26 min · 3,054 words · 6 June 2013 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 27-minute commentary on the first lines of the Seven-Point Mind Training, Ven Thubten Dondrub traces the root cause of all suffering back to ignorance and self-cherishing. He explains how we mistake unrelated causes for our misery—blaming external conditions rather than recognizing that actions and disturbing emotions, rooted in a false conception of self, are the actual architects of our experience. Drawing on Śāntideva’s Bodhisattva’s Way of Life and the Wheel of Sharp Weapons, he reveals how self-cherishing acts as an inner thief and butcher, stealing our virtue and blocking liberation. The teaching progresses through a vivid meditation on the six realms of rebirth, showing that all samsaric existence—from the bliss of gods to the agony of hell—is ultimately unsatisfying because nothing lasts. Pitched at practitioners already familiar with Buddhist fundamentals, including those studying the Lamrim.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2013 06 06 Mind Training.mp3
UUID: 72da6d12-0064-4dfe-8140-7496aad918c5
Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub
Collection: Mind Training (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Date: 2013-06-06
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 26.7 minutes
Words: ~3,062
Stay away, stay away. Okay. Well, so just keep going. Gönchok Rinpoche’s commentary on this first line of the seven point mind training is, we sentient beings run after misery that we do not desire and never achieve what we wish. At the root of it all, we seek to lay the blame elsewhere, which is a mistake.
This is because all the various lengthy and violent sufferings that come from being born among the five or six kinds of existence. Right? So these you know, we everyone knows what they are. Right? The hell realms and five or six five is if you include the demigods with the gods.
Right? So so all of these sufferings from the hell without respite, which is the lowest suffering, the the worst suffering, to the peak of existence, which is the the name of the highest God realm, one of the four formless realms, are not without causes nor do they arise from unrelated causes. So the point is that what the Buddha’s teachings are pointing out, what the Buddha is pointing out is that everything we experience, good and bad, has very specific causes and those causes are related causes. We may believe that yes, my suffering has a cause, but the trouble is what we call the causes of our suffering are not the real ones. They are unrelated causes.
You know, like blaming the government or one’s mother or someone for one’s suffering. We can say, oh, it’s because of them. That’s the cause. But it’s not the actual cause at all. It’s something completely unrelated to the actual reason we are experiencing something.
So these come about, meaning all the the sufferings of the the hell realms up to the god realms, all of these experiences come about in dependence upon the actions and disturbing emotions that give rise to everything. Since actions are caused by disturbing emotions, disturbing emotions are the primary factor. Moreover okay that that’s pretty straight. I don’t have to say anything about that do I? It’s all pretty clear.
Moreover among the disturbing emotions it is the ignorance that clutches onto a misconception of self that is the principal source of all misery. Alright? Ignorance itself creates a false appearance of the self and that same ignorance grasps that that appearance is true. Because of that then we and only because of that do we have the disturbing thoughts or what are called here the disturbing emotions. We wouldn’t have attachment and anger without the wrong view of self.
And because of the wrong view of self we also have a wrong view of everything. Everything appears, self and phenomena, all appear as though they inherently exist from their own side, not depending on causes, conditions, parts and our mind. So it’s because of that wrong view that and only because of that that we have the disturbing thoughts. And once we’ve got the disturbing thoughts, we act on them, and then we set in train the motion of all suffering. So in the Bodhicharyavatara, which is this wonderful text written by the great bodhisattva Śāntideva.
It says: However much torment, fear and suffering there is in the world, it all arises from the misconception of self. Oh, what trouble this great ghost brings me. So it’s a ghost because, you know, it’s like it doesn’t have any it has an appearance, but it doesn’t have any reality. It’s something completely insubstantial but we we believe it’s real. Furthermore, since disturbing emotions chiefly created by seizing onto a misconception of self bring us harm, they are the actual adversary.
They are the real problem, not other people. We should not maintain relations with this long term antagonist. The same text that is Śāntideva’s text says, Thus, through long unbroken contact, he is our foe, sole cause of an ever increasing heap of trouble. When we are certain of this in our hearts, how can we be happy and unafraid in cyclic existence? So once we realize that ignorance is actually our real enemy, the source of all our trouble, and is actually the cause of cyclic existence.
We wouldn’t have cyclic existence being reborn over and over again into all these different limiting limiting types of rebirth. Once we actually understood that, how could we remain happy in cyclic existence? We couldn’t be. Moreover, we can attribute all these harms to our selfish attitude. And thinking of how it slams the door on all benefits and accomplishments, we should be aware of it.
Due to ignorance, we have self-cherishing and when we follow that it slams the door on all benefits. There are no benefits that come from following the self-cherishing thought. So we should try to be really aware of it. Beware of it. Beware of it.
So to to be aware of it, we have to firstly be aware of it and realize it’s something to be aware of. Likewise, the self centered attitude is an expression of stupid ignorance. Since this lack of consideration for others is like taking hold of the sharp weapon of wrong views and slaughtering any concern for good and bad deeds. Okay. So right here within us is an evil butcher who cuts off the source of a life of high status and definite goodness.
Actually, some of you may be familiar, there’s a text in the mind training tradition called the Wheel of Sharp Weapons. So in that Wheel of Sharp Weapons, it points out that if if you’re if you’re experiencing this kind of suffering, it’s because you’ve done this in past lives. So this suffering is the Wheel of Sharp Weapons coming back on you. Just like a swordsmith who makes a sword might end up being killed by a sword, you know, all our suffering is is coming back to us because we created the cause. And in another in another part of that text, it refers to our self-cherishing as this butcher.
Because our self-cherishing, you know, it kills all chance of happiness within ourselves. So so it’s this this self-cherishing which is the butcher that cuts off the source of a life of high status, is referring to being reborn as a human being or in the god realms and definite goodness. So definite goodness is referring to the experience of getting out of saṃsāra. That’s that’s what is definitely good. Everything else is not sure.
But liberation from the experience of liberation from cyclic existence, that is definite goodness. This selfish thought holding up the bag of the three poisons, which is, you know, the three poisons as attachment, anger, ignorance, is the thief within us who destroys our harvest of virtue. By collecting rotten, worthless things in the cave of our heart, we have here within us an owl-headed deceiver who attracts all human and inhuman interferences. So when we are under the control of the self-cherishing thought, it it leads to following attachment and anger and ignorance. It perpetuates them.
And all of this steals whatever happiness we may have and destroys whatever virtue we’ve created in the past and puts all these these rotten, horrible, negative imprints in our in our mind. And when they ripen, that delivers us every kind of problem, every kind of interference, and so on. So in the fields of action are planted the seeds of consciousness Irrigating them over and over again with the waters of desire and craving is the farmer here within us who cultivates the numerous shoots of the five or six kinds of suffering beings. Do I have to comment on that? Actually this again I can’t if I was smart I could comment on it but the imagery that’s being used there is related to the teaching on the twelve links which some of you may be familiar with, the twelve links of Dependent Origination, because it talks there about the seeds.
The seeds are referring to the second link of karmic formations, and then consciousness is the third one and it talks about craving and grasping as the farmer that that nourishes those seeds And when they ripen, you know, in the in future lives, then we we are reborn into what it says are the five or six kinds of suffering beings. Right? Just in case there are some new people here who need reminding, the the five or six kinds of beings that we’ve that we’ve got the the human beings. Right? The pretas or hungry ghosts.
There’s the hell beings. So these are the being Oh, animals. Animals, pretas, hungry ghosts, hell beings. These are the beings of the lower realms. Then the beings of the upper realms are us, human beings.
Then the demigods, and then there are the the various kinds of long lived gods. So these are all rebirths within cyclic existence. When we have the mind controlled by delusion and karma, we cycle in these rebirths. Yeah. And yeah.
Which are all in the nature of suffering, even the the happiness, the bliss of the god realms is a subtle kind of suffering because apart from everything else, it doesn’t last. It may it goes on for a very long time, but, you know, those beings the the karma that that created those rebirths runs out, and then beings even in these high god realms fall down to be reborn as animals, humans, pretas in the hell realms and it just goes around and around. So even though the previous Buddhas, the transcendent subduers, have spent as long as us in this beginningless world, we have been unable to adhere to any of the excellent qualities of this or the world beyond. So here within us is a naked empty handed slob behaving overindulgently. That that sentence apart from the slob bit which is very clear is a little bit I think what that is saying is that the previous Buddhas have spent as long as us in this beginningless world in Samsāra but they practiced and got out.
But we because we didn’t, we’re still here. So we’ve been unable to adhere to any of the excellent qualities of this world or beyond. So that is the nature of the self-cherishing thought. It’s an empty handed slob behaving overindulgently. So wherever we are born from the peak of existence which is in the God realms to the hell without respite, we dwell in misery.
So this is what we should meditate on to try and see that that is the truth. Yeah. I mean, of course, the the obviously, the lower realms are miserable. We can’t see that all any of them except the animal realm. So if we look but, of course, some people think animals are having a terrific time.
Some people want to be reborn animals. They want to be born cats because, oh, you know, they’re all soft and fluffy, and they just lie around sleeping. How wonderful. But if you really think about it, it’s quite depressing if you just you get reborn in this body and all you do is sleep. Yeah.
Right. Oh, yes. Of course, they kill. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. They kill. Yeah. Yeah. And the same with, you know, of course, you know, dolphins.
They also kill. Dolphins are very nice beings they’re very cool in the new age system and everything. The dolphins and dolphins and porpoises, but they also kill all the time, every day to eat. So it’s miserable. And the god realm’s miserable because it doesn’t last.
Human happiness is misery because it doesn’t last. It’s just an illusion. There is no holiday in Samsāra. There’s no such thing as a holiday in Samsāra. So this is the jolly bit.
So it goes on to say, whoever we befriend is a friend of suffering. In other words, whoever is our friend, those people are suffering. Yeah. And they can’t make us happy. Ordinary beings can’t make us happy because they’re suffering.
We just add to our suffering with our friends in a sense. Whatever objects we use are nothing but objects of anguish. Well, that’s pretty heavy. Objects of anguish. But what this means is that I didn’t go into any details for those people here who are to Discovering Buddhism, but we have been looking at the four noble truths.
And the first noble truth is the truth of suffering, that there is true suffering. So suffering, of course, is a state of mind. It’s an experience of consciousness. But according to Buddhist philosophical views of things, you can say, these flowers are an example of true suffering. They are they are a true suffering.
Why? Which doesn’t mean that these flowers are suffering, but they are said to be a true suffering because their existence can act as the basis for by experiencing them we can suffer. Because these are contaminated phenomena, They have arisen due to karma and delusion. They’re not pure phenomena. They are something coming into existence like everything in saṃsāra due to karma and delusion.
Some good maybe sometimes some good karma, but even good karma is still a contaminated thing. It’s not the product of a pure mind. So, it’s called a true suffering because it’s an example of something that of giving the name of something to the cause of something. So by just looking at this thing, we can develop oh, and we think, this is beautiful. Smells nice.
Smells nice. I’ve done it again, spilt it. See true suffering, you know, trying to be happy by smelling it and I spill it all over me. So we get attached to the appearance and the smell, etcetera, etcetera. And that’s suffering.
The attachment is suffering. And then, you know, we we try and protect you know, if someone wants my bowl of flowers, I get angry. Someone’s got a better bowl of flowers, so I get jealous. I discover my bowl of flowers is better than anyone else’s bowl of flowers, so I get have pride. Pride.
So just because of that, all sorts of disturbing thoughts can can arise. So it’s a true suffering. These are the words of the Buddha, the transcendent subduer, found in the texts of the learned masters who commented on his thought and are to be heard in the songs of realization of the supreme spiritual masters. Yet, even though this is definitely the case, like an old dog attracted to a scrap of food, The glutton within us is constantly engrossed in the marvels of cyclic existence. What a great text.
Again, just sorry. Just what what is it what is it? Beating the dead horse or something? Flogging the dead horse? That what the Buddha is telling us is cyclic existence is awful.
It’s just something it’s the pits. It’s terrible. But we see it because we see it with this, you know, through ignorance and self-cherishing, and we think cyclic existence is just terrific. I should note off by heart by now, in the Lama Chöpa Puja that some of us do here regularly, there is a verse in the second part of the text where we go through the Lamrim where it says, please bless me to be able to see or stop seeing cyclic existence as like a pleasure garden. Remember?
But that’s what we do. We see we we try you know? And we want to. We want to think that the world is or can be made into this pleasure garden. But in fact, it’s the pits.
It’s a really dangerous jungle. This is what the Buddha is trying to say. We’ve got to get out of it, not hang around in it. So we have to kind of and of course, there are at one level nice things in the world. But we get bedazzled by them and just like, you know, because of the self-cherishing thought, with the friend, you know, we focus on the good qualities of the friend while the friend has been the friend.
And we don’t we don’t look at the at the negative qualities, but they they can be there. And sooner or later, you know, if we if we keep, you know, just focusing on the good stuff, the bad stuff attacks sooner or later. You know, we focus on being young and trying to stay young and look young, but that’s not reality. You know, young people do look nice. That’s that’s conventionally true, but no one can remain looking like that.
That’s also true, and we don’t want to admit that. So we suffer. We can’t there’s no way anyone can remain young or remain even looking young. It just doesn’t work. It’s not possible.
Actually, there are people who have tried, and the results are truly scary, truly scary. And the same, you know, when the body is healthy, it’s nice, but it does it yeah. That’s one reality, but the the actual reality is the body doesn’t remain healthy. It grows old and gets sick and dies. That’s the reality.
But we don’t want to know that reality. But denying that is suffering. Yeah? That denial won’t lead to any real happiness, just more suffering. So we have to look behind the illusion and see what what is the fundamental reality of cyclic existence.
All that glitters is not gold, someone said. Who said that? But they were right. Mister anonymous or miss or miss anonymous said that. Yes.
Yeah. Well, on that note, we’ll we’ll stop for tonight. Unless there’s one or two questions, complaints, suggestions, queries, qualms, clarifications, disagreements. Okay. So what we can do now if people feel comfortable if you if you’d if some people would like to leave, please do so.
Don’t be shy. Nothing wrong with that. But those people who feel comfortable to stay, we can do the well, firstly, maybe we’ll do the no. No. We’ll do the we’ll do the dedications afterwards.
We can do the praises to the twenty one Tārā.
Key terms in this teaching
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- six realms
- The general way that Buddhism divides the whole of cyclic existence; there are three lower realms (hell, hungry ghost and animal) and three upper realms (human, demigod and god). LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
- three poisons dug sum (Tib)
- Attachment, anger and ignorance. LYWA
- twelve links of dependent origination pratitya samutpada (Skt); ten drel yen lag chu nyi (Tib)
- Also called the twelve dependent-related limbs or branches; the twelve steps in the evolution of cyclic existence: 1) ignorance; 2) karmic formation; 3) consciousness; 4) name and form; 5) sensory fields; 6) contact; 7) feelings; 8) craving; 9) grasping... LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.