1 h 23 min · 9,263 words · 16 September 2014 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Venerable Thubten Dondrub concludes a six-week introductory course on refuge in the Three Jewels of Buddhism, the foundation of the spiritual path. In this 83-minute talk, he covers the measure of having taken refuge—knowing the good qualities of the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha, understanding the differences between these three (doctor-medicine-nurse analogy), and genuinely accepting them as one’s guide. He explains causal and resultant refuge: relying on external sources while practicing to transform one’s own mind into refuge. The teaching emphasizes that refuge rests on understanding the mind as non-physical and formless, the source of all experience. The final section introduces the five lay vows—avoiding killing, stealing, lying, sexual misconduct, and intoxicants—practical ethical guidelines that deepen one’s commitment to protecting the mind. Dondrub illustrates concepts through personal anecdotes, addresses audience questions on difficult cases (killing insects, white lies), and stresses that these vows are meant as helpful guidance rather than rigid rules. Suitable for beginners in Buddhist practice or those exploring the foundational teachings.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2014 09 16 DB Refuge in the Three jewels Week 6 16092014.mp3
UUID: 383a2395-b212-4755-808d-c085c54d7b3a
Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub
Collection: DB Refuge in the Three Jewels (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Date: 2014-09-16
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 83.3 minutes
Words: ~9,281
Good evening, everyone. Welcome to our last, sixth and last, talk, class on the Three Jewels of refuge. As you all know, there are three reasons for taking refuge or three levels of motivation for taking refuge, I should say. So the first one is to be free of the suffering, to avoid the suffering of a bad rebirth. Stronger level of motivation that we can develop, eventually develop, is to take refuge in order to be free of all suffering so that we can achieve the the blissful state of nirvana and the the deepest high deepest highest, greatest level of strongest level of motivation, the most profound is to take refuge in order to achieve enlightenment for the sake of others.
So since this course is taught from the Mahāyāna point of view, then in studying this topic, we can try and study it with that motivation, the bodhicitta motivation. Especially for those people who have a serious interest in following or beginning to follow the Buddhist teachings, then we can study this subject with the bodhicitta motivation wishing to realize the full potential of our mind in order to be in the best position, the perfect position to perfectly benefit others, to perfectly repay their kindness that we have received life after life in so many different ways. And we we repay that kindness by helping all these kind beings to be free of all suffering and all causes of suffering and helping them to achieve peerless, everlasting happiness. So to do that, to achieve that state so that we can be of lasting continuous benefit to others, we have to follow the path that leads to enlightenment. And to be able to follow the path, then we need that depends on understanding the path properly, and that depends on studying the teachings.
And the very entrance to the path to enlightenment or the very entrance to all Buddhist practice is developing refuge in the triple gem of Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. So for this reason, we can study this subject. So with that thought in mind, if you wish to do so, feel comfortable, then we can do the prayer of refuge in bodhicitta, which is on page eleven. And as we do do this, it’s helpful to visualize the Buddha in front of us as the very embodiment of all the Three Jewels of refuge, the thinking of Śākyamūni Buddha representing all Buddhas, all the Dharma, all the Sangha. At the same time, so we think of the Buddha appearing in front of us to remind us of our own Buddha potential and appearing there to encourage us to realize that potential not only for our own sake but for the sake of others.
And then we can motivate ourselves strongly to do so by thinking of all sentient beings surrounding us, at the very least those that we are connected to in this life, good and bad. So our parents on either side, family, friends, and helpers behind us, those who harm us in front. So at least thinking of that group of people, but as much as possible, in addition, trying to open our hearts and minds to an awareness and concern for all other sentient beings. So at the very least, we can think of the human beings of this world. But if one has some belief in the Buddhist teachings and the existence of other sentient beings, then we can think of the other beings in cyclic existence such as the beings trapped in the hungry ghost realms, in the hell realms, in the god realms, and in the intermediate or Bardo state.
So think in order to help benefit all these beings, I will study this subject of refuge. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, Dharma, and the supreme assembly. By the merits I create through listening to the Dharma, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings. So then we can imagine the Buddha being pleased with our motivation, showing this by coming to the crown of our head. And when directly above our crown, we imagine that the Buddha dissolves into blissful golden light.
And that light then pours down into us, blessing our mind. So then just briefly, we can enhance that positive state of mind by doing the nine round breathing exercise just for a short time, helping enabling our mind to become just a little bit more calm, clear, more concentrated so that we can use that level of mind to listen to and think about the Buddhist teachings tonight. K. Thank you. According to our schedule, the things I need to talk about still in this last class are causal and resultant refuge, the measure of having taken refuge, and the five lay vows, and also an introduction to the preliminary practice of refuge.
That last one I’m going to leave out because that is very, very much specifically a practice for committed Buddhists, and not everyone here is of that persuasion. So I will leave that one out. I I would like to talk about it sometime maybe in a Thursday night class, how to do the preliminary practice of refuge because it’s a very, very nice practice to do, very simp quite simple practice to do for people who are committed Buddhists. So anyway, So just very quickly, to bore you with repeating everything I’ve said before.
What is refuge? Refuge is a state of mind that we develop where we recognise that we have a mind, that our mind is the source of all our experience, the more we understand that or have some faith in that, we realize that we have to take care of our mind. So refuge is committing to taking care of one’s mind as continuously as much as possible and realizing that one needs a method to do so and one needs a complete method, not a partial incomplete method. We need a complete method. We need a perfect method, an unmistaken method.
A method that will never betray us. And such a one can argue that such a method such a perfect method, of course, can only come from a perfect source. And from a Buddhist point of view, the only perfect source is the enlightened mind because that mind is free of all faults, has eliminated all faults in such a way that they’ll never return, has awakened all positive qualities in such a way that they will never decline. So refuge is that commitment to take care of the mind relying solely on the Buddha’s methods because they come from that perfect mind. So something not coming from a perfect mind itself cannot be perfect.
There are many good ideas in the world coming from many good, very intelligent, wonderful people. But are they perfect people? Are they are are their minds totally free of all confusion? Are there have have they awakened every positive quality? If not, the ideas that they have, no matter how brilliant, can’t be perfect.
An imperfect being can’t produce something perfect. I don’t think. Yeah. Only a perfect being can produce something perfect. Right.
It’s very good to think of all the benefits of taking refuge so this board could inspire us to take refuge. Really, seems to me it all comes down once again to understanding whether we’ve got a mind or not, whether we come to the belief that we have a mind and really understanding what is implied by the mind from a Buddhist point of view. Because from the scientific point of view, the mind is just the brain or a byproduct of the brain, something quite limited. Although, apparently some experiment has just been done recently. I can’t remember where.
I think it was Americans did an experiment whereby I didn’t read the details. Should have never got I just looked at the headlines about somehow they managed to use someone’s brain to send a message to the brain of someone else in France. Yes. But, of course, that was the mind, not really the brain. But, anyway, we want to argue that point.
Yes. You see? Interesting. It was on Google News. Anyway, so if you Google it.
Yeah, yes. Right. No. Where am I? Anyway, yes, if one starts to see the potential of one’s mind, then one one can develop the, I think, the faith that Buddha Buddha mind exists.
And if Buddha mind exists then we have Buddha potential. And how do we awaken that Buddha potential by relying on the Buddha because that’s someone who’s realized their Buddha potential. So it kind of goes back and forth, these two things. But how one develops faith is really by understanding the qualities. Many people think faith is something completely stupid and irrational and there’s blind faith.
But from a Buddhist point of view, faith is something that arises from knowing the quality of something. Just like I always say, if you go shopping and you check the quality, if you want to buy something, if you want to buy a fruit blender, what do you call them? Chuso. Yeah? You check out all the different ones, especially if they’re all basically the same price.
And if you’re smart, you check out the qualities of the different ones, the machines. This one’s really plastic and shaky, not very reliable, not very good quality. This one is much more solid. Turn it on and the machine sounds better, you know, and if you were if you were really smart, you could, you know, pull it apart and check the engine and see what, you know, you check if you can put it back before the shop. Choice magazine who checked these things out.
Yeah, you develop faith that this brand makes good stuff. You develop faith in this product because you have some experience of the quality of it. And that’s what you do within the Dharma. You check the qualities of the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Sangha, and especially the Dharma. It’s different, you know.
One can have an abstract understanding of the qualities of the Buddha, but one can check the qualities of the Dharma, the teachings. But that takes some time by studying them. Yeah. Especially checking the qualities of the the teachings of the Buddha on compassion. These wonderful teachings on compassion and patience.
How to be patient with everyone and everything. No no justification. There’s a lot of people telling us it’s very good to get angry, but the Buddha says it’s never good to get angry. It’s a total disaster. Wonderful teaching.
Check the qualities of that, and then check the qualities of the teachings on the nature of reality. They will blow your mind. Then you think, where did they come from? Yeah. Where did they come from?
What kind of mind produced this? Yeah. And then then by doing that, one one’s faith can can develop knowing the qualities. And by but but especially by trying to put them into practice. Yeah.
Practicing these things. Even from the simplest thing like doing water bowls or doing circumambulations or all sorts of things or oh, circum going around stupas. Going around circumambulating stupas, holy images that symbolize the the mind of the Buddha. Even one of one of the most basic the most basic practice is before you meditate, there are six preliminary practices. The first of which is cleaning your room, sweeping the room.
Making it nice and clean. Just experiment doing that. Does it have any effect on your mind? Of course it has an effect on the carpet but does it have an effect on your mind? Maybe not.
Maybe. Oh, no. That’s another topic. That’s huge. Oh, I’m never going to get to the topic.
Yeah, one has to get a taste, one has to allow oneself, especially if you’re discovering Buddhism, this course is about discovering Buddhism, something we don’t really know about. Even some of us who have been doing this for a long time, we are really only just starting to discover the Buddha Dharma, which is about discovering our mind. It’s a very big, very interesting, huge project job discovering the mind, discovering the Dharma. So it’s really worthwhile experimenting with these things, especially the things you don’t want to do. When I first met the Dharma, I don’t think I should say brought up because it wasn’t anything conscious, but I born into a non religious family and I can sorry.
Sounds pretty pompous. But I was the only person in my family who went to university, so I thought I was pretty clever, smart aleck, intellectual kind of person, not interested in all this religious nonsense. And then, by accident, I met the Buddhadharma and by accident I kind of started to believe in it. It was very strange. I never went looking for it.
I was never interested in religion, future lives, meditation. I wasn’t interested in any of all that rubbish. But I fell into it. All my friends were not no. Now my friends were people who were always interested in these things.
Other monks and nuns. I was about one of the only ones who wasn’t interested in any of these things. And then suddenly I met the Dharma and had a great effect on my life. So my mind sort of did a kind of a like a radical change overnight practically. And so one of the things I used to do is I would just offer, and I still do, I offer incense to pictures of the Buddha because it’s so, you know, irrational.
No intellectual smart aleck who reads books would offer wave incense in front of pictures of Buddha thinking this is going to have any benefit. But I like doing it. And I went around telling people I don’t recommend this at all in general, but the reason I went around doing it because it was so embarrassing to have to admit I was religious to people who were not at all. It’s very good for the mind. I don’t know if I’ve told you this before.
I’ve told other people and I do mention these things many, many times. I sit up here and some people think I’m a great Buddhist and maybe you don’t. Some people make the mistake of thinking I’m an amazing Dharma practitioner and have all sorts of realizations and experiences. I have none of this. But one of the purest Dharma practice and probably the only Dharma practice I’ve ever done in my life is at the very beginning when I went to this Buddhist center, was trying to rescue someone from being a Buddhist, but they didn’t want to be rescued so I stayed because I didn’t have anywhere else to go.
You had to attain enlightenment meditation, so I attended not because I want to, because you had to. And but I then started to kind of enjoy them. I don’t know if I enjoyed them, but I found some benefit in them. But also all these strange people used to prostrate at the beginning, which I absolutely refused to do. There was no way I was going to do this ridiculous practice.
And then at the very end of my stay there, I decided that I had to try this because this is just my ego. So I did it. I was standing at the back of everyone. I always was so I made sure no one could see me doing this ridiculous practice. And it was very difficult for me to do it because I had this huge ego and it was a great thing.
But I did it. And I I although I can’t say I had some kind of major revelation immediately, from my from my looking back from my experience, I think it was that moment where my mind completely changed Because it really I I really it it was, you know, it was not something easy to now you just prostrate and you don’t think about it. But then it was it was it really was a very, very difficult thing to do. To put my body on the floor and admit at the same time that I didn’t know what was going on. I did not understand the universe myself or anything.
But maybe there was someone up there, out there, maybe this enlightened mind did with all these wonderful qualities. So maybe you could, you know, say hello to them, prostrate, recognize that, say I’m just a little twerp. You know? So that completely changed my life completely. So it’s really worth experimenting to get what Lama Yeshe calls the taste of the Dharma because the Dharma does does have a taste and it is delicious.
It is a very, very nice taste when when you when you do it. Yeah. Thirty. I was thirty. Yeah.
Yeah. So now I’ve taken up all the time and haven’t got. So the topic is well, firstly, measure of having taken refuge. The measure of taking refuge. So this is divided up into talking about the measure of having taken refuge is firstly knowing the good qualities of the Buddha, Dharman, Sangha.
So I have actually talked about that before, I won’t go into that anymore. As someone pointed out, and it’s completely true, unfortunately I didn’t talk much about the good qualities of the Dharma and Sangha, but what I did try to say is that the more one understands the good qualities of the Buddha, you can know by logic the good qualities of the Dharma because the Dharma, the teachings, are a reflection of all those good qualities and they show us they have these unmistaken methods to achieve the qualities that enable us to achieve the qualities of the Buddha. And the Sangha are those people, the the actual Sangha jewel, are those people who are genuinely practicing the Dharma, not sort of fluffing around with it, but are deeply committed to it, actually practicing it wholeheartedly and getting the taste of the Dharma. Remember technically the the actual Sangha jewel is any person ordained or not ordained who has experienced their their own true nature. Sorry.
So those people live a life of natural purity. They are naturally virtuous people. Well, they’ve achieved this state of being spontaneously pure in their behavior. They’ve realized emptiness. They have subdued minds.
These are the main qualities of the Sangha, the actual Sangha jewel. They are people who are living a life of pure morality. They are they have subdued their minds. They have directly perceived the nature of reality. So these are pretty good qualities that we can rely on.
And they are committed to following the path. They’re not people who have half heartedly committed. They are a hundred percent on the path to enlighten ment or at least to liberation. The, you know, the Mahāyāna Sangha are on the path to enlightenment. So so one of the measures of having taken refuge is in one’s heart is is knowing these qualities because the more we know the qualities of the Buddha, the Dharma, the Sangha, we will have faith in the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha.
And our refu that we will that means we will have some genuine refuge. And, of course, like many things, ref there’s many levels of refuge. You know, we you know, I talked about the three levels of motivation, but even within each of those levels, the you know, one’s refuge can deepen, you know, with with practice. The more we the more we know the teachings, the more we understand the teachings, the more we practice the teachings, our refuge in them will increase. And therefore, our refuge in the Buddha will increase.
And that will encourage us to practice more and therefore so it can constantly snowball. So another aspect of the measure of having taken refuge is knowing the differences between the Three Jewels of refuge. So I’d just like to talk a little bit about that. Yes. If you want to know all the details about this topic, you could look at Pabongka Rinpoche’s book, Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand.
And in there, there’s a section on refuge. And in that in that, there’s the this section of knowing the differences between the Three Jewels of refuge. Refuge. So one difference is, as I mentioned last week, seeing the Buddha is like the doctor, the perfect doctor, the Dharma is the medicine, and the Sangha is like the nurse. So when we take refuge, in a sense, it’s like admitting that we are a patient.
Yeah? We we realize that we have this sickness, which is in fact the worst sickness in the world. All of us have a fear of getting physical sickness of like having heart disease or cancer or something like that. We’d also be very unhappy about having some kind of mental disease like severe depression or schizophrenia or something like that. But all of these physical and mental diseases are symptoms of a much deeper disease that everyone has, which is the disease of ignorance.
Because of the disease of ignorance, we have other disturbing thoughts. We follow those, engage in negative actions, and that result one of the some of the results of engaging in those actions is having physical and mental ill health. But all of those physical and mental problems are just temporary whereas ignorance, the disease of ignorance, is something that goes on life after life after life if we don’t do anything about it. So it’s it’s really gruesome, much worse than Ebola or anything like that. If we think of these little these are actually nothing compared to this disease we have.
Fear getting cancer but we’ve already got something far worse. Far, far worse. That’s one word. There I go again, Trish. Sorry.
Not the jolly presentation. But the jolly thing is we’ve met well, maybe we’ve met the perfect doctor, the Buddha, the perfect medicine, the Dharma, and the perfect nurses, the Sangha. So that’s the good news. That’s the jolly thing. That’s the opt the good way of looking at it.
Just a minute. I have to find my notes. Sorry. Okay. So other other ways of looking at the differences between the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha is that the Buddha functions to transmit the Dharma effectively.
The Dharma itself is aimed at eliminating the afflictions. I mean, there there are many ways of defining what the Dharma is, and And one way of defining the Dharma is that it anything that directly or indirectly overcome, pacifies or eliminates our delusions. Any practice that directly or indirectly subdues or eliminates helps to eliminate our delusions, our afflictions. That’s what Dharma practice is because that’s what the whole thing is about, getting rid of our afflictions. So there are two levels of afflictions, the afflictions to liberation and the afflictions or the obscurations to liberation, and then there are the obscurations to enlightenment.
So anything that helps reduce those or get rid of them, that is Dharma. That and that is Dharma practice. So the Buddha transmits that that that Dharma teaching of how to do that. The the Dharma is is is is what actually does it. And then the Sangha, they inspire us and energize us to to in to engage in this practice.
Okay. There’s lots of other details on that, but maybe that’s that’s a couple of ways to know the differences between Three Jewels. Or or maybe just another one very quickly. One can think of the Buddha as a boatman, so respect him as the one who saves us. He’s he’s rowing the boat that is going to take us across the ocean of saṃsāra.
The Dharma is the the actual boat that is going to take us across the ocean of of suffering. So we need to use it. We need to use this boat. And the sangha are companions escaping in the lifeboat. So we should join them.
They’re already in the lifeboat. They’re already in this boat. They’re encouraging us to jump in, so we should. They’ll help us get in the boat. Right.
So then another the third aspect of the measure of having taken refuge refuge is simply accepting Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. Really accepting the Buddha as as one’s refuge, the Dharma as the what to practice, and accepting the Sangha as one’s spiritual guides. Really coming to the conclusion at some point that, yes, I I trust the Buddha. I trust the Dharma. I trust the Sangha.
Just you in one’s heart, one accepts the Three Jewels of refuge completely or tries to. You know, one can debate all sorts of things in one’s mind about this, that, and the other. I know quite a few people here in this course have written things in their homework saying that they find some of this course quite overwhelming and difficult to accept. But what can I say? Again, I see, the thing that brought me to the Dharma was the mind.
I always go back to that. Everything in the buddhadharma is a and and like the subject of refuge and all the the mind blowing aspects of it are all implications of understanding that the there is we have mind. That is not the brain. That is something formless. That is just arising moment by moment.
And that moment by moment arising produces all of this. All of this is coming from our mind, depends on our mind. So what our mind is doing now is just truly mind boggling. Yeah. And that’s an obscured mind.
And I think we can all tell to some extent that we’ve got obscured minds. Right? I think we I I remember when I was a little kid, I always, you know, used to think there was something like this this sort of dark thing on my head, you know, weighing me down, stopping me, you know, expressing what I really was. I think, well, temporarily, when I did those prostrations, some of that went away. And my mind went, But even when I first met the Buddhadharma and they said, you’ve got a mind, I thought, oh, wow.
Yes. I’ve always believed that, but I never thought what it really implied. But then one got this sense of this vast mind that’s just limitless. You know, your mind, if it’s nonphysical, it’s not just it’s not just up there. It’s it’s everywhere.
Potentially, it’s everywhere. And when it’s not obscured, like, that’s what a omniscient mind is. It’s everywhere. It’s here. It’s all knowing.
Oh. See, Buddhas don’t do stuff like this. They never make any mistakes. One of the differences between an arhat and a Buddha is that an arhat, when he sees a monkey, might make just uncontrollable monkey sounds. You know how when when we go to the zoo and we can say, we make animal noises and things.
So even an our heart will do that. Just sort of a bit out of control. But Buddha never does that. The Buddha’s mind is one hundred percent totally subdued. Oh, for purposes.
Not accidentally. See, misjudgment, not paying attention. The Buddha doesn’t misjudge anything or pay attention. Anyway, where am I? I’m just raving.
Yes. Yes. Accepting. Accepting. Yeah.
What I’m trying to say is that the point I’m trying to get to is that sometimes we use our intelligence in self destructive ways. You know, you one can get, like, some basic thing and yet the mind won’t doesn’t want to accept it. It goes around and around and gives up all these very complicated, very impressive, ridiculous arguments for just getting on with it. With something that’s basically quite simple, you know, in my opinion. Sorry.
But I’m you know? Oh, yes. Yes. We do. Somewhere.
But start. Yeah. There’s lots of things. It’s very, very, very difficult to understand and seem contradictory, but have to focus on the main things, the main things that grab you. So then the final measure of having taken refuge in the triple gem is that one really does rely completely solely on the Buddha, the Buddha’s teachings, and the Buddha Sangha, not on founders of other religions, other philosophies.
One doesn’t have to take refuge, but if one does, what it means is one doesn’t rely, one doesn’t trust put one’s trust in non Buddhas. It doesn’t mean one denigrates them and puts them down and criticizes, etcetera, etcetera. Actually, it’s very important that as a Buddhist to respect all religions because all religions are beneficial for people. And if you according to in in in the in India, in the they talk about Hinduism as though though it’s one religion, but actually, I I I don’t think Hinduism was one religion. There’s many many many different religions in India.
But anyway, a lot a lot of Hindus make the argument that because they try to be inclusive. So they say that actually Buddhism is a form of Hinduism but it’s a form of Hinduism for really degenerate people who don’t really understand the higher teachings. So that’s a little bit condescending from a Buddhist point of view. But so but and from a Buddhist point of view, and this could sound condescending or insulting to people of other religions, one could argue that because the Buddha, know, this perfect being who wants to free everyone from every kind of suffering, and even within the Buddhist tradition, the Buddha teaches different things. One could argue that the Buddha, the enlightened mind, has manifested as Christ, as Mohammed, and all other religious teachers because that system of teachings fits particular kinds of people.
And it’s just a skillful means to eventually lead people to becoming Buddhists. But one could argue that. Well, yes, everything is very politically incorrect. Yeah. Yes.
Yeah. Yeah. But it could be seen as very insulting to some people, and I accept that. Yeah. But like within Buddhism, the Buddha taught the path to nirvana then but also the path to enlightenment.
So it’s a different path. And within within the teachings on the path to enlightenment, there’s the slow way, and then there’s the fast tantric way. So there was kind of these three systems that the Buddha taught within Buddhism. And if you compare, like, Theravāda Buddhism with tantric Buddhism, they they are like, at at one level, chalk and cheese. They are so completely different in appearance.
But actually, from the Tibetan point of view, these all come from the Buddha. So one could argue that all all other religions, all other philosophies, even the ones most contradictory to Buddhism came from the Buddha. Yes. Yeah. Sorry?
But by that, I’m not saying all of the religions are the same lead to the same point. They are you know, some are quite different because, of course, some religions say it’s perfectly okay to kill at least animals and stuff. This is, you know but in according to the Buddha, not at all. Anyway so, anyway, what I’m trying to say is, you know, we don’t we don’t have to take refuge. We don’t have to follow the Buddha’s teachings.
Even if we want to follow the teachings, we may not want to follow them all. We may want to just sort of use whatever we like. But if one takes refuge, that has a particular meaning and purpose. And that is, I’m saying, someone who takes refuge and you take it voluntarily is you’re saying, I have complete trust in the Buddha and the Dharma, and the Sangha. That’s it.
I don’t follow others. I can admire them, respect them, appreciate the teachings that are the same as the Buddha, but the ones that are different, I don’t place you know, put refu take refuge in them. I take refuge in what the Buddha taught. So when we have think like that, that’s that’s the measure of having taken refuge in the triple gem. So just very briefly, to cover everything still left, they talk about causal and resultant refuge.
So basically all this is meaning is that causal refuge refers to the external Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. We rely on them. They are the causes for us to work with our mind to practice. And so the resultant refuge is actually being having that determination to take care of the mind using the Buddha’s methods. That is the resultant or one aspect of the resultant refuge.
And but by having that, by practicing the Buddha’s teachings, our mind step by step, it gets transformed. Our mind becomes the Dharma. We gain the these these various realizations, authentic realizations, and eventually, we we will we will ourselves become Sangha, and then we become a, you know, a a refuge to ourselves. We won’t rely we won’t need to rely on the external refuge. We will have the you know, this authentic experience ourself.
But to to reach that point, we have to rely on the external Buddha, Dharma, Sangha. Even to even to know that we’ve to really develop a a proper understanding that we have a mind and what it is, one one relies on the Buddha’s teachings for that. And then how to develop the mind, one relies on the Buddha’s teachings. So we have all these qualities within us. Of the things that Lama Yeshe, the founder of this organization that Buddha House is a member of, one of the things he emphasized so much in his teachings in a few year very few years actually that that he was with us teaching around the world was how we can rely on our own wisdom.
Yeah. But, I mean, one shouldn’t take that too concretely because our own ideas can be very misleading leading and egocentric, etcetera. But the Lama emphasized we all have this potential for wisdom within us. And if we rely on the Buddha’s teachings, which is a wise thing to do in itself, but by relying on the teachings, that inner wisdom can be awakened and developed more and more. And that’s what we should do.
So that’s what he emphasized, that there there is this wisdom within us. Deciding to take care of our mind, that itself is a very wise thing to do. Yes. Yes. You become an inner being.
Yeah. That’s the benefit of taking refuge. You become an inner being. Yeah. You recognize that everything is coming from your mind or you start to understand that or accept it.
Yeah. Okay. So when do we finish? Before the break? When’s the break?
You’re bell ringer? Oh, okay. Ten minutes. Alright. Final topic are the five lay vows.
So I mentioned last week that one of the benefits of taking refuge is that it is the basis for being able to take vows because vows, at least certainly from a Buddhist point of view, vows work by understanding and believing in the law of cause and effect. That there are actions, there are behaviors of body, speech, and mind which are naturally negative. Whether a person knows an action is good or bad, there are things which are naturally good or bad because of the way they affect the mind. So whether one knows this or not doesn’t change things. If you know if you kill thinking it’s okay, it’s still naturally negative and it’s going to have a suffering result.
Alright? It’s not just Buddhists who create negative karma because only Buddhists believe in karma. Whether you believe in it or not, it works. So there are things that which are naturally negative. And this is what the Buddha has pointed out.
What what are the actions that are naturally negative? So the more we believe this, understand it, accept it, then we see how important it is to avoid these negative actions and taking vows. So the more we believe in the law of cause and effect, the more we will try to avoid these these negative behaviors. And so on that basis, vows really work because we we want we want to avoid negative actions. So taking a vow forces us to be more mindful of what we think, what we say, and what we do.
Yeah. More more aware of the negative things we think, what we say, and the negative things we do because we’ve taken a vow to avoid certain negative things, specific negative actions. So by having that vow, if we take if we really believe in the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Sangha, then we we see how important it is to avoid these things. Taking the vow helps us, and it helps us by forcing us to be more mindful. So by being more mindful, we can avoid these actions more and more.
So it’s incredibly helpful. So there are five lay, what are called the pratimoksha vows. Prātimokṣa is a Sanskrit word which means individual liberation. Prati is individual. Mokśa is means liberation.
nirvana. So the the the pratimoksha vows are the basis of achieving freedom from suffering. The more vows one has, which means the more commitment to avoid negative actions, the more one is creating the cause to achieve freedom from suffering. Yeah. So they’re they’re a fundamental practice.
And hopefully everyone knows by now there are four schools in Tibetan Buddhism. We follow the Gelugpa school, which is the most recent of the four schools that developed in Tibet, started by Lama Tsongkhapa in the fourteenth century. And our school, the Gelugpa school, literally means the virtuous tradition because Je Tsongkhapa emphasized that the whole basis of the spiritual path is living a life of ethical discipline, observing the law of cause and effect. That if one wants to get a good rebirth, one has to do that. If one wants to get, out of saṃsāra, one has to do that.
And if one wants to achieve enlightenment, one has to have take the bodhisattva vows. And even if one wants to follow the quick path of tantra, even more one has to live a virtuous life. Some people you know, there’s a lot of misunderstanding about tantra because it has some very unusual aspects. And some people think because of that and because it’s the most advanced path that, you know, when you practice tantra you don’t have to worry too much about the law of cause and effect and living a moral life because it’s a very special kind of practice. But actually proper tantra, as it’s correctly taught in the tradition, you have to observe karma even more carefully and observe the tantric vows very carefully.
So, anyway, the pratimoksha vows, you one can take these on the basis of having refuge, and they’re they’re extremely helpful for us as beginners in the practice. So the the five lay vows are the the the vow of not killing any sentient being, not just human beings, but any kind of sentient being, avoiding stealing any object of value, belong anything belonging to anyone else. Because it may be something very small, but people can value that object. You know? It may it may even be a pebble, but it may have some great sentimental value to someone.
And if you steal it, it causes that person a lot of suffering. Yeah? Beings. Well, it’s more difficult to steal from many of them. Yes.
Yes. That’s true. That’s true. Yeah. Killing, stealing, lying, avoid yeah.
So there’s the vow of avoiding lying. And the worst kinds of lies are spiritual lies where you claim to have qualities that you know you don’t. And lying can be done you know, lying normally refers to speech, but lying can also be done by not speaking, you know, or just kind of give doing some bodily gesture or a little wink to sort of like someone says, oh, I think you’re highly realized, aren’t you? And you you don’t say anything, but you just give a kind of little bodily movement or wink to that is designed to you want that person to believe that you are. Right?
And if they do, that becomes lying and it becomes the worst kind of lying. You know, there are people who think they’re real. They are totally unrealized, but they honestly think they are. So if they go around saying, I highly realized, that’s not actually lying. It’s just being totally deluded.
Lying is where you know you don’t have a spiritual quality, but you want people to believe you do. So that is the worst kind. Yeah. And then there is what? Sexual misconduct?
Avoiding sexual misconduct? That is a very complicated, tricky subject. I don’t want to go into too much. Yeah, but. Yes, but I I think this.
What is sexual conduct? Well, you need to know. I mean, I just did this there’s not much time now. Yeah. You it is good to know all of these things But in the case of killing the spider, I think this is an example where this is a what if.
It’s a what if. I don’t think it’s a very good well, I don’t think it’s necessarily a very good justification to avoid doing something really positive because of one what if. And even if you do end up well, I don’t well, even if in some cases you do, like, kill insects, by having the vow, it will help you avoid killing many other things. Whereas if you don’t have the vow, there is nothing stopping you killing things all the time. Not that people do that, but like in case of insects.
What? Yes, of course you’re creating the yeah. Yes. Well, you’re trying you’re doing that vow to help you not do things. Well, they are intended for you to stop them completely.
No. No. You’re making a very good point. Sorry. I will do things for.
And I Well, if if you know you will no. That’s different. If you know I’m a girl that takes spiders out of the bathroom when I have a shower. Whether I did this or not, I always have. That’s very good.
Terrific. And I try not to lie. I’m just saying, I’m human, and I’m Yes. Yes. Here to make vows that I might break.
Well, there’s one there’s a difference between things that you might do. If if you know you’re definitely going to do it, then you shouldn’t take a vow. But if you only think, well, I might break it, then this this is not such a good justification. Yes. But well, I personally would argue that that is not lying.
I mean, in the teachings it says it is, that you should never even say in fact, they say you shouldn’t even make jokes, which are, you know yeah. But and I can see the point for that. But, again, it seems to no. Anyway, this is very accurate. This is just my own thing.
It seems to me all of negative karma, every kind from the small it’s it’s all about it’s it’s all coming from ignorance, the wrong view of self, and like the ten non virtues, one of which is killing, but all of the others are also about self-cherishing and ego aggrandizement. The main reason to lie as a negative thing is you you one is trying to get some benefit for oneself and and harm others. When someone says, oh, you know, I’ve you know, isn’t this the most I’ve just got this new dress. Isn’t it beautiful? Don’t I look wonderful?
And you think they look really awful. Again, I do not think it is compassionate to say I think you look really ugly. This is maybe honest, but I think in those cases, I personally think it is perfectly okay to say you look okay. You don’t have to go over the top and say I think you look like the most beautiful person in the world. If if you’re if you’re doing it if you’re doing it you know, you know, what’s the word to curry favor with this person, that’s different.
But you you do it purely because you don’t want to upset them. It’s just for that. I I think there’s personally, there there is minimal harm in that. Minimal. Minimal.
You know? So to avoid taking a vow that can help you take care of your mind to avoid bigger lies is, I think, ridiculous. Good. But, I mean, this is only my opinion in the teachings they give. I mean, the the example they give is if if someone’s fleeing from their lives, there are three men chasing another man to kill him, and you see the man running away, and then the killers come up and say, where did the man go?
And the the lamas say, you don’t tell him. You can’t you can’t lie, so you change the subject and say, isn’t it nice day? This is pathetic. No one’s ever had the courage to say to the Lamas, but I’m sorry. This is totally pathetic.
Especially in these days, three killers aren’t going to be, you know, tricked tricked by you changing the subject. They’ll start torturing you until you tell the truth. So I’m sorry. You know? There I go.
Don’t go to hell for that probably, criticizing the Lamas and the Dhamma. But, you know yes. That’s what yes. It’s that’s what I’m trying to say. And and all negative karma has this ego motivation that you are trying to get something and you don’t care.
Either you’re it it involves knowing you’re harming someone or you don’t care if it harms another person. You just want, you know yeah. So when you when you avoid saying you know, or, know, someone cooks you a meal and it tastes absolutely disgusting, you know, you don’t say, oh, this is the most disgusting thing I’ve ever you’re a really lousy cook. You eat it and say, oh, this is interesting. Know?
Right. Yeah. It’s just what’s you know, it’s it’s just sort of common sense. Yeah. Oh, yeah.
And also yeah. Anyway. It’s good. Life before you had nothing to do with this, but I just wondered in terms of Well, I mean, this is my opinion. I mean, I I’m not the the Buddha.
So but this is how, you know, But all of this shouldn’t be seen too concretely. All these teachings are guidelines. There’s many subtleties and change. Yeah. Yes.
Yes. Yes. There’s two. There’s it’s natural. There’s just quickly, you know, people for example, if if if you don’t know or believe killing is negative but you kill, it is creating a certain level of karma.
As soon as you become a Buddhist and you take refuge and you accept well, not even before that. You you believe that killing is negative and you’re doing it. It’s worse. Yeah? It’s worse.
If you then have take refuge, it’s worse. And then if you have the vow, you take the vow not to kill, it’s even worse. And then, of course, if you take the bodhisattva vows on top of that, it’s even worse. And if you have the tantric vows, it’s just unbelievably nightmare worse. Yes.
There’s also yes. You can purify. Yes. Yes. But what yeah.
Yes, yes, yes, this is all guidance to help us. Yes. Yes, of course. No. No.
No. No. Please don’t outcome the bleach. No. They’re not doing anything.
There’s also a mantra you can say. They’re they’re okay. They’re not gonna do anything. Don’t have labels for that. Oh, we’re falling apart here, folks.
Sorry. Just in conclusion, fifth lay vow is avoiding intoxicants of alcohol and other drugs, mind altering drugs and also cigarettes should be included there. Bad for the mind, bad for your health. Yes. You can.
Go. So these are considered the basic if you if one wants to follow the Buddha’s path teaching, then these are the basic ones. Even if you don’t actually take the vow, one should try living according to those guidelines of avoiding killing, stealing, sexual misconduct, lying, and and intoxicants. And, actually, just to freak you out, of all of those five, probably the most important one is avoiding intoxicants. Because what is Buddhadharma about?
It is about taking care of your mind. Yeah. And trying to subdue the mind, develop some control of the mind. Well, there are of course, but you know yeah. Yeah.
Actually, in one of the sutras it says, anyone who takes even one drop of alcohol is not a follower of me, the Buddha said. Don’t go into it, don’t want to know all the details. These are guidelines, know. You don’t have to take the vow but yeah. And there’s there’s versions of it as well.
Some lamas say you can take the vow where you commit not to get intoxicated. You know, you can drink up to the point of not getting intoxicated. Before you start to get start to, you should stop. So that’s better than yeah. So there’s things like that.
No. So you can take any one of them. So there is a ceremony where you on the basis of firstly having taken refuge, you can take all five. If you don’t or you can take four or three or two or one. And then at another if you just take one at another time, you could you could take all the the other four or three more or two more or just one more.
Some very cautious person could take five ceremonies to to get all four. Some people never take any of them. But these are the five lay precepts which are really basic guidelines in our life. Yeah. Yes.
Quickly. Yeah. The ants. The green is killing. Yes.
Yeah. Killing an ant is not the same as killing a human being. That’s for sure. Yes. Yes.
But it but, no, it doesn’t mean not killing any sentient being. You you take the vow to avoid killing any sentient being. You don’t have to do that. You can do that. Yes.
So you well, you just well, you just most most mosquitoes aren’t dangerous. Most. You know, there’s so many endless things, you know, of little, you know, this is this is an example of what I was saying of how you get all this end Well, that’s fine. Okay. Good.
But, yeah, there’s so many details that you don’t know. Yeah. Yes. So Yeah. It’s make it’s it’s to make you more aware and yeah.
Please help me. Because I think I have finished. You can discuss afterwards. Anyway, if I can just read this, please. It says, in summary, the great master Tsongkhapa has said in his abbreviated points on the graded paths of the mind, After death, there is no assurance that you will not be reborn in one of the worst states of wandering rebirth. Yeah.
We we just can’t say whether we will or not. We can’t. Yeah. There’s no assurance that that won’t happen. Nevertheless, it is certain that the three rare supreme gems of Buddhadharma Sangha can provide you a safe direction out of your dread of this fate.
For these reasons, be extremely steadfast in taking their safe direction, you know, the safe direction of the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha, and unrelenting in following their points for training. Your success in not falling or further in not falling into the lower realms will further depend upon your considering well which types of impulsive behavior are noble or dark, good or bad, and what are their results, and then living according to the sound judgment of what should be adopted or forsaken. I so this is Lama Tsongkhapa speaking. I, an integrated practitioner, have personally done just that. If you would also seek liberation, please cultivate yourself in the same way.
So now we will take a break and a cup of tea. So we’ve now finished the the topic, well, of refuge in the Triple Gem. So except for the retreat, is this coming Sunday. So it’ll be at starting at nine o’clock, finishing at three thirty. So I’d encourage people if they can to come along for that.
And if people do come, then we ask people to bring a plate or a bowl or a huge platter, what do you call those things, saucepan of food, vegetarian food. I don’t have a favorite. Something vegetarian to share with everyone. Yes. And then that will be it.
So the next course which will be starting at the very end of October, very end of October will be Transforming Problems. So this is a very interesting, useful, practical course. How to look at problems in a positive way in order to make them rather than something harmful to us, something beneficial especially in our spiritual practice. So then next year, remaining topics in the DB are the subject of an introduction to Tantra, also the subject of devotion to developing or relying on a spiritual master. And although it it was done when my fill in what’s his name?
Ian Coghlan came and talked on emptiness. I think he did it at quite an advanced level because he’s a very scholarly gentleman. I thought to do this topic again a basic way as it is meant to be for as an introduction to the topic. So even if you have done it with him, this is a very, very, very interesting profound subject that one needs to look into again and again and again. So I will do that as well next year.
And then we will start the whole thing again. But of course, yeah. There is many some some people here. There are topics that I haven’t done. Some people have already done them, but it doesn’t hurt really to do them again.
Or if you don’t wanna do Discovering Buddhism, then there’s Thursday nights and other things. Okay, thank you very much. So we can dedicate the positive energy that we’ve generated not only tonight but throughout the six weeks. May this become a cause for us to really awaken our Buddha potentials not only for our own benefit but especially for the benefit of all suffering mother sentient beings. If we can again do the dedications on page eleven.
Due to the merits of these virtuous actions, may I quickly attain the state of the Guru Buddha and lead all living beings without exception into that enlightened state. May the precious bodhicitta not yet born, arise and grow. May that born have no decline, but increase forevermore. Okay. So thank you very much.
Since this is the end of the course, the tradition is, according to the Tibetan lamas, not to prostrate at the end because that makes it sort of very final. So by not prostrating, it sort of becomes auspicious to meet again.
Key terms in this teaching
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- five lay vows panchashila (Skt); ge nyen gi dompa nga (Tib)
- The precepts taken by lay Buddhist practitioners for life: to abstain from killing, stealing, lying, sexual misconduct and taking intoxicants. LYWA
- Gelug
- The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
- inner being nangpa (Tib)
- Another term for a Buddhist, so called because the person has entered "inside" the teachings of the Buddha by taking heartfelt refuge in the Three Jewels... LYWA
- pratimoksha vows pratimokshasamvara (Skt); so thar gyi dompa (Tib)
- The various levels of individual liberation vows for lay and ordained, including the five lay vows, and the novice vows and full ordination that monks and nuns take. LYWA
- resultant refuge drabüi kyab (Tib)
- The potential of our own mind to achieve the absolute refuge, to become a buddha ourselves (resultant Buddha), to actualize the true path within our mental continuum (resultant Dharma) and to attain the state of an arya being (resultant Sangha). LYWA
- tantric vows sang ngag kyi dom pa (Tib)
- Vows taken by tantric practitioners. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.