DB Bodhicitta — 2014-04-27

1 h 44 min · 9,721 words · 27 April 2014 · Buddha House Adelaide

DB Bodhicitta (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
DB Bodhicitta (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
DB Bodhicitta — 2014-04-27
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 104-minute final session of a nine-week course on bodhicitta, Ven Thubten Dondrub explains the bodhisattva vows—the ethical commitments that protect and strengthen the mind of enlightened intention. He distinguishes between the aspiring bodhicitta vows, which carry lighter karmic weight, and the engaging bodhisattva vows, which are far more stringent and are traditionally required before receiving tantric initiation. For the aspiring vows, he covers four commitments to prevent degeneration in this life (remembering bodhicitta’s benefits, reciting the refuge prayer daily, continuing to help even hostile beings, and dedicating merit) and four to preserve it in future lives (the four black karmas to abandon: deceiving gurus, discouraging others’ generosity, criticizing bodhisattvas, and dishonesty). He then outlines the eighteen root downfalls of the engaging vows, explaining that these require four disturbed mental factors to fully break them, and walks through the forty-six secondary downfalls, organized by how they contravene the six perfections—offering practical guidance on water-bowl offerings, developing concentration, reading minds, accepting apologies, and the morality of benefiting others. Throughout, he emphasizes that studying these vows is beneficial even for those not yet taking them, and uses extended discussion of self-cherishing, Tonglen practice, and the meeting with Lama Zopa Rinpoche to ground the teaching in lived application. Aimed at serious practitioners in the Tibetan Buddhist tradition.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2014 04 27 DB Bodhicitta Week 9 27042014.mp3

UUID: 63d3c372-7e48-4cbd-9d39-eb43581b31c1

Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub

Collection: DB Bodhicitta (Ven Thubten Dondrub)

Date: 2014-04-27

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 104.0 minutes

Words: ~9,723

So, if people like to. Oh, sorry. Firstly, hello, is this working? Hello, not working. Is it working?

Yes. Hello? Oh hello! No one is saying hello back, can you hear me? Oh yeah?

Alright, welcome everyone to our last class on how to generate bodhicitta. So we begin by doing the, for those who feel comfortable to do so, the motivational prayer. Sorry, I don’t know what page it’s on because I’ve got a different version of the book. And I think I’ve lost my copy of Anyway, if we turn to page eleven, it would be good while I mess around. As I have tried to emphasize, is really important when we listen and study the teachings to try and do so with the very best motivation possible, And the Mahāyāna teachings make it very clear that the very best motivation we actually can have for doing anything is the bodhicitta thought to achieve enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings.

Since this is our topic, to generate bodhicitta, then it’s really important to try and have the bodhicitta motivation for how to learn how to generate bodhicitta, but nevertheless we can try and do that especially since we have actually covered the ways to generate bodhicitta. Just to remind you the main ingredients to help us generate at least the effort for bodhicitta motivation is to have some faith in our own Buddha potential recognizing that because we have the precious human rebirth we have got the optimum chance to realize that potential and we can be motivated to realize it through becoming more and more aware of our interconnection with all sentient beings, how they are immensely kind and how we totally depend on that kindness life after life, especially the kindness of a mother which we have received from every sentient being many times in beginningless saṃsāra. But also we generate bodhicitta, so the more we think of that kindness we can develop the wish to repay that kindness. Especially when we realize how all these kind beings are trapped in cyclic existence helplessly, then we can generate that wish that the very best way to repay that kindness is to free all beings from suffering and all its causes and to lead them to peerless everlasting happiness.

And this is something really vital because the suffering of sentient beings is really appalling. And if we don’t do anything about it, that suffering is going to go on and on forever. So in order to perfectly repay the kindness of mother sentient beings, The only way we can do that is for ourselves to achieve enlightenment. And that means giving up all our negative qualities, awakening all our positive qualities completely. So think for the sake of all kind mother sentient beings, must achieve enlightenment and to do that I must train my mind in bodhicitta.

And so for this reason I’ll study this topic tonight. To make that way of thinking as meaningful as possible we visualize the Buddha in front of us as our source of refuge, inspiration and guidance and we think of all sentient beings surrounding us starting with our parents on either side, family, friends and helpers behind us, those who harm us in front, and then as much as we can, to think of all the other sentient beings of cyclic existence, trying to have that awareness, that strong sense that all these beings are in essence only kind, but unfortunately they are only suffering. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma and the Sangha from the virtuous merit I create by listening to the Dharma. May I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings. Thinking the Buddha is very pleased with our motivation, we imagine the Buddha now coming to the crown of our head.

When directly above our crown, we imagine the Buddha dissolving into blissful golden light, that light pouring into us, blessing our mind. Briefly we do the nine round breathing exercise to help enable our mind to become that much calmer, more clearer, concentrated so that we can use that level of mind to listen to and think about the Buddha’s teachings tonight. Okay. Thank you. For our last class, if you have checked the schedule of what we are covering, I just want to talk briefly tonight about the Bodhisattva vows.

So there are three handouts that go with that. Could some people Danny, could you help? Danny is giving out the first one so you don’t get all confused because they’re not numbered. And then page two. So this should only be given to the people who are registered for the course.

The people who aren’t registered for the course, didn’t print enough copies. Please. Cheryl is giving out page two and Christina is giving out page three. So has everyone got a copy? This should have three pages.

The first one says aspiring bodhicitta, the second one says the bodhisattva vows and the third one is a continuation of the bodhisattva vows. We okay? Right. So What’s the problem? That one?

Yes. Okay. So someone who has generated bodhicitta, authentic bodhicitta is a bodhisattva and that person traditionally what they do in order to make sure that that state of mind known as bodhicitta is preserved within their mind stream, doesn’t degenerate but they are able to actually develop it more and more. Take the bodhisattva vows There are two levels of bodhisattva vows which we talked about briefly earlier on. There are the wishing bodhicitta vows and the actual engaging or entering bodhisattva vows.

These days practice has developed that long before we generate bodhicitta because it may be millions of lifetimes before we ever generate bodhicitta but the practice is to take the bodhisattva vows first because then this becomes a basis to be able to accumulate the merit that will enable us to be able to eventually generate bodhicitta. Firstly the aspiring bodhicitta vows, the karmic commitments of these are nowhere near as strong as the entering or engaging bodhisattva vows. So in the Buddhist tradition certain vows that one takes cannot be known before one takes them. For example the vow, certainly the way it’s practiced in the Mahāyāna tradition it’s a little bit different in the Theravāda tradition but in the Tibetan tradition the vows of monks and nuns are not known — lay people aren’t supposed to know them. So even someone who wants to become a monk or nun can’t know the vows they are taking until they actually take them.

So they are kind of kept secret a little bit. But the lay vows, the five lay vows of not killing, stealing, avoiding sexual misconduct, lying and intoxicants, of course one can know those. And the tantric vows, you are not allowed to know those until you actually or after you have taken them. Of course the meaning of the reason is because you are so committed to the path that it doesn’t really matter what the vows are, you’re going to keep them because you want to follow that path. That’s the theory.

Of course these days everyone wants to know everything in writing before they sign anything. Anyway you’re not allowed to know the tantric vows until after you’ve taken them during tantric initiation. What is different are the Bodhisattva vows. The karma of these is extremely powerful but it is okay to know the vows and even receive commentaries on the vows even if one hasn’t taken them because it is so beneficial to know the vows and even if you don’t actually take them we can still try to live according to them. Certainly for anyone who is interested in any of the different versions of the Mahāyāna tradition and want to follow the Mahāyāna tradition, it’s really important to know the Bodhisattva vows and in fact at some point in one’s life to actually take the Bodhisattva vows.

Because they are so beneficial. All kinds of vows, every level of vow is very beneficial. Many people are reluctant to take vows because they think, oh if I break them you know there’s so much negative karma and I won’t be able to keep them so I’ll break them and it’s very negative to break them which it is true but it’s also very positive karma to keep them and mostly we’re able to keep vows more than break them. The purpose of keeping vows is that well there are many reasons but one very very important, very significant reason and benefit, it’s a reason and a benefit for taking vows is that and before I say that, vows really only work or the degree that they work, certainly from the Buddhist point of view, is depending on how much we understand the law of cause and effect, How much refuge we have in the Buddha’s teachings and the essential teaching is the law of cause and effect. So if we have come to some strong belief that the law of cause and effect really does explain how existence works, basically, and that belief should lead us to the determination to avoid negative actions and engage in virtuous ones.

Then the more we believe that, the more the taking of vows has a great benefit. Because by taking a vow engaging in a naturally negative action creates negative imprints that are going to bring great suffering to us in the future whether we know an action is negative or not. It doesn’t depend on knowing it, it just is negative. There are things that are naturally negative such as killing. If we engage in it, even if we believe killing is good, it still doesn’t change the fact that it’s negative and it’s generating these negative imprints in the mind.

But if on top of that we have a vow to kill, the karma is even worse. Right? Or secondly, if we know killing is negative, that it’s worse than killing not knowing it’s negative. But then if on top of that we have a vow not to kill, then the the karma is far worse than without the vow. That’s why, and so that’s the reason to take the vow because it forces us to be much more careful in our life, to be more mindful because if we go up against a vow it’s doubly, actually it’s more than doubly worse than just normally engaging in negative actions.

Am I making sense? Yeah? Yeah. So if we take vows on the basis of believing in the law of cause and effect, having refuge in the Buddha’s teachings, it forces us our own belief in karma forces us to be more mindful in our daily life. And by being more mindful, will avoid depending on how mindful we are that much we will be in a position to avoid negative actions.

And also that mindfulness of karma will help encourage us to engage, to keep the very well, to engage in virtuous actions more and more. So every time we keep the vow, every time we are not breaking the vow, we are accumulating great merit as well. So there’s the benefit of it keep taking vows helps us to be keep the mind clean, clear, and mindful during our life. Yeah. So we’re much more, what’s the word?

Careful. Focused. Focused, yes, and careful and we become much more sensitive to everything which helps us to be more kind and compassion gentle, forgiving, blah blah blah. All those good things, yeah? So there’s many benefits in this life but then on top of that there is the benefit of accumulating a lot of merit by keeping it.

And of course that also purifies our negative karma as well. So vows are really important to take and so for someone wanting to follow the Mahāyāna way of life, the Mahāyāna tradition, it’s really important to consider taking the Bodhisattva vows at some point, at least the wishing Bodhisattva vows but hopefully the full engaging Bodhisattva vows. So anyway there’s no time to go through all the vows tonight. Takes a long long time to really explain them all. I just want to make a few points, certainly firstly about the wishing or aspiring bodhicitta vows.

So really there is only one bodhisattva vow which is whether it is an aspiring or engaging one it is the vow to become a Buddha. Right? In order to benefit all sentient beings to repay their kindness. But there are different ways we can transgress that vow, that commitment. So with regard to the aspiring Bodhisattva vow, what we have to do is we have to guard our Bodhisattva vow from degenerating in this life.

And there are four things we commit ourselves to do in order to prevent our bodhicitta from degenerating in this life. So this is in your notes here, you’ve got it, right? So I’m just going to briefly go through them. The first one is to remember the advantages of bodhicitta over and over again. I gave you an outline at the very beginning of the course and it talked about the eight or ten benefits of bodhicitta.

The main benefit of course one achieves enlightenment. The bodhicitta is the most virtuous, positive, compassionate, courageous, all encompassing mind possible. So it’s got every benefit. It helps us purify our mind, it helps us accumulate enormous merit. In the teachings it says that when we do good action, what determines a good action is a good motivation.

So that produces a certain merit or a karmic imprint. That karmic imprint ripens and it brings a result and that’s it. But things done with bodhicitta, when one actually generates bodhicitta, anything that is done with bodhicitta, the karmic results never cease. It doesn’t bring just one good result, it brings ongoing good results. As Śāntideva says, somewhere in his Guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life he says something like, I’ve forgotten.

What does he say? The exact example. Ordinary merit is like a plantain tree or a banana bush where a banana it’s not actually a tree but anyway let’s call it a banana tree. It produces a bunch of bananas and that’s it. And it’s finished.

Ordinary merit produces one result and that’s it. Merit produced, motivated under the power of bodhicitta, that brings results over and over and over and over again because it’s so powerful. So we need to remember those advantages, all the advantages of bodhicitta. Because the more we remember those, of course, that will want us to cultivate that mind and act on that mind more and more so our bodhicitta won’t degenerate. Second thing is to strengthen one’s bodhicitta through the thought by generating the thought of bodhicitta three times in the morning, three times in the evening.

So the prayer that we say at the beginning of the teachings, the prayer of refuge, that is actually Mahāyāna refuge. It’s saying I’m taking refuge in order to become a Buddha to enlighten all sentient beings. That is also a bodhicitta prayer. One can say that prayer three times in the morning, three times in the evening as a way of helping to remember one’s bodhicitta, strengthen it. Of course, it’s not just a matter of really saying it, but trying to really engage one’s heart and mind with what those words really mean.

Of course we don’t have to confine it to saying just three times in the morning and three in the evening but at least a minimum of saying it three times in the morning, three times in the evening. I think I have said, maybe not in this class, but quite a few times already here at Buddha House that once His Holiness, the Dalai Lama said in a teaching that actually when you say this bodhicitta prayer, although the tradition is to say it three times, as His Holiness said, one should say it until the hairs on your arms stand on end. In other words, you have this incredibly intense deep feeling of what it means. So your whole being is kind of lifted up with this thought of wanting to achieve enlightenment for the sake of all beings. But that actually could take a long time of reciting it.

So the third thing to help our bodhicitta from degenerating in this life is not to give up working for sentient beings even when they are harmful towards us. When people are negative towards us we shouldn’t reject them but still continue to try and benefit them. Finally, what we should do to enhance our bodhicitta is dedicate this life to accumulating merit and wisdom as much as possible. Then there are the four things to try and do to prevent our bodhicitta degenerating in future lives. This is also another interesting thing which I must confess I don’t really understand because the pratimoksha vows which are the different vows that lead to the basis for achieving liberation from cyclic existence.

Prātimokṣa, the individual liberation. These are like the five lay vows and the vows of monks and nuns and all of the eight precepts that are taken for one day. Not the eight Mahāyāna precepts. The eight Mahāyāna precepts are the same as the eight pratimoksha vows. Difference is for the Mahāyāna, you take them with the bodhicitta thought.

Anyway, so all of these pratimoksha vows — oh, no. Maybe forget the eight one day vows, sorry that’s wrong. All the others, the lay vows, the five lay vows and vows of monks and nuns, these only last for this lifetime. When you die, the vow ceases with death. But in the teachings it says when you take the bodhisattva vows, they last forever.

They remain in your continuum forever. There could be many interesting debates about that, but that’s what the teaching says. Anyway, so having generated bodhicitta if we manage to do so even just a little bit then we want we don’t want this to degenerate in future lives. So to stop it, to help it, not degenerate in future lives, there are four unwholesome acts we should abandon. The first one is deceiving our Gurus and teachers and holy beings.

As it says here, also this applies to one’s parents. We shouldn’t deceive these people who are immensely kind to us because this is really so contrary to what the bodhisattva way of life is all about. We should abandon causing others to regret wholesome acts that they have done. So, you know, so so sometimes someone is very generous and gives some something to someone and then, you know, you can come along and say, oh, that was really stupid. You shouldn’t give it away given that to that person or you shouldn’t give them so much.

So one should not do things like that because for someone to give, to be generous, this itself is a good thing. As a bodhisattva we should be encouraging people we should be doing good things and encouraging other people to do good things because it is beneficial for them. So to discourage them from being generous or doing wholesome things is really quite harmful. We should abandon expressing unpleasant words to bodhisattvas. We shouldn’t criticize them because bodhisattvas, what they do is for the purpose of quite literally all sentient beings without exception.

So to criticize someone who is motivated to benefit all sentient beings is pretty heavy, pretty negative, pretty contrary to the bodhisattva way of life. And since we don’t know who is a bodhisattva, it’s better not to criticize anyone, which is the Buddha’s teachings anyway. Finally, in the four unwholesome acts, sometimes called the four black karmas to avoid, to prevent bodhicitta degenerating in future lives, is to abandon dishonesty towards sentient beings, especially to those who entrust themselves to us. We should never sort of mess around with them and be dishonest with them because if you think about it, one of the most essential things for there to be any kind of functioning of society and harmony between people so that there’s the even just a modicum of peace and goodwill, there has to be trust between people. And where there isn’t, things go really very bad.

You know, societies can’t function if the people in them don’t trust each other. You If people don’t trust the government, the government doesn’t trust the people, or you don’t trust the institutions of the society, etcetera, etcetera, things just don’t work. Everything breaks down. If people within a family don’t trust each other, it doesn’t work. If a couple don’t trust each other, it’s not going to last.

Everything gets really horrible and nasty. So and and especially in a spiritual relationship the job of a bodhisattva is to enlighten everyone, is to lead them away from suffering, to follow the path to enlightenment. So the job of an actual bodhisattva is to be a guru, is to become a guru in some way or another, directly or indirectly. And so one of the vital things in a student disciple relationship, of course, student teacher disciple relationship, is trust. And if one breaks that trust, this is really because the person who who loses their faith, that can be so incredibly destructive for them, harmful, especially in relation to spiritual faith.

Just losing faith or feeling betrayed by another human being is one thing, but when you think that that being has very special spiritual qualities, you trust them and then it turns out you were cheated, it’s really extremely awful. So for oneself, claiming to follow the bodhisattva way of life to do that to others is really quite contrary. Also to protect one’s bodhicitta from degenerating in future lives one tries to practice what are called the four wholesome acts, the four white karmas, which are more or less opposite to the four black ones. So this is practicing not lying to one’s gurus, one’s gurus, parents or sentient beings even for a joke. Secondly, what we should do is when people ask us for advice, to be very skillful in giving that advice so that that person will eventually follow the Mahāyāna path.

In other words, for those who are willing to listen, we should encourage people to follow the Mahāyāna path eventually. The third thing is to train in developing a pure view of everything as much as possible because the more pure view we have of things, our self and of others, the greater this protection for our mind this is. If we have a very impure view of things, especially of people, then it’s very easy to develop anger, aversion, etcetera, pride and jealousy towards others. So the purer the view, the more we create a condition for our heart to open and feel affection, love, compassion, kindness, generosity, etcetera, etcetera. Really trying to see sentient beings as Buddhas or at least as potential Buddhas.

Trying to remember if we can’t see them as Buddhas, at least it’s very important to try and remember that every sentient being has been our mother, that in fact this being is my mother, to have that pure view. We can also try and see them as bodhisattvas, also try and see them as our teachers, especially the enemy, the person who is unkind to us, we should try and think that person is our manifestation of the guru. Because the job of the guru is to point out or eventually to show us all our faults so that we can get rid of them. And enemies always point out our faults. So they are doing the job of the Guru.

Of course they don’t have the same motivation or wisdom, but actually the result is the same. They’re pointing out our faults, forcing us to practice patience, which is such a vital quality to develop. So it’s valid in order not to get angry with that person is to think, oh, this is my guru manifesting as this really nasty person. How incredibly kind a guru is. So I can’t get angry with this person because actually it’s a manifestation of the guru.

So these are different ways we can try and train to have pure view of sentient beings. Finally the fourth white Dharma to practice to prevent our bodhicitta degenerating, our wishing or aspiring bodhicitta from degenerating in future lives is to practice not being hypocritical towards others. Just very briefly, these are the commitments of aspiring bodhicitta. I think you can see that trying to live one’s life according to those guidelines is extremely helpful. So even if one doesn’t actually take the aspiring bodhicitta vows, just knowing the vows, trying to live according to them as much as possible is really helpful.

But of course, if one has the vow, it’s that much more beneficial. Because, for example, if there’s an opportunity to kill or steal or lie or any other negative action and we don’t do that, consciously don’t oh no, hold it. Yes. Knowing that this is a negative action, so consciously avoid engaging in that negative action. Conscious avoiding of engaging in a negative action when there’s the opportunity to do that is a virtuous action.

So it creates a virtuous karmic imprint which is going to bring some benefit in the future. But if on top of that we have the vow not to kill and we don’t then the merit is infinitely greater. If we engage in a virtuous action of avoiding a negative one, that is virtuous so it creates positive karma. But if on top of that we’ve taken a vow not to do it, that the imprint, the karmic imprint, is far, far greater and therefore brings a far, far greater, better result. Similarly, unfortunately, if we engage in a negative action it produces a certain amount of karma.

If we engage in the same negative action, taken the vow to avoid it, that is infinitely worse. But the reason to take the vow is to give more energy not to do it. Because it’s quite different from taking taking a vow if you’ve never done so is quite different from, like, New Year’s resolutions. Because in this case, the vow is taken on the basis of having refuge in the Buddha Dhamma Sangha. It’s done through a proper ceremony relying on a person doing it, and you’re promising the Buddhas, the Gurus and the Buddhas.

So because of all those things coming together and arising dependently on all those things and one’s understanding and one’s motivation, then that makes a certain effect on the consciousness. And it gives one some energy that normally one wouldn’t have not to do these negative things. I mean, not it’s not a magic guarantee that we won’t because it depends on many things depending on how sincere one is, how what one you know, how strong one’s understanding is, how much refuge in karma we have, etcetera, etcetera. So depending on those things, though, then it it it has this effect. It is really very helpful to take the vows if one can at some point.

Just very briefly, because it would take far too long to explain the actual engaging Bodhisattva vows, but with the actual engaging Bodhisattva vows so these are much much stronger. Traditionally in order to receive a tantric empowerment you would have to take the full engaging Bodhisattva vows. There are eighteen root downfalls. So as I said there is really just the one Bodhisattva vow which is to achieve enlightenment and there are eighteen ways that one can seriously contravene that or break that commitment. So there are eighteen downfalls.

There are eighteen root downfalls and forty six secondary downfalls. So if one breaks any of the root downfalls then you lose the Bodhisattva Vow. You’ve lost it. So that’s really super duper heavy negative karma. If you break the secondary downfalls that’s also pretty heavy but you don’t actually lose the Bodhisattva vows.

I am not going to go through the root downfalls, you can have a look at them. There are commentaries on them, maybe one day I can give an explanation here at Buddha House on the Bodhisattva vows, there are also books you can read explaining in detail what they mean. One thing that is important to understand is that of the eighteen root downfalls, So to actually break the to create these downfalls that will lead to losing the Bodhisattva vows, has to be four factors operating and if all of those four factors are not present then you don’t actually completely create a downfall and therefore you don’t actually completely lose the vows. So the four factors are firstly break the vow and you think that there is nothing wrong with it. You think it is perfectly okay to break the vow.

Secondly, if you break the vow with the thought that you don’t care about whether you break that vow again in the future. Thirdly, the third factor is that you have to actually kind of enjoy breaking the vow. The last one is having no shame or consideration. So these two mental factors, so if these virtuous mental factors of shame and consideration aren’t present, then this means that one creates one of the downfalls. Actually, to break the root Bodhisattva vows is extremely difficult in other words because you have to have all of those four factors present and if you think about them they’re all pretty disturbed minds.

It’s one thing to break a vow, but to break it thinking there’s nothing wrong. Most people, when they break vows, break it knowing it’s wrong, but they just we just can’t help themselves breaking it. But here it’s where you think, oh it doesn’t matter at all and I’m quite happy to do it in the future. I’m actually enjoying breaking the vow and I have no concern, no shame in the sense I don’t really care what happens to me and I don’t care how it affects other people me breaking this vow. So that’s a pretty deluded mind to get into.

So hopefully we won’t. But there are two of the vows where you don’t have to have these four factors for them to be. And one of them is number nine which is holding distorted or perverted views and number eighteen which is giving up bodhicitta. So of course if you give up bodhicitta then you have lost your vow. So those two downfalls you don’t have to have all the four factors present.

Just very quickly the forty six secondary downfalls I think are very helpful to know about and are very useful guidelines for life because the forty six secondary downfalls are broken down into they’re all related to the six perfections of how one goes against the six perfections because remember when one generates bodhicitta and becomes a bodhisattva what are the main actions or activities of a bodhisattva They are to engage in and perfect the six pāramitā or six perfections of generosity, morality, patience, perseverance, concentration and wisdom. So these remaining forty six secondary downfalls are all in relation to going against practicing the six perfections. So these are very helpful to know even if you don’t take the vows, They are good to know and good to be mindful of in one’s daily life so that one’s life really does become meaningful and one actually does get involved in practicing the six perfections as much as possible. So the first seven are about the practice of generosity. How one can contravene the practice of generosity.

So the first one is not making offerings every day to the Three Jewels. In other words, we should make offerings every day to the Three Jewels of refuge. The easiest way, which was invented by the Tibetans, was to do water bowl offerings because everyone can afford that and it’s a practice of generosity. If we’re too stingy to give things to people every day, surely we can set out a bowl of water to the Buddha. But, of course, the idea is to try and do it properly, not just plonk, but to make it beautiful and visualized and and etcetera, etcetera.

That’s why there is a ritual around it. But, yes, a ritual, which makes it really meaningful and wonderful. As I’ve yeah.

Highly recommend people doing water bowl offerings. I’ve I have tried to teach how to do this here. There are a few people here who know properly now. You could ask them if you like to do this. Very good practice every day.

First thing in the morning, jump up, make offerings to the Buddha. Those first seven are about helping us practice generosity. Then the next numbers eight to sixteen are about the practice of morality so we don’t contravene the practice of morality. Then verse numbers seventeen to twenty these are about the practice of patience. One of which, number nineteen, is refusing to accept the apologies of others.

So that’s not a bodhisattva thing to do. If someone apologizes to us, we have to accept. And that means really accept, not just say, oh, I accept. It means we have to accept. I knew you would ask that.

I didn’t know you would ask that. The Four Noble Disciplines, gosh, I should know, shouldn’t I? The Four Noble Disciplines, they are all around. No, no. The Four Noble Disciplines are along the lines of not getting angry back.

If someone gets angry to you, not returning that anger, not returning insults if someone insults you, not criticizing someone if someone criticizes you. Other words, it’s examples of four negative things being done to you and not returning. A noble being. Not reciprocating negative behavior but particularly in relation to anger and criticism etc. These are the four noble disciplines that a noble being adopts.

They don’t get angry just because someone is angry with them. They don’t criticize people just because they’ve criticized oneself. You don’t insult people just because they insult you don’t return an insult with an insult. I know we are missing one. Yes, I know.

Sorry. Sorry, this is terrible. I should know these back to front. But I don’t. We can check.

No. No. It’s not. No. No.

That doesn’t no. No. No. No. That’s not the no.

Thank you. No. It’s not them. Now because these are all around practicing patience so it’s being one is patient by not getting angry with someone who’s angry at you, not retaliating with insults when someone insults you because also that comes from anger, not reacting with criticism to someone criticizing you, along those lines. These are all contravening the practice of being patient.

Least it gets you thinking doesn’t it? Numbers twenty one to twenty three are all about the parameter of perseverance, enthusiastic and perseverance or joyful effort. The Sanskrit is Vīrya so it’s translated as effort, joyful effort, perseverance, enthusiasm, enthusiastic perseverance. Take your pick. There’s three, only three downfalls related to that or three downfalls.

Two of them, very interesting, wasting time and energy on trivial matters which is trivial matters, TV, footy, cooking programs, all those things. Wasting time and energy and being addicted to frivolous talk. In other words we try and direct our energy more and more into Dharma practice if we can. Next three numbers twenty four, five, and six, downfalls related to developing concentration. The first one is not seeking the means to develop concentration.

In other words what we should do if we want to follow the Bodhisattva way of life is we should try and learn about how to develop single pointed concentration, learn how to focus our mind, meaning firstly just get an intellectual understanding of it, but more importantly, in the sense of actually training the mind to concentrate. This is really, really important because the sooner we learn to develop single pointed concentration, the sooner the realisations will come. Because when we are really able to focus our mind on our practice completely, then everything becomes so much more easy. Also we will develop incredible memory so we will be able to remember all the teachings. Of course if we can remember them we will be able to be mindful of them in our daily life.

We’ll be able to practice just so much more deeply and pervasively. There is another reason from a bodhisattva point of view for developing samadhi because if we manage to do so, then we will eventually become clairvoyant. Bodhisattva needs to be clairvoyant to be able to benefit sentient beings. Need to really you can’t guess what’s going on in people’s minds to really benefit them, to be able to really benefit them and not harm them by making mistakes about what is going on in their life, one needs to be able to read their mind. So there are people who can do that properly.

I’m not talking about those, you know, television guys and ladies and with sparkling clothes and things. Not that lot. I’m talking about people who’ve really developed Samādhi and can read minds. I think almost without yeah. Lama Zopa Rinpoche can definitely read your mind.

There’s many examples of Rinpoche doing this with people. So he knows how to help you because he knows what is going on in your mind. For example, a friend of mine, a French guy, he received a letter from Lama Zopa Rinpoche saying, be very you know, just be really, really careful for the for the next period of you know, I can’t remember. Sometimes these messages are always a little bit cryptic, but, anyway, the letter just came out of the blue from Rinpoche. Rinpoche was in India, and this man was in France.

And he got this letter, and Rinpoche was saying, you know, you need to be really, really careful in the coming days. And three days later, he was bashed up in the street after receiving the letter. There’s many other stories. There’s just one little one. There’s a long distance clairvoyance.

Many people have had the experience of Rinpoche reading their minds. Rinpoche is really a special being but just being able to read minds is no big deal. Lots of not particularly nice people can also read your mind unfortunately. Numbers twenty seven to thirty four are all in relation to developing the perfection of wisdom. Then the last lot, thirty five to forty six, these are all about the ethics of benefiting others because if you remember when we looked briefly into the six perfections, the perfection of generosity which is the first one no, the perfection of morality, the second of the six perfections.

There are three aspects of the perfection of morality, if you remember. Yes? Which are? Somebody? Not Cheryl.

Cheryl knows them. I know she’s looking, she’s cheating. Can anyone think of any one of the three types of morality? Avoiding negative actions of body, speech and mind. Right.

Bodhisattva vows are all about the first practice of morality, the morality of avoiding negative actions. Is generally, it doesn’t fit always completely perfectly but generally one could say that the eighteen root downfalls are in relation to practicing the morality of avoiding negative actions. The first thirty four of the secondary downfalls are in relation to the morality of engaging in virtuous actions and so this last group thirty five to forty six are the third type of morality which is the morality of benefiting others. So it doesn’t mean that you don’t help those who are in need, you break the Bodhisattva vow by not helping those who are in need. So if there are people in need and we don’t help them then we’re contravening.

That’s a downfall of the Bodhisattva Vow. It’s secondary downfall but still very significant. Also if we don’t help people who are sick, if we don’t try to stop the suffering of others, when people are engaging in negative actions we should try to show them that what they’re doing is wrong. Of course there are modifying factors to this one. Bodhisattva has to be very skillful but if we see that someone is engaging in negative behaviour and we have a connection with that person in some way and we know that that person has some connection with us and might will listen to us, usually would tend to listen to us, then have some if we have the bodhisattva vow especially, we have some obligation to try and show that person that what they’re doing is wrong.

Not saying, oh, you’re bad and evil and terrible, but in a compassionate way, skillful way. One shouldn’t just think, it’s got, you know, it’s got nothing to do with me. We’re supposed to use, you know, our dharma knowledge and sort of try and help that person see what that what they’re doing is negative, Harming themselves, harming others. But of course we have to do that very carefully, skillfully in the right situation. It’s not like you just blunder in.

One thing, a bit of advice, can always remember receiving a long, long time ago, which I think is very simple but very wise, is never ever criticize anyone when they’re doing something wrong, while they’re doing something wrong. Because that per the person will never listen to you while they’re doing something wrong, and they’re likely to just get really angry with you. They’ll they’ll get angry, and they won’t listen. And in fact, they’re likely to do more just to prove that, you know, don’t tell me what to do. That’s how our self-cherishing stupid mind works.

You wait till the person stops doing thing, the negative thing, and then when they’re in a relatively peaceful state of mind, then you can say, oh, remember when you did such and such? Then you can try. Then they’ll hit you again as well. That’s when you can try, when the person is in a good state of mind. Certainly not fully engaged in the thing you’re trying to point out is not so good to do.

Anyway, there is no time to go all through those. I just thought it would be very good for people to have a copy of these vows so that they can get to know them and hopefully develop the wish to take these vows at some point if one wants to really engage in the Mahāyāna tradition of the Buddha’s teachings. And this is something that our lamas, the lamas of the tradition, encourage us to do. As I said, even if we don’t take the vows yet, is good to know the vows so that we can try and live according to these guidelines as much as possible. It is really helpful to read them over and over again.

Before we take a break, are there some questions? Remember this is our last session. Apart from the four noble disciplines, what I was trying to answer the question, Kathy’s question. If that is your motivation and while you’re talking about it you maintain that motivation, it’s okay. Because the trouble is sometimes when we talk about those things we talk ourselves into a negative state.

So it kind of goes against what we are trying to do. But if one is just trying to talk about it in a rational, calm way, that’s good. I don’t know what to say. I said, one is actually able to talk about it in a rational manner, in a calm way, then it can be helpful. But as I said, the more you talk about things, the more you can sort of bring up negative there’s a possibility of just reliving the the negativity or bringing up negative things.

So sometimes, maybe it’s not so good to always talk about, and he did that, and I did that, and I feel this, and I feel that. It just seems to reinforce it. A little bit of that sometimes, but all the time I think can be not so helpful perhaps. But to try more of just letting go of those things. They’ve happened.

They’ve gone. You know, just letting it yeah. Mean, it did happen. You don’t deny that those things happened, were unpleasant and hurtful and painful, but it’s gone, you know. But when you start talking about it again and thinking about it, you kind of make it real again to some extent.

Yeah. But if you see the lamas, they get tremendous fun out of everything. Yeah. Just terrific. I have a terrific time.

I yeah. I have the best sense of humor. Okay, so I think we’re going to have a break and then there’s discussion time, last discussion time. There may be even time for a little meditation. But maybe I just in conclusion, because looking at the homework again, I feel a little upset that I don’t seem to have explained what very well what self-cherishing is because people still still seem to think I’m saying anytime you take care of yourself, do anything good for yourself, this is self-cherishing, and this is utterly rubbish.

So, you know, we’re supposed to take care of ourselves, look after ourselves, love ourselves, be kind to ourselves, do good things for ourselves. That’s not self-cherishing. self-cherishing is doing things self-cherishing sounds nice. One has to stop being hung up with the sound of the words. The words sound good but they refer to a very negative state of mind where we are taking care of ourselves by what we were thinking we’re taking care of ourselves by opting out, by taking the easy, happy now way.

And that mind, what that implies is the easy, happy, now mentality is the mentality that engages in negative actions to be happy and to avoid suffering or to stop suffering. That’s self-cherishing and selfish. But practicing the Dharma is for oneself initially. Getting liberated is certainly for oneself but it’s not self-cherishing. It’s not negative.

It’s good. Oh actually, to get complicated, from a Mahāyāna point of view, that’s a very subtle kind of self-cherishing. But when we’re talking about self-cherishing now, the self-cherishing we have to deal with is this very gross one which is totally negative, which doesn’t even benefit ourselves let alone others. It harms ourselves. Even in this life it gets in the way of you know, doing having worldly success.

I wish I could make that clearer, otherwise practicing Dharma would be self-cherishing. Practicing Dharma isn’t self-cherishing but it’s taking care of oneself. Right? And if you think about it, you know, in the in the story the life story of the Buddha, the Buddha left his sorry. This is a terrible story.

Give me time to explain. The Buddha left his wife and son, you know, to become a monk. This looks like a very gross example of self-cherishing, of not caring about his wife and child and just doing something for his own benefit. But in the Buddha’s case, being actually was already a Buddha. He was just manifesting being an ordinary person or so on.

And Prince Siddhartha or the Buddha, the this enlightened being manifesting as Prince Siddhartha knew that by leaving his wife and child, he would go on to become a Buddha and that his wife would become an Arahat and so would his son. He he didn’t do it, you know, with with a negative state of mind. He did it to benefit himself, understanding that benefiting himself would benefit others immensely including his his wife and child. So that’s a very extreme example. But also in the history of what I’m trying to say is in the history of Buddhism many people have left their families and their families didn’t want to become monks and nuns or lay practitioners and their family didn’t want them to do it and the family could say, oh, you’re so selfish.

But actually it wasn’t. They were doing something that was extremely virtuous and and beneficial. I mean, some people can do those things with this completely self selfish mind, but other people are doing it with a very sincere, genuine motivation. So that’s not self-cherishing. Am I is is that is that sort of making some sense?

Yeah. Of self-cherishing. Yeah. Well, also, more likely, the person wouldn’t think of helping them in the future either. Yes.

Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So is having a cup of tea self-cherishing? Any final last questions?

What are the problems and disadvantages? What is the attempt to, what is it I don’t know, I’m asking you. I was just asking, do you think there are? I’m not saying there necessarily are. No.

What you felt were, could be, or felt were or Oh, yeah. Sure. Yes. Yes. Yes.

Yeah. I was wondering whether, because of the question before that the difference between self-cherishing and taking care of self, do you know the difference in heart affects Tonglen. So Yes. Yeah. Well, I tried to talk about that, about how having that you need to have that understanding of one has self-cherishing, but there is the clear mind.

So by getting rid of our self cher we’re not trying to hurt ourselves. We’re trying to hurt the self-cherishing. Yeah. If you’re doing it with the wrong motivation, with the wrong motivation, wrong understanding. But also I mean this may sound a bit strange the purpose of doing Tonglen isn’t to heal other people and take you know it may have that help and benefit or help people temporarily, but the real purpose is to to help undermine our our self-cherishing and to help cultivate our ability to love and feel compassion.

Right? And the purpose and the reason to do that, of course, is to enable us to develop in the spiritual path to cultivate actual bodhicitta so that we can become be in a position where we can be of very deep benefit to others. Because of course healing people’s sickness and helping them become free of poverty and all the problems of this life, these are all great things to do but they’re still ordinary things. Getting rid of a person’s sickness is great but why do they have the sickness in the first place is because there’s this under underlying problem of being in saṃsāra, having ignorance and delusion. So what we really need to do is help people not just get rid of sickness, but the actual deep, deep causes.

And the only way we can do that is to become a Buddha. Yeah? So the the aim of Tonglen isn’t to heal ourselves of sickness now or problems now or help other people. It’s to do this really amazing thing of undermining our self-cherishing and awaken our love and compassion. And not so that we can be a nice person in this life and win popularity contests, but so we can follow the spiritual path.

Right? But it just so happens that Tonglen can benefit others and can temporarily help our own sickness and problems and whatever as well. But that’s not the aim of that’s not the main purpose. Right? Okay, I think that is it folks.

So that is the end of the course. I hope you found it of some benefit and I hope you found things that you can apply in your life. So please do so. That’s the aim. Because even if one thinks bodhicitta is such an enormous concept, something impossible and enlightenment is impossible or something so far in the future and benefiting all sentient beings far in the future.

By training in these practices that we’ve gone through, even if we don’t generate bodhicitta in this life, what we can be sure of if we do these practices, we will become a kinder, more compassionate, loving, generous, peaceful person. And that’s beneficial for this life, you know, future lives. It’s beneficial for ourselves. It’s beneficial for the people around us, for all sentient beings. So in fact these teachings are incredibly practical because at the heart of bodhicitta is giving up self-cherishing.

And if you really look at what one’s own self-cherishing is, it is really destructive. It’s our worst enemy or second worst enemy because of ignorance. But ignorance is hard to understand. self-cherishing is not that difficult to really understand and identify. And one can immediately start to see how it gets in the way of everything, even ordinary stuff, even getting out of bed, as I said.

You know? Yeah. And and and so so and it’s about cherishing others. You know? So that’s something, you know, that’s so important in ordinary life.

Even if you only think of this life, you know, to be able to cherish others is the most is the most wonderful thing to be able to do, the most satisfying complete thing, beneficial thing. And as I I quoted, you know, Rinpoche, Lama Zopa Rinpoche once said that the meaning of life is not to be happy, but to be have a meaning you know, the meaning of life, the purpose of life is to have a meaningful life. This is much better than happiness in the sense of sense pleasure, entertainment, and ego, you know, ego gratification. That doesn’t last. It’s not very fulfilling.

It can be entertaining. You know? Going to Kim and Kanye’s wedding would be very ego gratifying, you know, at some level for some people. But, hey, how meaningful is it? What else are we thinking about and talking about?

What else is more important than that? You look, mean there’s really sad comment on our society that this thing dominates people’s minds. That that is the meaning of life? Gosh. Anyway, now I’ve got yeah.

So we dedicate the merit of not just tonight but the whole course. May this become a cause for us to be able to live a bodhisattva way of life more and more. To be, as Lama Zopa used to say, baby bodhisattvas so that we can eventually generate bodhicitta and through that achieve enlightenment for the sake of all kind suffering mother sentient beings. Through the merits of these virtuous actions, may I quickly attain the state of the Guru Buddha and lead all living beings without exception into that enlightened state. May the precious bodhi mind not yet born arise and grow.

May that born have no decline but increase forevermore. Since the end of the teaching, the tradition is not to finish with prostrations because that sort of creates a sort of open ended situation and so it becomes auspicious to meet again. And anyway, so the next DB course, I don’t think the actual date has been fixed yet because it depends on while I’m away in Spain. Mentioned this scholar, Tibetan scholar, Australian Buddhist Buddhist scholar Ian Coghlan will be coming to teach and he will be doing the next DB module on the wisdom of emptiness. So this is a fantastic module to study.

And by someone who was a monk for many many years lived at Sera Je Monastery and did all the Geshe studies. He finished the whole so he really should be called Geshe Ian but he actually never got the title because of some complication because you have to not only do debating but you have to write and do a written exam and he wasn’t able to write Tibetan well enough to do the exam. But apart from that he should have got a Geshe degree. So he is really has a great knowledge of the Buddhadharma. So he will be teaching that but we’re not sure exactly when that’s going to start.

Book for that so there’ll be a bit of a break. Anyway please come for the retreat on this Sunday. Bring your book and everything and fill out the forms, the couple of forms and please if you can bring some nice vegetarian food to share. And just finally again sorry to bombard you but if you can really think about coming to Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s teachings in Bendigo in October, September, late September, October. Unfortunately, it’s gonna be very expensive, but save your pennies because it’s worth it even if you just go for a short time.

If you can’t attend that, Rinpoche will be coming for one day to Buddha House on the twenty ninth of October thirtieth thirtieth of October. Rinpoche will be giving an initiation here that evening, but before that Rinpoche will give a talk, a Dharma talk, which will be open to everyone. So that will be for several hours because Rinpoche’s talks are always at least several hours. It may not stop in fact. So really you definitely should come for that.

No excuse. Put that in your diary now and make sure to come Because really the chance to hear, to be in the presence of a truly great practitioner of the tradition is very rare, special and immensely beneficial and inspiring if one has the karma to connect with the lama. Not everyone does, but Rinpoche is definitely whether one see you know, from your side or not, he is definitely the real thing. He is there’s no question of that. Absolutely.

He is one of the he is one of the most admired lamas of the Gelug tradition these days and someone whose holiness the Dalai Lama definitely highly respects and relies on to help him in what he does. Yeah. And he’s been teaching people, non Buddhists, us Westerners and non Westerners for a he’s dedicated his life to that. So he’s a very exceptional being, a really great practitioner. Okay now I stop.

Okay so I hope to see you in August. Oh, Sunday.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
eight Mahayana precepts thegchen sojong (Tib)
One-day vows to abandon killing; stealing; lying; sexual contact; intoxicants; high seats; eating at the wrong time; and singing, dancing and wearing perfumes and jewelry. LYWA
five lay vows panchashila (Skt); ge nyen gi dompa nga (Tib)
The precepts taken by lay Buddhist practitioners for life: to abstain from killing, stealing, lying, sexual misconduct and taking intoxicants. LYWA
four noble disciplines
Avoiding responding to: 1) anger with anger; 2) physical harm with physical harm; 3) criticism with criticism; and 4) verbal argument with verbal argument. These are said to distinguish real practitioners and are part of the secondary bodhisattva vows. LYWA
pratimoksha vows pratimokshasamvara (Skt); so thar gyi dompa (Tib)
The various levels of individual liberation vows for lay and ordained, including the five lay vows, and the novice vows and full ordination that monks and nuns take. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
three types of morality tshultrim sum (Tib)
Three aspects of the perfection of morality: the morality of restraining from wrong-doing, the morality of accumulating merit and the morality of benefiting sentient beings. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top