Evening with V M McAndrew — 1998-08-20

45 min · 4,895 words · 20 August 1998 · Buddha House Adelaide

Evening with V M McAndrew (Ven Margaret McAndrew)
Evening with V M McAndrew (Ven Margaret McAndrew)
Evening with V M McAndrew — 1998-08-20
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 45-minute teaching, Ven Margaret McAndrew guides the audience through the three scopes of the graduated path: small scope (fortunate rebirth through karma practice), medium scope (liberation from cyclic suffering via moral conduct, concentration, and wisdom), and great scope (bodhicitta—attaining enlightenment to free all beings). She then focuses on the first perfection: generosity. She explains how motivation transforms any action into spiritual practice, covers three types of generosity (material, Dharma, protection from fear), and addresses practical concerns—giving within means, avoiding regret, organ donation, rescuing insects. She emphasizes that aspiring practitioners begin with small deliberate acts, rejoicing in their own virtue and others’, laying groundwork for bodhisattva practice. Pitched at students new to Lamrim or those exploring Mahāyāna foundations.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 47 6P 1998 08 20.mp3

UUID: 2d0c6295-68da-4816-8817-0551f37df29e

Teacher: Ven Margaret McAndrew

Collection: Evening with V M McAndrew (Ven Margaret McAndrew)

Date: 1998-08-20

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 45.5 minutes

Words: ~4,891

Not when I get up to the on enthusiastic perseverance anyway. So I was going through the the different stages of the graduated path, and we’ve got up to the the topic of the six perfections now. And so we’ve been going through the the small and the medium and the great scope. I was going through a whiteboard for this, but, anyway, I didn’t get around to it. So, anyway, just in general terms, when we’re going through the practices related to the small scope, it related to the thought of attaining fortunate rebirth, avoiding rebirth in the lower realms.

And the practices that were involved with that was the the main practice was the observance of karma, avoiding the ten non virtuous actions and accumulating virtuous actions. And that was done with the motivation of avoiding lower rebirth and attaining fortunate rebirth and attaining fortunate rebirth. And the the medium scope was involved with doing with achieving liberation from cyclic existence, understanding that there is no essence in the the brief transient happiness of saṃsāra and that while one’s in saṃsāra while one’s caught up in cyclic existence, then one’s always going to be experiencing different kinds of sufferings and that there’s no security because you’re always in danger of falling back even from the higher states of rebirth. There’s always a danger of falling back to lower states of rebirth again. And so this practitioner understands very strongly that they need to take action to put an end to this situation and to achieve liberation.

And so this, of course, has to be based on the same practice that the person of the lower scope is doing, which is observing karma. The person of medium scope goes on to practice the three higher trainings. So does anybody have a good memory for what the three higher trainings were? Well, that that is one of the higher trainings. Yes.

Concentration is one of them. Yes. Wisdom is another one. Yes. No.

No. No. We’re talking about medium scope here. Okay. So, actually, the first one is we’ve already mentioned really is moral conduct.

So that that is something that has to be practiced in the small scope, but when somebody is practicing at the medium scope level, it becomes the higher training of moral conduct, whereas before that it was simply moral conduct or ethics. Now it becomes the higher training. It’s a higher training because doing it that person is doing it with the purpose of attaining liberation. And, of course, they have they gradually develop more and more refined, more and more strict viewpoint of what constitutes moral conduct, and that particularly involves taking on a vow. So probably the person who’s in involved with the three higher trainings would be perhaps looking at taking on more vows than the person who is at the first level would be perhaps interested in.

But in any case the person definitely has to engage in these, has to take start to take an interest anyway in understanding these things and embarking on their practice. But when we got to the medium scope part of explanation I said I wouldn’t talk about these things particularly I wouldn’t talk about the concentration and wisdom because actually they get explained in terms of Mahāyāna practice in the Six Perfections. So we’re getting up to this point now and so when we started on talking about the great scope we started off with going through the stages of developing bodhicitta first of all developing great love and compassion and then the thought of on the basis of that great love and compassion of wanting to save other sentient beings from suffering and bring them to a state of everlasting happiness and understanding the way to do that is in enlightenment, attaining enlightenment oneself, becoming a Buddha. So this is the meaning of the motivation of bodhicitta. The explanation of the great scope and the graduated path starts off with these practices of cultivating bodhicitta or in other words the Mahāyāna motivation and it’s understood that we have to continue on doing the practices that were explained in terms of the small and medium scopes but they become Mahāyāna practices when we’re doing them with the attitude of bodhicitta and having cultivated bodhicitta then it’s a natural next step to actually take the bodhisattva vows.

The person who has cultivated bodhicitta strongly enough particularly the engaging bodhicitta thought would take the vows which are related with that thought and so if you’re interested in taking bodhisattva vows generally the lamas do give these vows from time to time But anyway, we talked about this last week just briefly. We just mentioned the bodhisattva vows briefly, but that would be the logical next step after cultivating this sort of bodhicitta. So when you’ve taken the bodhisattva vows, that doesn’t make your body bodhisattva, but it does commit you. I’m sorry. Sometimes it does.

Sometimes they say that when somebody takes the bodhisattva vows from the heart, they really become a bodhisattva at that stage and that all the buddhas in the pure lands know that somebody has generated bodhicitta somewhere because because the earth trembles in the pure lands. So maybe that’s why we get earthquakes sometimes. But anyway, the thing is that we’re committed to carry on with this practice and work towards really becoming bodhisattvas. Has anybody got an idea of what the difference is between having the Mahāyāna motivation and actually having bodhicitta? Okay.

But bodhicitta really refers to a motivation. It’s a motivation of wanting to attain enlightenment. So what’s the difference between, for example, myself saying, oh, I want to help all others. You know, I I I’ve been thinking about these topics of love and compassion. I think it’s great and I would would want I would want to attain enlightenment to help others.

And what’s the difference between that and the actual bodhicitta? Mhmm. Right. But, yes, that’s right. It becomes spontaneous.

Actually, it has to be attained in meditation. It is a lot of hard work. The way that the six perfections are explained tend sometimes to give you impression that you become a bodhisattva and then attain single pointed concentration but in actual fact I had some questions about this once and I asked Khensur Rinpoche about this topic and he said that in actual fact to develop bodhicitta, to become a bodhisattva, you need to develop single pointed concentration first and then use that single pointed concentration contemplate on these topics which lead you to the development of bodhicitta. In that single pointed concentration you can really attain this spontaneous realization of bodhicitta, this spontaneous effortless arrival of the thought which continues and you don’t have to keep on working on it as you were saying, wasn’t it, Tom? Yes.

Tom was saying that it’s something that just comes keeps on coming. Yes. It’s just there. It becomes part of your being. So You have to continue practicing a point of concentration, but you wouldn’t need to be putting effort into the bodhicitta motivation at this point.

It becomes effortless. It just says that very distinctly in the scriptures. Suppose if you would mean, is possible to lose one’s bodhicitta. It’s possible to For instance, if the person gets very, very discouraged by the bad behavior of sentient beings, sometimes they can, in the early stages of their bodhicitta, can give it up. But that’s a different thing.

Now I’m not sure about this because I the I seem to remember that the bodhisattva has to come back right at beginning of the first Mahāyāna path again, although he has passed the path of seeing he has to come back to form the accumulation of merit. But I’m not sure of that. Have had an explanation explanation of the five paths for an arhat. The difference for the arhat is that, of course, he doesn’t have to get the accumulation he doesn’t have to achieve the he’s already achieved the wisdom of the path of of seeing so he doesn’t have to accumulate the wisdom accumulation up to that path. But I think he still has to accumulate the merit accumulation up to that path by engaging in activities.

But I’m not terribly sure. I’d have to really check that up. I don’t know where you’d find it set out in the teachings. It was a teaching that Tashi Tsering taught us but I’m not sure what text he got it from and I’m not sure it’s a text that’s been translated into English and I’m not sure even if I had all my notes here with me that I’d be able to put my hands on it right away. But it was very interesting to have had that teaching.

You don’t very often hear it taught from that perspective of the Arhat. Of course, it’s not relevant to us really because we’re not taking that path but it is interesting to see how that does fit into the general setting out. They will eventually, yes. They have to come back, yes. Yes.

Yes. Well, according to the Sūtra teachings, leaving Tantra out of it for the moment, they do have to go through the accumulation of merit. Yes. It’s a merit. You see, we need two two accumulations of merit and wisdom.

We need the wisdom to achieve like the Dharmakāya of enlightenment, need the accumulation of merit so as to achieve the Buddha’s body. The arhat has not accumulated that much merit as Bodhisattva has on the path. They’ve accumulated the wisdom which has enabled them to achieve liberation. Of course, they need to accumulate more wisdom because it takes a higher wisdom to attain enlightenment. But of course their accumulation of wisdom is still ahead of the beginning bodhisattvas, because the beginning bodhisattva hasn’t attained the path of seeing, hasn’t realization of emptiness, let alone attained the cessation of the gross delusions.

Whereas the arhat has taken his practice wisdom up to the point where he’s attained the cessation of the deluded mental states, cut off saṃsāra at the root. So his practice of wisdom would be at the same level of that as a very advanced bodhisattva, an eighth level bodhisattva. That’s what you were saying, yes. So his practice of wisdom would be at that level of the eighth level bodhisattva. However, his accumulation of merit would be way back and he’d be starting off from the beginning like a beginning bodhisattva and he has to accumulate that merit.

That’s mainly done by working for others and the practice of the first four perfections. Generally concentration is included with wisdom but it’s actually, technically speaking, concentration really is involved with both merit and wisdom. Depending what on what on the object of the concentration when when when you’re using the concentration to to focus on emptiness and it becomes wisdom. But anyway Mhmm. When we talk about wisdom generally we’re referring to that.

Of course there’s also other kinds of wisdom. You know there’s wisdom of understanding the difference between virtuous and non virtuous actions and so on but we don’t generally refer to those things just as wisdom. Perhaps it’s discriminating wisdom or something like that. But when we talk about the higher training of wisdom and the perfection of wisdom, we’re talking about practice of understanding emptiness. That’s from the point of view of the Madhyamaka school.

If it’s being explained perhaps by teachers from the Theravadin tradition perhaps they might explain it in terms of selflessness because that’s the explanation according to the school that they’re following. So anyway doing the, the three higher trainings, we also is the, the practice of the person on the medium scope. And when we’re in the when we’re practicing on the great scope then the practice becomes the six perfections. So the six perfections are actually the practice of a bodhisattva and an actual fact of a bodhisattva who has achieved the path of seeing and is practicing on the ten bhūmis or the ten bodhisattva grounds. So for us actually we’re not going to be practicing the six perfections at this stage but still our practice we have to understand this practice of the six perfections and our practice can be in terms of our understanding of the six perfections but the difference is that for us we’re not actually practicing perfections because we’re not at that stage.

Well I don’t know, know, there might be somebody here who’s a bodhisattva in disguise and is really practicing the six perfections but in general we can say yes. We’re aspiring bodhisattvas and we hope that one day we’ll become bodhisattvas and in the meantime we have to understand these practices and we’re practicing them as virtues rather than as perfections so for us they don’t become the perfections. The Sanskrit word is paramitas which really is interesting because it translates really literally as gone beyond and so we’re not very gone beyond at this stage but it’s excellent to understand these practices according to our level and to begin to practice them and then in this way we can enhance our practice and continue on and become bodhisattvas eventually because we need to develop these qualities. Does anybody here actually know what the six perfections are? Mhmm.

Righto. Maybe since Sue’s got the written down, can read them out. Yeah. Ethics, patience, Right. So anyway, want to develop all these qualities.

Might only start off with a very small practice of generosity, very small practice of ethics and so on. And we shouldn’t expect ourselves to be like a bodhisattva at this stage, we should just realize that we’re putting in the groundwork and do the best we can. What do you understand by aspiring? Well, I’ll be explaining that when I get to it after I’ve talked about generosity. So I won’t say just now.

So we actually yes we might think that at this stage we’ve got no hope of understanding the teachings on Śūnyatā or emptiness and we might think it’s really difficult to engage in the practices of single pointed concentration. It doesn’t seem so unreasonable to think we can practice generosity and moral conduct and patience and enthusiastic perseverance but when we come to these last two we think oh you know what hope have I got but even with those two if we start by doing a little bit now then it’s going to be easier later on in this life we can have a deeper understanding of these topics and certainly in our future lifetimes we’ll be reaping the benefit of having put a little bit of effort into these things now so it’s worthwhile at least to look at these topics and to make some sort of an effort towards them. Of course, we don’t have to think that the other four are easy either because some people perhaps might find that generosity is easy but patience is difficult or another person might find that perhaps enthusiastic perseverance is their hard one but we can expect to find that once we really start to look at these things we’re not going to find those necessarily very easy either.

And so the practice of generosity or giving, sometimes it’s translated as giving. So, most people do engage in giving sometimes and whether this giving becomes the practice or perfection of giving depends on the motivation. So it’s not so much the action as whether it’s done with a particular kind of motivation. Of course, as I said before, it’s really the Bodhisattvas who are practicing the perfection but we can be practicing something that leads up to this becoming the perfection. If we want it to be something that leads up to the perfection of giving then we have to cultivate the right motivation, right thought, the right mental attitude.

This mental attitude is the wish to give with true selfless generosity. Generosity. So with this kind of thought, then if we give a bit of food to a dog with this motivation, then it’s greater than giving a house full of gold with the thought of your reputation. Because if we’re just giving with a thought of our reputation, it’s only a worldly action and it doesn’t bring us the great results that we want to progress on the path. So in actual fact it might even be better to be poor if we can get so much result just from giving a small thing with the right motivation whereas if we’re giving with pride then it cancels out the good results of the action.

And so if we’re rich and giving great things and we’re in danger of having pride because of our giving, that isn’t going to help us at all. We can look at it from that point of view and say that we’re probably better off to be, well, not terribly well-to-do. The thought also should be to give for the welfare of others. So we’re trying to overcome stinginess with this practice. We’re trying to overcome our instinctive clinging and attachment to our possessions, all the things that we own or that we consider belong to us.

And this isn’t necessarily just material possessions but when we’re doing this practice we at this level of our development we shouldn’t give more than we can afford because this might backfire on us it does backfire on us if we feel that we’ve given too much and we suddenly realize that we’ve created difficulties for ourselves by giving away too much then we regret having given and this also destroys the merit of the action. So it’s it’s necessary to be rational about how much we can give. Also, we should sorry. Wouldn’t that be wrong motivation if you had more than you could afford? Well, it might be from a generous impulse.

If it’s from pride, of course, it would be wrong motivation. But we can sometimes give with a generous impulse. But that generous impulse might be not taking into consideration the hardships that are going to arise for us later on when we find that we are short of money or whatever it might be. And so we do have to consider these things because it’s important that we should continue to rejoice in our virtuous actions actions and not regret them. Regret is a mental factor that stops the increase of the karmic result.

And so if we regret our bad actions, it’s extremely helpful because it stops the increase of the bad karma. On the other hand we don’t want to regret our good actions because it stops the increase of the good result. If we don’t regret it we keep on the good result keeps on increasing naturally and if we can rejoice in it afterwards that increases the good result even more. That shouldn’t be pride. It’s a different kind of rejoicing.

If you feel pride, of course, that’s a harmful mental state. It’s really good to rejoice in our own actions. Yes, it makes them much more powerful, much stronger and it also helps us to overcome ideas of our own limitations. We feel that we can’t really do much then by rejoicing in our virtuous actions we can see that we are capable of doing something. But it’s also important to rejoice in the virtuous actions of others.

Of course, if we do feel pride in our own virtuous actions, we only have to look at the virtuous actions of others and realize that our own virtuous actions are not so great. It’s really good to rejoice in the virtues of others because in that way we can accumulate virtues that we can’t do with our own actions. One example of this would be, of course, with generosity. If we don’t have a lot of wealth ourselves and we can’t make great generosity but we can see other people around who are making big offerings, we don’t need to look at what their motivation might be, we just look at the action and rejoice in it. In that way we can accumulate a tremendous amount of merit of giving through the action of rejoicing.

Of course, we have to give ourselves within reason as much as we can afford. A bodhisattva of course can give everything they have and they can even give parts of their body. When we’re not bodhisattvas we’re not allowed to give parts of our body. I think giving blood to the blood bank and that’s something that can be a way of approaching this particular practice of making generosity of the body without doing anything that’s going to harm you in the long term. Yes, you might have an opportunity to do that too.

That’s pretty rare and of course it’s only other family members who can be the recipients of these things. But yes, with modern science being what it is, sometimes these things can happen and if somebody was in that situation and they took the bodhisattva’s motivation towards it, then it could become this kind of practice. Some of the descriptions in the scriptural text sound pretty gruesome about people giving their eyes and so on. I don’t know whether it’s really meant to be taken literally, but the whole point is that the Bodhisattva has the willingness to give in this way, whether anybody would actually take them up on it or not. When you’re dead, then that’s different.

If you’ve got Yes. Yes. Well, of course, you know, we can do that. That’s a wonderful thing to do. Yes.

And if you have this motivation of wanting to help others, this sort of attitude of generosity, then it’s an excellent practice. Well, well, yes. That’s right, when people have organ transplants and so on perhaps it’s enabling the person to extend their life longer, perhaps to enjoy more health than they were enjoying. You don’t know what use they are going to make of their life but it does give them the opportunity to have a longer and healthier human rebirth, which does give them the potentiality for Dharma practice. Now it’s really up to the person, you can’t control what use they make of it, but at least you’re giving them that opportunity.

Some people also say, Well isn’t that going to interfere with my rebirth? Because the organs have to be removed while the body is fresh, whereas it’s always taught in our teachings. Actually if you willed your body to help others with this very strong motivation, the Lama said that this would cancel out the bad effects of disturbing the body and so therefore it’s probably fine to do it. But if you did feel concerned, we’re not saying you have to do it because it could go either way, particularly if you’ve had strong reservations about this, you might choose to state that your body shouldn’t be touched. On the other hand, if you felt that your organs would be beneficial to others then you could will them and the great merit from that would cancel out the possible deleterious effects of having your body touched immediately.

If you look at it another way, it’s usually people who get killed in accidents while they’re still young whose organs are useful. A person who’s been killed suddenly in an accident probably isn’t going to be left alone for three days. They’re not going to be in that situation where being left alone is going to benefit them. The violence of the accident is going to be such that the person’s consciousness probably leaves quickly already before anybody even touches the body. For this person, the merit that would come of having willed their organs to medical purposes, to transplants, would be tremendously potent.

Whereas for a person perhaps who’s been sick for a long time, their organs might not be much use anyway. I’m not so sure about this. Maybe some of you in the medical I thought I understood that if a doctor had visited you within within, you know, sort of a few day or two and was Yes. For them to actually leave you in in the house, it’s it’s very rare. There’s a I think Yes.

Yes. And as the medical profession becomes more aware They just say that generally the the the hospitals and so on try to be aware of religious needs. And for instance, with the the Judaism, the people in Judaism Judaism want to be the first ones to prepare the body and they don’t want anybody else touching it and that the hospitals make allowance for that. There is some sort of precedent for the medical staff in the hospital leaving the body alone. But I think for three days that’s something that they wouldn’t that would be very much yes, right, yes.

Yes. Yes. But at least, you know, if somebody was there to say prayers over your body and to touch your head so that it didn’t so that it wasn’t the wrong part of your body that got touched first, all that There’s quite a lot that could be done. Yes, it’s the people who are involved with the hospice movements who are really, like Sue, who are up to date with developments here in this area. So, anyway so giving.

So, also, we have to have have some regard to the recipient. We should have respect for the person who is receiving the offering. We shouldn’t think of us as giving something that’s helping them. We should see them as being the person who is helping us. They’re giving us an opportunity to practice and so we should have this attitude of respect and appreciation of the person who is the object of our generosity and also of course we should consider the effect that our act of giving is going to have on the person.

There might be some circumstances where you feel it’s better not to give people what they they ask for and use your judgment about that. The example here is you shouldn’t give alcohol to a monk or you shouldn’t give weapons to somebody if you think that they might commit a crime or commit suicide with these weapons particularly. And so there are three kinds of generosity. Maybe I don’t really need to go into so much detail with all this, but there’s generosity of material goods. And we don’t this doesn’t only have to mean wealth.

We don’t sometimes have a lot of wealth, but we can also give our energy and time and our sympathetic understanding to other people even if we don’t have much money. Generosity of Dharma This means It doesn’t have to mean necessarily that you have to give teachings yourself. It can mean encouraging others in virtuous actions. For instance, I think with parents, you know, they train their children up in virtuous actions and this is giving the generosity of Dharma if you do it with this motivation. Other people also can be encouraged if you get the opportunity you can encourage people to come along to Buddha House and all these kinds of things are giving generosity of Dharma.

And the third one is giving protection from fear and this can be for example rescuing insects from a spider’s web and if you think that you’re doing this as the action of generosity then it becomes this generosity of protection from fear. When we do these actions then we can engage in them and first of all, motivating with bodhicitta and then dedicating the merits then it becomes this practice of generosity. Yes. Well, of course. It’s down to the torch for a moment.

That’s a tricky one. I suppose the spider will just go and catch another insect. But if the spider goes hungry, at least it’s avoided the karma of killing that insect. Yes. It’s true.

It’s yes. It it’s a a lighter level for insects because of their ignorance, but at the same time, it is bad karma for them. So they really have no choice because of the realm they’re born into. They really have no choice but to create that sort of karma. What do you think?

Yes. I think dogs dogs are actually what they call adventurous eaters. They’ll eat anything. If you’ve been in India, you’ll see that. I’ve seen that somebody who investigated into this said that it is possible to keep a healthy dog on a vegetarian diet, although I don’t know exactly what you’d do with it.

But for a cat it’s not possible because cat systems are designed for meat and meat only. Whereas with dogs perhaps it’s a bit more of an open question. But in any case, we’re allowed to eat meat ourselves, you know. It’s not considered to be non virtuous. But, on the other hand, of course, if you consider the fact of the, sort of like the chain of supply and demand and so on and, don’t want to get involved in that, then I think there’s a virtue in, avoiding eating.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
three higher trainings lhagpäi lab pa sum (Tib)
The three higher trainings of ethics, concentration and wisdom when conjoined with refuge in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. LYWA
two accumulations sambharadvaya (Skt); tsog nyi (Tib)
Also called the two collections or two types of merit, they are: the merit of virtue, which develops the method side of the path by practicing generosity and so forth, and the merit of (transcendental) wisdom... LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top