1 h 43 min · 10,260 words · 29 August 2014 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 104-minute session, Ven Thubten Dondrub leads the third week of a six-week exploration of the four immeasurable thoughts from a Mahāyāna perspective. He opens with foundational motivation—developing bodhicitta, the commitment to attain enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings—then walks through equanimity as the basis for the other three practices. The core of the teaching focuses on love: distinguishing affectionate love (seeing the goodness and kindness in others) from the deeper wish for all beings to have genuine happiness and its causes. Dondrub emphasizes that this love arises from recognizing that despite appearances of success and comfort, sentient beings fundamentally lack real happiness; he illustrates this with concrete examples—wealthy people still suffering, terrorists trapped in minds of hatred—and explores why extending this wish even to difficult people strengthens rather than weakens our own capacity for happiness. He then introduces compassion, drawing extensively on teachings by the Dalai Lama to show how voluntarily taking on others’ suffering differs from being overwhelmed by our own pain, and how this practice generates inner strength and courage. Throughout, Dondrub emphasizes the graduated path: starting with those closest to us, then extending step by step to all beings. Practical for anyone working with Lamrim teachings; assumes familiarity with basic Buddhist concepts.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2014 08 29 Four Immeasurable Thoughts Week 3 29-08-2014.mp3
UUID: 1cbc9ed3-2cff-401f-bafa-e03b6cc57a19
Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub
Collection: DB Four Immeasurable Thoughts (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Date: 2014-08-29
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 104.0 minutes
Words: ~10,265
Would like to welcome everyone to our Thursday night class, especially those people who haven’t been here before. For the next few weeks we are going through just looking at the four immeasurable thoughts over six weeks. That is what we are doing, just briefly looking at them. Although these four immeasurable thoughts are common both to the Theravāda tradition and what His Holiness calls the Nālānda tradition of Mahāyāna Buddhism. Here we are looking at them from the Mahāyāna point of view contemplations that help us to generate the bodhicitta thought and if one has managed to actually generate such a thought to maintain and strengthen it.
Since this is the purpose of this practice then it’s good that we listen with the appropriate motivation trying to have the bodhicitta thought for being here and listening to and studying the Buddha’s teachings. Trying to have that determination to use this in all future lives to realize our Buddha potential in order to become enlightened so that our mind is then as an enlightened being free of all negative qualities that could cause harm to any sentient being and has all positive qualities fully awakened so that one can be of complete, perfect, lasting benefit to all sentient beings. And why should we do that? Because we have a huge debt of gratitude to all sentient beings because they are immensely kind to us, life after life. We are interdependent and reliant on the kindness of all sentient beings, which we receive in countless ways throughout beginningless saṃsāra.
Particularly we depend on the kindness of a mother, and we’ve received that from all sentient beings many, many times. But apart from that kindness, we’ve received the kindness of father from every sentient being and every other kind of kindness and support. We have received this from beings who are trapped in cyclic existence and suffering. The majority of these beings right now are experiencing far greater suffering than we are with far less ability to overcome their suffering in any way, to modify it, transform it, and particularly to eliminate it. In their confusion, the vast majority of sentient beings at any time are in fact creating the causes for more suffering, more saṃsāra completely helplessly.
By thinking about these things more and more and also thinking about them more deeply, we will be able to eventually generate this bodhicitta mind being determined to achieve enlightenment. But right now we can maybe just generate what Lama Zopa Rinpoche calls the effortful bodhicitta motivation. So to help us do that there’s the oh, I’ve jumped the gun before we do that. Anyway, that’s our motivation. But before we do that, firstly, we’ll do the prayer of the lion faced Dakini, which is on page five.
This is for dispelling hindrances. So if you’d like to join in, we start there. I prostrate to the gathering of the dakinis and the three places who abide in the holy yoga of using space by your powers of clairvoyance and magical emanation. Look after practitioners like a mother her child. By the teachings of the three supreme jewels possessing the power of truth, may inner and outer hindrances be transformed.
May they be dispelled. May they be pacified. May they be completely pacified. May all negative forces opposed to dharma be completely pacified. May the host of eighty thousand obstacles be pacified.
May we be separated from problems and harmful conditions to Dharma. May all enjoyments be in accord with the Dharma and may there be auspiciousness and perfect happiness here right now. Then visualizing Śākyamūni Buddha in front of us as our source of refuge, inspiration and guidance, we can offer a mandala of the whole universe as a way to request the teachings and by offering these things it helps us to overcome our attachments and all other disturbing thoughts which are obstacles to being able to understand and practice the teachings and by sincerely offering all the things of the universe as a way to request the teachings this accumulates great merit. It is a basis that enables us to understand the teachings properly and to be able to practice them correctly so that we can eventually gain the unmistaken realizations. In this case particularly the realizations associated with the four immeasurable thoughts of love, compassion oh, sorry.
Firstly, equanimity, love, compassion. Sorry. I just that always happens. Badly designed, this mandala. You see, you can tell you’ve got a dodo teacher.
This no. No. The the lamas, that never happens with the lamas. There’s nothing I can do with any kind of grace or dignity. Just a complete dodo.
So sorry about that. Lama Zopa Rinpoche used to have the most beautiful mandala set in the world that Lama Yeshe gave him. So when Rinpoche did the mandala offering, was just so beautiful. Anyway, then he gave the mandala set to Pabongka Rinpoche. Because Pabongka Rinpoche one day said, oh, that’s nice, so he gave it to him.
But if you say this is nice to me, I won’t give you this. That’s another reason I’m a dodo teacher. Sorry. Sorry, that was very delete all of that. We try and generate a good mind of offering them so we visualize the Buddha in front of us and try and sincerely make a heartfelt offering to the Buddha as a way to request the teaching.
So then continuing to think of the Buddha in front of us, we try and particularly focus on all sentient beings surrounding us and trying to have that awareness of how they are only kind but unfortunately only suffering. So in this way trying to generate the bodhicitta motivation as we recite the prayer refuge in bodhicitta. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, Dharma, the Supreme Assembly by the merits I create through teaching the Dharma. May I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings. So then we can imagine the Buddha being very pleased with our motivation and showing this by now coming to the crown of our head.
And when directly above our crown, we imagine the Buddha then dissolving into blissful golden light. And then that light pouring down into us, blessing our mind. And then just briefly, we can do some breathing meditation such as the nine round breathing exercise just to let the mind become a little bit calmer, clearer, more concentrated so that we can use that mind to listen to and think about the Buddha’s teachings tonight. In the first week I talked a little bit about the first of the four immeasurable thoughts which is the immeasurable thought of equanimity. So this is the basis of the other immeasurable thoughts, especially the development of love and compassion.
So to really awaken our love and compassion, we need to develop firstly to put effort into training our mind in equanimity so that we don’t respond so strongly with attachment and desire towards people who are friendly to us to us, so that we don’t respond so negatively towards people who have aversion to us, and so that we don’t respond with such strong indifference to people who are from their side indifferent to us, but rather we try to have this balanced open attitude, friendly attitude to all beings. So that’s the immeasurable thought of equanimity. So on the basis of developing that we can then develop the immeasurable thought of love. So it’s interesting also to consider that love and compassion are said to be, or even equanimity, said to be thoughts. They’re not emotions.
Love isn’t an emotion. Buddhist love, love as understood and compassion as understood in Buddhism, they are not feelings. They are not emotions. They are thoughts. They are they are ways of thinking about others.
So one thinks about others with equanimity, with love and compassion. As I mentioned last week, there are two aspects of love. First aspect is developing what is called, what could be translated as, affectionate love. Where one, as my teacher, Lama Zopa Rinpoche, says, one sees others in beauty. One sees the beauty, the goodness of others.
And this affectionate love, having this sort of friendly attitude, a sense of kindness towards others arises from recognizing how others have been kind to us. So the more we recognize that kindness coming from others, we develop this this affectionate love, seeing others in beauty, having a friendly, kind, warm attitude to others. And of course, the more we develop that affectionate love, this tends to lead in to the higher form of love, which is defined as wishing others or wishing self and others to experience happiness. And as I was saying last week, here we should understand happiness as not just not really referring to worldly happiness as such, but it can include that. Love as it’s understood in the Buddhist context, what we’re trying to develop and what we have the potential for is this mental factor that wants ourselves and others to have genuine, lasting happiness.
Not just worldly pleasure, the illusion of happiness, but this deep spiritual or mental peace, contentment, well-being that comes really ultimately from a lack of suffering and the causes of suffering. So that’s what is meant by love. And as I was trying to say last week, How this is cultivated is really the main essence of it is recognizing more and more deeply how oneself and others don’t have happiness. You know? Love is wanting others to be happy.
So you only want someone to be happy if you recognize they aren’t happy. There’s no point wanting someone to be happy if you believe them to be happy. Of course, you would want them to continue to be happy, but there’s no point wanting someone to be happy if they’re already happy. Or there’s no point wanting someone to, I don’t know, what, live in Adelaide if they already live in Adelaide. If you have someone you like who lives far away, you could think, oh, wouldn’t it be wonderful if they lived here?
But you wouldn’t go around thinking that if your friends already live here. Wouldn’t it be wonderful if my friends who live in Adelaide lived in Adelaide? Wouldn’t that be good? That’s completely ridiculous. So love, as it’s understood in Buddhism, the mental factor that we’re trying to cultivate is that thought that arises when one realizes more and more deeply that oneself doesn’t have genuine happiness, one’s family and friends don’t have it, all all the people who are human beings who are strangers to us, they don’t have it, All our enemies don’t have it.
That ordinary sentient all sentient beings, which is remember a being a living being with a consciousness controlled by delusion and karma, which is what a sentient being is. All sentient beings by definition lack genuine happiness. And this is what we don’t really get. As good little Buddhists who have studied the teachings, we can intellectually understand that myself and others don’t have happiness, perfect happiness, genuine happiness, but we haven’t got any kind of real realization of that. I should know this off by heart, but in the Lama Chöpa ceremony puja that is done here at the center twice a month.
I highly recommend people come along to this by the way. Very important practice. In there, there is a lam rim, a prayer at the end of this Puja composed by the first Pänchen Lama who was believed to be an incarnation or a sorry, a manifestation of Amitābha Buddha, one of the truly great, great tantric Mahasiddhas of the Gelugpa tradition. Tradition. So in that text, he says something like, please bless me to realize that oh, what is it?
How does it go? Something like that saṃsāra is not a beautiful park. Because we look at the world and think, oh, isn’t it nice? Isn’t it lovely? It’s full of, you know, beautiful like today, we’re just saying, beautiful day, wonderful.
And we latch onto that and think that that that is is what it’s all about. But it’s not. That hides the the true nature of cyclic existence. Sorry to be depressing again, but that’s my job. First noble truth, ordinary existence is in its nature suffering, and we just don’t get that.
And we we we so we think we you know, that I am happy, everyone else so if we think we’re happy, we will tend to think other people who are, in one’s own situation, are really happy too. But what we have to understand is we’re not. We don’t have real happiness. We may have some success, we may have some friends, this and that, but we don’t have real happiness. We’re completely bereft of it, and same for everyone else.
When we really get that, we will we will develop this deep wish, not just a superficial wish, but this very deep wish to have happiness. Therefore, this will lead us to want to create the causes for it and for others to create the causes for it. So that’s basically the the essence of cultivating love, to realizing more and more that despite all the superficial appearances in success and whatever, people lack real happiness. And therefore, when one sees that based on having affection for them, affectionate love, realizing how kind sentient beings are and basically good and lovable, etcetera, etcetera, then one will want them to have real happiness. So that’s the first stage of contemplating the immeasurable thought of love, how wonderful it would be.
We try and imagine. Just that itself, know, everyone’s got a copy of the prayer, yes, except myself. Anyway, it says how wonderful it would be if all sentient beings could have happiness and the causes of happiness. So there it’s stating that that’s the case. But with everything in the Dharma, we should check out first, would it be wonderful if all sentient beings had happiness in its cause?
Because one of the features of developing immeasurable love is, as I’ve pointed out already, it has to include all sentient beings. It can’t exclude anyone. In order to achieve enlightenment, we have to want to help every sentient being without exception. And in the teachings it points out, if one just has love for one person, that isn’t love. That is singling out a person or a group of people.
This group of people may be a very large group of people. But if it’s just a group, it isn’t pure love. It is it is a it’s it’s still a type of attachment that says this group of sentient beings, even if it’s an enormously large group of sentient beings, they deserve deserve happiness, but everyone outside that group doesn’t. So that isn’t love. That’s attachment.
Because attachment is always focusing on something saying it is special. Yeah? Especially good, particularly, distinctively good, better, superior. Whereas love is, by definition, the state of mind has as its basis equanimity, not distinguishing, saying this person deserves happiness, this one doesn’t. This person should remain unhappy.
So we have this potential within us to experience love for all sentient beings. This is what we need to work on. So we have to try and train the mind to extend it to all beings. But, of course, we start in a small way with what is easiest, wishing family and friends, then strangers, and then working on enemies, little enemies, medium sized enemies, big enemies, like that, until we can include all sentient beings. So we should really reflect, do we really agree?
Do I really feel it would be wonderful if all sentient beings had happiness? Or are they like we mentioned last week, we tend to think that there are people who deserve to suffer because of what they did. Actually, in the class on Tuesday night someone asked this question about karma and I was trying to what did they say? What am I saying? It’s always me.
I’m trying to say what the Buddha says. Are you saying that the people in Syria created the causes for their suffering? And I said, Yes. And she said, Oh, this is very simplistic. And then I said, Well, what is the explanation?
Oh, maybe it’s because there are just evil people in the world. So evil people, of course, don’t deserve to have happiness if you believe there are evil people in the world. There are people who are naturally evil. That’s the point I was trying to get to. Yes, anyone you dislike.
All that people are enemies. Well, it’s personal in the sense you don’t like those people. Not that they necessarily are threatening you personally, physically, but in a sense their behaviour you find offensive to you. We find personally offensive. I don’t like that whole group of people.
I’ve never met them or anything but these kind of people are terrible. So they don’t deserve happiness. So of course, at our level now, is very difficult to if we’re honest, because we should look at our actual thoughts and feelings towards others, And it’s very difficult to want pedophiles and people who blow up people and chop the heads off innocent reporters to be happy. As I often say, because this is something His Holiness once said, I think probably has said it many times, but when His Holiness said it in the teaching, I was present to it. I found it very, very interesting and helpful and moving is that, because His Holiness made this point that, being very humble as usual, he said, haven’t generated bodhicitta, I don’t have bodhicitta, but I can say I have immense admiration for it.
So I found that very interesting. Of course, His Holiness does have bodhicitta, but, you know, His Holiness always does this. They all everyone is very humble. But and and it really struck me how important it is in trying to practice the Dharma because the Dharma standards of the Buddha are immensely high. Know, we’re way down at the bottom and, you know, many people don’t even like themselves like, let alone all sentient beings and and so, but let alone able to do it, you know, so but what what is really essential to be able to move in that direction is to admire these things.
That maybe I can’t think like that now. I do hate people. But one can check, is it good to hate people? Is it good for me to hate people who are hateful? I do it, but is it good for me?
Is this something I should encourage within myself? Whereas the teachings say, Buddha says, Śāntideva, the great bodhisattvas say, how wonderful it would be if all these terrible people could be happy. Is there is there a valid reason and benefit for thinking that way? That’s what we should. And so and then we can develop some admiration for that way of thinking.
Because if we don’t have any admiration for it, seeing, oh, that that actually is a valid there is a valid reason for thinking like that, And this would be very beneficial if we could think like that, if I could think like that, if others could think like that. Then even if we can’t think like that yet, but if we admire that way thinking and behaving, then, you know, we can there’s something to move our mind in that direction. But if we don’t agree with the philosophy at all, you know, we’re not going to move anywhere. Like if this lady doesn’t move beyond thinking Buddhist teachings on karma are simplistic, then one’s not going to get very far. But if one understands that the teachings on karma are very profound, one can develop some admiration for them and want to understand them more and put them into practice.
And that applies to every aspect of the Dharma. First, we have to have some admiration for it. And, of course, that comes from having admiration for the source of the teachings, the Buddha as well. The more we have refuge in the Buddha, the more we will think, well, these teachings are really way out there, but there is a reason to try and practice this way. So of course in developing the four immeasurable thoughts are presented in this positive way encouraging one to cultivate these positive ways of thinking.
But of course to be able to really so it’s very beneficial just as I said last week to recite this prayer regularly and contemplate it as much as possible. But also to be able to develop real equanimity, deep love, compassion, and sympathetic joy, the four immeasurable thoughts, one also has to work on recognising opposing thoughts in one’s mind. There’s a little tendency to go in that direction but I have many negative tendencies, ways of thinking that inhibit the development of equanimity, love, compassion. So one really has to work on those. And of course, in general, the great obstacle to developing love towards ourself and towards others is our own self-cherishing, which tells us to take the easy way out, the quick way out, to distract ourselves, to find happiness in something out there because that’s quick and easy and entertaining, but it’s not true happiness.
It’s not lasting. And the more we do that for ourselves, you know, we’re we’re really just following our self-cherishing. We’re we’re opposing the the real development of love for ourself. The more we unconsciously cultivate our self-cherishing, which focuses on me, me, me all the time, then it’s very difficult to generate even awareness of others. And the the less awareness we have of others, the less aware we are that they really aren’t happy.
Because if our mind is basically distracted by our own self-cherishing, what we pick up on others is very superficial, and we may pick up on the appearance that they are happy. Or I asked this person how they’re going and they said, oh, I’m fine. Oh, they must be fine. Don’t have to worry about them. They’re perfectly okay.
And this person’s smiling and this person looks very well dressed. This person’s got a nice house. This person’s got a nice car. They’re fine. They’re happy.
But, anyway, one’s just too busy with oneself to really think about others and want them to be happy. So we really have to work on our self-cherishing. Particularly, we also have to work on the very destructive thought of anger, really is a great obstacle to developing love and compassion. But also one of the great obstacles, is a much more subtle one, is pride. Having pride in ourself for whatever reason, for different aspects of who we are.
Because pride makes this barrier between ourselves and others. You know, pride tells us that somehow we are somehow inherently better than others. So if one has that pride strongly in the mind, then one’s wish for others to be happy isn’t very sincere, isn’t very genuine. It’s some kind of condescending kind of wish, not genuine one. So, anyway, love is wishing others to have happiness seeing that they lack it.
And so one can begin to cultivate that by thinking how wonderful it would be. Yeah. Would it be wonderful if all my family and friends, all the good people in the world had happiness? Of course, the answer for that is obviously yes. It would be wonderful, wouldn’t it?
If all the nice people because not sometimes not all the nice people are happy. Sometimes the not nice people have more suffering than others. But how wonderful it would be if all the good people had happiness. And it’s fairly easy to see, to generate the thought, how wonderful it would be if, you know, all strangers had happiness, all the neutral people. Yeah.
Not too difficult, at least as a thought. But then the tricky part is the not so nice people. The people who have personally upset ourselves in some way or the people that we like, you know, politicians, criminals, drug dealers, arms dealers, all these kinds of people, unpleasant people in the world who cause some you know, maybe not directly cause suffering to us, but we see cause or harm others in so many different ways. So it is very difficult to really want them to be happy. But I suppose what we have to reflect on is seeing that people only cause harm because they’re controlled by negative emotions, disturbing thoughts.
So that means that they are suffering. Whether they admit it or not, they are suffering. They are certainly suffering in the sense that they are creating the causes of future suffering for themselves. But the mere fact that they engaging in negative actions means that their mind is controlled by very strong disturbing thoughts. So that is suffering.
So one can generate that thought that if these people were were not controlled by their disturbing thoughts, but in fact, their minds were taken over, they got possessed by all their positive thoughts, then they would stop harming others and they would actually benefit others. So wouldn’t it be wonderful if they could have happy thoughts and be happy? If Hitler had been grown up a happy person, not a bitter person, Imagine what the world you know, the world would be a completely different place. And also the very unhappy people who joined him. And then there’s all these like, right now, all of these terrorists in the world who want to their solution to life is to kill all their opponents.
Everyone who doesn’t think like them, exactly like them, has to be eliminated. So that’s a pretty horrible state. Those people can’t be too happy in that state of mind. But imagine if those people, those very people, couldn’t bear to harm another person, that their minds of love and compassion were operating. Even if their mind of equanimity was operating, whether they didn’t mind what other people thought, what other religions they followed.
How wonderful that would be. There’d be so much less suffering in the world. So in some ways, if all the terrible people in the world became super happy first, that would be better than all the nice people becoming super happy first. So I think if we think about it, at least think about it in an you know, it would be wonderful if all sentient beings could have happiness and particularly have causes of happiness. You know?
This is especially what we should think of as Buddhists, not just have this vague idea how wonderful it would be if all sentient beings suddenly became happy, but how wonderful it would be if all sentient beings created the causes of happiness, knew what the causes of happiness were, because most people don’t, how wonderful that would be. And and they actually use their lives more and more creating the causes of happiness. Because I know this is probably not a very nice, you know, good thing to think about. Well, to remind you, but but, unfortunately, many of the people we know that we really like, who are our family and friends and so on, people who’ve been kind to us, if we if one is really honest from a Buddhist point of view, these people are not creating the causes of happiness. They’re not really taking care of their mind, not purifying the mind, not creating lots of merit.
Just using up their good karma. So that’s really sad. But how wonderful it would be if they did. It’d also be how wonderful if I, myself, created more causes of happiness, real causes of happiness, meaning not I’ll go out and try and get more money, not creating those causes, but really worked on my mind more. Really, I had the energy and wisdom to use this life to create the causes of happiness, not suffering.
How wonderful that would be. Wouldn’t it? It’d be good now, and it would, you know, it would carry on more and more later in this life, future lives. So, actually, just that meditating on that first line can be very powerful to put our mind in the right direction. And instead, when we catch ourselves developing negative thoughts towards others because they said this to us, looked at us like that, you know, did something against us, We can try and replace those negative thoughts with thinking how wonderful it would be if this person, you know, stopped creating the causes of suffering and created the causes of happiness.
How wonderful that would be. It’d be wonderful that for that person, it would be wonderful for me as well because they wouldn’t harm me anymore. They wouldn’t be a problem anymore. And that’s the long term solution because our short term self-cherishing solution is when someone harms us, we want to harm them back to stop them. But in fact, that’s just creating the cause for more and more harm.
So how wonderful it would be if every sentient being could have happiness in its causes. And this leads to the next of the immeasurable. No. Next of the the part of that prayer, which is to say you know, to reflect on may they have this happiness. May they have it.
Not just thinking how nice it would be in an, like, an abstract way that it might happen, but it may it happen, meaning it’s got to happen, it will happen. Why? Because every sentient being has the potential to experience perfect happiness. There is not one sentient being who doesn’t have the potential to experience perfect happiness. I myself have it.
My family, friends, everyone has the potential. So may that potential manifest. And then the third line is the most important from the Mahāyāna point of view, is to really try and cultivate that very genuine, powerful thought that goes beyond just thinking how nice it would be if oneself could have real happiness, how nice it would be if others could be happy, but to make the determination I am going to do something about it. I’m I’m going to commit myself. Right.
That’s the that’s the that’s the the key Mahāyāna point of the four immeasurable thoughts. Because this is what distinguishes ordinary love and compassion from great love and great compassion. And what great love and great compassion refer to is the commitment that oneself will help others. Because if we reflect more and more on the realizing more and more how oneself lacks genuine happiness, how others lack it and are and and will continue to because they’re not creating the causes for it, then the more we feel that, because even though love and compassion, etcetera, are thoughts, every thought has a feeling. Yeah?
And if that feeling gets stronger and stronger, the thought gets stronger and stronger, then, you know, we we won’t we won’t be content with just imagining and thinking how nice it would be, how lovely, lovely if everyone could be happy. Then we we decide I’ve got to do something about it myself. Because I can’t make other people help everyone to be happy. The only person I have any sense of control over is myself. I don’t have much control over myself yet but I’m going to in order to benefit others.
So what what does the third line say? I myself will, yeah, yeah, cause happiness. Yes. So that’s the key point to try and to be able to really generate that mind more and more. And in analytical meditation, this is a type of a simple form of analytical meditation, Our teachers say that when one meditates on the lamrim topics by doing analysis of the different points, At some stage, ideally what will happen is that by having reflected on a particular point, over and over again, at some point the realization comes or the insight comes or starts to arise in the mind.
And what one is supposed to do at that point is you stop doing the analysis and the logical thinking and you just try to single pointedly hold on to that little insight, that moment where the mind really gets the point. Because by focusing on it single pointedly, that drives that impression deeper into the mind, into a much more subtle level of the mind where it stays and really transforms the mind. So it may take a long time, many meditations before that ever happens. But until that happens, what one tries to do is you imagine you’ve you’ve in the meditation, you imagine you’ve gained the realization, that insight, and you so you hold on to it. So you imagine that you’ve reached the point where you’re completely determined to dedicate your life and all future lives to helping all sentient beings to achieve happiness and its causes.
Yeah. So you try and hold that thought as strongly and sincerely as possible because even though it’s not the actual commitment yet, it’s making some impression in the mind, some little dent in the mind, which we need to build on again and again until the realization comes. Yeah. Does that make sense? Yeah.
So then the fourth line says so then one makes this heartfelt request to the Guru Buddha to bless one’s mind to be able to help all sentient beings create the causes of happiness. Because, of course, as we are now, we can’t do it. We we have to change in order to benefit others, we have to change our mind. We have to be willing to change our mind, meaning we have to be willing to overcome the negative aspects of our mind, which are harmful to ourselves but also prevent us benefiting others. We have to be willing to put that real effort into cultivating our positive qualities.
At first, even just for ourselves, we have to develop that determination, that decision to do it for ourselves, to develop love for ourselves. But we can have that wish to do so in order to then really be a more loving person towards others. But for that, we need the blessings of the Buddhas and the Gurus. So we make that request. So one can imagine the Buddha on the crown of one’s head or and the Buddha is inseparable from if one has a guru or or gurus, then you think of the Buddha as inseparable from one’s gurus, and you imagine the light coming into you, blessing your mind to be able to actually gain that realization.
And, again, this is something that one has to you know, one visualizes this, and at the same time, one has to try and develop this belief that it’s act happening, that the mind is being blessed, that something is really happening to one’s mind, that the that the that the the qualities of the guru Buddha are entering into one’s own mind, changing it, transforming it, inspiring it, lifting it up. Yeah. And, again, this is something that hopefully will happen at some point that the blessings of the well, they they do happen to people, so they’ll happen to us. But it’s it’s something that happens like everything else, everything is a dependent arising. Things arise depending on doing on many, many factors.
So to receive the blessings of the Gurus and Buddhas, partly it arises by depending on preparing the mind receive these blessings by imagining it happening. And by imagining this happening over and over and over again, this is creating the cause for for it to happen in reality. One imagines it happens over and over again. And by doing that, it’s laying the foundation for that to happen at some point. In the Zen tradition, they talk a lot about instant enlightenment, that enlightenment happens in an instant, which I think is true.
But what they don’t emphasise so much is that instant of enlightenment arises depending on working very hard for a very long time. But that’s what our tradition emphasises. Not so much instant enlightenment but working for a very long time. By doing that, at some point, in an instant, the realization comes. The little enlightenments that bring about eventually the great enlightenment.
So, like in class, you know, I I I I the beginning of teachings, I was you suggest how you imagine the Buddha coming to the crown of your head and the blessings coming. Yeah. So by doing that, it’s it’s preparing the mind. So one night when you do this, it will happen. You you won’t be just imagining it in a very vague, wishy washy way.
You’ll be sitting there and bingo, the Buddha’s mind will blast your mind away, your ordinary mind. Yes. No, I’m the dodo remember? Nothing, no. No, no, no.
Anyway, you never ask anyone that question. Especially not me, because I haven’t had any of these. But really, someone was to say, yeah or no anyway, that sounds like I’m implying no. But I haven’t. Unfortunately.
One of the most important topics of my Tibetan Buddhism is guru devotion, seeing the guru as Buddha. And my teacher, Lama Zopa Rinpoche, once made the point, very profound, that the whole base you know, guru devotion doesn’t make any sense whatsoever unless one understands one very, very fundamental thing, which is that the Buddhas are everywhere acting for our benefit all the time. All the time. Doesn’t feel like it, but the Buddhas are present all the time, acting for our benefit a hundred percent all the time. But the trouble is our minds I don’t know about yours, but my mind is very, very obscured, and so we don’t get it.
Although the Buddha is acting for the benefit of sentient beings all the time, sentient beings are extremely obscured. Of course, beings in the lower realms, their minds are unbelievably obscured. So there’s very little that the enlightened mind can do for such obscured minds. And in the god realms, the their minds are not so obscured as in the lower realms, but the the the beings in the god realms’ minds are totally distracted by this illusory pleasure. It’s only really when one is reborn as a human being that this omnipresent, ever present enlightened activity of the Buddha can really touch us in a profound way.
But then even among human beings, most people most people aren’t interested and so on. So it’s only when when one becomes not only a human being, but a human being with the eight freedoms and ten endowments of a precious human rebirth, that the mind is open to hearing the dharma. Because the most profound way that an enlightened being benefits sentient beings an an enlightened being benefits sentient beings with their body, with their speech, and their mind. These are the three mystical powers of an enlightened being, their perfect speech, body, and mind. But the most direct way an enlightened being benefits is through their pure speech teaching the Dharma.
So it’s only someone who has a precious human rebirth who hears that, is open to it. Or maybe I should say listens because people hear the Dharma, but they don’t listen. What’s what’s the right word? Yeah. No.
No. That’s I think that yeah. Yeah. People people hear and go away, but there are people who hear and They listen but don’t hear. Yeah.
They listen but don’t hear. So yeah. So it’s only when one has a precious human rebirth that you actually hear the Dharma. It touches you. So for that to happen, I’m making a very long point here or a long way to get to a point, which is that the Buddha’s always present trying to bet I shouldn’t say trying, is acting for our benefit.
But we you know, our obscurations put up this huge block. But so it’s when so even as someone with a precious human rebirth, it’s that’s when we can start to be in really influenced by the Buddha. But even with a precious human rebirth, we still have an obscured mind that blocks things. So when one does those practices of even just mentally thinking, oh, Buddha, please bless me, that is opening up the mind just that much more. And by visualizing the Buddha blessing, that opens the mind that much more.
It becomes a way for the ever present blessings of the Buddha to actually become, at least in some small way, a reality. And if we train that way more and more, then something really amazing can happen at some point. So that’s why the concluding line of each verse is, please, guru, Buddha, or bless me to be able to do this. And by reciting, doing these practices over and over again, which can sound very boring and one can feel very what’s the word? Oh, the bell went, didn’t it?
What’s the word? I think many of us sometimes if not much of the time feel what we’re saying and doing is hypocritical because we don’t really believe it. And of course we don’t. We don’t want all sentient beings to be happy. We would like some of them to be miserable.
But so we’re not one hundred percent sincere yet. But by saying it again and again, and thinking about it, and wearing away, purifying our mind that that creates all the obstacles, that thought becomes more genuine, more sincere. Right? The whole thing becomes much more genuine and powerful. Tea break.
Thank you very much. So as I was saying last week, the prayer of the four immeasurable thoughts is just a very condensed way of relating to the these four practices of developing equanimity, love, compassion, and sympathetic joy, each of which is really a major project. Could be lifetimes of work developing any of those four immeasurable thoughts, but this prayer is just a summary of them putting a positive imprint in the mind. But one can reflect on those verses to make them stronger. Anyway, as I mentioned, there is affectionate love, seeing others in beauty, seeing the kindness of others, and then there is love in the deeper sense, which is that genuine wish for others to have happiness its well, for self and others really to have happiness and its causes.
Great love is where one develops that genuine determination that oneself will commit to helping all sentient beings create the causes for genuine happiness. So that involves committing oneself to purifying one’s mind, accumulating merit, getting because we we need to purify our mind of the obstacles, accumulate merit, which is the basis to be able to gain the realization, cultivating all the positive aspects that bring about love, and developing all the antidotes to everything that is obstructing the development of love within us. So, yes, that’s a little bit about the immeasurable thought of love traditionally. But I would like to ask people, as fellow Buddhists, when the subject of love comes up, you know, developing may the thought of developing love towards all sentient beings, what do you understand by that? What is love?
What what are the aspects, the components of love? I’ve just said all that, but personally, what do you think of that love apart from just that thought, what does it really in in cultivating it, developing it, what does it really mean? What does it involve? Accepting people. Yeah.
Accepting people. Trusting people. Yeah. That’s actually sympathetic joy more. But anyway, yeah, technically.
Yeah. Doing kind things people, sure. Yeah. What? That’s just a word.
What do you mean? Which is all about acceptance, isn’t it? Accepting. One’s self being sincere. No.
No. I don’t know. I’m just Yeah. At the moment, is, isn’t it? But I’m saying, what what do you think?
What what is involved in cultivating this pure love? Genuine love for others that you that we don’t that we don’t love at the moment. Sorry? Of yeah. Sure.
But what? How do you love people? Mhmm. Sure. Do they like your muffins?
What if they didn’t like your muffins? Yeah. This is another aspect of loving sentient beings. You don’t necessarily get any kindness back. Sentient beings are very difficult.
So you can’t expect anything in return. No, I’m not saying you personally. I’m not criticizing. And then they criticize you. Oh, sorry.
Oh, sorry. Okay. Anyway, I was a Buddhist for many years before I realized that love was developed wanting the you know, it comes from realizing people don’t have happiness. There’s so so much mush about this word love. You know, I love you and talking about loving everyone, but what does it really involve?
What does it really involve to love another person? Very interesting to really think about. I think a lot of that love is actually comes under the category from a Buddhist point of view of affectionate love rather than the love which is wanting others happiness to have this happiness that comes from seeing they don’t have it. That sounds very simple, but I think it’s really quite profound it was very profound, actually, when you realize that the people you care for, everyone isn’t really happy. Like, as I’ve mentioned a few times here already, but I’ll do it again.
Sorry. My teacher, Lama Zopa Rinpoche, when I first met Rinpoche, I don’t think he was very famous at all. Maybe only among a very, very small group of Tibetans. But now after thirty, forty years of teaching around the world, he’s become quite famous and he knows many famous people and very rich people, blah blah blah. He has disciples who are famous and rich and Hong Kong pop singer and all this kind of stuff.
And Rinpoche, in one teaching, once made the point that because of this, he gets invited to very rich people’s homes, and they show him around their beautiful, huge, gigantic houses with all their incredibly expensive, beautiful objects and heated marble floors and heated swimming pools and how wonderful everything is. And Rinpoche says but says, but at some point, after all of that, that’s what happens first. But at some point, then this person talks about their problems. So let me yeah. Yeah.
Everyone has problems. When you take the first copy, they’re all very strong. Oh, yes. Yes. Yes.
Of course. We all do because we’re all sentient beings. We all have delusions which which create lots of stories. Unfortunately, many, many stories. But I think it’s so easy for us to, especially if one doesn’t have the Dharma, to think that if someone is beautiful, they must be happy.
If someone is rich, they must be happy. If they’re important, they must be happy. But, of course, they’re not. Yeah. And even people who think they’re happy aren’t happy from a Buddhist perspective.
Yeah. So then one can develop this thought how wonderful if they could have happiness, and especially if they how wonderful if they created the causes for it. Because people have such strange ideas of what happiness is and perhaps even stranger ideas of what is going to cause happiness. Alright, rapidly moving along. The next of the immeasurable thoughts is the immeasurable thought of compassion, thinking how wonderful it would be if all sentient beings could be free of suffering and the causes of suffering.
Again, just as love is is is arises for for others recognizing they don’t have happiness, compassion arises. It it it is this state of mind that arises when one realizes self or others are suffering. So, actually, maybe what I’d like to I’d like to read rather than me blab along. I’d like to read something from His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, because in one way it seems I mean there’s all sorts of practical reasons for developing compassion. It seems a vital thing to survive in the world, society to operate, for human beings to be able to survive, that people are compassionate with each other.
But beyond that, the Buddha is telling us that if we want to experience real happiness, the only way to achieve that is not by relying on things in the external world, but in cultivating our mind. Cultivating the positive qualities of our mind, are all aspects of our Buddha nature. And the the the main qualities to cultivate are our wisdom, our potential for love, and our potential for compassion. So the teachings are saying that the way to experience real happiness, perfect happiness, is to develop our potential for compassion, which is the potential to feel or experience, share the suffering of others. So this sounds really counterintuitive that the way to be happy is to feel the suffering of others more and more.
This sounds really bizarre, I think, but that’s what the Buddha is saying. Alright? So just one thing I’d like to quote first is Buddhist teachings describe the cessation of suffering as the higher state of happiness. And this happiness should not be understood in terms of pleasurable sensations. We are not talking about happiness at the level of feeling or sensation.
Rather, we are referring to the highest level of happiness which is constituted by total freedom from suffering and delusion. Again, this is a state of mind, a level of realization. So when we’re talking about following the path to peerless everlasting happiness, this happiness isn’t some kind of extreme form of pleasure and entertainment which we associate with happiness. This happiness is referring to a state of mind where there is an utter absence of all suffering and all its causes. So that’s one thing to bear in mind.
But then His Holiness says later on in his little commentary, His Holiness says this, which is relevant to thinking about developing compassion. Another thing that is quite clear to me, so this is His Holiness speaking, is clear to him, is that the moment you think only of yourself, the focus of your whole mind narrows. And because of this narrow focus, uncomfortable things can appear huge and bring you fear and discomfort and a sense of feeling overwhelmed by misery. So that’s what our self-cherishing does. You know?
It focuses on me. The mind becomes very narrow, and our our suffering gets completely blown up. And, particularly, we feel overwhelmed. We can’t deal with it, which makes it worse and very kind of panicky. The moment you think of others with a sense of caring, however, your mind widens.
Within that wider angle, your own problems appear to be of no significance, and this makes a big difference. If you have a sense of caring for others, you will manifest a kind of inner strength in spite of your own difficult situations and problems. Yeah. So this is one of the things that’s what has struck me listening to his holiness over the years, that what his holiness talks a lot about in in developing compassion is he associates it a lot with courage and strength and hope. These are essential ingredients of what real compassion is.
And this is what he’s saying here, is that when when when we when we deal with our own suffering with this through the self-cherishing thought, it there there isn’t any courage. We kind of panic and feel overwhelmed and we can’t deal with it. But somehow, when we focus on the suffering of others, when we care for those people, especially if we have affectionate love for these people and care for them, then somehow it gives us strength. There is some what goes with that immediately is a sense of strength to deal with the situation to some extent, a sense of capability, not incapability. With this strength, your problems will seem less significant and bothersome.
By going beyond your own problems and taking care of others, you gain inner strength, self confidence, courage, and and very interestingly, a greater sense of calm. This is a clear example of how one’s way of thinking can really make a difference. So, of course, his holiness isn’t saying that one in caring for others and developing compassion for others, you just simply ignore one’s own problems. That is not skillful at all. Yeah?
That’s quite dangerous that you just you know, I’m not gonna take care of myself. I’m not gonna worry about myself. I’m just going to care about others. This is not the way to go about things. That’s why developing love and compassion, one has to, in a sense, first develop it for oneself Or at least at the same time as one’s developed care caring for others, one has to care for oneself.
And in order to care for others properly, one really has to take care of oneself. Because if you don’t take care of yourself, you can’t can’t take care of others. As it it you know, I don’t do it so much now, but years ago, I used to travel a lot and fly a lot. I became the flying monk. Never thought this would ever happen to me.
When I first got ordained, I got ordained at Chenrezig Institute and Lama Yeshe. This is when I became a novice monk, Lama Yeshe came especially from to Australia to take part in this very first Tibetan Buddhist ordination in Australia. He’s very I’m a very historical person. I don’t know if you know this. Yeah, that’s pretty historical.
Oh, now I’m getting carried away here. And and at the end of the ordination, he said there were seven of us. And he said, now as a monk, you are going to stay at Chenrezig Institute until you die. And I thought that’s that’s what would happen because I didn’t have any money. You know?
Buddhism hardly existed in Australia. Nothing. I just thought I would live there forever. But I but very soon I got sent here, there, and everywhere and ended up living overseas and traveling here. From my point this is ridiculous.
God, I’m hopeless. So in planes, you know, they have that demonstration where they you know, in case of, you know, the the bag will drop down, put it on your face first and then, you know, on the kids and I thought, that doesn’t seem very compassionate. You should put it on the kids first and then, you know, on yourself. But of course, while you’re putting it on the kid, you suffocate the lack of oxygen, you’re going to die and the kid will too. So first, you have to put it on yourself so that you can look after the people less capable.
It took me years to work that out. I’m very slow. I’m a dodo as you say. I didn’t say it. No, no, no.
Mean I appreciate it. You did. So in developing love and compassion and everything for others, one has to develop it for oneself, but not in a neurotic self obsessed way. Okay, then His Holiness goes on to say, The Bodhicaryāvatāra which is this wonderful text written by the great Bodhisattva Śāntideva says that there is a phenomenological difference between the pain that you experience when you take someone else’s pain upon yourself and the pain that comes directly from own pain and suffering. This is this is the key point.
This one. Yeah? There’s a big difference between the pain you feel when you take on the pain of others than the pain you feel when you take on or are aware of your own pain. In the former case, that is when you feel the pain of others, in that case there is an element of discomfort because you are sharing the other’s pain. However, as Śāntideva points out, there is also a certain amount of stability or equanimity because, in a sense, you are voluntarily accepting that pain.
In the voluntary participation in others suffering, there is strength and a sense of confidence. I can do this. I’m going to do it. But in the latter case, when we just have to deal with our own suffering, when you are undergoing your own pain and suffering, there is an element of involuntariness, and because of the lack of control on your part, you feel weak and completely overwhelmed. So somehow feeling the pain of others is different than feeling one’s own pain.
Voluntarily allowing oneself to feel the pain of others is somehow a different experience than uncontrollably having to experience one’s own pain. And the first one, when one voluntarily allows oneself to feel the pain of others, that’s something that enriches us, it develops us, whereas the other tends to diminish us. Well, don’t take it too concretely. The general point, this is voluntarily, and of course you do it step by step. You don’t, you know, remember, lamrim.
Everything is a lamrim, graduated path. You start off trying to feel a little bit of one person suffering, sharing that. Yeah. So you’re not overwhelmed. Yeah.
That’s you know? And then step by step, one can cope with more and more. Just found another terrific line which emphasizes what I’ve been trying to say. The fundamental point is that if you do not have the capacity to love yourself, then there is simply no basis on which to build a sense of caring towards others. Yeah.
That’s what I’ve been saying a million times already. As soon as I say it’s from His Holiness, oh, that’s profound. When I say it, oh, that was a bit dumb. The fundamental point is that if you do not have the capacity to love yourself, then there is simply no basis on which to build a sense of caring toward others. His Holiness goes on to say, Love for yourself does not mean that you are indebted to yourself.
Rather, the capacity to love oneself or to be kind to oneself should be based on a very fundamental fact of human existence, which is that we all have a natural tendency to desire happiness and avoid suffering. Once this basis exists in relation to oneself, one can extend it to other sentient beings. Alright. Finish. Finish for tonight.
So we can dedicate whatever, If you think you’ve generated some positive energy, some positive imprints, we can dedicate this that it becomes a cause for us to be able to really generate the four immeasurable thoughts and on that basis generate bodhicitta, become enlightened for the sake of all beings. Dedication starts on page eight. Through the merits of these virtuous actions, may I quickly attain the state of a Guru Buddha and lead all living beings without exception into that enlightened state. May the precious bodhicitta mind, not yet born, arise and grow. May that born have no decline but increase forevermore.
The object of refuge of myself and of all transmigratory beings in all our lifetimes is the embodiment of the Three Jewels, the all encompassing three refuges in one, the guru, the wish granting jewel, his holiness, the Dalai Lama, the Master Padmasambhava, the Dharma King Songtsen Gampo and Trisong Detsen, the Abbot Shāntarakshita and the numberless holy beings who preserved and spread the Buddhadharma in Tibet, and the Tibetan people who practiced and served Buddhism so faithfully for a thousand years, as well as those who along with many others died sacrificing their lives for Tibet and His Holiness. May all their positive wishes be fulfilled immediately. Due to their limitless kindness, the sun of Tibetan Buddhism has now risen in the West, which was a dark land. But now that I have met with the Dharma, I have received the perfect human body, enabling me to lead a meaningful life. Our refuge and savior, the supreme one, his holiness, the Dalai Lama, and the Tibetan people have been so kind to us.
Remembering this, we make the following dedicating prayers. May all His Holiness, the Dalai Lama’s wishes be successful immediately. May the snow land of Tibet achieve pure freedom and develop the Buddhadharma even more than before in Tibet. And may all mother transmigratory beings achieve enlightenment quickly. Gangri Raö Kor Zhing Khamzhi Päl Du Teng Gyur Chü.
Savior of the snow land teachings and transmigratory beings who makes extremely clear the path that is unification of emptiness and compassion. To the lotus holder, Tenzin Gyatso, I beseech, may all your holy wishes be spontaneously fulfilled. You who uphold the scriptural and realized, who serve as the bountiful bearer of all, sustaining, preserving, spreading Mañjuśrī’s victorious doctrine, who masterfully accomplished magnificent prayers honoring the Three Jewels, savior of myself and others, your disciples, please, please live long. Lord of Dharma, who in accordance with the various dispositions of those to be subdued, makes clear in the light of your well spoken advice the sacred Ganden tradition, essence of Buddha’s teachings, O foremost and holy Lama to you who are supreme. O Lama, please please live long.
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- guru devotion
- After finding a fully qualified spiritual teacher and establishing a connection, the disciple trains in devotion using logical reasoning. LYWA
- kor
- A multi-layered term that can mean wealth or material offerings given to the Sangha and the Three Jewels, and can also have a negative connotation of misusing offerings. Read more about the term dkor here. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- mandala khyil khor (Tib)
- A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
- wish-granting jewel cintamani (Skt); yizhin norbu (Tib)
- Also called "wish-fulfilling jewel". A jewel that brings its possessor everything that they desire. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.