1 h 58 min · 13,613 words · 2017 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 118-minute opening session of the Discovering Buddhism course, Ven Thubten Dondrub introduces the central Buddhist topic that underpins all teachings: the nature and potential of mind itself. After contextualizing Tibetan Buddhism within the four schools and the Gelugpa tradition founded by Lama Tsongkhapa, he establishes the motivational framework—bodhicitta, the commitment to enlightenment for the benefit of all beings—that should accompany serious study. The core teaching unfolds progressively: the Buddhist definition of mind as “clear and knowing,” a formless consciousness entirely distinct from the physical brain, yet currently operating in dependence upon it; the universal equality of all minds in nature; and the radical Buddhist claim that nothing exists without mind to know it. He then explores mind’s fundamental potential—its innate capacity to know all phenomena perfectly and completely once obscuring factors are removed—which constitutes Buddha-nature itself. Throughout, he emphasizes that intellectual understanding must be tested through direct observation: a simple meditation practice where one distinguishes between physical body and the knowing awareness of it provides the experiential seed. The session concludes with teaching the eight-point meditation posture and the nine-round breathing exercise to begin calming the mind. Pitched at newcomers and established practitioners alike, with regular homework assignments designed to embed learning through study, reflection, and practice.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Mind and its Potential Week 1.mp3
UUID: 25af8188-c975-4260-9703-7f0289a45467
Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub
Collection: DB Mind and its Potential 2017-18 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Date: 2017 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 118.1 minutes
Words: ~13,608
Is this a light supposed to come on, John? Or You just press it? Yeah. Oh, it’s I think that’s there. So I’d like to welcome everyone to to Buddha House, especially those people who are are new to the place.
Although I think most people have been coming to something here. I’ve been away quite a long time, there’s quite a few new people I don’t know. So anyway, welcome to Buddha House, and welcome to our Discovering Buddhism program. As you may know, Buddha House is a member of an international Buddhist organization called the Foundation for the Preservation of the Mahāyāna Tradition, which was established by Tibetan lama, Lama Thubten Yeshe, and his main disciple, who was Nepalese, Lama Thubten Zopa Rinpoche. So Lama Yeshe passed away in the beginning, early nineteen eighty four.
And Lama Zopa Rinpoche has been the spiritual guide of the FPMT since that time. He’s also my main teacher, my root guru. So it’s because of him that I or his permission that I’m the resident teacher at Buddha House. So my name is Thubten Dondrub. I’ve been a monk since I first met the Dharma here in Australia in nineteen seventy six.
I took the first step of stage of ordination in nineteen seventy seven and became fully ordained in nineteen seventy nine. All of that happened in Australia. Then I went to oh no, don’t need to know my history. But I’ve had the good fortune to have received teachings from many great lamas of the Gelug tradition, which we follow here, including His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, and His Holiness’s Root Guru, Kyabje Ling Rinpoche, and of course from Lama Yeshe and Lama Zopa Rinpoche, and a number of other great, great Lamas. So can’t really claim, as I’ve said before, some of you have heard me say this, I can’t claim that I have any real qualities or experience of the Dharma, but at least I’ve got some imprints of the Dharma from some great lamas, so that gives me some minimum rock bottom minimum qualification to be able to sit here and pretend to teach the Dharma.
And of course I have the permission of Lama Zopa Rinpoche to do so. So I hope everyone who’s enrolled for the course has listened to the introductory, whatever you call, audio that was sent out to everyone. I hope you have listened to that. So just a couple of things to remind you. I can’t remember exactly what I said in that because that was taped a few years ago.
Discovering Buddhism is meant to be basically introducing Buddhism to new people or giving a refresher course to people. And of course, particularly, it’s an introduction to Tibetan Buddhism. In particular, there are four schools of Tibetan Buddhism. The oldest one is called the Nyingmapa School. Then the next one to develop was the Kagyu tradition, then the Sakya.
Then the last school to develop was the Gelugpa tradition, which was founded by the glorious Lama Tsongkhapa in the fourteenth century. So this is the tradition that we follow here, the Gelugpa tradition, and the term Gelugpa means something like, or the Geluk tradition it should be. Someone who follows it is called a Gelugpa, a person of Geluk tradition. So the Geluk means something like the virtuous tradition, because Lama Tsongkhapa emphasized that the basis of the spiritual life is really following a pure moral discipline as much as possible. So the aim of this course is to introduce some of the basic ideas of the Mahāyāna teachings, the Mahāyāna path to enlightenment, particularly as it was taught by Lama Tsongkhapa.
And this course is particularly the system of courses called Discovering Buddhism is particularly designed to encourage people to not just come and listen to talks and have a little bit of spiritual entertainment, but to really try to engage your mind with the teachings by doing a little bit of study and meditation on it. That’s why you’re going to get some homework every week. And so I would encourage everyone to do the homework. It’s very, very simple and you don’t pass or fail it. I do tick things and kind of write stuff all over it sometimes, but there’s no passing or failing.
It’s just a way to encourage people to engage with the teachings because all of the from the time of the Buddha to onwards, all the people who have taught the Buddhadharma have taught it not just to entertain people or to give some information. All of the teachings are meant to be, if one believes in them or has some faith in them and sees some value in them, the whole purpose is to put them into practice in order to change one’s mind, to overcome the disturbing harmful aspects of our mind and to encourage the positive aspects of our mind, not only for our own sake in this life, not only for our future benefit in future lives, but especially what Tibetan Buddhism encourages because it’s part of the Mahāyāna, it’s an aspect of the Mahāyāna tradition, and the Mahāyāna tradition emphasizes achieving enlightenment in order to benefit all living beings, all sentient beings. So this is what we were encouraging in a simple way in this course. So please, if you can, do the homework and try and do it as well as you can, and involve yourself as much as you can. Because, of course you will get the benefit from it.
The more you put into this course, the more benefit you will get. So I haven’t been I’ve been teaching on and off for many years, but I haven’t been teaching for seventeen months. I think I’ve done everything I’m supposed to do, so please excuse me tonight. I’ll try to improve as I go along, but no guarantee that I will. So you’ve all been supplied with a notebook, an empty notebook.
This is to encourage people to take notes. This may, from my side, sound very pompous that I’m going to say all these profound things, but I will try to say some intelligent, useful things that may be worthwhile to take notes of because unfortunately, I think most of us in this modern world have very, very poor memories. We don’t retain things very well. I mean, some people may have the good fortune to do so, but many of us seem to forget things very We don’t concentrate very well and we forget very easily. So it can be very helpful to take notes.
At the very first course I ever attended with Lama Zopa Rinpoche in nineteen seventy six, which was at the beginning of Chenrezig Institute in Queensland, I took lots of notes, which is really the very basis of everything I know. All the main things I know is dependent on that first course, I would say, and the notes I took at that time. During that course, towards the end of it, Lama Yeshe was also there teaching as well. Towards the very end, he was giving a talk and he said to everyone, Stop taking notes. So I wrote down, Stop taking notes.
And I could understand why Lama Yeshe said that because I think he was saying it was really important to really concentrate, listen to what’s being said rather than just write things down. But the thing is with the Western mind, or not just Western minds, but modern minds, don’t Tibetans have incredible memories, at least the monks and nuns, because they train to memorize. But most of us haven’t done that. So actually, it can be helpful to write things, not everything, but write bits and pieces that you find, Oh, that was interesting or worth checking out. Because there will be things I say that won’t be written down in the reading material that you have.
But of course, it’s up to you whether you take notes or not. Okay, think that’s odd. Maybe what else? Another thing, especially for those people who are quite new to Buddhism, of course, in studying everything, every subject has its own terminology, so you need to learn that, and that takes time. And of course, it’s important to understand that the Buddha’s teachings, at one level, of course, many of the teachings, if one has any connection with them, are very easy intellectually to understand, but some things are more difficult.
But also because most of us have come from a different culture, a different background, we we may not be conscious of it, but we interpret the Buddha’s teachings through our Western culture and whatever, and so that can lead to confusion. So the Buddhist teachings are actually extremely profound and have their very own unique viewpoint. And this is not something that we can just suddenly understand and grasp altogether. It takes time. So you need to be patient.
There will be things you won’t understand. This may be just simply because I can’t explain it properly or just because of the nature of the topic itself, the subject itself. So you need to be patient with yourself and the teachings. It does take time. And this is why in the Tibetan tradition, especially in the Gelugpa tradition, the Gelug tradition, that listening to teachings is emphasized so much because we need to hear the teachings over and over again for them to go deeper and deeper into our mind, for us to retain them more and longer.
And every time we hear the teachings, especially if we’ve been trying to put them into practice and so on, then every time we hear the teachings, we can understand maybe that same teaching a little bit more deeply or in a more just from another angle, another perspective. So please be patient with yourself, with the Course, with me, with life. We need to be patient, that’s for sure. And things you don’t understand or find difficult to accept, just don’t get too excited and worked up. Just relax, leave them aside, and maybe later on these things that you didn’t understand will start to make sense, or even if you sort of intellectually understood them, didn’t agree with them, found them kind of repugnant, then maybe with time and hearing other aspects of the teachings, one can start to accept those things.
Because I think the Buddhism, like any religion or the way it’s used by people, can be a very conservative thing. Conservative thing. But the Buddhadharma itself is actually very radical. It’s very revolutionary. It really That doesn’t mean you go around burning buildings and things like that, but the actual Dharma is so contrary in many ways to the way we think about ourselves and the world and other people.
It really can bring quite a lot of change in our mind if we connect with it. So there are things we may hear that may be upsetting at first, don’t fit with what we’ve understood and believed. So we need to have an open mind as much as possible. I will try not to be too radical and revolutionary in this course. That’s enough of the first first introduction.
Second introduction is that traditionally, at the beginning of any teaching and this is particularly emphasized in Tibetan Buddhism I must confess that really the only form of Buddhism I know is what I’ve learned from the Geluk tradition. I haven’t had much contact with other schools of Tibetan Buddhism, or I’ve had a little bit of contact with Chinese Buddhism because I lived in Taiwan for three years. But I’m not much contact with Theravāda Buddhism. So anyway, in the Tibetan tradition, in the Gelug tradition, all my teachers have emphasized at the beginning of the teachings how important it is that for the teachings to make the greatest impact on our mind, the best impact, and for us to be able to understand them the way they’re meant to be understood, then it’s really important that apart from having an open mind and really trying to concentrate on them, be attentive, it’s really important to try and listen with a good motivation, actually to listen with the best motivation. So the best motivation one can have is what is called the bodhicitta motivation.
This is one of the jargon terms that one will need to learn. So bodhicitta is referring to the motivation of wishing to achieve enlightenment in order to help enlighten every sentient being, recognizing that all sentient beings have been very kind and all sentient beings are suffering. So the more we recognize that and the more we recognize our Buddha nature, our Buddha potential, we can begin to generate this bodhicitta thought, the wish to eliminate totally from our mind all obscurations, all limitations, all negativities, and awaken all our positive qualities. Of course, this is going to benefit us completely, but the aim is ultimately so we can be of perfect lasting benefit to all sentient beings, to repay the kindness that we’ve received from them. Even if one is, of course, to actually generate that actual motivation is extremely difficult.
It takes a lot of time, maybe many lifetimes. But even just directing our mind in way can be extremely beneficial because that is the most powerful, most virtuous, most all encompassing motivation motivation that we can possibly have. But at least I would encourage people to attend this course and stick with it all six weeks, because you may find one class particularly boring or frustrating or whatever and just chuck it in. But the next talk may be just exactly what you need to hear. So please make the commitment, if you can, to really stick it out.
It’s only six weeks, it’s not that painful. And with the thought to use these teachings or whatever you find in them that is beneficial, that makes sense, worthwhile, to use it to work with one’s mind, to reduce one’s negative qualities, and to help develop, awaken one’s positive qualities, at least try and have that motivation. But just very briefly, if I’m sorry for those people who’ve heard these things before, and I will try not to because I have a habit of apologizing for all the things I’ve said before, and I will try to avoid I will make this my New Year’s resolution, at least for next year, to stop saying that so often. But anyway, if you I’ll just do a little bit a long motivation here. If you think about today, like from the moment you woke up and had breakfast, just to have that breakfast, like maybe I don’t know what you had for breakfast, but if you just had a piece of bread and something on it, or even just had a piece of bread and a cup of tea or coffee, just to have that piece of bread involves an enormous number of human beings.
The person who put it on your table, the person who bought it, the person who sold it in the shop to you, the people who delivered it to the shop so you could buy it, the people who wrapped it up in some other place, then the people in the factory who made that loaf of bread or whatever you had. And then it had to be grown or the raw material had to be transported to the factory, then it had to be grown. Like if you take some wheat or something to make the flour, to make the bread, the wheat had to be grown. And so there was the farmers. And for the farmer to grow that wheat, someone grew wheat before them, and before them, someone grew it before them, going back and back for hundreds and thousands of years.
And there was also lots of animals involved, pulling ploughs and so on. And for the wheat to grow in the soil, there were all these insects. Without them, no good soil, no wheat, no flour, no breakfast, no happiness. So that’s just one thing. That’s just one piece of bread one time.
You cannot count how many sentient beings were involved for me to have that one piece of bread, that one little bit of benefit. And then there’s all the clothes we wear and the house we live in and the furniture we have and our cars and our entertainment and our protection and our health care provided by people and animals and insects. A lot of our medicine is made up of bits of animals that have been experimented on, tortured for our benefit. So just for us to exist, just to merely exist in this life, we totally, absolutely totally depend on an enormous number of sentient beings. And so just as this is true for this life, because Buddhism, I suppose you know Buddhism believes there were past lives and future lives, it also is true for all our past lives and it will be true for all our future lives.
And not only just for our mere existence, all the good things that happen to us only happen depending on others. We may enjoy reading and that we can read and enjoy reading because someone taught us, and then someone taught them and taught them back and back and back. So all the good things that we enjoy, all the good qualities we have have depended on others in this life, and it’s true for all our past lives, will be true for all our future lives. So it means that we have a huge debt of gratitude to others. They have been so immensely kind in countless ways, many of which we don’t recognise.
We just take it for granted. Even that someone serves in a shop, of course they’re getting paid, many people don’t get paid for working in shops, but they do it. And many of them do it as nicely as they possibly can. And sometimes they go out of their way to help us. So it’s incredibly kind because if they didn’t, we’d be stuck.
And so all sentient beings actually are immensely kind to us. We couldn’t live without them. And so that’s one thing. The other thing is that all of these beings are suffering just like we are. All of us are suffering in some ways.
This is a big topic in Buddhism, many kinds of suffering, obvious suffering of physical and mental pain, but there’s more subtle kinds of suffering of feeling dissatisfied. Even our happiness, Buddha says, is a type of suffering because it doesn’t last. It’s never completely fulfilling. So just like we are suffering in various ways, it’s true that everyone else, the richest, the poorest, the most powerful, the weakest, victims, victimizers, everyone is suffering in various ways. So everyone is incredibly kind and everyone is suffering.
So the Buddha encourages us to break out of our little self-cherishing concept where we just focus so much on thinking about poor little me and my suffering and how so important it is for me to be really happy, forget about everyone else, I have to get that happy. What the Buddha says, we need to sort of let go of that mind because we’ve been following it for countless lifetimes and it’s only brought us more confusion and suffering. We need to let go of that mind and replace it with really thinking about others, of cherishing others, recognizing that they are so kind, recognizing that they’re suffering. And that the more we think about those things, we can generate this bodhicitta thought, the wish to achieve enlightenment, so that I’ll be in the perfect position to repay the kindness, all the kindness I’ve received. And particularly what helps us to generate this bodhicitta thought, the wish to achieve enlightenment, is recognizing that we have the potential to do so.
And that comes from recognizing that we have a mind and what its potential is. And so that’s what this course is about. What the mind is as it’s understood in the Buddhist tradition, not in other systems. Because in other systems, the view of the mind’s quite depressing. Well, people say it doesn’t even exist.
But the Buddha says it does exist and the mind is truly amazing, the most important thing in the universe. Universe. So when we start to realize or develop a belief that we have a mind and it has these amazing qualities and potentials, then we can develop develop this wish to achieve enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings, to help them realize their Buddha nature, their Buddha potential of their mind. So please, as much possible, try and generate that thought right now as the basis for tonight’s talk and for the whole course. And the tradition is that there is a prayer, or there are various prayers that are said at the beginning of the teachings, but one of them, which I’ll do now, those people who are familiar with it, please join in.
Also, everyone can join in. It’s on page ten. So that’s the tradition to recite this prayer of refuge in bodhicitta at the beginning of the teachings. So we’ll do this twice in Tibetan for the sake of connecting with the tradition, and one time in English for the sake of understanding the meaning of it. So refuge refers to someone who, having studied the teachings for some time, feels a strong connection with them, a strong belief in the teachings and the source of those teachings, the Buddha.
And then one makes a strong commitment to follow for the rest of one’s life, hopefully for many lives, the Buddha’s teachings. So this is the mind of refuge, where one develops a faith in the existence of the Buddha and the perfect qualities of the Buddha, a faith in the truth of the Buddha’s teachings, which is the Dharma, and a strong faith and confidence in the great, highly realized practitioners of those teachings, which are the Sangha. The Sangha can refer to ordinary monks and nuns like myself, but actually the Sangha, in talking about the objects of the Three Jewels, what are called the Three Jewels of refuge, the Sangha jewel of refuge is not referring to ordinary monks and nuns, but those highly realized beings who have put the teachings into practice very deeply and have developed a deep unmistaken insight into the true nature of themselves and all phenomena. Those beings are the actual Sangha. When one develops faith in those Three Jewels, this is when we have refuge.
So this is for those of us who have taken refuge, it’s important that we recite this prayer at the beginning of the teachings. But for the new people here, there’s no obligation, of course, to do so. But since one is discovering Buddhism, you may like to join in to see what happens. Sorry, this gets longer and longer. And the tradition is to make this prayer more effective as well as trying to generate that thought of bodhicitta, at least the wished with developing a good motivation for listening to the teachings, to make it more effective and powerful.
What we try to do is we imagine or visualize the Buddha in front of us as the embodiment of all the Three Jewels of refuge. We think of the Buddha seated on a lotus, a sun and a moon disc. The lotus symbolizes the mind of renunciation. The sun disc symbolizes wisdom, and the moon disc symbolizes bodhicitta. Because these are the three qualities that bring about enlightenment, developing complete non attachment or renunciation, wisdom, and bodhicitta.
So then one imagines the Buddha with a body of golden light in the aspect of a pure monk seated on those lotus sun and moon, looking directly at oneself with great compassion, and at the same time to inspire us with the thought of the Buddha, at the same time to motivate us to perhaps take the Buddha’s teachings seriously and connect with them and practice them, We try to motivate ourselves by thinking of our mother on our left, our father on our right, and all our family and friends, the people we like, which we like to put in front of us, we put them behind us to have less attachment to them. But all the people who’ve been our family, friends, people who’ve been kind to us, we imagine behind us. And the people we don’t like, who we don’t want to see, we imagine in front of us. Not to generate negative thoughts towards them, but to realize, just like my parents, family, friends, helpers, that these people have been very kind to me. Even if they’ve harmed me in this life, have upset me in this life, at some point in the past, they have been very kind to me.
In future lives, they will be very kind to me. And these people are suffering just like everyone else. So they deserve my compassion, not my aversion. So at least it’s really good to try and have thought of those beings, those people that you know in this life around you. But as much as possible and as much as one knows and understands and believes, one can try to imagine all other human beings.
But Buddhism talks about that there are many other kinds of sentient beings other than human beings. So if you know about that and believe in that, so for example, we Buddhists believe that animals and insects, all kinds of animals are sentient beings just like us. They have mind just just like us. But there are other kinds as well. So if you know about them, believe in them, try to imagine all these beings around you and think all of these beings are only kind, only suffering.
I will think about my mind and its potential and study it and work on my mind, not only for my own sake, but hopefully for the benefit of all these beings. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, Dharma, and the Supreme Assembly. By the merits I create through listening to the Dharma, I have become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings. So then we can imagine that Buddha in front of us now comes to the crown of our head, and then went directly above our crown, we imagine the Buddha dissolving into light, and then that blissful light pours down into us through the crown of our head. Imagine that it blesses our mind so that our mind becomes very calm and clear, very peaceful, very quiet.
So just focus on that calm state of mind just for a short time, just to create a very calm, clear, peaceful mind so that we can use that mind to listen to and think about the Buddha’s teachings tonight. Okay, thank you. So before going on to starting the talk on the mind itself, one thing that we’re going to do at the beginning of every session, and which is also part of your homework, is to do some simple breathing meditation. And there’s a very simple exercise called the nine round breathing exercise, which we’ll do at the beginning of each session starting next week and as part of your homework. So this is explained on pages twelve and thirteen of your student material.
So if you’d like to turn to that, I’d just like to go through this briefly. Most of you here may be familiar with it, but there are some new people. So firstly, there is what is called the eight point Vairochana meditation posture. Vairochana is one of the Buddhas, and Vairochana symbolizes the pure physical form of a Buddha. So this is what we try to emulate when we meditate, sitting in that posture.
So the ideal position for the legs to be in is what is called in the Buddhist tradition the vajra posture, which is usually called the Lotus position, that’s a Hindu term. The Tibetan form is the vajra posture where both legs are crossed. If you can’t do that, then one can sit in the half vajra posture with just one leg raised on the thigh, but otherwise, one just places your legs in whatever way is comfortable. When I met the dharma, it was mainly young people who were attracted to the dharma. People who are coming to the dharma classes these days tend to be a little bit older, so the body is a little bit older and not so flexible, so maybe it’s harder to learn to sit on the cushion.
So I would encourage people to try and do so if you can, if it’s not too gruesome. I think for everyone it’s pretty painful at first. It was pretty agonizing for me, still is sometimes. Not that I have very good meditation posture anyway. But if it is difficult, it’s not absolutely essential.
So it is okay to sit on a chair. Anyway, that is the first part, to place the legs correctly. Because if you can sit on a cushion, it really does help to keep your spine really straight and to be able to sit for a long time. Because actually even sitting on chairs is not actually, after a long time, all that comfortable. Anyway, in different meditation traditions, there are different ways of sitting in meditation.
I would encourage people, since one is discovering Buddhism and particularly discovering Tibetan Buddhism and particularly the Gelugpa version of it, in our tradition what we do is to place the right hand on top of the left, and then you have your thumbs lightly touching and then just resting in your lap. So if one is able to sit in the full vajra posture, then your hands rest on both your feet. But if you can’t do that, then your feet aren’t there, so you have them a little bit low, but just underneath your navel, maybe so that at least your thumbs are about at the height of your navel and you hold your hands there. And you also have your arms just a little bit away from the sides of your body. The tradition is about the size of an egg away from the sides of your body.
You don’t visualize an egg there, but just work out roughly how far away that is. The reason is if you have your arms caught right against your body, then your body will heat up. And when your body gets too warm, then your mind becomes drowsy. Dullness and drowsiness and sleepiness is one of the big obstacles to meditating, so you don’t want that to happen if you can avoid it. So that’s the reason for keeping your upper arms just a little bit away from the sides of your body.
So one of the main parts of meditation posture is trying to hold your back up and you’re having your spine straight. So you try and straighten your spine, lift your shoulders up a bit and then relax them. And yes. Try and do it in a relaxed way though. Don’t not have you slumped, but hold your body up, but not so it’s kind of tight and tense.
Because if your body is tight and tense, your mind will also be a little bit tight because our body and mind, although they are kind of different, they are connected at this stage. We would like them to remain so for a while. So yes. So the thing is to be able to sit correctly, put some effort into the meditation posture, but also do it in a relaxed way. Effortful relaxation, if there’s such a thing.
And also with your torso, you try to avoid tending to lean to the left or right or backwards or forwards, but to try to really have your body centered and your spine upright straight. And also it’s very important to try to position your head so that your head is not tilted down too much because if your head is tilted down, it tends again to make your mind dull and sleepy or also a little bit depressed. If you noticed, anyone who’s depressed or oneself gets depressed, the mind goes down, the head goes down as well. So just holding your head up helps to avoid that. But also you want to avoid holding your head too high because that tends Remember, this is just sort of general guidelines.
Everyone is different, so we all have to kind of work with these general guidelines to what fits us. But in general, if you lift your head up, it has the tendency, but not necessarily, but it can be an encouraging factor for the mind to become a little bit distracted. Because I won’t go into any detail now, but Mahāyāna Buddhism has two aspects. There is an exoteric aspect of teachings which available to everyone. And then there are the secret Mahāyāna teachings, which are called the tantra or vajrayana.
So the vajrayana teachings of the Buddha, which are preserved uniquely in Tibetan tradition, contain some of the most profound teachings of the Buddha about the mind. Tantric Buddhism talks about there are three levels of mind. There is what is called a gross level of mind, a subtle level of mind, and then a very subtle level of mind. This takes too long to explain. Too much information, maybe at once.
No, maybe I’ll leave that. I think I’ll bombard you with too much stuff at the beginning. I have a tendency to do that. Sorry. Anyway, what I was trying to say, in a nutshell, that the physical posture is not just something superficial or arbitrary, it is actually connected with the subtle workings of the mind, of more subtle levels of mind.
So the more one can put one’s physical body into the correct meditation posture, it actually helps the mind become calmer and clearer. Just that itself, the actual physical posture, is extremely conducive to allowing the mind to calm down and to become a little bit clear. And that means it’s easier to you’re creating a conducive condition in which to meditate. So the more one can sit in that posture, the more one can access more subtle levels of mind. And the subtler the level of mind, the easier it is to work with that mind.
The grosser levels of mind are very difficult to work with. Like when someone’s completely drunk and angry or angry, that is a very gross level. When one’s very drunk or very angry, that is a very gross level of mind, and that mind is very difficult to work with. When you’re extremely angry, it’s like very difficult to read a book when you’re very angry. When you’re angry, it’s very difficult to even enjoy what you’re eating.
It’s very difficult to control that mind, to focus that mind in a good way. So the more subtle the mind is, the easier it is to work with it in a virtuous, meaningful, beneficial beneficial way. And so if we can sit correctly, that’s really good. But don’t get too uptight about that and think, Oh, I can’t sit perfectly in meditation, therefore I’ll never be able to meditate, and it’s all point less. It doesn’t mean that.
Those great meditators doing very advanced practice, there is a real need to be able to sit in that of posture. But we’re a long way from that. We’re just at the beginning, so we don’t have to worry too much at this stage about that. Sorry, I going on too long about all this? I know I have a tendency, but I do like to explain things properly if I can.
Okay. Yes, positioning the head is important. You need to check that so that your head is not tilted down too much or lifted too high, but just sort of So you tuck in your chin a little bit and you direct your eyes down a little bit in front of you. They actually advise you to try and look at nose. The tip of your nose.
But that makes me just cross eyed, and I find that very uncomfortable. So it’s better just to direct your gaze just a short distance in front of you. And with some exercise not exercise, what’s the word? Experience, you just check what is a comfortable distance to look at. Because if you direct your gaze too far away, you can see too much.
And it is best to try to learn to meditate with your eyes open just a little bit. Because when you close your eyes, of course, in one way it’s good because you don’t see anything, but what you do see is darkness. And we’re accustomed when we see darkness to fall asleep. That’s what we do every night. We close our eyes in the dark and that helps us go to sleep.
But meditation is not about going to sleep, it’s about waking up, being more awake than ever. So the danger is when you close your eyes to meditate of just becoming dull and sleepy. His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, always advises to try to meditate with your eyes a little bit open and just directing your gaze just a short distance down in front of you, but not actively looking at anything. Because if you focus at something, then you can start to think, Oh, that’s interesting, and get distracted. So when tries to meditate with the mouth lightly closed and the jaw relaxed and placing the tip of your tongue at the of the palate, at the back of the top row of teeth.
This is not terribly important at our level of practice, but the purpose of it is to stop the flow of saliva because when one is developing really strong concentration, even swallowing one’s saliva becomes a distraction or can be. So by keeping the tongue at palate, that helps that process. So these are the seven physical aspects of the meditation posture. And then the eighth aspect is this nine round breathing exercise. So the way I’ve explained it here is a simplified version of what is done.
And this is done just at the beginning of meditation to reduce the gross agitation agitation in the mind. It’s not meant to be a meditation practice in itself to do for a long period of time, but just at the very, very beginning of the session. So what we do is in this nine round breathing exercise, the breath is coming in both nostrils and going out both nostrils. But one starts there’s various interpretations of this. I better follow what it says here.
Yes. So what one does in this nine round cycle is that you focus on, you start by focusing on your breath coming in the left nostril, so you breathe in, the breath is coming in both nostrils, but you just focus on your breath, being aware of your breath going in your left nostril, and as you breathe out, then you focus on the breath just going out the right nostril. Nostril. It’s going out both, but you focus on it going out the right nostril. So you do that for three consecutive breaths where you focus on the breath coming in the left nostril and then focus on the breath going out the right nostril.
So you do that left, right, left, right, left, right. Okay? And then you change, you reverse it, and as you breathe in, you focus on the breath going in the right nostril and out the left nostril. So you do that for the next three breaths, in the right nostril, out the left, in the right, out the left, in right, out the left. And then for the last three breaths of the nine breaths of the cycle, you focus on the breath coming in both and out both, in both, out both, in both, out both.
So that completes one cycle of nine breaths. So the tradition is you do it for maybe one, two or three cycles depending on how agitated your mind is. You imagine the breath, yeah, just focus like that. So having done that for one, two or three cycles, then you can do the actual meditation topic. And another way of doing this, which I think is explained here, yes, is to make it more interesting, more effective, but some people maybe find this more difficult is that as you’re doing that breathing exercise, as you breathe in, you imagine breathing in white light.
And that is very calming and pacifying, makes your mind very calm. You imagine it makes your mind very calm and clear. And as you breathe out with each breath of the cycle, you imagine you breathe out all your agitation, negativities, harmful thoughts. If you believe karma and negative karma, which we’ll talk about a bit in this course, then you imagine breathing out all those negative karmic imprints and so on in the form of black smoke, really thick, disgusting smoke. And it just disappears.
So you can breathe in white, out black, in white, out black, in white, out black, then in white, out black, in white, black, in white, out black, in white, out black, in white, out black, in white, out black. Like that. Is actually the very first meditation A slightly different form of this meditation was the very, very first meditation I was ever taught when I went to Chenrezig Institute with a not very open mind to Buddhism, I must admit, at the time. But it changed my life, completely changed my life eventually. Anyway, so that’s the exercise.
So it’s part of your homework for this coming week and we’ll do it at the beginning of each session as well. So any questions so far? Can I clarify anything? Please, it’s very important to ask questions. Don’t be shy.
Don’t think you have to ask unbelievably profound questions. Some people think the question’s too silly. Usually everyone else is dying to ask the same question. And I just don’t want to talk and find out people haven’t understood what I’ve been talking about or completely misunderstood. So please, if you don’t understand words I’m using or something I’ve said, please ask.
I’m very happy to try and explain if I can. Right. Mind and its potential. Finally, I’ve got to this topic. Oh, no, I haven’t.
There’s still more to do. This is for the newer people. Just very quickly, The Buddha appeared something like two thousand five hundred years ago on this earth and passed away at the age of eighty, having taught for about fifty years. From then, the teachings of the Buddha developed in various ways, got interpreted by various people, and various traditions and schools of Buddhism developed. So there are two major traditions of Buddhism existing in the world today.
So one tradition is the Theravāda tradition, which exists mainly or originated with the Buddha in India, spread to Sri Lanka, Burma, and Thailand, exists also a bit in Laos and Cambodia, but mainly it exists nowadays in Thailand, Burma, and Sri Lanka. So that tradition of the Buddha particularly emphasizes following the path to nirvana, to achieving liberation from suffering for oneself. And the end result of that, when one achieves nirvana, the state of complete cessation of all suffering, one becomes an arhat. The goal is to become an arhat, totally free forever from all suffering. The other tradition that developed from the Buddha’s teachings, or is believed was taught by the Buddha, is the Mahāyāna tradition.
And that tradition spread from India into China and Japan and Korea and also Tibet and Ladakh and Sikkim and Bhutan, Nepal. So that tradition emphasizes not so much becoming an arhat, but becoming a Buddha. Because an arhat, while they are alive as a human human being, they can benefit, help sentient beings. But when an arhat dies and enters nirvana, in that state an arhat has no awareness of anything other than the bliss of their own mind. They’re not aware of any human beings, sentient beings.
And of course, not being aware of them anymore, they can’t help them. Whereas a Buddha experiences that state of nirvana continuously, but is totally aware all the time of everything. Not just some things, but everything. All sentient beings all the time. And the being who has become a Buddha has cultivated their potential compassion far more than an arhat has.
So a Buddha’s awareness is constantly pervaded by great compassion for all sentient beings. Because you can be aware of someone and think, Oh, that person’s suffering, oh, too bad. So that kind of awareness wouldn’t be so great. But a Buddha’s awareness is pervaded by a total knowing of every being, but that knowing, that awareness is pervaded by an unbearable great compassion for the suffering of every sentient being, great love for every sentient being. And so Buddha mind works for every sentient being in a perfect, spontaneous, continuous way.
So to become an arhat, first one has to renounce this life, then renounce Samsāra. So I’m using a lot of jargon words, we’ll explain them eventually. One has to renounce Samsāra no, firstly renounce this life, then renounce Samsāra, and then then work to achieve nirvana. To become a Buddha, one has to renounce this first renounce this life, then renounce Samsāra, but not rather than renounce Samsāra to become an arahant, one renounces Samsāra to become a Buddha, to repay the kindness of sentient beings. I would try to make all this make more sense as we go along for the newer people, but I can’t do it all at once.
I wish I could, but it’s just impossible to explain everything in one lump. It’s just not possible. That’s why you have to come back for six weeks. So as I mentioned already, within the Mahāyāna tradition, there are two major aspects. There is the sūtra aspect, which is teaching a slow path to enlightenment, and the sūtra aspect of the Mahāyāna teachings is what has been practiced in Japan and Korea and China.
Whereas there is another form of Mahāyāna, which is the tantras, which is the fast path to enlightenment. Those teachings, because they’re very difficult and can be dangerous, were were kept secret. So these teachings spread a little bit in China, but I think they died out there. One form of tantra still exists in Japan, but the totality of the tantric teachings, which is believed were taught by the Buddha to just a select group of people, those teachings moved from India to Tibet and are preserved up to the present day in their entirety, only in the Tibetan tradition. So these are the teachings that enable one to achieve enlightenment as quickly as possible.
And as I mentioned, it’s these teachings which have present the most profound explanation of mind and its potential. And all four schools of Buddhism in Tibet, of the four schools, is a combination of sūtra mahayana and tantric mahayana. So for example, in the Gelugpa tradition, there’s a great emphasis on practicing the sūtra teachings of the Buddha as a basis for then being able to practice tantra. Because if one hasn’t understood and practiced the sūtra teachings of the Buddha about developing renunciation, wisdom and bodhicitta, one doesn’t have the proper foundation to practice tantra. Okay.
So that was all my introduction. Now I will try and start saying something about the mind. So all of the teachings of the Buddha, the Theravāda teachings of the Buddha, the Sūtra teachings of the Buddha, and the Tantric teachings of the Buddha are really all about the mind. There is no other topic subject in Buddhism other than the mind. It is all about the mind.
But the strange thing is there are not many teachings in Buddhism directly on the mind. It’s all assumed that the mind is there how but the teachings explain how to work with it and all the consequences of it and so on. Certainly in the English language, there isn’t much translated that is just directly talking about the mind as such. That’s why this course is, I think, so good. I wish I could do more justice to it, but a lot of people study Buddhism without ever getting around to really directly studying the mind.
But if one doesn’t understand what is meant by mind from a Buddhist perspective, one really is it’s much harder to really appreciate and understand what Buddhism is, what the Dharma is about. But once one gets the hang of what is meant by mind and its implications in Buddhism, I think everything in Dharma is so much easier to understand and makes so much more sense when you understand it from that perspective. So in order to understand mind, by understanding mind sorry, start again it’s really necessary to understand the Buddhist view of mind in order to understand karma. Everyone knows karma. This word is used more and more now, everyone’s talking about karma, but there is a particular view of karma in Buddhism.
But to understand that properly, one needs to understand what is meant by mind in Buddhism. To understand rebirth, which is a key concept in Buddhism, one needs to understand mind. If you don’t understand mind, you can’t understand rebirth. Once one understands what the mind is, I think it’s just obvious that there is rebirth and that there is past lives and future lives once one gets an idea and a belief in what in the mind. Also, Buddhism talks about different realms of existence and that makes much more sense when one understands the mind.
And the key teaching of the Buddha, because Buddhism is about helping us ultimately there’s so many ways one could talk about what Buddhism is, but one essential way of saying what Buddhism is, it’s about the Buddha’s teachings are about the Buddha appeared in this world to teach us how we can stop suffering, with the implication of how we can therefore be really happy to experience genuine happiness. And further from that, not only how we can stop suffering and be happy, but how we can help everyone stop suffering and how we can help everyone become genuinely happy. So to do that, the Buddha said there is a cause. The first teaching the Buddha gave is the teaching on the four noble truths, that there is suffering, that there is a true cause of suffering, and there is a true cessation of suffering, and there is a path whereby one can bring about that true cessation. So without going into any detail now, the Buddha said that all our suffering comes because we do not understand our true nature.
We don’t really understand how we exist, and we don’t understand understand how anything exists. We don’t really know. We are not directly experiencing correctly how we ourselves personally exist. We do not correctly, directly experience how anything actually exists. We’re all in a state of ignorance about who we are, about how everything exists and works.
And because of that fundamental ignorance, we all suffer and we create the causes of suffering and we act as conditions for others to suffer. So the key teaching of the Buddha is the wisdom teachings of indicating how things actually do exist, how we actually exist. So to understand those wisdom teachings, one has to understand the mind, get an idea of what the Buddha meant by mind, not what psychology means by mind or scientists mean by mind, but what the Buddha meant by mind. So it’s very difficult to say what the mind really is. The definition of it is extremely simple, but to understand that is quite tricky.
But before I get into that, I just have to say, I can’t prove anything that the Buddha said. That’s kind of impossible, unfortunately. I wish I could. Because everything really depends on faith, but not blind faith. One of the things or the Buddha emphasizes, and certainly His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, as a true follower of the Buddha, if you ever attend any teachings by His Holiness, and he’ll be coming to Melbourne and Sydney next year very briefly, One of the things His Holiness constantly emphasizes is how important it is to investigate carefully, scientifically oneself.
Lama Yeshe, the founder of the FPMT, always used to say, Check up. Or, Check up, dear, he used to say. Check up, dear. And that’s what the Buddha said, Check up. Don’t believe what I say just because I said it.
Check up yourself. Because if you check up yourself and come to the same conclusion yourself, then your belief, your faith will be very strong. But if you only just have a blind belief because you think I’m nice, then someone else will come along and say something and your belief will collapse and your life will become miserable. But if one has reasons for believing, then one’s faith can be very strong. And there are definitely, I think, reasons to believe that the Buddha’s view of mind is true.
But it’s difficult to prove it, and I think it’s just become incredibly more difficult with the invention of artificial intelligence, which has got me really worried in many ways. Because I think they’ve just now invented Was it Google or someone has just Mr. Google has just invented a robot? Firstly, they taught some robots how to play What is it? Go?
Is it Chinese chess, which is called Go? Anyway, they taught some robots how to play it. But now these robots have taught other robots by themselves. They didn’t have any human beings. The robots taught other robots how to play it and they can beat the world’s champion in seconds flat.
So is that robot a sentient being? I don’t think so. Anyway, the key thing is that in modern times, like in our language, in the English language, we have the word mind. So language corresponds with some things we believe in. So we all talk about we’ve got a mind.
Everyone says, You all believe you’ve got a mind, right? Yeah? You’ve been more enthusiastic. Yes. Yeah, we all believe we’ve got a mind, but do we know what that mind actually is?
And in our culture to a large extent, often the mind is associated just simply with the brain, that it is the brain or some kind of byproduct of the brain. So this is a very interesting point because Buddhism says the mind The Buddha says the mind is not the brain and it is not a byproduct of the brain. And I would like to be able to prove this, but I can’t. And it’s very, very difficult. It’s extremely difficult.
But this is the key point. And even it’s quite, I’ve tried a little bit to read various scientific articles about the mind and so on. And they start using the term brain and mind often interchangeably, which is not very scientific. Sometimes in the article they’re talking about the brain and the mind as being different things and then suddenly they’re using the same words, the two words for the same thing. Some scientists argue there’s no such thing as mind, yet there’s just the brain.
Everything can be explained by functioning of the brain. There’s there’s nothing else. So this is not the Buddhist view. Buddhism says the Buddha says there is mind, and it is not the brain, and it is not some electrical activity of the brain or some kind of chemical reactions produced by the brain, it’s got in a sense ultimately nothing to do with the brain. It is something completely different altogether.
So what is it? This is very difficult. The special feature of the brain, there’s two features of the brain. Oh, actually, definition of mind in Buddhism, as given in the Gelugpa tradition, by the lamas of the Gelugpa tradition, is that the mind is that which is clear and knowing. The mind is that which is clear and knowing.
Some great lama I’m not capable of doing this, but many great lamas could explain that for months on end, what clear and knowing means, but I can only talk for about five minutes on it. But I’ll try to talk a bit more as we go on in the course, but the essential at our level to understand what the word clear is referring to is that the mind is formless. It is non physical, and it has none of the characteristics of physical so that you cannot see it, you cannot hear it, you can’t taste it, touch it. It has no dimensions, it has no weight. It is not physical.
It is formless, it is without any kind of physical form. It is like space. It is not space, but it is like space in that it has no physical form. It has no shape, no dimension, no color, none of the characteristics of form, but it exists. It is like space, but it exists.
And so the wonderful quality of mind, the unique quality of mind, is that it is clear, and the unique quality of mind is that it is knowing. So it is only mind that can know, has the ability and potential to know things. And what we can also understand by the term knowing is that the mind is that which experiences things. A robot can learn or can learn to play chess or various things. And now the most advanced ones can teach other robots to play chess.
But I would argue, I probably can’t argue, but some smarter, his holiness would argue that the robot isn’t experiencing what it’s doing. It’s not experiencing it. Because with every moment of knowing, with every moment of mind or consciousness, mind and consciousness, more or less the same thing. In every moment of consciousness, every moment of experience, there is feeling. This is one of the distinguishing features of mind or consciousness.
It knows, it experiences, and it feels. A robot does not feel. It can act like it feels. It can look like it feels because it’s been programmed to do those things, but it does not actually experience feelings. Are three in our English language, which is unfortunately the only language I know, our word feeling is used in all sorts of strange ways.
I feel sick. I feel that this is not right. We use it in very vague, interesting ways. But in Buddhism, I don’t know the actual I should probably know the Sanskrit or Tibetan for feeling, but I don’t. But we’ve only got this word to translate the Sanskrit or the Tibetan term, but it has specific meanings which is not so vague.
So feeling is referring to There are three kinds of feelings. There are pleasant feelings, unpleasant feelings, and neutral feelings. There’s pleasant feelings related to happiness, unpleasant feelings related to suffering, and there are neutral feelings. So neutral feelings are still an experience. This thing, this object has no feelings whatsoever.
If I massage it, doesn’t have pleasant feelings. If I get it, it doesn’t have unpleasant feelings. And even while it’s just there, it doesn’t have neutral feelings. It has no feelings. Neutral feeling is a feeling.
Like for example, probably most of us right now, if we try and check at the tip of our fingers, aren’t experiencing pleasant feelings or unpleasant feelings. There’s just a neutral feeling, but there is feeling there. Because we’re not dead. A dead body has no feelings. A alive body has feelings.
Well, the body is Oh, this is getting tricky. The body itself doesn’t have any feelings from a Buddhist point of view. It’s the mind that pervades the body that has the feelings. I’ll just say a little bit more to confuse everyone and then we’ll take a break. One way of looking at feelings is that there are three kinds, pleasant, unpleasant and neutral but there’s also another way of looking at them which is that there are physical feelings and mental feelings.
But both physical feelings and mental feelings are all mind. It’s just that physical feelings are experienced through the body, whereas mental feelings don’t depend on the body. So for example, if our body is cut, there is physical feeling, painful and unpleasant physical feeling. But that feeling actually is consciousness. It is not the body.
It’s dependent on something happening to the body, but it is the mind knowing that, experiencing it. So if we cut our hand, there’s unpleasant physical feeling, but also the mind itself can have unpleasant mental feeling as well. Oh, my hand is cut, I might die, I might bleed to death. So we have these feelings or thoughts and feelings that go with those thoughts that are unpleasant, unhappy suffering feelings. But they both are consciousness.
This is the Buddha’s view. And same as pleasant feelings, pleasant physical feelings, pleasant mental feelings, neutral body feelings, neutral mental feelings. But it’s all consciousness. It’s all like space. It’s non physical.
You can’t locate it anywhere at all. You can’t see it. No machine will see it, but it’s existing. Okay. We’ll take a break, fifteen minute break.
Right. So did you hear that question? Do you have any questions so far? Oh, right. Sorry.
Okay. So the Buddhist view is that the mind definitely exists. It is really the most important thing in universe. In fact, the only way the universe can exist is because of mind. If the mind didn’t exist, nothing would exist.
There would be no way of knowing it, and if One definition of an existent thing in Buddhism is that which can be known. If something can’t be known, it doesn’t exist. And how is it known? By the mind. I mean, one could argue that there are things floating around existing in the world that we don’t know about, but that just becomes just a completely abstract argument that just some kind of fantasy.
But in reality, from the Buddha’s point of view, the only way something does exist is it depends on the mind, the mind knowing it. If there is not any mind existing that is not knowing it, it doesn’t exist. There are things that our minds don’t know at the moment, but that doesn’t mean they don’t exist. They do because there are minds more purified than ours that know them. So the mind is really the most important thing.
Without it, nothing exists. Do we know how do we have a body? Or how do we know we have a body? It’s because experiencing our body. Our body isn’t knowing our body, it’s our mind that’s experiencing it.
And we have a sense of self. This is a very very important topic. We have this sense of I, me, all the time. Sometimes it’s very strong and very obvious, but it’s actually there all this time, this sense of me, me, me, this what is called in Buddhism, I grasping. We’re always grasping at this sense of me, of I, all the time.
How do we have that sense of I? It totally depends on our mind. It can only exist because of the mind. And then there is this stuff, this world, this room, this city, this country, this planet, this universe. How does it exist for us?
It totally depends on our mind knowing it. No mind knowing it, at least for us, it just doesn’t exist. And also, what’s interesting to check up is the way there’s the mere existence of things depending on our mind, but also on top of their mere existence, the way they exist for us depends on our mind. For example here we go again. Fortunately, there’s always a vase of flowers to my left.
I would not be able to survive without a vase of flowers to my left. You see, there is the mere existence of these flowers. The only way that those flowers can exist is depending on our mind, our mind knowing those flowers. But then the particular way we experience those flowers, night, you know, flowers, depends on our mind. So there’s white flowers, pink flowers.
So some people might really like the white flowers best, think they’re so pretty, and other people might think the pink flowers are really pretty, and some people might think the flowers are really block. It totally depends on our mind. Some people will hardly even notice flowers. Some people will the first thing they see is the flowers. And it all depends on our mind.
Doesn’t depend on the flowers, depends on our mind. Yes. Because there’s mind seeing it. It may not exist for us at the moment because we can’t see it, know it, but it’s being known by animals, insects, and of course the Buddha mind is seeing it, so it exists. So actually, I’d just like to explain this.
This is very simple, I think, and maybe we can do this very simple, simple meditation. It’s simple but difficult, which is one can do this little meditation where you just become aware of your body as this physical thing, because our body is a physical thing. So you just sit, and because it’s a physical thing, our physical body exists in space. So it’s located in a particular place, and you can experience the weight of your body. For example, you can feel the weight on your buttocks, the weight on the cushion.
And you can experience maybe there’s a little itch in your head or on your nose, on your ear, or part of your body feels warm, part of your body where there’s just bare skin may feel a little bit cooler. Right? Don’t do too much meditation now, just listen. So the idea, we’ll do it, I’m just describing it, then we’ll do it. So you just become aware, just in a very simple way, nothing fancy, complicated, just feel, just observe the physical body.
And then the tricky thing is to try to, in a sense, stand back a little bit and try to be aware that there is your body and there’s the knowing of your body. And These two things are different. And although if we’re really honest, we can’t do this completely yet because our mind isn’t subtle enough, one at least can start to get some intellectual and a tiny sense taste of the difference. That there is your body, this physical lump here, and then there’s the knowing, the experiencing of it. Just the mere simple experience, and that mere knowing of your body, in any way whatsoever, that mere knowing is mind, is consciousness.
It’s not your body, and it’s not something physical, and it’s not your brain. It is consciousness knowing your body. So just try it. Don’t force it. Just be relaxed and just sort of sit comfortably and just experience your body as a thing, having weight, solidity, hot and cold and so on, all those physical things, just note in a very simple way those physical qualities.
And as you continue to be aware of those physical qualities, just try to have that sense awareness that there is that, there is that which is knowing this body with its physical qualities. Physical qualities. And that knowing is not the same as those physical qualities. It is something formless without shape or color. So just continue that for a short time.
Just go back step back, try again catch that knowing of the body. If you become aware of a noise of a car going by. So the noise, the sound of the car, that’s something physical. But then there’s the knowing of the noise, the experiencing of it. That’s your mind.
It’s different. Okay. Thank you. So according to the Buddhist view, a sentient being is a living being that has mind, that has consciousness. And every sentient being, by definition, has a mind.
So all minds are the same. There is no difference. Minds are that which knows A mind is that which is clear and knowing. So all minds are clear. You can’t have one mind more clear than the other, especially in the sense of being formless.
Formless is formless. You can’t have something more formless and less formless. Right? So all minds are the same. They are all clear and they’re all knowing.
They all have this ability to know, to experience, to feel. They’re all exactly the same. Bodies are different, but the mind is the same. But that doesn’t mean that we’re all one, that there’s just one big mind, because all our minds are the same in nature, but each mind is a discrete entity, a separate entity. To give a rough analogy, I hope this is If you have a car factory that produces a particular kind of car, or used to produce Holdens, doesn’t do it anymore.
So this factory produces Holden Manaros or something. Think they died a long time ago, didn’t they? But anyway, that’s the only one I can think of. So every Holden Monaro is the same, but the factory doesn’t produce just one Holden Monaro, or all the cars when they come out of the factory merge into just one Holden. There are many of them, but they’re all the same.
Same nature, but discrete separate entities. We’re all of us here, we’re discrete separate entities from each other, but our minds are exactly the same in nature. Our minds are clear and knowing. What distinguishes our minds at the moment is Just go back a bit. So the nature of the mind is to know.
If it’s allowed to do it, it will know anything. If something exists, the mind can know it. And yeah, so for example, when we were born, we could not walk. We did not know how to walk. But through trial and error, we learned how to walk step by step, one step at a time, through a process of knowing and experiencing.
Or if you learn a language, first you don’t know the language, then step by experiencing over and over again, one knows more and more. So we are able to know many things at the moment, but our mind, our ability or our potential to know is obscured. That’s why we’re suffering. So even when we know, we can never say right now as ordinary beings whether what we know is one hundred percent true or not. Because sometimes what we know is correct and sometimes it’s not correct.
And we don’t know. But we have the potential to know. But when what is for example, right now I’m trying to explain something about the mind and you’re listening, so you are knowing what I’m saying. But are you knowing everything I’m saying correctly? I don’t know.
But many things are going on in your mind so that you’re not able to know exactly what I’m saying a hundred percent correctly. Or maybe some of you are, I don’t know. But we have the ability to know completely, perfectly, unmistakenly if everything that was obscuring our mind was removed. Just think about it logically. If something has the ability to do something, but something is stopping it, then it can’t do it properly.
Or it can do it a bit, but it can’t do it properly. If you remove the problem and this thing has the potential to do something, it will do it. Our mind has the potential to know. That’s what it does. There’s nothing else can do with that, but mind can.
But right now, our mind is like in a fog. It’s obscured in so many ways, mainly by all our thoughts. We have so many thoughts bubbling up through our mind all the time, most of which we’re not even aware of. Many people say when they start meditating that, Before I started meditating, I didn’t have many thoughts. Just when I’m trying to meditate and concentrate, I’ve got more thoughts than I’ve ever had before.
And that’s wrong, because the thoughts were always there. It’s just that when you start learning to meditate, you become aware of them. We are controlled by all our crazy thoughts that we’re not aware of, but they’re there. You get rid of them and all the other obscurations, our negative imprints, karmic imprints, you get rid of them and then the mind can know. And if nothing is stopping the mind from knowing, what will it do?
It will know everything, because there’s nothing stopping it. It. Because it can be known and nothing yeah. If something exists, it can be known, and there’s a thing that can know it and nothing is stopping it from knowing, the mind can know everything. This is our Buddha potential or aspect or simple way of describing what our Buddha nature is, our Buddha potential, that we have the ability to know everything.
And the word know can sound very boring and dry, like you read the newspaper, so you now know that so and so robbed a bank somewhere. That’s a very boring kind of knowing. That’s a very abstract intellectual kind of knowing. But there is a knowing which is a total one hundred percent engagement with the object, free of any confusion or mistake, and sort of an identification with the object, a full involvement with the object, which is something really, I’m not able to do it, but it sounds terrific, something very rich and involving, where the feeling that goes with that is complete. So when we talk about use the term mind in Buddhism, often people associate the term mind and consciousness just with intellect, but the Sanskrit word for mind is citta, which is where you get the word bodhicitta, bodhicitta, enlightenment, mind seeking enlightenment.
That word also has the connotation of how we use the word heart in English. Someone has heart, and so it’s referring to all good feelings as well. So the mind encompasses all ways of knowing, not just intellectual knowing, but total unmistaken, direct, vivid experience of things. So this is what we should understand more when the word knowing is used. It just doesn’t mean some kind of intellectual information, but a total involvement with things that awaken, that involves an appreciation, love, compassion, etc, of phenomena.
So just briefly, as I mentioned, in the tantric teachings it explains that there are three levels of mind or or consciousness. So there is the gross level of mind, a subtle level and a very subtle level. So the gross level of consciousness is the level of consciousness that we are operating through right now, dependent on right now. So the interesting thing is that according to the tantric teachings, the gross level of mind which we are using now, although it is non physical, it is not the brain and not a product of the brain, it does depend on the brain at the moment. That level of consciousness, that level of mind does operate depending on the brain.
And because of that, this is how modern scientists and so on say that the two things are the same, because if you do various experiments on various parts of the brain, various mental things occur that can be measured. And so this is used as some kind of proof that the two things are the same. But Buddhism accepts that there is a relationship, definitely a relationship between the brain and the gross level of mind, that if the brain is damaged, our gross mind will not operate properly for sure. And various mental problems are explained because of various factors relating to the brain and various I don’t know what the terminology is chemicals or something that not operating correctly or something, and because of that there can be some mental disturbances. So Buddhism accepts that completely from the tantric point of view, because there is definitely a gross mental consciousness depends on the brain and the full functioning of the brain, but it is still a different thing.
My way of trying to explain this is probably not a very good analogy, but especially I don’t know about modern things have changed a lot but if you have a television set, I don’t know how television sets operate anymore, but there’s all this stuff at the back that makes the TV set work. So if anything in the actual physical thing is damaged, then the television set won’t work. The image won’t appear. But of course, the image that you see on the screen isn’t totally dependent on the machine itself. That machine is a basis for some electrical impulses to be sent from a television station or whatever so that the image can appear. So our mind isn’t being sent from somewhere else, but there is the mind existing, the continuity of consciousness arising moment by moment, and so that then works through the brain to generate the experiences we’re having right now.
Now. And if the brain isn’t working well, that moment by moment arising of consciousness is not able to function well. Did that make any sense? Sense? No.
No? We’ll try again next week. You have to think about these things. Like I said, I can’t prove these things. I’m just trying to say some things to get you thinking to try and get a sense of this yourself.
Right? Oh, where are they? Where’s the homework sheet? On the table on the side. Oh, yes.
Sorry, I should have explained. Sorry, this is very bad, but I’ll have to stop here. We’ve run out of time. There’s millions of things to say. I’ll try and make it clearer as we go along.
It is a difficult topic to talk about. Anyway, so the homework sheets are over there. Please collect it as you go out. If you go to page seven of the student material, it sets out at the top our class schedule for each night. So from now on, for the next five weeks, as part of the course, we will have a discussion group.
So I’ll put everyone into groups for next week. So you’ll be put into a group. And so after the break, when you get something to drink, you can take it away into your group and have your tea, coffee and discuss at that time, then we’ll come back and finish the class. Yes. So your homework consists of reviewing the class, some reading to do, and a little bit of meditation homework and sort of a bit of mindfulness practised during the week.
So I really encourage people to try and do that as much as possible, however much they can. I think there was something else I wanted to say. I can’t think. Okay. So we can if people would like to join in, can dedicate the merit, which is on page ten.
So we’ve had a good motivation and an important topic. And so now, from a Buddhist point of view, just believe we’ve generated some positive imprints in our mind, some good karmic imprints, so then we can dedicate that these good karmic imprints ripen in a beneficial way for ourselves so that we can quickly achieve enlightenment for the sake of sentient beings. Due to the merits of these virtuous actions, may quickly attain the state of a Guru Buddha and lead all living beings without exception into that enlightened state. May the precious bodhicitta, not yet born, arise and grow. May that born have no decline, but increase for evermore.
Although I didn’t make it part of the homework, it’d be good to try that little meditation we just did, that little exercise of just checking your body and then trying to catch the knowing of the body. But you can also do that with anything like you hear a sound, there’s the sound, and then there’s the knowing of the sound. And then there’s the seeing of an object, there’s the object, but then there’s the knowing of the object. And then there’s the eating of your food, and then there’s the knowing of that. There’s the taste of your food and the knowing of the taste.
And they’re different. They’re different. And then you can smell something. The smell is something actually physical, but then there’s the knowing of that smell. That can be very entertaining a whole week doing that.
You won’t be bored checking the difference. You’ll be so busy. Thank you very much. Good night. Hope to see you next week.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- Gelug
- The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
- Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
- A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.