2 h 30 min · 8,684 words · 28 September 2013 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 151-minute teaching session, Venerable Thubten Dondrub guides practitioners through two foundational meditations that anchor the graduated path to enlightenment. The first focuses on the precious human rebirth, walking participants through detailed posture and breathing preparation before guiding reflection on the eight freedoms from obstacle realms and ten endowments that make spiritual practice possible. He emphasizes the rarity of this rebirth by comparing human numbers to animal populations, then explores three deepening meanings: freedom to achieve any virtuous goal, capacity to make every moment meaningful, and the optimum opportunity for enlightenment itself. The second meditation addresses impermanence and death, establishing why renouncing attachment to this life is not pessimism but wise priority—clarifying that genuine Dharma practice begins with determining to secure a good rebirth, which then creates conditions for renunciation, liberation, and finally bodhicitta. Throughout, he answers questions on the relationship between attachment and motivation, relationships and practice commitment, and the role of faith in sustaining Buddhist engagement.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2013 09 28 DBPresentingTPathRetreat280913.mp3
UUID: 4ff69acb-3add-4a6d-ac00-ef83ed9bcfbd
Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub
Collection: DB Presenting the Path (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Date: 2013-09-28
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 150.8 minutes
Words: ~8,683
So so for the first session, we’ll do a little meditation on the the precious human rebirth. So we we begin by sitting comfortably in the correct posture as much as possible, sort of particularly paying attention to our back. So whether you’re seated on a chair or on the floor on a cushion, the most important thing is to try to have the back nice and straight, well aligned, and your upper body not leaning forwards or backwards or to either side. If you’re sitting on a chair it’s best not to lean against the back if you can unless you have some physical problems. And if you sitting on a chair have your feet flat on the ground.
In either case have your right hand resting on the left with the thumbs slightly touching resting in your lap close to your body so that your elbows and upper arms are just a little bit away from the sides of your body. If you lift your shoulders up and back a little bit and then relax them and then straighten your head, tuck your chin in slightly, you can position your head so that it is not tilted down or lifted too high. Have your jaw relaxed, mouth lightly closed. We rest the tip of the tongue at the back of the top row of teeth at the palate. And although it is okay to meditate with your eyes closed, is much better to learn to meditate with your eyes just a little bit open, just very slightly.
And directing your gaze just a short distance down in front of you but without actively looking. Instead having a passive unfocused gaze. So then just check your posture briefly by moving your awareness from the crown of your head down through your body. And as you do so, you may notice different points of tension and you might notice that that tension tends to exist or continues because we are unconsciously pulling inwards and holding on to that tightening around that. So as we become aware of that process we can begin to gently let it go.
So having prepared the body, we now begin to prepare our mind to meditate by firstly doing the nine round breathing exercise just to establish a calm, neutral mind So on the basis of that neutral mind we now cultivate a really positive mind of refuge in the triple gem as much as one feels connected and the bodhicitta motivation. So we can do this by firstly trying to have that clear recognition right now that it is our mind that gives rise to all our experience of happiness and suffering. The more we recognise that it becomes obvious that if we want less suffering, more happiness, then the vital thing is to take care of the mind. And especially if we recognise that our mind is something that being formless, insubstantial, will never come to an end, will go beyond this life forever. Then in order to take care of our mind we need a method which is complete, perfect unbetraying.
Such a perfect method can only come from a perfect source which we recognise as the pure mind, the enlightened mind of the Buddha. So this is why we entrust ourselves to the Buddha, the Buddha’s teachings and the great practitioners of those teachings. And so one way to do this is to think of or visualise Śākyamūni Buddha in front of us as the very embodiment of those Three Jewels of refuge. The Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Think of the Buddha as the very embodiment of all perfect qualities.
So we can imagine the Buddha seated on a very beautiful multi colored lotus symbolising renunciation. Above the lotus appears a golden sun disc symbolising wisdom that overcomes the darkness of ignorance. Above that, a white moon disc that symbolises bodhicitta. And then we imagine the Buddha seated directly above the centre of the moon disc. Having a hollow body of golden light adorned with the saffron robes of a monk holding a deep blue begging bowl in his left hand which we imagine is filled with the wisdom nectar that overcomes the causes of all suffering.
So as we think of the Buddha in front of us as our possible source of inspiration, guidance, refuge Think of the Buddha appearing there to remind us of our Buddha nature and encouraging us to realise it. We can motivate ourselves to do so by reflecting on how our existence in every moment now, in the past, in the future can only arise depending on the existence directly, indirectly of all sentient beings. And particularly we depend on their kindness which we do receive. And most especially we depend on the kindness of a mother, which we’ve received life after life from all sentient beings. So try and generate a strong sense of the living presence of these beings around you, starting with your mother, of this life on your left, your father on your right.
Behind you, imagine the rest of your family, all your friends, all those who have helped you. In front, think of those who may have harmed you or disliked you, not to generate negative thoughts towards them, but to have some compassion, understanding and love for them, realizing that they have been immensely kind to me in past lives, will be so in future. And then, as much as possible, trying to open one’s heart and mind to an awareness and concern for all the other beings of the realms of cyclic existence. Trying to have that awareness that all these kind mother beings are suffering in cyclic existence. Most are trapped in the lower realms right now.
And wherever they are in cyclic existence, the vast majority of sentient beings don’t understand how to overcome their suffering, to modify it, transform it, eliminate it. And in their confusion they are creating the cause for more suffering. So try to recognize and feel that, generate that thought that no matter what, I must use this in all future lives to follow the path to enlightenment So that I can achieve that state whereby I can perfectly repay the kindness of all mother sentient beings. And particularly to follow the path I need to recognise that I have the optimum chance to do so. So for this reason I will do this meditation on, for the sake of all sentient beings, I’ll do this meditation on recognizing I have the precious human rebirth.
So we should be doing the refuge prayer on page ten, which is the one for meditation. I go for refuge until I am enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma and the Supreme Assembly. By my practice of giving and other perfections may I become a Buddha to benefit all sentient beings. So then, just briefly, we can recite the mantra of Śākyamūni Buddha and as we do so imagining blissful white light coming from the Buddha pouring down into us eliminating all confusion in our mind, all suffering, all disturbing thoughts, negative imprints, and particularly all obstacles to being able to understand and realize that I have this incredible, precious human rebirth. So then think, the Buddha now comes to the crown of our head, dissolves into golden light, and that blissful golden light pours down into us, blessing our mind to be able to meditate correctly, single pointedly, so that we can eventually gain a complete realization, recognizing that we have the precious human rebirth, its great meaning and rarity.
So now I will just spend firstly reflect that we have a mind which is beginningless and endless. And the very nature of our mind is pure and perfect. Our mind possesses the potential of every good quality great compassion, wisdom and so on. But during beginningless time, that pure nature of our mind, that Buddha potential, has been obscured by ignorance and disturbing thoughts and negative imprints. But what we need to recognize now is that we have not just a human rebirth, where we are free from the incredible suffering of the lower realms, but we have a particular kind of human rebirth that gives us the optimum chance, the very best opportunity, the greatest freedom to work with our mind, eliminate the causes of suffering, and awaken all the positive potentials.
We have this incredibly rare and precious opportunity to be of perfect benefit to ourselves, but also perfect benefit to all others. And if we don’t recognise this opportunity, we will waste it on meaningless things and remain suffering. So now spend a little time trying to get a sense of how much freedom one has right now simply because I I haven’t been born in the lower realms, as an animal, as a hungry ghost in the hell realms, Or I I haven’t been born in the human equivalent because so many human beings on this planet have lives that are like being in hell or like a hungry ghost or like an animal. Just be even though I have problems and difficulties in this life, nothing compared to other human beings or those trapped in the lower realms. Also try and get a sense of how much freedom one has by not being born in the god realms, where even although there’s an enormous pleasure, the beings in that realm are completely distracted by it, waste their lives.
Just like so many human beings who are very wealthy, have every advantage, fail to use that situation, just waste it in self indulgence. So think how incredibly fortunate I am to have this freedom. And what kind of freedom is it? It’s the rarest freedom, the freedom to practice the Dharma, the freedom to be able to work with one’s mind in a truly meaningful way. And then just thinking within the human realm itself, imagine what it would be like to be born in those places in the world which are like barbaric places where there is incredible violence or and wars or political repression.
Places where, because of so many factors, religious traditions of any kind either don’t exist, barely exist, or are suppressed. Where there is complete lawlessness, brutality, where there may be so much poverty, but that all sense of kindness to others is lost. Imagine what it would be like to be born into such an environment. Imagine how difficult, if not impossible, to practice the spiritual path in those conditions, Or even meet one. And then realise what incredible freedom one has right now.
And then consider that because of negative actions in the past I could have been reborn like so many human beings on this planet with very severe physical or mental problems, born completely blind or deaf. So think again, if I’d have been born that way, how difficult it would be to meet the Dharma. And even if I meet it, to put it into practice. But I’m completely free of all those obstacles. I have this incredible freedom to turn my mind to the Dharma, to the spiritual path, to spiritual practice.
This is the rarest freedom of all. Haven’t had this freedom in many previous lives. I have the potential to be reborn in the future without that freedom. But right now, in this very short human life, I have this amazing freedom. How can I waste it on meaningless things?
I also reflect that although in this world there are many people who are physically well off, very comfortable, very intelligent, live in very peaceful places and so on, have all the conditions to follow a spiritual path if they wish. But they’ve been born with very cynical minds, with no belief, no belief whatsoever in the mind, future existence. No interest, no belief. So that although they are controlled by delusion and karma, are experiencing suffering, creating the causes for it, they completely reject all the methods that can help them. So they have no freedom.
But I have that freedom. Think how precious that is. How can I waste it? So we will just take a couple of minutes break. You might like to stand up, relax just a little bit and then afterwards we will continue the meditation.
So just re establish a comfortable position to meditate in. Just again reaffirm one’s motivation. One can also think that the Buddha is above the crown of our head, creating a protective environment in which we can meditate and constantly blessing our mind. So then we can begin by reflecting that not only in the rebirth I have now am I free of all the greatest obstacles to practicing spiritual path, following the Buddha’s teachings, Actually, what I need to recognize is that, in addition, I have all these encouraging factors or endowments that make it as easy as possible to follow the path. I have all these personal factors and environmental surrounding factors.
So the first is just simply being being born a human being. I have a human body in mind. And I’ve been born in a place where all the different spiritual traditions exist, but particularly where the Buddhadharma is existing. And I’ve got a healthy body and mind that enables me to practice. I haven’t, in this life, engaged in any of the extreme negative actions, such as killing my parents, which are so extreme that this affects the mind so much in this life that it’s not really possible to practice.
And most important of all, consider if one has faith in the Buddha’s teachings, in the triple gem, then this opens up the whole path to enlightenment. Just reflect that there are many people who know the Buddhist teachings, are very intelligent. They understand them, study them, even write books about Buddhism, but they have no faith in it. It’s just a philosophy. It’s just one of many, many ideas.
But once we have some faith in the teachings, in the Buddha, in the Buddha’s teachings, then the whole path to enlightenment is open to us, becomes a possibility. A good rebirth becomes a possibility. Freedom from saṃsāra becomes a possibility. Enlightenment becomes possible. So also consider that it’s incredibly rare for all of those factors to be born human with a healthy body and mind in a place where the dharma exists, not having engaged in extreme negative actions, and actually having faith, for all of these factors to come together in one life is unbelievably rare.
As reflected, many previous lives, I’ve been born human, but never where the dharma exists, or I didn’t have a healthy body, healthy mind, didn’t have faith, and so on. This one time, this one time, I am human with a healthy body and mind, born where the dharma exists, not having engaged in the extreme negative actions, and actually having some faith. This is really like a miracle. So then in addition to that, I have all these environmental factors encourage me. Such as that I’ve been born in a place where the teachings still exist.
And especially more than that, there are great realized masters of the teachings that I can meet, be guided by. I have the support of Dharma friends. There are Dharma centers, Dharma books. Everything is available that I need to practice if I want. I just need to recognize this and recognize this is all incredibly rare.
If we just take a simple example of this center, most people don’t know this place exists. So it can be of no benefit to them. But it exists in my world, in my environment. And in my world, I know of the existence of other Dharma centers, retreat centers, teachers, monks, nuns. All of this exists in my world.
And that makes it very easy to practice if I want, as easy as possible. And to live in such a world is unbelievably rare. And why is it rare? Because to to be born with all these freedoms, all these encouraging factors doesn’t happen simply by chance, by fluke, by accident. It depends on causes.
I had to create the causes in past lives, And the causes are immensely difficult to create because the causes are practicing pure morality, practicing pure generosity. Even in this life, we find it very difficult to practice pure generosity, pure morality. But somehow, over many, many lifetimes, we created these pure causes. And now we have this result. How can I waste it on meaningless or negative things?
We can try and get a sense of how rare a precious human rebirth is because it’s so difficult to create the causes by just comparing the number of human beings on this earth with another the number of beings trapped in the animal realm. Think of all the fish in the sea from the tiniest to the largest, all the different kinds of birds in the air, insects, all the different kinds of animals on the earth. All the insects inside the earth. So for every human being on this earth, there are millions of of beings in the animal realm Because it’s very easy to create the negative causes to be reborn a human an animal, but immensely difficult to create the cause to be born a human being. But then among the seven thousand million human beings, very, very, very few have a precious human rebirth.
So then reflect what what is the meaning of having such an incredibly rare, precious human rebirth. The very basic meaning is that I have the freedom to accomplish any meaningful goal in this life I wish to. Any virtuous project, goal, I can achieve with a precious human rebirth. If I want to develop more kindness, compassion, wisdom, patience, it’s possible with a precious human rebirth. And particularly, if I want to achieve a good rebirth, it is definitely possible with a precious human rebirth.
Because I have all the freedom, all the encouraging factors. The only problem is I fail to realize this. I don’t recognize it. And there is my own laziness. Another way of looking at the real meaning of this precious human rebirth is that with all the freedom I have, all the encouraging factors, especially meeting and having some faith in the teachings, then I can make every moment of this life meaningful.
I can use my body, my speech, my mind in so many ways to free myself of suffering, to create the causes of happiness now and in the future. I have the freedom. I have the encouraging factors. Nothing is lacking. Only my failure to recognize this amazing opportunity and my own spiritual laziness.
The final, ultimate, deepest meaning of having this precious human rebirth is that it is the optimum chance to achieve not just liberation from cyclic existence, but to actually achieve complete enlightenment. There is all the freedom, all the encouraging factors. The only things missing is my failure to recognize this and my own laziness. So bring this meditation to a conclusion by making a really strong determination to be more and more mindful in daily life, especially from the moment one wakes up that I have this very precious human rebirth, this optimum chance to make every moment of this life meaningful, The optimum chance to free my mind of all suffering. The optimum chance to achieve enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings.
So I have to use this life in this meaningful way. I can’t waste it on negative and meaningless things. Because if I don’t seize this opportunity, when will I ever get it again? So think that the Buddha on your crown is very pleased with your meditation and shows this by dissolving into golden light. And then that blissful light pours down into you, blessing your mind to be able to eventually gain a complete realization, recognizing one has the precious human rebirth, its great meaning, recognizing its great rarity.
Due to the merits of these virtuous actions, may I quickly attain the state of a Guru Buddha, and lead all living beings without exception into that enlightened state. May the precious bodhi mind, not yet born, arise and grow. May that born have no decline but increase forevermore. Thank you very much. So we’ll take a half hour tea break, coffee break, water break.
Before we start, if possible in the three break. So I’ll ring the bell and the idea is just to have a silent three minute break, not not charge out the room if possible. The idea is just to stay here. If you have to go, that that’s okay. That’s fine.
But, generally, the idea is just to kind of remain seated or stand up and stretch a little bit during the break. And the other thing is yes. Doing meditations, the tradition is it’s always good to prepare the body and mind by doing the sort of checking your posture, doing the nine round breathing, really working on one’s motivation, doing some of the traditional prayers. So that all takes quite a bit of time, it’s good to do. But having just said it’s really important to do it, we’re not going to do it much anymore because there’s just not not much time to cover much of the meditation topic.
Ideally we should have spent at least two day retreat for this particular course because, you know, we’re just going to skim through things. But anyway, even that’s good to do. So we’ll do a little bit about we’ll cover a few topics in this session I think, briefly. Mainly about renouncing this life in order to ensure we have a good rebirth. So think a little bit about impermanence and death.
What happens afterwards. So again we can just begin by sitting comfortably in the correct posture as much as possible. And then just briefly calming the mind by doing the nine round breathing. And then imagine the Buddha appears seated above the crown of one’s head facing the same direction as yourself. And at the same time think of all kind suffering mother sentient beings surrounding you.
Starting with your parents on either side. So as we recite the Buddha’s mantra three times. Try and generate strong faith, refuge, confidence in the triple gem and also generate as much as possible the bodhicitta motivation. And as one recites the mantra also one can imagine blissful white light pouring down from the Buddha into oneself eliminating all confusion in the mind, suffering, causes of it, negative imprints, all obstacles to being able to do meditation well. Begin by reflecting that during beginningless time my mind has been trapped in cyclic existence.
Much of the time having to endure the sufferings of the lower realms. But this one time, not only have I been reborn human, but I’ve achieved the very rare precious human rebirth. With all the freedoms and encouraging factors that enable me to practice the Dharma to free my mind But now try and get a sense that this incredible rebirth I have, this amazing freedom I have, this amazing opportunity, which is so meaningful, is not going to last. Because I’m definitely going to die. Every being who has been born on this earth has died.
Not just ordinary beings, but the most powerful, the richest, the most intelligent, even the most spiritually advanced have all died, have left this body. So definitely, I am going to die. With the passing of each second, my life comes to an end, moves towards its end. Especially reflect on how the Buddha taught that everything that comes into existence depending on causes and conditions is impermanent. It changes and decays moment by moment, irreversibly.
So this body, this life I have now, has arisen depending on causes and conditions. So it is coming to an end, decaying moment by moment. From the moment of birth, aging has been occurring moment by moment. So death is definitely going to come. And this precious human rebirth is going to come to an end.
This optimum chance to be free of all suffering, to help all beings free to become free of suffering is going to come to an end. So the conclusion is, if I’m intelligent, wise, have love and compassion for myself, I should practice the Dharma. I should take care of my mind. Particularly consider that try to develop a strong awareness inside that not only am I going to die and lose this precious human rebirth, but this could happen, death could happen at any moment, at any time. The lifespan of human beings is infixed, so death could happen at any time.
And it can happen at any time because there are so many, many causes for death. There are common ones of disease and accidents. And there are common kinds of accidents but very uncommon ones. Very rare. One can be killed in wars, being murdered.
There are dangerous animals, insects. There are natural disasters that can bring death. There are so many, many causes. And since I’m not immune from any of these, It means that death could come to me really at any time. Although it doesn’t feel like it, that doesn’t mean anything.
karma ripens at any time. Without any control, it ripens. And then one can experience at any time, just like others have, these causes of death. And even the things which we normally think of that support life can become causes of death, such as the medicine we take, the food we eat. And our body itself is so fragile, so easily harmed.
It is so complex so that if one little thing goes wrong, that can trigger something else that triggers something else, and death can come. So what we need to realize is since death could come at any moment, we’re just not sure, not certain when it happens. Then not only do I need to practice the Dharma, take care of my mind, I need to do it now to make it my priority, not to postpone the practice. Then check how much time of this very precious, potentially meaningful human rebirth we waste is eaten up by things that are not going to help us at the time of death. So much of our time goes into following attachment to friends and family, chasing after money, possessions, influence, reputation.
Taking care of the appearance of this impermanent body. So much time and energy goes into these things. Are they going to help at the time of death? Actually, our attachment to these things is going to be a great obstacle at the time of death. What am I doing that is actually gonna help me when the mind leaves this body?
Leaves behind everything familiar. What am I doing that is going to help? In fact, what will help at that time? Check up whether it’s true or not that when death comes, when the mind leaves this body, moves into the bardo in the next life, what is really essential is for the mind to be calm, strong, stable, peaceful, in a virtuous state. To have qualities such as faith, love, compassion, and so on.
Those qualities will only be present at the time of death if we’ve trained in developing them throughout our life, practicing the Dharma. Check that it’s not only important to decide to practice the Dharma now, because death could come at any moment, but I need to practice the Dharma purely. Because it’s only through sincere practice that genuine change in the mind will occur. That real transformation will occur. So then reflect that not only am I going to lose this precious human rebirth because of death, which could happen at any moment, But I am while I have this precious human rebirth, I am wasting so much of it chasing after things which are impermanent, that aren’t going to last.
I get attached to people and things, situations, reputation. None of which can last, can only bring a fleeting kind of happiness. Because it all has arisen depending on causes and conditions. So it changes and changes, moment by moment. Like trying to hold water in one’s hand.
It’s just not possible. Just consider that there’s so much time and energy of this precious, very short, definite to end. Optimum human rebirth goes into chasing after things which are impermanent, short lived. When I could be using all that time and energy taking care of the mind. A mind which is going to continue forever.
And the positive effects of Dharma practice can carry on forever. So if we think more and more deeply about our own mortality and impermanence This can help us to turn our mind away from thinking only of the things of this life to thinking more and more about our next life. Using this precious human rebirth to ensure we create the causes of a good rebirth, not only for our own sake, but ultimately for the benefit of others. But then consider that even a good rebirth as a human, especially as a human, or even in the god realms, these are still rebirths where the mind is controlled by delusion and karma. Still, the mind is trapped in cyclic existence.
So we still have to experience so much suffering. So by reflecting more and more on the suffering nature of our own cyclic existence this will motivate us to have the courage, wisdom, compassion to eliminate the causes from our own mind that bring about all suffering. So reflect that if I don’t use this precious human rebirth to work on reducing my delusions, negative behavior working on actually ultimately eliminating all delusions from my mind. Then I will have to continuously, life after life, even if I’m reborn human, life after life, I will still have to experience over and over again the suffering of being born over and over again, the suffering of dying over and over and over again, all the different kinds of suffering of growing old over and over again. And the suffering of sickness over and over again, life after life.
So reflect that even in any particular human rebirth I may not experience much suffering of sickness or even much suffering of aging and old age. But if I remain in saṃsāra which means if I don’t eliminate delusions and ignorance from my mind, then even if I’m reborn a human again and again, There will be time for me to eventually experience every kind of sickness, every kind of suffering of aging, every kind of suffering that occurs during birth, every kind of suffering that occurs at the time of death. These things will definitely happen if I don’t eliminate their causes. But in addition to those basic sufferings, there is all the mental suffering that comes from being separated from people and things and situations I don’t want to be separated from. And this will occur many times within one life but then life after life after life in beginningless saṃsāra, endless saṃsāra.
If I don’t eliminate attachment from my mind, Then I will experience over and over again the suffering that comes from being separated from people and objects of my attachment. It’s inevitable. And the more attachment, the more suffering. And if I don’t eliminate desire and attachment from my mind, then in endless saṃsāra, I will have to experience over and over again the suffering of not meeting the people and things and situations I crave to meet. If I don’t develop the determination to eliminate aversion and anger from my mind then saṃsāra will continue endlessly.
And then I will have to experience, even if I manage to be reborn a human again and again, I will still have to experience all the suffering, fears, and worries, problems that come from meeting the people, and things, and situations I don’t want to meet up with. And consider that if I don’t develop the mind of renunciation which is determined to eliminate all the causes of cyclic existence from my mind. If I don’t do that, then not only will I have to experience over and over again obvious suffering, but even the happiness I experience in cyclic existence is not not real happiness. It’s just the suffering of change. Just check how all the the good experiences we have, the all the experiences that we label happiness, that we crave to reproduce, to experience over and over again, or other experiences we haven’t had but we crave these, thinking this is happiness.
Just check how in reality none of it lasts. It arises depending on causes and conditions, so it’s impermanent. It fades away like the sound of a bell, like a rainbow in the sky. It just momentarily appears to be happiness to the deluded mind. Compared to what is obvious suffering, an experience can occur that momentarily seems like happiness.
Is the illusion of happiness. But after some time, that illusion fades. And check how the unfortunate fact is that we try to achieve this illusory happiness by following attachment and craving. The actual effects of which, the final real results of which, are obvious suffering. Why do we experience these waves of suffering and dissatisfaction?
Because of the inner cause, our own disturbing thoughts. Just check the nature of anger and pride and jealousy. Afflicted desire attachment. The moment they arise in the mind, the mind is disturbed, agitated. When desire meets its object, there appears to be happiness.
But that happiness is only illusory anyway. But when desire doesn’t meet its object, we can discover the true nature of desire, which is painful, disturbing. And the Buddha discovered that the nature of the cause inevitably determines the nature of the effect. So if we follow desire, anger, pride, jealousy, We act on it. The inevitable actual resulteffect can only be suffering.
And why do these disturbing thoughts exist at all? The Buddha discovered because of ignorance. Due to ignorance, the mind experiences everything in a false way, creating the illusion that oneself and everything exists somehow from its own side under its own power, that it’s really there the way it appears. Things are really independently good, beautiful, bad, ugly. And so because of that ignorant appearance, We crave what appears to be really beautiful, have aversion to what appears to be really bad.
And then all suffering follows. So bring the meditation to a conclusion by making a strong determination to be more and more mindful in daily life That everything that one experiences, good, bad, is all impermanent. That this precious human rebirth can come to an end at any moment. So it’s important to turn the mind to the practice of Dharma. Now to practice purely.
And especially to not be content just getting a good rebirth, but to work to become completely free of cyclic existence, recognizing its suffering nature. So be determined to be more and more mindful to use this precious human rebirth to not just try to subdue the disturbing thoughts, but to lay the causes to become completely free of all disturbing thoughts, to eliminate them from the mind. So then recall the Buddha on one’s crown, Imagining the Buddha is very pleased with your practice. And shows this by now dissolving into golden light. And then that golden light, very blissful in nature, pours down into you, blessing your mind to be able to renounce all obsession with the meaningless things of this life, blessing the mind to be able to develop the great renunciation determined to seek freedom from cyclic existence.
Due to the merits of these virtuous actions, may I quickly attain the state of a Guru Buddha and lead all living beings without exception into that enlightened state. May the precious bodhi mind not yet born arise and grow. May that born have no decline, but increase forevermore. The March two thousand and eight National Geographic Animal Minds. It’s great.
Talking about animal intelligence such as a what is he? A bonobo ape by the name of Kanzi who is twenty seven years old and he talks using more than three sixty keyboard symbols and understands thousands of spoken words. Then there’s a Western scrub jay who is able to recall the past and plan for the future. Which most yes. Yeah.
In other words, they’ve got minds. Minds. So this article proves saṃsāra. Yeah. Because if the animals have got minds, they’re the same as ours.
That means an animal can become of a human. humans can become animals. And that’s what saṃsāra is. Yes. Well remember renunciation is a state of mind.
Renunciation doesn’t mean necessarily not having anything or not doing any ordinary things. It’s about putting it all in perspective and not being attached to things and so on. This doesn’t work very well. So this is why the Buddha said the person teaching is supposed to sit higher than people. This is not all about some ego trip, although there’s a great danger of developing one’s ego sitting up here.
But there is some psychology to it. Sorry. I can see people too. Right. Yeah.
So practicing the Dharma, like renouncing this life, renouncing saṃsāra, that requires a lot of time and effort. So the more time and effort we can put in it, the more result we’re going to have. But in the meantime, we need to live. It’s it’s that simple, really. Even monks and nuns in the West have this problem to some extent, some more than others, about surviving because traditionally in Buddhist countries then monks and nuns would be provided for.
But this doesn’t happen so much in the West yet. But house looks after me a bit. Actually the government does now. Having reached that age in life Of course the more renunciation we have the more we I mean the less we need or want. Because when the mind doesn’t have any renunciation then there is of course a tendency for the mind to think it needs an awful lot of stuff.
To just survive let alone be happy. But I think when start to develop a little bit of renunciation and non attachment and so on, less craving, then things start to be put in perspective. And one can start to realize one can be quite happy with less, sometimes more happy with less. Less is more, as they say sometimes. Come on, please ask questions.
Yes. Yes. Yes. Years. No!
A better rebirth. No, but that’s the one this is what I’ve been trying to say through the whole course that you first have to get that motivation. You can’t have bodhicitta motivation first. Actual we can say the words and put that but one can’t develop that motivation first. One first has to want to have a good rebirth.
Because we’re not going to get enlightened in this life as we are now. No way! So firstly we have to make sure that we get a good rebirth particularly a human one or get reborn in the pure lands where we continue to practice the Dharma. That is the thing. That’s the whole psychology that I’ve been trying to present.
The three levels of motivation. First one, what the lamrim is about, the graduated path, is that one has to like, right the average person, their mind is completely stuck in this life. You know? And that with that mindset, it’s practically impossible to create the cause of a good rebirth. The very first There’s this wonderful teaching in four lines which is the basis of the Sakya tradition.
We follow the Gelugpa tradition here. In the Sakya tradition they have a teaching called Parting from the Four Attachments. And the first line of the first of these four lines says, what is it? If you are attached to this life, you are not a religious person. Meaning you are not practicing the Dharma.
Because if one is attached to this life, one won’t be able to get a good rebirth. So the very first step in the spirit what defines real Dharma practice, actual Dharma practice, just coming to a Dharma center or saying mantras or even meditating what actually defines it is seeking a good rebirth. Doing things in order to why am I coming here? Why am I saying this mantra? Why am I doing this meditation?
Why am I being nice to the dog? Because I see this as all creating causes for a good rebirth. That is the first step. Oh, yes. Okay, good question.
Right. So yes, good. Now I see. Yes. So what is the difference between so what you’re saying is what is the difference between being attached to this life we’re experiencing now and if that’s what we’re supposed to do, why are we trying to get another ordinary human rebirth?
Isn’t it the same? Now it’s not a linear trajectory. You have to start, you know, a journey of a thousand miles starts with the first step. To get, you know, to go up Mhmm. No, you’re not.
But this is the first step. You can’t aspire to getting out of saṃsāra or benefiting all sentient beings if one first hasn’t decided to help oneself first. That’s the first step. And the difference between someone who’s simply attached to this life and someone who wants to get a good rebirth even just for the sake of that good rebirth rather than being able to advance in the spiritual path. There is a difference because the person who is attached to just this life, only thinking of this life, is being their mind is controlled by attachment.
And they see nothing wrong with it and they follow it and therefore get caught up in anger, pride, jealousy, blah blah blah blah blah. In order to get another human rebirth, even for the sake of just having that good rebirth and having fun, as you know, having nice clothes, money, cars, parties, you know, wanting to be reborn just for that, you have to make the decision in this life I won’t follow attachment so much. I won’t be I will modify my anger, I won’t harm, I kill, steal, engage in sexual misconduct, lie, followed divisive speech, blah blah blah. Whereas the person attached to this life is happy to, more or less, speaking in general, engage in the ten non virtues and will because of their attachment to this life. So in order to get a human rebirth, another human rebirth, just for the pleasures of that human rebirth, one has to develop a more virtuous mind.
And that’s the step. So once you’ve got that new rebirth, there’s the chance for you to meet the dharma again and evolve your motivation. Develop one’s motivation. Does that make sense? Well, with all due respect, Kathy, and I’m sorry this may not apply to you, but like I was saying when was it?
I don’t know. Anyway, previous talk, one talk somewhere. There is a big difference between like many people who aren’t religious see life as miserable and suffering and they don’t want that. But that’s not renunciation. That’s just not liking suffering.
No one likes suffering. I don’t want anything else. I don’t want this. I want to be out of it. But that’s not renunciation.
Yeah, yeah. But anyone can recognise obvious suffering when it pours down on them. Like I said, there’s a huge difference between not wanting suffering and being upset when suffering occurs and being, ‘I hate life, I don’t want this’. There’s a huge difference between that and being determined to stop the causes of it. So you had a belief that there was something beyond this life before you met the Dharma?
Right. It’s not a common view, Kathy. Most people well, Christians believe there’s one thing after this and there’s a lot of Christians and then there’s a lot of materialists who think ‘finished’. Totally nothing. I mean, I think I was a type of materialist I didn’t believe in anything beyond this life but I did believe in the mind but I didn’t realise what the implications of that were.
I never believed I don’t know about never but I couldn’t believe there was just a brain that just didn’t make sense to me. There was a mind. And then I met the Buddha Buddhism I never met the Buddha. I met Buddhism and then it said, oh, mind means this. Wow!
Yes! But it’s true, I think there is a difference. I’ve never really heard lamas talk about this because there is definitely a difference, it seems to me, between wanting believing in future lives and therefore wanting another good one and being not just wanting another way, everyone would want one if you believe in but being determined to create the causes of that one just for the sake of another human life. And then there’s it seems to me there’s another motivation of wanting to be reborn as a human being to have a precious human rebirth again in order to practice the Dharma, not just become rich and famous and beautiful and have parties but in order that seems to be a definitely different motivation. And that one is what we need to develop.
Only then can the real motivation of wanting to get out of saṃsāra develop and only once that’s developed can bodhicitta develop. Because if we don’t have the wish to get out of saṃsāra, you know, really develop that wish that means that we believe, despite all the evidence, that saṃsāra is okay, that I can manage. Yes, sure, there’s suffering in saṃsāra, but I can manage it or I’ll avoid it. And why we think that is because we think this is saṃsāra. Well, this is saṃsāra, but it’s only one teeny teeny aspect of saṃsāra.
This is like the good bit, a pretty good bit. And we think, oh, you know, the sufferings of humans, that’s it. But if we stay in saṃsāra, we’re going to be hit with the whole shemozzle sooner or later. Anyway, if that anyway, go back. If we haven’t renounced saṃsāra it means we haven’t developed real compassion for ourselves.
And if that’s the case, there’s no way we will be able to develop real complete compassion for others. Therefore there is no way to develop bodhicitta. Because if we think I can handle saṃsāra, it means and it’s not actually all that bad it means everyone else can handle it and they’ll be okay so they can stay there as well. No need, you know? Really!
So that’s why there is this psychological evolution. Can have now we can all hopefully here have some idea, wish to develop bodhicitta to become a Buddha. We can see if we have any belief in what’s been said about the mind, saṃsāra, everything. Then of course, in a very abstract way, yes, I want to become a Buddha to stop yes, of course, I want to stop the suffering of all sentient beings if I could. Therefore, I’ll be you know, I yes.
Sure. I I would really ultimately like to become a Buddha. But that’s just a fluffy thought in our head. It’s not. It doesn’t have any real guts to it.
I mean, we shouldn’t delude ourselves. Right? Because we haven’t even renounced saṃsāra yet. Because we haven’t even renounced this life yet, most of us, probably all of us, to be honest which we should be. We’re quite content plodding along because we’re not aware, we haven’t realised I’m not giving you a hard time, this applies to me, but this is why we have to work on it.
We haven’t realised things are impermanent. That’s why we’re attached to stuff because we think, If I have it, I will be happy. Intellectually we know otherwise of course but even as we know it we, you know, I’ll buy this, thank you. This is a very big issue. Difficult for me to comment on.
This is one of the big problems of one person in a relationship meeting the Dharma and practicing. It causes lots of problems. There’s no easy answer to this. Yeah. Yeah.
Yes, because as a Buddhist, if one has a commitment, made a commitment to someone then it’s important to somehow fulfill that as much as one can. And also the general commitment of a Dharma practitioner which is a much better term than Buddhist. Lama Yeshe always used to talk about Dharma students trying to be a Dharma student. Anyway, the fundamental, most fundamental commitment is to not harm others and to benefit them. To benefit them in whatever way one can.
Not to harm them and to benefit others in whatever way one can from giving people a chocolate up to enlightenment. So it’s a Yes, of course. As a Dharma student, one can’t really explain, tell other people the Buddhist view to people who don’t have it. The other individual. Well, I don’t know if the penny will drop unfortunately because Oh, well, that case, well that’s maybe good.
That’s good. But for many people, the Buddhist view is very weird, unhealthy, unnatural and creepy. Sorry? No, of course not. But even if people go into, you know, go into Buddhism, if one doesn’t, sorry, from a Buddhist point of view, have the karma to connect with it, no matter how much people go into it, they don’t get it.
I mean, this is why the precious human rebirth will always be rare. There are seven thousand million human beings, but very few humans have the precious human rebirth because don’t have know, are the what defines a precious human rebirth are the eight freedoms and the ten endowments and of all of them, the single most important one of course is faith. If you don’t have faith in the Dharma, you don’t have a precious human rebirth. And not everyone can have that. You can’t force yourself to have faith.
You may like many Buddhist ideas and think this is terrific blah blah blah. I like this, I like this, I like this. But one still doesn’t have this faith. There is a book now for sale in our shop called Buddhism Without Beliefs which I think is one of the most ridiculous books ever written by someone who should know much much better. I don’t know why we’re selling this book in our shop.
Because of course one has to have belief. Faith, belief. There’s a stupid blind belief where no one you know, as a dharma practitioner, one shouldn’t have that. There is and many people associate belief or faith with something completely irrational and stupid. But there is a faith that is based on logic.
But even so, if one doesn’t have the karma, no matter how much one presents the logic, thinks about it oneself, it doesn’t come. Because there’s some kind of thing, some click where you feel, Yes, this is right. And you have reasons. But of course nothing in the dharma can be improved. Like, you you can’t if someone doesn’t want to believe it, can’t prove that smoking causes cancer.
Right? You can’t. They won’t believe it. There has to be something, you know, this mysterious thing where ninety five percent of scientists say climate change is due to human and there’s many people who don’t believe it. They won’t believe it.
They can’t believe it. Impossible for them to believe it. Not not just because, you know, of nasty reasons, but maybe this is oh, I’ll turn this off.
Key terms in this teaching
- eight freedoms dalwa gyä (Tib)
- The eight states a perfect human rebirth is free of: birth as a hell being, hungry ghost, animal or long-life god; as a barbarian; in a dark age when no buddha has come; with wrong views; or with impaired faculties. LYWA
- Gelug
- The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
- hungry ghost preta (Skt); yi dag (Tib)
- The hungry ghost realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence, exemplified by incredible insatiable hunger and thirst. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
- What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.