1 h 48 min · 12,274 words · 4 June 2013 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 109-minute teaching, Venerable Thubten Dondrub brings the weekly saṃsāra series to a close by exploring nirvana and enlightenment and why the Mahāyāna path to full Buddhahood matters more than individual liberation. He begins by briefly reviewing the twelve links of dependent origination and how they operate across multiple lifetimes to create repeated rebirth, then pivots to nirvana itself: what it is, how it arises when ignorance is destroyed, and why it brings bliss as the mind’s natural peaceful state. He contrasts the Theravāda view—where nirvana means the mind ceases entirely—with the Mahāyāna understanding that an arhat’s liberated mind enters a self-absorbed blissful state unable to benefit others, whereas a Buddha’s omniscient mind works ceaselessly for all beings. The core of his teaching outlines the path: developing moral discipline, single-pointed concentration, and wisdom to eliminate ignorance; then, for Mahāyāna practitioners, generating bodhicitta and training in the six perfections across many lifetimes and bodhisattva levels until enlightenment. He weaves in vivid examples—the garlic-scented bowl analogy for subtle obscurations, the nurse observing lung cancer patients who still smoke, a story about the Dalai Lama promising to stay if Tibetans recited a hundred million mantras—to make abstract doctrine visceral. Pitched at committed Buddhist students, some of whom have studied the preceding six weeks on saṃsāra.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2013 06 04 DB Samsāra week7 Dondrub 040613.mp3
UUID: 8f21b732-1eb9-4165-98e7-1e1b3d630552
Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub
Collection: DB Samsāra & Nirvāṇa (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Date: 2013-06-04
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 108.7 minutes
Words: ~12,273
Welcome everyone to our last class on saṃsāra nirvana. So we dealt mostly with saṃsāra. We’ll talk a little bit about nirvana tonight. So because this topic is taught in the context of encouraging us to follow the path not just to the state of nirvana, but the greater state of enlightenment because in that state of enlightenment, we’re we’re able to be of perfect lasting benefit to all sentient beings. Why should we?
Because sentient beings have been so immensely kind to us in this life, all our past lives. While we’re in saṃsāra, we will depend on the kindness of others over and over again. To get out of saṃsāra, we depend on their kindness to achieve enlightenment. We can only do it depending on the kindness of sentient beings. So sentient beings are very, very, very, very kind to us.
We really need them. And the sad fact is all these beings are suffering in saṃsāra. Most are experiencing right now. While we’re in the human realm, the vast majority of sentient beings are in the lower realms of cyclic existence. And although there are many beings in the the upper realms, they they don’t stay in those realms.
They fall into the lower you know, the the more obvious suffering realms and cycle over and over again, experiencing no real happiness and continuously creating the causes for more suffering, more saṃsāra. So by thinking about these things, can generate the wish to achieve enlightenment. And that so to achieve enlightenment, that depends on following the path and to follow the path that involves understanding the suffering nature of cyclic existence, understanding that nirvana is possible, not just the simple nirvana of liberation, but the great nirvana of enlightenment. So for these reasons, for our own benefit, for the benefit of all sentient beings, we can look into this subject tonight. So if you’d like to join in the prayer, which is, I think, on page what?
Nine? Ten? Nine? Nine. If you’d like to join in.
So as we think these things, we can think of the Buddha in front of us as our source of inspiration and guidance, and at the same time, thinking of all sentient beings surrounding us, encouraging us to become free of saṃsāra to achieve nirvana and enlightenment. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, the Supreme Assembly. By the merits I create through teaching the Dharma, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings? So that we can imagine the Buddha now coming to the crown of our head, then dissolving into light so that that blissful light pours into us, blessing our mind. And then we can enhance that by doing just briefly doing the nine round breathing exercise to establish a calmer, clearer, more concentrated mind in order to use that mind to listen to and think about the Buddha’s teachings tonight.
Okay. Thank you. K. So before I get on to to my tonight’s topic, which is sort of talking about I’ll look just very briefly about nirvana and enlightenment, the difference between these two things, and whatever, few other things. I just like to try to just briefly go through oh, don’t don’t I haven’t got it with me.
Does everyone have the have the copy of the handout from last week on the twelve links with them? Good. I’ve sorry. You David? Andrew, you didn’t get one.
You weren’t here, were you? There’s one copy. You didn’t want either. You weren’t here. Yeah, has everyone got access to one they can borrow at least tonight?
Someone need one? Alright. Just very quickly, I just want to explain, if I can, just very simply, the the last part of this, which is how we actually take rebirth. So that’s on the backside of them, how the twelve links operate in two or three lifetimes. So through studying the the twelve links and what they what the twelve links are referring to, one can then understand how they operate to bring about rebirth in cyclic existence over and over again.
So one thing to understand is that the twelve links in producing rebirth take a minimum of two lifetimes to operate in but they can also occur in three lifetimes where if it’s three lifetimes the thing to understand is the the gap between one of the lifetimes and the third lifetime can be a huge period of time. You have to have two lifetimes that are are one after the other, but the third one can be many, many lifetimes, eons afterwards. Right? I will try to explain that as it’s right? So in a prior in a previous lifetime, for example, we’ve we’ve been controlled by ignorance, which is the the first link.
Because of that, we’ve created throwing karma, the second link, and that has been established on the consciousness which is the third link and then at the end of a previous life as we were dying that the link of craving occurred grasping and becoming so they all occurred in a previous life and so we could say that in this life so there is birth, name and form because of name and form which is the beginning of the new aggregates we have the sense powers and then because of that there is contact and feeling occurring and and then aging occurs and this leads to death. So this is how the the twelve links can operate over two lifetimes. Right? There’s the previous life and then the next one. Right?
Because you have a a have the throwing karma created in link two, and then that is ripened at the end of that life. And so then you have the rebirth straight away. So then the other way this can happen is that that you you have ignorance in in one life. During that same life because of ignorance you engage in an activity which can be positive or negative that creates a positive or a negative throwing karma and you establish the the consciousness that is that is supporting that karmic imprint. But at the at the end of the life when that cut throwing karma is created, that that throwing karma doesn’t ripen in that lifetime.
Right? And so are we we we together? No. No. Like, in in this life, take take this life.
In this life we have already created many positive throwing karmas and many negative throwing karmas. At the end of this life only one throwing karma is going to ripen. And the throwing karma that ripens at the end of this life may not be one created in this life anyway. Because remember, for those people who study the karma module, remember the cows in the barn. So when the door opens, what cow is likely to come out is is the the the cow closest to the door.
Remember? So there’s many conditions affecting what cut throwing karma is going to ripen at the end of at the at the time of death. So if if you just take the you know, simplify everything and just think in a particular life due to ignorance, one creates a throwing karma, you know. Right? And there’s the consciousness supporting that throwing karma.
But that throwing karma doesn’t ripen at the at the end of that life. So but that the consciousness supporting that throwing karma still exists. It goes on into the next life. And maybe at the end of that life, it it could ripen at the end of that that next life. But maybe it doesn’t, and so it’s carried on.
And and it doesn’t ripen at the end of that life or the one after that or the one after that. But eventually, after many, many lifetimes, that throwing karma has to ripen if it hasn’t been purified. Okay? So you’ve got these three links in the first life, a a you know, a one life and then the the next three links don’t occur until in another life when there’s this craving at the end of the life which starts to ripen that throwing karma created in life a. Right?
Here we’ve got a life a, b. Right? And the grasping occurs, existence comes, and so then so that’s two lives, but separated by you know, could be just one life separating them, two lives, three lives, or millions and millions of lives could be separating those two. Right? But life c is the the one that comes immediately after b.
You’ve got the throwing karma ripening at the end of one life, so it has to bring its its result in the very next life. Right? Am I making some sense? Yeah. So that’s what how the the twelve links can operate over three lifetimes where there is a huge gap between two of the lives.
Between a and b, there can be a big gap in of time. But between b and c, c occurs in the very next life. Life three. Right? And yes.
Yeah Bee what we’re trying to understand is particularly how the link number two you know we’re just we’re isolating. As I said, in any one life such as this life, we create many throwing karmas, good ones and bad ones, but only one throwing karma is going to ripen at the end of this life to produce the next life. Right? So if we just take a particular throwing karma, a one set of because in in this in any life, we start initiating many twelve links. Right?
So we’re just looking at how one set of twelve links operates. Because in one life, we have many moments of ignorance, and therefore, based on that link of ignorance, we could create many throwing karmas in any life. Right? So, for example, in this life, we create a good a really good throwing karma, you know, to be reborn a human being again. But, unfortunately, at the end of this life, that throwing karma doesn’t ripen, and the throwing karma to be born a rat ripens instead.
So we get be get reborn as a rat, and then we die as a rat, and another throwing karma ripens, we get reborn as a dog, and then a cat, and a goanna, and a kangaroo, and rhinoceros, and eventually get reborn as a human being again. And then that that throwing karma that we created in this life, we die as a human being, and that one ripens. Right? So, of course, we’re still existing as a human or nonhuman, whatever, but we’re still existing. And during all those existences, we’re creating we’re starting the process of creating many twelve links.
So saṃsāra is really quiet, a jail. Many, many chains we’re wrapping around ourselves. That’s the bad news. Right? Finishing karma.
Yeah. The completing karma. Yeah. Yeah. No.
That doesn’t work in the same way because because that doesn’t that’s not part of the twelve links because that doesn’t determine what kind of rebirth you’ll have. It’s it’s the throwing karmas. So that’s link number two. Yeah. Okay.
So, again, the purpose of studying this subject is to get some sense of this this how powerful these forces are that are driving us to take rebirth in saṃsāra, in cyclic existence over and over again. And and and and to see that the root of that is ignorance. And if we eliminate ignorance, then all the twelve links fall apart. Suffering comes to, you know, rebirth, suffering rebirth, cyclic existence completely comes to an end. Right.
So by meditating on these things over and over again, the suffering nature of cyclic existence and how the twelve links operate, we can generate this mind of great renunciation wishing to be free of cyclic existence, realizing there isn’t a moment real peace in it. It’s it’s all suffering. Right? It’s all yeah. And so then we with when we develop great renunciation, we can have the motivation to what goes with that is one just doesn’t simply renounce cyclic existence.
One has to replace it with something which is the wish to achieve nirvana, liberation from cyclic existence. Right? So what is nirvana? I mean, there’s many, many complicated explanations of it. I’m I I don’t know these anyway.
But, basically, I think all we would need to understand really is that that liberation is or nirvana is that state of mind where our where our mind is completely free of all negative karmic imprints or all delusions and all the causes of delusions which are which is ignorance. So nirvana comes about when ignorance is completely eliminated from the mind. When ignorance is eliminated from the mind, then all delusions are eliminated instantly and all all karma as well. It’s not a gradual process. You don’t get rid of the delusions step by step, and and then you get rid of ignorance.
You get rid of ignorance and which has to be done step by step. You can’t get rid of ignorance just in oops. In in one hit, one eliminates it step by step. But what once ignorance is eliminated, all delusions are instantly eliminated and with it all karma, all negative karma. And so this is the third noble truth all suffering can be you know, there is a true cessation of suffering, meaning a permanent cessation of suffering, a true permanent cessation of suffering.
And that that is because the cause of our suffering, ignorance, itself can be eliminated if we it it as I’ve tried to say, why cyclic existence continues is because ignorance continues. We don’t do anything about it. Why don’t we do anything about ignorance is because we don’t know we have it. And even once we know we’ve got it or we’re told we got it by meeting the Buddha’s teachings, we may still not do anything about it. We may not try to get rid of our ignorance.
Right? And even if we do, it takes a long time. But if we start working on our ignorance of of overcoming it, it it we it can be eliminated. Ignorance creates an illusion of things existing in a particular way and grasping at that appearance as being true. But through the power of logic, we can understand that that appearance, although it’s very convincing, is simply not possible.
Things appear to inherently exist, but when one checks carefully, then one can discover that things, not only don’t inherently exist, nothing can inherently exist, that everything depends, on many, many factors. And when we realize that, ignorance is destroyed. When we completely realize that, ignorance is destroyed. And once the mind is free of all those obscurations of ignorance, disturbing thoughts, and karmic imprints, then the the natural state of mind is experienced as bliss. So the experience of of liberation from cyclic existence, the experience of nirvana is bliss, perfect bliss.
As I’ve I think I’ve already mentioned here some somewhere, but not in this course. But if you get into the habit of doing some meditation, even if one isn’t a great meditator or even far from being a great meditator, you know, one starts out with a very agitated mind like that. And by training the mind, you can start to reduce the agitation, at least in meditation, the the arising of all sorts of negative and disturbing thoughts. And relatively speaking, at least for a short time, one can maintain a sort of a calm, still mind. Right?
So when one achieves that state, what is that experience? Well, the answer is, you’re supposed to say very quickly, that it’s a pleasant experience. It’s a very pleasant experience. It’s it’s much better experience than when the mind is like that. But all that’s happened, one hasn’t added anything to the mind at all.
One hasn’t sort of taken some drug, and one hasn’t sort of added somebody else’s mind to your mind, you haven’t added the Buddha’s mind to your mind or the Guru’s mind to your mind or anything, what in in a sense, we could say what has happened when the mind calms down is that we’ve got rid of a lot of rubbish from the mind, at least temporarily in meditation. And when that what what is extraneous to the mind is even temporarily removed, the experience is pleasant. So this indicates, it suggests, it may may not prove, but it it does it certainly wouldn’t prove a scientific to a scientific materialist, but it does suggest that the nature of the mind is blissful. It actually is blissful. But we’re not able to experience it because we constantly agitate the mind.
But when we stop agitating the mind, we can start to experience something of the true nature of our mind, which is blissful. And when the when the mind is totally free of all agitation and all causes of agitation, then one experiences the the the the actual pure bliss of the mind, which is nirvana. Roughly speaking, generally speaking, that’s what nirvana is. Yeah. It and it comes about when we develop the wisdom that is the the complete opposite to ignorance.
Wisdom is that mental factor that is experience is perceiving, experiencing self and things as they are, as they actually are. Once that occurs fully, completely, ignorance is eliminated. Just simply cannot operate and cannot come back. Right? So there is I haven’t got lots of details about this.
Just to make it more complicated for you. As you may know or should know or could know, there are two main traditions of Buddhism. There is the Theravāda tradition and the Mahāyāna tradition. Right? So they have different interpretations of things.
Right? So according I haven’t studied the Theravāda tradition very much at all, but just very simply, according to the Theravāda tradition, what they believe, because this is what the Buddha taught in the Pāli Sutras, is that what nirvana the the word nirvana literally means something like to snuff out, just like a candle is snuffed out. So in the Theravāda tradition, what nirvana actually refers to is the mind ceasing altogether. Because they argue that what drives the mind to take rebirth and to exist and to be reborn again and again is the, you know, the driving force of ignorance and disturbing thoughts. When they are eliminated, then there is nothing driving the mind to continue, and it just ceases.
The and that’s it. Well, as a human being, you achieve liberation. All delusions and ignorance stops, but you still got a body and your mind is operating in it. But once you die, the arhat, that’s finished. Nothing.
That’s nirvana. The nirvana without remainder. Yeah? So this is one view, and it’s what the Buddha taught in the Pāli tradition, but it’s not the Mahāyāna view at all. It’s completely yeah.
Because the Mahāyāna view, which I find much more attractive and also more logical, is that the mind always exists. It’s not something that can cease at all. The mind is always giving rise to experience. But what happens with when liberation is achieved is that the disturbed mind ceases, the obscured mind ceases, but the pure mind can continues forever in this blissful state. So but There’s a question.
What? No. It’s not. Buddha nature isn’t a Buddha isn’t isn’t a Theravāda view at all. This is a unique Mahāyāna view.
Yeah. And and and so especially but so in the Mahāyāna view, the an arhat, when they die, their mind goes on and exists in this blissful state. But from a Mahāyāna point of view the problem of even that of the mind continuing in this blissful state of nirvana is that what happens is that when the arhat who has achieved liberation dies, their mind absorbs into that meditative state of simply a total awareness of the bliss of the mind which is nirvana. And that’s all the mind is aware of. So the arhat like as a human being and an arhat living in the world, in the world is of course has no delusions, no negativities, no suffering, but they are because they’re a human being with senses and everything, they are aware of human beings and their suffering and arhats have love and compassion, generosity, etcetera, etcetera.
And so they benefit sentient beings teaching them the Dharma, whatever. But when they die, then from a Mahāyāna point of view, their mind doesn’t cease. It continues, but it continues in this, like, absorbed meditative state of bliss where there is totally no awareness of anything else. No awareness of, you know, the universe of sentient beings and the suffering of sentient beings. So once an Arhat dies, they are of no they don’t cause harm, of course, to anyone, but they don’t bring about the slightest benefit because they’re not aware of anyone.
So from a Mahāyāna point of view there’s no there’s not a great deal of benefit of becoming an Arhat, of achieving nirvana because it only benefits one sentient being, oneself. I mean, which is kind of that’s kind of nice that oneself gets benefited, but from a Mahāyāna point of view, it’s only one person. So what the Mahāyāna tradition emphasizes is achieving enlightenment because it is a unique view of the Mahāyāna teachings of the Buddha that every sentient being has Buddha nature. Because one of the views of the Theravāda teachings is that Well, Buddha nature is not something that is possessed by every sentient being. Only very rare sentient beings have the potential to become Buddhas and follow the Mahāyāna path, follow the path of a Bodhisattva and achieve enlightenment.
And so we we don’t know if we’ve got that potential. But the Maha so why why try and follow the become a bodhisattva and achieve enlightenment where one may not have the potential to do so? So the Theravāda tradition encourages people to achieve their own liberation because every sentient being can do that. Right? So the argument is go for it because you’ll get out of suffering.
Who wants suffering? Get out. Escape while you can. Yeah. And yeah.
But the Mahāyāna tradition, Mahāyāna teachings of the Buddha say the sutras of the Mahāyāna say that every sentient being, because of the very nature of mind, has Buddha nature. So everyone can generate bodhicitta. Everyone has the potential to be able to generate bodhicitta, follow the bodhisattva path, and become enlightened, become a Buddha. And we should do so. Why?
You all know why. To repay the kindness of mother sentient beings, to enlighten everyone. Right? We have to repay the kindness of suffering sentient beings. So there’s a huge difference between an arhat and a Buddha.
An arhat, especially when they have been freed from these contaminated five aggregates, is just dwells in this self absorbed blissful state of nirvana not benefiting anyone. Whereas a Buddha experiences that that that continuous bliss of the mind but they have their mind isn’t sort of self absorbed in this unknowing state. It’s quite the opposite. A Buddha is a being whose mind is is completely awake. You know, they have become the awakened one.
Their mind is totally aware of everything all the time. And actually, there there is a difference between what a Buddha is according to the Theravāda tradition and the Mahāyāna tradition. So both traditions say that a Buddha is an enlightened being, but there’s a difference between what that means. So according to the Theravāda tradition, a Buddha, an enlightened being, is omniscient. They they know everything.
They have the potential to know everything. But according to the Theravāda tradition, a Buddha doesn’t know everything all the time. But they when they want to, they can. So if I was a Buddha, if I according to the Theravāda tradition, I wouldn’t know what’s going on in your mind. But if I wanted to, I’d just zoom in and I would know.
Right? But the Mahāyāna view of the Buddha is that a that a Buddha is omniscient knowing everything all the time. The Buddha the so the the Mahāyāna view of of Buddha is something really inconceivable. So according to the Mahāyāna, omniscience means that you know the past, the present, and future of everything in every moment. So a Buddha in one moment knows the past, present, and future of everything.
So if you just just take one person, you know, I’m the Buddha, we’d take Arnold. With my omniscient mind, I would know in this moment in this moment and every moment all the past lives of Arnold, all his everything about his present and all his future lives, I would know all of it precisely, not jumbled up, but I would know all of it precisely, every single bit of it, all the time. And at the same time, I would know all of you, all of your lives, past, present, and future, all your all the thoughts you’ve ever had, all the clothes you’ve ever had, all the food you’ve ever had, where it came from. You know, for a Buddha, you could take a giant tree, chop it up into, like, toothpicks, throw them over ten million universes, and and the Buddha could see every toothpick and say, oh, that was that part of the tree. While being totally aware of everything else at the same time.
So if this is possible, it’s very useful in benefiting sentient beings because you know exactly what they’re thinking and why they’re thinking it and the whole history of why they’ve been thinking and feeling like that. So you know what to say and do to help them. And the Buddha’s mind, of course, is pervaded by great compassion. Great that omniscience is pervaded continuously by great love and great compassion. So Buddha mind, you know, is acting for the benefit of all sentient beings all the time because it couldn’t do anything else.
It’s not possible for Buddha mind to do anything else other than help sentient beings. Of course, people say, well, if that’s the case, how come he hasn’t helped me? I’m still suffering. And the answer is, they say, that the mind of Buddhas and the mind of sentient beings is equal in one sense because we are very deluded. So even though the Buddha is he like, Buddha mind is right here now.
It’s here. All around you, always has been. The Buddha is always aware of you, always has love for you, always has compassion for us all the time, has limitless ways to benefit us, but we don’t open our hearts and minds to the Buddha. That’s why, like, Buddhas can do many things, but they they yeah. They can only do things according to our karma and our mind.
If we don’t want to be helped by the Buddhas, we can’t be. The Buddhas can’t help us. If we want to be, the Buddhas will help because they’re helping all the time. They’re doing stuff all the time, standing right in front of us, waving at us, telling us, you know, take care of yourself. But, like, you know, what can a Buddha do to an ant?
Can’t do much. But whatever can be done, Buddhas are doing it. It’s really only when we’re human beings that the Buddhas are able to really very powerfully affect us. And even more than that, not just when we’re human beings, but when we have met the Dharma and believe in it. That’s when the Buddhas can really move our mind, change our mind.
That’s why the precious human rebirth is so vital to have and to recognize that one has it. Maybe I’m just raving as usual, but I remember many some years ago when I was in Bunbury, I used to teach when I was living in Perth, I used to go down to Bunbury one oh, that’s too long introduction. One lady there is a nurse, and she she made the point that it’s just really amazing that people would come into the hospital with, you know, like, lung cancer, and they would be told not to smoke cigarettes, and they would go out. You know, they were practically dying of, you know, cancer. And they would go out, you know, when the nurse turned their back and would smoke cigarettes.
You know? And she said, it’s just so difficult to help sentient beings. You know, an obvious thing, you have cancer, you don’t smoke, especially if you’ve lung cancer. You don’t smoke. But people do.
You know, the doctors, the nurses tell you, don’t smoke. It’s gonna kill you. Oh, no. I like it. You know?
So you do it. Yeah. This is a person talking directly to you with charts and everything and it doesn’t affect us. If we don’t want it to, we don’t believe it. We don’t you know, it doesn’t affect us.
It doesn’t touch us. Yeah. It’s only when we open our minds to something that anything can get in, And we’re very good at blocking our minds. Even when we have amazing teachers like His Holiness teaching us, Lama Zopa Rinpoche, many great beings come here doing amazing things. We don’t practice.
We go and we, you know, we say, oh, how inspiring. But inspiring actually has meaning. That means you’re you know, it leads you to do something, but we don’t. We just say, oh, that was very inspiring, meaning it actually wasn’t. We didn’t get inspired.
We just thought it was a nice talk. But we don’t we don’t practice what the gurus, you know, advise. We just think they’re lovely people to hang around with. Yeah. We are very difficult.
Oh, this applies to me entirely. I’m doing don’t know about you, but I’m just talking about myself. So so but when we really do open our minds, then the Buddhas can do an awful lot because they have this great compassion and this amazing wisdom. So anyway, we’ve got to become Buddhas because we have the potential, and there’s this immense need. So there is a great difference between liberation and enlightenment between an arhat and a Buddha.
Because when a a a being achieves nirvana, they do that by basically developing the wisdom, the complete wisdom that destroys ignorance permanently. But even though ignorance has been removed from the mind, the mind of an arhat is still obscured. The arhat’s mind still has these very very subtle obscurations that prevent the mind the true the full potential of the mind in manifesting because the full potential of the mind is to be omniscient. But an arhat isn’t omniscient. They’re only aware of the their own bliss.
As an arhat, a human arhat, they are clairvoyant and everything. They can read people’s minds and but when they die, that their mind absorbs into the bliss of nirvana and it’s all gone. They’re not aware of anything. Just their own their own bliss. Alright?
And so this is because the mind is still obscured in a very, very subtle way, and these obscurations are called, believe it or not, the obscurations to omniscience. So there are two levels of obscuration in our mind, The obstacles to liberation, which is what an our heart gets rid of, but there are the very subtle obscurations to omniscience. And this is what a bodhisattva gets rid of following the path to enlightenment. So what are these subtle obscurations? They are said to be the very, very subtle imprints of ignorance.
And in the teaching, some of you have heard this, the analogy that is given, I’ve only ever heard the one analogy, is that if you have a bowl which you regularly use to crush up garlic, if you get out all the garlic from that bowl and wash it thoroughly, then there’s no garlic in the bowl. Right? It’s eliminated. This is like, an arhat’s mind. It’s it’s free.
The the bowl, that clean bowl, is like the arhat’s mind. There is no garlic. But if you smell that bowl, it will still smell of garlic even though there’s, you know, roughly speaking, no garlic there. So this is said to be like this even though ignorance has been removed and the arhats mind still has this subtle imprint of ignorance which is obscuring the mind. And it’s in following the Mahāyāna path that these very subtle obscurations are removed.
And how what removes them is the wisdom realizing the true nature of things. We sorry. Just go back. What what eliminates the obstacles to liberation is wisdom. What liberate eliminates the obstacles to omniscience is also wisdom, but the difference is that the wisdom that eliminates the obstacles to omniscience is much more powerful because it’s empowered in a sense by bodhicitta.
So an an arhat doesn’t generate bodhicitta. A bodhicitta an arhat develops love and compassion in a very, you know, advanced form, but they don’t develop bodhicitta. They don’t develop this wish to repay the kindness of all sentient beings. They don’t develop the wish to achieve enlightenment in order to repay the kindness of all sentient beings. So they don’t follow the bodhisattva.
They don’t become a bodhisattva. They don’t generate bodhicitta. And their focus, the the the Pāli the the Theravāda tradition is focused on achieving one’s own liberation. Whereas the Mahāyāna tradition is focused on encouraging the practitioner to achieve enlightenment, to get rid of the obstacles to liberation. So we need wisdom for that, but also to get rid of the obstacles to omniscience.
And one particular needs bodhicitta for that. bodhicitta to empower that wisdom. Does that make some sense? How can they be? Because the Buddha is is omniscient, and the Buddha sees that there are many different kinds of people and some people are just not attracted to the idea of benefiting all sentient beings because they think it’s just too terrifying.
It’s just too big and scary. Whereas the idea that achieving liberation, oh, that makes sense. I could do that. And the idea that liberation involves coming you know, being nonexistent is appealing. I find it revolting, but some people see that as quite appealing that just like there are, you know, so many people, you know, materialist people who who, you know, poo poo people who believe in future lives.
Oh, what a pathetic, you know, people who are religious, they’re such so childish and pathetic. They just want to, like, believe believe in a future life to make themselves happy. They don’t have the guts to face the fact that there’s nothing after death. So so the people, you know, the idea there’s nothing after death is very appealing to some people in in like, in the materials and within people who have some religious belief. There are people who are interested in following the spiritual path, but the idea of getting rid of suffering, but the idea of suffering finishing with nothing somehow is very appealing.
But and then yeah. So the Buddha taught many things to appeal, you know, not yeah. To hook people, to get them to practice virtue, etcetera, develop loving kindness, to become free of suffering. He taught different things that meets the minds of different kinds of people. No.
Once you die as an Arahant, that’s it. Finished. You don’t come back. You don’t take oh, no. Well, again, there no.
You don’t. No. You can’t. Basically, no. Yes.
They’re out of cyclic existence, dwelling in the bliss of nirvana, finished forever. They’re just blissed out. That’s it. You just hang out in bliss. Know?
Nothing to do. It’s just totally entertaining, just blissing out. It’s a bit like when we go to sleep. We don’t go to sleep with with a conscious of when I don’t think, well, I don’t. You don’t have this set plan that one’s going to wake up in a in a particular time.
You just go to sleep with not much control of whether you’re gonna wake up or not and when you’re going to wake up. Maybe you have an alarm clock to help you get up. Some people wake up, but there’s no consciousness going on that, you know, oh, I wonder what’s gonna happen to me while I’m asleep. You just go to sleep. So it’s a bit like that with an Arahant.
They they achieve nirvana and it just goes on. You know? Mhmm. No. Yes.
I don’t know if we have to, but but again, yeah, accord again, according to the Mahāyāna tradition, actually, it’s something I don’t understand how it works. But according to the Mahāyāna tradition, although there are the beings who follow the path to just to nirvana with the aim of achieving that state. At some point, the arhat doesn’t change their mind to become a Buddha, but at some point somehow the Buddhas are able to break through that meditative state of the blissing out in nirvana and in a sense kind of wake them up and tell them, you know, you have to achieve enlightenment. So they enter the Mahāyāna path. So the the Mahāyāna view is that ultimately everyone will become a Buddha because everyone has Buddha nature.
And even the arhats, even though they only want to be arhats, will be encouraged by the Buddhas to become Buddhas, and they will do so. Yes. Yeah. But whether that will actually happen, who knows? Yeah.
We don’t have to worry about that. Anyway, very quickly, to achieve nirvana, to achieve liberation, there’s many things to be done. Firstly, have to renounce this life, and we have to renounce saṃsāra. And if we renounce saṃsāra and which means involves, on the other hand, seeking liberation, wanting to achieve nirvana. What we have to do to achieve nirvana, there are three basic things we have to do.
The the main thing is develop the the wisdom that will destroy the root of saṃsāra, which is our ignorance. Right? But in order to develop that wisdom, one has to be before that well, while you know, as one is developing that wisdom, one also has to train in developing single pointed concentration because the the mind that is like that, which is, you know, just distracted and agitated by disturbing thoughts, will never reach the ability to be able to really penetrate into the nature of reality properly. Right? So we have to develop what is called single pointed concentration, the ability to hold the mind on one object effortlessly for as long as we wish.
And that involves subduing the disturbing thoughts and and training the mind to develop deeper and deeper levels of meditation. But in order to do that, one has to first train in something else, which is the basic thing is the training in the higher training in morality. So there are three things that we have to do if we want three fundamental basic things that we have to follow, train in to achieve liberation from cyclic existence. The first one is to develop the higher training in morality of avoiding all negative actions and engaging in every kind of positive action. And in this process taking vows is very important, very helpful because having a vow is you know, vows only work in a Buddhist context, certainly, vows work on the basis of believing the law of cause and effect.
That our actions, good and bad, always have effects and and are creating karmic imprints that have huge effects in the future. If we if we develop faith in that in that and base our life on that, then taking vows becomes very effective because on on the basis of having a strong belief in the law of cause and effect, if we take a vow, it forces us to be more mindful of avoiding negative actions. And so we will avoid more and more negative actions. So that frees our mind a great it purifies our mind a great deal, frees our mind a great deal. Lama Zopa Rinpoche, who’s my main teacher, says many, times that that any anything you do, any virtuous thing you do is far more effective and powerful if you do it with a mind possessing vows.
The more vows you have, you know, the more you’re purifying. Know, that is, of course, if you’re keeping vows, not if you’re breaking them. But if you have them and you’re keeping them well, if you’re living a a really good moral life, then on that basis, every virtuous thing you do is just that much more effective and more powerful. Or even just by doing a prayer, if you if you if if there are two people, one doesn’t have any vows and another person has some vows, the person saying the prayer who has the vows, that prayer, you know, done along the bait for the benefit of others is more effective, more, yeah, more powerful. So taking vows as part of keeping pure morality is extremely helpful, very important.
And yeah. So, anyway, that’s the that’s the first thing. Trying to live a moral life as much as possible. That’s the first training. And then the more we do that, that that is subduing our disturbing thoughts.
So then when we actively train in meditation to to really control our disturbing thoughts, it becomes it’s if we’re if we’re doing it. It’s easier, more effective, more quick if we’re living a virtuous life. And so we’ll be able to develop single pointed concentration. And once we’ve developed single point concentration, we will be able to use our understanding of the wisdom of the teachings of the Buddha to really penetrate into the experience of emptiness. Right now, we are experiencing ourself in a false way.
The way we experience ourself is is is not correct. It seems as though it’s true, but it’s very false. And in the Buddhist teachings, there are descriptions of how we experience ourself. And the general description is we experience ourself and actually all things as being inherently existing. And then so there are these two words inherently existing, and then you can have explanations of what inherently existing means.
And then you can meditate on them, and you can get some idea of what that means. And takes some time to get some idea of what inherent existence means, to get a mental concept, a mental image of what inherent existence really means. But then you have to be able to identify how you perceive yourself as inherently existing. It’s one thing to know in a general abstract way what inherent existence refers to, but it’s an it’s another level altogether to be able to correctly identify how one is actually experiencing oneself as inherently existing. So to do that, to be able to to able to identify this false view that we have of ourself, that requires a very, very fine subdued mind.
One has to have the teachings, the understanding, the wisdom teachings. One has to have that intellectual understanding, but one has to be able to combine it with this meditational ability to, yeah, to refine the mind in this very calm, still state so that one can identify this false view as a false view. It’s probably a very pathetic example analogy, but which I always give, but, you know, some artificial flowers are very, very obviously artificial flowers. They’re very badly made. You just from a long distance, you can see that that is an artificial flower.
But some artificial flowers are very, very convincing because they’re just so well made. So the wrong view of self that we have is very well made. It’s extremely convincing. So you have to investigate it very carefully until you realize you oh, it’s a fake. It’s a complete fake.
So you can’t do that with a mind like that. So we need these, what are called, the three higher trainings of morality, concentration, and wisdom. And when we’ve developed that wisdom, yeah, we can destroy ignorance. Then bingo. No saṃsāra.
Just nirvana. Eight question? Two questions? Yes. One renounces this life by seeing how it is very short that we’re going to die, that the things that we that we waste our life on are impermanent.
They don’t last. They don’t bring the happiness that we hope they will. Sorry? Renunciation? Yes.
Yes. Of course. Yes. Yeah. Like, I I I tried to say last week and this week that renounce renunciation has these two aspects.
You’re giving up something in order to get something else. You’re not just throwing something away. Right? You renounce something in order to get something far far better. And so to do to develop that authentic mind, it it it has to involve authentically understanding that this is not good.
This is not what I want, and this is much better. I really want that. It can’t be something we pretend. All the Buddha says that’s bad, and this is good. So I’ll I’ll believe that’s bad, and this is good.
But deep down, we don’t. You know, one won’t have real renunciation. One has to come to a genuine understanding that, you know, the things of this life, yeah, they’re nice, but they don’t last. They don’t really fulfill me. And as it involves following attachment and aversion and blah blah blah, which actually creates lots of negative imprints.
And the result of chasing all after these lovely nice things is creating lots of negative imprints and a lot of suffering. So forget it. I’ll live a moral life and have a to get a good rebirth. But so one has to be really convinced of those things. And then you one will happily let go of, you know, give up one’s obsession with those things in order to work for a good rebirth.
Okay, thank you very much. Tea break. Theravāda tradition it seems sometimes when they use the term enlightenment they’re actually referring to achieving nirvana and and in the Mahāyāna tradition, enlightenment is sometimes called the great nirvana. So you have nirvana and great nirvana. So I personally think it’s just easier to talk about nirvana referring to the state of liberation and and enlightenment, which is achieved through following the Mahāyāna path.
So one can ask the question, is there a difference between nirvana and liberation? And I think you could say yes. Because for for someone following the path to enlightenment, that that is a bodhisattva. A bodhisattva who is following the path to enlightenment, they which is us, of course. We’re encouraged to become bodhisattvas and achieve enlightenment.
So what we in order to achieve enlightenment, we do have to achieve liberation from cyclic existence, but we don’t need to experience nirvana. In fact, experiencing the bliss of nirvana would become an obstacle cause we would get, develop this kind of attachment to it and wanna just stay in it. So a bodhisattva following the path to enlightenment achieves liberation but not nirvana. Whereas someone following the the the what is now politically incorrectly called the Hīnayāna path, the path of the individual vehicle, is seeking nirvana sorry, seeking liberation in order to achieve bliss of nirvana, whereas someone following the Mahāyāna path is seeking liberation in order to go beyond it, you know, so that they can achieve enlightenment. Okay.
So just very briefly so this this course is called saṃsāra nirvana. So that nirvana includes from a Mahāyāna point of view enlightenment. So we have to understand saṃsāra in order to want to be free of it, to achieve the little nirvana. But in the Mahāyāna tradition, we’re encouraged not just to seek that little nirvana, but the great nirvana of enlightenment because that benefits not just one being but countless beings forever. So if you if you have if you look at this second handout which is titled Outlines of the Stages of Training the Mind on the Path to Enlightenment, This sets out very briefly what we have to do which takes quite a long time.
So firstly one has to rely on the spiritual master and by relying on the spiritual master we recognize that we have the optimum human rebirth meaning it’s the optimum type of rebirth to be able to practice the Dharma especially the Dharma of following the Mahāyāna path to enlightenment. So then how do we make use of this optimum human rebirth? The the basic feature of an optimum or perfect or precious human rebirth is a human rebirth in which one meets the Dharma, has faith in it, has a healthy body and mind to be able to practice it, and has all the conditions necessary to be able to practice, such as Dharma friends and teachers and and and so on, those various things. So if one has all of those factors, one can say one has a precious human rebirth, the optimum chance to practice and take care of the mind properly. So then the way to make use of this very precious human rebirth is firstly to train the mind in the path which is shared by the practitioner of small capacity.
So the practitioner of small capacity is someone who is seeking just a good rebirth. They realize that just being obsessed with this life is going to lead to following attachments and anger creating negative karma. So they renounce this life with a thought to have a good rebirth. But that’s the that’s the that’s the their entire aim is just to have a good rebirth. Whereas someone following the Mahāyāna path, their aim is to achieve enlightenment, but to achieve enlightenment, you have to at least first get another good rebirth because the chances of getting enlightened in one lifetime are extremely remote.
Right? The chances that we’re gonna get enlightened in this life is like zilch. Sorry, folks. What? Yes.
I know. But we yes. But I mean, talking about our this very particular life we have right now in this body and at the age we are at. Some of you are in a better position than others, but so we need at least one more lifetime, but actually a whole lot. So it’s said to be the training that is in shared with the being of smallest capacity.
Okay. Maybe just to go back a bit. I don’t know if this is making sense. The the the worldly being, which is maybe what we are or were, is someone who’s just thinking of this life. They have no belief or interest in future lives of any kind, Buddhist view of future lives, Hindu, Christian, whatever.
They just think about this life and chasing after the things of this life. Then if one meets the Dharma, then the minimum spiritual practice is seeking a good rebirth. What defines Dharma practice is practicing to achieve a good rebirth. Anything done just for the benefit of this life is not Dharma. It’s just worldly Dharma.
Doesn’t count. So the things that need to be done to renounce this life is contemplating impermanence and death, thinking of the suffering of the lower rebirths, developing faith in the triple gem, going for refuge, and then especially developing faith in the law of cause and effect because then one will live one’s life according to that. The next stage is training the mind in the path shared by the practitioner of medium capacity. So the aim of the practitioner of medium capacity is just nirvana to get out of cyclic existence and experience bliss. But someone following the Mahāyāna path is sharing that because they have to get out of saṃsāra, but their aim is not just to get out of saṃsāra, but to go beyond that to enlightenment.
So that that’s about renouncing cyclic existence. And yes. So that involves contemplating the general sufferings of cyclic existence, the specific sufferings, the causes of suffering and how one perpetuates cyclic existence which is about the twelve links. Then one considers determining the path to a liberation which is the three higher trainings of the training in morality, concentration and wisdom. So once we’ve renounced cyclic existence we can then train the mind in the stages of the path of a practitioner of great capacity, which is the person seeking enlightenment for the benefit of all sentient beings.
So that involves generating bodhicitta, the actual wish to achieve enlightenment because one has developed great compassion for all sentient beings. So there are different ways of generating bodhicitta. And then there is the training in the bodhisattva actions. So the six perfections are generosity, morality, patience, perseverance, concentration and developing wisdom. So a bodhisattva needs that wisdom not only to get out of saṃsāra, to destroy the obstacles to liberation, but to eliminate the obstacles to omniscience in order to achieve enlightenment.
So that’s just the beginning. That’s not even the actual path. So we have to develop these qualities of renunciation, bodhicitta, and wisdom. And when one has actually generated authentic bodhicitta, this authentic determination to achieve enlightenment, once one has generated that mind, one becomes a bodhisattva and one actually enters the path to enlightenment. One has actually entered the path.
And one enters the path on what is called the path of accumulation Because on the path of accumulation what about bodhisattva is doing is accumulating the merit that is necessary to be able to develop the wisdom will get them out of saṃsāra and help them achieve enlightenment. And then one at some stage I’m not gonna go into all these details because it’s very, complicated and takes a lot of time. This is just to give you a just a rough idea. Then after some time, one enters the path of preparation. And after some time, one enters the path of insight.
So the path of insight refers to the the the moment a Bodhisattva in meditation directly perceives emptiness for the first time. Emptiness referring to the true nature of self. Directly perceiving how the self doesn’t inherently exist the way it appears. So when one enters into the path of insight, one becomes what is called an ārya bodhisattva. An ārya is anyone who has directly perceived reality as it is.
And on the path of insight, an ārya bodhisattva also enters what are called the bodhisattva bhūmis. There are these ten levels or stages leading to enlightenment. So a first level, you know, so a Bodhisattva on the path of insight So on the path of insight, which only lasts a very short time, the bodhisattva for the first time directly perceives the true nature of the self, becomes a first level bodhisattva, and then enters the path of meditation. So the path of meditation also lasts an extremely long time, many, many, many lifetimes. And the Bodhisattva accumulates more merit and step by step from the second to the seventh levels they get rid of all the obscurations to liberation step by step.
So at the very end of the seventh level, the Bodhisattva has completely eliminated ignorance. So then they are the they have the equivalent experience of an of an arhat, but they don’t enter nirvana because they have bodhicitta empowering them to continue for the sake of sentient beings. So the eighth, ninth and tenth levels are said to be the pure levels because now the Bodhisattva is out of saṃsāra. They’re in this completely pure state. They no longer take rebirth due to karma and delusion, but they could take rebirth, be reborn back in the samsaric world out of great compassion for the benefit of others.
Example being his holiness, the Dalai Lama. Well, his holiness may be a Buddha, but he may be a great bodhisattva. So no. No. No.
Drop out. No. No. No. No.
You can’t drop out. No. I’m if I was, you know, halfway good monk, should know this by now after thirty six years. I still don’t know and I’ve read this comes up so many times that I never check. But on once you’ve generated bodhicitta, more or less, you can’t lose it.
But there there are exceptions where bodhisattvas give up their bodhicitta. They lose it and fall down into the into the other path. But I think it’s somewhere on the path of accumulation because the path of accumulation has four stages, and I think it is on the third stage of the path of accumulation that once bodhicitta becomes completely rock solid, and there is no way you can from then on, it’s like a, you know, one of what do you those escalator things. Do call them? Walkway things.
You just you just keep going. You’re on the path. You can never you you you are definitely going to achieve enlightenment. So you and certainly from the path of insight, there’s no way once you’ve a bodhisattva has entered the path of insight that there’s no way they fall beyond that. That you just keep going.
Yes, oh yes definitely even before that. So at the very end of the tenth level one achieves in so on the eighth ninth and tenth levels one is getting rid of the subtle obscurations to omniscience on the first to the end of the seventh, one’s getting rid of ignorance and getting out of saṃsāra. On the eighth, ninth and tenth, bodhisattva bhūmis, the bodhisattva is getting rid of the subtle obscurations to omniscience. And then when all that’s done, they enter what is called the path of no more learning, which is the state of enlightenment. And that goes on forever.
So that in a nutshell is the path to the great nirvana, which we can follow. And, yes, it could look very daunting, a lot to do, but what else is there to do? Because other the other choice is saṃsāra. saṃsāra goes on even longer, and it’s all suffering. Whereas this, and there’s no benefit to anyone.
Whereas this, one is step by step getting rid of suffering and replacing it with greater and greater happiness and at the same time causing less and less suffering to others and actually starting to be of actual benefit to others more and more. Just to blind you with some information which some people might dismiss as just pure fantasy and everything but according to the teachings when one become when we when the bodhisattva enters the path of insight and becomes an a first level ārya bodhisattva, at that state, such a person could be sitting in their room meditating, or they might be watching television. Although most first level Bodhisattvas probably don’t bother watching television. Anyway, you could be sitting in your room, but at the same time, you know, in this human body, what appears to be a human body, but you are you are actually able to create or manifest a hundred other bodies at the same time, which could be human bodies, dog bodies, any kind of body you want for the for the benefit to benefit sentient beings, and you send them out doing good things. While you sit in your room watching TV or reading or writing a letter or, you know, playing mobile games and things like that.
But there’s more. Each of those bodies, each of those hundred bodies can manifest a hundred bodies, which means as as a first level bodhisattva, you can manifest at the same time ten thousand bodies to benefit sentient beings doing all sorts of things all over the universe. And as you go through the Bhumis, the number of bodies that you can create, you know, increases exponentially, if that’s the word. Just more and more. Yeah.
So by the time you’re a Buddha, you can manifest as many bodies as you like. Just there’s no limit. Of course, they’re not like this. I mean, they may look like this, but they’re not. Actually, even long be oh, this gets starts to get all very, you know, spacey.
But by the time you’re a first level bodhisattva, you don’t have a body like this anyway. It looks like this, but it’s not. It’s a completely different kind of body. And you still might get pawned with through a human mother, but your body and, you know, a doctor looking at you would say, oh, yeah. Blood and bones and everything, but you it’s it’s not.
That’s just a trick. But I don’t understand all of that. They actually say even when you develop calm abiding, your body changes radically. That’s why you can wait for it folks, walk through walls. When you achieve calm abiding, yeah, you can Well, you have to do some other well, it it doesn’t come automatically.
Once you’ve developed calm abiding, there’s some other meditational tricks you can do, you know, and if you do those, then you’re able to walk through walls. You can rearrange the molecules in your body so they don’t bump into the molecules of the wall, so you walk through them. And you can fly, of course. Of course. Yeah.
Without a plane. And you have clairvoyance, clairaudience. No. No. That’s no.
This is way, way, way, way, way before. It’d be even before that. Yes. Sorry? No.
No. No. Be way way way way before any of this. Yeah. I think that’s about it for tonight.
We you have to ask me questions because it’s not time to have a discussion group, so ask me some questions. Yes. Oh, okay. Yes. Definitely.
Definitely. Yes. They go everywhere into the lower realms, everywhere. Who? No.
No. No. No. Because the a bodhisattva, you know, how do you say? They just appear in ordinary form.
And a bodhisattva is someone who I mean, even an ārya bodhisattva hasn’t destroyed their self grasping ignorance yet, although they’re in the process of doing so. But their their ego grasping is very small and their self-cherishing is, like, of nonexistent. So they have no wish to go around telling people, I’m a great bodhisattva. Well, it depend it it depends on one’s karma and faith. I mean, the I mean, there there are there are, like, the Buddha’s work in fairly obvious ways, you know, in the teachings it says, of course, as I was as I was trying to say, the most powerful direct way a Buddha can guide us is to appear as a teacher to a human being because that’s really only human beings who can practice the Dharma.
I mean, at least certain start the practice and get anywhere significant in the path. So to to do that, you have to have a teacher. So that’s how the the Buddha’s manifest as perfect teachers, such as his holiness. For example, I mean, I I mean, this is the belief. I I know I’m I’m I’m I I don’t know if this is true.
I because if if I knew, I I’d have to be at the level of his holiness to actually know. So it’s it’s very easy to say his holiness is the Dalai Lama. He’s a Buddha or a bodhisattva, but who knows? But he gives many indications that he’s definitely up there. If he isn’t someone, then forget it.
So so he is obviously manifest although his holiness is I’m just an ordinary monk and blah blah blah. From checking his behavior, it’s obvious he is a very special being. But many human beings don’t believe that, especially the government of China. You ask them. They’re not terribly impressed by the holiness of his holiness.
Right? But but then there are other bodhisattvas or buddhas who who don’t manifest in an obvious Dharma way. They just appear as ordinary human beings doing ordinary things, to benefit sentient beings. So those people would be very, very difficult to recognize as, you know, holy beings because they they are deliberately appearing, you know, in a very, very ordinary way. If not, even, you know, Bodhisattvas and Buddhas can appear even as quite negative people.
But even those who are appearing holy, not everyone thinks they’re holy and wonderful because it depends on one’s karma and faith and so on. Yes. That that’s what they can do, but whether we can see them is another question. That’s the point. We we can’t even see the good qualities of each other often.
Right? Someone actually in solid flesh who may be a nice person, but if we’re not in a nice state of mind, we don’t even see their good, you know, their good qualities. And, yeah, it’s a very complicated thing. Don’t understand it all myself, but although Buddhas can manifest many things, it also it also depends on the karma of the sentient beings, what Buddha can do. So, you know, according to the teachings, when the karma of sentient beings in in a particular world system gets really bad, they can’t manifest there at all because the the the yeah.
It’s just nothing happens. It doesn’t work. And I I mean, just just to fill in the story with some I I don’t know if this is, you know, a hundred percent pure dharma or if it’s just Tibetan belief, but certainly the Tibetans believe that but also the Tibetan lamas believe this. And since that many of them have great realizations, this may be the actual truth that and it seems to make sense that the karma of, like, human beings on this earth, the good karma, we we only have so much good karma at any particular time to have so many great lamas. Right?
And so, for example, the the year that Lama Yeshe passed away, nineteen eighty four, was the beginning of that that year. It was also when, according to Tibetan astrology, every twelve years of our life is an obstacle year where one could experience all sorts of health issues and even have life threatening problems occur. So that year was a year when his of his holiness’s obstacle year. And during that year, several very, very great lamas of the tradition passed away, including Lama Yeshe and also Zong Rinpoche and Serkong Rinpoche. And it is said that definitely Serkong Rinpoche passed away deliberately because he said there wasn’t the karma for him and his holiness to be on the earth at the same time.
So he left so people could still have the Dalai Lama here. And his holiness on I think I’ve well, I’ve told these stories many, many times. On a number of occasions, his holiness has twice that I know of. I I think maybe his holiness has only done it twice. Twice in this life, his holiness has told the Tibetan people that I am leaving this planet because you’re not behaving.
And I you know, if you’re not if you’re not gonna follow my advice, then there’s no reason to me to be on this planet. So many times, his holiness says, I’m just an ordinary, simple monk. And then sometimes, his holiness shows who he really is. Of course, some people could dis dismiss this as pure, you know, schizophrenic paranoid superman, you know, I am Christ delusional state. But if you’ve met his holiness, you know, he’s, you know, not like that.
And what he says is you know? Because this is the point about, you know, even if his holiness is just a bodhisattva at his level, bodhisattvas come to the earth not because they have to, they come to teach, to benefit. And if they’re not benefiting, they don’t they don’t stay because there’s billions of sentient beings elsewhere who could be benefited. So they withdraw the manifestation by manifesting growing old and getting sick and dying. And his holiness many years ago when he wanted a stat a large statue of Padmasambhava built and put in his main temple in Dharamsala.
And a lot of Tibetans critic I I won’t go into all the politics why, but, anyway, they said, oh, this shouldn’t happen. This shouldn’t happen. We shouldn’t have this statue. And his holiness says, I don’t need this statue. You need it.
I’m doing it for you. So if you don’t want if you’re not happy with what I’m doing for you, bye bye. I’m going. Meaning, I’m dying. I’m going to another place, another world to teach where people will listen to me.
So then all the Tibetans freaked out, started begging him not to pass away, and then and including great lamas went to him, including Serkong Rinpoche, who has a little beard, or he passed away many years ago, but he had this little beard, this goatee beard. And his actually tugged on his beard and said, don’t worry, old man. I’ll stay. Anyway, his holiness told the Tibetan people, if you do if you all come together and do a hundred million Om Mani Padme Hum recitations, I will stay. So they did.
They all came to Dharamsala or not all of them, a lot came to Dharmasala, recited a hundred million Om Mani Padme Hum together, and they do that now every year. Once a year, that ceremony is done. And they make all these little teeny tiny pills which they bless, which are called mani pills, which his holiness gives out to people all over the world. So that was one occasion. So that that shows something about how, you know, it depends on the karma of people whether Buddhas and Bodhisattvas manifest.
They can they can do what they like, but it depends. They don’t just do it. They don’t send manifestations if they’re not gonna create them, if they’re not gonna be of any benefit. Right? But if there’s going to be some benefit because there’s at least even one person who’s going to follow their advice, they’re there.
Like my teacher, he will teach for hours and hours until everyone goes except maybe one person. Bye bye. Well said. It’s working. Because he doesn’t care if people come or go.
But if there’s someone listening who’s benefiting, he will teach forever or a long time. Yeah. Okay. Anyway, don’t know if there was any use, a little bit about saṃsāra nirvana, which is the potential of our mind, really. We have the alright.
The potential for saṃsāra is active. It’s operating right now. The potential for nirvana isn’t active, but it is there. It’s indestructible. And we have the precious human rebirth, the chance to activate it.
And we can for the sake of all sentient beings. And people have been doing that since the Buddha appeared here. Right? So thank you very much for showing up. We can dedicate the merit.
Remember, on Sunday, there is the retreat, so I hope some people have enrolled for it. There’s still time to enroll and cook your veggie lunch to bring or put in an order at the shop somewhere for it. Okay. So, we can dedicate the merit of not just tonight, but of the whole doing the whole course. Page nine.
Due to the merits of these virtuous actions, may I quickly attain the state of a Guru Buddha and lead all living beings without exception into that enlightened state. May the precious bodhicitta, not yet born, arise and grow. May that born have no decline but increase forevermore. So since it’s our last night, we won’t finish with prostrations because if this becomes auspicious to meet again. So our next course is it sounds a bit grim.
It’s death and rebirth, isn’t it? Yes. Which is for how many weeks? Do you remember? Oh, seven weeks also.
But this is a really, really, really important topic to study and extremely, extremely useful in this life because we are going to die. So it’s really important to think about this topic and prepare for it. Yeah. Because also by thinking and studying and meditating on impermanence and death, this is not only incredibly beneficial for our self throughout our life, but also especially when we die, which is the most crucial time in our life. But also knowing more about impermanence and death having the courage and compassion to think about it strongly can is can put us in a position to be very helpful for people who are facing death and dying and their relatives because many people most people, because they don’t think about these subjects, when when death actually comes, it becomes a hugely overwhelming, stressful, frightening, experience.
So if one has thought about it strongly, regularly, has a little bit of understanding, at least because of one’s faith in the Buddhist teachings, this can be, really, really helpful to a lot of people. So I highly recommend people study this topic, about what’s called death and rebirth. Yeah. Very liberating. It’s, yeah, it’s a very vital subject.
It’s connected to many, many things. Yeah. Okay. Thank you very much.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- completing karma drubje kyi lä (Tib)
- Also called finishing karma, the karmic imprints that ripen to determine the type of experiences we have when we are reborn, as opposed to throwing karma that determines the actual rebirth. LYWA
- obscurations to knowledge jneyavarana (Skt); she drib (Tib)
- One of the two obscurations, the more subtle ones that block enlightenment; also known as subtle obscurations, obscurations to enlightenment and cognitive obscurations (Berzin’s translation). LYWA
- path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
- The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
- path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
- The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
- Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
- A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
- throwing karma phen jä kyi lä (Tib)
- Also called projecting karma, the karmic imprint that ripens at the time of death to propel us into the next rebirth. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.