1 h 51 min · 11,977 words · 10 February 2015 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 111-minute session, Ven Thubten Dondrub guides practitioners through week five of a course on the wisdom of emptiness, focusing on the nature of the self and the critical first step of Buddhist meditation: identifying the object to be refuted. After opening prayers and guru yoga instruction, he explains how the Buddha’s teachings aim to free all beings from suffering through realizing emptiness. The core teaching centers on two key insights: that the self exists only as a mere label dependent on body and mind, not as an independent entity; and that all phenomena arise only through dependent origination. Dondrub walks through the philosophical impossibility of inherent existence using the five aggregates framework, systematically refuting the notion that an inherently existing self could be identical to, separate from, or composed of body and mind. He uses vivid examples—rainbows, mirrors, ropes mistaken for snakes—to convey how mind projects an illusion of true existence onto phenomena that are actually empty of such inherence. The session culminates in practical meditation instructions: the four-point analysis technique for locating the false sense of self by recalling moments of fear or anger, then examining honestly what that sense of self actually is. Dondrub emphasizes that realizing emptiness is a profound, difficult undertaking requiring purification, merit accumulation, and study over many lifetimes, not a weekend achievement. Pitched at serious practitioners with some familiarity with Buddhist philosophy.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2015 02 10 DB Wisdom of Emptiness Week 5 10022015.mp3
UUID: f2570468-66a4-4b6f-b758-2737ad6d421a
Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub
Collection: DB Wisdom of Emptiness (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Date: 2015-02-10
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 111.4 minutes
Words: ~11,971
Class on the wisdom of emptiness where the nature of reality is becoming becoming clearer and clearer to everyone, I hope. So this subject is really the very heart of the Buddha’s Buddha’s teachings because the whole purpose of the Buddha’s teachings is to free us from suffering. So that that is the the fundamental purpose of the Buddha’s teachings. But beyond that, there is also the purpose of not only enabling us to be free of suffering individually, but having become free of suffering to be in a position to help every sentient being to be free of suffering. So we need that wisdom for for our own sake, but for to eliminate the subtle obscurations to omniscience so that we can achieve enlightenment for the sake of others.
So as much as possible, try and generate the the bodhicitta motivation right now wishing to study this this subject and put it into practice as much as one can, as much as one understands, not only for one’s own benefit, but with a thought to be able to be in a eventually be in a position where one can be of continuous, perfect, lasting benefit to to all sentient beings without exception. So with that thought and and visualizing the Śākyamūni Buddha in front of us as our source of refuge, inspiration, guidance, we can think Three Jewels of refuge and possessing all the qualities of the Three Jewels of refuge. One can think of the Buddha as the embodiment of all past, present, and future perfect teachers. And we can think of the Buddha appearing in front of us to remind us of our own Buddha potential, to inspire us to realize it. And at at the same time of thinking of the Buddha, we think of all sentient beings surrounding us, how they are not only suffering, but have only been and are only kind to me in countless ways, especially giving me the kindness of a mother and father over and over again.
So in this way, we can that that we can by thinking of them, of those beings surrounding us, we can that can motivate us to free our mind of all delusions or confusion because because those that confusion and delusion causes us suffering, leads us to harm others. So we have to develop this wisdom that realizes the true nature of all phenomena, the empty nature of all things. So if you’d like to join in, the prayer is on page eleven. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, Dharma, and the Supreme Assembly. By the merits I create through practicing the Dharma, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings.
So then thinking the Buddha’s pleased with our motivation, we imagine the Buddha coming towards the crown of our head. And then when directly above our crown, we imagine the Buddha dissolving into light so that that blissful light can then pour down into us, blessing our mind to be able to be receptive to these teachings, blessing our mind to be able to understand and put them into practice so that eventually at some point, we’ll be able to gain a direct realization of the empty nature of our self and all phenomena. And then just briefly doing the nine round breathing exercise as a way to further focus and and concentrate our mind, enabling it to become a little bit more calm and clearer so that we can use that level of mind to listen to and think about the Buddhist teachings tonight. Okay. Thank you.
So before we go into the topic, the subject, just someone mentioned in their homework, just asked me to explain a little bit what guru yoga is because it’s mentioned in the Mahāmudrā about the preliminaries of of preliminary practices that are very important to purify the mind and accumulate merit for being able to directly perceive the empty nature of one’s mind. So one of those practices is Guru Yoga. So in in the in the Mahāyāna teachings, especially as they preserved in have been preserved in Tibet and and now spread around the world, There is a great emphasis on especially if we want to achieve enlightenment, then there is the incredible need to rely on a qualified teacher and to devote oneself to that that qualified teacher, having checked out the teacher for for having the right qualities, especially of someone having a subdued mind, living in pure morality, having great compassion, and having some real wisdom experience of the true nature of themselves and phenomena. If one has discovered such a guru, then it’s important to and one feels a connection with them, then it’s very important to devote oneself to that person, particularly in the sense of seeing devotion particularly refers to training the mind to develop the faith, the conviction that a genuinely qualified teacher who is actually really affecting one’s mind, really benefiting one’s mind, really inspiring one’s mind to follow the path, that person — it is valid to see that person as a Buddha..
So guru devotion refers to training the mind in seeing the the qualified teacher that one feels connected to as a Buddha. There are many reasons for doing that, but the main one or two main ones is by by having that pure view. It’s the purest view you can have, it cuts all doubts that what what you’re hearing, what you’re being advised to do is correct. Yeah. So if one believes one’s one’s qualified teacher, not any any teacher, but the really qualified one, is Buddha, if you really develop that conviction, not forcing yourself to believe it, but believing it through having a valid basis for believing it, then you have no doubt that what you’re being taught, what you’re being advised to do is exactly what you need to know and do.
And therefore, one will tend to do it unless one is really, really stupid, which we do tend to be speaking for myself. But, otherwise, we will do those things. And so, therefore, one cuts through that’s the best way to cut through all obstacles and difficulties. And the other main reason for seeing the guru’s Buddha, which is difficult to explain, is a much more mystical thing, which is that you receive blessings of the Buddhas this way. And one needs the blessings of the Buddhas to really gain realizations.
So on the basis of practicing guru devotion, seeing the guru as a Buddha, then there is the the more advanced practice of what is called Guru Yoga, which is more a tantric practice. But also, I think certain aspects of Zen have this practice. So in in in the tantric system of Guru Yoga, Guru Yoga is the practice whereby on the basis of understanding that one’s guru is who the the the guru’s mind is the same as the mind’s as all the Buddhas. It’s inseparably the same. The guru’s mind is the Buddha’s mind.
The Buddha’s mind is the guru’s mind. And and that mind is pure and perfect in every conceivable way and inconceivable way. And the very subtlest level of one’s mind is has Buddha nature. So one could say that the subtlest level of one’s mind and the Guru’s mind is the same. And the and the Guru’s and the mind is the same as the Buddha’s mind.
So it’s all one. It’s all one, man. It’s all one. Sorry. Excuse me.
So that’s what guru yoga is, is training to try and unify one’s mind. There are different ways of doing this, of seeing one’s own purest level. Not not this ordinary gross deluded mind, but the pure level of one’s mind, which is always there as inseparably one with the guru’s mind, which is inseparably one with the Buddha’s mind, yeah, with the dharmakaya. So that’s what, in a nutshell, guru yoga is about. Yeah.
So in a sense, you could say that that’s just a more a super profound practice of guru devotion, and that brings the greatest blessings if one can do that to any degree. And, actually, believe it or not, that’s what you’re doing that’s what we do. When you imagine the Buddha dissolving into you, that really is guru yoga because you imagine the guru’s mind, the Buddha’s mind, and your mind become the same. So if one can really do that, that’s it. Then then you it it is kind of like you’re you’re enabling your that deepest level of mind to connect with Buddha mind.
Actually, I have no idea what I’m talking about, but, you know, that’s what what I’ve understood or misunderstood. I think it’s a very profound subject, actually. Alright. And, of course, the guru has realized one trains the trains the mind to understand that the guru’s mind has realized emptiness. So by practicing guru yoga, it helps one to realize emptiness, unifying one’s mind with the mind that has realized the true nature of all things.
So, yeah. So in the teachings on the nature of reality, it points out that in reality, is the emptiness or the selflessness of the person and the selflessness of phenomena. So hold it just a minute. Just gotta check this. Yes.
So there is the selflessness of the person and the selflessness of phenomena. So usually, to understand this topic, firstly, the selflessness of phenomena is explained, but in actually in actuality, to realize the selflessness of phenomena is more difficult than to realize the selflessness of persons. So the selflessness of the person is actually easier to realize than the selflessness of phenomena. I think I’ve got that right. But in both cases, the easiest way, according to Lama Tsongkhapa, to realize both the selflessness of the person and the selflessness of phenomena is through the understanding of dependent arising.
Because in both cases, the we are although the object is different, the object in one case is the person, me, and in the other case, the object is all other phenomena. So although the object differs, the way we perceive those objects is the same. This false way that due to ignorance, our mind experiences both self and phenomena as inherently inherently existing or truly existing or existing from its own side under its own power as though it were independent, an independent phenomena, not needing a base, not needing even a label. We grasp that the I really exist. Every phenomena really exist there from its own side.
So the easiest way to undermine that is to depend on the labeling mind. And more than that, that’s the only way they can exist. It’s not that just that when you check, this is the way things do exist. But what’s more important to understand, I think, is this the this is the only way things can exist, that they really can’t exist any other way than depending on, well, causes and conditions, parts, and the labeling mind when we’re talking about impermanent phenomena, which is the vast majority of everything. Right?
There are permanent phenomena. They don’t depend on causes and conditions, but they’re not very important. Except there there is one important important permanent phenomena, which probably just gets confusing, but I probably have to mention it, and that is emptiness. Emptiness is a permanent phenomenon. It doesn’t change moment by moment.
See, this this glass, its ultimate nature is empty. So the emptiness of this this glass, the conventionally existing, merely labeled, dependently arising glass, that depends on causes and conditions. But the emptiness of the glass doesn’t depend on causes conditions. It is permanent. Yeah.
But the emptiness of the glass is still a dependent arising because you can’t have the emptiness of a glass glass without a glass. So the emptiness of a glass depends on a glass existing. You can’t have the emptiness of something that does not exist. The only things which are empty are things which exist, which which that itself shows how one should be free of the extreme thinking things don’t exist when talking about emptiness because emptiness can only exist depending on things existing. You can’t have emptiness by itself.
Then it would be truly existing, but emptiness doesn’t truly exist. It does exist, but it doesn’t inherently exist because nothing inherently exists. Nothing can inherently exist. So maybe my language has been, as usual, very sloppy because I’ve I’ve just been reading some of the homework, and and terrifying what people have understood from what I’ve been saying. It doesn’t really approximate what I’ve been trying to say.
But, anyway, the Cittamātra view, as I just very roughly speaking, as I at least as I’ve understood it, the Cittamātra view, the mind only school, is saying that that there is only mind. Everything out there is just purely a projection of the mind. There isn’t anything out there. It’s all simply coming from the mind. But the the Mādhyamika view is not that.
The Mādhyamika view is not I’ve been saying everything, you know, is well, I’m not quite sure what I’ve been saying, but I have been I think I’ve been trying to say everything depends on the mind. So there is a difference subtle difference between the Cittamātra view and the Mādhyamika view that the Madhyamikas are saying that there are external phenomena, but they’re they’re they’re not something they’re not independently existing from their own side, but there is external phenomena. They’re not just made up of mind, but they do depend on the mind to exist and the way they exist. The only way anything can exist is by being merely labeled by the mind. If the mind isn’t labeling something, it isn’t existing.
It can’t exist. It just simply can’t can’t exist. This is the view. So it’s a very, very profound, quite radical view. There’s nothing like it anywhere else, especially the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika view because they’re saying, you know, yes, that there’s nothing there from its own side.
It’s it’s all dependent on the mind, but it’s not just made up of mind. There’s nothing there from its own side, but there is something there. So because things don’t truly exist, they they require a name. They have to have a name. Yeah.
This is something really interesting too. I should have given this as the homework. I haven’t. But if you if you can’t do any of the other homework, just meditate on that every day to think about this. Because things do not truly exist, they require a name.
They have to be given a name. And that’s what we do. We give things a name all the time. And requiring a name just doesn’t mean the word, you know, like glass and conscious and it doesn’t mean consciously giving that name. I mean, that’s involved, but there’s there’s something much more subtle than that going on.
I mean, maybe this doesn’t help, but I’ll try. If if we eat eat eat something for the first some some dish for the first time and we say, oh, that was really nice, really tasty. So we are labeling it as being tasty, and therefore, it appears tasty. But when we in the in the process of saying, oh, that’s really tasty, that’s not when we labeling it as tasty. We’ve already you know you know, we may be thinking in our mind, oh, this is delicious, or we actually say to someone, oh, this is delicious.
But the labeling has occurred before that. And it’s not something conscious. It’s just something that we grasp instinctively, maybe due to some conditioning in this life, but also past conditioning, past karmic imprints, you know, that we conceive of something in a particular way. And in the next moment, as Lama Zopa Rinpoche says, you have to you have to I highly advise all of you if you can get a chance to meet Lama Zopa Rinpoche and listen to Lama Zopa Rinpoche teach on emptiness because I don’t there’s anyone who can teach it better. If you if you’re patient and listen, it’s mind blowing when Rinpoche teaches on emptiness because if yeah.
But but he says, you know, so in one moment, you know, the mind labels something, the, you know, glass, water, delicious, delicious, cold. Oh, nice. In one moment, the mind labels it that way, which means conceives it. We conceive it in some way. We our mind conceptualize, creates an image of it.
Yeah. It’s this. Yeah. And we do that instinctively, not consciously, not and but then, Rinpoche says, in the next moment, you know, so we label it. We conceive it.
And depending and that conception depends on many things such as words and labels. But then in the next moment, having done that in the next moment, this object appears back as though it really is that. It appears as though we haven’t labeled it. It’s like some painter who paints something, then they have amnesia, and then they look at that and think, oh, that’s a beautiful painting. I wonder who painted that.
That’s marvelous. No. That’s not a very good example. But, anyway, some it’s something like that. We paint things and don’t know we’ve painted it and think, oh, that’s what it actually is.
We paint an orange on on think it’s a real orange. So we label something this, that, and it appears back as really being that from its own side. Just from completely there from its own side. Because Rinpoche also makes this point. He always says this, you know, it’s it’s there.
I think that has a lot of meaning. I’m not quite sure what the meaning is, but it has a lot of meaning that that Rinpoche says it’s it’s there. Because I think what it implies is we believe that it’s, you know, separate from us. It’s there. It’s not connected to my mind.
It’s just there. Everything is just there, out there. Out there. But it’s not really a hundred percent out there. That’s what we’re doing all the time and believing that’s not happening.
We’re unaware of it, and we think it’s what we’ve what we’ve conceived is it. Anyway, merely labeled. It’s just merely labeled. Yes. Yes.
In a yes. I think yes. Yes. Do you think we could close that door? It’s happening.
It’s happening. Alright. Okay. So it’s not like that there is this glass waiting for us to come along and label it. The glass that we experience, you know, isn’t there waiting for us to see it and label it.
The glass arises depending on causes and conditions, the basis, and the labeling. And only then when all those things come together is there a glass. Just like, you know, the sound isn’t waiting for us to hear, you know, it has to it it arises depending on all of those things coming together in one moment, and then there’s the sound. So because things don’t truly exist, they require a name. Without a basis, it can’t be labeled.
There has to be a see, this is, you know, you have to have the basis to label it. You can’t just label things on anything or label nothing. There has to be something to label. So that shows that things arise dependently. But we the point is we don’t experience anything that way, and we don’t we don’t experience any phenomena at all that way, and we don’t experience ourself that way either.
We experience ourself, the self that we’re grasping at now due to ignorance. We we we believe you know, this is not the right word. I don’t know if we’ve got a word that really covers. Don’t if there’s a word in in Tibetan or Sanskrit either. But just for the sake of know, let’s use the word believe because believe implies something very conscious and whatever, but because this is something instinctive.
This is our innate ignorance is just grasping. Maybe just use the word grasping. We we grasp that there is a a real person, a real me. There is a me. Right?
Just like there there is a conventionally merely labeled glass. Yeah. A conventionally existing merely labeled clock, which is arising dependently. That clock, that those things do exist, but inherently existing things don’t exist. They only exist as an illusion.
So there is a person that does exist, and that person that does exist, the me that does exist, the I that does exist, exists like everything else as merely labeled depending arising. It arises depending on a base. And what is the base of the person? The base of the person is the body and mind. Or in technical Buddhist philosophy, they talk about rather than the body and mind, they talk about the five aggregates.
So just very briefly, what are the five aggregates? The five aggregates are the aggregate of form, the form aggregate, which is referring basically to the body. Yeah. And then the other four aggregates refer to aspects of the mind. So the second aggregate is feelings.
The third aggregate is what are called discriminations. The fourth aggregate is called compositional factors. I’ll talk about that. Well, feelings, that’s all. Well, there’s there’s physical and mental feelings.
Even physical feelings are mental, but they they they’re called physical feelings because they operate through the body. But and and then there’s mental feelings. And then feelings are also there are pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral feelings. Pleasant, unpleasant, neutral physical feelings. Pleasant, unpleasant, neutral mental feelings.
Then there are discriminations, which discrimination is referring to this basic ability or factor of the function of the mind to be able to distinguish one object from another, to be able to separate, to distinguish that this is different from that and and this is different from that, etcetera, etcetera. So so it’s this this fundamental ability to distinguish things, discriminate, which is a very vital thing. We wouldn’t be able to function if we couldn’t discriminate different things and the different parts of different things. So the compositional factors, I’ll leave that for the moment. And the fifth aggregate refers to this gets tricky.
The six primary consciousnesses. So there is the primary eye consciousness, ear consciousness, nose consciousness, tongue consciousness, body consciousness, and the mental consciousness. So there there are five primary sense consciousnesses and the primary mental consciousness. Primary consciousness refers to, just in a very simple way, the fundamental ability of a particular consciousness to know its object. And because with each primary consciousness, there are all these secondary or mental factors that operate at the same time.
So, for example, with your eye consciousness, there’s the primary eye consciousness that knows shapes and colors, experiences shapes and colors. But at the same time, there are all these other mental factors that are able to distinguish colors and different shades of colors and shapes and so on and, yeah, all that kind of stuff. And there’s, you know, the mental factor that directs the eye consciousness to to the object and concentrates on it and all these things. But there’s the primary consciousness that just has an overall general experience of its object. This and so on.
Right? So we have six of those primary primary consciousnesses, five sense ones and the mental consciousness. Okay. So right. So now we’ll go back.
So I’ll just repeat again. So there’s the form aggregate, feeling aggregate. So form aggregate referring to the body. The other four aggregates are referring to the mind. So there’s feelings, discriminations.
The fifth aggregate, which is the this is the six primary consciousnesses. And then the fourth aggregate, going back, is called compositional factors. So this refers to all other aspects of the mind, such as all our delusions, all our positive mental factors of love, compassion, patience, and generosity, and etcetera, etcetera, all our dreaming, all of the the the the the And the Sanskrit term which is translated as aggregate is Skandha. And what what this is referring to, like, in the aggregate is a collection of things, an aggregation, a collection of things. So why this term is used is to indicate that it it so, yeah, the whole purpose of talking about the five aggregates is to help us under undermine this wrong view that we have that I am this one fixed concrete thing.
Yeah. Because this is one of the fundamental wrong views that we have about things that, you know you know, you know, this is just a one thing. You know, it’s just a one thing. But when you investigate, this one thing has many, many components. Yeah.
But when you just first think, oh, it’s a rose. It’s a. What I a rose. But a rose is made up of many, many things, many components. So this body is is is an aggregation of many, many things, and the mind is an aggregation of many, many things.
So there’s the four aggregates of the mind, but then each of those aggregates is made up of many, many, many, many factors. Yeah. Changing. Changing. Changing.
So just having an understanding of the aggregates helps us to loosen this wrong view of we wrong view we have of ourself and and phenomena. Kept within. You get you get a new set every every every life. Yeah. A new lot.
And and but each new set are are contaminated aggregates. They’re impure contaminated. Whereas Buddha has five pure aggregates, which represented by the five what are called they’re sometimes called the five Dhyāni Buddhas — Vairocana, Vairocana Buddha. You know, we have the Vairochana posture. So Vairochana symbolizes the pure form aggregate of the Buddha.
Akṣobhya symbolizes the pure consciousness aggregate of the Buddha. Yeah. Like that. Right.
Where are we? Okay. Yes. Okay. No.
I don’t know that at all. I have no idea what you’re talking about. So no. Sorry. Go on.
But I don’t. Go on. This is a nice experience to have, but how can I say? What is your question? Yeah.
But that that that experience, I mean, that experience is probably arising because the mind is a little bit concentrated. So that so that kind of nonduality is quite different. It’s not the same as the nonduality that’s referred to as the experience of emptiness. Because to achieve that that that non dual experience that’s referred to in empty in relation to emptiness, you have to meditate in a specific way. And and to gain that actual experience, you can’t just do that in one meditation.
This is like lifetimes. To realize emptiness is like a major, major, major project. Really, there are some teachers or one teacher in particular, maybe I shouldn’t even say this, who claims you can if you haven’t realized emptiness in this life, you’re a dud. So this is just pure nonsense. The number of people who can realize emptiness or even get remotely close to it in one lifetime is unbelievably difficult because you have to do millions of things to to experience it.
I mean, you have to purify your mind, accumulate merit. You have to have studied the teachings and gained a profound, you know, absolute def definitive realization conceptual understanding of emptiness before you can directly perceive it. This this is a, you know, life you know, some people are saying, oh, I’m having trouble understanding this topic. It’s like, everyone has trouble understanding this topic. This is not something you just understand, you know, over a weekend or a year or ten years or ten lifetimes.
Not to put you off. Every every just even trying to understand this is incredibly beneficial to think about these things. Yeah. Yeah. Anyway so and we have to find the object to be refuted.
Yeah. And that’s the tricky bit. We actually have to find the object to be refuted to realize emptiness. That’s the that’s the special. That’s the heart of the whole whole business.
So so where was I? Oh, yeah. So, yes. So the I that does validly exist, is exists like everything else as a dependent arising. It arises as being merely labeled by the mind depending on a base.
And the base, I was trying to say, what is the base of the merely labeled I? The person me is our body and mind. And, of course, the body arises due to causes and conditions. So the I that validly does exist is what what is merely labeled by the mind depending on the body and mind. Yeah.
So that I does exist. It doesn’t inherently exist, doesn’t truly exist. It just nominally exists, conventionally exists as being merely labeled, yeah, arising dependently. But that I, that’s the only I that does exist. So it’s something impermanent.
It’s changing moment moment by moment. It’s it’s not something you can grasp onto, but it does exist. Yeah. It’s not it’s not something separate from the body, but it’s not something, it’s not the body and mind. It’s not something separate from the body and mind.
It’s something arising depending on the body and mind, and it can only exist arising depending on the body and mind. So it’s like an illusion. It’s not an illusion. It is like an illusion. It is like a rainbow.
It is something insubstantial. You can see a rainbow. A rainbow does exist. You can see it, but it’s something insubstantial. A rainbow arises depending on certain conditions that you have certain amount of moisture in the air.
You have air for a start. You have a certain amount of moisture in the air. You have certain sunlight existing and you have to have someone looking and you have that person has to look in a particular way up there in the sky. And if you look in a particular way, you will see a rainbow. And you have to look up there to see it, but there actually, there there is no rainbow up there.
But there is a rainbow that appears to be up there. But if you were to go up there, you won’t get a better look of it. You won’t see it because it’s not up there. But there is one arising dependently. And that rainbow is not the sunlight.
It’s not the water. It’s not the air. It’s not the person looking. There’s none of those things. It’s none of those things altogether.
It arises totally depending on them. It isn’t made up of any of those things, but it’s not separate from those things. The rainbow isn’t made up of air particles. It isn’t made up of water particles, but it’s there. It depends on them.
And the I, the person that is existing, is like that. The I that does exist isn’t the body. It isn’t the mind. It isn’t a combination of the body and mind, and it’s not something nor is it something completely different from the body and mind. It is something which merely, merely, merely, merely arises depending on the body and mind.
So as Lama’s over Rinpoche always gives us just the simple examples. Simple examples are always best. You know? Right now, we are all sitting. And because we are sitting, our body is sitting, and our mind is connected with our body always except when we’re dead.
We can say validly, I am sitting. I am sitting. Yeah. We can say I, conventionally, I am sitting. There is an I sitting.
Why? Because Because the body, the five aggregates are sitting. Yeah. And as soon as we stand up, the I that was sitting doesn’t exist at all. It’s finished because now I am standing up.
Why am I standing up? Because the body, the five aggregates are standing up. And it’s valid to say, I am standing up when the body is standing up. And when the body’s lying down, it is valid to say, I am lying down. And when you’re putting food in your body, it is valid to say, I am eating.
But in all of those examples, you can’t find an I an I eating that is separate from the body and mind. The I that is eating is not the body and mind, and it’s not something separate from the body and mind. It is what is merely arising arising in the moment when the body and mind are eating. Well, the mind isn’t really eating, but, you know, when the body is. But the mind is connected to it anyway.
And when we’re standing up, up, the I that is standing up is not the body and mind standing up, but it’s not something completely separate from the body and mind standing up. It is what is merely momentarily arising depending on what the body and mind is doing. That’s all I am. I’m nothing big deal. We’re all trying to find our true self, the real me.
But all the real me is is something that changes moment by moment, every single moment, depending on the body and mind because the body and mind is changing moment by moment by moment. And if if my mind is depressed, I am depressed. If my mind is happy, I am happy. And that’s the only I that exists. But the I, you know, when the mind is depressed, we say I am depressed.
That I isn’t the mind that’s depressed. But it’s not something completely separate from the mind that’s depressed. It is what is just merely labeled by the mind depending on the body and mind. That’s all it is. But we experience something quite different.
We grasp that there is a real me that is not the body and mind. Well, maybe maybe actually, what we do, because of ignorance, we have many levels of ignorance and wrong views of ourself. So much of the time, we do believe we are our body. Yeah. This is one of our big mistakes.
Gross mistakes is that we identify ourselves as our body much of the time. Yeah. And as I always say, you know, if people say if people say we we look nice, we you know, that makes us happy, and we think, oh, yes. I am good looking. And if people will say you look ugly or horrible, then we get depressed and upset because we identify with our body.
And we want to look young because that then we think I will live forever. If I remain looking young, I’m going to I mean, I won’t die. I’ll stay the same. I will will keep going if I look young. Yeah.
Do people say that? No, they don’t. Oh, that’s different. That’s completely different. Yeah.
No. I’m talking about us. Just No. That’s yeah. That’s mixing.
No. Forget that. Yeah. If you check, just in general, human beings spend a lot of time looking after their body, you know, feeding it, exercising it, making it look strong and healthy, blah blah blah, because they identify so strongly with with with the body body as being me. And, also, in because we had this, what is it, compassion and action thing about death and what was it called?
Funerals. About funerals and everything. And the two professionals who came along to talk about that from the funeral industry are all mainly talking from a Christian point of view where in Christianity and most other theistic religions, there is a huge identification with the of the person with the body so that looking after a dead body is incredibly important because the dead body is the person. It to a large extent, there is a strong feeling. And you show peep you know, and they often like in movies and things, you’ll see scenes where people go to the grave and talk to the person because the body is there.
So it’s totally irrational. And and, of course, these people will say, of course, the person’s not there and blah blah blah. But at at at some level, there is a huge identification with the body and how important it is for if someone dies for them to have the body because then they know, you know, that’s that’s, you know, that that’s the dead person. Now I know they’re really dead. Yeah.
So we have this huge identification with our our body. But that’s only a superficial level of ignorance. And, of course, if someone says, oh, you’re really smart. When we think, oh, yes. I am really smart.
That’s me. Yes. And, oh, someone says you’re really stupid. Oh, we get very depressed. Oh, me.
I’m I’m I’m stupid. Yeah. So we we we swap around. Sometimes we identify with our body. Sometimes we identify with our mind.
But deep down, that that is not the innate ignorance, which is the real root of Samsāra. Deep down, we think I am something quite separate from the body and mind. This is what the Buddha discovered. This is what we this is what ignorance is. It’s grasping that there is a real me that’s not the body, not the mind, not a combination of them, but something quite separate, and it’s really there.
And as I’ve often said in class other classes, one can see this operating in our own lives and in the lives one could always see it, all these things, you know, other people better, but although we shouldn’t do that because we should only apply the teachings to ourselves in order to be of benefit to others. But, you know, people well, I used to too. I was a chain smoker before I met the Dharma, and you and you smoke and you think, I’m not gonna get cancer. Other people do it, but not I, not me. Yeah.
I can fill my lungs with tons of cigarette smoke, but I I won’t get cancer. Why? Because I’m not the body. You don’t think this logically, but that’s why you believe that. That’s why one can be so incredibly stupid to think that you can smoke, fill your lungs with all this stuff, and be perfectly okay.
Or you can, you know you know, shoot up, be like a ton of heroin, and you’ll be fine. I won’t get addicted. I won’t. Other people, yeah, because they’re stupid or blah blah blah, but not me. Not me.
What is the the rationale? There’s no rationale. It’s just because it’s me, and me isn’t this thing. And that’s why, you know, people scream through red lights because they won’t have an accident. I can I, especially when you’re young?
Sorry. We all these can say this. You know? You’re never going to die when you’re young. You know?
I I I can do all of these things. And, especially, the saddest thing is what the huge mistake that ninety nine point nine nine percent of human beings in every culture and every place all the time have made is I can be happy without taking care of my mind. That is the hugest, biggest error that we make. Everyone is try everyone wants to be happy. Everyone is doing millions of things to be happy, but most people, most of the time, aren’t take doing the thing that is necessary to be happy, which is to take care of the mind because you can do a million things to be happy, get billions of dollars, have tons of boyfriends and girlfriends and, you know, all that stuff, travel all over the world.
But if your mind is like that, because doing all those things doesn’t really change the state of your mind for very long, since your mind is like that and the I that does exist is merely labeled by the mind on the mind. When your mind is berserk, it means I am berserk, which means I am confused and suffering. I confused and suffering, which means I am confused and suffering. Yeah. That’s the one of the main things to realize in all the Buddha’s teachings.
If you get this one, please, I I can retire. Yeah. I haven’t got it either, but one day, I’m hoping to really understand that I totally depend on my mind. If I want to be happy, the only way is to calm the mind, to have a calm, peaceful, virtuous mind. Not a billion dollars, a thousand girlfriends, boyfriends, both, neither, neither, and everything else.
But we can think I can be happy when we don’t know, when we believe I really exist. But that I doesn’t exist. That I is just an illusion, a total illusion, a very, very, very convincing illusion, unfortunately, but an illusion. I haven’t oh, yeah. Okay.
Haven’t got on to the topic properly yet tonight. Well, I’m I’m on the topic, but actually yeah. So what we what we have to realize is to understand is that the I that does exist is the if we start to see, you know, through looking at phenomena that the only way phenomena exists is arising dependently. This is the only way they can exist being merely labeled by the mind depending on the base, which depends on causes and conditions. Then we can start to see that the I that the validly exists, the only way I can validly exist is in the same way as being merely labeled by the mind depending on the body and mind.
Because if if if there was a truly existing I the way we believe and grasp, while I if if that if the truly existing I existed, then while the body is sitting, I could be standing or I could be going for a walk. Right? But that’s not possible. Yeah. Because the I isn’t an independent phenomena.
But if it was a truly existing independent phenomena, the body could be doing one thing, and the mind and the I could be doing something else. The mind could be miserable, and I could be happy. I the mind could be happy, and I could be miserable, but that’s not possible. It’s just not possible. Excuse me.
How would Tom Cruise look to someone who’s realized emptiness? He would look like Tom Cruise, I think. But I wouldn’t worry about that, my friend. Don’t worry about what things look. Look.
I I don’t to be honest, I really don’t think it helps to to think about those kind of things, about what what things will look like and how I will experience things when I realize emptiness. It’s we are suffering. The point is, am I suffering now or not? Is that true? Is that is that obvious or not?
If so, why? The Buddha says it’s because I am ignorant. And this how does this ignorance manifest in creating the illusion of true existence? What undermines that is understanding dependent arising. So the project is to understand dependent arising because the more also, the more we understand dependent arising, it helps us to see to understand our wrong view.
Yeah? The more we understand that dependent arising is the only way things could exist, we start to see that I don’t see things like that. I don’t experience things as a dependent arising. Now I can understand they are, but I don’t experience them that way. I experience them in a quite different way.
And that helps us to be able to identify the object to be refuted, which is the actual appearance of true existence that we or inherent existence that we’re grasping right now, which we’re unaware of. Alright? That that’s that’s all we need to know about, not what’s gonna happen as a result other than it’ll be good. It’ll be blissful. That’s what it’ll be.
It’ll be free of suffering. It’ll be very spacious. It’ll be very good. It’ll be very nice. And it it’ll give a lot of space for all sorts of good stuff to manifest from the mind, like love and compassion and all that.
Any more questions? Yep. Yeah. That’s true. But, again, the changing the label again, you have to remember, changing the label is not just simply using a different word.
Changing the label means changing your mind. Yeah. You know, if if if if I okay, I I tell my you know, I see these as beautiful. I can say ugly. This is ugly.
But I might be even tortured into saying it’s ugly. And at some level, it may be due to being tortured. I might come to the belief it’s ugly, but deep down, I would still be grasping it as beautiful. Yeah? So changing the label is not just a matter of, you know, saying different words.
It’s something very profound and particularly changing from conceiving inherent existence to perceiving dependent arising. This is not just a matter of words or saying, oh, I’ve got you know? Yeah. This is this is changing the mind, and this is making the most profound change in the mind, an absolutely radical change of the mind, which requires many things, many lifetimes of purifying the mind, accumulating merit, depending on a guru, studying the teachings, meditating on them, living in pure morality. Remember the three higher trainings, living one’s life based on pure morality, developing concentration, then studying the teachings, and then meditating on them.
Purifying one’s karma, then then the mind can change. In some cases, like like, we can have relationships with people, and we develop an aversion to person and a person by through working on our mind even in this life after a short time, we may change our attitude to that person. That’s somehow that’s possible. But some things, like we re friend can become I mean, enemy can become friend. Yeah?
But other things, it’s much more difficult to change. Isn’t it? Yeah. And this one is the most difficult because it’s innate. It’s not a conscious thing.
With sort of seeing a person as an enemy, that sort of a conscious decision we’ve made, maybe also through some instinctive impulses as well, but it’s something that we can consciously change fairly quickly if we really apply our mind to it. But but the one about inherent existence, that that’s a that’s a lulu. That’s really something to that really takes a lot of work. Yeah. Tea tea break.
Are we all here? Looks like we lost a few people. So I’d just like to talk a little bit in the time remaining about the way to meditate on the look meditate on the emptiness of the eye, trying to get some sense of the emptiness of the I of the person. Not that the the eye doesn’t exist at all, but the I is empty of inherently existing. So there is a very traditional famous method of of meditation technique for doing this, which is called the four point analysis.
This is so I just I don’t know if I got I don’t have time to go through it all in detail tonight, but at least I can start. So the so the first point of the four point analysis is actually the trickiest bit, which is to try and discover the object to be refuted. In this case, the person, the the appearance of the truly existing person. And this is not referring to having some intellectual understanding of that, but trying to pinpoint as as much as one can the actual way one sees oneself as existing, existing in a very fundamental way. As I mentioned before, this is one the most difficult realizations to gain in the whole spiritual path, but still everything begins step by step, little by little.
So it all begins by by trying to do this. And for most of us, if we’re honest, we try and do this, we can’t find anything. Nothing appears very clearly at all. So one may may make may one may may no. One may make the mistake thinking, oh, I can’t find the I.
Oh, I’ve realized emptiness. I’m a Buddha. So that that just means you’re we’re just very confused. So but, anyway, the way to do it, the basic way to do it, simple way to do it, is is to well, one aspect of it is to remember in one meditation, you just take one instant from the past, not too distant past, where you remember an incident where the sense of I, which is always present with us, but in meant much of the time, we’re not not very conscious of our sense of I. But in some situations, the sense of I arises very strongly, particularly what may depend on people’s personalities.
But, obviously, when we’re when we’re very angry or excited or what embarrassed or afraid, these are some of the main situations where the sense of I arise is very strongly. So what you try to do is remember an instant like that where one was very afraid or embarrassed or angry or what? Very proud, excited. Yeah. Some incident.
But the the tricky thing here is not you know, the the the problem is in remembering such an incident, one just gets caught up in the incident and distracted by the incident. The idea is not to go into the incident, but to remember the incident just enough in order to try to get that sense of self. So you don’t want to remember an incident too far in the past because, like, maybe you were very angry when you were seven, but we were all much older than seven now. So we that sense of I then is not who we identify with now. So it needs to be something not too far in the past.
Do you know what I mean? And yes. Right. So so then the idea is to just recall that incident so that sense of I arises, and then the thing is to try and look at that. What is that I that is is embarrassed or angry or ashamed or proud or afraid?
What is that I? Not what am I wearing? What do I look like? You know, those kind of ordinary things, but what is that I? What is it that is what is this I that is experiencing this particular emotion?
Right? So that’s what one has to try and focus on. No. No. No.
No. No. No. He said that. She said that.
No. She shouldn’t have said that. He should have. No. No.
No. No. No. No. None of that.
No. What’s going on? But no. Yeah. Yeah.
There’s there’s an angry I. What is this angry? Not why am I angry or why am I unhappy or why I am this or what caused it. None of those things. You remember that to bring up that I, but then what is that I?
Yeah. What is that I, that me? Not not what it’s supposed to be according to the Buddha’s teachings, what one actually feels it to be, believes it, grasps it to be. Right? We’re not trying to pass some being a good Buddhist, you know, student or something, we’re trying to identify our wrong view, our wrong experience of ourself, to identify the object to be refuted.
So that that’s one way of doing it. And and another way of doing it, more or less, it’s similar, that the Lama Zopa Rinpoche suggests is, just when you’re sitting meditating because you’re one is sitting meditating doing this, you can just ask yourself or you can just even say the words I am, you know, I am sitting, yeah, or I am meditating. I am sitting, I am meditating. Just one, not both. Just do one of those things.
And then you check, you try and find out what one is grasping at as the I that is sitting. So, of course, the body is sitting and the mind is connected to the body. So the mind is there sitting with the body in a sense. But so you try and find out this I that is you know, when you say I am sitting, you try and find out what is that I. So if if you can sort of get some sense that one is grasping that there is something even a little bit more than the body and mind sitting here, that is the object to be refuted.
Yeah. Because there isn’t something else sitting here. But if you think, you know I mean, you can even well, we could even try and do it for a few seconds now. You know? We’re all sitting here, sitting on a cushion, sitting on a chair, and and we all we all think I am sitting.
I I we are all convinced. You know, I am convinced. I am sitting here. What is this I sitting here? What is it?
What is it made up of? What does it consist of? How does it exist? Does it feel like it’s something inside your body or something inside your head, inside your brain? Can you locate where where this I is?
Okay. Thank you. So you could spend a long time looking for the I that way. But the idea is not to come up with some, you know, academic answer. It is to try to identify what one is believing, grasping, you know, as honestly as one can.
Because we have to peel away the layers of ignorance. Anyway, so that’s the first point point of the the four point analysis. And, eventually, we’ll be able to do that if we purify our mind, etcetera. We study the teachings, which helps us to understand the wrong view and therefore locate that, actually, I’ve got it. I have this wrong view a hundred percent.
So and to do that, we need to purify our mind, accumulate merit, concentrate, learn to concentrate our mind more and more, still our mind. But one day, we’ll be able to locate it, but it all starts. You know? Being able to locate it for the is not an inherently existing thing. It will arise dependently by by training the mind starting now, trying to do this.
So, anyway, that’s the first and most important point. The second point of the second point of the four point analysis is to come to an understanding, an intellectual understanding that if the I you know, this is assuming we’ve found the object to be refuted, which is the truly inherently existing I. So if that I, the inherently existing I, did exist it doesn’t. But if it did, it could only exist in one of two ways and there’s no other alternative. This inherently existing I, if it did exist, it would have to be inherently the same as the Body and Mind or it would have to be inherently different from the five aggregates.
Possibility is there’s no third possibility. Sorry? What do you mean by that? Yes. Well, this is the point.
You you seem to have jumped and saying, oh, this is dualistic. Yes. It is. It’s saying there’s only two possibilities because you have to come to the conclusion yourself that there are only two possibilities. For example for example I could say I have an animal.
What you have to tell me no. No. I don’t know how to put this. Yeah. If if if someone oh, I don’t know.
You’ve got some kind of game and you have an animal and you have to say what it is. No. No. No. An animal.
And you have to identify what kind of animal it is. And I and I say, well, it can only be a dog or a cat. Well, that is ridiculous because there are many more possibilities for animals to be other than dogs or cats. But in this case, what we need to understand is if an inherently existing I exists, it can only be something connected to this or something utterly different from this. No.
No. Just listen, you know. We’re grasping that I really exist. I really exist inherently. If that inherent I exists, how can it exist?
Give me an example of what it could be other than something connected to this body and mind or something not at all connected to this body or mind. These are the only two possibilities. There is no third possibility. There is possibility. You have to work this out yourself.
Go home. This is the meditation. One of the meditations is to come to that conclusion that there’s no third possibility. This called in philosophy the law of the excluded middle. Yeah?
There is no third possibility in this case when we talk about I, me. Yes. Right. No. It’s not.
We’re not talking about the dependent nature of life. We’re talking about the I. We’re talking about the I. We’re trying to identify what the I is. We’re not going all over the place.
Keep it focused. Yeah? Otherwise, you can’t do this. You will never you you have to because then you can say there’s all there will always be an an escape clause. Oh, you know, I’m this.
I’m this other weird thing. But what other weird thing? Either we are the this body and mind, which we believe now, or we have this gross belief that the the I’m I am this body and mind because look. I keep doing this. Most people do, if if you find out.
Except Chinese, they point to their nose, which is very interesting. When you say I, most people go like this, but Chinese people actually do that. They go, me? And, actually, there is significance for that, but we won’t go into this right now. Right?
Anyway, think about that. Is there another possibility possibility of what I could be other than something completely connected to the body or mind or something utterly separate? And if you can think of a possibility, then you have to list it. Yeah. And you win a prize because the Buddhas couldn’t.
So, anyway, there’s that. So then the third and fourth points are the main parts of the meditation, which is then to check, am I some this truly existing I, is it inherently the same as the five aggregates? So one investigates. Yeah? One can, through logic, realize that it is impossible for the I to be a truly existing I to be inherently the same as the five aggregates.
So this is where in the in the book the teachings there are, you know, very extensive teachings on this, which go into great complex details. So in just in a very quick summary, a couple of points that one could think of is that if the I, if the inherently existing I is the five aggregates, well, there are five aggregates. So which aggregate am I? Am I all the five aggregates? If I’m all five if there are all five aggregates that would have to mean there are five i’s.
There are five aggregates. So am I are there five mes? Because there are five different aggregates. There’s a physical aggregate and four types of mental aggregates. So if I’m the five aggregates, there would have to be five mes.
But does it feel like there are five mes? We don’t think of ourselves as having five mes. As I often say, sometimes we could we’ll admit, sometimes I’m good, sometimes I’m bad, sometimes I’m happy, sometimes I’m sad, sometimes I’m smart, sometimes I’m dumb. But although we can admit those things, sometimes I’m right and sometimes I’m mostly I’m right, sometimes I’m wrong. So we can admit all those things, things, but deep down, we feel there is the real me.
Yeah. Like when we get angry and we apologize to someone sometimes and say, I’m sorry. You know, I said that. That wasn’t the real me. That wasn’t really me speaking.
I don’t know who it was, but it was uncle Fred. Actually, it was one speaking. Yeah. But but we grasp that there’s a real you know, all these all these superficial changes. Yes.
We’re all happy to admit we superficially change like waves on the, you know, on the ocean. But the ocean is, you know, deep down, it’s just really me, me, unchanging, essential me. That’s what we’re grasping at. So how can I be five aggregates? So then well, maybe I am one aggregate.
The inherently existing me is one of the aggregates. But then which one? Am I my body? So if I’m my body, there’s many faults to that. One of which is if I’m the body when I die, that’s it.
There’s no future lives. There haven’t been past lives. So then you could argue all that proves that Buddhism is all false. But if one has some faith that in past and future lives, then this is a big problem. And that you would be denying that mind mind exists that continues.
Or and the mind could continue. You get reborn, but I don’t get reborn at all. I’m finished if I’m the body. The mind goes on, leaves me behind. That becomes very weird, strange.
But, also, the body itself is made up of all completely different things, skin and bones and meat and blood. And so and and, you know, there’s hands and legs and heads. They’re all quite different things. So which which bit of the body am I? Am I all the body?
Bit of the body? What? Yeah. Many parts of the body. Again, many mes.
So many problems in thinking, you know, saying that the true there is a truly the truly existing I is the body, inherently the same as the body, inherently the same. But one really good simple exercise to do, especially if we haven’t studied a lot of the philosophy yet, is just simply to if one is thinking I am the body and really and we all do have this wrong view, even though it’s not the ultimate deepest wrong view, but anyway, is just to is just to say the words in meditation, just think my body. My body. And when we think my body, you know, this is my watch. Me watch.
My watch. Two different things. And when we say and think my body, we think there’s a me that has a body. It’s not just words. We really feel that I have a body, which means we don’t think I am my body because then we’d have to say body body’s body or my my.
My my. This is my my. You like my my? But we don’t say body’s body or my my. We say my body, and we really feel, you know, experience my body.
This is my body. So if we’re grasping that there is a me that’s got a body, then is that body inherently no. Is that me inherently oneness with the mind? No. No.
We’re not we have to so, again, so there are four mental aggregates. So I might you know, if I’m the all four mental aggregates, again, since they’re different, there’d have to be four mes. But, again, we don’t experience feel like there are four mes. There’s just the one essential me. So am I inherently oneness with one of the aggregates?
Which one? If I’m if if I’m inherently one with my discriminations, then that means I don’t have any feelings. The feelings aren’t mine. Feelings aren’t mine. But, also, if I if I’m my feelings, because, you know, my emotions are so wonderful special, you know, and and so important.
We all think our emotions are so important. You know? We like to be emotional. So so which one? So there are many emotions.
There’s a whole aggregation of emotions. So which emotion is really me? Which is the real me, the emotion that which is really me. See, it starts to become ridiculous. So we we may be grasping this, but we have to use this logic to sink in to realize that this is ridiculous.
It’s the same with a snake and a rope. We see a snake which is not there, and there’s a rope that is there which we can’t see. Someone has to come along and say, you can’t possibly have seen a snake because snakes have never been in this country ever. You know? And you you know, you saw a a rope that appeared like a snake because it was dark and you were moving quickly and blah blah blah.
And if you listen to that person and you trust that person and you listen to their arguments, then eventually one will come to the conclusion, I never saw a snake. I thought I saw a snake. My mind created the illusion of the snake, but there’s no snake. So we have to listen to the Buddha and trust that the Buddha is saying the truth. We’d have to on that trust, we can understand the Buddha’s teachings, understand that logic, and use it to see that at first, there’s the appearance of a truly existing me.
You know? But then the logic says, yes. There is the appearance of a truly existing me, but that truly existing me simply cannot exist. It can’t be the body. It can’t be a part of the body, and it can’t be your mind because the mind is made up of many things, and it’s changing all the time.
Yeah. And if it’s the mind, what which mind? Is it the mind of this life? If I am the mind of this life, then I didn’t exist in past lives because the mind of this life is different from past lives. And if I’m the mind of this life, then I again, when I die, finished.
The mind will go on. There’ll be the continuum of of the mind, but the mind of this life will cease. Therefore, I cease. Finished. No rebirth, no liberation, no enlightenment, no nothing becomes absurd.
And it means no karma. karma doesn’t work. Forget karma. Rob a bank. It’s okay.
No problem. It becomes completely absurd. You know, we can kill and and rape and murder in this life, but but since I’m I’m the mind of this life, the continuity of mind carrying the karma, don’t have to worry about. Free. Let’s rob a bank tonight.
Be happy. Don’t, by the way. Again, you know, if it it what just in a simple way, when we think, you think, my mind. My mind. Again, my mind.
My glasses. My glasses. Two different things. Things. So then maybe, maybe I’ve got the solution.
I, the inherently existing I, is both my body and mind. Yes. Must be. Gotta be. Because they go together.
I must be. I may not be my own body. I may not be my mind, but I must be my body and mind together. Saved. Solution.
But no. Because if I’m not this and I’m not that, how can I be something made up of two things I’m not? Impossible. I’m not this and I’m not that. I can’t be something made up of two things I’m not.
I’m not this at all. I’m not that at all. I can’t be made of something. See, purple is made of red and blue. But if I’m not have nothing to do with red and nothing to do with blue, I can’t be purple.
If I had a little bit to do with red and a little bit to do with blue, I could possibly be purple. But if I’m saying I am not red at all and I m not blue at all, how can I be purple? It s impossible. So we ve just refuted the fact even though we re grasp grasping maybe that I am somehow inherently oneness with the five aggregates. It can’t be.
It’s impossible. It feels like I’m the five aggregates or something to do with them right now. Now? My hand, my body. When I look in the mirror, I think I’m seeing me.
I don’t know about you. You. When you look in the mirror, do you think you’re seeing you? Don’t tell me I’m the only one who’s making this mistake. Oh, sorry, folks.
It’s getting late. Go home and look in the mirror and see if you can see you or not. Who are you seeing? Is there a stranger in the room? We will complete this next week.
But remember, in case you’re all freaking out that you don’t exist, we’re talking about the inherently existing I that doesn’t exist, can’t be found. It’s just an illusion. It’s just a wrong view. But there is the I that does exist. That little, you know, that little rope that’s lying there unseen?
There is the I existing, waiting to be seen, waiting to be looked after. And the best way to look after it is to take care of the mind, because the ‘I’ that does exist arises only depending on that mind. Created some merit so we can dedicate that merit that it becomes a cause to eventually be able to realize the empty nature of self and phenomena, achieve enlightenment for the sake of all suffering sentient beings who are suffering because of grasping at inherent existence. Due to the merits of these virtuous actions, may I quickly attain the state of a Guru Buddha and lead all living beings without exception into that enlightened state. May the precious bodhicitta, not yet born, arise and grow.
May that born have no decline but increase forevermore. So just try and do whatever of the homework meditation topics that make some sense. Leave the others on just that don’t that I haven’t covered and maybe just repeat some. But particularly think about my body, body, my mind, and the point about which I haven’t and the the one I didn’t put as homework, but I mentioned at the beginning of the talk about thinking about how because things don’t truly inherently exist they require a name, they need a label and to be labeled they need a base. And okay just finally next week is our last week in this course, and on the Sunday of of next week is the retreat retreat day starting at nine o’clock in the morning, finishing at four in the afternoon.
So I’d really highly encourage people who’ve done the course to come along for the retreat because it’s a chance when we can meditate on these these topics together, and, hopefully, it will all become so much more clear. And people who’ve done these retreat days usually enjoy them very much. It’s a that’s also a chance to get people to get to know each other a little bit more, share some nice food. Yes. And just have a retreat.
You know? Take the mind away from its usual worldly concerns, normal concerns, and focus on something that is really really worth, you know, very meaningful, beneficial to to focus on in a nice environment. Okay, thank you very much.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- guru devotion
- After finding a fully qualified spiritual teacher and establishing a connection, the disciple trains in devotion using logical reasoning. LYWA
- guru yoga lama nel jor (Tib)
- A practice in which one views the guru as inseparable from a deity or the Buddha, in order to amass the two collections of merit and wisdom and to purify negativities and obscurations. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.