart before the horse or something, whatever it is. Yeah. There is a flower here, but the flower that which is here is what is arising momentarily. It’s just nominally existing.

Because the flower isn’t the base. Right? The base is the base for to label something. So a flower is what arises in our mind depending on causes, conditions, parts, and the labeling mind. That is the flower.

No. The flower the flower is what arises dependently on all those things, but it it needs the base. They’re separate. Sorry? What about the interpretation of the base?

Yes. Yes. Yes. No. But they do see the base of a flower, but they don’t recognize it’s the base of a flower.

I’m not quite sure what you would see, but you’d see a merely arising flower. Mom? What? No. I go on.

No. Go on. What would you see? What do you think you would no. I think you you would see a flower.

Someone who’s realized emptiness would still see a flower. They’d see me holding a flower. They’d see a white flower like this. They wouldn’t see something like radiating light nor sparkly or anything like that. Oh, they would definitely experience it.

Would experience yes, definitely. Well, part of the the difference would be when you experience things having realized emptiness, it’s blissful. That’s the whole point. No. No.

No. That’s see a flower. Who who are we talking about? Well well, let’s not talk about Buddhas because they’re in another category. It’s very strange to understand what Buddhas but just someone realized you, when you realize emptiness, Peter, do you think you’ll stop seeing flowers?

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. This is gonna happen next week, probably.

Yeah. Sorry? Right. Right. No.

No. Only Buddhas can do that. In meditation if you took this object you are visualizing this flower If you started off like if you started off when you sat down on the cushion to meditate you were on the path of preparation and you visualized a flower you would be visualizing a truly existing flower or an inherently existing flower. And if you realized emptiness in that meditation and entered the path of insight, the the the appearance of a truly existing flower would cease, and all you would experience would be the emptiness of of that true existence. So nothing would appear to your consciousness.

There would just be space like emptiness, The mere lack of the true existence of the flower would appear to your mind. Out of meditation, when you got off the cushion as an Ārya being for the first time and had a cup of coffee, you you everything would still appear truly existing, but it would appear you wouldn’t believe, you wouldn’t grasp. We wouldn’t grasp. It would appear like an illusion and more yeah. Yeah.

The the appearance of true existence would be there, but one wouldn’t be grasping at it as such. Well, even a first level bodhisattva or an ārya being on the first bhūmi, they have started to eliminate their ignorance. But they still have ignorance, which still means they still have delusions. But but they’re able to control them much better than we can. Yeah.

Yes. Yeah. Everything. All the, yeah, the soil, the seeds, all the causes and conditions. Yes.

Yep. Yeah. Yeah. In the room. Yes.

I think so. No, that’s slightly different. That’s the base. This isn’t a it’s not so much the cause. It’s this piece of paper is, you know, money is printed on paper.

So this is a piece of paper, but it’s not just just me calling this base a million dollars, you know, won’t make it a million dollars, whereas if it was a check written one million dollars and signed, that’s that’s different. That’s a valid base for one million dollars You would have to have one million dollars in the bank for that check to be a valid basis. Oh, I was talking about how for us there is the base and then the label. So these are different things, but for us we are not able to distinguish these two things as different. They seem the same.

So that is one way of looking at what is the object to be refuted. Right now I’m explaining that and hopefully you can understand my wonderful explanation that there is labeling and the base. These two things are separate. So we can understand that. So we can understand intellectually that here there is the base, and depending on the base, the mind labels that a flower.

Two different things. But so but when when we look, we can’t we can understand there’s a difference between a flower. Hopefully, we can begin to understand there’s a difference between a flower and the basis of a flower. So we can understand that intellectually, but we can’t right now, because of ignorance, we can’t distinguish these when we look at a flower, the difference between the base and the label. So that when we realize that I’m not able to when we actually realize, when we really get it that I can’t distinguish the basis from the label, that that view, that experience is the object to be refuted because the base is different from the label.

But I’m seeing something that is inseparably two things which seem to be inseparably the same, So that is the object to be refuted. Same when talking about the person, me, like like I mentioned, I think, last week, in in a sometimes we identify ourselves as being our body. Sometimes we identify ourselves as being our mind. So these are gross levels of ignorance. But deep down, we the the I that we are grasping at is an I that isn’t the body or mind.

It’s something separate. So when we can identify that view that we are holding, that’s the object to be refuted. So it’s one thing to intellectually understand that’s what we’re doing, that we’re actually grasping at an I that is separate from the body and mind. But to actually identify that actual personal experience of doing that is very difficult, but that’s the object be refuted. We have to be able to identify that.

Because only by identifying it correctly can we get rid of it. I. Yeah. Well, the sense of I. We all have a sense of I.

So what is this I? We all believe I. I am going to the shop. So who is this I? I got interrupted then.

Who is this I that got interrupted? As I often pathetically joke, tomorrow morning if you have a shower and you put your body under the water, just check who is this person having a shower? You know? Do you do you have to put your body under the water to have a to to have a shower? I am having a shower.

So who is the I having the shower apart from your body? Can you have a shower without your body getting wet? Oh, no. We’re not trying to refute the base or the label, or both. We’re just trying to identify here.

In this example, Ling Rinpoche, who was the senior tutor of His Holiness, made this point that the mind unable to distinguish the base from the label and seeing them as one, that view is to be refuted. That is the object to be refuted. Along maybe you weren’t saying this, but just in case you were, and it just brings something to mind many people seem to believe that realizing emptiness means you don’t label anything, that labeling is bad. And when you stop labeling, you’ve realized emptiness, or someone who’s realized emptiness doesn’t label anything. So this is completely wrong.

Completely wrong. Because the only way things exist is by labeling. Things don’t exist any other way. Yeah. So you you yeah.

One has to label. The trouble is, you know, well, one thing is we sometimes label things incorrectly. That that’s a big problem. So that’s not good. But as I was saying before, the only way anything can exist in a particular way for us is by labeling them.

But the trouble is so there’s the base. We label it, and it appears back. But the trouble is that when it appears back, it doesn’t appear back as being merely labeled. It appears back as truly existing. That’s the problem, not the labeling.

Things have to be labeled. Otherwise they wouldn’t exist for us. Nothing would exist if our mind didn’t label things because they have no power to exist from their own side. That’s what, you know, if things inherently existed or truly existed, they wouldn’t require a label. They would just exist from their own side.

But because nothing has the ability to exist that way, the ONLY way things exist is by being merely labelled. They merely exist nominally by being labelled by being created by the mind but not just like the Cittamātrins say, just the mind creates something but the mind can only create something depending on causes and conditions and the base the label. And then just just nominally, conventionally, something appears like a rainbow. Rainbows are good examples. You know?

There’s the appearance, and it’s depending on all these things. You know? So a rainbow appears because there is some moisture in the air, some sunshine. There’s the sun, and there’s a person, a viewer, and who has to be in a particular angle or something. And all depending depending on all those things, a rainbow exists.

But that rainbow is not the sun, it’s not the sunshine, it’s not the water in the air, it’s not the air, it’s not the viewer, it’s not the angle, and it’s not all of those things together. And it’s not something separate from those things. The rainbow isn’t separate. It can’t exist independently of all those things. It just comes into existence because of all those things momentarily.

And everything is like that, is what the Prasangikas are saying. Things don’t appear that way to us now, but that’s how they actually are. They’re just there, and that’s all. But you say, solid. But that solid is just something, that sense of solidity is something which is merely labelled by the mind depending on causes and conditions.

Solidity doesn’t inherently exist. Oh, yeah. Sure. So even before you realize the emptiness, you can walk through walls apparently. Once you develop Samādhi and you I don’t know exactly.

You have to do something a little some other little trick after you develop Samādhi, and you can walk through walls, read people’s minds, and fly in the sky without Qantas. That one’s becoming very necessary. Oh, no. Not quite that. You’ve still got your body, but you fly in the sky, apparently.

That’s what it’s and you can walk through walls. And I think once you’ve developed Samādhi or calm abiding, you you then are able to realize momentary impermanence so you can see actually things disintegrating. Apparently, they are doing all sorts of things. Anyway, I think we better stop here. Anyway, please don’t just leave all this behind here in this room, but try and, if you’ve got the book, read over it and try and think about it and just think about generally what we’ve tried to look at tonight and and especially try and apply it to one’s experience of, you know, when we when we when we look at something, think about something, hear something, taste something, try and really investigate what’s going on.

How am I experiencing this? How does it appear to me? Why is this delicious? Where is the deliciousness of the food? So we can dedicate the merit of thinking about emptiness.

Such a good thing to think about. Through the merits of these virtuous actions, may I quickly attain the state of a Guru Buddha and lead all living beings without exception into that enlightened state. May the precious Bodhi mind, not yet born, arise and grow. May that born have no decline, but increase forevermore. The object of refuge of myself and of all transmigratory beings in all our lifetimes is the embodiment of the Three Jewels, the all encompassing three refuges in one, the Guru, the wish granting jewel, His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, the Master Padmasambhava, the Dharma King Songtsen Gampo and Trisong Detsen, the Abbot Shanta Rakshita and the numberless holy beings who preserved and spread the Buddhadharma in Tibet, and the Tibetan people who practiced and served Buddhism so faithfully for a thousand years, as well as those who, along with many others, died sacrificing their lives for Tibet and His Holiness.

May all their positive wishes be fulfilled immediately. Due to their limitless kindness, the sun of Tibetan Buddhism has now risen in the West, which was a dark land. But now that I have met the Dharma, I have received the perfect human body, enabling me to lead a meaningful life. Our refuge and savior, the supreme one, is the Dalai Lama, and the Tibetan people have been so kind to us. Remembering this, we make the following dedicating prayers.

May all his holiness, the Dalai Lama’s wishes be successful immediately. May the snow land of Tibet achieve pure freedom and develop the Buddhadharma even more than before in Tibet. And may all mother transmigratory beings achieve enlightenment quickly. Savior of the snow land teachings and transmigratory beings who makes extremely clear the path that is unification of emptiness and compassion to the lotus holder, Tenzin Gyatso, I beseech. May all your holy wishes be spontaneously fulfilled.

You who uphold the Vinaya moral way, who serve as the bountiful bearer of all, sustaining, preserving, spreading Mañjuśrī’s victorious doctrine, who masterfully accomplished magnificent prayers honoring the Three Jewels. Savior of myself and others, your disciples, please, please live long. Lord of Dharma, who in accordance with the various dispositions of those to be subdued, makes clear in the light of your well spoken advice, the sacred Ganden tradition, essence of Buddhist teachings, oh, foremost and holy Lama, to you who are supreme. O Lama, please please live long. And just to remind you about, we have our picnic on Sunday, and this is to commemorate the the life of, Lama Yeshe, the founder of our center.

And, in in the afternoon, three o’clock, we’re we’re doing a Maitreya Buddha Puja also to commemorate Lama Yeshe’s life, to remember his incredible kindness. So please come along if you can to both or either. And the picnics and pujas afterwards. Yeah. The other thing is, again, to remind you of the the visit of Khandroma, this great practitioners, this yogini, Dakini lady who’s coming to teach here at the end of March.

Book now while you can. And also if you can help out in in the organization that’s needed for this program, please let us know. There’s gonna be a list very, very soon. It’s up there now? Oh, it’s up there now.

So great. So if you can put your name against any little job that you’d like to do, this would be really appreciated because we do need lots of help to put on this program. Okay. Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

atman dag (Tib)
Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
four seals
The four basic tenets that define Buddhism. They are: all compositional phenomena are impermanent, all contaminated phenomena are by nature suffering, all phenomena are empty of self-existence and nirvana is true peace. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
transmigratory beings dro wa (Tib)
Sentient beings who pass from one realm to another, taking rebirth within cyclic existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top