DB Samsara & Nirvana — Samsara and Nirvana week 5

1 h 32 min · 10,150 words · 2018 · Buddha House Adelaide

DB Samsara & Nirvana (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
DB Samsara & Nirvana (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
DB Samsara & Nirvana — Samsara and Nirvana week 5
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 92-minute final session of a five-week course on saṃsāra and nirvana, Ven Thubten Dondrub guides practitioners through the profound consequences of understanding cyclic existence. Opening with the cultivation of bodhicitta—the motivation to achieve enlightenment to benefit all beings—he then explores the twelve links of dependent origination, showing how ignorance and karma perpetually trap us in saṃsāra across lifetimes. He distinguishes between subtle forms of suffering that feel like happiness and clarifies how the twelve links operate across two or three consecutive rebirths. The teaching emphasises renunciation: developing the determination to abandon saṃsāra requires repeated reflection on its inescapable suffering. Dondrub then outlines the path to liberation: the three higher trainings of morality, concentration, and wisdom, anchored in recognising that our disturbing thoughts perpetuate ignorance. Finally, he contrasts the lesser nirvana (achieved by an arhat) with enlightenment itself, explaining why the Mahāyāna perspective rejects mere nirvana in favour of the bodhisattva path available to all beings. Throughout, he stresses the power of group practice and the value of the four holy days in the Buddhist calendar.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Samsāra and Nirvāṇa week 5.mp3

UUID: 04b2cf53-3b1f-40c8-b7fd-ec3dda8420d3

Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub

Collection: DB Samsāra & Nirvāṇa (Ven Thubten Dondrub)

Date: 2018 (exact day not recorded)

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 92.6 minutes

Words: ~10,150

So welcome everyone to our last class on saṃsāra nirvana. So please generate good motivation for being here, especially trying to generate the very best motivation of bodhicitta, wishing to be of lasting benefit to all sentient beings, repaying their kindness, wanting to repay their kindness by helping them to become free of all suffering and its causes, wanting to help them achieve peerless, everlasting happiness, and recognising the only way I can do that is to realise my Buddha potential and achieve enlightenment. So to achieve enlightenment I need to follow the path and that involves understanding the suffering nature that I myself and all sentient beings are trapped in and understanding the possibility of achieving not only the small nirvana or the lesser nirvana of liberation from saṃsāra but the possibility of achieving the great nirvana of enlightenment. So we can do the would I find it? The prayer which is on page ten, I think.

Is it page ten? The pages are done in our student material. What is page ten? We have several page tens. Right, page ten.

So visualising the Buddha in front of us as our possible source of refuge, inspiration and guidance, recognising that the Buddha has achieved what we have the potential to achieve within us, And being motivated by thinking of all suffering mother sentient beings surrounding us, starting with our parents on either side, and trying to have awareness that all of these beings, whether they’re humans, they appear to our ordinary mind as friend, enemy or stranger and all the other beings of cyclic existence, in essence what is most important to focus on is not all those superficial things, but that in essence they are only kind and only suffering. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma and the Supreme Assembly. By the merits I create through teaching the Dharma, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings? So thinking the Buddha is pleased with our motivation, we imagine the Buddha coming to the crown of our head, then dissolving into blissful golden light so that that light can then pour down into us, blessing our mind to be able to understand the teachings about saṃsāra nirvana, blessing our mind to be able to put them into practice correctly, blessing our mind to be able to gain the realisations of the suffering nature of saṃsāra that enables us to renounce it, blessing our mind to gain the realisation of the possibility of achieving the two Nirvanas.

So then briefly we can do the nine round breathing exercise just to help establish a calmer, clearer, more concentrated mind so that we can use that level of mind to listen to and think about the Buddha’s teachings tonight. Okay. Thank you. So the teachings of the Buddha really emphasise how important it is to understand what cyclic existence is, what saṃsāra is, and that it’s our mind controlled by delusion and karma. And because our mind is controlled by delusion and karma, we are always experiencing some form of suffering.

Sometimes it’s the obvious suffering of pain, physical and mental. Sometimes it’s the much more subtle suffering which we think of as happiness because we have no idea of what positive states our mind can actually give rise to. But always, whatever situation we’re in, we’re experiencing from the beings in the lowest hells to the highest god realms. And all of us have experienced all of those states of rebirth countless times in the past. In all of those situations every sentient being is always experiencing what is called compounded pervasive suffering, the most subtle kind of suffering which arises simply because we have a body and mind, the five aggregates that are produced and controlled by delusion and karma.

So this is what we have to in one way it’s a very depressing topic to think that we are trapped in suffering, but it’s taught and emphasised to motivate us to become free of that suffering, because we can, because that suffering has causes and those causes don’t inherently exist. They do exist but they don’t inherently exist. They arise depending on many factors. So if we change those factors, then we can not only reduce the suffering, but eventually we can totally eliminate it in a way that it can never return. It becomes a true cessation, not just a temporary or partial cessation, it becomes a complete and permanent cessation of all suffering.

But it all comes about by allowing ourselves to have the courage to recognise how bad our own saṃsāra is. And that will lead us to develop the wish to be free of it, especially when we develop faith in the teachings that say that we can be free of this suffering and there is a path to follow. Also, the other aspect of thinking more and more about the suffering nature of cyclic existence is that on the one hand we can develop compassion for ourselves. And remember there’s different levels of compassion. There’s the compassion that just wants to be free of suffering, wishes oneself and others to be free of suffering, then there’s a much deeper suffering, a deeper level of compassion where one wants to be actually free of the causes of it, And then beyond that there’s the even deeper level where one develops the determination, I am going to get rid of those causes.

Right? So that’s the level of compassion we need to develop for ourselves and that comes basically from allowing ourselves to be aware of how much suffering we have, either right now or potentially. And that potential won’t go away, it will never go away by itself. We have to make it go away. We have to eliminate the causes that create that potential or that ever present potential for suffering.

And so the more we develop that compassion for ourselves, reflecting on we can understand that everyone is in saṃsāra, they’re all suffering and one can the more one thinks about that, especially in the context that all these beings have been so incredibly kind, have been my mother many times, or even just once. You know, once someone’s your mother, she’s always your mother. Our mother never stops being our mother. Right? So especially in the context of recognising that all beings have been so immensely kind to me, I totally depend on them, then their suffering becomes unbearable to the point where I have to do something about it, not just think how nice it would be if they weren’t suffering, but I’ve got to do something about it.

Especially because they’ve been kind to me. I have to repay that kindness. No one else can repay the kindness I’ve received from each and every person. Right. So, yes.

Right. So we need to develop this mind this mind of renunciation, of wanting to renounce saṃsāra, and that comes from it only comes from allowing ourselves to think about its suffering nature over and over again and also to realise there’s no real happiness in saṃsāra. It’s just a complete illusion there’s no real happiness in saṃsāra. It’s impossible. While our mind’s controlled by delusion and karma, we can have something we call happiness but only our confused mind thinks it is.

It’s not the real thing. Because what we really want is perfect lasting happiness. Perfect lasting happiness. And we can achieve that because that’s the very nature of our mind. So we need to develop this mind of renunciation, this great renunciation that sees that, you know, saṃsāra is just lousy.

There are stronger words I could use but I’ll just leave that for that. Pabongka Rinpoche, who I’m sure used to say is just like, you know, used toilet paper. Everything in saṃsāra is just like used toilet paper, just one does, you know, so you renounce it, you have no interest in used toilet paper whatsoever. Right, so And what helps us to strengthen that mind that has an aversion, a wise aversion, not the aversion that is a negative mind to, you know, having in the ordinary sense, but a wise aversion to our own cyclic existence is also to meditate on, think about the twelve links of dependent origination, which show how we take rebirth in cyclic existence over and over again, how we perpetuate it. So we’ll just go through that very briefly.

This is a very complicated subject really. It’s one of the most I find most personally, but that’s maybe just my mind. You might find it fascinating and easy, but my mind finds it quite complicated and technical and a little bit academic, I shouldn’t say that. But So there are the twelve links of So we’re just going to do this very, very briefly because it is a huge subject. And if you are particularly interested in it, in the front of the student material there is a recommendation of a text to read by His Holiness the Dalai Lama, which I now of course can’t find, which is called what?

Where is it? Dear. Maybe it’s not in this version. Oh yes, of course it did. No, no, no, no.

It’s been dropped. Anyway, what’s this book called? Think it’s called The Wheel of Life by His Holiness the Dalai Lama. Is that what it is? We have a copy in the library anyway, so it gives quite a detailed explanation of the twelve links of dependent origination if you want to get into this topic.

But of course what you’ve got from Pabongka Rinpoche is quite detailed too, but it doesn’t talk about how the twelve links work. So I should have made a list of the twelve links because they’re all kind of spread out. Because it’s good to know the numbers. Where are they? Did you want the diagram?

No, no, no, no, the actual list. So anyway, these start on page four eighty. Maybe there’s a shorter version by Lama Zopa Rinpoche. Oh yes, actually if you go to page ninety nine towards the very end of the book, it sets them out. Ignorance number one is ignorance, two is karmic formations.

Has everyone got that? You know it in your head, good, all right. Right. So one thing to understand, which is really very scary, is that in any life, if we just take this life that we’re experiencing right now, in this life we create many, many sets of twelve links, or more accurately, we start the process of creating them, right? Because throughout our lives we’re controlled by ignorance and then when yeah, So the first link of the twelve links is ignorance, right?

So then because of that, we have disturbing thoughts, we act on those disturbing thoughts and create Well, also we have positive thoughts, so we can create positive and negative karmic imprints. And especially for those people who studied the did the module on the Law of Cause and Effect, there are two kind just to remind you, there are two major kinds of karmic imprints there are throwing karmas and completing karmas. So throwing karmas are the ones that are very powerful because there are four main factors that determine the potency of a karmic imprint, positive or negative. And if you have all of those four factors present and very strong, you create what is called a throwing karma. And throwing karmas are those that have, because they’re so strong, they have the power to determine what our next life or our future life will be.

And the throwing karmas only ripen at the time of death to determine our next rebirth. That’s very important to understand in the twelve links, right? Whereas the other karmic imprints we create, what are called completing karmic imprints, which again can be positive or negative, they only ripen during a lifetime. So the throwing karmas can only ripen at the time of death. So in link number two, when it talks about karmic formations, this is talking about throwing karmas, because the twelve links are explaining how we take rebirth.

So we take rebirth because of the strong positive or negative throwing karmas. So the twelve links explains how we take rebirth, whether we’ve created good throwing karma or bad throwing karma. Okay. So number three is talking about consciousness. So because of ignorance, once that link is established and unfortunately it’s there present in our mind all the time, then the next link comes of karmic formations.

So in this life we can create many positive and negative throwing karmas. But if we’re really honest, we are much more likely to create many more negative throwing karmas than positive throwing karmas, because it is very easy to create negative throwing karmas and it’s very difficult to create positive throwing karmas. If we really check our own mind, to have a very pure strong motivation to do something and to carry it out in a very good way to complete it and to really rejoice, have no regret, we’ve done it. And we may think that’s easy to do, but it’s not. It’s not at all.

I mean we have done it in the past, maybe we’ve done it in this life, hopefully, especially yeah, anyway. But it’s very easy to create negative throwing karmas. Yeah. So once those two are established then all the others, the other ten links will occur. So we’re creating the causes in this life, we’re constantly creating well, maybe I shouldn’t say, sorry, not constantly, but we are many times in this life creating the cause for many future lives just in this one life.

Does that make sense? Making sense? Yeah? Right. So that’s why we have to get out of saṃsāra.

So the more we reflect on this, we can start to see how kind of what a monster saṃsāra is and how we have to get out of it. And we can do it, especially now in this life because we have the precious human rebirth, we’ve got the optimum chance. And as my teacher, Lama Zopa Rinpoche, says, I can’t quite capture exactly how he said it, but something along the lines about, because of having met the Dharma, we can be in retreat from saṃsāra. We don’t, you know, we can, we have the chance, we have the possibilities, the freedom to not act out of ignorance, not to especially create, you know, negative throwing karmas, and that by not doing that we’re breaking the cycle of saṃsāra, breaking the chains. At least we can start creating more and more chains of positive rebirths.

Because to get out of saṃsāra, it’s going to take many lifetimes, So we need to create a consecutive chain or many precious human rebirths so we can keep progressing along the path, life after life, as much as possible until we’re completely free of cyclic existence. So I just wanted to briefly explain that with the third link of consciousness, that doesn’t mean we create consciousness, but we now have a consciousness that has, that is bearing this new throwing karma, right? And that consciousness here has two aspects, there is what is called the causal consciousness and then the resultant consciousness. So the causal consciousness is referring to that last period of, you know, the last brief part of our life when we’re dying where the consciousness is bearing that throwing karma, or bad, which is going to ripen and so it’s that last moments of consciousness carrying that karmic seed that is about to ripen and drive us, our consciousness, into the next life and determine the particular kind of life, it will be either a good or a happy or a suffering one, rebirth as a human or in the God realms or in the lower realms.

So that’s the causal consciousness and then the resultant consciousness of this third link is referring to the first few moments of the consciousness in the Bardo and the next life. Okay. So name and form is referring to the just the first few moments of the development of a new body and the gross mind of the next life. So of course in the case of, it’s easy to understand in the case of a human being, it’s really referring to the first few moments when the sperm and ovum are fertilised. That’s the beginning of name and form.

And then because you have the foetus, then the foetus develops and that’s when the sense powers start to develop. So the sense powers is referring to the subtle okay, we have got an eye consciousness, an ear consciousness, nose consciousness, tongue consciousness, body consciousness and mental consciousness. Is that right? That’s six? We have five sense consciousnesses and then the mental consciousness which is the most important part of the mind.

So those consciousnesses which are formless, you know, they’re mind, so they’re insubstantial, but the gross consciousness of this life operates depending or those six gross consciousnesses of this life operate depending on these subtle physical organs existing. So it’s not referring to the eye consciousness, the eye organ doesn’t actually according to Tibetan Buddhism, not Tibetan Buddhism, Buddhism in general doesn’t mean the actual eyeball but this subtle, very subtle physical organ within the eye which enables the eye consciousness to function. So you have the eye sense power, the eye consciousness and then the object of the consciousness. And then you have experience of something, shapes and colours. So once you’ve got that name and form, for example the human foetus, then as the human foetus develops these sense organs develop and because of that then the consciousnesses can function and then you have contact, which is the meeting of the organ, for example the eye organ, the eye consciousness and the object of eye consciousness, which is shape and colour.

And those three things coming together simultaneously in one moment, that is what is called contact. And then because of contact automatically one has feeling and because of feeling automatically there is craving and grasping and then that leads to becoming that because the craving and grasping is referring to what happens at the time of death, the craving and grasping causes that throwing karma to begin to ripen. So because of that you then have Becoming, which is just referring to this moment just before the karmic imprint actually ripens. And then it ripens, so then you have the next link which is rebirth. Rebirth can actually cover actually taking rebirth in the Bardo state, but then because what kind of situation you end up or we end up unfortunately we end up in the state determines what kind of rebirth we’re going to have.

Rebirth can really start with going into the Bardo state. And then because of rebirth, then there is actual birth, and then because of that, there’s ageing and death. So the point is once we create, especially on the basis of ignorance, create these karmic formations in this life. We act out of anger and do something, say something, whatever. We’ve created, could have, if it’s really strong with all the four factors, then we’ve created one of these karmic formations.

And so we’ve set off these twelve links. We also hopefully will engage in some virtuous actions strongly with all the four factors and set off some positive twelve links, start a series of twelve links, good twelve links that will lead to a good rebirth. Okay? So then, if you have this handout, how the twelve links actually work. So I will try and explain this without getting too confused.

So it takes there are some Buddhists who say that the twelve links occur within one lifetime, but this is not correct. This is a complete misunderstanding. The twelve links, one set of twelve links does not occur and cannot occur in one lifetime. The minimum it takes for one set of twelve links to operate is two lifetimes, and the maximum it takes is three lifetimes. But the thing to understand with the yeah, let’s leave that for the time being.

So firstly let’s have a look at how the twelve links work over two consecutive lifetimes. And this can be for a positive rebirth or a negative rebirth, Okay. It’s the same. Because the law of cause and effect is really basically talking about how things work in saṃsāra. So on the basis of ignorance, if we engage in negative actions, then that leads to the lower rebirth in the lower realms.

But on the basis of ignorance we engage in virtuous actions, we get reborn in the upper realms of saṃsāra, but still saṃsāra, it’s still suffering. Even due to our virtuous actions, our virtuous actions based on ignorance only result in rebirth in saṃsāra. Right. That’s why we try to dedicate our virtuous merits to not just, you know, to being able to for them to become a cause or at least a condition for us to be able to follow the path, to follow you know, practice the Dharma to achieve enlightenment. So in this way our virtuous, our positive imprints become an indirect cause for liberation and enlightenment.

But for our actions to become a direct cause of liberation and enlightenment, that they have to be done free of ignorance. Which is not easy. So anyway, going back, so the twelve links work over two consecutive lifetimes, which is two, yeah, two consecutive lifetimes. So there’s the link of ignorance, and because of that, for example, we engage in a negative action with all the four factors create a negative throwing karma, so link two is established in this lifetime and then because of that the consciousness carrying that imprint is established, the causal consciousness. So then, so we’ll just imagine this is in this life, so then at the end of this life as we’re dying, the mind of craving occurs and that gets stronger as we’re dying, so this leads into grasping.

And because of that, that karmic imprint that was created, that negative karmic imprint is being ripened so that, and is just about to actually bring its result, so that’s link number ten. And so because of that the consciousness leaves the body, enters the so death occurs, enters the Bardo state and goes into the next life. So that is link number two, which occurs in the very first moment of the next life, in the Bardo state. So link number eleven is also associated with link 3B, which is the resultant consciousness, because you now have the consciousness in the next life. And so because the consciousness has entered into the next life, say for example, well, maybe one gets reborn as an animal, so then you have name and form, you know, the consciousness, that new consciousness is stuck in the foetus, like for example of a dog or something.

And then within the womb of the dog the six sense powers develop. And then throughout life contact and feeling occur, but also throughout the life ageing has been taking place, so eventually there’s death. So this is a way in which all the twelve links operate, are connected in two lifetimes, two consecutive lifetimes that occur one after the other. So then there’s the other explanation of how the links could work over three lifetimes. So again, taking the example of engaging in a negative action, That’s because of the link of ignorance, so that creates because of acting out of ignorance, following our delusions, a throwing karmic formation is created.

There is the causal consciousness carrying that throwing karma. So unlike in the previous example, what could then happen is that, or maybe it’s better to give the example of a good throwing karma. Go back again. Out of ignorance we engage in some we do some virtuous action, a strong virtuous action, and create therefore a good, you know, throwing karmic formation. So then that leads to the causal consciousness carrying that imprint, right?

But, so imagine we do that in this life, but then at the time of death, maybe we generate a really negative state of mind as we’re dying so that positive throwing karma can’t ripen. So it’s still there in the consciousness, but a negative one ripens instead. So then, So then the second life where this one set of twelve links, you know, is operating, that that second life hold it here’s the life where those first three links have been created, but that karmic imprint doesn’t ripen at the end of that life because something else gets in the way. So second life so there’s a gap of maybe at least one life, and then maybe in this life, this good throwing karma that was created in this life can start to ripen. Yeah?

Okay? Got that possibility? But the other possibility is that between this first life where the good throwing karma was created and the life where it starts to ripen to bring its result, there could be many, many lifetimes between. Right? Could be one, two, three, it could be a million lifetimes.

Because maybe here we fell into a really, the lower realms and got stuck there for a long time. And then we pop out and this good karma can start to ripen, because then in life too, as we’re dying, there’s this craving and grasping that ripens, that nourishes this positive imprint, which is link number ten, becoming. And then in the immediate life straight after that, all the other links occur there’s birth, name and form, the six sense powers, contact feeling, ageing and death. So in that example of taking three lifetimes there can be a gap between life one and two and the gap can be one lifetime or many lifetimes but there’s no gap between life two and three, those two occur one after the other. So that in a nutshell is how the twelve links work apparently.

But the basic, I think the basic point to remember is that once the set of links is started all the other links naturally follow and this is how saṃsāra keeps going and going. So if we want to stop ageing and death and all the suffering that occurs between ageing and death, then we have to stop birth, and to stop birth we have to stop becoming, but to stop that we have to stop grasping and craving, going back and back, ultimately to stop ignorance. If we can stop ignorance, the whole lot stops. And the wonderful thing is that the Buddha discovered that we can eliminate this cause of suffering because ignorance exists. Yes, unfortunately it exists, but it doesn’t truly inherently exist from its own side.

And because it doesn’t inherently exist, it can be completely eliminated from the mind. And once it’s eliminated, it can never come back. So when we understand what inherent existence means and things can’t inherently exist, then one will develop great faith in the possibility of becoming free of all suffering. Right. Any questions keep them simple Yes?

What does bardo mean? Bardo is the Tibetan term that just simply means ‘between’. So it’s the in between state that occurs between after death and between when an actual fully realised rebirth state occurs. So according to the Tibetan system, which gives the greatest explanation of all these things, all the tantric teachings explain all these things. The Bardo state normally lasts about seven days, up to seven days.

And like within that seven days sentient beings normally are able to take rebirth. But even if they can’t within that seven days the bardo being dies and enters the bardo state again. And this can happen seven times, so a total of forty nine days. So in Tibet, among Tibetan practitioners, when someone dies they do prayers and practices for the dead person for forty nine days. Because it’s also believed that whatever one does for the dying person can affect their rebirth.

You can actually affect their rebirth’s possibilities by doing prayers and practices and offerings on behalf of the dead person. So it’s like a temporary state. A temporary state. Yeah. So the more we meditate, develop some faith in the Buddha’s teachings on the nature of the mind and saṃsāra and how terrible it is really, the potential of it, then we can develop the mind to be free of cyclic existence.

And so that state of being free of so one can have the wish to be free of cyclic existence for two reasons. I think the obvious one, well, is that when one is free, totally free of cyclic existence, one has completely eliminated ignorance, then one can experience this incredible, the bliss of the mind forever, so this is the state of nirvana. So this, for the person experiencing it, is wonderful. It is free of all suffering, it is completely blissful because that is the true nature of our mind and it goes on forever because the mind is indestructible. But from the Mahāyāna point of view, the state of nirvana is not something to achieve, to aim for.

What we need to aim for is to become free of cyclic existence, which is to achieve liberation from cyclic existence. This is what the Mahāyāna teachings are encouraging us to do, that we do have to get out of saṃsāra because if we stay in it, we’re going to continue suffering, but especially we won’t be able to benefit up, we will continue to harm others and won’t be able to benefit them. We can’t benefit them when our mind is still controlled by all the different delusions, especially attachment and anger. And we will always have them while we have ignorance. Whereas when we’re free of saṃsāra there’s no ignorance.

Anyway, I think I got lost again in my explanation what my point was, but yeah. So from the point of view of the person experiencing nirvana, it’s wonderful, it’s completely blissful, no problems. But from a Mahāyāna point of view, it’s not a state to achieve, aim for, because in that blissful state one is unaware of anything else. As a human being one can achieve, one can become an Arhat. An Arhat is someone who has liberated themselves from cyclic existence and can experience the bliss of nirvana.

So a human Arahant is a wonderful person, you know, they’re free of all thoughts, very kind, loving, all these things, and they can teach the Dharma about how to achieve nirvana. And, you know, when they’re by themselves, they can just go into the bliss of nirvana whenever they like, you sit down and meditate and focus on that. And when they die, their mind so when they’re alive, they can benefit others, but when they die their mind just absorbs into that bliss of nirvana, the bliss of the mind. Totally unaware of anything else so they can’t help anyone because they’re not even aware of them. So from a Mahāyāna point of view, this is not a goal to achieve, to become an Arahant, to achieve nirvana.

But we do need to be liberated from cyclic existence. And the reason to get liberated but not hang out in nirvana is so that we can continue the path to enlightenment. Because in our heart, their mind, although it’s free of the causes of suffering, is not, still not start again, it is still obscured because, as I mentioned a few times before, there are two levels of obscurations in our mind. There are what are called the obscurations to liberation, which is ignorance and delusion, and then there are the obstacles or obscurations to omniscience. And another term for that is the dualistic mind, because this dualistic mind still has what are said to be the very, very subtle imprints of ignorance and delusion.

What that actually means, I personally have no real idea what that really means, the very subtle imprints of because they’re not causing suffering in any way, but they are still obscuring the mind, preventing the full potential of the mind functioning, especially what it’s preventing is omniscience. This ability to know everything all the time. Because when you can know everything all the time, of course you know about the existence of all sentient beings and you know that they’re suffering and you know how to stop their suffering and you know and you have the endless energy as an enlightened being because nothing’s obscuring your mind to benefit them, especially one has another thing that an Arhat hasn’t done, although arhats have no negativity and they do have love and compassion, etc, etc, the people who have followed that path to achieve only nirvana have not cultivated their potential for love and compassion completely. They have not developed the thought that I will stop the suffering of others. They have cultivated the thought, I don’t want other sentient beings to suffer, I do want them to be happy, I do want them to create the causes of happiness and I do want them to stop the causes of suffering and I will help them a bit, but I won’t take that responsibility.

They have not cultivated that. Only the bodhisattvas do that, cultivate that mind, that I will do this. But especially more than that is the thought that I alone will do this. This is the unique feature of bodhicitta that I alone will free all sentient beings from suffering. I alone, unaided by any other being, I will lead all beings to purest everlasting happiness.

So the beings on the path to nirvana don’t have those thoughts. They’re very nice people, they’re wonderful beings. They have great, you know, big love, big compassion, but they don’t have the mind of great compassion that a bodhisattva has generated. So, you know, it’s a little bit like a very gross analogy between wanting to achieve liberation and wanting to achieve nirvana is maybe a very primitive example I thought up, is that it’s like someone, you know, you could have two motivations for wanting to be very, very rich. One motivation is just simply just to be very rich.

So one will, I’ll have lots of stuff and I’ll be able to enjoy all the pleasures of being very, very, very rich, which is like wanting to achieve nirvana. And the other motivation to be very, very rich is to use that to benefit others. So we all need to get liberated, we all need to get out of saṃsāra, so that’s like wanting to become rich to benefit others. Whereas some people want to get out of saṃsāra to get the bliss and just dwell in the bliss. So of course it’s very easy when one is very far away from the bliss to think, Oh yes, I want to benefit all sentient beings.

So that as one gets closer to being able to experience the great bliss of nirvana, it could become a big attraction. That is why the Mahāyāna teachings emphasise the bodhicitta motivation at the very beginning. You know, we are, with all due and myself, I’m a billion miles away from having bodhicitta, but one tries to put that imprint in the mind from the very beginning to try to make sure the mind will go towards enlightenment rather than nirvana. Yes, we have to, you know, there is that station, liberation, but don’t get off there and hang out in the station, the nirvana station, but we have to keep going. So in order to achieve nirvana, one has to practise what are called the three higher trainings.

They’re called the higher trainings because there are similar trainings in non-Buddhist traditions, but I suppose there’s a bit of Buddhist propaganda, but because they’re based on refuge in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha, they’re said to be the three higher trainings. And so the three higher trainings are the higher training in morality, concentration and wisdom. So aim of course is to be able to develop this wisdom that directly perceives the true nature of oneself and phenomena, because it is that perception, that direct perception, that will eliminate ignorance, which is experiencing things in a false way and grasping that that false experience is actually truth, is reality. So one has to destroy that by undermine it, developing this wisdom, this ability to be able to see, perceive things as they actually are. But our mind, you know, is agitated all the time, pretty much to some extent.

And that mind cannot possibly develop this realisation of the wisdom experiencing the true nature of things because that perception is something extremely subtle, the way things actually exist. It’s something very, very subtle, very refined. So one needs to have a very calm, clear mind to be able to develop that wisdom. So we need to be able to develop single pointed concentration where the mind is able to stay on whatever virtuous or neutral object we place it on and it can stay there effortlessly for as long as we like. Once Samādhi or single pointed concentration is developed, one has real mastery over the mind and you stick, you place your mind on the object and it just stays there effortlessly in a blissful state for as long as you like.

So that mind is needed to be able to directly perceive the true nature of things. And Samādhi is basically achieved by overcoming all the distracting thoughts in the mind, which takes a lot of time and effort. It’s not easy to do and can be quite dangerous because people kind of tense up trying to do this practice and that causes a lot of nervous tension and imbalances in the body which in Tibetan is called Lung. There’s various kinds of Lung you can get this imbalance of wind energy which makes the mind really and the whole body really kind of berserk and can actually lead to like all sorts of mental problems and like extreme craziness. Yes, yes, definitely.

There’s something called Toglong, that’s the worst kind you can get. Toglung. There’s various varieties of lung to choose from. Comes from pushing oneself too much, you know. As I’ve often mentioned in previous classes, there’s a type of lung well, the sign of this is you get this intense pain in your heart chakra, there.

It’s like being stabbed. And one form of it is like for people who too meditate too much and push themselves too much, that even if you look at your meditation cushion, you get this. I knew a guy who did this. He would just have to look at his meditation cushion and he would get this like intense unbearable pain here. So you’ve got to be very careful.

That’s why the Lam Rim meditation is okay. It’s good, it’s cool, it’s very nice. But again people can always overdo anything push, push, push. But single pointed concentration where you’re trying to let go of thoughts and just hold one thing that can, you know, unless one’s done it, prepared the mind properly and does it properly and has a qualified teacher to guide one in it, it can be quite dangerous. So to develop wisdom, basis is developing concentration.

This doesn’t mean by developing concentration you will automatically develop wisdom. One has to study the teachings about wisdom and then by meditating on those, which is a conceptual process, but on the basis of being able to conceptually understand both on the one hand the wrong views we have and conceptually understand the right view, then by I’m not sure if I really understand the whole process, but right now we have a wrong view of self. This is the wrong view of self. By understanding the wrong view of by being able to recognise what that wrong view of self is, we can start to understand how what the right view actually is. And also by studying the teachings on the right view, we can help to understand it.

And that helps us to understand our own wrong view. You can say there’s the abstract wrong view in general, which we all have, but we have to be able to identify that yes, this is I am grasping myself, I am grasping this view of self in this way, and one has to be able to identify it. We’re doing it right now, but we can’t identify it that that’s what we’re doing. We have to be able to identify that. That’s why one needs a very still clear unconfused mind to do that.

So then, by using all this logic one can, so one can identify that this is my wrong view, like in meditation. And so you’re able to hold the wrong view which is called the object to be refuted. The object to be refuted is our wrong view of self that we actually have and then you use the logic that the Buddha gave to show that this wrong view, that this appearance we have cannot exist. Things can’t exist that way at all. So this is all done conceptually, but by bombarding, you know, on the one hand there’s the wrong view of self that we identify, and then one uses this, the Buddha’s arguments to kind of undermine that view and eventually, so with time that wrong view gets weaker and weaker and eventually it collapses.

And so through the power of conceptual thought one eventually has a direct non conceptual perception of true nature, the empty selfless nature of things. But one can only do that with a concentrated mind. Just having concentration doesn’t bring about this wisdom at all, which is what some people think and even in Buddhist schools there are certain Buddhist schools that are thinking just developing concentration is the same as developing wisdom. It’s got nothing to do with it. I mean, just by itself.

You have to have concentration to develop wisdom, but the wisdom arises from this conceptual understanding one has to develop. So this is something that we can do now, develop that conceptual understanding without single pointed concentration, But to transform that into this realisation of wisdom, we need concentration. And the main so that means subduing our thoughts and the main thoughts we have to subdue are not thoughts of pride or jealousy or anger, but guess what? Attachment. That’s the main problem.

Yeah. And so to develop single pointed concentration there are many things to do, but the basis is morality, the higher training in morality. Because, many ways to show that, but one of the main things to understand is of course if we’re not living a moral life, it means we’re engaging in negative actions, accumulating negative imprints, and those negative imprints are our obstacle. All that is obscuring our mind, that is an obstacle to achieving concentration. And of course, by engaging in negative actions, what does that mean?

We only engage in negative actions motivated by our disturbing thoughts. So we’re just activating our disturbing thoughts all the time, which is the greatest obstacle to developing concentration. And also why do we follow our disturbing thoughts? Because we believe in them. And what do our disturbing thoughts tell us?

They disturb, oh, look! They tell us this is really beautiful, you know, inherently existing, our disturbing thoughts reinforce our ignorance, the very thing we’re trying to destroy. You know, our ignorance tells us, you know, our disturbing thoughts say, Oh, this is really bad. This person is beautiful, this person is ugly, this person is good, this person is bad. Whereas at least, you know, on the other hand living a moral life, engaging in virtue in order to virtue, those positive imprints empower our mind not only to understand the wisdom teachings but empower our mind to be able to gain single pointed concentration.

Because one of the things the Tibetan lamas emphasise is that to achieve things like Samādhi you have to have a lot of merit. It’s not that you just, you know, trundle off into the forest, into a cave and meditate. You have to have a lot of merit for it to succeed. Because a lot of people who’ve tried this in the past without the merit and they go crazy, get really disturbed because they don’t have the merit. There’s lots of reasons to have merit.

It’s incredibly important to accumulate merit, and two things accumulate merit and purify the mind. As Holiness said, the whole path to nirvana or even enlightenment can be summarised in three things, three stages. Firstly, stop the first thing we have to do in our spiritual practice is stop engaging in negative actions. And then the second thing is to subdue our disturbing thoughts. And then the final one is to get rid of them.

And that’s a sequence. You you can’t get rid of our disturbing thoughts first. The first thing we have to do is stop engaging in negative actions as much as possible, then subdue the disturbing thoughts and then get rid of them. And to do that we need to have a consecutive, you know, a series of precious human rebirths. And of course to get those we have to engage in, live a moral life.

That’s the very basis is to live a moral life. Avoid negative actions, engage in virtuous ones as much as possible. Any questions so But that is the path, basically the path to achieve the lesser nirvana, if that’s what one wants. The thing is we have to develop this wisdom that will destroy ignorance, But to have that we have to develop concentration, to get that we have to live a moral life. And it’s all based on renunciation, you know, renouncing negative actions, seeing that they are harming myself and creating all these obstacles for future happiness.

So firstly we have to renounce this life, renounce our obsession with the things of this life. And eventually we can renounce saṃsāra realizing it’s just all suffering and no real happiness. There’s more to come, a little bit more. Can I keep going? It’s almost time to finish.

Oh, it’s time to stop. Two minutes. We have to get to enlightenment. Yes, yes, you’ve got many questions. Well, yeah.

Well, everyone knows what’s enlightenment. I’ve explained it many times. But what distinguishes to achieve enlightenment on top of the three higher trainings of morality, concentration and right view, one has to cultivate bodhicitta, the wish to achieve enlightenment, comes from generating great love and great love for sentient beings, which comes from recognising they’ve all been our mothers and how we’re dependent on them and so on. I also just realising to get out of saṃsāra, to achieve nirvana, we can only do that depending on others. So the Mahāyāna view is how can you possibly just want, how can we possibly get out of, you know, use other sentient beings to get out of saṃsāra and leave them to suffer when they’ve all been one’s mother?

How can we do that? And the answer that people following that path give is, well, we can’t, we don’t have the abilities to do that. But the Mahāyāna teachings say we do, that we all have Buddha nature, that every mind has Buddha nature, so we all have the potential, the possibility to achieve enlightenment. We can benefit all sentient beings And it’s the best thing to do for ourselves and others, the most meaningful. So what enables one to achieve enlightenment, what actually brings about enlightenment is getting rid of the obscurations, and what gets rid of those obscurations is wisdom.

But it is basically, oh not basically, it is the same wisdom that one needs to achieve nirvana. So one could ask, why don’t arhats become enlightened? Because their wisdom and the answer is because their wisdom isn’t as strong. It’s the same wisdom, but it isn’t as strong because they don’t have bodhicitta. But because of the power of bodhicitta, that wisdom, the mind practitioner who has combined bodhicitta and wisdom, that wisdom becomes so strong it is able to eliminate those very subtle obscurations and enlightenment becomes possible.

And also because of bodhicitta all the potentials of the mind have been cultivated. That’s it. A question? What’s paranirvana? Oh, paranirvana. Oh, paranirvana means the nirvana without remainder, which is when nirvana can be achieved in the form realm as well, but often achieved as a human being.

So the the arhat, the human arhat has achieved nirvana, but when they die they achieve the parinirvāṇa where they no longer have this suffering physical aggregate and the mind is free, freed completely. So often Parinirvana is used just in a very what’s the word polite term for a holy being dying, such as the Buddha. Yeah. But especially it is referred when, like the Buddha passed away and, yeah, into that state where there is no remainder whatsoever, no ordinary remainder of a contaminated body and so on. Okay.

Thank you very much. Come on. Got a question about you know the meditation on the precious human rebirth? Mhmm. Towards the end of the meditation, they talk about the rarity of the precious human meditation, they talk about the rarity of the precious human rebirth.

Yes. And they go through the ideas of, like, so to create the cause for precious human rebirth, we need to practice pure ethical discipline. Yes. Practice of the six perfections and having strong spiritual aspirations. But I’ve read somewhere that pretty much with those three main aspects, a sort of fourth one that isn’t really written down is pretty much we need the intelligence to understand that these things are the causes and therefore to cultivate them.

So wouldn’t that mean by that that really the only opportunity we have to create causes for a precious human rebirth is during a precious human rebirth? Yes. Yeah. Pretty much. Yeah.

Yes. Well, sucks. saṃsāra sucks, so that’s the whole thing. Yes, it’s terrible. Yeah.

Oh sorry. Like Śākyamūni did by teaching the Dharma to people. Sorry, what? In other worlds and all that kind of stuff. Yeah, everywhere.

But like if you just keep it very simple to the Buddha appearing on this earth, he taught the Dharma in exactly the way, like he said different things to different groups of people, he said exactly what that particular group of people needed, know, and taught them in a way that they could understand with, yeah. Well, I mean, the Buddha does, as a Buddha you can do all sorts of things, you can manifest your body in all sorts of ways to benefit others. But in the teachings it says that the most profound way the Buddha can benefit others, because the Buddha can’t make us practise, the Buddha can’t make us enlightened, all the Buddha can do is influence us and inspire us. And so there’s all sorts of things a Buddha can do along those lines, but the most powerful direct way is teaching the Dharma, because that’s what affects our mind most. But there’s millions of things you can do as a Buddha, simultaneously also.

But, you know, and in a sense, know, a Buddha does many of the things ordinary people do to benefit others, but a Buddha does it unmistakably. They know that if I say this, this is exactly what this person needs to hear and I will say it and the Buddha knows that when I say it, they will understand it the way I want them to understand it. Because like when we talk to each other, you know, people, you know, we get completely, can get completely different, you know, understandings than what the person speaking meant. Whereas when a Buddha knows that their speech will be understood the way they want it to be understood, you know, and whatever they do, they know it will work the way they want it to. Whereas for us it’s all a bit hit and miss.

Yeah. When you talk about great nirvana and ordinary. Speaker Yeah. Speaker My understanding was, so when a Buddha passes away and an Arhat passes away, it’s the exact same No, no, no, I don’t think so. No, arhats teach.

Yeah, but not like an ancient arhat. Not as well as a Buddha. Possibly. But a Buddha has definitely far, you know, it gets very complicated because there’s the Pāli or Theravāda view of the Buddha as preserved in the Pāli’s canon and the Mahāyāna view. So because as probably everyone knows, the word nirvana literally means something like to be blown out like a candle.

So one view, you know, because of course one view that existed and still exists is that an arhat, when they die, their mind, you know, not only does their body cease but their mind ceases completely. So this is not the Mahāyāna view at all, that all minds go on forever. Whereas the Theravāda view, interpretation of some of the Pāli Sutras is that what propels the mind to go on are the delusions and once the delusions there are stopped, there’s nothing propelling the mind so it ceases. But this is definitely not the Mahāyāna view. And also even for the Buddha, the Theravāda, but a lot of Theravadans these days avoid saying these things and they kind of I’m not trying to insult the Theravadans, but it seems that they’re not very clear on I mean this is only one view, and one view is even the Buddha’s mind doesn’t exist anymore.

The Buddha only exists as an inspiration of what he was when he was alive, but Buddha and this is certainly not the Mahāyāna view, that the mind is something indestructible, it just goes on and on and on. And also the view of omniscience is different between the Pāli Canon and the Mahāyāna teachings. And one of the unique teachings of the Mahāyāna is, which is what I was alluding to at the very end, is that according to the Theravāda school, Buddhas are definitely far superior in their qualities to an Arahant, but almost no one has the ability to become a Buddha. They do believe in the Mahāyāna Bodhisattva path, they talk about Bodhisattvas, but their view is that only, you know, like a handful of beings in all of saṃsāra can become, can follow that path and become a Buddha. So there’s no point trying to be a Buddha because one doesn’t have the potential.

Whereas the Mahāyāna school says every sentient being, because of the very nature of mind, has Buddha potential. And this is particularly what the Lotus Sūtra says, this is why it’s so famous, is that every being has Buddha nature. Everyone can become a Buddha, so we’ve, you know, let’s do it. Because we can be, and there’s a great need for it. On that happy note, maybe we should cease, but I’m Okay, so our next course, people are interested, is which will start in a couple of weeks, will be presenting the path, so it’ll be an overview of the path to enlightenment.

So this is very good to do, have that overview of the path to enlightenment. Some of it you will have already heard before in various things, but still it’s good to do, great. More imprints. Maybe inspired to study the path to enlightenment in more detail. Also remember Sunday is our one day retreat, I would really encourage people to come along and do that.

From nine o’clock, starts at nine, finishes at four, and we ask people to bring a plate of vegetarian food to share with everybody if you can. Yeah, I think that’s it, except I just have one little bit of propaganda I’d like One thing I would like to encourage people I was teaching for ten years in Hayagrīva Centre in Perth. During all that time I taught the Discovering Buddhism programme regularly, and I’ve been doing it here well, I’ve been an adult, except I took a seventeen month break, but I’ve been here five years. And one thing that seems I find a bit sad doesn’t seem to happen is that many people do study DB but nothing else, they don’t come to anything else at the centre and there can be many reasons. But I would encourage people that if you can come to some of the other things, because Tibetan Buddhism has many aspects to it.

There can be a very intellectual aspect to it, especially when one gets into, you know, which I don’t present here, although like the deep philosophy of Tibetan Buddhism, is very extremely profound and complicated, and there’s the lamrim stuff which we do. But there’s all sorts of devotional things like pujas, which I think are also very important to do. They present the same stuff in a same stuff things, dharma, holy Dharma, in a different way, in a different way. And one thing that I mean many people have, I’m sorry, I’ve got on my little hobby horse again, I will try and stop, but many people have this idea that Buddhism is you just practise by yourself, it’s got nothing to do with anybody else, you’re just all alone practising the Dharma. But really, it’s not like that.

No one can practise by themselves completely. Mean eventually people like Milarepa went off to caves by themselves, but I mean they’re exceptional people, even he had many other lives and things. One needs the help and support of many people and also practising together is a very, very good thing. It creates a lot of good energy for the individual, the group and also, like they say, what is it, with one stick of grass you can’t clean a room but if you get a whole bunch you can make a broom and sweep things. You know, a whole group of people doing something together creates a very powerful energy that benefits, you know, in many ways.

So it’s really good to come together to do practices together. I would really, really encourage people there are four holy days, major holy days in the Buddhist calendar which I would really encourage people to come and do practice together. Like, there was the Day of Miracles not so long ago. Now what is coming up is Sakadawa, most holy day which commemorates the Buddha’s birth, enlightenment and paranivana, they all occurred on the same day. Different years of course, but same day.

So this is a super special day and then there’s the first turning of the wheel, the first teaching of the Buddha and also the day commemorating when he returned from the realm of the thirty-three when he went to this God realm to teach his mother the Dharma to repay her for her kindness giving birth to him. So these are days where it says the karma, good and bad, multiplies millions and millions of times, so it’s great to practise and great to practise together. And we have a very nice programme on those days. So I would really encourage people to come along, you know, and we do this Lama Chöpa Puja, the offering to the Guru, which is a very special practice. So if you can come we do the sixteen hour Hut Puja, which is tomorrow night, medicine Buddha practice.

All of these things have been suggested by, advised by Lama Zopa Rinpoche that are really beneficial for this centre, for the students. So I would really encourage people if you can to come along from time to time, if not regularly but at least from time to time, but especially those four special days of the year don’t work. These are holy days, you know. We just had our holy day of the Adelaide Cup when people don’t work. So, you know, there are the four holy days of the Buddhist year.

Don’t work, give up, you tell your boss you’re not working that day, and you come here. Or stay at home and practice. But anyway, that’s my little hobby horse for the time being. Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
parinirvana
The final nirvana the Buddha attained when he passed away in Kushinagar, India. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
three higher trainings lhagpäi lab pa sum (Tib)
The three higher trainings of ethics, concentration and wisdom when conjoined with refuge in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. LYWA
throwing karma phen jä kyi lä (Tib)
Also called projecting karma, the karmic imprint that ripens at the time of death to propel us into the next rebirth. LYWA
twelve links of dependent origination pratitya samutpada (Skt); ten drel yen lag chu nyi (Tib)
Also called the twelve dependent-related limbs or branches; the twelve steps in the evolution of cyclic existence: 1) ignorance; 2) karmic formation; 3) consciousness; 4) name and form; 5) sensory fields; 6) contact; 7) feelings; 8) craving; 9) grasping... LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

What does the Tibetan term bardo mean?

Bardo is a Tibetan term that simply means 'between'. It is the in-between state after death and before a fully realised rebirth occurs. In the Tibetan system, which gives the greatest explanation of these things, the bardo state normally lasts up to seven days, and within that time beings can normally take rebirth. If they cannot, the bardo being dies and enters the bardo state again. This can happen seven times, for a total of forty-nine days. For this reason Tibetan practitioners do prayers and practices for a dead person for forty-nine days, since what is done for the dead person is believed to affect their rebirth.

Scroll to Top