39 min · 2,215 words · 2006 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 40-minute guided meditation, Venerable Thubten Dondrub offers a systematic reflection on the law of cause and effect, presented as the centerpiece of a two-day retreat practice. He begins by establishing the connection between attachment and cyclic existence, then walks through the four fundamental aspects the Buddha taught: that actions are definite in their results; that causes produce effects and no cause yields no effect; that results manifest only when the karmic seed ripens, however many lifetimes later; and that small actions generate disproportionately large results. Throughout, Dondrub emphasizes that the root cause of suffering or happiness lies within the mind, not in external conditions, and that virtuous and negative actions are determined by whether they align with or obscure the mind’s naturally pure and blissful nature. He integrates practical instruction on purification through Vajrasattva practice and illustrates how present meditation on these truths itself plants powerful karmic seeds for future Dharma experiences. The talk closes with a dedication visualization. Suitable for practitioners already familiar with Buddhist concepts of rebirth and karma.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 6b. Day 2 Meditation Law of Cause & Effect.mp3
UUID: fcd845d5-c088-47c3-b4a2-9a2995dac3f4
Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub
Collection: Meditations DTL (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Date: 2006 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 39.8 minutes
Words: ~2,209
So we can begin our reflection on the law of cause and effect by thinking how we are trapped in cyclic existence because of attachment. Attachment perpetuates our cyclic existence. And because of our attachment, we are clinging to attachment to worldly things. We’re attached to them believing they’re going to bring real happiness. But the most we get is just, you know, illusory happiness, impermanent illusory happiness.
But believing the lie our attachment tells us, We engage in all sorts of negative actions to obtain the objects of our attachment, to keep the objects of our attachment, to protect them. And so we create negative actions and perpetuate cyclic existence. So we do this either because we’re completely ignorant of the law of cause and effect, or we have no faith in it, or we have faith but our attachment overwhelms us, and we go against the law of cause and effect. So it’s vital that we reflect on the law of cause and effect more and more so we get a deeper and deeper understanding, seeing, and the deeper that understanding is. This will help realizing that if we engage in a negative action, it is only going to bring suffering.
It’s inevitable. If we really understand that and we are mindful of it in our daily life, this will help us cut attachment. It will help us to reduce our anger, our pride, our jealousy, all negative, disturbing thoughts. When we really understand that even the tiniest virtuous action will bring incredible happiness in the future and is the basis of all realizations, the accumulation of merit. Then we will use our life not chasing after meaningless things, but seeing the most important thing is to accumulate merit.
It will bring us happiness in saṃsāra, and that merit is the basis for being able to gain realisations. We need to meditate, but what will make our meditations effective, complete, bring the realisation is the amount of merit we have, the power of merit meditating on the path. So then we can begin reflecting on the four basic aspects of the law of cause and effect that the Buddha taught. The first of these, perhaps the most important, is recognising that actions are definite. If we engage in a negative action, it will definitely bring a suffering result.
We can just reflect basically one of the most fundamental teachings of the Buddha on which everything is based and is all related to the profound understanding of the empty nature of all phenomena is that for an effect to exist, for something to exist, there has to be a cause. And if a cause is created, there will inevitably be an effect. So if we create a negative action and create a negative cause, there will be an effect, and that effect will only be suffering. If we engage in a virtuous action of body, speech and mind, there will be effect, and the effect can only be beneficial, bringing happiness and well-being. This, the Buddha said, is definite.
It never ever changes. It will never happen, the Buddha taught, that we will create a cause and there won’t be an effect. It will never happen that there will be something arising without a cause. This is impossible. If we plant a bitter seed, we get a bitter fruit.
If we plant a sweet seed, we get a sweet fruit. This never changes. It never changes. It’s important to reflect more deeply on this point by thinking that the effect of suffering or happiness, there are outer conditions for our happiness and suffering, but they are not the actual cause. The happiness there’s an outer condition, but that induces a mental state of happiness or suffering.
So since the the effect is experienced by mind, by our mind, one’s own mind, my mind, then the cause for that mental effect of suffering or happiness in itself must lie within my mind. The cause of my happiness is not my friends, my possessions, the place I’m living in. That’s just a condition. The root cause has been created within my mind. The cause of my suffering is not my so called enemies and bad conditions outside in the world.
It comes the root cause of my suffering lies within my mind. So only virtuous actions connected with the mind, and actions of speech and body, of course, are motivated by our mind. So it’s only virtuous actions of body, speech, and mind that result in happiness. It’s only negative actions of body, speech, mind that result in the actual cause of suffering. The root cause.
It’s very important to reflect also. This is very fundamental to understand what is meant by positive or negative, virtuous and non virtuous in the Buddhist context, because we can try and argue that, well, good and bad are very arbitrary things. They change with time, with culture. Some cultures think this is good, others say it’s bad. So who determines what is good and bad?
From a Buddhist point of view, what determines that is the mind itself. It’s not something arbitrary, superficial that changes with time. The fundamental basis of Buddha’s teaching and insight, the Buddha discovered that the very nature of our mind is blissful and pure and perfect. So when we do an action of something from our own mind obscures that pure blissful nature negates that, that is a negative non virtuous action. It produces suffering.
It has obscured, negated the arising of the natural bliss of the mind. So there is suffering. And when we act from the natural potential, positive potentials of our mind of wisdom and compassion, kindness and so on. These create the conditions for the pure nature of our mind to reflect, to manifest. So these are positive actions, naturally positive, not arbitrarily posited, arbitrarily determined.
It’s the natural way the mind is working. If we negate the natural quality of our mind, the only effect is suffering. If we follow the natural tendency of the pure nature of mind, if we follow in that direction, do virtuous actions, the only result can be happiness. This is definite. And we can ask ourselves, well, how can I know that the actual nature of my mind is blissful?
We can get some sense of this by training in meditating, just by doing a simple practice of breathing, observing the breath, focusing on that, we can have the experience, even the small experience of the mind becoming calmer and clearer, even if only for a short time. And when that happens, there is some peace. It is not a painful suffering experience. What arises is some kind of peace and joy, even just a little bit. That that experience hasn’t come from outside.
It hasn’t come from something. It is just a a very minor reflection of the actual nature of our mind. If we don’t agitate it, it is blissful. It is joyful. That is its nature.
If we negate it, we suffer. Second fundamental aspect of the law of cause and effect that the Buddha taught is that if we create a cause, there will be an effect. If we don’t create a cause, there is no effect. If there is an effect, a cause has been created. So this means that if we want to experience the effect of happiness, we have to create the cause, the proper cause, the exact cause, the inner cause.
And if we don’t want to experience the effect of suffering, we have to stop creating the causes of suffering. Another fundamental aspect of the law of cause and effect that’s important for us to always be mindful of is that once a cause has been created, an action has been done with our mind, with speech, with our body, the result will definitely come. It may take a very long time for the full karmic result to come. It may take thousands of lifetimes, but eventually the result definitely comes. It is never lost.
So to make more sense of that, it’s important to remember to reflect that in talking about the law of cause and effect, what it’s particularly referring to is that every time a cause is enacted, virtuous or non virtuous, with body, speech and mind, an imprint, a karmic seed, is generated within the mind. And it means that that seed will definitely ripen at some point. Usually not in this life, only if it’s an incredibly strong positive or negative action will the karmic result begin to be experienced in this life. The result may not even be experienced in the next life. It may take many lives before the seed ripens, but it will ripen, and then suffering or happiness is experienced.
It’s so important to remember this point because our self-cherishing can engage in negative actions and there’s no apparent negative result. So we can think, oh, karma doesn’t really work. But actually immediately and simultaneously as the negative or positive action is engaged in, the karmic seeds, potentials, imprints are generated, and they will stay within the mind until the result comes. Just reflect that, in fact, we are accumulating vast numbers of karmic imprints, good and bad, every day with our body, speech, mind. Reflecting on this fact, we should consider how important it is to use this precious human rebirth to purify the negative imprints that we’ve generated.
Because if we use this life, practice the Dharma, use the four opponent powers, do the practice such as Vajrasattva, we can purify those negative imprints and then they won’t bring their suffering result. But if they’re not purified, they will definitely bring the result sooner or later. And similarly, by being very mindful in our life that it is there are virtuous, positive imprints in our mind generated by virtuous actions that are going to bring every kind of happiness for us in the future, then mindful of that, we need to be very careful to guard our mind particularly from very heavy delusions such as anger, because these can destroy the positive imprints. We work so hard to create these virtuous imprints, but a moment of anger can eliminate them. The fourth fundamental aspect of the law of cause and effect to reflect on is that the Buddha said that the karmic result that comes from positive and negative actions is far greater than the cause.
A very simple virtuous action can result in a whole lifetime of happiness because there is this increasing effect. A tiny negative action can bring the result of suffering in the lower realms. The Buddha himself gave the analogy that just as a tiny seed can bring the result of a huge tree, many branches and fruit growing from it. In the same way, just a tiny karmic imprint, good or bad, when it ripens, can bring a huge result. Understanding this, it’s important that we put energy into avoiding even the smallest negative action of body, speech, mind.
And being enthusiastic about creating even small virtuous actions, because these will bring fantastic, wonderful results in the future. We should understand that what we’re doing right now by training the mind in in analytical meditation right now, This is an incredibly virtuous act because we try to generate the bodhicitta motivation. We’re meditating on the very positive subject, the Dharma. So as we do this, we are creating these powerful karmic seeds in our mind right now. So these can only ripen as happiness and the conditions for happiness.
Right now we’re creating the seeds in our mind, the potential within our mind, to meet the Dharma in the future, to have more faith in it, to be able to practice it more easily, to be able to meditate more effectively. We’re creating these causes right now. So bring this reflection to conclusion, making a strong determination to be more and more mindful of these four points of about the law of cause and effect in one’s daily life, because these will help protect our mind from engaging in negative actions. Mindfulness of these four facts will encourage us to be enthusiastic about practicing the Dharma, realizing that even if no great result happens in this life, definitely we are planting the seeds for better rebirths and for greater Dharma experiences in future lives. And recall the Guru Buddha at your crown, seeing the Buddha very pleased with us, and because of that, the Buddha happily dissolves into golden light, and that blissful light comes down through our crown, pervading our whole being, blessing our mind to be able to gain an unmistaken, stable realisation of the truth of the law of cause and effect.
Through that realization, gain the mind that completely renounces all negative actions, and it has great enthusiasm for engaging in Dharma practice. Dedicate the merits to protect the seeds of virtue from anger, and to make sure that they ripen not just as illusory happiness but as the conditions for realizations on the path to enlightenment. If you want to dedicate the imprints to taking rebirth in the god realm, you can, but not such a good idea.
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- four opponent powers nyenpo tob zhi (Tib)
- The four practices used to purify nonvirtuous imprints on the mindstream. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.