2 h 35 min · 9,237 words · 2018 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 156-minute retreat morning session, Venerable Thubten Dondrub guides practitioners through the opening stages of Lam Rim practice, beginning with proper meditation posture and mind preparation, then moving into analytical meditation on precious human rebirth. He establishes motivation grounded in bodhicitta, the aspiration to benefit all beings, and works through why human rebirth is rare and meaningful—emphasizing freedoms from major obstacles and access to authentic Dharma. After addressing mortality and impermanence, he introduces the law of cause and effect as essential practice. Throughout, he balances detailed instructions on visualization, breath meditation, and mental cultivation with the underlying purpose: recognizing this rebirth as an optimum opportunity for practice. He concludes with a Q&A addressing purification methods, karma ripening, and the relationship between recognizing precious human rebirth and taking real advantage of it. Suited for those new to Tibetan Buddhism as well as more experienced practitioners seeking foundation work in the graduated path.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Presenting the path retreat am.mp3
UUID: 2bce8730-a9d6-4002-a103-a7755d49f869
Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub
Collection: DB Presenting the Path (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Date: 2018 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 155.7 minutes
Words: ~9,234
Really gain some mastery over our mind, begin to subdue our disturbing thoughts and create the space for our positive potentials to manifest and so that we can cultivate them more and more. So, and we start with some introductory traditional prayers and, yes, so then we take a three minute silent break, and in the second segment we do some analytical meditation on meditations which are related to the graduated path to enlightenment. So normally there is a sequence that is being followed, but because today there is a group retreat happening, that sequence is going to get all mixed up for this, so we’re going to go back and meditate on the precious human rebirth just very, very briefly this morning. And then at the end we dedicate the merit. So there are some traditional prayers, so if you’d like to join in those, these are on page two of the prayer book, so it’s good to have it open at that page.
So we begin by firstly sitting comfortably in the correct posture as much as possible. So whether you’re sitting on a cushion or on a chair, the main thing is to try to have the upper body really straight, the spine really straight, and one’s upper body positioned so that one’s not leaning forwards or backwards or to either side. And also to position the head correctly so that it’s not tilted down too much or lifted too high. So also one places the right hand on top of the left with the thumbs lightly touching, and your hands resting in your lap, so that your elbows are just and upper arms are just a little bit away from the sides of your body. So it’s okay to meditate with your eyes closed, but it’s much better to have them just a little bit open, directing your gaze just a short distance down in front of you without actively looking.
So then just briefly one can correct one’s or check one’s posture by moving one’s awareness from the crown of one’s head down through the full length of your body, just noting any points of tension. So then having prepared the body to meditate, it’s important to really prepare the mind, generating the right motivation. Also, recognising that it is our own mind that is the source of all our experiences of happiness and suffering. It is our mind that gives rise to our experience of our self, of our body, our body in this world. It’s all arising depending on our mind.
Every experience has a feeling of either pleasure or pain, happiness or suffering. The more we’re aware of that, it’s obvious that if we want less suffering in this life and future lives, if we want more peace and contentment and well-being in this and future lives, then we have to take care of our mind. And to do that we need a method which is perfect, complete, unbetraying. And such a perfect method can only come from a perfect source. This is why we take refuge in the enlightened mind of the Buddha, and the Buddha’s teachings, and the advanced practitioners of those teachings.
So this is the triple gem of the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. So, we visualise Śākyamūni Buddha, the historical Buddha, in front of us as the embodiment of the Three Jewels of refuge. We imagine the Buddha seated on a beautiful teaching throne. Above it is a lotus symbolic of renunciation. Above that, a sun disc symbolizing the wisdom that frees us from all ignorance and suffering, and above that a white moon disc symbolic of the mind of great compassion and bodhicitta.
And we imagine then the Buddha with a hollow body of golden light seated above the center of that moon disc. So we can be inspired by what the Buddha achieved, that mind free of all suffering, free of all faults, possessing all good qualities, And we can be motivated to achieve that not only by our own wish to be free of suffering, but by recognising that one’s own existence totally depends at all times, moment by moment, year after year, life after life, it depends directly and indirectly on all other living beings. We simply couldn’t exist without them. They have been immensely kind in the past, present, will be kind and helpful in the future. But all these kind beings are suffering, just like myself.
The vast majority of them have far more suffering at the moment than myself, with far less ability to do anything about their suffering. So try and generate that very strong compassionate thought that no matter what I must use this in all my future lives to free my mind of all limitations, awaken all positive qualities, achieve the enlightened state to be in a perfect position, to perfectly repay the kindness of sentient beings, helping them to be free of all suffering, helping them to achieve peerless everlasting happiness. So, I dedicate this practice as one part of the process of achieving that enlightened state. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, the Supreme Assembly. By the practice of giving and other perfections, may I become a Buddha to benefit all sentient beings.
I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, the Supreme Assembly. By my practice of giving and other perfections, may I become a Buddha to benefit all sentient beings. May all sentient beings have happiness and the causes of happiness. May all sentient beings be free from suffering and the causes of suffering. May all sentient beings be inseparable from the happiness that is free from suffering.
May all sentient beings abide in equanimity, free from attachment for friends and hatred for enemies. So then think that the Buddha’s extremely pleased with one’s motivation to benefit others, and the Buddha shows this by now coming to the crown of one’s head, and when directly above the crown of one’s head, Buddha turns facing the same direction as oneself. And for the rest of the session we can imagine that the Buddha remains above the crown of our head, creating a protective environment in which to meditate and continuously blessing our mind. It’s not necessary to continuously visualize the Buddha anymore, but just to have a sense that the Buddha is there. So having prepared our mind to meditate, we can now direct our mind to the object of meditation which is our breath.
So just become aware of your breath coming in, going out. Don’t change it in any way, but just simply let your mind rest in the experience of the breath coming in, just observing that as carefully, precisely as one can and then the breath going out. One can focus on the subtle sensation in and around the nostrils as the breath comes and goes. And one can also, if you find it helpful, to keep the mind focused, to count the breaths, so considering one in and out breath as one complete breath, trying to follow eleven or twenty one continuous breaths. But we have to be really mindful to be able to detect the different hindrances that arise.
On the one hand, the mind can tend to become dull and sleepy, or on the other hand, it gets agitated, distracted. So we have to be aware of those things and as soon as they occur, we have to let go of them and bring the mind back to the breath. And to and start the count again if necessary. And just keep doing this throughout the session without any sense of disappointment or expectation. So, before we start the second segment of doing some analytical meditation on the precious human rebirth, maybe I should just say a few words about it.
So The Buddhist view is that our mind has this Buddha potential, this Buddha nature, but our mind is obscured right now. And that the mind obscured by delusion and karma, this is saṃsāra. But saṃsāra also means that because our mind is obscured by delusion and karma, our mind can cycle in very different kinds of rebirths. And the human rebirth is only one kind of rebirth we can have. There are better rebirths while our mind is controlled by delusion and karma, in the god realms where there’s a lot of pleasure.
But there’s also far worse rebirths we can have of being reborn as an animal, as a hungry ghost and even in the hell realms. So many people find it very difficult to believe in these realms but we but there one can also imagine not imagine, but check that there are human versions on this planet of these kinds of suffering. So the reason for meditating on the precious human rebirth is to realise that not only do we have just a human rebirth, but a precious one, which is referring to having an enormous amount of freedom and opportunity to work with the mind. And it’s very, very, very rare to have such a rebirth because it’s immensely difficult to achieve it. So the more we think about this, this will motivate us not to waste this life doing ordinary things but to work with our mind to become free of suffering and achieve peerless, everlasting happiness, especially for the sake of others.
So although this is put at the very beginning of the presentation of the path to enlightenment, it’s really one of the most important meditations of all, because if we don’t get motivated to practice, it’s never going to happen. And thinking about the fact that or trying to recognise that we have a precious human rebirth, not just an ordinary human rebirth, but a very special kind of human rebirth, and how meaningful that is, and especially how incredibly difficult it is to create the causes to achieve such a rebirth, then the more we realise that, the more we will be motivated not to waste this life. Okay. So we can begin again by sitting comfortably in the correct posture as much as possible. And we can bring to mind our motivation, doing this not just for some benefit for ourselves in this or even in future lives, but especially trying to have that thought of doing this practice and dedicating it to be able to be ultimately to be able to benefit others.
And also one can recall the Buddha on the crown of one’s head. So then reflect that my mind existed before this life, it was in another body, in another place, before this, in another rebirth, and then death occurred. So I could have been reborn in a far more suffering situation than I have been reborn in. So I need to recognize this. So, for example, I could have been reborn as an animal, trapped in an animal body, because it’s so easy to create the causes to be born an animal, to create the negative causes.
So try to imagine what it would be like to have been reborn as any kind of animal, where the mind is so obscured. And there is so much fear in animals, so much ignorance, always being attacked by some other predator. Their minds just reduced to being only concerned about mere survival. If one finds it difficult to imagine that, just think that so many human beings on this planet right now, in many ways their life is not much different from being an animal, just merely trying to survive. They have this incredible human potential but no chance to awaken it.
Try try to put your mind in that suffering situation. And then try to realize how incredibly difficult it would be to practice the Dharma, to follow a spiritual path, to work with one’s mind in that situation. And then realize that right now, because I don’t have that kind of rebirth, I have so much freedom. How can I waste that freedom doing meaningless or negative things? And try to be aware that that freedom is not going to last.
The human life is so short. Also, imagine or think of all the human beings on this planet right now who spend their life at a level of starvation. Hardly ever having enough food to eat, their whole life concerned with just getting something to eat. Their life is so incredibly precarious, so much fear and worry. Millions and millions of human beings right now are experiencing that life.
I could have been reborn into such a life. So try and imagine that. Or think of all the people, the humans on this planet right now, whose life is like hell, caught up in horrific wars and violence and brutality, various kinds of addictions, mental illness, brutal governments, repressive governments. I could have been born into that kind of life also. Imagine the suffering and think, could I, in those situations, practice the Dharma, follow a spiritual life?
In those situations, would it be easy to train the mind to be kind and generous, compassionate, loving, forgiving? And then recognise what incredible freedom I have right now. The freedom to understand my mind, overcome the negative tendencies, the amazing freedom to actually awaken my potential for kindness and compassion and wisdom. So then reflect that not only have I been born in a situation where I’m free from all the greatest obstacles to prevent me leading a meaningful life, to prevent me from following the spiritual path. Actually, I need to recognise that I’ve been born with so many encouraging features, factors in my life.
That I’ve been born in a place where the the religious, all the different religious traditions exist. And most fortunately, one can think of in a place where the Buddhadharma exists. I have a relatively healthy body and mind that enables me to practice. And most importantly, I have some actual interest in practicing, in understanding my mind. Hopefully, have some faith in the Buddhist teachings.
Just consider that I’ve had many rebirths, I’ve been born a human before, free of all the greatest sufferings, but in all those previous lives, or many of them, I was never born in the place where the Dharma existed. Or if I was, had too many obstacles with my body or mind to be able to practice, or just simply had no interest or no faith. But this one time, I have all those encouraging factors. How can I waste this situation? Also I’ve been born at a time when the Buddha’s teachings are still flourishing.
There will come a time where they won’t exist at all anymore. They have been wiped out almost in some countries where they used to flourish. I’ve been born at a time where there are still great masters of the Buddha’s teachings alive and teaching the Dharma. I’ve been born in a situation where I know the existence of Dharma centers, where there are similar people, like minded people like myself, that I can meet, befriend, who can support me in my practice. So then reflect that although I may have difficulties and problems in my life, we all do, but nevertheless, I’m free of all the greatest hindrances to being able to follow the spiritual path, and I have all the main encouraging factors.
In other words, I have the optimum situation to follow the spiritual path, to make this and all future lives meaningful. It means that with this precious human rebirth, whatever meaningful, virtuous quality I want to develop in this life, I have all the freedom and encouraging factors to do so. I have the optimum chance to create the cause for a good rebirth. But I have to recognize this situation and take advantage of it. With this freedom and encouraging factors, I can make every moment of my life meaningful.
I can use my body, speech and mind in meaningful ways to benefit myself and others. I have the optimum chance to do this, but I have to recognise it or I will lose it, I will waste it. Most important of all, right now, as I am, I have the optimum chance, the optimum freedom to create the causes, to become totally free of all suffering forever. I have the optimum chance to actually achieve enlightenment, the state of peerless, everlasting happiness, the state whereby one can be of continuous perfect benefit to all living beings. We tend to take this human life for granted that it’s nothing special to have a human rebirth.
And we assume, if we believe in reincarnation, that just automatically one will get another human rebirth. But in fact, even to be reborn a human being, even a suffering human being, the suffering of a human being is far less than the sufferings of those trapped in the lower realms. So it is immensely difficult actually to create the causes to be reborn human. And to have a precious human rebirth is even more difficult. One has to practice pure morality, pure generosity.
It has taken us many lifetimes to do that. So how can I waste this life on meaningless or negative things? Try and get a sense of how rare it is, how difficult it is to have a human rebirth by just reflecting that for every human being on this planet, there are thousands and thousands of beings trapped in the animal realm. As fish, as insects, different kinds of reptiles, mammals and so on, birds. This is because it is so easy to create the negative causes to be reborn as trapped in an animal body, and so difficult to create the causes to be born human.
And then among human beings, so many human beings’ lives are like being in the hell or like hungry ghosts or like animals. Even if they’re free of those kinds of sufferings, many human beings never have any contact with the Buddhadharma. Even if they do, they have no faith in it or no ability to practice it. It is unbelievably rare to have the optimum precious human rebirth. So bring the meditation to a conclusion by making a strong determination to be more and more mindful every day, especially when one wakes up, that one has a precious human rebirth, the optimum chance to practise.
So to be mindful not to waste this precious human rebirth doing meaningless, and especially not to waste doing meaningless things, especially not to engage in negative things, but to be mindful to really use this precious human rebirth in the very best possible way. Not only for one’s own sake, but especially for the benefit of others. So then recall the Buddha on the crown of one’s head, imagining the Buddha is very pleased with your meditation. And the Buddha shows this by now dissolving into blissful golden light that pours down into you, blessing your mind to be able to gain the actual realization, recognizing that one has a precious human rebirth, how meaningful and how rare it is. And then we can dedicate the merit, Page three.
Through the merits of these virtuous actions, may I quickly attain the state of a Guru Buddha and lead all living beings without exception into that enlightened state. May the precious bodhimind not yet born arise and grow. May that born have no decline but increase forevermore. May the precious right view not yet born arise and grow. May that born have no decline but increase forevermore.
Now? It is on now. Yeah? Okay. So again we can begin by sitting comfortably in the correct posture, generating as strongly as we can the bodhicitta motivation, visualising the Buddha in front of us, all sentient beings surrounding us.
I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, Dharma, the Supreme Assembly. By the merits I create sorry. Benefit all sentient beings. So thinking the Buddha’s pleased with our motivation, we imagine the Buddha, coming to the crown of our head and then turning to face the same direction as ourself, remaining there for the rest of the session. So even if we start to develop some understanding, some insight, some realization of having a precious human rebirth, how meaningful it is, how rare it is to achieve it.
Even so, we can still we still have this wrong view of permanence. We grasp that our life will just keep going on and on. And because of that we can avoid, you know, we end up not practising the Dharma, thinking there’s so much time, always postponing things. We really need to, in order to really renounce our obsession with this life, we need to think about how we’re going to die. Otherwise, we would just waste this life, and in fact, not only waste this life but end up creating the causes to have a bad rebirth.
So just consider that I am definitely going to die because I simply have no power to remain in this life. No sentient being who has been born on this earth has lived forever. Everyone, not just human beings but all the different kinds of sentient beings that have been born on this earth, they’ve all eventually died. So why do I think I will not die? What valid reason do I possibly have to think I won’t die?
Right now, there’s something like over seven billion human beings on this planet. In a hundred years’ time, almost none none of those seven billion human beings will be alive. I also reflect that not only just ordinary human beings die, but even the most powerful human beings die. Even the great religious leaders, those highly accomplished, realized beings have died. Even the Buddha manifested leaving the body.
This was his final teaching to us to show that everybody dies. And particularly reflect, I’m definitely going to die because my life is constantly passing away moment by moment, hour by hour, day by day, year by year, without any way of adding to it. All the things I might do or could do to be healthy and strong and what I eat and exercising and so on, none of those things add to my life. They, at the very best, act as conditions for me to live out the full extent of my life, but they don’t add to it. The length of my life is a karmic result of actions done in past lives.
So there’s no way to add to the length of life. All that happens is from the moment I’m born, I get closer and closer to death, day by day. So particularly reflect that I’m definitely going to die and within this short life there is just so little time to actually practice the Dharma. When I am young, I have no interest to do so or no ability to do so. When I get really old, also, I lose the ability to practice.
It’s really only in the middle of my life that it’s possible. But then so much of my time is taken up with so many other things. Things that have to be done, just so many things that don’t have to be done. Especially one can reflect that a third, you know, about a third of my whole life is lost just sleeping. If I lived to be ninety, thirty years of my life, completely taken up just sleeping.
So thinking along those lines that I’m definitely going to die and there is so little time to practice, develop that conviction, that determination that I really do have to practice the Dharma. I really do need to take care of my mind, to protect it, cultivate it, and especially prepare my mind for the time of death. Because it’s definitely going to happen. So then try and develop that awareness, that understanding that not only am I going to die, but I could die at any time. And this is especially because the duration of the lifespan is not of human life is not fixed.
People die when they’re very young, not just when they’re very old. So this means that I could die at any time. It is a common feature of human existence all over the world that the young can die before the old, the healthy can die before the sick, The strong can die before the weak. Which means I could die at any time. Especially reflect that I could die at any time because there are just so many ways death can occur, so many causes of death.
Some from very common ways due to sickness and so on. But many uncommon ways, sort of freakish accidents and so And so since this has occurred these things occur regularly for human beings all over the world, Dying because of accidents, sickness, wars, natural disasters. Because of all these different causes that people die from all the time throughout history, it means that any of those things could happen to me at any time, just like they’ve happened to other people unexpectedly. I’m not immune to any of those things, so they could happen to me at any time. And I could die at any time because not only is this human life not fixed and there are so many causes for death, but also because there are so few things that can be guaranteed to sustain my life.
Even the food I eat can become a cause of death. Even the medicines I take can become a cause of death. And the human body itself is such a fragile thing. So thinking like this, come to the conclusion that since I could die at any time, is not enough to be determined to practice the Dharma. I really have to practice it now.
I have to stop postponing it, especially I have to stop postponing doing serious practice. I have to stop postponing doing serious practice, thinking that I’ve got plenty of time to do things later on, that later on may never come. I really have to practice now. So now it’s really important to reflect that when the time of death actually comes, that time when the mind is going to permanently separate from this body, that I will leave this life, this world, what is gonna help me at that time? What am I doing now that is gonna be of real benefit at that crucial time.
I have a precious human rebirth which is so short, that time is so precious, how am I using that time? What of that time, the activities during that time, are gonna be of benefit. So think of all the time that is spent with on family and friends. But will they be able to help me at the time of death? And consider that, in fact, my attachment to them and their attachment to me will be a great obstacle at the time of death.
And similarly I spend so much time trying to acquire money and possessions and so on. But is any of that gonna help at the time of death? And won’t my attachment to wealth and possessions and so on be an obstacle at the time of death? And then think of all the other ways I use this precious human rebirth, that eats up all the time of this precious human rebirth, Taking care of the body, being concerned about reputation, influence, power, all those things, none of which will help me at the time of death. My attachment to them only becoming an obstacle.
So then consider what will help me, what will be of actual benefit. Is having a peaceful mind, a stable mind, a mind that has genuine faith in the triple gem, in the guru, a mind that has genuine compassion, kindness. A mind that has been purified and has a lot of merit. Those qualities one can’t suddenly acquire at the time of death. I have to cultivate them throughout my life.
So bring the meditation to a conclusion by making strong determination not to waste this precious human rebirth, but to practice the Dharma, practice it now, but most importantly, to practice it sincerely, to practice it purely as much as possible. Because it’s only that kind of practice that will really help me at the time of death. So we’ll just take a couple of minutes silent break, and then we’ll start again. So our next topic is that we can meditate on is the law of cause and effect. So actually we really need to do a two day retreat on the path to in line with presenting the path.
So there’s really just not enough time to meditate to do all the meditation on karma. We just have to do the very first bit anyway. So we can start again. Sitting comfortably in the correct posture, reaffirming our good motivation. As part of that we can recall the Buddha on the crown of our head.
So we can begin by reflecting that the more we realise that we’re definitely going to die, then this encourages us to practise the Dharma, especially when we realise that if we don’t practice, it is so easy to end up creating the causes for the lower realms and experience that tremendous suffering. And the more we realize that that is a possibility, the more we’re encouraged to take refuge in the Three Jewels of Buddhadharma Sangha. And the essential refuge is to practice the Dharma. And the essential Dharma practice is to observe the law of cause and effect. So I think that the more I develop faith and the law of cause and effect and live according to it, I will create fewer and fewer causes of suffering, fewer and fewer causes to take bad rebirths.
And I will begin to create more and more causes for happiness for now and the future. So for this reason, I need to be really mindful that there is a definite relationship that never changes between the nature of the cause and the nature of the effect. Every activity of my mind, good and bad, has an effect. Every activity of my mind is a cause that produces an effect. And the nature of the effect depends on the nature of the cause.
So every time I allow my mind to come under the control of the disturbing thoughts, Those disturbing thoughts are creating the cause to give rise to a suffering effect. That is definite. It never changes. So every time I allow my mind to come under the control of the positive thoughts of love and compassion and so on, this will definitely produce a beneficial effect. That is definite.
Whether I believe this is going to happen, whether I want it to happen or not, doesn’t matter. This will definitely happen. This is the way the mind works. Whether I know something is positive or negative is irrelevant. If what is a negative thought arises in the mind, if I even if I don’t think it’s negative, but it is, if it is one of the disturbing thoughts, then it’s creating the cause for a disturbing result.
So also consider that in order for a particular for my mind to experience a particular effect, a particular result, good or bad, my mind has to create the cause for it. Either in this or past lives. And if I don’t create the cause for something, good or bad, then I I will not experience the result. So if I want to experience happiness, I have to create the cause for it. If I do not want to experience suffering, I have to stop creating the causes for it.
So then consider that once a cause, good or bad, has been created, which means once a positive or negative karmic imprint, karmic seed, karmic potential, karmic potency has been created, whether it’s a good one or a bad one, that imprint will remain in the mind until it ripens. That imprint will not, you know, just disappear, not produce its result. It will eventually produce the result. Of course, there are the exceptions to that are, if I create positive imprints, unfortunately, those imprints can be destroyed by the power of my own negative thoughts. That’s why we’re encouraged to dedicate our positive actions and therefore the positive imprints to protect them.
Also, negative imprints can be purified by applying the four opponent powers. So apart from those exceptions, once the imprint’s created, no matter how much time goes by, that potency never gets weaker, never disappears. It will eventually produce the result. I then consider that the Buddha taught that when the karmic potencies ripen, the result is far, far greater than the energy that went into creating the cause. And whatever result occurs within the life when that action was created is nothing compared to the result that is experienced when the karmic imprint ripens.
So if we can get, you know, kill someone, we may as a result experience a lot of suffering in this life, but that’s nothing compared to the suffering that comes when the karmic seed ripens and throws us into the lower realms. So then we can briefly reflect that the extent of the greatness of the result that comes from any actions that we engage in really depends on the interaction between four fundamental factors operating at the time of creating the cause. So one of these is the impulse, which is the conscious intention to engage in a particular action, either good or bad. And in the case of the negative actions, that impulse has to be mixed with, the motivation of one of the three poisonous minds of ignorance, attachment or anger. So depending on how strong that impulse is, how strong the disturbing thought is, that determines how great the effect will be.
Another factor that determines the extent of the result is the nature of the object that we direct our action towards. So if we direct our action, good or bad, towards an inanimate object, that tends to create less, lesser result than if it’s towards a sentient being. And if we direct our actions towards human beings, this produces a greater result than with animals. And then amongst human beings, if we direct our actions towards holy beings or our parents, the Sangha, or people who’ve been kind to us, have helped us, then the result is greater. And of course, the most potent karmic object of all is the Guru.
So any action directed towards the Guru, good or bad, produces the greatest result, good or bad. So then another factor to consider that influences the extent of the result is the, when we’re engaging, creating the cause, it’s the way we do that. So if we do engage in a negative action that is done in an extremely vicious way, then that creates even more, you know, stronger negative result. So, the more suffering our actions create or cause or the the more benefit our actions cause to others, in the same way, the greater the result coming back to us in the future. And then the final determining factor is whether we complete the action or not.
So we could start out intending to benefit someone or to harm them. We start trying to do it, but we don’t complete the action. So this means the karmic result is not as great as it could have been if we’d completed the action. And in addition, what is also a factor is the state of mind we have when when we complete the action. So if we complete a good action and we’re happy we’ve done it, that increases the potency, increases the result.
If we do a virtuous action, we complete it, but we regret it, that reduces the effect. If we do a negative action and complete it and we’re happy we’ve done it, that increases the effect. If we complete a negative action and regret it, that reduces the effect. So we can bring this meditation to a conclusion by making a strong determination to be more and more mindful in our daily life of these factors that determine the potency of karmic actions, also to be mindful of the other four factors of how karma is definite, expandable, is never lost, that if one doesn’t create the cause, one doesn’t experience the result. By being mindful of those all of those factors, this will encourage us to be really careful with the actions of our body, speech, mind.
So then recall the Buddha on one’s crown, thinking the Buddha’s pleased with one’s practice and shows this by dissolving into blissful golden light so that that light can then pour down into us, blessing our mind to develop strong faith in the law of cause and effect. And then we dedicate the merit Through the merits of these virtuous actions, may I quickly attain the state of a Guru Buddha and lead all living beings without exception into that enlightened state. May the precious bodhimind, not yet born arise and grow. May that born have no decline, but increase forevermore. May the precious right view, not yet born arise and grow.
May that born have no decline but increase forevermore. So remember that understanding the law of cause and effect or developing faith in it is the conventional right view that leads to the highest right view. So as I’ve said before, and I will now say again, Lama Zopa Rinpoche says, it’s really important to reflect on, meditate on those four first four factors of how karma is definite, that it’s if you don’t create the cause, you don’t get the result and vice versa. If you’re getting if you’re experiencing something, it means you’ve we’ve created the cause, then karma is expandable and the the karmic imprint is never lost. And he says, it’s really important to meditate on those four things again and again because if one can by by being mindful of those in one’s daily life, this will protect us, this will encourage us not to engage in negative actions, and it will encourage us to engage in virtuous ones.
The reason we engage in negative actions is we’ve completely forgotten those four things, or we don’t believe in them. But if we had developed some faith in them and we Even if we have faith in them but we forget them, we’ll engage in negative actions. But on the basis of believing those things, then we have to remember them. And if we actually remember them, just as if we’re about to create a negative action, that will help us not do it. Because what else will?
What else is gonna stop us? Nothing. Except the police, maybe. But remember, even if the police stop us doing negative actions, it just means we didn’t complete the negative action. But even an incomplete negative action is still generating, remember, a negative imprint.
It’s not as big bad as a completed one, but it’s still a negative imprint. Nasty. So that’s very important, yeah. Very it’s a very simple thing to do. But of course, we also should reflect how try to get some understanding of how those things do work at some level.
Yeah. Any questions? No, this is question and answer time just before lunch, so now you have to ask me questions. On the Yes? In purification practices, is there any way that you can get some understanding or sense of whether or not you’ve been effective with your efforts?
Yes. There are. I think in general, you you Firstly, just a general answer is I think you have to have faith in the method. That if you do the method as sincerely and as strongly as you possibly can, you should have faith that it has definitely had some effect. How much effect one can’t know, but one should have faith that it is working.
But for to get some definite there are definite there are signs you can get that one’s purification has been really effective and that comes in dreams when you get various types of images in dreams. So they, none of which I think I can remember, don’t think at the moment. But there are auspicious signs you can get in dreams that indicate that you have, you know, made a significant dent in your negative imprints, some real purification. I think things like being offered milk and yogurt, something like that, or you just dream of those things. I mean, if you just dream of them in general, it doesn’t mean that.
But if you’ve actually engaging in some serious purification practice and then at that time you have that kind of dream, then it’s very meaningful. Also going uphill, you know, uphill where you visualize you’re going uphill is a very good sign. Dreaming of monks and nuns, of course, is at that time is a very good sign. What else? There are some others, but I can’t think of them now.
Sorry. Do you think that doing Bodhisattva’s Confession purification practice, the short one is sufficient for beginners, or should we be doing more than that? Short one, yes, yes, that’s very good. Yeah. Well, we could all be doing more.
There’s a We all have to admit that there’s a lot to purify really, so Yes. But doing pure doing Vajrasattva purification every night is really important. This is As I’ve said many times, this is something that all the four schools emphasise that any practitioner should do every night. Yeah. At the end of the day to purify what’s done during that day but also everything beforehand, that’s really, really important.
And to do the long mantra, you know, for beginners, twenty one long mantras with trying to do the visualization as much as possible, you know, combined with the four opponent powers. Yeah. That’s very important. How do they ripen? What do you mean?
In what way? Well Because if we are aware of what we cause in this life, so how these other things they they ripen? These are the karmas ripening. I’m not quite sure what you’re saying, Christina.
So we you we know we do negative things in this life. No. No. We don’t do any negative things in this life. Oh, but we all do.
We all do, but we are aware aware at the moment that we are not doing any negative poses. Yeah. And suddenly So let’s assume we’re we’re being very, very virtuous this week. Yeah. Yeah.
So and so that some negative karmas they can ripen in this During that time, possible, yes. It is possible. But of course, the more virtuous one lives one’s life, that is in general creating the conditions for negative karma not to ripen. Negative karma is more likely to ripen when one is in a negative state of mind and doing negative things in general. But, I mean, karma is very, very complicated the way, you know, and so even if one is, you know, living a virtuous life For example, there were many well, good, you lay people, but monks and nuns living very virtuous lives in Tibet, and yet the communist Chinese invaded and did terrible things to monks and nuns.
Even the you know, especially to, you know, to the great Lamas. Many great Lamas were tortured, starved to death, all sorts of horrendous things for that. Happened to them. Yeah. Yeah.
That’s But but but that and and the only way you can explain that is because some karma, heavy karma from the past ripened because unless something is purified, it’s gonna ripen and even it will ripen, you know, the power of of it, you know, it’s the time for it to ripen has come even if one’s living a virtuous life. Or for example, Lama Yeshe lived a wonderful life, an incredibly beneficial life, but, you know, he had this very bad heart condition. And in fact, the fact that he spent his life travelling around the world teaching people, acted as a condition to make his heart condition worse. And he had many heart attacks, and eventually he died from it. So that means that to purify your karma, that take very long time.
Yeah. Yes. Yes. Everything takes a lot of time, except if one is eventually able to practice tantra very well. But even to be able to practice it well takes a lot of time.
But once one can practice it very well, then one can quickly get out. That the monks and nuns, they they do a lot of practice, isn’t it? Some do. Not all monks. Come on.
Monks and nuns are human beings. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Come on. Some questions.
Anything. Margaret, come on. Have a question about precious human rebirth. Right. Ordinary things or something.
The value, the first one. Yeah. Yeah. How do you mean that? Well, it means that we because we have we, you know, we we don’t we don’t have all these obstacles and we have all these encouraging factors, then any temporary temporal good quality that we want, you know, or good thing we want to do, we can do if we, you if apply ourselves.
In other words, if we want to be a nicer person, a kinder person, more compassionate person, something like that, then we can achieve that because we we’re free of the greatest obstacles to achieving it and we have all the encouraging factors to achieve it. We just have to recognise that and do it. And then among all of those things that we could achieve in this life, good things that we can achieve with A Precious human Rebirth. Or like for example, if we want to become an expert in the in the Lam Rim teachings and practices, we can. It’s just a matter of recognising, oh, I could do this and, yeah, and doing it.
Or for example, like I could could memorize all of Śāntideva’s Guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life. There’s nothing stopping me doing that and I have all the encouraging factors. I could do that or even if I don’t memorize it, I could become, you know, I could devote my life to really understanding that text because it’s such a wonderful text. There’s nothing stopping me. Yeah.
But especially that’s also referring to, I I I can I can create the cause for a precious another precious human rebirth or at least, you know, or a good rebirth in a pure land with this life? There’s nothing stopping me. I just have to, you know, recognize that I can do it and do it. Yeah. Well, firstly, I’m not sure how authentic all of those are.
But even if they are, there is a huge difference, huge difference, huge difference between being reborn a human being and having a precious human rebirth. Remember, a precious the word precious is not an adjective for every human rebirth, it’s it’s a distinguishing adjective to separate Right? Yeah. There are human rebirths and then there are precious human rebirths. And a precious human rebirth is someone who has got all eight freedoms and all ten endowments.
And that that is unbelievably rare to have. Otherwise, this hall would be full all apart from the pack, know. Yeah. It would be full every day with people. I think the teaching’s fulfilled that say that people Yeah.
We have. Look how many there are. Not many. Yeah. Adelaide is not never going to become a hundred percent Buddhist or ninety percent or even fifty percent Buddhist.
Does the fact that we are here and we’ve had contact with previous contact with the Dharma, does that make it more No. No. We’re just using up this. If we don’t use it, you know, create new causes, that’s the whole point of what we’ve been trying to make. If we if we waste this precious human rebirth, we we not only waste this life, but we we don’t create the cause for a good rebirth.
And again, you know, the point I was making, you know, first thing in the morning was that what we can have a precious human rebirth, but if we don’t recognize it, it’s it’s the same as not having one. Because if we don’t recognize it, we don’t use the diamond. We just have it and it’s just there, useless. Because recognizing the precious human the whole what that means is if you if you recognize it, one practices the Dharma. When the you know, the more one recognizes what it means, you don’t waste this life.
They say, you know, the when you have the recognition of the precious, you can’t bear to waste this life. What does Lama Tsongkhapa say? Lama Tsongkhapa says What does he say? Lama Tsongkhapa says, if you knew how hard it is to acquire, meaning a precious human rebirth, if you knew how hard it is to acquire, living an average life would be impossible. If you saw its great benefits, you would be sorry if it stayed meaningless.
Sorry, very, very sorry. Says, if you thought about death, you would make preparations for your future life. If you thought about cause and effect, you would stop being reckless. Meaning, if we really thought about these things, if we really meditated on them strongly, let it really grab us. So that’s what we’ve got to do because we have the optimum chance to meditate on these things.
And as Rinpoche was saying, was it? Was it Saturday? Last Saturday? When was Rinpoche here? Sunday.
Sunday. Last Sunday. Gosh, last Sunday. You know, meditation doesn’t have to mean like doing this stuff. You know?
It’s okay. It’s about just, you know, holding in mind these things, reflecting on them again and again. One time for one more question on the Lam Rim. What’s the balance between getting paranoid about every negative thought that you have sort of working with the the stuff that really grabs you? What’s you know, there’s there seems to be there’s a level of stuff that just pops into your mind that you have seem to have very little control over.
Mhmm. And then there’s kind of, like, taking off with that. So how how do you view that initial the stuff that just kind of comes into mind even if you don’t kind of follow it that far? Well, I think we just have to accept that all sorts of garbage floats through our mind and it always has been floating through our mind since beginningless time. And so we’re so lucky that now we can be aware of this and start to do something about it because for most most of our lives, we had no method what so ever, no knowledge of what was going on, and even if we did, no no way to deal with it, but now we have.
So we can rejoice. And all this rubbish is still gonna float through our mind for a long time to come. But, you know, we’re we’re starting. We’ve met the Dharma, we have some faith in it, we have Dharma friends, we have access to lamas, etcetera, etcetera. You know, one thing about the meditation on the precious human rebirth, one of the environmental, encouraging environmental factors is that we’ve been born in a time and place where there are there are still greatly, you know, highly realised teachers of the Dharma.
So what that means is, you know, it’s not just that they’re there, it’s because they’re there we can access them. So it means we have if we’re accessing them or trying to make connection with those people, then that’s when we’re we really have a complete precious human rebirth. Just the fact that they’re out there is not much benefit. I mean, is some because they’re having some modifying influence on our crazy environment and therefore us, but it’s really do you know what I’m trying to say? No.
Do you know what I’m trying to say? It’s it’s like, you know, if you have a disease, some sickness, you know, if you’re in some countries like third world countries, then there’s virtually no access to the medicine and doctors who could help you. They’re just not there. Whereas if you have the same disease in Australia, that same sickness, there is the medicine and doctors there. So just the mere fact that they’re there is not going to cure you.
But it’s that you, you know, you can know that they’re there and go to these doctors and get the medicine. So by doing that, that is what is really helpful. Yeah? So the mere fact that great lamas are here is not so terrific, Doesn’t mean all that much to us, but it’s when we connect with them, go and receive teachings from them, make a karmic connection with them, then something really amazing has happened. Yeah?
That’s so that’s the point. Yeah. Because, you know, in this world, like like in the western world now, the Buddhadharma is coming or particularly just in the case of, you know, you know, like like Tibetan Buddhism is spreading. There are many Well, no, I believe that. Just Buddhist centers are spreading and popping up all over the west.
Even Whyalla has a Tibetan Buddhist center. I can’t believe that, but Whyalla has a Buddhist center. And one of the great lamas of the Sakya tradition visited and taught there, Chogye Trichen Rinpoche, who was an amazing teacher. Unfortunately, passed away a few years ago, but he he actually taught in Whyalla. I mean, anyway, so so that, you know, all of these amazing Dharma centers and many of them have, you know, really great teachers there and whatever, Tibetan masters teaching in them. So that this is happening, it’s existing, but most people in the West don’t know this.
So they, you know, they don’t have any access to it. Yeah. But then when you actually know it and take advantage of it, that’s a completely different thing. Like, you know, people walk past here all the time, but will never come in, so it’s no benefit to them in a sense for indirectly. Waves of indirect benefit, of course, like the what the vibes coming from here are just amazing.
And people stopping and taking photos. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yes.
Yes. Yes. Oh, we had many people from Sri Lanka yesterday. Yeah. Beautiful.
They have some temple around here, don’t know where. And they just passed, because they saw the cars here, it was about six o’clock, I see. We were doing the flowers with Jen. Right. Yeah.
There were six of them. So the we show everything, and they were amazing. I said, oh, wow. That’s beautiful. Okay.
Good. Thank you. Lunchtime.
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- eight freedoms dalwa gyä (Tib)
- The eight states a perfect human rebirth is free of: birth as a hell being, hungry ghost, animal or long-life god; as a barbarian; in a dark age when no buddha has come; with wrong views; or with impaired faculties. LYWA
- four opponent powers nyenpo tob zhi (Tib)
- The four practices used to purify nonvirtuous imprints on the mindstream. LYWA
- graduated path lamrim (Tib)
- A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- pure land kshetra-zhuddhi (Skt); zhingdag (Tib)
- A pure land of a buddha is a place where there is no suffering. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
In purification practice, is there any way to tell whether your efforts have been effective?
In general, one needs faith in the method. If you practise as sincerely and strongly as you can, you should trust that it has definitely had some effect, though how much cannot be known. There are also definite signs of effective purification, which come in dreams. Auspicious dreams, such as being offered milk and yogurt, going uphill, or seeing monks and nuns, indicate a significant dent in negative imprints and real purification. Such dreams are meaningful only when they occur while you are engaged in serious purification practice. Dreaming of these things in general does not mean the same. There are some other signs, but they could not be recalled at the time.
How should we view the negative thoughts that spontaneously arise in the mind, even when we do not follow them further?
We have to accept that all sorts of garbage floats through our mind, as it has since beginningless time, and it will keep doing so for a long time. We are lucky that we can now be aware of it and do something about it, whereas for most of our lives we had no method or knowledge. So we can rejoice. We have met the Dharma, have some faith, Dharma friends and access to lamas. Yet the mere existence of great teachers is not enough, just as a sick person gains nothing from doctors and medicine unless they actually go and use them. The benefit comes when we connect with teachers and receive teachings.