DB Presenting the Path — DB Presenting The Path Week 8

2 h 7 min · 14,022 words · 2016 · Buddha House Adelaide

DB Presenting the Path (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
DB Presenting the Path (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
DB Presenting the Path — DB Presenting The Path Week 8
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 127-minute concluding session of the Discovering Buddhism Presenting the Path series, Ven Thubten Dondrub offers a comprehensive overview of the Buddhist path to enlightenment, anchoring everything in the central motivation of bodhicitta—the wish to achieve full awakening to benefit all sentient beings. He walks through the sequential development of the path’s foundational stages: renouncing attachment to this life and cyclic existence, then cultivating equanimity, love, and compassion for all beings. He explains how the six perfections—generosity, morality, patience, perseverance, concentration, and wisdom—form the practical structure of the bodhisattva path, with the first five rooted in compassion and method, and wisdom as the ultimate antidote to ignorance. Drawing heavily on Śāntideva’s Guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life, he stresses that wisdom must come from hearing teachings, analytical thinking, and meditative stability, and that all these practices together lead to the direct perception of emptiness and dependent arising. The talk includes detailed advice on cultivating patience and subduing anger through understanding harm rather than mere suppression, and closes with reflections on the difference between arhat nirvana and Buddha enlightenment, emphasizing bodhicitta as the motivation that develops the stronger wisdom necessary for full omniscience. Suitable for anyone beginning serious Buddhist study or deepening their understanding of Mahāyāna path structure.

File metadata (for organising)

File: DB Presenting The Path Week 8.mp3

UUID: 95e620e2-f94b-4215-be64-9f18e6db775b

Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub

Collection: DB Presenting the Path (Ven Thubten Dondrub)

Date: 2016 (exact day not recorded)

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 127.3 minutes

Words: ~14,021

Okay. Welcome everyone to our last class on this in this module of was it presenting the path? Also, my last class on DB for maybe quite a long time. So the path that we’re presenting is the path the path to enlightenment. So to follow that path, we have to have a very strong motivation in order to overcome all the difficulties, all the obstacles.

And so we the the best motivation we can have for following the path is the bodhicitta motivation, which is wishing to realize our full potential, achieve enlightenment, to be in a position to repay the kindness, perfectly repay the kindness of sentient beings by helping them to be free of all causes of suffering and helping them to achieve a peerless everlasting happiness. And that wish comes from realizing wanting to, you know, to repay their kindness comes from realizing that we actually have received kindness from every sentient being. And not just a little bit of kindness, but an inconceivably vast amount of kindness, every form of kindness we’ve received countless times from every sentient being. So it’s very easy to say those words, but it’s very hard to actually get a sense that that is actually the case, that every sentient being has been immensely kind in every possible way, that particularly every sentient being has given us the unconditional love of the mother many times. But that is the case if we really think if we understand the nature of our mind.

And but also what we need to realize more and more, allow ourselves to create the conditions so our our mind can realize this more and more profoundly, is that all these immensely kind beings who I depend on so much are suffering in cyclic existence. And most of them, even right at this very moment, having conceivably more suffering than myself with far far less ability at the moment to make sense of their suffering, to modify it, subdue it, transform it, and eliminate it. And actually, so they’re completely helpless. And in their helpless situation, sentient beings are blindly creating the cause for more suffering. Creating the cause for more suffering.

So the more we allow ourselves to realize those things, the more we can generate this bodhicitta motivation for studying the path. So anyway, this is the motivation as much as possible we can try and generate right now as we think of the Buddha in front of us as a source of refuge, inspiration, and guidance, and thinking of all sentient beings surrounding us as much as possible. As we say, if you’d like to join in the traditional prayer of refuge in bodhicitta, which is on page Roman XI in your student material. I go for refuge until I am enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma and the Supreme Assembly. By the merits I create through listening to the Dharma, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings.

So then we can think the Buddha is pleased with our motivation to benefit others, and because of that, the Buddha now comes to to the crown of our head, and when directly above our crown, the Buddha dissolves into blissful golden light so that that light can then pour down into us, blessing our our mind. And then briefly, we can do the nine round breathing exercise to allow that that positive state of mind, to enhance that positive state of mind just a little bit more, allowing it to become just a little bit more calm, clear, and concentrated so that we can use that level of mind to listen to and think about the Buddhist teachings tonight. Okay. Thank you. So we should understand the the path to enlightenment is all about generating bodhicitta, the wish to to achieve enlightenment for the sake of others, and comes from feeling the suffering of sentient beings as really unbearable and want and therefore wanting to be involved in in helping sentient beings overcome all the causes of suffering and more than that replace that suffering with all with the experience of peerless everlasting happiness.

So the whole path to enlightenment is about overcoming our self-cherishing thought and replacing it with the thought of cherishing others more and more until we can actually generate the mind of cherishing others more than self. So one should understand that the whole path to enlightenment is all about that process of it’s directly or indirectly helping us to generate bodhicitta so that we can achieve enlightenment. So even the teachings and meditations of the of the lowest scope, the practitioner of the lowest capability about renouncing this life, all of those meditations and teachings are also part of the process essential to generating bodhicitta. If we if we haven’t renounced if we if we haven’t renounced this life, there’s no way to generate bodhicitta. You can’t skip the steps.

One first has to renounce this life. Because while we’re obsessed with this life, you know, we it means that we’re whether we like to admit it or not, we’re basically focused on our self and not others. And so we’re blocking the full development of our love and compassion, which are the very basic ingredients of developing bodhicitta. And and we’re not thinking about ultimate happiness or long term suffering even in relation to ourselves, but just the suffering and pleasures of this life. So we we definitely have to renounce this life.

And then while we remain attached to cyclic existence, it means that we somehow think that the suffering of cyclic existence is manageable, which it isn’t, and and we somehow think the pleasures of saṃsāra are good enough, but they’re not because they don’t last. And so while we think that, you know, while we’re attached to saṃsāra, again, we can’t fully we can’t fully we’re blocking our mind from fully understanding the incredible suffering of others. Because if we can’t admit our own potential for samsaric suffering, we can’t admit the suffering that others are actually experiencing. And while we’re telling ourselves that the pleasures of saṃsāra are good enough, we can never develop real love for ourselves, wanting ourselves to have perfect happiness, and if we can’t do it for ourselves, we can’t do it for others. So we have to develop that mind fully renouncing saṃsāra, and only then are we in a position to to really generate bodhicitta.

We can try and cultivate it now, plant the seeds, the imprints, because even by studying the teachings on bodhicitta now and trying to put them into practice, meditating on how all sentient beings have been our mother, how kind sentient beings are, developing the wish to repay their kindness, cultivating great love, great compassion, and so on. Cultivate, you know, meditating on equalizing oneself with others, meditating on seeing the faults of the self-cherishing thought, the great benefits of cherishing others, training the mind to exchange oneself with others, especially by doing the Tonglen meditation, which I haven’t talked about, but anyway. All of these things are designed to help us generate bodhicitta, but if one hasn’t got all the other things in place of having fully renounced saṃsāra, if one hasn’t worked on purifying the mind, accumulating merit, we won’t be able to generate bodhicitta until all those things are really developed. But at least if we work on doing these meditations now, at least it will help us to become a more loving, compassionate person, for sure. And it’s planting the seeds to be able to generate bodhicitta in the future.

Alright. So did I talk about Tonglen a little bit last week? Not at all. Not at all. I’m I’m sure I talked about it last week somewhere, but maybe not in the DB course.

Maybe it was in this Thursday Thursday night. Yeah. So in Shantideva’s method of exchange of generating bodhicitta, which is called the method of equalizing and exchanging self with others, first one trains to develop basic equanimity of seeing all friends and equalizing friends, enemies, and strangers as all equally deserving of happiness, wanting them all equally not to suffer. Then on the basis of that, we need to develop the mind equalizing ourselves with others, seeing that essentially we are no different from anyone else. In essence, you know, we are all the same in wanting happiness and we’re all the same in not wanting suffering.

Yeah? That’s the that’s the essential thing that unites all human beings. It unites all sentient beings because we’re all exactly the same in this case. You can’t make any significant difference. How people go about doing that can vary a great deal.

People do really good things to avoid suffering. Some people do really terrible things. Some people do stupid things. Some people do wise things. Some people do virtuous things.

Some people do very non virtuous things. Some people do very short sighted things, some people do very long sighted things, but it’s all fundamentally because of that fundamental wish not to suffer and to be happy. So that’s what we really need to work on. This is such a good meditation to do. It doesn’t you don’t have to be a genius to do it.

It’s very, you know, it’s so you know, it’s a very simple meditation in many ways, just thinking about focusing on the similarities and so beneficial for the mind. And because it opens that, you know, we we feel a connection with others and this makes us this enables our that potential for love and compassion to be able to flow more easily. And and but also we start to realize what what blocks that all the time, that ability to love others and to have compassion for them is our own self-cherishing. The gross self-cherishing, but even that subtle self-cherishing that wants just liberation for oneself. So we have to meditate on seeing all the faults of the self-cherishing thought more and more.

And we have to see the benefits, as Śāntideva says, of cherishing others more and more. And in summary, what it say in the lama chopa? Something like what does it say? I can’t remember. Something like well, basically, the idea is that the foot is it?

The childish cherish themselves and the Buddhas cherish others. You just have to look at the difference between them and then you can see what’s beneficial to do. You know, we cherish ourselves because we’re the childish ones, you know, we haven’t matured, our minds haven’t matured at developed our real potential. We may think we’re incredibly mature and sophisticated, but we we still really operate at a very childish level of just thinking about me. And we’re still suffering, we’re still in saṃsāra, whereas all the beings who’ve become Buddhas, how do they become Buddhas?

They did it by giving up the self-cherishing thought and cherishing others more than self. So that kind of shows in a nutshell nutshell what to do, the faults of self-cherishing, the benefits of cherishing others. And the final stage of developing bodhicitta according to the Śāntideva is training the mind to exchange oneself with others, to think of others as basically oneself. And the and the one of the the ways to do that is this practice called Tonglen, which is of giving and taking, where we train in meditation to focus on the suffering of others and trying to feel that suffering as unbearable, so that you then imagine taking that suffering from that person and and you imagine experiencing it yourself. And the purpose of doing that is to try to suffocate, to destroy the self-cherishing thought because this is the complete opposite to what the self-cherishing thought wants.

It doesn’t want to know about the suffering of others. And you do that in association with also imagining giving your happiness and all the causes of your happiness to that person. You take their suffering and experience it yourself, imagining that destroys your self-cherishing, liberates the pure nature of your mind, and then you imagine that from that pure state, you give all your dharma understanding, all your merits, all your happiness, all your good karmic imprints, you give to that person or all other sentient beings, imagining that becomes the cause for their their real happiness. And again, one does that to counteract the self-cherishing thought that that never feels satisfied with how much happiness we have. We always want more and more and more.

We feel as though we can’t give things because we we need everything ourselves. Śāntideva in the Guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life says something like, you know, this mind of self-cherishing that never has enough for oneself, doesn’t want to give, is the way of thinking of the hungry ghosts. Whereas the way of thinking of the gods and here the term gods is actually really referring to Buddhas and Bodhisattvas. For them, they think they they never have enough to give to others. You know, we think, with hungry ghost state of mind, if I give this to others, I won’t have anything to make me happy.

Whereas the bodhisattvas think what do they think? If I keep this for myself, then there’s nothing to give to make others happy. I’m sure it’s put much better in Śāntideva, but it’s along those lines. Yeah. If I keep this, sentient beings will suffer.

That’s the that’s the thinking of the gods and the bodhisattvas. Whereas the hungry ghosts think, if I give this away, I will suffer. So we really have to overcome that way of thinking, and what helps to do that is training the mind in this Tonglen practice of giving and taking. Because also, not only does it help reduce and eliminate the self-cherishing thought, but at the same time it also helps us cultivate love and compassion because the mind imagining taking the suffering away from others helps us generate compassion, and the mind imagining giving our happiness to others helps us cultivate great love. And by cultivating this in a really, really powerful way, one eventually comes to the conclusion that and you can by involving your mind in it more and more, it helps develop that very courageous mind that is willing to take on suffering, all the suffering of following the path.

But also, the more you imagine that and you imagine taking on the suffering of others and actually being able to give to others, the more you want to do it in reality because you think, oh yes, it’s very how wonderful to be able to imagine that, but how even better it would be to actually do it. So how am I going to do it? The only way I can do it is to become a Buddha. I can’t just leave it at sitting on the cushion, you know, visualizing things and imagining how nice it is to take the suffering of others and give them them happiness, but I have to really do this. Yeah.

So I have to become a Buddha. That’s the only way I can do it. Therefore, I will become a Buddha. That’s bodhicitta. bodhicitta is that mind determined to become a Buddha in order to end the suffering of others and bring them perfect happiness.

Right. So what helps to generate bodhicitta? There’s many many things, renouncing this life, renouncing saṃsāra, generating equanimity, purifying the mind, accumulating merit, relying on the spiritual guide, what else? That’s about it. But also what helps, of course, doing all the studying the teachings on all these things and and meditating on them, putting them into practice.

But also what helps us to generate bodhicitta and once it’s generated to maintain it and increase it is taking the bodhisattva vows. So these there’s no time to go into these in any detail, but it’s very good to study these vows. There are what are called the wishing vows and the engaging bodhisattva vows. So at some point, if one wants to follow the, you know, the Tibetan tradition, which is about encouraging us to follow the path to enlightenment, it is very good to take the bodhisattva vows, to make that commitment to achieve enlightenment for the sake of all beings. And at the heart of taking the bodhisattva vowels, what the bodhisattva vowels is basically committing to practice what are called the six perfections or the six pāramitā in the Sanskrit term, which is translated as perfection is pāramitā.

Actually, word pāramitā means something like gone to the other other side, something like that. It will take us to the other side beyond saṃsāra, beyond suffering, to enlightenment. So to achieve, to generate bodhicitta, one needs needs to practice the six perfections, but having generated bodhicitta, to maintain it and develop one’s bodhicitta, one has to continue the practice and actually perfect these six practices. So I’d just like to talk briefly about these tonight. So the six perfections are the practice of generosity, morality, patience, perseverance, concentration, and wisdom.

So the first five practices are related to the method side of practice, or one could say the, like, the compassion side of the practice, and of course, develop the six perfection of wisdom, of course, is the wisdom side. You need these two, you know, as they say in the teachings, to fly to enlightenment, you need the two wings of method and wisdom, and you need to combine them. Can you just repeat this piece again? Yes. I’ll repeat it many times.

So these six perfections are also although we try to these are also practiced in the Theravāda path to achieving nirvana. These are like essential Buddhist practices, but in the Theravāda tradition, again, the motivation is basically one’s own benefit. Of course, practicing the six perfections benefits others, but the main purpose is to accumulate merit, purify the mind, create the conditions for oneself to achieve nirvana, but what distinguishes the six perfections in the Mahāyāna tradition is practicing them with the bodhicitta motivation. So they’re practiced at deeper level, with a deeper motivation. And it’s important to try to understand that although we’re encouraged to, in this life, try to practice all of these six perfections, these are fundamental practices in practicing generosity, morality, patience, perseverance, concentration and wisdom.

They develop sequentially. First one needs to perfect generosity and the more we perfect that, we’re able to then perfect the practice of morality, then patience, then perseverance, then concentration, and eventually wisdom. There is a very famous book called The Guide to the Sanskrit name for it, it was written by this great bodhisattva Śāntideva in the eighth century of this era. The Sanskrit term for it is the Bodhicaryāvatāra, which is translated into English as something like the guide to the bodhisattva way of life or entering the bodhisattva way of life. Something like that.

So this is an amazingly wonderful text, probably the single most popular Mahāyāna text in Tibetan Buddhism, probably the most quoted text of any text in Buddhism, in the Tibetan tradition. His Holiness, the Dalai Lama says, whatever good qualities he’s developed in this life comes from studying and meditating and practicing Śāntideva’s Guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life. So that’s about the six perfections. And in the ninth chapter, which is about developing wisdom, in the very first verse that ninth chapter, Śāntideva says, all of the previous five perfections were taught for the purpose of developing wisdom. And in fact, in other words, one could say all of the Buddhist teachings are about developing wisdom.

Because why do we need wisdom? We need this wisdom to destroy ignorance, which is the source of our suffering, To get out of saṃsāra, to end our suffering completely, so that it will never ever come back, even the tiniest bit for one second, we have to develop this wisdom as the complete antidote to ignorance, which is the very root cause of cyclic existence and samsaric suffering. But also, so if we want to experience nirvana, we have to develop this wisdom. But if we want to achieve enlightenment, we have to develop this wisdom as well. But even make it stronger because even if we get out of saṃsāra, this is an important point that many people don’t seem to get, that there is a difference between nirvana and enlightenment.

In fact, there is a huge difference between nirvana and enlightenment. Or you could say in another way, there is a huge difference between being an arhat and being a Buddha. An arhat experiences nirvana, only a Buddha experiences enlightenment. And in a very simple nutshell, the difference between them is that when one achieves nirvana, as an arhat, like a human arhat, you know, suddenly you practice as a human being and then you become an arhat, you destroy, you develop the wisdom that completely destroys ignorance. So as an arhat, your suffering has finished, you’re completely blissed out all the time, and you can go around being kind to people and helping them and teaching them the Dharma, encouraging them to practice the Dharma, etcetera.

But when an arhat dies, when their contaminated body dies, their mind continues in this state of nirvana forever, and in that state they are totally unaware of anything other than the blissful feeling of their mind. They have no awareness of the earth, human beings, the universe, sentient beings, or anything. Nada. Nothing. So not having that awareness, they can’t help sentient beings because they’re just blissed out, which is nice for them but not beneficial for others.

This is why we’re encouraged to follow the Buddha path, the path to enlightenment, because a Buddha experiences an even greater bliss than an Arahant, but a Buddha is awake all the time. The Buddha is fully aware all the time, and that awareness is not just the awareness of a human being, but it is omniscient awareness, which is really hard to keep one’s tiny mind around what omniscience means, especially because there are two versions of omniscience. There’s the Theravāda version and there’s the Mahāyāna version. So in a nutshell, in a simple version, the Theravāda version of omniscience is that a Buddha can know, you know, there’s nothing obstructing the Buddha’s mind, so a Buddha, if they want to know something, they can know it. If some, you know, like, if someone’s a Buddha sitting here and someone’s in New York and the Buddha thinks, oh, I’d like to know what Freddie so and so in New York City is thinking at the moment, they could just tune in to that person and know what they’re thinking completely or and see what they’re doing and everything, whatever.

Yeah. But when when the Buddha’s not interested in Freddie so and so in New York, then they’re not aware of them. But, you know, anything they want to know that is knowable, the omniscient mind of the Buddha can know. The Mahāyāna idea of of the omniscience is far more mind blowing than that. According to the Mahāyāna version, omniscience means that our Buddha’s mind is aware of everything everything all the time.

And is and is not only aware of the present of everything all the time, but the past of everything all the time and the future of everything. The Buddha is aware of the past, present, and future of every single existing phenomena all the time. So the Buddha is fully aware of our minds, of the minds of all sentient beings all the time and everything else without ever getting confused knows everything all the time. It doesn’t take a few seconds to recall it. The Buddha is absolutely in the moment of everything all the time.

So that mind is very helpful to benefiting sentient beings because the Buddha’s mind knows exactly what’s going on in every sentient being’s mind all the time, always has, always will, without any mistake. So to get that mind, you need the wisdom to destroy ignorance, but see the difference just again in a very simple way, the difference between when an arahat has removed the basic obscurations of the mind, the ignorance and delusions and negative karmic imprints, but according to the teachings, an arahat’s mind is still obscured. It still has these very, very subtle obscurations. And these obscurations are said to be the Although the ignorance and delusions have been removed, there is still somehow a very subtle imprint of them existing. And that prevents the mind being fully omniscient, having perfect love, compassion, etcetera, etcetera.

So what gets rid of those very subtle obscurations is the same wisdom that destroys ignorance, but it’s more powerful and what empowers it is bodhicitta, that incredible determination to achieve enlightenment. So the people following the, with all due respect, the Theravāda path to nirvana, they never cultivate that. Does that make some sense? Right. Okay.

So the first of the six perfections is generosity. This is the first to cultivate, the first to put effort in. We we should try as much as possible if we want to follow if we want to follow Tibetan Buddhism, follow the path, we should try in this life each day, practice all the six perfections as much possible, but the first one to really emphasize as beginners is generosity because it’s the first attack also. I mean, there’s many ways to look at why we practice all these things. Generosity is the cause for wealth, yeah, to have all the resources needed, not wealth, know, not that we need to be, you know, super rich, but it’s it’s the cause to have resources, to have abundance, to have the things that we need to survive and also to practice the Dharma.

So we need to practice generosity. Poverty and lack of resources is because of not practicing the Dharma. Not practicing generosity, sorry. But also, generosity practicing generosity, if you think about it, is is beginning to undermine the gross self-cherishing thought and also even the subtle self-cherishing thought. Yeah.

Because to give, you have to think of others and their happiness. And by giving, you see that makes them happy. You want to give and you also want to make them happier. And you can bet and you can also think, well, I’m giving this, you know, I give this pomegranate to someone, it makes them happy. But then you can think that happiness is just it’s good to do, but really that happiness is just very short lived.

How wonderful if I could give them everlasting happiness, if I could give them other sentient beings. So it’s planting the seed to want to make people happier and happier in a more in a more profound, longer lasting way. So it’s the first line of attack on our self-cherishing thought. Because we, you know, we we have the whole aim of the Buddha’s teachings is to get rid of ignorance. Yeah?

Because that’s the source of our suffering, prevents us achieving nirvana, prevents us achieving enlightenment. So we have this self grasping ignorance, but because of that, we have self-cherishing. And, Because of ignorance, we have self-cherishing, but our self-cherishing also reinforces our ignorance. And because of ignorance, we have self-cherishing, and our self-cherishing reinforces our ignorance. It’s a really nasty combination.

So we have to try to reduce the more we can reduce our self-cherishing, the easier it will be to attack our self grasping ignorance. So also it’s important to understand that generosity doesn’t refer to giving lots of stuff, that doesn’t make you generous. Generosity, because if it was, only rich people with lots of stuff could practice and perfect generosity. Generosity is referring to a state of mind, and so it’s a state of mind that wants to give. That’s what we need to cultivate and enjoys giving.

Yeah. There are people who can give millions of dollars, but that’s because they’ve already got billions and there’s really nothing to them. Often, many people with billions of dollars aren’t willing to give that anyway, but and, of course, one can give for all sorts of false reasons for reputation and and blah blah blah. So here, the practice of generosity is, you know, developing that mind that wants to give, that is happy to give in in the sense of wanting to bring happiness to others and enjoys doing that. That’s the mind we have to cultivate.

And just very quickly, there are said to be three main types of giving. There’s the obvious giving of material stuff, you know, money and possessions and this and that. And then there is what is called the the the giving of protection from fear. And and that’s about sort of, you know, supporting and developing one’s love and compassion for people and helping those who are in in how can you say? Just unhappy in any way, doing the best one can to help people who are sick and suffering in some form or other.

So you’re you know, support to that person who who who needs some kind of protection because of sickness and sadness and suffering and depression and and whatever. And then the final type of giving, which is said ultimately to be the best, is the giving of Dharma, of teaching the Dharma. But this, of course, means teaching properly with a very not like me, blah blah, but teaching with a very pure motivation in a very perfect way that is, you know, really suited to the minds of the people one is teaching. So that is said to be the highest giving because if you think about it, it is because teaching the Dharma is that is giving the method to become free of suffering. It is the method to achieve everlasting, peerless everlasting happiness.

There’s no better gift than that. So to be able to give that is the best you know, that’s the best gift. Because even a Buddha can’t give happiness to others. A Buddha can’t give freedom from suffering to others, but what a Buddha can give is perfect teachings, teachings, perfect inspiration. Yeah?

So that’s the best gift. And the Buddha’s already done that in this world and continues to do it by appearing as gurus and so on. So the more we practice generosity and see how beneficial that is to others, this acts as a basis for being able to practice morality, practice moral discipline, ethical discipline. Because the more we see how good it is, you know, how it brings some some real contentment and well-being within ourselves when we bring some, even some temporary happiness to others, then the more we practice generosity, the more we will be disinclined to engage in non virtuous actions which harm others and we want to engage in virtuous actions which benefit benefits others more and more. The great Lama Atisha once said that the highest moral practice is a peaceful mind.

If we have a peaceful mind, we will tend to be just naturally virtuous. We won’t with a peaceful mind, there isn’t those thoughts to harm. If we have a genuinely peaceful mind, we won’t want to harm others. We won’t want to steal, lie, engage in sexual misconduct and all these things, and we’ll be happy to live a virtuous life if we have a peaceful mind. So there are said to be three kinds of ways one practices morality, moral discipline, that the essential one is restraining from engaging in negative actions.

Next is engaging in virtuous actions. Many people get upset that Buddhism always tends to emphasize the negative first rather than the positive, but if you think about it, it’s very clever. It’s more than clever, it’s very profound and shows the wisdom of the Buddha because if one just worked on trying to increase one’s virtuous actions, this would be very nice. But if we don’t stop the negative tendencies in mind which lead us to engage in virtuous negative actions, no matter how much good we do, our negative actions will under under undermine the good stuff if if that’s if we’ve got that really well established, then any actively virtuous things we do will be will be so much more beneficial and long lasting. Yeah?

Like some politicians who I won’t mention, who have done many good things, but unfortunately, they did some naughty things. And that’s undermined their reputation, not just their reputation, their because what goes with reputation is one’s ability to influence and and and do good stuff and, you know, weaken one’s ability. And and so there are, you know, throughout history, there are people who’ve done really good things, but they’ve botched it up because some other aspect of their their life led them to do some other not so great things. Oh, and the third form of of moral discipline is just generally working for the benefit of others, doing anything that benefits others. So for example, studying the Dharma.

Just studying the Dharma is a practice of can can be seen as a practice of morality because one’s I mean, if one’s doing it with the right motivation, because that practice will eventually be of benefit to others. So one can see that as part of one’s moral discipline. So if you think about it, the more one practices generosity, the more it becomes easy to practice morality, and the more we practice those two things together in harmony, then it becomes easier to practice patience, which is the antidote to anger, and anger is is the single most destructive emotion causing so much harm to others. And, you know, in following the Bodhisattva way of life, what are we trying to do? Stop.

We want We’re trying to develop the compassion that can’t bear the suffering of others, developing the love that wants others to have genuine lasting happiness, so how can we get angry with them and cause them incredible suffering? So the more we practice generosity and morality, there’s a really fantastic basis to be able to practice patience, which is the antidote to anger. I mean, one has to cultivate patience by thinking about all the harm of anger and so on, but that cultivation will work better, you know, if we’ve got this underlying basis of developing generosity and morality. Yeah. You can disagree if you like.

God. And there are three kinds of patience. So the first one is the obvious one of having compassion for the enemy. Because basically, if you think about it, what what patience is, it is related to compassion. Compassion for one doesn’t get angry from the point of view of oneself, having compassion for oneself because getting angry is is really and, you know, all anger is creating these incredibly negative imprints that are going to bring great suffering to oneself.

And what’s worse, our anger destroys our positive imprints, which are the source of all our happiness. And on top of that, those negative imprints are obscuring our mind, making it difficult to practice the Dharma and follow the path. So if we have real compassion for ourselves, we we will try not to get angry, and also if we’re developing compassion for others, we will try not to get angry because our anger will lead us to harm them. Important to remember, or I say, patience is a huge, huge topic, best explained by Śāntideva in the book I mentioned, the Guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life, there’s a very famous chapter on it, but it’s important to understand when we get angry, the the it is it is completely negative, it’s always negative. Yeah?

And the negative effect is only felt by oneself. The effect, the negative effect is only felt by oneself because one creates these negative imprints, you know, within one’s consciousness, which ripen to bring suffering only to oneself. But of course, you know, anger is expressed by screaming and yelling at other people, punching them, killing and stabbing and whatever. So that is having a harmful affect on others. My anger is having a bad affect on others which lasts just this life.

You know, I scream at you, punch you or something, so you get a bit upset or have a bit of a bruise, but my anger at you has created this imprint that is going to bring incredible suffering in the future. So anger, the effect is oneself. Of course, my anger towards an individual may have all sorts of bad consequences in this life, you know, I get a bad reputation, he goes around and tries to, you know, I don’t know, puncture my tires. Then I have a car accident, get into a fight with a person I, you know, know, so all sorts of consequences from that, but the main effect is the karmic imprint that ripens to bring incredible suffering, part of which can be meeting another enemy. And also there’s the, you know, you’ve put the imprint of the delusion of anger in your mind again, you’ve created the habit to get angry again.

So there’s this there’s essential patience of not, you know, of of of Not suppressing one’s anger, but subduing one’s anger in relation to the enemy, the so called enemy. Then there is the the the patience of voluntarily accepting one’s own suffering. Right? Because we can get angry with ourselves, we can get angry with our own limitations, our delusions, you know, we can get angry because we can’t meditate properly. We can’t we can get angry because we’re not as holy as we would like to be, something like that.

Yeah. We could get yeah. We get angry with ourselves in so many ways and and and with sort of life in general or something, so we need to develop that patience as well. Yeah. Even from an ordinary point of view, but especially if if we’re following the spiritual path.

But ultimately, the most important patience to develop is the patience of being able to practice the Dharma, because Dharma practice is difficult, as you may have started to realize. There there’s no such thing as easy Dharma practice because Dharma practice is about working with one’s mind, change changing the mind, and that this is not easy. It is not easy. It’s not easy for anyone. It it it takes constant work and yeah.

And there’s many difficulties of working with one’s own mind. There’s the difficulties of understanding the the teachings, the difficulties of putting them into practice, there’s the difficulties of dealing with sentient beings. Sentient beings are not easy. Sentient beings are difficult. Yeah.

It’s very it’s very difficult to make sentient beings happy. It’s not easy. There are many stories in the Dharma of, you know, great bodhisattvas having a really hard time trying to help sentient beings and almost giving up in desperation. So one needs that patience. As I’ve quoted many times, my teacher, Lama Zopa Rinpoche says, there is no is nobody who has achieved any spiritual qualities who has not been able to bear suffering.

If you cannot bear suffering, there’s no way to follow the spiritual path. No way. So you have to meditate, for example, to achieve realizations one has to meditate. To meditate, you have to sit in meditation. You have to put your body in meditation posture so that there’s aches and pains.

It’s inevitable. It’s inevitable. Someone has to learn to do it and make your mind do it as well. We need that patience. But what helps develop that is the wish to benefit all sentient beings.

So the more one’s bodhicitta motivation, the more one can practice it. And then the more we’ve developed patience on the basis of practicing generosity and morality, then it becomes easier to practice one of the most important Actually, all the six perfections are very important, but one of the most important is perseverance or enthusiastic joy. So the definition of perseverance, the Sanskrit term that is translated, is virya, and definition of this or Śāntideva’s definition of virya is, which I really like, it’s the only definition in the Dharma I actually remember, all these great scholars, know, the Geshe’s can rattle off millions of definitions, I don’t know any of them except this one, which is perseverance is finding joy in the practice of Dharma or finding joy in what is wholesome, in what is virtuous. And if you think about it, if you enjoy doing meaningful things, virtuous things, practicing the Dharma, if you find joy in you actually it makes you happy, there’s some joy in practicing the Dharma, you will do it. If you don’t get any joy out of it, you won’t do it.

And because you don’t do it, there’s no result. You don’t we don’t progress. But if we actually find some joy, even if it’s difficult and it may be painful, one physically, it may be difficult, it may be painful, and even mentally, in some ways, But part of the mind thinks, oh, this is really good. I’m doing something fantastic for all sentient beings. Yeah.

I don’t mean that in some kind of arrogant way, how terrific I am, but just that simple recognition that recognition that what I’m trying to do is correct, it’s the right thing to do, it’s the best thing to do for myself and others. Yeah. There is nothing better than this. That should give joy, some joy. Not just, you know, rolling around hysterical happiness type of stuff, but some calm joy.

Yeah? And when you have that, you’ll be happy. That gives energy to keep doing these things. Because if one is not happy doing something, there’s no energy to do it. You know, we have lots of energy energy to to shop.

Yeah? Window shop, actual shop, party, prepare for parties, go to the footy, come, you know, go to the pub, all of these things. We have lots of energy to do that. But when it comes to Dharma practice, not so much energy. Because we follow the self-cherishing thought that says this is hard and difficult, so there’s no joy.

We listen to the self-cherishing thought that says this is difficult, this is taking too long, this is bad. But if we didn’t listen to that thought, it would be different. But that thought tends to get in the way because it’s so old and it’s so habitual. It always gets in first. But if we can let our wisdom get in first, we can find joy in practicing the Dharma.

And then you can see that’s what if you’ve met Lama Zopa Rinpoche Rinpoche’s name is Zopa, which patience, the perfection of patience. But Lama Zopa Rinpoche is also the perfection of enthusiastic joy. Because you can see his Rinpoche’s whole life is just doing virtuous things, and he gets incredible enjoyment out of it, and he has endless energy to do it. Endless energy. As I’ve often said, because I was Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s attendant for three years, in all of that time, I think I saw Rinpoche lie down maybe three times.

Vertical. Rinpoche does not go to bed. Much too boring, wasting time sleeping. Rinpocheer only goes to sleep when he cannot keep awake because why would you ever go to sleep when you can benefit sentient beings? Studying, meditating, doing pujas, stuff.

True. I’m not lying. It’s just amazing. And Rinpoche’s been like this since he was about five or six. All the little talk when he went to the Sera Je School for monks.

Frida Bates School for talkers. All the other monks used to throw pillows at him at night because he was still up studying when they were going to sleep. So Rinpoche then had a stroke a few years ago, and then he was supposed to do all these exercises for his stroke, but, of course, he would never do those because they were a waste of time when you when you why do those things when you could practice Dharma? Because most of the symptoms of your stroke have gone away now, most. Yeah.

Same with this wholeness, you know, how old is this wholeness? Charging around the world nonstop, flying. Try it. Try it. I did it for three years with Lama Zopa Rinpoche, landed, flew from Australia to Los Angeles and immediately Rinpoche went out to have lunch with someone.

I stayed home and just went gaga, completely jet lagged, insane. I just I just went I was just completely out of it. But his holiness in Rinpoche, His Holiness and Rinpoche, they just travel nonstop. Meet meet a couple hundred people at the end of the airport, you know, they don’t go First thing they have to do after the airplane is, you know, to shake hands with three hundred people, which they do happily with enthusiastic joy, and then do something else and then something else and then something else and then something else and then something else and then fly somewhere else and it all starts again. And they don’t complain.

They’re having a terrific time, a terrific time, because they don’t listen to the self-cherishing thought. They find joy in practicing what is wholesome and meaningful. Real joy. Yeah. We can do it sometime.

That mean his whole entourage is also involved in this nonstop? Pretty well, they they have to take it in turns. They sleep like like Rinpoche’s attendants. They take it in turns getting up and going to bed and doing stuff. I was the only attendant.

Rinpoche used to make me we used to I used to have to write letters for Rinpoche up until about two in the morning, then at four o’clock I had to get up, then I would rush back to bed, and at four o’clock I had to make him Rinpoche a cup of tea and take it to his room every morning. He never drank it, but I always had to make the cup of tea. That was just to make me get up. But of course, after making the cup of tea, I would go back to bed again. So how can you survive on this much little sleep?

I think it’s called bodhicitta. It gives you a lot of energy. And Rinpoche is just not an ordinary being. I mean, he is he is a genuine incarnated lama, that he is the real thing. There’s no question.

Not yeah. Really, I I mean, I was with Rinpoche for three years. There’s no ordinary person does you know, you can fool some of the people some of the time, but even even me, you can’t fool all of the time. Mhmm. Mhmm.

I mean, Rinpoche was just an incredible incredible being and just amazing. Never does anything for himself. Nothing nothing ordinary. Nothing ordinary at all. But still manages to look ordinary all the time.

And some people think he’s kind of needs help. Poor guy can’t speak English properly and he shakes around. Some good stories. Oh, yes. Well, also Roger is quite amazing.

He is also superman, unbelievable being. There’s no question. Yes, of course. Yes. Yes.

Sure. To achieve that. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. But it’s all part of the same thing. To be able to do that though, you have to have a motivation. I mean, people are oh, you know, in the past, you know, Rinpoche asked people, Rinpoche to have a holiday.

So Rinpoche’s idea of a holiday is thinking up new more things to do. Rinpoche I have no idea what a holiday is. You know, our idea a holiday, Rinpoche’s idea of a holiday is practicing more and more Dharma. It’s amazing. So then the more we develop where are we?

Is a bell supposed to ring sometime? Have we got a bell ringer? Has someone forgotten You’re Four minutes. Seven? Ten.

Ten? Oh. The more if you think about it, the more we develop this enthusiastic perseverance which really enjoys, has energy to practice the Dharma, then it becomes easier to perfect the next practice, the next perfection, which is meditative concentration. One will have the energy to persist in training the mind in meditation, particularly, well, particularly developing single pointed concentration, which is a necessary basis for developing wisdom. There are three kinds of so this leads into the next one.

I’ll just talk about wisdom quickly. There are three kinds of wisdom. There’s many ways of talking about wisdom. There is the wisdom that arises from hearing the dharma. This the first level of wisdom that we develop.

Because before we hear the Dharma and and trust in it, we are kind of ignorant of the truth and therefore creating the causes of suffering. But by hearing the teachings, certain with an open mind and, you know, for those who connect with them, then a certain level of wisdom develops of knowing this is right. You know, that we hear about the law of cause and effect, and of course we don’t understand it at a profound level, but we connect with it, and so there’s now that wisdom that understands negative actions have suffering consequences, not just now, but in the future. So that is a wisdom. And we know, you know, certain these actions lead to suffering, these actions bring happiness.

So that’s a wisdom. It’s an insight into what is true, either conventionally or ultimately. And then the second, a more deeper level of wisdom develops from doing what is said to be the wisdom of thinking, which refers to doing analytical meditation on the teachings. Because basically, when you hear the teachings, this is you have a wisdom that is really based on blind belief, not not necessarily much understanding, but then by doing analytical meditation, there is a wisdom which is much stronger because it’s based on logic, that you really understand why you believe a certain thing. It’s not it’s not just, you know, oh, the Buddha says so, or this teacher says so, or that sounds good, I like that.

But you have some very rational reasons to to under to underline, not undermine, underline your belief, to stabilize it and makes it very strong. And then the final kind of wisdom arises from developing single pointed concentration. So that wisdom, can by having single pointed concentration, one is then able to change one’s wisdom from a conceptual correct understanding to a direct perception. Because with single pointed concentration, your mind is able to stay on the object long enough I I don’t think I can explain this properly. Sorry.

That might sound like I have a great deep deep understanding of it, just that doesn’t mean that, it just means I can’t explain it. No. I’ll leave that for the time being. Anyways, single pointed concentration is really important. It’s essential for developing wisdom, which is the essential aspect of the Buddhist teachings, but also all of the other realizations will develop more quickly, more easily, the sooner we develop the ability to concentrate our mind single pointedly.

Even just, you know, listening to a teaching, we are not able to listen single pointedly for very long. And because of that, we miss a lot of things, we don’t hear some of what is said, and also we misunderstand things, we forget it, and so it takes a very long time to develop a comprehensive, correct understanding of the teachings. But if we had single pointed concentration, as we listened, we would we would it would be, you know, that aids our understanding because our mind is completely focused only on what is being said. Or if you study the teachings, you read them, your mind would only be aware of the teaching. And we can’t do that now.

You know, while we’re listening to something, reading something, there’s all this this other stuff going on in our mind. And of course, if we were able to one hundred percent single pointedly focus on whatever we were hearing, seeing, reading, studying, meditating on, we would also have a more a better memory of it, we would have total recall. Why don’t why we don’t remember things so well is because when they were happening, we weren’t fully present with what was happening. What what and what we do remember well is because the event was so good or bad that we were really really aware of it. We were focused on it.

So I think many people have had the experience, if you haven’t, you will in the future, of hearing some teaching and you think, especially on things like emptiness and while it’s being taught, you can think, wow, I understand this, this is really good, now I’ve got it. And then the teaching stops and it’s gone, you can’t remember it. Just have some vague memory that, oh, that was good. Yeah. But it’s forgotten.

Yes. So It’s not easy. It’s quite difficult. But it well, I should say it is attainable? Yes.

Of course. Yes. Everything’s at that yes. Yes. And is it only a brief moment?

What? That moment when you attain it? No, no, single pointed concentrate. Once you attain it, I mean, is part of the attainment of single pointed concentration is that once you’ve achieved it, the achievement comes when you’re able to place your mind on an object, a virtuous or neutral object, and it stays there for as long you want, effortlessly. But once you’ve achieved that ability, if you don’t what’s the word?

Keep practicing it, you’ll lose it. So people can achieve single point of concentration, but maybe they they don’t meditate much, and because of that, they will lose that ability. Is is there a sensation in the body? Bet. I don’t have it, but in the teachings, explains when you when you achieve sama samadhi or especially when you achieve calm abiding, you first experience what is called physical pliancy and this then lead no.

No. You first achieve mental pliancy and then that leads to the experience of physical pliancy. And once you’ve achieved physical pliancy, this leads to a physical bliss, and that leads to mental bliss, the bliss of Samādhi, which just continues while you’re in it. It could be a few seconds or it could be minutes. Hours, days, months, years.

There are people who sit in Samādhi for months, years, and you don’t breathe, don’t have to eat. Is it achievable in one month? Yes. Yeah. This is even said to be like a worldly accomplishment.

This is not even supposed to be high level spiritual stuff. Necessary for high level spiritual stuff, spiritual stuff, spiritual realizations. But it is very difficult to achieve. You have to have lots of merit, have to purify the mind, have to have developed a bit of a reasonable degree of renunciation of this life, have to be content with simple things because you have to to achieve Samādhi, you have to eventually you can start achieving some of the stages at home, but to achieve the full result, have to go off into a very isolated, very quiet place and stay there for quite a long time until it’s achieved. And not many people can do that.

That’s the trouble. Because you have to be simp you know, satisfied with simple food, you know, no entertainment, you know, just meditating day and night on the one thing all the time. No reading, no TV, no, yeah, no friends, but people do it. Think I’ve turned everyone off. You said what’s going Like in the early you know, I I haven’t done these things, in the early days when I lived at Chenrezig Institute, there was a young guy, not a monk, was a layman.

He he did a Samādhi retreat for about two years in an abandoned farmhouse on the property next to Chenrezig Institute. I used to take him food from time to time. Oh, you know, we regularly took him food. I I did it I did it personally time to time. I don’t think he achieved it but he did very well, think.

He came out in a very calm, balanced way. Some people they do short retreats and they come out of retreat and they can’t handle life anymore. You know, nothing everything’s too too much for, you know, for a while. But he he was just completely down to earth and ordinary as soon as he came out of retreat. And I also noticed because when I used to take the food to him that around the house, there was no sign that he went outside.

Like, you know, the grass wasn’t you know, if someone had been walking around a lot, the grass would have been all trampled. Because it was just out in the countryside, so the grass grows, you know. So he he obviously stayed in the house and meditated all the time. So I don’t know what level he got, but, yeah, it can be It’s just a matter of step by step working on these things. Is that the retreat that you’re going to embark on, Sophie?

No. No. No. No. Mine’s different.

Mine’s different. I haven’t got to the end of the path, which is wisdom. It’s okay. We’re not gonna get there either. Yes.

You are. Yes. You are. Don’t say that. Don’t say No.

Okay. But Anyway, very quickly. Sorry if your if your brain’s about to pop, just in five five seconds, the very ultimate aim of all the Buddhist teachings, of all the other perfections, is to develop wisdom, the very antidote to ignorance. So ignorance is this mental factor that, because it’s there, our mind cannot perceive things correctly, it perceives things in a completely false way. So we have to develop the wisdom that is able to directly perceive the way our self and all things exist.

And Lama Tsongkhapa, the founder of the Gelugpa tradition that we follow here, says, the easiest way to develop wisdom and under undermine ignorance is to understand dependent arising. Because, in a very simple way, what ignorance does, it creates the illusion that oneself and everything exists as though it existed from its own side under its own power, which means if things did exist that way, they don’t, but if things really existed out there from their own side under their own power, it would mean, it logically follows that they didn’t depend on anything. They were just there from their own side under their own power. But if you invest in and it means they would be independently existing, not dependent on anything. For example, beautiful flower.

I assume why these are here in this vase is because someone thought either someone disliked me and thought I’ll put these ugly flowers here to upset him, or they thought, oh, these are nice flowers, make him happy. So when we look at this flower and think, pretty flower, beautiful flower, nice flower, the beauty, we seem to believe, the beauty of this object seems to be there and it just is beautiful. Why is it beautiful? Can you really explain anything you believe is beautiful? Not just this, but what you personally think, like with beautiful people, beautiful cars, beautiful objects, can you really say why you think it’s beautiful?

Can you really say? Sort of after the effect, well, it’s a not I I like that red or that’s a nice orangey red or something. Is the way we perceive? No. I’m not asking for explanation.

No. Or, you know, know, a beautiful color. Why is your your favorite color beautiful? Just is. It’s it’s obviously beautiful.

It seems to be independently beautiful. But why does something you eat taste delicious? Why is that taste delicious and that one isn’t? Just is. It seems to be just that’s this taste.

Wow, that’s a delicious thing. Seems to be just independently like that. But if we investigate, investigate, as Je Tsongkhapa says, one can start to discover actually things don’t exist that way, they appear that way, they appear to our mind, appear to ignorance, to exist out there from their own side, under their own power, as though they were independent, not depending on anything, but if you check, everything depends on well, just very quickly, sorry There are things that don’t exist at all, that are just complete fantasies and illusions, and there are things that validly or conventionally exist. An example of something that doesn’t exist at all, according to the tradition, are the horns of a rabbit. Rabbits exist, horns exist, but there are no rabbits that grow horns out of their heads.

So the horns of rabbits don’t exist at all. And then there are things that conventionally exist, validly exist, such as rabbits. Rabbits do conventionally exist. Right? And horns do also.

And of things that conventionally exist, there are two types of conventionally existing things. There are impermanent things and permanent things. Impermanent things depend on causes and conditions. Permanent things don’t depend on causes and conditions. There are only a few, very few permanent things.

I was gonna say that. One of which is space. Space is a permanent phenomenon. It never changes moment by moment. Moment by moment, it’s exactly the same.

It doesn’t change. But everything virtually everything else depends on causes and conditions, so it’s impermanent. So so this is an impermanent phenomena, so in fact, it depends for existence on causes and conditions. It also depends on parts. When we we we call this a flower, you know, one thing, it is one flower, but if you investigate, this one thing actually is made up of many parts.

This is a very good example, many parts. Is that one flower or is that one flower? Or is that a flower conventionally? Anyway, you see? And even if you say that’s a flower, actually, when you investigate yeah.

A flower, one thing, you know, at first when you don’t think about it, when you don’t analyze, it’s just a one thing. Right? But when you analyze in reality, it’s it’s made up of parts. It depends on causes and conditions. It depends on parts.

And most interestingly of all, the only way this thing can exist is depending on our mind. Yeah. And especially, it depends on how we label this thing. So does anything exist from its own side? No.

That’s the point. Right. If you investigate, nothing can exist from its own side under its own power. If you investigate everything impermanent and the vast Let’s forget the permanent things because our world is made up, our body, everything we use is impermanent. So if you investigate, it depends on causes and conditions, parts and our mind.

This object has no ability from its side to make us experience it as a flower or I have no idea what kind of flower. Does anyone know don’t yell out the name, but does anyone know what kind of flower this is? Right? I have no idea. I don’t think I’ve ever seen this flower type of flower before.

But this does everyone agree this is a fruit, a piece of fruit? Don’t. Does anyone don’t don’t be shy. Does anyone not know what kind of fruit this is? Not to know.

You don’t know. You don’t know. But if I had an you know what an apple looks like. Right? Yes.

So if I was holding an apple, you would know it was an apple. Right? This comes from this planet. Right? It’s a piece of you you agree it’s a piece of fruit?

So if if I was holding an apple, apple, why can’t why don’t you know what this is? Because I haven’t talked. Right. Right. Haven’t experienced it before.

Right. But they both exist in the same way. And every time you see an apple, you know an apple. Right? You don’t have to be told every time you see an apple.

Once you’ve been told once, you can tell all the similar things that’s an apple. Yeah. But when you look at an apple that you’ve never seen before, it just looks to be obviously an apple. Right? It seems to be saying, I’m an apple, and this exists in the same way, but this has no way to tell you what it is from its side.

But every time we look at anything, it doesn’t seem as though it depends on us being told what that is. It just seems to be obviously a flower or a vase or a glass or glasses or a pomegranate. What about you? What what about me? What about you?

What? What about you? What about me? Yeah. What about you?

Are you existing from your own side? No. No. Neither are you. Nothing exists from its own side.

I depend on causes and conditions, parts, I have parts. And I depend on my mind and the labeling. I have many labels. Like, I’m labeled a monk. See, some people when they look at me, they don’t see me as a monk because they don’t have that label.

They don’t identify. They think I’m just dressed up, you know, for a fancy party. Who suddenly said that to me? Just some old guy came when was it? Where was that?

Just a few days ago. What if he said something kind of it was meant to be funny, but it was could have been taken as insulting. I was on the on the ferry. I think it was on the ferry going to Kangaroo Island. I know a Mongol story, they thought he had a great fancy dress uniform.

Yeah. Was terrific. Yeah. Anyway, but other people see you you see, they label monk, but then also when people see this, they they label, oh, this is bad, this is ridiculous, other people label good so that they see when I was in I’m sorry. When I was in Taiwan, I think I was the only western monk in Taiwan when I lived there.

Or there weren’t too many, that’s for sure. Little kids would see me and scream and run away, but I remember once, it happened, you know, old old ladies and men would look at me and glare at me, Whole busloads of people would stare at me. Remember being on a bus once, squashed in Taiwanese buses, you’re squashed in this bus and there was this young woman with a baby on her shoulder was looking, and the young woman turned around and saw me and she smiled, and she was obviously somehow really she must have been Buddhist, and somehow I got the impression she was very happy to see this foreigner who was a Buddhist monk. So, you know, she had this genuine, like, friendly attitude and she so but when she moved, the baby could see me and the baby smiled. I think the baby picked up mom’s vibe.

Mhmm. That was meant to explain, merely labeled. Depends you know, some people look at me and think, what? Scary, weird, creepy. Other people think, oh, nice.

Oh, not nice. And it’s changed in the early days. Yeah. I mean, definitely, people look look at you and think, I still do think it’s weird and creepy and funny and ridiculous, but more and more people look at you and say, oh, you know, they associate you with a Dalai Lama and some people even think I’m a Dalai Lama. What are you laughing at?

He’s just looking at and seeing if he’s got a gap in his teeth. No. He doesn’t love me as you have. So, yeah, it’s all labeled by the mind, but then your mind labels good, bad, beautiful, ugly, this and that, but then it then it appears back that way, as what my teacher says. Our mind puts a label, projects something onto something, but then in the very next moment it appears back as though that’s what it really is there.

It’s not that I’ve labeled it this, it’s not that I’ve labeled it a pomegranate, but it is one. It appears back from its own side, and that’s the problem. And nothing is like that because everything depends on causes and conditions, parts, and the labeling mind. So this is what we we need to cultivate this wisdom that is aware that everything we experience, our mind, our body, you know, other people, everything is arising dependently and especially depending on our mind. We can develop this wisdom, the best wisdom of all.

But when things appear truly existing, the problem is because things from the basic existence appears truly existing, then also the qualities of the things also appear truly existing as beautiful, ugly, good and bad, and because of that, and only because of that, do we have the delusions. If we didn’t see, experience things as truly existing from their own side, we wouldn’t have afflicted desire, we wouldn’t have anger, we wouldn’t have fear and aversion and pride and jealousy. But because things appear so concretely like this out there separately, we have these delusions and therefore we have suffering. Whereas when we experience things with wisdom as being empty, we experience their true nature as empty of inherent existence, that experience is bliss. They say bliss.

That’s what we’re into, but that’s what we’re trying to get. But also the ultimate wisdom is experiencing bliss that is fully aware at the same time, completely aware, a total vibrant awareness of everything. Blissful awareness. Wisdom. That’s what we’re trying to get.

Blissful awareness. So to help us to do that, we need to try and practice that everything we’re experiencing is an illusion. It’s the illusion of inherent existence. When we change our mind, everything changes. The whole world changes when we change our mind.

Because the world isn’t separate from us, it appears to be, but it ain’t. But you always look like that. What? I hope not. Oh, no.

The the hot mean you fly because you get older and older and older and all of that sort of stuff. Mhmm. But you look like that in a second or in a minute, you’ll still be I so struggle with this concept. I mean, I I get it at a at a like a Yeah. It’s very very yeah.

It is very profound. It’s very difficult. Don’t expect to understand it not just like that. It’s impossible. The understanding arises dependently.

It depend your understanding of dependent arising arises depending on purifying your mind, accumulating merit, listening to these teachings over and over again, and thinking about them over and meditating on them over and over again. But you are not an illusion. I didn’t say I was. The appearance you have of me is an illusion. My existence is like an illusion.

I do exist. Yeah, you do. Yeah. But not the way you think. You don’t exist the way you think either.

Nothing does the way you think it does, but it still exists. Because for something to be empty, it has to exist. What? For something to be empty. It has to.

To be empty of inherent existence, it has to exist. Something the horns of a rabbit aren’t empty of inherent existence because they don’t exist at all. A rabbit is empty of inherent existence because a rabbit exists. Can you explain inherent existence? No.

I’ve just been trying to. Inherent existence refers to things existing as though they are there from their own side under their own power, implying that they would be independent. Because when look, this flower the flower seems to in its existence seems to be inherently within there. The beauty seems to inherently exist there, but you can’t find the the beauty of this flower, one can say, conventionally exists, but you cannot find an inherently existing beauty there. Do?

Good. I don’t know if I do. It’s taken me for a long time. Okay. It’s like we all agree beauty exists.

Yeah? But beauty exists. It exists conventionally. It just exists conventionally because you cannot find it. What, you know, what one person labels beautiful is not beautiful for another person, but nevertheless, beauty exists.

If everything inherently existed, you would be able to find it separately, independently, and say, there it is. But you can’t do that with anything, actually. Short things exist, but you can’t but only conventionally. Long things exist, but only conventionally, because if they inherently existed, you could say that is a long thing, and everyone would agree that was a long thing, but compared to something else, it’s short. But if it inherently existed as a long thing, it would be a long thing in relation to everything.

But you can’t find such a thing. Just like you can’t find a beautiful thing from its if it if there was an inherently existing beautiful thing, it would be beautiful in all times, in all situations, for all people. Doesn’t exist. So even even emptiness only conventionally exists. That’s a killer.

Isn’t it? That it only conventionally exists. Oh, tea oh, tea break discussion. Yeah? Oh, is there time?

No. No. Oh, I’ve done it. We’ll have an early minute maybe. Questions?

This is it. The end. Is this the last? Yeah. Ignorance?

Like, the Christian belief would have a, you know, a fall from grace. Right. And thus the inherent Apple apples and things? Yes. Eating of apples.

Comparable view within Buddhist practice? No. No. No. No.

No. There’s no beginning. Yeah. There’s no beginning to anything because I think I’ve explained this. Here is the mind, right, which is naturally pure.

Yeah? If if if ignorance started come on this. Here is the mind, continuity of mind. So if ignorance, which is naturally pure, so if ignorance is removed completely, the gross subtle ignorance is removed sorry. Ignorance and subtle imprints are removed, you have enlightenment.

Right? So this is an enlightened mind here. But no. Hold on. If ignorance is removed here, you’ve got enlightened mind, and then you’ve got ignorant mind here, obscured mind.

But if ignorance started, if ignorance started here, it would mean that, you know, this is it starts here, so now the mind is obscured, and that would mean before it started, the mind was enlightened. That’s impossible, because the very nature of enlightenment is that it is correctly experiencing everything as it is. That mind will not suddenly experience things as they are not. If it did, there would be no point to get enlightened because you get enlightened and ignorance would start again. But the whole point of achieving nirvana and enlightenment even before you achieve enlightenment, ignorant you know, enlightenment means ignorance has ceased in a way it never returns.

But if if ignorance is something that started, you you could achieve nirvana, and after some time, it would end. And you’d be ignorant again, or you’d achieve enlightenment, and then it would end and you’d be ignorant again. But the whole point of achieving nirvana and enlightenment is to stop all suffering, and it does. Because this is the very nature of wisdom. Once you are seeing things as they are, you don’t start seeing them as they aren’t.

Ignorance never started. It’s always existed. But it does end. Yes. No questions?

When when you’re in that space, if you’re not being distracted, you’re in a situation where there’s nothing to distract very few things. And then oh, can I talk about it first, please? We have to talk about it. Okay. So then I become aware that there’s anger.

I would like to know what is the Buddhist way to work with removing that from the body? Well, anger isn’t in your body. It’s in your mind. Right. I’m labeling this feeling or this experience It will affect your body for sure, but anger is a state of mind.

Right? Yes. Right. So how do you remove it? Is that the question?

Well, you can’t actually remove it, you can subdue it, right? You can reduce it, pacify it and that is done, I tried to say I think last week that you subdue it with patience, cultivating patience, but you have to cultivate patience when you’re not angry. Right? And you cultivate is a huge subject, but you cultivate patience. There’s millions of ways, arguments, but basically you cultivate patience just like you cultivate all the antidotes to all the delusions by being aware, really knowing more and more deeply in your heart the harm of that delusion.

In our society we are told that anger is bad, right? So we believe that but in being told that, not a great deal of explanation is given why it is. So we tell ourselves, we have been brought up believing anger is bad, I shouldn’t be angry, it’s bad to be angry. But just saying that, knowing that, is very very superficial and doesn’t have much power to really subdue anger. Especially if one’s anger is really really strong because it’s affecting, because one’s self-cherishing thought is being strongly affected in some way.

We have to reflect, think deeply about why anger is bad, not just simply say anger is bad, but to really know in our heart that it is. Not simply because the Buddha says so, the Dharma says this, this and this, but we have to come to this agreement, this deep agreement in our own heart that it is harmful. And the more reasons we have for believing how harmful it is to ourselves now and in the future, harmful to others now and in the future, then the more we’ve ingrained that understanding in our mind, when anger starts to arise, that understanding will arise as an antidote, as an opponent. But we have to cultivate it because with all our delusions, including anger, when anger arises, it arises — part of the reason anger occurs is because we believe anger is appropriate for the situation. We have habituated ourselves into believing even superficially because of culture and blah blah blah we say it’s bad, but emotionally we have conditioned ourselves to believing this is the way to deal, this is the best way to deal with the problem.

You know, our self-cherishing has conditioned us to say, getting angry, this will do it. So it happens instinctively. So we have to decondition that by conditioning ourselves to to understand, not just superficially believe, but have a deep understanding that anger is incredibly destructive. Alright. Yeah?

Yes. That wasn’t what I was really asking. Oh, what were you asking then? Do you wanna leave it? And I I can just ask you.

Okay. Listen to me. No. This is anger that I have suppressed in the past. Okay?

About a particular thing? About About quite a few particular things. Yeah. Right? But I I again, I think it’s as far as I understand, it’s the same process.

You simply have to when that feeling arises, that feeling arises physically because of all sorts of suppressed thoughts which are starting to manifest, one has to try to counteract those thoughts by realizing that these thoughts are harmful no matter yeah? That’s it. Whether it’s just something that’s happened now or some suppressed thing, I think it’s the it’s the same process, really. Because as I’ve tried to explain many anger is what is labeled on a whole series of thoughts and experiences and conceptions about oneself, others, this and that. And so while those thoughts are there, even if they’ve been suppressed and they come up suppressed or not suppressed, those thoughts are what are labeled.

That network of thoughts and feelings is what is labeled anger. You have to replace that as much as possible with thinking in another way. That’s it. And that other way of thinking is seeing the harm of those thoughts, the harm and the falseness of them. Also even looking at the ‘I’, the ‘I’ that was hurt.

What is this ‘I’ that was hurt by this experience? That ‘I’ that was hurt actually is an illusion and the ‘I’ that I am now is not that ‘I’ that was hurt anyway. Those are the things we have to look at. Okay? That was the problem.

It is reasonable to say or unreasonable to say that no matter what we think, Yeah. Those thoughts are. Yes. But, unfortunately, we don’t have only those thoughts. But they mostly Yeah.

Now we’re over time. Sorry we didn’t have a discussion tonight, but anyway, I don’t know if that made the path clear or not some idea of the path to enlightenment. But of course the path is very long and to be honest, it is difficult. But it is possible. Many beings have followed it and those beings who followed it and achieved the results are definitely no different from us.

They just had a mind like us, they had delusions like us, they had self-cherishing like us, but they used their wisdom to realize that that self-cherishing wasn’t benefiting them but harming them, and they freed themselves just by working at it and not giving up. We can do it. Thank you very much. So we can dedicate the merit of this time to be able to actually follow the path and achieve enlightenment for our own sake, but especially for the sake of Mother sentient beings. Due to the merits of these virtuous actions, may I quickly attain the state of a Guru Buddha and lead all living beings without exception into that enlightened state.

May the precious bodhi mind not yet born arise and grow. May that born have no decline but increase forevermore. Okay, thank you very much. So since this is the end of this module and the end of the DB, at least for me, we won’t prostrate because this is said to be auspicious to meet again sometime in the future and I hope that happens. So I will no.

I I hope to see some people Sunday, some people won’t be coming to the Sunday retreat. So I wish you all the best and I encourage people to still continue to come to Buddha House sometime in May or June. Hopefully, there will be a Tibetan Geshe from who will be replacing me while I’m in retreat. So he speaks English. He’s been teaching in America for about twelve, fifteen years.

So I presume his English is pretty good. So and hopefully, he will continue to teach discovering Buddhism program. I’m not sure. But, anyway, I hope people continue to come to Buddha House and study the Dharma and have some Dharma friends to support them in their practice, especially in our new to be hopefully wonderful premises at McGill Road, which probably we won’t be able to move into until the end of the year or the very beginning of next year. But yeah.

So I yeah. So that for those people I won’t see, so I wish you all the very best. And yeah. K. But I do hope to see you on Sunday for the retreat.

Yeah. Okay. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
obscurations to knowledge jneyavarana (Skt); she drib (Tib)
One of the two obscurations, the more subtle ones that block enlightenment; also known as subtle obscurations, obscurations to enlightenment and cognitive obscurations (Berzin’s translation). LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

What is inherent existence?

Inherent existence means things existing as though they are there from their own side, under their own power, which would imply they are independent. A flower seems to have beauty inherently within it, but no inherently existing beauty can be found there. Beauty exists conventionally: what one person calls beautiful another may not, yet beauty still exists. If things existed inherently, they could be found separately and independently, and everyone would agree on them. A long thing would be long in relation to everything, but compared to something else it is short. An inherently beautiful thing would be beautiful at all times, in all situations, for all people, and no such thing exists.

Scroll to Top