Discovering Buddhism: Karma Module Week 5 — The Four Opponent Powers and Purification Practice

2 h 5 min · 14,670 words · 2018 · Buddha House Adelaide

DB Karma (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
DB Karma (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Discovering Buddhism: Karma Module Week 5 — The Four Opponent Powers and Purification Practice
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 126-minute final session of a five-week karma module, Ven Thubten Dondrub completes the four opponent powers framework for purification, focusing on the power of remedy. He details six virtuous practices: meditation on emptiness, recitation of Buddha names paired with prostrations to the thirty-five Buddhas of Confession, reading Dharma texts especially on emptiness, and making statues and offerings. He walks students through the prostration practice step-by-step, including visualization methods using the Five Dhyāni Buddhas as a framework, and emphasizes why this practice—standard in Tibetan Buddhist preliminaries—purifies eons of negative karma. He then pivots to patience as the antidote to anger, arguing that anger itself destroys peace and creates causes of future suffering far greater than any present benefit, and that genuine patience arises not from suppression but from cultivating compassion toward angry people and reflecting on the harm anger causes to oneself. Suitable for serious practitioners and those already receiving teachings in the Tibetan Buddhist tradition.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Karma week 5.mp3

UUID: d62d4c07-3c48-4a40-9436-4e39e22a6d2d

Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub

Collection: DB Karma (Ven Thubten Dondrub)

Date: 2018 (exact day not recorded)

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 125.8 minutes

Words: ~14,674

So welcome everyone to our last class on maybe a bit loud on all about karma or something about karma. So still lots to cover. So please generate good motivation for being here. At least the thought, wanting to understand one’s mind and overcome all the negative aspects of one’s mind, to pacify those, eliminate them and awaken all one’s positive potentials so we can have that thought to do it just for this life but even better to think for the sake of future lives, even better than that is having the motivation wanting to take care of our minds so that we can become completely free of cyclic existence, of all suffering. But even more, the very best motivation we can have for working with our mind is to achieve the enlightened state, to be in a position to repay the kindness of mother sentient beings, trying to generate that bodhicitta motivation.

So if you’d like to join in the traditional prayer, this is on page twelve, visualising the Buddha in front of us, all sentient beings surrounding us trying to have that awareness these beings are only kind but only suffering. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, Dharma and the Supreme Assembly. By the merits I create through practicing the Dharma, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings. So then think the Buddha comes to the crown of one’s head then dissolves into light, that blissful light then pouring down into us, blessing our mind to be able to understand the teachings correctly, especially on the law of cause and effect, blessing our mind to be able to practice them properly, blessing our mind to be able to eventually gain the unmistaken transformative realisations. So then briefly doing the nine round breathing exercise, combining it with the visualisation of white light, breathing in white light, breathing out one’s negativities and so on in the form of black smoke.

Just doing that briefly and I want to generate a calmer, clearer, more concentrated mind so that we can use that mind to listen to and think about the Buddhist teachings tonight. Okay. Thank you. Drat. My mind’s falling apart at the moment I think.

Could you, in that striped bag, there should be my glasses. There should be. Otherwise in the top drawer under the mandala there’s a pair. Okay so there’s lots of things to say catch up on but I’ll just continue talking about the four opponents. No.

I didn’t know. You do it. Sorry. Sorry about this. Don’t get in a tizz.

That’s okay. I’m here. Okay. Yeah. Yeah.

So last week we were talking about the of the four opponent powers. And the last one is the power of remedy. So this can be any virtuous action but in the teachings it points out that there are six particularly powerful virtuous actions so it’s wise to use those if one’s trying to specifically engage in purification practice and especially if one’s trying to purify some particularly negative actions that one knows that one has done. So these are listed, if you remember, on page twenty two. So I talked about so the single most powerful one, but of course it’s the most difficult to develop, is applying meditation on emptiness.

Meditating on the empty nature of oneself, the empty nature of phenomena. So if one is able to do that then that or the more one is able to do that correctly, the more powerful the purification would be. But apart from that, the two most one of the others is the repetition of Buddha’s names and mantras and within that, in the Tibetan tradition, the most powerful practice is the practice of prostrating to the thirty-five Buddhas of Confession. So this practice is taken from within a particular Mahāyāna Sūtra. Actually in the Chinese tradition they have practice of prostrating to a hundred different Buddhas.

So of those hundred Buddhas there are these thirty-five Buddhas. The main difference in the way the Chinese tradition practices it and the Tibetan tradition is that in the Tibetan tradition the Buddhas are actually visualised when the names are. So basically did you get the practice last week? No, was it handed out last week? Yes.

The vajras, not the oh here it is here. Yeah, so here are copies if you would I’ll just take one. So there is that practice if you’re I would encourage people if they are, you know, have any serious interest whatsoever in following the Buddhist teachings, especially according to the Mahāyāna, to try and do this practice regularly if one can or to try and do it sometimes at least if one knows one’s made some big mistakes, and this is a very powerful way to practice. And I’ll put these, or someone can put these over on the table over there, but this is a large poster of the thirty-five Buddhas, so you’re most welcome to take one of those. Yes please, just the yeah, both yeah that’s true.

Great, thanks. So, according to the Sūtra these Buddhas manifest actually according to the Mahāyāna teachings, in the path, following the Bodhisattva path to enlightenment, at one point a Bodhisattva at a very advanced level, when they’re about an eighth or ninth level bodhisattva, don’t remember exactly now, they make these great vows of what they will do, what they will specifically do when they become Buddhas. And because of the enormous merit they’ve accumulated, then these vows become extremely powerful and they’re able to accomplish these things. So these thirty-five Buddhas, well, one of them is Śākyamūni Buddha and then there are these thirty-four other Buddhas made these particular vows that are all related to helping sentient beings purify their mind. So if one has refuge, depending on one’s refuge and one’s, you know, applying the four opponent powers and having faith in this particular practice, it is said in the Sūtra, I know this is all relate to karma, at one level it’s very difficult to believe and it’s certainly impossible to explain, but according to the teachings it says, if you just simply say the name of these Buddhas, it purifies eons of negative karma.

If you say it in faith, and just not by saying it, but if you have some faith and the more faith you have because this is how the mind works, the more faith you have in the practice and in these Buddhas and the vows they made, then just by saying the name itself purifies enormous amounts of negative karma. This is why my teacher Lama Zopa Rinpoche advises if you do this practice when you, and it’s combined with you visualise them or you try to visualise that Buddha as you say their name and as you say the name you make these full length prostrations to that Buddha. So since there are thirty-five Buddhas that’s thirty-five prostrations but in the tradition one is encouraged in one session ideally to do three full prostrations to each Buddha so that works out at one hundred and five prostrations and then there’s three preliminary prostrations where you recite this mantra. So that’s one hundred and eight prostrations altogether. I mean it’s your choice, it depends how much you want to purify your mind and become free of suffering, you know, and how much one believes in it.

Of course if one doesn’t have any belief then there’s, you know, one’s not going to be motivated to do it. But what Lama Zopa Rinpoche says is because according to the Sūtra just by saying the name of each Buddha or any one of those Buddhas it purifies so much negative karma, then the wise thing is to recite each name many times. So as you’re doing one prostration you try and say the name of that Buddha that you’re prostrating to as many times as possible. So it’s completely your choice really what you do. But basically again one applies the four opponent powers: developing regret for specific negative actions and also through logic knowing one’s done many negative actions in the past.

So wanting to purify that not only for one’s own sake but especially trying to have the bodhicitta motivation for purifying, which is recognising that all these negative imprints in my mind from these negative actions are obscuring my mind and with an obscured mind it’s more difficult to practice and even if I practice with an obscured mind it’s difficult to gain the results. So the more obscured my mind is, the longer it’s going to take me to get enlightened and therefore sentient beings are going to continue to suffer. So I want to get rid of all that so I can benefit sentient beings, repay their kindness as quickly as possible. So you generate those thoughts, then take refuge and again generate bodhicitta and particularly generate refuge in this practice, have strong faith that this is a true practice that comes from the enlightened mind. The Buddhas have manifested specifically in this way, just like the Medicine Buddhas manifest in that way to bring various kinds of healing and so on, these Buddhas manifested as a way to bring about powerful purification.

So then one recites the names and so then you apply the so that’s the first two opponent powers, then the third opponent power is actually reciting the names and prostrating to them. So even if you find it difficult to do the physical prostrations, ideally one does the long prostrations, that’s best. If you can’t do the long prostrations you do the short ones like we do at the beginning of teachings. If you can’t manage that, you can just sit and go like this. But, you know, if one can, one should do the full prostrations, or as many as you can.

Or you can just sit and, you know, do it. And as one is prostrating you recite the name, you know, at least one name per prostration but as I said my teacher advises to try and recite the name as many times as possible. And also to make it more effective, more powerful, you try to imagine that all your past life bodies, all the bodies that created all this negative karma, are prostrating with you. But also another way to do the practice to energise oneself to do it is to think that all your family and friends and helpers and all sentient beings are prostrating with you and therefore they’re purifying their minds as well. So I have to keep prostrating because if I stop prostrating they’re all going to stop prostrating so I have to keep going.

So then at the end of that, doing however many prostrations you wish, should at least do thirty-five, one set but one can do two sets or ideally, you know, three. Just to terrify you even more, in the Tibetan tradition, which encourages people to eventually enter the practice of tantra and then eventually to do long retreats of highest Yoga Tantra in order to do these long to successfully do these major Tantric retreats because one can there can be many obstacles to doing these kinds of very powerful practices which can be very beneficial, can have very many obstacles, right? And therefore that’s why people who are wanting to do these practices before they start these very advanced meditation retreats, have to do these, what are called the, in Tibetan it’s called Ngöndro or it’s translated as preliminary practices and there are four or five major ones that are common to all the four schools and one of them is doing this practice of prostrating to the thirty-five Buddhas, but you have to do one hundred thousand of them. So that takes about three months non stop to do one hundred thousand prostrations. So it’s an extremely important practice.

Many, many Tibetan Buddhists, even if you go to Tibet, I suppose it’s still possible, it’s very sad because the Chinese government is trying to destroy Tibetan Buddhism as quickly as they can. But even still, when I well I didn’t I visited Tibet in the eighties twice. But even then when you went to Lhasa, to the main temple there, the Jokhang, there would be these old men and old women prostrating like crazy, you know, all day long they prostrate. Or if you go to Bodh Gaya you see young monks, old ladies, old men every age prostrating, zoom, zoom on their boards at the temple, the Bodh Gaya stupa. Nobody can prostrate like a Tibetan.

They just go zong zong. It’s amazing. They’ve got you see how I prostrate like an old dog or something. But anyway, oh dear, yeah. So a lot of Tibetan Buddhists or Tibetans and many people all around the world now who are following Tibetan Buddhism do this as a regular practice.

Many students of the FPMT have done the one hundred thousand prostration retreat. I don’t know about many but lots, lots have done that. People do it as a daily practice. So this is good to do. And so having done the prostrations then at the end of it, if you look at page also what is encouraged after doing the prostrations to the thirty-five Buddhas you can then do prostrations to the eight medicine Buddhas.

It’s just one to each Buddha. And then after that, so they’re set out on page eight and then on page nine unfortunately it doesn’t I forgot to put the heading here but there’s this recitation where you confess all your faults and rejoice in all the good things you do. So this, that section page nine and ten, this is actually from that Sūtra, what is called, this is a Sūtra in itself, it’s called the Sūtra of the Three Heaps, the section where it starts off all you thirty-five Buddhas, as many, Tathāgata, arhat, perfectly completed Buddhas. Alright? So that’s like the conclusion.

And then at the end you imagine all the thirty-four Buddhas dissolving into Śākyamūni Buddha, Śākyamūni Buddha comes to your crown, dissolves into you and then you make the promise that you apply the fourth opponent power which is the resolution, I will, now I’ve purified my mind, then I make this commitment, I will not do these actions again for whatever period you think you can avoid them. You know, if there’s some, you know, like Like Lama Zopa Rinpoche says, Even You can say, Even for a few minutes, I won’t do this. If you know that you have some very bad habit that you’re, you know, you’ll definitely, you know, do it again, there’s no point saying I will never do it again because you know, we know we’re going to do it. So we’re just lying to the Buddhas and it’s not helpful in any way. So one makes a commitment, I will avoid this action for three minutes or five minutes or half a day or one day.

And then dedicate the merit and rejoice. Right. So that’s the practice in a nutshell. I probably shouldn’t say this because this will stop you coming, but we’ll do this on Sunday for those people who come to the retreat. And I would encourage people to come to the one day retreat.

They’re very good, very helpful. And it is the one time we get to do some meditations on the topics. Ideally, you know, we should it’d be good to meditate, you know, each session but there’s just not enough time to cover the topic and meditate and discuss and everything. Unless you’d like to stay a couple of hours more each night but everyone’s too tired from work. But so yeah.

So at least the retreat we get to do a little bit of meditation. So are there sorry I did that very, very quickly but are there any questions on that? Don’t be shy. Was that too confusing? Yeah.

We have to thank Chris for being one of the few people who ask questions. It’s so nice to have someone ask questions. Yes, please. Because you’re supposed to do, like, a visualisation of each Buddha, where would be a place where you could get There. That’s it.

The poster over there, I just said. Where were you when I just said that? So actually you may discover with time that there are various traditions of how to visualise the Buddha, the thirty-five Buddhas, because various great practitioners had visions of these Buddhas. For example, Lama Tsongkhapa, the founder of our tradition, he did a retreat for three years where he did a hundred thousand mandala offerings and he prostrated one hundred thousand times to each of the thirty-five Buddhas, so that’s three and a half million prostrations. I went to the place it’s called Wolka where he did this retreat with eight of his disciples while he was eating I think one or two juniper berries a day that’s all he ate for all that time.

He did this on a rock which he wore a groove into the rock by doing the prostrations but during the Cultural Revolution that was broken but it’s there in Tibet I saw it. Yeah. And so when Lama Tsongkhapa first, the first, there’s one of the Buddhas called the King of Naga Lords, so this is the first Buddha he was able to see but then all of the thirty-five Buddhas appeared in front of him but they didn’t have any heads. So then he added the term Tathāgata when he was prostrating to them as an extra sign of respect and once he started calling them the Tathāgata so and so, etc, then all their heads appeared. So then also the great Indian master Nāgārjuna has a particular way of visualising them and they’re but this Tanga here that you’re all welcome to take and use if you’d like, that a particular form that Lama Zopa Rinpoche himself encourages students to visualise because it’s the easiest one because they’re just in rows and each row, all the Buddhas are in the same colour with the same mudras.

And for those people who may or may not know, may have heard of what are called the five Dhyāni Buddhas which represent the five different kinds of wisdoms of the enlightened mind. So these thirty-five Buddhas are in the aspect of the five Dhyāni Buddhas. So you have a row of first the Śākyamūni Buddha, then there’s a row of blue Buddhas in the aspect of Akṣobhya, a row of six Buddhas in the aspect of Akṣobhya. Oh, maybe I should So the Akṣobhya is like the same Mudra as the Buddha with the right with the earth touching Mudra and the left hand is in the lap but not, whereas the Buddha holds a begging bowl, Akṣobhya is not holding a begging bowl. And then there’s a row of seven Buddhas that are white in color in the aspect of Vairochana, who represents the pure body of the Buddha and I can never remember the wisdoms they represent.

Anyway, so he’s in this, has this Mudra of Supreme Enlightenment which is something like that. He has various Mudras but this is the one something like that, the mudrā of supreme enlightenment. So then there’s a row of so there’s a row of seven Buddhas like that, and they’re all sitting on elephants, white elephants. Because the elephant symbolizes the mind, because the elephant is the most powerful animal, and they’re white, so they’re pure, and they’re decorated with strands of pearls, lots of strands of pearls. So the Buddha sit on those on a lotus seat on the back of the elephant.

So there’s the row of six Buddhas that are blue in color, then the of seven, the other four rows are all seven of them. So the seven that are white in colour in the aspect of Vairochana, and then there’s the row of seven Buddhas that are yellow in colour in the aspect of Ratnasambhava. So Ratnasambhava has the right hand on the knee but with, instead of the hand down like that it’s open like that in the Mudra of granting blessings and the left hand is in the meditation posture. And then there’s a row of seven Buddhas in the aspect of Amitābha, so they’re red in colour with the in the meditation posture. And then there’s the row of seven Buddhas that are in the aspect of Amoghasiddhi that are green in colour.

And he has his hand in the mudrā, the right hand in the mudrā of giving protection, like something like that, and the left hand in the meditation posture. So these are the you know, so there’s seven you know, Buddha, then six blue, then seven of white, yellow, red and green. So they’re the thirty-five Buddhas and of course they’re wearing the saffron robes of a monk. Something like that. Yeah.

Well, it very important. It’s very powerful really, but it’s also not something to worry about if one can’t do it very well. I mean, people seem to be able to visualise unbelievably easily. And some people find it like myself find it very, very difficult. But you just it’s it’s you know, trying to do it.

You know, it’s trying to do it. Yes, something, anything, anything or just the thought that they’re there, because they are, in a sense they are always there. So one way to visualise, the ideal way of course is to be able to visualise all the thirty-five Buddhas even though you’re prostrating to one particular one at the time you try and visualise all of them. But another way to do it is just as you’re prostrating to a particular Buddha you try and just focus on that one. You don’t worry about trying to visualise the other thirty-four as well, but you just try and visualise that Buddha in the different colours and Mudras.

Or another way, which I haven’t heard officially is correct but I think is probably okay, is if you can’t do that at least try and visualise the Buddha and because they’re all emanations of Śākyamūni Buddha anyway in a sense. So you just visualise Śākyamūni Buddha and think it’s the particular different Buddha as you’re prostrating. And another way is you can, like you start visualising the Buddha and then the first Buddha in the row of blue ones and so you build them up, so first you’ve got Śākyamūni Buddha and then you’ve got the first blue Buddha, then you’ve got the Śākyamūni Buddha, the first two Buddhas, then the three, so eventually you have all thirty-five. So there’s different ways you could try and do it. But the main thing is to try to have and the same with Vajrasattva is even if you can’t visualise anything, the main thing is to at least have the thought that the Buddha is there.

Yeah. Because many many many many many years ago I did Vajrasattva retreat with a couple of people and I remember in one session and like Lama Yeshe always wanted us to do the retreat, the sessions in the retreat very, very strictly and in the group we tried to do it like that so we weren’t really supposed to leave once the session started. And the sessions went for about two hours. We weren’t supposed to leave, we kept silence for the three months and but, I remember in one session towards the end I was just dying to go to the toilet so I was, you know, just, you know, I was reciting the mantra and visualising and I was getting up thinking, oh, you know, I just want to go to the toilet and put it, you know, no visualisations happening. And then I decided I just had to leave, you know, rush out and and what I realised is that I was telling myself I couldn’t visualise anything, nothing was happening, but as soon as I stopped and had to charge out to go to the loo, I realised that, and I’m not claiming anything special, but something actually was happening, you know?

Because once I’d stopped the session, I could realise that my mind was now in a much lesser state than what even though I’d been thinking, oh, got to go to the loo, I’ve got to go to loo, as well as that something quite good was happening and powerful. And I’d lost it because I had to go to the loo. So I was telling myself I’m not visualising, you know, this is not working, you know, all this garbage that the mind does, but actually something had been happening. Because I think it’s very important, you know, maybe some of this Anyway, for people who have no faith, what I’m saying just sounds all rubbish, I think, and just ridiculous, but, if the Buddha’s teachings are true, the enlightened mind is everywhere. It’s not a thing, it’s not like some goo hanging everywhere.

But the enlightened mind, enlightened awareness is everywhere, is everywhere. Yeah. It’s everywhere. So when we visualise that is a way, it acts something like some kind of conduit whereby the enlightened mind and the qualities of the enlightened mind which are in a sense, trying to contact us all the time, all the time. You know, it’s a way to be more effective when we open our, that’s what refuge is about, we are opening our heart and mind to yes, the enlightened mind, I believe in the enlightened mind and then you try and visualise it in that form, it doesn’t have a form but for our sake we visualise this incredibly beautiful form and that’s some way that the two things become very powerful for our consciousness.

So it’s not so much being able to, I don’t think actually ten points out of ten points, you know, I’ve got the whole visualisation. The main thing is putting, allowing the mind to have that faith that the Buddha is there. That’s the main thing and it’s working, the practice is working. That’s what it’s all about. The Buddha?

Oh yeah, sure. Well I don’t think that’s clairvoyance, it’s another quality but yes, when one is able the more we purify the mind, the more chance one can actually see Buddhas. There are different kinds of experiences that apparently you can have, none of which I’ve had by the way, there are where you can have what is it called? You can have dreams where actual Buddhas appear. I mean people sometimes think they’ve dreamt of, you know, their Guru and things, but you know, it may not be at all.

It may be, you know, quite a nice dream but it’s not but there are other dreams where the Guru, you know, can actually appear in the dream or a Buddha could appear in a dream. But then there are what are they called? What does Hallucination call them? But anyway there are experiences where you can with the eye, the purified eye consciousness actually see a Buddha, not just have a vision like a dream of a Buddha, a valid dream, a valid, you know, vision of a Buddha, but you actually can see them. But that’s of course, you know, something very very advanced.

You know, Buddhas can appear to us if we have created the causes for it. And of course there’s lots of stories in Tibet and all over the place in China and wherever of people sick, like seeing Tārā and seeing Kuan Yin. Oh I can tell you stories. Just, oh we’ll never get anywhere. Anyway, it’s nice, some stories.

When I was Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s attendant one time we went to Malaysia and met this man, his name escapes me at the moment. He was quite well off, he owned a printing factory and anyway, very quickly, at one stage, I think he’d been brought up Christian, but at one stage his brother got cancer and was diagnosed that he would die very quickly. So this man, oh, forgotten his name now, he did all sorts of things, went to all these various churches and things and prayed and prayed cause he was very close to his brother, please may my brother not die. And then, you know, he said, since he tried everything he, he went, started going to some famous Chinese temples and he went to this Kuan Yin temple and he, he, what did he say? He was telling Rinpoche this, he bowed, he knelt down and closed his eyes.

What happened? And he said, you know, if you exist and you can help my brother then I will, you know, I will follow you forever or something. And he opened his eyes, this was in a public temple somewhere and he said Kuan Yin was standing in front of him and he freaked out and said, oh please don’t tell me I have to become a monk, I’m married, I’ve got kids, I’ve got a big business, I can’t And she said, No, no, you don’t have to do that, but I will appear to you in the future and help you and you have to help people. So from that day he saw Kuan and you could dismiss this as just some neurotic projection or something, but from that day these people would start knocking on his door at his office in his printing house and they said, Kuan Yin sent me, I’m sick, help me. So he would do these healing practices and they got healed.

And but more than this, every morning he gets up bright and early and Kuan Yin comes and talks to him and he’s written it all down. I’ve heard a lot of stories. Sorry? I’ve heard a lot of stories about Kuan Yin. Yeah, yeah, many, many people see, yeah, many people, not even Buddhists, many, many Chinese people everywhere, whether they’re Buddhist or not, have a lot of faith in Kuan Yin.

Also in stories of Tibetan people seeing Tārā and this and that, people appearing. It depends on your karma and things and your faith. Yeah. Anyway, right, so the other, so then one of the other powerful ways of purifying is of course Vajrasattva which I talked about briefly and I hope people did some of the homework. So do you have any questions I can help?

Because we did it very quickly but we’ll also do this in the retreat the Vajrasattva we can do again, yeah. And then we’ve got it so that we can use it. Well, did chant it last week too but we can do it again, yeah. But as I said, normally when you’re doing the actual purification you don’t chant it, you just recite quietly and quickly. But some people enjoy chanting mantras out loud and it’s good.

Of course you can recite at any time and Yeah. Sure. Yep. Can do. But are there any other questions?

Is it sort of generally what to do is reasonably clear? Well, there’s nice it’s good imprints to hear these things. Lama Zopa Rinpoche is into all of this kind of stuff, having mantras playing all the time so dogs and animals and all sorts of things can hear them and yes sure, but of course it is much more powerful to say it yourself, yeah, because it requires more effort and the whole idea is to try and concentrate on it as well, the more one concentrates on it. Because of course you see Tibetans when they do circumambulations in Bodh Gaya and places around stupas and things, you know, they’ve got their mala and or mani wheel. Often you see these old ladies instead of counting one after the other go, they, om mani padme hum, om mani padme hum.

They skip about ten beads and things. But the whole time they’re talking to their neighbour about, you know, she said that and he said that and what about this and all that. So that’s not very, you know, great. You know, one’s supposed to be, you know, visualising the deity, trying to concentrate on the mantra and the sound and the whole practice. So the more one does it properly, the more effect there is.

But definitely hearing mantras is good because, I mean, yeah, this is very good for animals but for ourselves but also for example the practice of saying prayers and mantras when someone is dying so that the last things they hear, the imprints are mantras and so on. And some are, it is believed, can have incredible effect, you know, power to protect from falling into the lower realms just by hearing certain mantras and so on. So maybe just to clarify with the Vajrasattva practice, there are three different visualizations you can do one for purifying the body, one for the speech and one for the mind, so I mentioned those and they’re actually explained in the little booklet you have. So if you want to do a practice at night of purifying it’s good to do seven mantras for body, seven for speech, seven for the mind. But if you find the different visualisations confusing it is okay just to use the one visualisation which is the first one of just the light coming in and all negativity leaving in the form of black liquid from the lower part of the body.

That’s the general one. It’s more specifically for purifying the body but you can use it also for purifying the speech and mind. But there are those specific meditations, visualisations for purifying the speech and mind. Okay. Does that make sense?

Was that yeah? Yes, please. Yeah. So you’re teaching this to us, explaining it to us, we’re going to undertake to do that. If you were in, say, one of the Southeast Well, I mean, this particular practice of prostrating to the thirty-five Buddhas, although it is a, comes from the general Mahāyāna teachings, my understanding is it is mainly practiced among Tibetan Buddhists.

There’s a similar practice among Chinese Buddhists. You know, I lived in Taiwan for three years so they did, as I mentioned, so they do that, yes. How many people, ordinary people do it, I don’t really know, but among Tibetans, definitely, like I said, you know, most Tibetans would know this practice in some way and do it, yeah. And of course, you know, Tibetans also have this, like the people, you know, before when Tibet was flourishing, people living in the Far East of Tibet, in Amdo would prostrate all the way to Lhasa, do a pilgrimage where they would prostrate all the way for months in the dirt, you know. They’re into prostrations.

You go to Dharamsala now where his holiness lives, they prostrate all around the building where he lives, you know, not a little short circuit prostration but, you know, all around the hill, you know, all around. Yeah, most Tibetans do this. Yeah, not the young people anymore, no, they’re busy taking drugs and things, but Yeah. And they do Vajrasattva, of course, and Yeah. Many, many things.

And they memorise prayers and all sorts of things, yeah. A lot of it is done on faith, don’t have much understanding behind it, but they have Tibetan people have enormous devotion and faith in the practices. And the Lamas do encourage us to do these things. When I was in Taiwan, there were people doing all sorts of practices. Just ordinary people, ordinary people.

But again, it’s really up to oneself what one does. Like His Holiness the Dalai Lama does this practice every day, prostrations to thirty-five Buddhas. All the great Lamas do it, all these things, Make water bowl offerings every day. Every home has got an altar. Every Tibetan has an altar.

Even when I was in Tibet I stayed with, you know, with some nomads in a in a yurt, you know, a yak hair tent with a pole, and around the pole was a little wooden thing, Picture of his holiness, which was pretty dangerous, was pretty dangerous to have in those days. Possibly still is. You could get jailed and beaten up if you had a picture of his holiness, the Dalai Lama. So, carrying on, number three of the six virtuous practices is reading Dharma texts, especially on emptiness, but it can be any sūtra or any text, like the Heart Sūtra, which is a short version we’re on page twenty two, remember, of the student material. So the four opponent powers and the six special virtuous actions.

So number three is reading texts on emptiness. So, the Prajñāpāramitā Sutras are sutras on emptiness. So there’s the eight thousand verse Prajñāpāramitā you could read, it’s in English, it’s been translated, that’s available. There’s the one hundred thousand verses on the emptiness you can read. But there’s also the Heart Sūtra, which is just two pages.

There’s the Diamond Cutter Sūtra, which is about ten or twelve pages. So reading these is meant to be incredibly powerful purification. And of course the more one understands what one is reading as well, then this is even more beneficial. But it doesn’t have to be sutras on emptiness, it can be any of the sutras because they’re all expressing the Buddha’s truth, so these are great to read. And it doesn’t have to be sutras, it can be any valid Dharma texts, like reading the Lamrim texts and so on.

But again, the point is to do it specifically consciously, I’m doing this to purify this particular negative karma, having generated regret, you know, refuge and bodhicitta and now I’m reading this particular or doing this particular practice of reciting the mantra or reading this text to counteract the negative imprints I’ve put in my mind. So number five, because we talked about number four already, number five is either making oneself, if one has the ability to do so, or repairing or sponsoring the making of new statues, Dharma statues, thankas, you know, thangka is the Tibetan term for these painted images of the Buddha, or this is a painted one, this is a, what do you call it, applique image of the Buddhas, texts, stupas, and so on. So one can sponsor the making of, the printing of Dharma books. This has been a very common practice in Buddhist countries, like in Taiwan and China and Malaysia, all Dharma books are free, yeah, because there are so many devoted Buddhists who donate money for the printing of books. All Dharma books are free there.

Of course this is not the case in the West because, you know, Buddhism is very new in the West and there isn’t that custom so much, but it is developing. So, you know, the FPMT organisation itself has a publishing company called Wisdom Publications. It was one of the first companies to be developed just to print, produce, you know, good dharma books. So those all, you you have to buy them because it’s, you know, it’s an extremely expensive business to organise and it was started from scratch. But since then the man who started Wisdom Publications, Doctor Nick oh my mind, an old friend of mine, I can’t think of his name, Nick Ribush who started that, because Lama Yeshe told him, Start a publishing company.

No money, no nothing, he just said, you start a publishing company. So he did. So he was the first director, but now then he started Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive and those books, which we often give out during Discovering Buddhism courses, are free, completely free. Unfortunately, the one I wanted for this course has run out, is out of print. But there are a lot of those, you know, outside that you’re most welcome to take for free.

What was the name of one? I can’t remember the name of it but I think it was once called Making Life Meaningful or something like that and it had pictures of the thirty-five Buddhas in it and it had the whole thirty-five Buddha practice and a picture of the thirty-five Buddhas in it, but it was out of unfortunately. So this is a great way of, you know, you can donate money for making books, making statues, making thankas, These tsatsas, these little images of a thousand armed Avalokiteśvara which are just below the picture of Lama Yeshe, these are called tsatsas. So I don’t even know exactly what the word means but they are these little, you know, relief images of Buddhas. And there is a custom, one of the in the Tibetan tradition, in the Gelugpa tradition, a retreat of making a hundred thousand of those images.

They used of course in Tibet they used to be made out of clay which is a lot of hard work, making a hundred thousand of these with a mould, stamping them out. In the West we do it with rubber moulds or plastic moulds and plaster of Paris, much quicker but more expensive. Very nice practice to do though. So one can do those oneself or if one can’t, you know, has the ability to do them oneself, one can sponsor people to do them or, you know, also what is very nice is repairing such things, repairing Dharma books, repairing statues, thankas and so on. Also you’ll find in many Buddhist countries there is a tradition of offering gold leaf to Buddhas.

This can also be a nice practice to do for purification or just accumulating merit. But again it has to be done with all the four opponent powers and done really strongly and so on. And then the final one, the final way is to just generally make offerings to the triple gem so one can donate money to monasteries or Dharma centres, to monks and so on, or one’s gurus. Serving the Sangha, making mandala offerings. Mandala offerings is where you there’s this practice of visualising the whole universe.

So you visualise the universe but you also physically build it up by, you have this maybe you’ve seen me sometimes do it, you know, you have this base and these rings and you have these grains and various things and you pile them up as you imagine this you’re visualising the whole universe. So this is also another of the Ngöndro practices that you can do a hundred thousand times and is also something that many ordinary people do every day as a Dharma practice, as a way to accumulate merit. So this last one sounds a little bit dodgy because it sounds like you can just buy your way out of, you know, you engage in some negative action and then so you just make some offerings to a monastery or a temple or give some money to your guru or a monk and hope, you know, that’s it. But of course it doesn’t work that way, It has to be combined with genuine regret, genuine reliance on refuge and bodhicitta and really making this offering in a very, very sincere way, really not wanting to engage in negative actions again. So and making the resolution not to do so.

So it’s only if it’s done with that really good mind, that really pure mind, that it will work. And within that section of making offerings and serving the Sangha and so on, it mentions particularly serving, honoring and following the Guru because the Guru is, especially one’s root Guru, the person one feels has the qualities that can lead one to enlightenment, guide one to enlightenment, the person you feel this strong faith and connection with. Seeing that person as the Buddha, then by serving that person, respecting them and following their teachings and advice, this is the most powerful way to purify the mind. Also the most powerful way to accumulate merit. In the teachings it says, well, Lama Zopa Rinpoche, my teacher Lama Zopa Rinpoche often says, you just offer one glass of water to the Guru, visualise with a faith that the Guru is Buddha, you accumulate skies of merit.

Skies of merit. You give a billion dollars to ordinary people, you accumulate some merit, some merit. Yeah? But you offer a glass of water to the guru with the absolute conviction that your guru is Buddha. That’s a bit much.

Anyway, skies of merit, much more merit than offering a billion dollars to an ordinary person or to lots of people. So, and then particularly, particularly what is the greatest purification of all is following well, is following the advice of the Guru, but especially as my teacher Lama Zopa Rinpoche says, following the difficult advice of the Guru. Because sometimes the Guru gives some advice which is easy to follow and one is happy to do, but it’s also the job of the Guru, It’s the job of the guru to purify one’s mind. So this often involves the guru giving some advice that we just do not want to hear, do not want to do, find it very, very difficult and painful to do. But if we do that or try to do that, then that is the single most powerful way to purify the mind.

This is what Milarepa did, having killed thirty-six people, and he became a Buddha in his life. Because he followed the difficult advice of the Guru without a question he he never had the slightest doubt that what the Guru was doing was the best thing for him, even though it was unbelievably painful. But of course, you have to be sure that the Guru is the real thing, because if you follow some very painful advice from some dingaling, then of course it’s not going to benefit you. And there are plenty of these dingalings out there, unfortunately, and Buddhist dingalings, by the way. Famous Buddhist dingalings.

Creepy people you would not really want to have a bar of soap with, but unfortunately, they’re famous, they have big followings, everyone thinks they’re wonderful. And it’s difficult to say anything about them because it’s very difficult. Yeah. Because people have faith in them, it’s very bad. You can’t really destroy people’s faith.

But unfortunately there are all these strange people around, deluded people. So Guru devotion is a very tricky thing. It’s a very wonderful thing, but it’s also very tricky, both from the side of the disciple but from the side of the Guru because the Guru can start out okay, but as the saying goes, power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely. So one has to be really careful who one follows. Okay, so anyway, so in conclusion, the teachings say that any negative karma can be purified and there is one way to do it and only one way, which is applying the four opponent powers.

And within those four opponent powers is the power of remedy, so within that power of remedy there are various, many, many kind of methods one can apply within that opponent power, right? Any questions? Yes. This might sound stupid but what’s the definition of the Is that just who I am personally teacher or? Yeah.

Well, the word guru, you know, the Sanskrit word guru, well, is applied to any teacher, you know, if you are teaching something you are a guru. But in the Buddhist context or in a Dharma context, is is particularly in a Buddha Dharma context, the term guru is the person who is teaching one the Dharma and it gets very tricky. So but it’s used in in the sense of someone that you have faith in. The Guru my teacher, Lama Zopa Rinpoche says that the term guru, the Sanskrit term guru, literally means or has the connotation of someone heavy with wisdom. That is what the term guru actually means, someone heavy with wisdom.

And the term in Buddhism or especially among Tibetan Buddhists, the guru is the person or you may have many Gurus who you have a lot of faith in because you believe they have many special qualities and are practicing according to the teachings and so one and they are teaching the Dharma correctly as it’s meant to be taught so one can trust that person’s teachings and advice. But there are different levels of Gurus. The highest level of Guru one can have is where you feel that this person is definitely a realised being, you know, maybe a highly realized being, has the ability to guide me to enlightenment. So that guru then within that, in developing that guru devotion, there is the practice of seeing the guru as a Buddha. So this is particularly what is emphasized in the Tibetan tradition of seeing the Guru as a Buddha, Because that’s that is developing the highest pure view and by having that pure view, one is cutting through the negative mind and doubts and so on.

But that is a very tricky thing to achieve. Okay. Right. How much more time have I got? We’re not having a break, is that right?

Or just a quick break, we’re not having discussion. Some people suggest we wouldn’t have a discussion tonight so I can finish everything or try to. Is that okay with everyone? Yeah. Yeah?

We’ll have a tea break, a quick tea Tea break in France. When? Thursday. Oh, that’s now, isn’t it? Well, there’s quite a few things I wanted to mention but what I was supposed to talk about next is patience, practising patience, because this is the antidote to anger.

And the reason this is included in this topic about karma is because with anger, we create some of the worst negative karma, the most destructive negative karma. We engage in the most negative actions and therefore generate really powerful negative imprints and that can bring so much suffering. So patience is an incredibly important practice, you know, for that reason. Another reason why, especially in the Mahāyāna tradition, it’s important to develop patience is because practising the Dharma itself is difficult, it’s not easy, so we need to be patient. Yeah, we need to be patient with all the difficulties.

So here the main patience that is encouraged in this topic is developing patience in relation to subduing one’s anger with other people. But if one can do that, the more one can do that, the easier it is to be patient with every other kind of difficulty and problem and suffering. Alright? The object is different but the way of practising is basically the same. So what, you know, just quickly, a couple of points and then we’ll take a break and then I’ll go into it after the break.

But one thing to understand about patience is that practising patience is quite different from suppressing anger. Suppressing anger is not being patient. The anger is there, you just suppress it. Patience involves subduing one’s anger or diffusing it, right? So it’s quite a different thing because if you suppress the anger, the anger is still there and it just takes different forms and is affecting the mind in a harmful way.

Whereas when one practises patience, it diffuses the anger, and the negativity is diffused, is eliminated. So we really need to practise, learn to practise patience. So, yeah. So that’s one thing. Another really important thing to think about, to be aware of is because so many people have this complaint, is that Yes, ignore that previous statement but another important thing to be aware of is that patience is something that we have to build up.

When anger arises one can’t just simply be patient, Right? Patience is a quality that we have the potential for but we have to cultivate it, we have to train our mind in developing it. And if we don’t do that, we won’t be able to diffuse our anger. We might be able to suppress it, but we won’t be able to diffuse it. So once anger is there, you can’t suddenly generate patience if one has never trained in developing it, right?

Am I making sense? Yeah. So we have to cultivate, we have to train our mind to be patient when we’re not angry, we have to put these imprints in our mind, we have to cultivate this habit of what patience is when we’re not angry. But the trouble is, when people are not angry, they think, Oh, what’s the point of wasting time cultivating patience because I’m not angry? But the thing is we all do get angry.

I mean some people are more angry than others or more, put it this way, more prone to being angry than others and some people tend to get more angry when they do get angry than others. Some people, their anger lasts longer than other people, but we’re all subject to it, yeah. Some people don’t get angry very often at all, but when the object is there, bingo, it can arise. And anger arises when things we don’t like happen. That’s when anger tends to arise because something goes against our self-cherishing, against our sense of self, what I am, what I want, what I need, you know, and also, you know, I like, my family, my friends, my ideas, my political party, my football club, all these things, my country, my race, my religion, my my my my, anything that is against me and my and what, you know, I I don’t like that and that’s we get angry.

And of course, one of the things we really don’t like is going to be we’re going to die. We are going to die if we really don’t like that. So be nice to be patient when it happens because it is going to happen. So developing patience is really, really important. And basically, if you want to study this topic in more detail, there is a book that is by the great eighth century Indian master called Śāntideva.

He composed this text called in Sanskrit, it’s called the Bodhisattvacharyavatara, which translates in English either as the Bodhisattva Way of Life, the Guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life, Engaging in the Bodhisattva Way of Life, something like that. There are about six English translations of it. We have copies in the library and for sale in our bookshop. It is one of the single most important Mahāyāna texts written, probably the most popular book in Tibetan Buddhism. His Holiness says this is how he understands the Bodhisattva teachings because of studying this book.

It’s a wonderful book. So in there is a chapter on how to develop patience. So there’s all sorts of techniques one can use, but the basic technique, the fundamental one, is understanding the harm of anger. Alright? And really developing a deep understanding of how harmful anger is.

Alright? That’s the there’s so many arguments one can apply to that but that’s the fundamental thing. So in our culture, generally speaking, or in most cultures, you know, we all accept that anger is bad, yeah. But that is not enough to be able to practice patience just saying anger is bad, yeah. Or I shouldn’t be angry, it’s not nice to be angry, it’s not proper, you know, it’s not polite.

Those things are not good enough. We have to know why it is bad. Why is it labeled bad or negative or non virtuous or whatever? And we have to be convinced ourselves. We have to really know in the depths of our hearts that this is really harmful for me now and in the future.

And of course, it’s harmful for others now in the future. My anger is harmful for me now in the future and it is harming other people. This is what we have to deeply know, so that it’s so instinctive that once anger starts to arise, that knowing, this other form of knowing, arises at the same time and undermines. Because, as I often say many times, many times, Anger is not a solid thing just like there is no solid thing. Anger is what is labeled on a whole lot of perceptions and conceptions and feelings that bubble up in our mind related to how we think about ourself, how we think about others, the situation, a whole lot of things bubble up and all that bubbling up we label anger.

It’s not a separate thing, yeah. It’s all of that together, working together is anger. So while that is there, we say anger is there, right? And part of that bubbling there is while that is all happening, one of these things bubbling along is saying, This is good, I should be angry. This is the way to deal with this situation, get angry, be angry.

Whereas, so you’ve got anger. So, but over here, patience is another way of thinking about myself, others, the situation and whatever, and is reminding oneself that this way of thinking and perceiving and understanding and experiencing is good and that one is not. This is beneficial for me now in the future, that one isn’t. So you have those two bubbling along and they come along and the mind can only be in one state, you can’t be happy and sad at the same time. You can’t be angry and peaceful at the same time, right?

So one has to win. So, yeah, if this one, if you knock that out, all that stuff out, then you’ve knocked out the anger and you’ve got patience. That’s what we’re trying to do. So I’ll try and talk a bit more in detail. I mean this is a very big topic but I’m just going to rush through it in a few minutes but one could talk about it for many, many hours, how to practice by all the many examples and ways to think.

None of which are really difficult, complicated, it’s just we don’t think them. And sometimes for some people these are just because some people think the more complicated something is, the more correct and better it is. But some of the beauty of the Buddhadharma is some of it is just so unbelievably simple but incredibly powerful and Śāntideva’s chapter on patience is full of unbelievably simple statements, knockout statements that are so simple but so irrefutable. Think. They’re not clever, they’re not fancy with lots of fancy complicated, you know, existential explanations, gigantic philosophical rumblings and tumblings.

They’re just, you know, a couple of lines, wham, straight to the point. Here it comes. Wait for it. Right. Break.

So people like to grab something to drink and we could come back and drink it here and I’ll keep going, something like that. Pee break and tea break, yeah. If you’re saying of a guru, someone who has heavy wisdom Mhmm. And they’re practicing the Dharma that they’re teaching Mhmm. And can’t read the last one because of that.

Does that mean that we could call you a Guru? No. No. No. Because you’re being modest or because because you should be doing all of these things?

No. Am I raising you up? So just also by way of introduction, in practising patience a lot of people make the objection or think that this means that people will just walk all over you and use you as a doormat and, you know, take advantage of you. But practicing patience doesn’t mean that you necessarily let people get away with doing negative things. One should as much as possible avoid people harming oneself and doing negative things.

But what the Buddha is saying is that it is not necessary to get angry to protect oneself from harm or to stop people from doing harmful things to others. One can do it with a peaceful mind. And of course, this is not easy. Practicing patience is not easy. But that’s irrelevant.

Some people could say, Oh, it must be bad if it’s difficult. It can’t be right if it’s difficult to do. But practicing changing the mind is difficult simply because our mind is habituated from countless lives in experiencing things in the false way and believing they’re true. And although the negative states of mind of anger and attachment and pride and jealousy and so on can be removed from the mind forever, are superficial aspects of the mind. Unfortunately they’ve been there since the mind existed.

And so we are habituated with them. So patience is about breaking down that habit and building up another habit altogether. And that takes time and effort, effort but it’s really vital to do. So the way to, the basic way to cultivate, the simplest basic way to cultivate patience or start doing so because there’s no time to go through it all, is reflecting on the harm of getting angry. Because we have habituated ourselves to thinking, This is a necessary tool to protect me, myself and everything else.

It’s quick and easy, it’s what the self-cherishing does. Whatever’s quick, easy, that’s good. And anger can be very quick and easy, but it is very harmful. So there’s a whole lot of ways one could argue, points one could argue how anger is harmful just in this life, but these are not the main arguments why anger from a dharma point of view is bad, but even from a worldly point of view, anger, well put it this way, this is a basic dharma argument but it can be used in a worldly point of view. Basically, we get angry because we are in a we’re sort of happy about something or in a peaceful or contented state of mind things are going okay with me and mine, and then something comes along, someone or something comes along and upsets that situation.

So we become Anger is basically when we can’t bear something. We’ve we, you know, something is happening and that is upsetting us and we cannot bear it. And so the more we can’t bear that, the longer it goes on, our mind explodes with anger. And we’ve got upset because someone or something has disturbed my situation, my little worldly bubble, you know, and it’s been evaporated in some way. There was some kind of peace and now that’s stopped.

And so we’re angry. So we get angry to protect our little, you know, world and the peace and, you know, lovey dovey thing going on. What we need to what we need to check is and realise is that let’s just keep it to another person for another time, because this is one of the main reasons we get angry is because of other people saying, doing things and whatever, is that we say the anger, You made me angry, You made me unhappy, You have destroyed my little bubble, You did this to me, and that also justifies me being more angry. But actually, if one checks, it is one’s own anger that has destroyed one’s peace. This is what we have to convince ourselves about really strongly.

Just that itself is a way to cultivate patience, to realise that, to really get it, that it’s my, I mean, when someone insults me, let’s take insulting because it’s easier to deal with, because there’s extreme examples where it seems that anger is more justified but you know, let’s just take a simple example which is a common one because people fortunately don’t go around trying to kill us most of the time but people do say upsetting things to us, right, from time to time, either deliberately or unconsciously or whatever. So if we analyse those words, from themselves, you know, have no power to hurt us. The words themselves cannot hurt us, yeah. What happens is that our mind’s interpretation of them hurts us. We’ve decided that this person saying you’re ugly or stupid or blah blah, we decide, you know, somehow, unconsciously, instinctively, immediately that this is hurtful.

You know, if someone says, as Śāntideva points out, if someone insults someone, you know, if someone says, Oh, you’re ugly, if they say, I’m ugly, I get upset. If there’s someone I don’t like and the same person says, He’s ugly, I don’t mind. I’m not upset at all, I don’t like that person, and my enemy says, This person is ugly, I’m fine with that. But then when he says, I’m ugly, terrible. So it’s all our mind’s interpretation.

We open our mind to be hurt. Or maybe it’s more accurate to say, those thoughts that, Oh, he said ugly to me, you know, that does that, and that is suffering. And then that, we say, You did that to me, you made me All that is from you, you are bad, evil, nasty person and that makes me even more upset. And so it’s completely ridiculous, even from this life point of view. Because one can see that there are some other people who, you know, people insult them and they don’t get upset.

But, you know, we do. It’s our mind. It’s our mind that is the problem, our uncontrolled mind. So there’s no point getting angry. And also from a worldly point of view, some things to reflect on, you know, but the point is to really think about them so that they go deeper into the mind, not just superficially accept them and tick them off, but really think about them and check out, is that under the power of anger we say and do things that we regret later on.

Things that can be really harmful for our own interests in this life cause harm to people that we don’t really want to harm. Yeah. So we feel a lot of guilt, we get a bad reputation, because this person gets angry and angry, you know, watch this person. Our anger can cause us to lose friends and create enemies. So where’s the benefit?

Why get angry? And if you check, like, in what happens in the world, you know, like the situations like in Ireland that has been going on for hundreds of years. It’s still going on slightly, yeah, where people are shooting and killing each other, not so much now but still every now and again it flares up. This hatred, you know, there’s Palestine and Israel and all that Middle Eastern stuff going on. All sorts of horrible things all around the world that have been going on for so many years.

So, you know, people dislike each other, then there’s a fight, then someone gets killed. So then the relatives of the person who killed then kill more people on that side and then the relatives of those more people killed are now enemies of these people. So the anger just creates more enemies, more and more enemies. These people are angry with these people, so that makes more angry people there, and so those more angry people get angry with more people there, so more and more it just increases. It doesn’t decrease, the anger doesn’t lead to a decrease of a problem, it just creates more problems in the long run.

But the mind of anger only sees, you know, the immediate moment. All our delusions come from ignorance, which means they’re stupid. They can look very clever, but our delusions are very stupid. They only think in the immediate moment, but also at the same time, they grasp things are permanent. That’s why we, you know, our anger sees this bad person there and it feels like this is going to be forever, that makes it so much more unbearable.

And all of these are false perceptions which we grasp as real. So we have to spend time to think about these things, let them really sink in. Getting angry can make you sick. Makes you look ugly. Even good looking people, when they’re angry, don’t look so good looking.

There’s not even from an ordinary point of view, not much point in being angry. But then especially one should reflect on the Dharma arguments, which of course we need more faith in because we can’t see the long term effects, But basically what the Buddha is telling us, because the Buddha perceived these things, is that every time we Well firstly, the nature of anger itself, which we can check out by remembering, is that when we get angry, it’s painful. It’s painful. It is painful to be angry. Mentally and physically, it’s painful.

It’s disturbing. And the Buddha saw that a negative, a painful cause can only produce a painful result. Anger, no matter why we’re angry, whether we feel we’re angry for a good reason, a justified reason or a ridiculous reason, anger is anger and it’s generating negative imprints and those negative imprints are going to ripen to bring enormous suffering in the future. Right? Much more than any suffering in this life.

You know, to make the extreme example, because of anger we can kill someone. So there’s karmic results in this life, incredible guilt maybe, and even the most a lot of terrible criminals who have killed people feel terrible regret. There’s very few human beings who, you know, there are some unfortunately who can kill people and have not the slightest there are such people, but even good old Chopper Read, if you’ve heard about Chopper Read, he says he felt, you know, was a, what do you call a hit man for, I don’t know how many people he killed. And he, I saw an interview with him where he described these people he murdered as they were all, you know, the garbage of society so they deserved to die, but nevertheless he, in jail, suffered a lot because of his guilt for killing them even though he thought they deserved to be, you know, they were the scum of the earth. So there’s all the guilt one has to experience.

And I’ve met in jail, I wasn’t living in jail but I visited jail and spoke to a few people who have murdered people and I mean because of drugs and things like that and you know that these people, that’s what they say, you can see that they are really suffering. And of course living in jail is no fun, apart from, you know, just being in jail is a horrendous thing. No one wants to spend like any time in any jail anywhere, that’s for sure. Yeah, so there’s all that and the loss of freedom and whatever that comes from that. But that suffering in this life from killing is nothing to the karmic result in future lives of being reborn in the lower realms and then having all the other experiences, the result similar to the cause and whatever when one is reborn a human being again.

And although of course the karma of killing human beings can be purified, it’s very difficult to purify. And then one has to argue, so there’s that to think about, but also to think about why was this negative, why did I get angry? It was to stop this particular suffering that I was experiencing or felt I was experiencing. So to stop a little bit of suffering in this life, I created the cause, my anger creates the cause for a lot of suffering later on in this life, but then incredible suffering in future lives. So there’s no point getting angry.

It just doesn’t make sense. And then to take the extreme example where people would argue that it’s justified in killing because someone is going to kill me or my family and so on, if we die, if we’re going to be killed and we know we’re going to be killed, then we definitely don’t want even though we’re completely innocent, you know, there’s no reason why we should be killed from an ordinary point of view, then we don’t want to die with a mind of anger because that anger will throw us into the lower realms. If we know we’re going to be killed, we want to die peacefully as much as possible, certainly not with anger, in a state of anger. So anyway, that’s the major argument not to get angry because it is just creating the cause for more suffering for myself in future lives and developing the habit of being angry more and more.

But also, on top of that, is that every time we get angry, because, you know, it can apply to other delusions as well, but, you know, anger tends to be one of our most powerful delusions, is that every time we get angry we destroy the positive imprints in our mind. And these positive imprints are the source of all our future happiness and the basis of getting realizations. So not

Key terms in this teaching

four opponent powers nyenpo tob zhi (Tib)
The four practices used to purify nonvirtuous imprints on the mindstream. LYWA
guru devotion
After finding a fully qualified spiritual teacher and establishing a connection, the disciple trains in devotion using logical reasoning. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
mandala khyil khor (Tib)
A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
mudra chag gya (Tib)
Literally, seal or token. A symbolic hand gesture, endowed with power not unlike a mantra. A tantric consort. LYWA
preliminary practices ngondro (Tib)
The practices that prepare the mind for successful tantric meditation by removing hindrances and accumulating merit. LYWA
prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
tathagata de zhin sheg pa (Tib)
Epithet for a buddha; literally, “one who has gone to suchness.” LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top