2 h 29 min · 7,840 words · 2014 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 149-minute meditation day session, Venerable Thubten Dondrub guides practitioners through two foundational practices for generating bodhicitta—the heartfelt commitment to achieve enlightenment for the sake of all beings. The morning begins with calm-abiding meditation on the breath, grounding the mind before moving into analytical work. The core teaching focuses on equanimity: recognizing how self-cherishing distorts our perception of others into friends, enemies, and strangers, and how this bias blocks love and compassion. Dondrub walks through a direct three-person visualization exercise, tracing how these categories shift based on circumstance rather than inherent truth. The session then pivots to equalizing self with others—reflecting on how every sentient being, like ourselves, fundamentally wishes happiness and fears suffering. Finally, he examines the faults of self-cherishing (how it activates anger and attachment, keeping us trapped in suffering) and the vast benefits of cherishing others instead. Throughout, Dondrub emphasizes that these are not intellectual exercises but mind-training practices meant to build positive imprints for future realization. The teaching concludes with a discussion on motivation, karma, and how to avoid overwhelm when confronting worldly suffering. Suited for those new to bodhicitta practice or already initiated into Mahāyāna Buddhism.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 01 – DB Bodhicitta Meditation Day AM.mp3
UUID: 7af3ae76-46ef-4c9b-9cbb-f18781d2f4c8
Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub
Collection: DB Bodhicitta (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Date: 2014 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 149.0 minutes
Words: ~7,836
So I’m not sure if there are any people completely new this morning, but just in case there is, what we’re going to do is, in this one hour session, we’ll divide it into two segments. And in the first segment we’ll do some breathing meditation which helps develop a calmer clearer mind, and helps us to begin to gain some mastery over our minds so that we can then really work on subduing our disturbing thoughts, cultivating our positive potentials. And so as part of that, we’ll check our posture and our motivation and there’s a traditional prayer that’s on the sheet in front of you. So we’ll say that if you feel comfortable to join in with that. And then I’ll ring the bell at the end.
And at the end of that segment, we’ll take a three minute silent break where people can stand up and stretch if they feel so inclined. And then in the second segment, we’ll do some analytical meditation. And this time, we’ll do it on the topic of equanimity rather than our normal mind is to see people as either friend, enemy, or stranger. This seems a very natural thing to do. It may be it’s a very common thing to do, but it unfortunately, if we really want to develop our our our potential for love and compassion, we have to overcome this and try and develop a a mind of equanimity.
So yeah. Okay. So we’ll do a little bit of meditation on that in the second segment. So, we begin by sitting comfortably in the correct posture as much as possible. So particularly paying attention to the positioning of our our spine so that the vertebrae are well aligned one above the other.
So just place your legs in whatever way is comfortable. If you’re sitting in a chair, it’s best not to lean against the back of the chair, but hold your back upright. And placing the right hand on top of the left of the thumbs lightly touching, resting in your lap, close to your body, but so that your elbows and upper arms are just a little bit away from the sides of your body. So if you lift your shoulders up and back a little bit and then relax them and then straighten your head, tuck your chin in slightly, we can position our head so that it’s not tilted down or lifted too high. So have your mouth lightly closed, your the tip of your tongue resting at the back of the top row of teeth at the palate.
It’s okay to have your eyes closed, but much, much better to learn to meditate with your eyes just a little bit open, just very slightly, directing your gaze just a very short distance down in front of you, but without actively looking rather having a a passive unfocused gaze. So then just check your posture very briefly by moving your awareness from the crown of your head down through your body. As you do so, you may notice points of tension, and you may notice that tension tends to exist or continue because one is unconsciously pulling inwards, holding on. So by simply being aware of that process, one can begin to gently let go of it. So then having prepared our body, it’s really important to prepare our mind to meditate, checking and correcting our motivation.
So the whole basis of Buddhist practice is recognizing that it is our own mind which is the source of all our experience, particularly the experiences of happiness and suffering. The more we begin to understand and experience that, realize that, it becomes obvious that if we want less suffering, more happiness, we have to take care of our mind. To do so, we need a really complete method, an unbetrayable method, especially if we begin to understand that our mind is something that doesn’t just simply exist in this life, but goes beyond this life. It never ceases. It’s always going to give us experiences.
And if we don’t work with our mind, it will always bring us suffering. So we really need a complete, perfect, unbetrayable method to work with our mind. Such a method can only come from a perfect source, which we recognize as the enlightened mind of the Buddha. So this is why we entrust ourselves to the Buddha, the Dharma of the Buddha’s teachings, and the Sangha, the great practitioners of those teachings. So this is the first basis of preparing our mind, generating that mind of refuge, of trust in the triple gem, and committing to rely on the Buddha’s methods to work with one’s mind.
And then why do we need to work with our mind? It’s not just for the benefit of this life. It’s not just to get a good rebirth, just to free ourselves completely forever from suffering, but it’s to benefit others. That’s the real purpose of working on our mind so that we can stop harming others and being of great benefit to them, especially when we realize how we are deeply interconnected with every sentient being. We always have been, always will be.
We depend on their kindness and support for our mere existence, for all our good qualities, for all our good experiences. We totally depend on their kindness and especially the kindness of a mother which we’ve received from every sentient being life after life. Firstly, think of the Buddha directly in front of you as the source of refuge, inspiration and guidance reminding us of our Buddha potential, encouraging us to realize it. At the same time, try and have a strong sense of all sentient beings surrounding you, starting with your mother on your left, father on your right, family, friends, and helpers behind you, harmers in front, and then as much as possible, opening one’s heart and mind to an awareness of all other beings trapped in cyclic existence, recognizing that all of them are basically only kind but only suffering. So think that no matter what, I must use this in all future lives to realize my Buddha potential, achieve enlightenment for their sake.
And so for this reason, I’ll do this meditation this morning. I go for refuge until I am enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma and the Supreme Assembly. By my practice of giving and other perfections, may I become a Buddha to benefit all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Supreme Assembly. By my practice of giving and other perfections, may I become a Buddha to benefit all sentient beings.
I go for refuge until I am enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma and the Supreme Assembly. By my practice of giving and other perfections may I become a Buddha to benefit all sentient beings. So then think that the Buddha in front of you is very pleased with your motivation and shows this by now coming to the crown of your head. When directly above your crown, imagine that the Buddha turns facing the same direction as yourself. And then remains on the crown of your head for the rest of the meditation session, creating a protective environment in which to meditate and constantly blessing the mind.
So having prepared our mind in this way to meditate, we now direct our mind to the object of meditation, which is our breath. So just focus your mind as much as possible on your breathing. Don’t change it in any way. Just simply observe the breath coming in and going out. And let everything which is not the breath fade away.
Don’t focus on it. All thoughts and concerns about the past or future, just let go of them. Just let your mind stay with the breath as much as possible, particularly focusing on the subtle sensation in and around your nostrils as the breath comes in and goes out. It can be helpful to count the breaths. So allow counting one in breath and out breath as one breath, trying to follow, for example, eleven consecutive breaths.
But every time the mind gets distracted into any way or becomes dull and sleepy, then one needs to start the count from the beginning and keep doing this over and over again without any thought of expectation or disappointment. So just before we start the meditation, just briefly to explain in developing equanimity, what we’re trying to do is reduce our aversion to people we dislike, overcome our indifference to people who we think of as strangers, and especially with friends. We’re not trying to reduce or stop our liking of our friends, but our attachment to them. This is the point. Right.
And the purpose is so that we can see everyone as a friend, not just friends, but strangers, but even even the enemy. That just because people react to us in one way, we don’t have to react to them in a particular way. We can train to have a positive outlook towards everyone so our mind remains stable. Okay. Again, we can begin by sitting comfortably in the correct posture as much as possible.
And then reaffirming as much as we can the bodhicitta motivation wishing to cultivate our mind eliminating all the negative qualities cultivating, developing fully our positive potentials until enlightenment is achieved so that in that state we can be of perfect, lasting, continuous benefit to all kind suffering mother sentient beings. As part of that we can recall, remember the Buddha above the crown of our head. So then we can begin by reflecting why it is so important to develop equanimity, Not only for the benefit of this life, but especially if we understand the Buddha’s teachings about the nature of our mind, how it continues, how we are trapped in cyclic existence along with all other beings In order to free ourselves from cyclic existence, in order to develop our Buddha nature and to be of benefit to others, we have to develop equanimity. So just consider that the basic message of the Buddha is that the source of all our suffering, the cause of all our suffering are our own negative states of mind. The Buddha discovered that the real source of every kind of happiness, well-being, mental happiness, is our own mind, our virtuous states of mind, particularly love, compassion, wisdom and so on.
But when we don’t have equanimity, without equanimity we have attachment to friends, aversion to enemies or harmers, indifference to strangers. So attachment and anger are negative states of mind. They are the actual source of our suffering. They keep us in cyclic existence, And they bring suffering. So for this reason, we we need to reduce our attachment to friends, aversion to so called enemies or harmers.
But also, since our virtuous minds are the source of our happiness, the more we can cultivate love, compassion, the more we will be at peace in every possible way. But our attachment to friends, aversion to enemies, prevents the development of our love and compassion. And consider also what seems quite harmless, our indifference to strangers, the vast majority of beings. That indifference is also a huge obstacle to developing our love and compassion, which are the very source of all happiness. So we need equanimity.
So now we can train our mind in developing equanimity by selecting three people we know. So firstly, a stranger, someone we know but are not close to in any way. We don’t particularly dislike them. We don’t particularly like them. We just know of their existence, but don’t really involve ourselves with them.
Then think of someone who is a friend, not a really strong, very, very close friend, just someone that you are friendly with. And then think of someone who you dislike. Not someone you have a very, very strong aversion to, but someone who you have some dislike towards. So imagine those three people in front of you right now. And then just try and look at them objectively and see that these three people are just three human beings.
And each of them wants to be happy and doesn’t want to suffer. They’re same in being human. They’re same in not wanting suffering. Same in wanting happiness. And yet, I see these three people quite differently.
The stranger, I tend to ignore, not concerned with their wish for happiness suffering. The friend, I involve myself with, I want them to be happy. Don’t want them to suffer. And the so called enemy or harmer, I reject. So why is this?
Why do I do this? Why do they appear so differently to me? So try and check up honestly to see that despite whatever clear judgments we have of other people, recognizing their good and bad qualities and so on, try to see that to a large extent, the reason we see these three people in these three different ways is due to my own self-cherishing. Think of your friend. This human being appears as a friend, not stranger or enemy, because what they say and do fits with my own self-cherishing.
The friend makes me feel good, secure, comfortable. So therefore, I see them as good, as friend. The person I dislike doesn’t make me feel good, doesn’t make me feel secure or comfortable, is somehow threatening, doesn’t go along with my self-cherishing thought at all. I don’t like that. So that person appears as unpleasant, unlikable, negative, even an enemy.
And check how this person who we see as a stranger is someone who doesn’t really threaten myself cherishing, doesn’t go or doesn’t particularly go along with it as well. So I tend to ignore them. I remain indifferent to them. So they appear as a stranger. So just consider how ridiculous it is ridiculous it is to base one’s relationships on self-cherishing, which in fact is our most destructive state of mind, has been the source of all our suffering during beginningless time, That all the beings who have achieved enlightenment have completely given up the self-cherishing thought and developed the thought cherishing others.
Think in relation to the friend that all problems between friends doesn’t occur because of the affection, the love one has for another person. Is because of the attachment, that neurotic dependence and the expectation that goes with it. Consider with the stranger that my indifference is blocking the potential to feel affection, compassion, a sense of connection with this person. Believing in myself cherishing the the lies it tells me. I see this person as a stranger.
I don’t get to know them. This person is a potential friend, but my self-cherishing doesn’t let it happen. And think that because of my self-cherishing being upset by this the so called enemy or harmer, an unpleasant person, anger, my dislike, my aversion to that person is harming me far more than it’s harming the other person. My negative minds directed to that person are causing me suffering now, creating negative imprints in the mind that are going to bring me more suffering in the future. So then particularly reflect that these three people at some point, were all strangers to me.
I didn’t know them. But then I met them, and in one moment, because one of them went along with my self-cherishing, they became my friend. In that one moment, and then my mind grasps that this is my permanent friend. They will always be like this. I will always like them.
They will always like me. And because we think of them as permanent friend, we’re always friendly with them. In one moment, the person who was a stranger didn’t go against myself cherishing, didn’t support it. So in that moment, I labeled them stranger, and they stayed a stranger, became permanent stranger. And I remained.
I continued to be indifferent to them. And in one moment, another person went against my self-cherishing. And in that moment, I see them as an enemy, a harmer, and they become this permanent in my mind, they become this permanent bad person. And I continue to think of them in a negative way. I get stuck in these patterns of behavior, believing, grasping at permanence when nothing is permanent.
Everything is changing. Just reflect how we all know within this life, people who’ve experienced friendships that have gone wrong, friends become enemies, strangers become friends, Countries that were at war cease to have wars become friends. And yet my mind still grasps, this is my permanent friend. This is permanent stranger, permanent enemy. It’s not true.
Especially try and have a far more expansive perspective and consider this stranger in front of me. In past lives, it it logically follows in past lives this person at some point was my good friend, was my good friend in many lives, and will be in the future. In fact, it’s been my mother countless times. So why am I so indifferent just now? And consider the friend.
In future lives, will become a stranger. In past lives, it logically follows they could have been my worst enemy many times. So why be so attached right now? I can like them, appreciate them right now, but why be so attached? And if we think of that person in front of us who bothers us so much right now, in past lives, they’ve been a best friend to me, many times.
And this will happen again in future lives. So why grasp so strongly at this aversion to them right now? So we can bring the meditation to a conclusion by trying to make a strong determination to be more and more mindful in daily life, to practice equanimity rather than grasping so strongly at friend, enemy, stranger, grasping at permanence, trying to have an open spacious mind. Being mindful that, yes, people some people are more friendly to me than others. Some are like strangers.
Some may wish me harm. But from my side, I can still wish them happiness. From my side, I can have an open mind, a mind that sees that everything can change. So then recall the Buddha on one’s crown, imagining the Buddha extremely pleased with your practice and shows this by now dissolving into blissful golden light. And then imagine that that blissful light pours down into you through the crown of your head, blessing your mind to be able to eventually gain a complete realization of the mind of perfect equanimity.
So then we can dedicate our merits that we are able to actually achieve equanimity as the basis for awakening all good qualities so that we can achieve enlightenment. Due to the merits of these virtuous actions, may I quickly attain the state of the Guru Buddha and lead all living beings without exception into that enlightened state. May the supreme jewel bodhicitta that has not arisen arise and grow, and may that which has arisen not diminish but increase more and more. Thank you very much. Don’t know if anyone has any questions I can help with.
Perfectly clear. It was all per good. Good. Okay. Okay.
So for this session, we’ll do I’m sort of going backwards. Normally, we talk about Asaṇga and then Śāntideva but this morning or today we’re going to meditate on Śāntideva first and Asaṇga later. So in this session we’ll do little meditation on equalizing self with others. So if you remember in Śāntideva’s method this is the first of the four causes for generating bodhicitta on the basis of developing equanimity, is seeing friend, enemy, stranger as equal, having equal attitude to those kinds of beings, then we need to equalize ourselves with all other sentient beings. Okay.
So that’s what we’ll do and then we’ll take a short break and then we’ll do a little meditation on the faults of self-cherishing and the benefits of cherishing others. We have to do all of that in half an hour. But since you’re all great meditators, there will be no problem. See, actually, what we’re what we’re really doing in the is not really doing analytical meditation or it’s pseudo analytical meditation. It’s more like because it’s so brief, it’s like a review.
It’s a quarter glance meditation. Because to do real analytical meditation, you need we need to spend much longer reflecting on the points. You’re really letting the mind go into them. But there just isn’t that time. But anyway, it’s good to do this.
This is kind of Junior analytical meditation. Okay, so we begin by sitting comfortably in the correct posture as much as possible. Then then doing the nine round breathing exercise just for a very short time to establish a calm, neutral state of mind. You can make that breathing exercise more powerful by combining it with the visualization of, with the in breaths in the cycle, breathing in white light. Imagine that’s very calming, soothing, brings great clarity into the mind, stillness.
And with each out breath, imagine breathing out all agitation existing in your mind right now, but all causes of that, all suffering, all disturbing thoughts, negative imprints, and so on in the form of black smoke. So then on the basis of that neutral mind we develop a very powerful virtuous mind of refuge in the triple gem. Visualizing the Śākyamūni Buddha on the lion throne, lotus sun and moon in front of you. And having that commitment, that determination to take care of one’s mind, totally relying on the triple gem to do so. And then cultivating the thought that I’m going to take care of my mind until enlightenment is achieved for the benefit of all sentient beings.
I need to achieve enlightenment not only for my own sake but to be in the position to repay the kindness of all mother sentient beings. So as you visualize the Buddha in front of you, try and have a strong sense of all sentient beings surrounding you, starting with your parents on either side. And in order to achieve enlightenment I have to awaken all positive qualities and a very powerful basis for being able to do this is to be able to see the equality between myself and every other being in existence. There’s no real difference between myself and any other sentient being. So realizing this, all positive qualities can awaken.
So for the sake of all sentient beings, I will do this meditation on equalizing self with others. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, Dharma, the supreme assembly. By the merits of practicing giving and other perfections, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings? So thinking the Buddha is very pleased with us, we imagine the Buddha firstly the lion throne dissolves into the light, into light absorbing up into the lotus sun and moon. The Buddha seated on these now comes to the above the crown of our head, turning to face the same direction as our self.
And for the rest of the session, we imagine the Buddha remains there, creating a protective environment and continuously blessing our mind. So having prepared the body and mind in this way, make strong determination to keep your mind really focused on the topic, not letting it not letting the mind become dull and sleepy or distracted by sounds, feelings in the body, and particularly by one’s own thoughts. As soon as you detect any of those things, be determined to let go, bring the mind back to reflecting on this topic. So just begin by reflecting that because my mind right now is under the control of self grasping ignorance and self-cherishing, I have this wrong view of myself as being separate from others, more important. And and that that attitude, that mindset is the source of so much suffering.
It blocks the arising of my positive potentials. It acts as a condition for my negative states of mind to arise. On the other hand, by seeing the equality between myself and others, there is that sense of immediate connection with any other being. And therefore, feeling connected, there is a sense of, affection, the possibility of developing love, compassion, bodhicitta, and so on towards that being. So just reflect how if I go beyond just superficial appearances, because there are so many there are so many differences between myself and others at one level.
But if I focus on those, that’s the basis for attachment, aversion, indifference. What I need to do to let go of those negative minds and waken my positive ones is to focus on what are the essential samenesses, likenesses, similarities? And one of the most fundamental is to check how despite all those differences in behavior and appearance, ways of thinking, underlying all of that, what motivates all of that is the wish to be happy. What other people do, they do it believing or because believing it will make them happy because they want to be happy just like me. The essential motivation is just the same.
The way of thinking, the the way of acting may be very different, but the inner motivation, just the same. Especially try to consider how this not only applies to every kind of human being all over the world, but to all sentient beings. The only other ones that we can directly see are the beings in the animal realm. They seem so different from me, but there is something essentially the same. They just want to be happy, just like me.
Is it really possible to think that my wish for happiness is somehow significantly different, better, superior than the wish for happiness existing in the mind of any other human being, any sentient being. It is such a basic wish. How can one make distinct you distinguish the basic wish for happiness in the mind of one person from that fundamental wish for happiness in the mind of another? And looking from another perspective, the the ways of thinking, behaving, so on of others appear so different from myself. Yet underlying all of that is that incredibly fundamental, basic wish not to suffer.
If I check, no sentient being wants to suffer. There, they try as much as possible to avoid suffering just like me. And consider that whether sentient beings are experiencing obvious suffering or happiness, success or failure, whether they’re human or in the lower realms or in the god realms. Every sentient being is controlled by ignorance and disturbing thoughts, karma and delusion, just like me. Every sentient being, whether they’re human, in the lower realms, in the god realms, is subject to old age, sickness, and death, has the potential to experience all the sufferings of the six realms of cyclic existence, just like me.
And consider that although my mind is obscured, the true nature of my mind is pure, perfect, complete. I possess Buddha nature. And that’s true for every other sentient being. Their minds are obscured, but even the beings in the hell realms right now, their minds are pure, perfect, complete, possessing Buddha nature just like me. So then for the last part of the meditation, just simply focus in a simple but direct way on being aware that right now, in the very center of your heart, the center of your being, right now and at all times, there is the thought of I.
That I that doesn’t want to suffer, that is so desperate to be happy. That I which we grasp at so strongly, but is which is so fragile. Just be aware of that in a very simple way now, that dominating your mind, there is always that thought of I. And as you hold on to that awareness, also be aware that that same sense of I exists in the minds of everyone in this room, everyone in this city, in this country, on this planet, in the minds of all the beings in the animal realm on this planet, in the minds of every sentient being throughout the universe. So then bring the meditation to a conclusion by making a strong determination to be more and more mindful in daily life, not to focus on the differences, to grasp at those, but to be mindful to focus on what is the same, to remember that that very intimate thing that we know about everyone, friend, enemy, and stranger, That they don’t want to suffer.
They only want to be happy just like me. So just take a couple of minutes silent break. So this time we’ll do a little meditation on the faults of self-cherishing and the benefits of cherishing others. Again we sit in a comfortable position, generate that good motivation, the bodhicitta motivation as much as possible and remembering the Buddha on the crown of our head. So we begin by reflecting that because, my mind is, obscured by self grasping ignorance, that the the natural wish for happiness, meaning that pure, perfect, lasting experience, that natural wish for happiness becomes distorted by self-cherishing into just craving and grasping at what entertains us, distracts us from our suffering, something that we can achieve quickly and easily.
So if we check the nature of the self-cherishing thought, it is based on ignorance. It’s not understanding, experiencing who we are correctly. It is grasping at the wrong view of self as something truly inherently existing. And the nature of self-cherishing is to try and build up that sense of I, protect it by following attachment and and anger. Believing attachment is gonna bring me afflicted desire and attachment are gonna bring me happiness.
Anger is going to protect my happiness. Being under the control of those disturbing thoughts, we also follow self-cherishing leads us into pride and jealousy, fears and worries. Reflect, try to get some understanding that the I that does exist, I that do exist, that I that does exist arises depending on the body and mind. Especially if the mind is suffering, then I am suffering. Your I is not something it’s not the mind, but it’s not separate from the mind.
So when we follow self-cherishing, we’re caught up in anger and attachment, pride and jealousy. These are disturbing thoughts, painful thoughts. So the mind is suffering when controlled by them. Therefore, I am suffering. So self-cherishing thinks it’s bringing happiness, thinks it’s protecting us from suffering, but it’s doing the very opposite.
It is disturbing the mind. It is creating suffering and the causes of suffering, of poor suffering in the future. Check how the nature of our self-cherishing, its very nature, is to focus on what appears to be happiness and its causes just in the present moment. What is going to bring me happiness right now? What is the quickest, easiest way for me to be happy right now?
It doesn’t think about the consequences of our actions. What is the quickest, easiest way to stop my suffering right now? It doesn’t think about the consequences of those actions because it wants the result now, quickly, easily. And the nature of self-cherishing is to believe that happiness is out there. The source of my suffering is out there, not within me.
Check how our self-cherishing leads us to be selfish, short sighted, fearful, anxious, lazy, self indulgent, narrow minded. It leads to feelings of self importance. We become desperate for others’ approval, susceptible to flattery, and preoccupied with our own private predicament. It leads to self indulgence on the one hand and suicide on the other, whatever is quick and easy. Check how the gross self-cherishing thought leads us to only think of this life, leads us to create all the ten non virtuous actions which bring every kind of suffering, leads us to be caught up in the eight worldly concerns, that are a huge hindrance to practicing the Dharma.
Trapped in gross self-cherishing, we are not even able to create the causes of a good rebirth, let alone free ourselves from saṃsāra. It’s the greatest obstacle to developing loving kindness, compassion, the six perfections, and bodhicitta. Apart from ignorance, the gross self-cherishing is our worst enemy. But also consider that there is a very subtle kind of self-cherishing which is not a negative state of mind but it’s that mind seeking only one’s own liberation. So from a Mahāyāna point of view, this also has a huge disadvantage.
If we follow that subtle self-cherishing, only seeking our own freedom from saṃsāra, we’ll never be able to generate bodhicitta, will never achieve enlightenment, will never be able to repay the kindness of mother sentient beings. Following the subtle self-cherishing thought has the huge disadvantage that mother sentient beings will continue to suffer in saṃsāra. So then consider if self-cherishing has so many disadvantages or only has disadvantages and especially the gross self-cherishing is a completely negative state of mind that keeps us trapped in cyclic existence, then surely the very opposite state of mind of cherishing others cherishing others more than self must be incredibly virtuous, must only have advantages. Reflect how when we’re controlled by self-cherishing, which we follow believing it’s gonna bring us happiness, it actually activates all our negative states of mind of attachment, anger and so on. But when we cherish others more than self, in order to cherish others, that in fact activates all our virtuous states of mind.
Love, compassion, patience, tolerance, sensitivity, generosity and so on. So those virtuous states of mind naturally, by their very nature, bring peace and happiness, contentment, well-being, satisfaction into the mind. So when the mind is in that state, I that arises depending on the mind am happy at peace, experiencing well-being and contentment. Although I am cherishing others more than self, by doing it, I experience happiness. And I am creating the causes of more happiness.
Just like all the ten non virtuous actions are motivated by self-cherishing, if you check all the virtuous actions of avoiding killing and and even going beyond that of saving life, nurturing life, avoiding stealing and going beyond that and practicing generosity, and so on. If we check all the virtuous actions, are always motivated by the mind cherishing other. So bring the meditation to a conclusion by making a strong determination to be more and more mindful in daily life of one’s own self-cherishing thought, to be sensitive to it arising and being mindful of how harmful it is, having the courage, the wisdom, the compassion not to follow it as much as possible. And be determined to be more and more mindful to have the courage, wisdom, and compassion to practice cherishing others, cherishing others more and more, cherishing others more than self. When we’re cherishing others more than self, then we are really taking care of ourself.
Then recall the Buddha on one’s crown, imagining the Buddha extremely pleased. And the Buddha shows this by now dissolving into blissful golden light. And that blissful light pours down into you through the crown of your head, blessing your mind to be able to gain a complete realization of the the all pervasive harm of the self-cherishing thought and the all pervasive vast benefit of cherishing others. So then we dedicate the merits. Through the merits of these virtuous actions, may I quickly attain the state of a Guru Buddha and lead all living beings without exception into that enlightened state.
May the precious bodhicitta, not yet born, arise and grow. May that born have no decline but increase forevermore. According to our schedule, it’s now discussion time. I don’t think there’s not much point dividing into discussion groups. We could just have a large group discussion question and answer.
This is your last chance to ask questions on this topic. Otherwise we just sit and look at each other for half an hour. Yes. Yes. Yes.
Yes. Well, maybe that’s a anyone in the Theravāda tradition has the potential to generate bodhicitta but this sounds politically incorrect but the Theravāda tradition is preserving and emphasizing the Buddha’s teachings about achieving your own liberation. That is the is the essence of the Theravāda teachings to how to achieve liberation from Samsāra, not how to achieve enlightenment. So there are no teachings in the Theravāda tradition about how to generate bodhicitta or even encouraging one to do so. I mean that’s quite literally true.
That’s not a criticism. That’s just simply fact. Whereas the Mahāyāna tradition emphasizes the teachings that the Buddha gave about achieving enlightenment and therefore generating bodhicitta and how to generate bodhicitta. Yeah. So those teachings are preserved in the Mahāyāna tradition, not in the Theravāda tradition.
Because one of the distinguishing features of the two paths or the two traditions is that according to the philosophical underpinning of the Theravāda tradition, there is the view that only a rare handful of sentient beings has the potential to become a Buddha. And Śākyamūni was one of them. So there’s no point so they do accept a bodhisattva path, but it’s only something that a unique group of people are able to follow. So there’s no emphasis in the Theravāda tradition of teaching that path because they say it’s pointless because most people, ninety nine percent of people don’t have the potential to follow it. Whereas the Mahāyāna tradition says every sentient being has Buddha nature, Buddha potential.
Every sentient being has the potential to become a Buddha. So that’s that’s that’s what’s emphasized. So since we have, try and become a Buddha. Don’t just go for a liberation. Try and become a Buddha.
Because if you try, you will. I mean, you’ve gotta keep trying. Not try for a little bit, but keep trying. We will become a Buddha. So in the Lotus Sūtra particularly it says, every sentient being has Buddha nature.
Yes, yes, that’s what it’s all about. Yes, we’re trying to build up imprints. I mean that’s why we meditate. Would say that’s the main reason to meditate is to make imprints. With all due respect and without trying to be too depressing, I don’t think it’s very realistic to expect that we’re going to gain many realizations in this life from our meditations.
Not to say that we won’t, but probably not many. But what we can do is make imprints for the realizations to come in future lives. I’m not saying we won’t get realizations because it depends on the individual and how much we practice in this life, how much we purify our mind, accumulate merit, and how much imprints we’ve got from past lives built up already, etcetera, etcetera. Yeah, but basically we’re trying to put imprints in our mind because we’ve got huge piles, piles and piles and piles of negative imprints. We also do have positive imprints but we need many, many more.
So that’s what we’re trying to do. That’s what the tulku system is all about, capturing someone’s karma as quickly as possible. All those positive imprints can be built on and not lost in a sense. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Sure. There are many, many factors. In general, don’t get too depressed. There are many factors.
One may start old but the motivation may be very strong and one has all sorts of experience that can be very helpful. A young person may have many positive imprints but also there’s a lot of exciting things to do when one is young, when one is old. Those things aren’t so exciting! worrying. So anyway, it it’s you know, yeah, it can Yes The The throwing has already happened, right?
We have been thrown into this life. Some karma has thrown us here. There’s lots of lots of them. Yeah. I mean, they’re bubbling away each day, a ripening as far as I understand.
Yeah. Now this is getting too complicated. Ripening quicker. Yes, I suppose you can say that. In the teachings it says, Just to be able to meet the Dharma and practice and have teachings and teachers and various things, one is using up.
For example, by attending a teaching, that is creating good karma. That is good karma, therefore it’s creating good imprints, positive imprints. But to be able to attend a teaching, that is the ripening of some good karma. So one is using up good karma but also creating some. Whereas when you eat a nice plate of pasta or something, that’s using up some good karma.
But you’re not creating any good karma eating it. I didn’t get to that yet. Don’t jump in. That’s why we say the prayer and try to offer the food to the Buddha and sentient beings to create otherwise eating is just attachment. And the more you eat, the more yeah.
That’s an important thing to really understand. Every good experience we have, every good worldly experience, like being able to eat, have nice vase of flowers, nice clothes, nice house, car, blah blah blah. All of this is due to good karma. But as we experience it, we’re using it up, and we’re not. The mere experiencing it is not creating any good karma, actually, possibly because of our attachment and sort of like pride.
Look, I’ve got a bowl of nice flowers. You don’t. You know, we’re creating negative karma. Whereas in practicing Dharma, we are using up good karma but we are creating some as well. That is why we need to try and transform ordinary activities, worldly things, much as possible with the right motivation.
The best way to do that is to try and do it with the bodhicitta thought. Not just blah blah, I am doing this for all sentient beings. Anyone can say that or anyone can even think it. It has to be sincere, genuine, really trying to drink a cup of water for the sake of all sentient beings. Could you clarify a bit more?
In what way or what are examples of your bodhicitta stuff becoming overwhelming? If you don’t mind, I don’t In the movie. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, it is overwhelming.
Yeah. I don’t know what to say because I’m I’m I’m thick as a brick, cold as a block of ice. I don’t have this warm Yes. I don’t know what to say. No.
Wait. Wait. Okay. Go on. Discussion group please.
People can comment. Yeah. One does have to be very careful about that because it’s a great danger of getting just overwhelmed by how much suffering there is in the world even among people close. Yeah. Yeah.
Are you actually just talking about films, not people? What they represent? Any other? I don’t know if this is actually the same thing but in relation to also what Cheryl says about understanding its people’s karma, it’s also we have to accept that we, as we are, can’t solve everyone’s and take everyone’s suffering away. Yeah.
I mean, this is the ultimate aim, only a Buddha can do that. It’s it’s about I I think one of the reasons why, you know, all all the suffering makes us so upset and overwhelming is feeling that we can’t do anything about it and sort of feeling as though we to accept we can’t at the moment. Don’t know exactly how His Holiness puts it extremely well at this point but I can’t exactly remember how how well he puts it. But it’s it’s along the lines that the real nature of compassion isn’t doesn’t make you like this hopeless upset thing because some I’m not criticizing you because this is something we all experience. But somehow that that that compassion that is kind of despairing is not proper compassion.
It’s kind of mangled up with self-cherishing a bit that, oh, I can’t cope with all of this. I have to deal with it, but it’s it’s too much. Whereas his holiness says real compassion doesn’t despair because there is a sense of hope and that one can do something. And that’s all you have to focus on. Not that you can take the suffering of away of even this one person, let alone all people, but you can do something and I am going to do something.
Yeah. Slowly. Think by just reflecting on those points more and more. But I think it’s also something part of our like, our experience of meeting the dharma and understand of, like you say, maybe that we weren’t even aware or blocked of these things before, but then the dharma helps us become aware of how much suffering there is. And of course it’s overwhelming at first, but I think that’s something that we just go through.
And being not so overwhelmed by it is not necessarily a lack being less compassionate. It’s just, more realistic. Because, you know, the thing is to so don’t don’t his arm will don’t I I just wanna say something so your arm will fall off by the time I finish talking. I was just trying have some compassion for you, not ignore you. Sorry.
Oh, no. I lost my point. Oh, now it’s gone, I think. Yes. I know.
Okay. Maggie, what were you going to say? Yeah. Yeah. I was along those lines, that’s what I was trying to say that I think if you if because Lama Zopa Rinpoche says, one of his great sayings is, one way of thinking about things brings all kind of suffering.
One way of thinking brings one all kinds of happiness. So if you just focus on the suffering and thinking, how terrible, how much there is, how much suffering there is, etcetera, you know, that just makes you miserable. But if you focus on thinking I can do something, even to focus on trying to do something, that gives you hope. That’s a positive state of mind that enables you to move on and not get trapped in the overwhelming feeling that there’s just so much suffering, so much to do, but focusing on you know, what one can do. Even if it’s even that the one thing that one can do is not necessarily a a direct thing, but something indirect, like just being a nicer person.
Take something for that and you can say, well, look, I can’t go out and actively help someone. No. I can study and clarify and try and understand more the things that you can practice and actually do now, whether it’s not actively going out of it. But it feels like that you’re actually in some sort of direction in being able to do something. Yeah.
Suffering is One little question. Okay, that’s it. Thank you very much.
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- glance meditation
- In Tibetan Buddhism, a meditation that reviews the overall points of a broad lamrim subject, rather than going into detail. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
- Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
- A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.