DB Bodhicitta — 2014-05-20

1 h 50 min · 10,963 words · 20 May 2014 · Buddha House Adelaide

DB Bodhicitta (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
DB Bodhicitta (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
DB Bodhicitta — 2014-05-20
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 110-minute session, Ven Thubten Dondrub concludes an eight-week course on generating bodhicitta—the altruistic wish to free all beings from suffering and bring them to enlightenment—by introducing the six perfections that embody this commitment in action. He begins by anchoring bodhicitta in the law of karma and motivation, then walks through the traditional eleven-stage method before pivoting to the practical heart of the teaching: generosity, moral discipline, patience, perseverance, concentration, and wisdom. For each perfection, Dondrub offers concrete guidance grounded in Śāntideva’s writings and the insights of Tibetan masters like Lama Atisha. On generosity, he clarifies that it is fundamentally a state of mind—non-attachment—not mere material giving; on morality, he reframes it as the thought to avoid harm to all beings and cultivate a peaceful mind; on patience, he stresses it as genuine compassion for oneself and others, not suppression of anger. He weaves in practical examples (the kindness of workers we never see, the farmer to baker pipeline) and emphasizes that these perfections build on each other psychologically, each enabling the next. The talk is pitched at serious practitioners familiar with Tibetan Buddhist foundations, with an invitation to attend an upcoming retreat and engage with Śāntideva’s Guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2014 05 20 DB Bodhicitta Week 8 20052014.mp3

UUID: 053d114f-a093-4165-a93e-4a1fe2e89a17

Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub

Collection: DB Bodhicitta (Ven Thubten Dondrub)

Date: 2014-05-20

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 110.3 minutes

Words: ~10,962

Could we close the the door, Peter? Is that okay? Not too stuffy, I hope. Okay, so welcome everyone to our eighth class eighth class on how to generate bodhicitta. So Śākyamūni Buddha’s teachings emphasize the law of karma, cause and effect, And so because all effects, the nature of the effect, the intensity of it, the duration of it, all depends on the nature of the cause.

And this also means that the motivation that we have for whatever we do really determines to a great extent what results we get. So if we want a good result, need a good motivation. If we want the best result, we need the best motivation. And if we want a huge result, we need a really big motivation. So the best, biggest, most amazing, wonderful motivation we can have for doing anything is wishing to help free all beings from suffering and to help them achieve their own Buddha potential of peerless everlasting happiness.

And the way to basically generate that mindset is to continuously train the mind in developing a deeper and deeper awareness of how we are interconnected with every sentient being, how we totally depend on their kindness and how we do receive that kindness life after life directly and indirectly. And especially we depend on the kindness of mother which we have received from every sentient being many times. human mother’s kindness, an animal’s mother’s kindness, a preta realm mother’s kindness, God realm mother’s kindness, every kind of mother’s kindness we’ve received from sentient beings. So that’s part of what helps us generate bodhicitta and the other aspect is realizing more and more deeply how these kind beings who are no different in a sense than the kind mother of this life are suffering in saṃsāra and helplessly suffering in saṃsāra and in their confusion trying to be free of suffering most sentient beings are actually creating the cause of more suffering. So the more we really think about that and feel that then we can generate this wish to help them perfectly.

Especially when we realize more and more deeply how we actually have the potential to be Buddhas ourselves and how we’ve found the perfect situation now which is the precious human rebirth to begin to realize that potential. So when we put all those things together these are the essential ingredients we can generate bodhicitta. That’s the greatest benefit to others but it’s also the greatest, brings the greatest benefit to ourselves now and in the future. So that’s the motivation. Saying that the traditional prayer composed by the great bodhisattva Lama Rinchen Dorje can help us put us in the right state of mind and to make that more effective we visualize or try and think of Śākyamūni Buddha in front of us as the very embodiment of the Three Jewels of refuge and all our perfect teachers of the past, present, future.

And at the same time, we try and have a sense of all these kind beings surrounding us right now, particularly those we’re most connected to in this life. But if we can, trying to have that awareness and concern for all other sentient beings. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, the supreme assembly. By the merits I create through teaching the Dharma, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings? So now we can imagine the Buddha is very pleased with our motivation, and the Buddha shows this by now coming towards the crown of our head.

When directly above our crown, we imagine the Buddha turns around facing the same direction as ourselves. Then dissolves into blissful golden light so that that light can pour down into us through the crown of our head, blessing our mind. So then for a short time, we can do some breathing meditation, especially the nine round breathing exercise to allow a more calmer, clearer, more focused mind to arise so that we can use that mind to listen to and think about the Buddhist teachings tonight. To make that practice more effective, with each in breath, we imagine that we breathe in this very blissful, calm, soothing light from the white light from the Buddha’s that also helps to awaken all our positive potentials. With each out breath, we imagine breathing out whatever agitation is existing in the mind right now, but all the disturbing thoughts that are continuously arise day by day, year by year.

Imagine breathing all that out and all the negative imprints generated from following those disturbing thoughts. All in the form of black smoke. K. Thank you. So I’ve briefly covered the two main methods of generating bodhicitta which come from the bodhisattva.

This is the six causes one effect technique and then there is the method of Śāntideva, the method of equalizing and exchanging self for others. I didn’t say much about the benefits of cherishing others because basically if one sees the faults of self-cherishing one can imagine that the very opposite are all the benefits when you do the opposite which is to cherish others. But just one thing to reflect on is a simple way to look at the benefits is that just as I mentioned that if one looks at all our suffering comes from engaging in our negative actions especially the ten non virtuous actions of body, speech and mind. So as I mentioned in one of the classes, if you check all of those negative actions, the ten non virtues, what motivates them is the self-cherishing thought. So that shows how harmful the self-cherishing thought is.

So then all good karma, sorry, all good experiences come from creating good karma such as engaging in the ten virtues or avoiding that, sorry, good karma is created by avoiding the ten non virtuous actions and but also such as the consciously avoiding killing is a virtuous karma, a virtuous action which brings great benefits. But there’s a super positive action of saving beings lives, nurturing them, protecting life and nursing sick beings and so on. So that’s super virtuous. So again, if you check what is the motivation behind all the ten virtuous actions and the ten super virtuous actions is cherishing others more than self. From that way one can see in a practical way how all good things come from cherishing others more than self.

I just want to very briefly mention that there is another method of generating bodhicitta which really isn’t a different method. It’s really just a combination of the two techniques. So this is the eleven stage method of generating bodhicitta or sometimes called the combined method of generating bodhicitta. Part of your homework is to read all about that in Ribur Rinpoche’s article about how to generate bodhicitta. Rinpoche just quickly was he passed away a few just a couple of years ago but he was one of the great lamas of the Gelugpa tradition.

He was a if I’m not mistaken, he was a direct disciple of Pabongka Rinpoche who was in the Gelugpa tradition is recognized as one of the greatest Lamas who’s lived in recent times. Pabongka Rinpoche became the guru of all the great Lamas, the great Gelugpa Lamas who escaped from Tibet in nineteen fifty nine. Many of them were disciples of Pabongka Rinpoche. So Ribur Rinpoche was more or less the last of that generation and he died just a few years ago. He talks in his article about this eleven stage method, this eleven stage method.

So just briefly the way it’s organised is firstly there’s meditating, developing basic equanimity, then recognising all sentient beings as one’s mother, recalling their kindness, then developing the wish to repay that kindness, And then there is this next step, step five, which is a sort of a little bit distinguishing feature of this technique which is called developing special equanimity and there are two interpretations of that. But in Ribur Rinpoche’s commentary you can which is part of your homework, He explains it in a very simple way, which is basically meditating on the kindness of sentient beings when they’re not our mother. So sentient beings, when they are our mother, when they’re a nice mother, because not all moms are good unfortunately, but when they’re a good mom, good moms are incredibly kind, amazingly kind. But when sentient beings aren’t our mother, such as when they’re our fathers, brothers, sisters, other relatives, even not our relatives, not even our friends, but just people, still there are many ways to realize how sentient beings are incredibly kind, which I didn’t go into any details, but there’s the particular kindness of a father. Sometimes siblings, sometimes maybe quite a bit of the time siblings fight with each other, but also they are kind.

Brothers and sisters are kind in various ways. There’s the kindness of friends, we need friends. But then there’s the kindness of teachers such as like all the people who taught us at school and if we went to some other kind of higher form of education or learnt a trade, we learnt it from some teacher. So that’s incredibly kind. But everyone is kind if you think about it.

All the people who help us, who serve us when we go to a shop, who manufacture things, who drive buses, who are in the police force. You know, people, you know, love to hate the police, but actually we need the police. They do very good things. And when things go very, you know, we’re in danger, we’re very happy to have the police come along. Or if we have a car accident and and we’re we’re in a feel in the in the right and, you know, it’s very nice if the police come in and step, you know, step in with all those things.

And and, of course, some people try to argue, oh, but these people are paid to do that. That isn’t being kind. They’re paid. But if they didn’t do it, we’d be in big trouble. If someone didn’t collect their garbage, if people didn’t drive trucks, if people didn’t work in coal mines and did all these terrible jobs, even if they’re paid, it’s still very kind of them to do it.

And some people do their jobs really well. They they try to do them really well. Like someone working in a shop, yes, they’re paid to serve you, but some take their time to serve you and don’t do it very nicely, whereas others try to be really nice about it. But even the people who don’t do the job very well, it’s still fortunate they do it because if they didn’t do it, we wouldn’t get we’d be able to get the thing we wanted or needed. So it’s kind.

Yeah. Even if we never see them or, you know, there’s many things that we rely on that we don’t see the people who do it, we’ll never see them. So incredibly kind that they do it. You know, like, where where where was it? I should know this.

Where where there was that terrible coal tragedy. Turkey? No. Where was it? Turkey.

Yeah. Over two hundred men die like that. I mean, conditions in mines are still horrific things to work in. Yeah. So it’s incredibly kind that people do that for us.

We depend on that. Amazingly kind. It’s amazingly kind that people grow wheat and and harvest it and transport it, turn it into flour, cook make the flour into bread, package the bread, sell it in shops, toast it for us. All we have to do is put the bread on the the butter or the margarine or whatever, depending on one’s thing. Yeah.

Incredibly kind. And if it wasn’t for some ancient Egyptian or somebody, I don’t know where, working out how to, know, you could you could grow this stuff and crush it and make wheat. Incredibly kind whoever thought of that and kept doing it. All those the hundreds, thousands of generations of people all over the world who did that stuff for us. So then one goes on to think about the disadvantages of self-cherishing, understanding the advantages of cherishing others.

This leads to the development of the practice of wanting to give happiness to them induced by love. So it involves the next cause of developing loving kindness. This leads to the next cause which is wanting to take the suffering away from others induced by great compassion. This leads to the special attitude that I alone will benefit all sentient beings. I alone will enlighten them not just with all the other Buddhas and Bodhisattvas.

I alone will do this. And then this leads to the final step which is to actually generate the mind of bodhicitta by realizing that the only way I can do this is to become a Buddha. So therefore I have to become a Buddha. Okay, was the third method in a nutshell. So what I would like to specifically talk about tonight and it has to be unfortunately very, very brief and I hope I will be able to cover the topic, probably won’t, is what are called the six perfections.

The word in Sanskrit that is translated as perfection is pāramitā meaning something gone beyond to the fullest extent. So these are the six perfections. So these are practices that someone who has generated bodhicitta dedicates their life and the continuity of their lives to perfect in order to develop all the qualities and merit that will lead to complete enlightenment. So these six perfections, these six practices actually are practices common to all types of Buddhism not just Mahāyāna Buddhism but Theravāda Buddhism as well. But what distinguishes the six perfections in the Mahāyāna tradition is just obviously engaging in these practices with the bodhicitta motivation.

One does them in order to achieve enlightenment whereas in following the path to liberation one does these practices in order to create the causes simply for oneself to get out of saṃsāra. So there’s a big difference in the attitude of why they’re done. And again another difference is in the dedication of the merit. The Theravāda practitioner would dedicate in order to achieve liberation whereas the Mahāyānist would dedicate to achieve enlightenment. So that’s a simple way to see the difference but there are other differences as well.

Doing things with the bodhicitta motivation is a big difference from doing it just wanting to benefit oneself. So the six perfections I think most people are familiar with them but in case you’re not just to first briefly mention then we’ll go a little detail because there’s not much time. So the six perfections are firstly, the practice of generosity, the practice of morality, then the practice of patience, the practice of perseverance, then the practice of concentration, and then finally the practice of wisdom. So these six perfections are set out in that order because psychologically one perfects them, one develops them completely, properly in that order. First you I mean, and the idea of course whether one’s following the Theravāda tradition or the Mahāyāna tradition, the idea is to try in one’s life to practice all of these six things because they’re all important and they’re all interconnected.

But one perfects the first one first and the more one practices the first one, the easier it is to to not only practice the second one, but to practice it more purely, perfectly, completely. And the end result is to develop the wisdom that will liberate us from not only cyclic existence but also to enable us to remove the subtle obscurations of the mind which even an Arahant has so that we can become a Buddha. So the first five perfections can be seen as the practice of method. Buddhist teachings are divided up into two categories or there’s many ways they can be divided up. Talk about the practice of method and the practice of wisdom.

And the method side of the teachings is basically about developing a good heart. And wisdom is about wisdom. Developing a penetrative insight into the true nature of oneself and phenomena. So we need both of these practices. These are said to be the wings on which we fly to enlightenment, method and wisdom.

So the first five perfections help us develop the method side, the good heart, love, compassion, bodhicitta, they are also the basis for being able to develop wisdom. One of the great Kadampa Geshe, one of the Tibetan masters, direct disciples of Lama Atisha or anyway evolved from the teachings of Lama Atisha said, Enlightenment is based on merit and wisdom. Merit and wisdom are based on bodhicitta. bodhicitta is based on love and compassion. The precepts of love and compassion are based on the six perfections.

So we practice the six perfections in order to be able to generate bodhicitta. When someone has actually generated bodhicitta, then they continue to practice the six perfections in a really profound and vast way and perfect these practices. Anyway, before I go on, any questions about what I have said or anything else? I can repeat the quote. This is from the Kadampa Geshe who said, omniscience, enlightenment, is based on merit and wisdom.

Merit and wisdom are based on bodhicitta. bodhicitta is based on love and compassion, and the precepts of love and compassion are based on the six perfections. Elsewhere in the teachings you often read the expression in order to achieve enlightenment one has to complete the two accumulations. One has to accumulate two things. One accumulation is the accumulation of merit and one is the accumulation of wisdom.

When we’ve got both of those complete, enlightenment is achieved. So merit is accumulated through the good heart, especially bodhicitta. And wisdom, the accumulation of wisdom is, guess what, Is the cause of that is wisdom. Terrific. Yes.

Yeah. Fly to enlightenment. Mhmm. Has that got any reference to that the green bird? Garuda?

No. No. There’s a bird that Haven’t heard that. Sorry. Any other questions?

Nothing? Okay. You’re one of the very questioning lot. It’s good to ask questions. Any questions.

Don’t be shy. The very question you want to ask, lots of people want to ask, but then too shy to ask them or the ego gets you in the way. Anyway, okay. So the first of the six perfections is the practice of generosity. One great benefit of practicing generosity is that it releases us from poverty.

And so a definition of generosity given by the great Bodhisattva Śāntideva is it is the thought to give all beings everything. It is a thought. So generosity is a state of mind. And it is a state of mind which wants to give all beings everything together with the fruit of such a thought. You know, fruit meaning here, you know, the merit, the karmic, the virtuous karmic imprint.

So perfect generosity is wanting to give everything to all sentient beings, but also even the merit of wanting to do that, of giving the merit to all sentient beings as well. Hence, generosity is simply a state of mind. Generosity isn’t perfected by giving people lots of stuff but generating the mind that happily wants to. Developing that that mind, that generous spirit, that generosity of spirit. Another way of looking at it can be seen from the great Lama Rinchen Dorje’s statement which says, the highest giving is found in non attachment.

So in other words, when we develop the mind of non attachment, then it’s very easy to be able to give. There’s nothing blocking us from being able to give when we actually have cultivated that mindset of non attachment. Also if you think about it, why is generosity important? Especially well, generosity is the first attack on our self-cherishing thought. Because the self-cherishing thought or one aspect of it is, you know, it’s this mind that feels that I have to have so much, you know, so much to make me happy, so much to protect me from suffering.

I can’t afford to give anything away or share it with others because I will suffer. So that mindset is a great obstacle any kind of spiritual path to liberation but especially to enlightenment. So that mind is incredibly important to develop. The mind wanting to give. So although it is a state of mind, if it’s a genuine state of mind, so in other words a poor person can perfect generosity.

You don’t need lots of stuff to perfect generosity. But if you have stuff and you and and you and but you don’t wanna give it away ever and and think, oh, I don’t have to give it away because generosity is a state of mind. And I, oh, I really want people to have something. I visualize giving them stuff all the time, but I’m not gonna give them my real stuff, then, of course, one hasn’t generated generosity at all. You don’t actually have to give stuff to create to generate that mind, but if you’re not willing to give stuff when it’s possible to do so and when there’s a real need, then it means that that what you think is wanting to give isn’t there at all.

It’s just an illusion. And, of course, you know, wanting to give away your junk to other people is not is not particularly generous. So there are three forms of generosity. There is the based on developing this mind that wants to give, you know, is happy to give, sees how beneficial it is in every possible way. So on that basis there are three kinds of giving that we can cultivate.

The obvious one of giving material things. Then there is the giving, what is said to be the giving of protection from fear. So that can be done in many, many different ways. Giving advice, help, basically having a loving and compassionate heart towards others. Protecting them from all the fears of life, fears and worries and so on that can arise from all sorts of things.

That giving of protection can be done through speech or physical actions like for example taking care of a sick person in any way would come under that category of protecting from the fear of sickness and so on. Giving advice, calming words, encouraging words, all of that. And then the final kind of generosity which is said to be the best, the highest form is the giving of the Dharma. And here that’s referring to someone who is able to teach the Dharma in a very correct proper way. Not like me.

I’m not practicing that. I’m not claiming to be practicing that one. So. No, you can’t. Anyway, all the good bits you hear come from my Gurus.

Yeah. At least I’ve I’ve had the good fortune to hear the teachings from many truly amazing teachers and at least my tiny little mind can remember some of those things. So that’s what you’re getting. Not me. All the confusion.

That’s the real me. That’s me. Anyway, is just a brief introduction so I won’t say any more about it than that. For example in the case of someone could think, Oh, since giving Dharma is the highest one, I’ll drop the other two and just concentrate on teaching the Dharma to other people. So this is not the way to go about things.

But helping great teachers fulfill their job. So anything we do to help our Gurus teach the Dharma comes under that category and is also extremely beneficial. So even if we can’t help and teach the Dharma ourselves yet, if we help other people to do so this is incredibly beneficial and meritorious and an act of giving. Also helping the Dharma not just teachers themselves but helping the Dharma spread by helping Dharma centers function so that teachings can occur in a Dharma center. All of those things, if we do that with the right motivation and etc, etc, this is the giving of Dharma.

So it’s incredible merit and it’s yeah. It’s it’s a practice of giving. So we can do we can do these things. We can train to develop the mind to do these things both like directly doing them but also indirectly helping people who do do these things. So all of these the six perfections have roughly worldly benefits in this life but help us achieve a good rebirth, help us achieve enlightenment, but especially by trying to do it with these practices, with the bodhicitta motivation and dedicating it to enlightenment especially it helps us to achieve just that, to undermine the self-cherishing thought so that eventually when we perfect the sixth perfection of generosity we can undermine our self grasping ignorance.

You have any questions as I’m going along, please ask. Don’t be shy. Don’t then the second of the perfections is the practice of moral discipline, ethical discipline. So the benefit of that in this life, one of the benefits just in this life, is it releases us from the feelings of remorse because the more we live a virtuous life, then involving avoiding negative actions we will have less guilt, less remorse and so on and therefore a much happier mind. Śāntideva, maybe just quickly go back, The more we practice generosity and see that being generous, giving in various ways to sentient beings and wanting to give to them brings sentient beings happiness, then the more we see this and experience it for ourselves, then this becomes a basis to be able to practice purer level of morality and to be able to eventually perfect it because if we’re starting to enjoy making people happy by giving them things and giving them things, giving them help, advice, giving our energy and knowledge and whatever to others, more we see benefit from that and see how good it is, why would we want to harm them?

We would develop a mind that more and more would not want to harm sentient beings, would not want to engage in negative actions, and would want to engage in more and more virtuous actions that bring even more benefit to sentient beings. So the more we practice generosity, the more we will be able to live a virtuous life. Because again, if you check, the the less generous spirit we have, the more we have this really hard mind that is miserly and has a poverty stricken mentality, that hard mind, not thinking of others, can very easily engage in negative actions and harm others. That mind is certainly blocking the development of our love and compassion. The more we practice generosity, the more we’re able to develop the mind of moral discipline.

Because it’s a discipline. We have to discipline ourselves not to engage in negative actions and thoughts and so on when there’s the opportunity. We have to, you know, discipline ourselves not to do those things and to discipline ourselves to do virtuous things when there’s the opportunity and even when there’s not the opportunity. But, of course, when there isn’t any opportunity, it’s very easy to be moral. But it’s when there’s the opportunity to be immoral, that’s when we have to have the discipline not to.

And here the thought is not just because negative actions are harmful to me, it’s because they are harmful to sentient beings. But also at a deeper level the negative from a Mahāyāna point of view when we accumulate negative imprints from negative actions. The obvious problem is those negative imprints if we don’t purify them are going to bring me suffering. But from a Mahāyāna point of view, the real problem of creating, the real issue of creating negative imprints is not that the imprints are going to bring me suffering, but those imprints are obscuring my mind. And with an obscured mind, it’s very difficult to practice the Dharma.

It’s difficult to understand it, practice it, have faith in it. Even if we practice it with faith, with an obscured mind, it’s difficult to practice well and get the results. And therefore, the more obscured our mind, the difficult it is. The more difficult it is to benefit sentient beings or even want to benefit them. So that’s the worst obstacle.

That’s the worst problem of following self-cherishing and creating negative karma is that it’s obscuring the mind. We’re creating obstacles to achieve the very best thing possible for ourselves and others which is enlightenment. So that’s why a bodhisattva doesn’t want to do that. Not because it’s going to hurt me but because it’s going to make it’s going to delay my spiritual path which means the suffering of sentient beings is going to continue longer, their happiness is going to be delayed by me delaying my spiritual progress. So that’s how a bodhisattva thinks.

So Śāntideva, who is a bodhisattva, defines morality or moral discipline as the thought to forsake all harm to all sentient beings. So and and to develop that mind, of course, we have to develop a deep understanding what harm really means Because many things that we do as deluded sentient beings control controlled by attachment and afflicted desire are actually harmful to us. But we’re quite happy doing them because they think they bring some, you know, they bring some momentary entertainment distraction which we like, which we think is great. We don’t see the karmic consequences. We don’t want to know about the karmic consequences.

So So but a Bodhisattva is someone who is has realized what is harmful to themselves, has allowed themselves to acknowledge what is actually harming them in a profound and lasting way. And having developed compassion for themselves, they see that mother sentient beings are doing all these things that are actually harming themselves when and and they they think and they do it thinking it’s going to benefit. So Lama Atisha says, the highest moral discipline is a peaceful mind. Isn’t that great? Yeah.

So if you have a peaceful mind, then of course one is not going to harm others. If one’s mind is at peace, yeah, some inner peace, inner contentment, one won’t harm. One won’t even develop the thought to harm. So that’s the highest moral practice is achieving a peaceful mind, working to achieve a peaceful mind. So again, there are three kinds of moral discipline, especially the Mahāyāna perspective of developing the highest kind of morality.

There’s the morality of restraining from engaging in negative actions of body, speech, and mind. That’s the obvious one. There’s the morality of engaging in every kind of virtuous action of body, speech, and mind. And then there’s another kind of morality which is bit more general than all of that, is working for the benefit of others, doing anything that will benefit others. First one is avoiding all negative actions.

The second one is doing every kind of obvious virtuous action. And the third kind of morality is working for the benefit of sentient beings. Of course the first two are done for the benefit of sentient beings but then there other things that don’t specifically go into those first two categories but can involve working sentient beings. So the more we engage in the first two perfections of generosity and morality, which we are benefiting others more and more, seeing how wonderful that is, then this enables us to begin to practice patience more and more and perfect it because patience is the antidote, the direct antidote to anger and anger is the single most harmful of the delusions in relation to other sentient beings. It is our anger that can cause the greatest harm to others.

And a bodhisattva only wants to benefit others, is horrified at the idea of harming a sentient being in any way even if sentient beings harm them. So a bodhisattva pays great attention to developing the mind of patience. Patience, I don’t have an actual definition of patience but patience is not the repressing of anger, the denying of anger patience is a state of mind that undermines the the factors that give rise to anger. It’s it’s it’s it’s it’s it involves cultivating another way of looking at things, thinking about things, which is the opposite to the the way of thinking about and looking at things that gives rise to anger. If we look at things and think about things in one way, anger arises.

If we look at and think about things in another way, we will be patient. So and you can’t do both at once. So one has to win. Either one is angry or patient. So we have to cultivate this new way of looking and thinking about things.

And the more we can do that, the less energy to feed this other false way. What patience really is, from my opinion, this may be not one hundred percent dharmically correct, but my understanding is that really, what boils down to is just another form of compassion. Or or or at least, genuine patience, which is not like biting your tongue and smiling when you’re actually loathing someone. Patience is not hiding your anger from others or yourself. It’s when you’ve dispersed it.

Not repressed it, one’s dispersed it, one’s diffused it, one’s stuck a pin in it so it just fizzles. So that genuine state of patience is integrally linked, related to compassion for oneself, for others. Because one has genuine compassion for oneself one won’t get angry because one understands anger anger is really destructive of one’s own well-being. And because of compassion, one won’t get angry to the enemy. I know none of you ever have enemies.

I remember that. But, due to having compassion, one won’t get angry with the enemy because one will understand the enemy is behaving badly because they’re suffering. And the only response to suffering, the valid response to someone who has a clear mind is to feel compassion. As usual Lama Atisha gives a wonderful way to look at what patience is when he said the highest patience is humility. So in other words, if we cultivate a genuinely humble outlook, then though we still have the wrong view of self, we don’t grasp that sense of self so strongly and inflate it.

The less we have that sort of ego attitude, less reason to be angry with things. Because our anger flares up because the sense of I has been contradicted or thwarted. You know, what I want has been thwarted. Thwarted. Thwarted.

Yes. I thought I thought. Yeah. Contradicted, thwarted, averted. Yeah.

So I don’t like that. The I controlled by self-cherishing doesn’t want that. Oh, don’t know what that’s called. Difficult. Or it could be many things why they don’t recognize it.

They think it’s false or something. Is that self-cherishing? It could be. I don’t know if it’s necessarily self-cherishing. It’s certainly deluded whether it’s it could in many it could be self-cherishing.

Yeah. So if one is humble, you know, whether whether one you know, people agree with you or not, go along with say you’re a nice person or not, doesn’t matter so much. So one doesn’t get angry or so angry. Or if one does, it’s easier to control it. And the Japanese Zen master, our Japanese Zen master called Sengai, once upon a time he said, I really like this expression statement, It is not patience which you can bear patiently.

Patience is to bear what is unbearable. In other words, it’s only when one starts to feel something or someone is unbearable that one has to practice patience. If it’s difficult but one thinks I can manage this, one’s not really being patient. It’s only when our buttons are really pushed, the self-cherishing is really starting to that’s when we have to practice patience. Patiently.

Patience is to bear what is unbearable. To bear, to support, to bear, to put up with. Yeah, to bear. Yeah. Support, to bear something, to hold it, maintain it.

Yes. Yeah, sure. Yes. Yeah. Well there’s many many ways, many many aspects.

Yeah, I’m sorry I’m not going into any details how you do these things because each of the six perfections is a huge thing. But especially this topic of patience is wonderfully dealt with by Śāntideva in his amazing book, The Guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life. Which brings me to an advertising break here. Which is, so that chapter on patience is the most wonderful chapter in Śāntideva’s Guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life and Lama Zopa Rinpoche will be in Bendigo from the twenty fifth of September teaching Śāntideva’s Bodhisattva Way of Life for two weeks. So, in my humble opinion, if there is one Buddhist book you have to read in this life before you die, not just read, but study for the rest of one’s life, it is Śāntideva’s Guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life.

This is essential for reading essential reading for all for all people who have even the slightest interest in Mahāyāna Buddhism. Right? So it is the single most wonderful book. As I’ve said many times, from my understanding, it’s probably the single the most quoted book in Tibetan Buddhism, certainly in the Gelugpa tradition, I’m pretty probably sure it’s the same in all the traditions. And one that needs a commentary to really appreciate it fully.

This commentary is given by Lama Zopa Rinpoche who is unquestionably a bodhisattva and one of the most amazing, wonderful beings on this planet right now. And so the chance to be in the presence of such a person, just to be physically next to near such a person is something unbelievable. To have the chance to actually hear such a person teach is just mind boggling. So save your pennies and spend them all on coming to Bendigo for Rinpoche’s teachings. For one day, two days, if you can afford the whole time, you know, the first two weeks, fantastic.

But even if you can go just for a little while, try. You won’t regret it. I hope. The Bendigo Centre itself in in the Great Stūpa itself is quite something, quite amazing. A truly amazing structure that even though it’s half built is quite mind boggling amazing.

When it’s finished it’s going to be just super spectacular. Really something very special. I suppose I should practice patience now, should I? Just quickly to finish this little section. Again there’s three kinds of patience, there’s not really three kinds of patience but there’s three areas where we need to which we which we need to develop patience.

The first is with with sentient beings and this is the obvious way to develop patience in relation to other people. Other people, you know, give us grief. So we need to be patient with them. Also we need to develop patience basically with our own suffering, own physical mental suffering. We need to be patient with our own delusions and self-cherishing.

The aim is to get rid of our self-cherishing, but we have to understand that we’re not gonna do it overnight. It’s gonna take, you know, sorry this is to say this, but we just have to be honest. You know? It’s it’s it’s gonna take a long time to get rid of our self-cherishing. And not only that, the bad news is it’s gonna take a lot of hard work.

A lot of hard work over a very long time. You can go now and and find another happy religion that makes you instantly enlightened in two weeks. But this is, you know, even with tantra, very hard, you know. Anyway, so we need to be patient with our self-cherishing and all our other delusions. We have to accept that it’s going to be there for a long time, but in accepting that, we try to work on reducing it, but we have to do it gently and skillfully and with wisdom.

And rather than beating ourselves up for having delusions and making mistakes and not being able to get rid of them, we need to be patient with ourselves and and just be happy that we are doing something. Because before, we never we billions of lifetimes, we didn’t do a thing right. It was just a total disaster. Now we’ve met the the Dharma, the perfect teaching. So we are so lucky.

And everything we do is is putting positive imprints. So we’re so lucky. So we should be happy, not thinking, oh, I’m deluded, still deluded. So then be patient and I’ll finish. Yeah.

And finally, the the other kind of patience that we need, which ultimately for a bodhisattva is the most important is the patience of being able to practice the Dharma. Being able to face all the difficulties of actually practicing the Dharma. For example, listening to teachings for a long time, studying difficult texts, trying to meditating on them, learning to be able to actually physically sit in the correct posture and to do it for long periods of time. And to, you know, doing many, many hours and of meditation and long retreats, etcetera, etcetera, and doing prostrations and water bowl offerings and accumulating merit in all sorts of ways. Patience.

So by learning to be patient with difficult people and our own problems this is the groundwork to be able to practice the patience of following the Dharma. And just quickly, just oh, no. No. That’s it. Finished.

Tea break. Just a brief look at the six perfections. So the more we practice patience where we are able to bear difficulties more and more especially the difficulties of practicing Dharma etc. Then this leads to being able to engage in enthusiastic perseverance more and more. Enthusiastic perseverance defined.

Śāntideva defines this as finding joy or experiencing joy or happiness in what is wholesome. In other words, one finds joy in doing things which are virtuous and meaningful. That is practicing the Dharma. We actually we reach a point where we actually enjoy doing it even if it’s difficult to do because we know it’s beneficial for ourselves and others now and in the future. So if we check our own experience, just our ordinary worldly experience, things we don’t enjoy doing we don’t put effort into and have very little energy to do them.

We just force ourselves to do them. If we enjoy doing something we have energy to do it and to do it for a reasonably long period of time. So if we enjoyed, if we actually enjoyed practicing the Dharma we would have energy to do it and that means we would practice it more. And if we practiced it more combined with the fact that we were able to bear the difficulties of that then we would get the results. We would, as Lama Yeshe used to say, we would get the taste of the Dharma.

We would get the taste, is a very delicious taste, so the Lamas say. And that would encourage us to practice more and more. So we’d have more energy to practice, so we’d be able to advance along the path. Lama Rinchen Dorje, to give another slide on it, says that the highest effort is to abandon attachment to activities. Of course what that refers to is worldly activities.

Not getting attached to worldly activities. And of course if we’re not attached to them, then we’ve got time to practice the Dharma. So then this leads into the next of the or the last of method pāramitā, perfections which is concentration because the more we have enthusiasm or energy to practice the Dharma that means one aspect of practicing Dharma is training the mind to actually meditate, to concentrate, to focus the mind. Not all meditation is concentrating but an essential aspect of concentration and a particular form of concentration meditation is concentrating the mind, learning to focus the mind on one object and keep it there for longer and longer periods of time. So if we’ve developed patience where we can bear difficulties and we’ve cultivated enthusiasm for the Dharma where we really enjoy it even if it’s difficult, especially when it becomes easier and easier through the power of familiarity then we will learn to meditate.

We will learn to put up with the difficulties and enjoy the difficulties of actually sitting in the posture properly, training the mind to stay on the object and bringing it back again and again and again. Not letting, you know, getting caught up with the distracting thoughts and so on. So we will be able to develop single point concentration. So Lama Atisha says that the highest meditation is the mind without pretension. So when all ego thoughts have gone then very easy to concentrate.

So the reason for developing concentration is some people throughout history in places where meditation was practiced especially in India and China and so on people got caught up in practicing concentration because it produces this very blissful experience in your body and the mind and people came to take that as an ultimate goal and even identified that bliss with liberation and enlightenment. But from Buddhist point of view it is just a worldly accomplishment. That bliss is something far great that comes with developing Samādhi is something far greater than anything we as ordinary people who haven’t developed it can experience. So it can look something really mystical and super duper and liberated and enlightened and look like and feel like nirvana. But it’s just a worldly accomplishment.

It’s still a samsaric state. It’s just a worldly accomplishment. Yeah. It’s Samādhi. It’s just a worldly accomplishment.

But in in the Mahāyāna in the in the Buddhist tradition, we still need to develop concentration for the one can develop it with a spiritual motivation, not just for the temporary bliss and so on that it can bring, but in order to really deeply penetrate into the meaning of the Buddha’s teachings and most particularly the teachings on the nature of reality one needs to develop concentration. This mind, that mind is not able to really understand and penetrate the meaning of emptiness, Śūnyatā. Particularly find the object to be refuted. Just simply not possible. Once we’ve developed concentration then we have the basis to then develop.

Of course concentration can be used to the more concentration we have the easier it is to develop every spiritual quality that we meditate on to realize that we’ve got a precious human rebirth, to realize everything’s impermanent, that death is coming, to realize loving kindness, compassion, bodhicitta. All of those things will come more quickly and be able to be sustained more easily if we develop the Samādhi. But especially we need it in order to cultivate wisdom, the wisdom that’s gonna destroy ignorance. So just developing wisdom sorry, concentration doesn’t lead to wisdom. It’s but we need it to focus on the wisdom teaching.

So we have to train in hearing those teachings, meditating on them, you know, contemplating them. And then when we’re able to actually concentrate on them, that intellectual understanding becomes so powerful, it destroys that that those wrong views. But without a concentrated mind, the mind isn’t powerful enough to undermine those wrong views. To stay on the right view long enough to penetrate its real significance strongly enough to completely annihilate ignorance. For example, especially for those people who’ve heard some teachings on emptiness before and while you’re listening to them you think, oh, I I can understand that.

Before I didn’t. Now, oh, that makes sense. I understand that. I’ve got that. And so there’s some real understanding while you’re listening and then the teacher stops and all that understanding disappears.

You remember that you got it and it was very nice when you got it but you can’t remember exactly what it was anymore. Why? Because we weren’t concentrating. Maybe we were a little bit but our concentration wasn’t complete. It was a long way from being complete.

That understanding, that insight which may have been correct and valid, may not have but it may have, it just wasn’t focused enough to stay in the mind. Alright, so we need a level of concentration where our understanding stays in the mind. Yeah. Yeah, sure. Of course how strong that imprint is will also depend on how concentrated we were at the time.

But even if we weren’t concentrated at all still some imprint is there which is good. Yeah, so okay. So by perfecting or concentration this leads us to be able to perfect wisdom. So Lama Atisha says the highest wisdom is not to grasp anything as it appears. So that’s something we can even we are now we can try to do because just like patience is the direct antidote to anger, wisdom is the direct antidote to ignorance and ignorance has two aspects.

Ignorance, the way the obscuration of ignorance works, it forces the mind, it causes the mind to experience things in a false way. That’s firstly what it does. So it creates the illusion of what is called inherent existence or true existence. As though things it creates the illusion that things are really out there separate in dependence upon the existing from their own side. So it creates that illusion and secondly, as it’s creating that illusion, ignorance grasps that that illusion is real, is true, that it’s not an illusion but it’s actually true.

So this is why so to get rid of the appearance of true existence is very difficult but what what one can do to some extent now or train is not to grasp that that appearance is real. Especially if we understand that that actually it isn’t real. If we think it is real, not only if we you know, it’s appearing real, but if we allow ourselves to believe, oh, it really is real. And but, you know, as I’m a Buddhist, I suppose to pretend I have to force myself to believe that it’s not real. That’s not gonna work.

But if we understand the the teachings about emptiness and we start to gain some understanding that actually things appear this way but they couldn’t exist that way. Especially if we start to gain that understanding then it becomes easier to if we practice strong mindfulness when certain things arise in our mind, in our experience rather than immediately grasping that this is how it is, this is good, this is bad, this is right, this is wrong, this is beautiful, this is ugly, then we, you know, let go a little bit and, know, try to have that space where we try to see, yes, this is appearing this way, but is it that way? We can try and withhold judgment. Easier said than done of course, but we can try. So just that is being wise.

We can practice the mindfulness trying to see that everything is like a dream. Because dreams are all produced by our mind but while we’re dreaming we think it’s all completely true. We don’t think it’s been created by our mind. It’s just there. But in fact, the Buddha is saying waking reality is like that.

It’s arising depending on our mind, but we think it’s just there. Like that. Nothing to do with me, nothing to do with my mind, it’s just there. So we can try to have some awareness that actually everything I’m experiencing, my sense of self, my body, everything that’s on my body, everything around, it’s all like a dream. So one can talk about wisdom in many, many ways.

There are well, you could talk about two kinds of wisdom. There’s the wisdom that realizes the ultimate truth, the emptiness, Śūnyatā, nature of everything. There is the wisdom that understands the law of cause and effect. The great bodhisattva Nāgārjuna who is in a sense the source of the wisdom teachings of the Buddha reintroduced them to the world. He said something along the lines of until one has realized the highest truth one should take how did he say it?

He said it very well. It’s really good and I’m just skipping a really dodgy version of it. Until one has realized the highest truth anyway, follow the law of cause and effect. In other words, for us, wisdom is understanding and practicing the law of cause and effect. That is being wise.

Until one’s realized the highest wisdom, it is wise to understand and practice the law of cause and effect. That’s the ordinary man’s and woman’s wisdom. Because and if we do it, the point is that by understanding and observing the law of cause and effect we will realize the highest wisdom. Going against the law of cause and effect, living a life where we’re denying the law of cause and effect will create all the obstacles preventing us realizing the highest wisdom. Because if you think about it, why do we engage in negative actions is because that is really bad.

That’s making me that is really bad, and that’s making me really angry. In other words, I believe this is really inherently truly existing. So every time we engage in negative actions we reinforce our ignorance because we’re not only you know, these negative emotions are not only arising but we’re agreeing with them. We’re saying, yes. That’s right.

So it’s a double disaster. Double disaster. So traditionally it talks about the three kinds of wisdom. Firstly, there is the wisdom that arises from hearing the teachings. Just by listening to the teachings with an open mind, of course, and of course, if we have some karmic connection with the teachings, just by listening, we develop a certain degree of wisdom.

We start to know things as true that we never knew before. And which without hearing the teachings we may never in all our life have come to understand or think about. Certainly in my case it’s true. So one becomes wise just by listening to the teachings. Then a higher or deeper deeper and higher level of wisdom develops by contemplating those teachings doing analytical meditation on them.

Where one develops a logical inferential understanding of the teachings. So that wisdom is much deeper, much stronger. The first kind of wisdom that can be easily undermined by smart alecs arguing with us and saying prove it and you try and oh I can’t remember, but I believe it but I can’t exactly explain why. So it all collapses but if one has a genuine logical understanding, an inferential understanding of the teachings then this is very very strong and this also has much more power to undermine one’s own doubts because we can have all sorts of doubts about the teachings which weaken our faith and refuge and so on. An inferential understanding is it’s referring to a logical understanding.

You can by a process of logic you can infer something that one can’t directly know yet. You know our mind is capable of directly perceiving emptiness for example but right now we can’t directly know it but we can know it inferentially indirectly and in the teachings it gives the traditional example is if in the distance, you know, there’s some mountains, hills and behind those hills you can see some continuously billowing smoke for some time. There’s continuous billowing smoke for some time. You can know that there is a fire. You can’t see the fire.

You have no ability to directly perceive the fire but you can infer logically, correctly that there is a fire. That’s inferential understanding logic. There are incorrect inferences too but there are also correct in that’s one of the valid ways of knowing. That’s what the teachings are all about. They present logical reasons that for this.

This is this is like this because of this, this, this, this, and this. Before one directly perceives emptiness one can know it validly through logic by inferring that things although they appear this way they can’t exist that way. Appear to exist from their own side independently but actually if you check the only way things exist is depending on causes and conditions, parts and the labeling mind. If one really checks that is the way things exist. It’s the only way things can exist.

So by understanding dependent arising one can infer that things are empty. They don’t truly exist. They are empty of inherent existence because they arise dependently. If one understands that logic that is correct inferential understanding. And then the final wisdom arrives from is the wisdom that arises through concentration.

As I try to explain briefly that when the mind when you apply that inferential understanding that has been developed by doing contemplative meditation, analytical meditation, by doing this again and again and combining it with developing concentration, when the mind becomes single pointedly concentrated effortlessly, then that inferential understanding becomes so powerfully directed onto the wrong view that it destroys the wrong view. And then the mind directly perceives the object emptiness. So it becomes a direct perception. Inferential understanding is a valid conception about something. It is an idea about something, a correct idea.

Direct perception isn’t an idea, it is a direct experience of the thing itself. If you’ve never eaten a particular kind of food, someone can describe what it tastes like so you can get an idea of the taste. But it isn’t the taste. You have to have a direct perception yourself. So that is the highest kind of wisdom, the wisdom that is directly perceiving things as they are.

And just finally briefly, another way of looking at wisdom, there are three kinds of wisdom. There is the wisdom that understands or experiences the ultimate truth, emptiness. There’s the wisdom that experiences, understands the conventional truth, which is of dependent arising. And then there is the wisdom understanding how to benefit sentient beings. So we need all three because not only do we need compassion, we need to combine that compassion with the wisdom that understands how to benefit others.

The wisdom of knowing how to benefit under yeah. The wisdom understanding how to benefit others. Okay. I think I have run out of things to say. There is actually tons to say about those three.

There have been those six perfections. But I won’t bombard you with more tonight and we don’t have much time left. No time for discussion group and not really any time to meditate. Reverted back to type. Am sorry.

Sorry. So how about some questions? Come on. What you’ve always wanted to ask but never been Yes? What’s the difference between the ultimate truth and the conventional truth?

Yes, what is the difference? The conventional truth is what we see when we’re not perceiving the ultimate truth of emptiness of things but the conventional truth is referring to the fact that things don’t exist and that they exist and function by arising dependently. That this object here is arising dependently on causes and conditions, parts and the labeling mind. That’s the way it is existing as a flower. Ultimately this flower is empty of inherent existence.

It’s not existing from its own side under its own power. Although it appears that way to our ordinary mind. To the mind not perceiving emptiness it appears to exist in that very concrete way. But it’s not like that. It appears to, yes.

Well, technically that’s not true. It appears to exist inherently, that’s the term. And what inherent existence means if something was inherently existing, nothing is inherently existing, but if it was inherently existing it would logically follow that it was independent. But if you check things aren’t independently existing. The only way this phenomena here and every other phenomena can exist for us is depending on causes and conditions, parts and our mind and how our mind labels this.

This thing here, this thing which is a very sad looking thing, not as happy as it once was I don’t think. This flower, this object, for us, this is obviously a flower. Right? It’s obviously an orchid. This is a orchid or orchids?

Anyway, right? Obviously orchid, but the reality is that this object here has no power from its side to make us experience it as an orchid. It has nothing there. There’s nothing there whatsoever that can make us know it’s an orchid. The design from its side.

Yes, the design helps us know it’s an orchid and the shape and the color and everything but not from its side. Think about that. Yeah, it depends on our mind saying that this is a flower, this is a orchid flower, this is a beautiful orchid flower or this is a kind of saggy orchid flower. That all depends on our mind. But when we experience it, it looks like from its side it is telling us I am this.

Yes. It depends. The only way it can anything appears in a particular way, it depends on many things including our experiences in this life, but even more interestingly from the past. Because also, you know, we all have the experience of looking at things and people and having an instant liking or disliking of them. And this, you know, one can say, oh, it’s because of blah blah, you know, I like them because of blah blah blah.

But actually that’s just what’s the word? Rationalization. You know, we’ll have this instant, oh, I like this person or I like the taste of this apple or this this thing and I don’t like this. Why? Never had it before.

Never seen it in this life at all. And then suddenly we have this incredible, Karmic imprints. Karmic imprints. As a monk I shouldn’t get into this topic but why do people fall in love with someone? Know it’s just that there’s no logic to that.

It’s just karmic attractions. You don’t decide you you to fall in love or get it, you know, get caught up involved with a person. It’s just imprints. The ultimate truth is that things well, it was the simp very simply, the ultimate truth is that things are empty of the way they lack existing the way they appear to us now. So in other words, the ultimate truth is that phenomena are empty of existing inherently from their own side under their own power.

Sort of. Sort of. Yes. I might note, I think we have to end. Unless there is one tiny little small question that could be easy to answer question, dilemma, okey doke.

So next Thursday is our last Thursday. No. Tuesday. Fooled you, didn’t I, for a moment? No.

Sorry. So, again, the Saturday is our retreat. So, please, I I would encourage people to come to the retreat. They’re they’re very beneficial way to finish the retreat, meditate on the topics, discuss together, have lunch together. It’s very pleasant, good thing to do.

I highly encourage. It is meant to be an integral part, so please think about it, register, and if you are coming, please remember to bring all your student material just in case we refer to it and need it. There are a couple of forms in it to fill out. Also we encourage people to bring a plate of vegetarian food to share with everyone. So this is also a nice thing to do.

Practicing generosity. Yes. Good. Bodhisattva way of life. So So we can dedicate the merit.

Through the merits of these virtuous actions, may I quickly attain the state of a Guru Buddha and lead all living beings without exception into that enlightened state. May the precious bodhicitta, not yet born, arise and grow. May that born have no decline, but increase forevermore. Oh, just for sorry. Very, very quickly, the with the homework, just the the the meditations.

So tomorrow night or morning, the idea is to go through the whole of the eleven point bodhicitta meditation. So it’s set out in the reading material, page eighty six, eighty seven. So just reflect on that way of generating bodhicitta. And then for each day successively is to meditate on the six perfections. So that’s also in your reading material.

The the there’s the article by Geshe Rabten talks briefly about each perfection, so you could use that as a basis for reflecting the thing I hope maybe you took some notes from what I said so you can reflect on those, that you can listen to the MP3 again and get some notes if you didn’t take notes now. And just reflect on each of those perfections, you know, one each day. And and the the mindfulness is to practice is to try and, like, each day successively take one of the perfections and try to be really mindful of that perfection that day and try and practice it as much as possible that day. Okay. Thank you.

So we can finish with three prostrations.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
Gelug
The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
special attitude adhyashaya (Skt); lhag sam (Tib)
The sixth of the seven points of cause and effect technique for developing bodhicitta, where the practitioner takes on the responsibility to lead all sentient beings to enlightenment by him- or herself. LYWA
ten virtuous actions gewa chu (Tib)
Actions of body, speech and mind which are the opposite of the ten nonvirtuous actions, therefore, one refrains from killing, speaks the truth and so forth. LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

What is the difference between ultimate truth and conventional truth?

Conventional truth refers to how things exist and function by arising dependently, relying on causes and conditions, parts and the labeling mind. A flower, for example, exists in that way. Ultimately, the flower is empty of inherent existence: it does not exist from its own side under its own power, even though it appears that way to a mind not perceiving emptiness. If it were inherently existing it would be independent, but things are not independent. Nothing in the object itself makes us know it is an orchid; this depends on our mind and on karmic imprints. Ultimate truth, put simply, is that phenomena are empty of existing inherently from their own side under their own power.

Scroll to Top