Meditations DTL — 10b. Day 3 Meditation Suffering

36 min · 2,006 words · 2006 · Buddha House Adelaide

Meditations DTL (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Meditations DTL (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Meditations DTL — 10b. Day 3 Meditation Suffering
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 36-minute guided meditation, Ven Thubten Dondrub leads practitioners through a contemplation on the suffering nature of cyclic existence. He begins by establishing mental discipline and mindfulness, then systematically deconstructs attachment to worldly happiness by examining how ordinary pleasures are impermanent and fundamentally unsatisfying. Using concrete examples—sitting and standing, the fading sound of a bell, the pleasures of higher realms—he shows that what the deluded mind calls happiness is merely the suffering of change. He then turns to inevitable forms of suffering that accompany rebirth: sickness, aging, loss of sense faculties, separation from loved ones, and death itself. The meditation culminates in generating strong determination to renounce attachment to saṃsāra and develop the wisdom needed for complete liberation. Pitched at serious practitioners with familiarity to Buddhist meditation and renunciation teachings.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 10b. Day 3 Meditation Suffering.mp3

UUID: 24939e41-8706-43b5-aa4e-732d90739de4

Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub

Collection: Meditations DTL (Ven Thubten Dondrub)

Date: 2006 (exact day not recorded)

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 36.4 minutes

Words: ~2,003

Having prepared the mind for the main part of the meditation, make strong determination that I will not let my mind wander from the boundaries of this subject of suffering or cyclic existence. I’ll be very mindful throughout the session to catch any hindrances arising dullness, sleepiness, or the agitated mind that arises by being distracted by sounds, pains, other sensations in the body and my own thoughts. Make determination to quickly let go of these things or apply the antidote if necessary, at the very least thinking of the Guru Buddha at one’s crown, sending powerful white light to immediately dispel any difficulty. So then we can begin our reflection by thinking how while I remain in cyclic existence, and I remain so because of the fundamental delusion of ignorance, but because of that ignorance I have attachment, and I constantly follow that attachment, constantly listen to my self-cherishing thought, and become attached to the illusory appearances of this life, believing it’s happiness. And then when my happiness is threatened, I get angry, I get proud, jealous, full of doubts and fears and worries.

Every other delusion arises. And following those delusions, I create negative karma, negative actions, generate negative imprints in the mind, and this ripens in suffering in the lower realms and suffering in the upper realms, and it just goes on and on. So think, even with this human body, even though I’ve got a precious human rebirth, almost every day I create negative actions that can become the cause of the lower realms. Just allow your mind to think of the suffering of the lower realms right now, what it would be like to have an animal body, to be something like that tiger snake we saw yesterday, or any other kind of animal, or to be trapped in the even lower realms. Sooner or later, we will create the cause for such a rebirth, and sooner or later, those negative imprints will ripen and throw us into those realms.

If we remain attached to cyclic existence the way we are. So basically, we create the cause for falling into those lower realms and experiencing that horrific suffering because of our attachment to the happiness of this life, what we think of as the happiness of this life. Certain things, people, appear in our mind as so incredibly desirable that if I am with this person, have this possession, live here, go there, do this, I will have real happiness. What we really need to understand with this precious human rebirth, because we’ve got the optimum chance to do so, is that all the happiness that we’ve experienced, everything that appears to be happiness, is what the Buddha discovered to be simply the suffering of change. It isn’t happiness at all.

It’s just another form of of experience that brings dissatisfaction, that is unsatisfying, is frustrating in its nature even as we experience The simplest way to understand this that we should think on right now is that every possible, ordinary happiness that we can think of, that we’ve either experienced or could experience that others have experienced, other human ordinary human beings experience, it doesn’t last. It just simply doesn’t last. Even if it lasts all the lifetime, our life comes to an end. It isn’t perfect happiness. It isn’t permanent happiness the way we believe, the way our self-cherishing and attachment tells us?

It is. It just isn’t real happiness. All the wonderful experiences we’ve had in this life are now a memory. The experience of this retreat will become a memory. Nothing lasts.

In the ordinary samsaric mind, it just doesn’t stay. So why should we be attached to it, obsessed with it? It’s all bound to frustration. It might be pleasurable, but it isn’t happiness. And if we reflect on how we meditated on impermanence before, all our happiness arises depending on causes and conditions.

So even though it may last for some time, it is actually fading away moment by moment, irreversibly, just like the sound of the bell. Every ordinary worldly happiness is no more substantial or lasting than the sound of that bell. It’s just fading away as we experience it. So how can we call that happiness? Then at a more deeper level, can reflect how what we are attached to believing the experience to be happiness is not happiness is because to our confused, inexperienced mind, It’s only relatively happiness compared to what we could experience.

These limited things we label happiness because we have no idea of what we could actually experience. Even the bliss of samadhi, which is is in fact a worldly experience, that bliss is far, far greater than any kind of happiness that we experience. But even that bliss of samadhi is something worldly that doesn’t last. The pleasures of the god realms are far greater than anything in the human realm. But even the pleasures of the god realms don’t last.

We simply don’t know what real happiness is. So in our confusion, we label the suffering of change as happiness. And one can reflect that even from a very gross point of view, when we’re very unhappy, depressed, upset, something comes along the slightest thing to distract our mind. We get attached to it. We decide this is happiness.

Anything to distract our mind is happiness. Anything that distracts us away from feeling our ever present dissatisfaction, we call it happiness. And the sad thing is we create negative karma because of attachment to that illusion. But still somehow our mind seems to think that the suffering of change means that something is first, it’s somehow happiness, and then it turns into suffering. But the suffering of change doesn’t mean that at all.

It means that what we think of as happiness is always, from the moment it arises, is actually suffering, unsatisfying. We’ve probably all heard the analogy before, but we can reflect on it once again to understand this point, that if we’re experiencing the suffering, the obvious suffering of, for example, standing up, then when we sit down, there is the pleasure of sitting down. We call this a type of happiness. But in fact, from the very first moment when we sit down, the suffering of sitting is there. But we don’t notice it.

Our gross mind isn’t aware of the suffering of sitting. What our mind is aware of is that the suffering of standing up, being exhausted and so on, from standing up, bearing the weight of the body, all that has stopped. So compared to that, sitting down appears. It just appears to the mind to be pleasure, to be happiness, and the mind focuses on that difference and calls it happiness, believes it’s happiness. But as we continue to sit, we forget about the suffering of standing that we just experienced, and we become more and more aware of the subtle discomforts of sitting.

We have to move here and there. Eventually, have to stand up. But that discomfort of sitting was always there. It was very subtle in the first moment, but then it becomes more and more noticeable. But it was always there.

The pleasure of sitting didn’t change into the suffering of sitting, it was always suffering, unsatisfying, incomplete, frustrating, annoying, unfulfilling. Everything that we experience as happiness is like that. Just reflect that if the pleasure of sitting, the happiness of sitting was real happiness, the longer we sat, the longer the happiness would would remain or it would even increase. If sitting was a true cause of the happiness of sitting. If we hit our head with a piece of wood, it hurts.

It’s obvious suffering. If we hit our head again, it hurts again. If we keep doing it, it keeps hurting, because it is suffering. It really is suffering. It’s not truly existing suffering, but it is conventionally genuine suffering.

But when we perpetuate the causes of what we call happiness, our happiness just doesn’t stay because it isn’t happiness. So we can reflect on what is the nature of desire and attachment. What attachment and desire do is that they exaggerate the pleasant nature of something. Conventionally, relatively, there is some kind of pleasure or happiness, but attachment, desire, completely exaggerated, far beyond what it is, and at the same time, the illusion that it’s permanent. With our precious human rebirth, we now have a clear mind, we have the dharma wisdom to be able to see through these lies and not follow them and create the causes of suffering, but instead to renounce it and become free.

So the sad thing of being in cyclic existence is even the happiness we experience isn’t real, is just an illusion. But what goes with cyclic existence is definite suffering that even we can, with our deluded minds, know is suffering. Even if we take rebirth as a human again and again, we still have to face many obvious sufferings. There’s the suffering of being born again and again. Having taken rebirth in an ordinary body produced by delusion and karma, we have to experience sooner or later, even as a human, various kinds of sickness.

Even if in this life we remain very healthy all our life, we have to reflect and understand that while we remain in cyclic existence, even if it miraculously happened that we got reborn as a human again and again, it means sooner or later we’ll experience every kind of sickness, the most horrific kinds of sicknesses again and again and again. If we don’t develop renunciation, this is absolutely, absolutely going to happen to us sooner or later. Similarly, even taking being a human again and again, we will have to experience the suffering of aging and growing very old. The suffering of losing whatever attractiveness of body that we may have. We have attachment to that, so the more attachment we have to our appearance, as it fades away, we suffer.

We have to suffer our body becoming very weak and frail, difficult to move. The suffering of our senses fading away, food becomes less enjoyable, difficult to digest. Our hearing becomes difficult, difficult to see. Our mind becomes more confused. Our memory fades away.

The longer we live, we have to have experience the suffering of losing all our friends. Just when we become most dependent, we’re surrounded by strangers. Even if we don’t experience these things in this life, it’ll happen in the next life or the next life, again and again and again. This is saṃsāra. And having taken birth again and again, we have to experience death again and again.

So we may be fortunate to sometimes experience good deaths, peaceful deaths, but because of our negative imprints, we will have to experience many sufferings of death again and again, and having to go into the Bardo state, experience the terrifying visions of the Bardo state again and again. So we can bring a conclusion to our meditation by making strong determination to use this precious human rebirth more and more, not to perpetuate the causes of cyclic existence, but to completely renounce our attachment to the appearances of this life, completely renounce any kind of attachment to cyclic existence, to make this strong determination to completely become free of all of that suffering, to make a definite emergence from all of that, to use this precious human rebirth to particularly start to develop the wisdom that is able to free us of all suffering. Then thinking of Guru Śākyamūni Buddha at one’s crown, you see the Buddha is very pleased with our practice, and because of that, the Buddha happily dissolves into light, and that blissful light comes down through our crown, permeating our whole being, blessing our mind to be able to gain a complete, stable, unmistaken realization of the suffering nature of cyclic existence and through that, the realization of complete renunciation.

Key terms in this teaching

higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
upper realms
The three higher realms in samsara of human, asura and sura. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top