Evening with V M McAndrew — 1998-04-08

45 min · 4,870 words · 8 April 1998 · Buddha House Adelaide

Evening with V M McAndrew (Ven Margaret McAndrew)
Evening with V M McAndrew (Ven Margaret McAndrew)
Evening with V M McAndrew — 1998-04-08
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 45-minute evening teaching, Venerable Margaret McAndrew establishes motivation—specifically bodhicitta, the commitment to achieve Buddhahood for the benefit of all beings—as the foundation for practice. She guides students through the graduated path: from small-scope concerns (avoiding worse rebirths) through medium-scope renunciation (seeking freedom from saṃsāra) to great-scope bodhicitta. A central theme is the distinction between two paths: arhats, who achieve personal liberation and then remain in nirvana, and bodhisattvas, who deliberately return life after life to help all beings. Through the story of Thai forest yogi Achan Mun, she illustrates this compassion in action—how his commitment brought hostile, fearful villagers gradually to the dharma. The talk also covers why we each need to become Buddhas, how karmic connections form between beings, and the supreme powers of enlightened beings to emanate infinite forms suited to help others.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 24 BaB 1998 04 08.mp3

UUID: db392e2a-2064-47e2-91e8-4d4ababc6fa5

Teacher: Ven Margaret McAndrew

Collection: Evening with V M McAndrew (Ven Margaret McAndrew)

Date: 1998-04-08

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 45.5 minutes

Words: ~4,870

This should be the thought not any sort of worldly thought, not any sort of mundane attitude, but, we should set our mind on a thought that’s going to bring a long term result, a spiritual result, and in particular, if we set our mind on the thought of wanting to benefit others, this will be the greatest thought that we can produce in our minds. So the result that we get from the practice depends on the motivation with which we embark on the practice, and if we start off this practice of listening to the teachings today with the thought that we’re doing it with the long term goal of becoming able to bring about the benefit of others. And if we make this sort of benefiting others not just partial but extended to all others then this becomes the extremely powerful thought of bodhicitta when we consider that in order to bring this about we have to gain enlightenment we have to achieve Buddhahood so as to have the qualities the particular capabilities of a Buddha to be able to help others so thinking in this way we set our motivation. So this week the topic is about developing bodhicitta, and this brings us to the great scope because previously, we’ve been looking at the small and medium scope and the small and medium scope explanations and the teachings.

So you remember, some of you have been here before, you’d remember what we’ve been talking about in terms of small and medium scope practitioners, motivations, sort of goal they intend to achieve by their practice. So we start by looking at our situation, the fact that we’re very fortunate to have a human rebirth, but also that this human rebirth is a situation within cyclic existence. That while we’re in cyclic existence, we’re being thrown from one state of suffering to another, that we never achieve the happiness that we want and that we’re never really secure. And so we come to the conclusion that we have to make good use of our human life, and also that we need to work towards becoming liberated from this state of suffering, of this bondage in cyclic existence, which is going to always produce suffering, which is never going to be secure and safe from suffering. So the small scope really had more to do with the thought of making good use of the human life in order to avoid being thrown into worse states of suffering in our future lives.

And the medium scope had to do with this sort of really finding a way out of the sufferings of cyclic existence or out of saṃsāra, achieving freedom, achieving liberation, cutting off bondage to saṃsāra, cutting off the cause of saṃsāra so that we can have lasting, uncontaminated happiness. So the person who has attained this understanding of the medium scope, the motivation of the medium scope, goes on to develop this motivation of renunciation of saṃsāra or renunciation renunciation of being born again and again into cyclic existence and being under the control of the cause of suffering. And by continuing to develop this sort, eventually they achieve the realization of renunciation. So when we talk about achieving a realization, it doesn’t mean just having some sort of thought, occasional thought, it doesn’t just mean having an intellectual understanding, but it means having a very heartfelt, very spontaneous awareness of the truth of this thought. And this thought becomes something that’s very much with the person day and night.

It’s behind all their thinking. Even when they’re not consciously thinking this thought, it arises spontaneously as a sort of thought behind the thought. It’s something that guides all their activities, guides all their thinking. And it’s always ready to arise spontaneously whenever circumstances provide the opportunity for thought to arise. The person doesn’t have to put any energy now into having this thought arise.

It will just be there spontaneously. So this is very, very powerful. This kind of realization has to be produced through meditation, and it becomes more powerful than the thoughts that arise spontaneously with us now, which are the thoughts such as anger and hatred and clinging attachment. These kinds of emotion arise in us spontaneously now, because we’re very habituated to them from previous lifetimes, life before life before this one. So we don’t have to put energy into developing anger.

We don’t have to put energy into developing clinging attachment. As soon as we encounter a suitable object, thoughts arise spontaneously. So by putting energy into familiarizing with such thoughts as renunciation, we can have the thought of renouncing cyclic existence arising spontaneously. And this will be a much happier thought for us because our delusions, our deluded thoughts and emotions only cause agitation for us and they cause us to create bad karma, which produces more and more suffering. Whereas if we can have positive thoughts such as renunciation and the thought of escaping from saṃsāra, then this will bring immediate benefits of making our mind calmer and giving us a steady goal to work towards, and it will bring us the long term benefit of achieving this state of freedom.

So has anybody got any questions about this? Was anybody here last week? Does anybody remember? Well, that’s one of the practices we have to do to achieve liberation. To achieve the state of mind of renunciation, remember well, I think that, yes, that definitely comes into it, but that’s really associated with the small scope.

What particularly goes with medium scope? No, actually what comes with the medium scope is the meditation on the general sufferings of cyclic existence. Not just the lower realms, but the fact that just being in cyclic existence wherever you are in it is basically being in bondage to suffering. First of all, the meditations on the suffering lower realms, of course, give a tremendous amount of impetus to this sort of thought, but that really belongs to the small scope. The small scope person wants to escape the sufferings of the lower realms, but when you add to that the thought that as long as you’re in cyclic existence, you’re never free from the suffering of lower realms, because you can always fall back again.

And also add to that the thought that even when you’re in the higher realms, also is a state of being under the control of delusion and karma, it’s also subject to various sufferings. Reflecting in this way, then the person really develops the thought that they have to get right out of this situation completely. And of course, it goes along with the understanding that there is a state attainable, which is a state of everlasting uncontaminated happiness. So anyway, a person who’s really developed this attitude of renunciation then goes on to at this point, when they achieve this realization, not just the sort of renunciation which is produced with effort, the effortless spontaneous renunciation. At that point they enter the first of the Hīnayāna paths, if they’re not practicing the Hīnayāna meditations in association with it.

So anyway, they enter the first path and then they go on to practice the three higher trainings. We talked about those last week, didn’t we? Do you remember? Okay. So anyway, the three higher trainings are moral conduct, concentration, and wisdom.

So by practicing these three things, the person progresses along the five paths and eventually becomes an arhat. We won’t go into details about what those practices are because they actually come into the six perfections and we’ll be going into them in detail in the six perfections, which is the Mahāyāna practice. But a lot of it’s just the same. So, anyway, when the person attains liberation, they become an arhat. This this word arhat means somebody who has attained liberation, who has cut off the root of saṃsāra, in other words.

So they’ve got rid of things that bind us in saṃsāra, which is two things, delusion or deluded mental states and karma. And this is particularly through meditation on emptiness, which is what is meant by the the practice of wisdom, that they that they cut off this root of saṃsāra. So, anyway, when a person becomes an arhat, then they’ve attained liberation. That means that they’re capable of leading other beings on the path to liberation also, And they’re capable of guiding their disciples all the way to liberation. So you can see that some arhats do lead many others on the path to liberation, Many others, comparatively speaking.

Some of these arhats can be very compassionate. Told you was it last week I told this story about the Thai yogi, Achan Mun? Well, anyway, that was to me a good example of the compassion of an arhat. He became an arhat in that life, and he was very compassionate towards his disciples. One story that was told of his compassion was that he and his monks went to meditate in a very backwards part of the country where the people at that time were spirit worshippers and knew nothing about Buddhism.

These people were frightened when they saw these monks living this very austere life, living in the forest with tigers roaming around. Was quite hair raising just to read the description of how they used to meditate just on a low platform of bamboo, with tigers growling around at the foot of their bamboo platforms. They saw these monks living there, they thought they must be demons because they didn’t think any human being could possibly stay in the jungle like that. They didn’t think of offering them any food, And so the poor monks were starving. Ajahn Mun saw that the people had this attitude of mind, and so rather than going away somewhere else where they would have got better looked after, he insisted that these monks had to stay there and gradually overcome the fears of the local people and arouse faith in them so that they would take on the Buddhist path.

There was a funny follow-up to that story. I think was these people, I can’t remember, anyway, certainly at one point he went into an area where the people were very backwards and they came to him and asked him to teach them meditation. He taught them a very, very simple meditation, just reciting Buddha over and over again and focusing on like a mantra. Because these people had very, very simple, uncomplicated lives, they very quickly developed sort of Samatha, a sort of single pointed concentration, and they developed psychic powers. And they started to read the minds of Ajahn Mun’s monks.

And they came to him and they said, of course, your mind is perfect, but some of you monks are not so perfect. But anyway, that’s a bit beside the point, but the point was that he had did have that great compassion towards the people. And of course, he was being compassionate towards his own monks too, because although they had to go hungry, this was very good for their practice. But anyway, arhats do have this kind of compassion, and others seem to go off, as far as you can understand the stories that you read in the scriptures, some of them just seem to go off and meditate in a cave and never come out of their meditation. So in that case they really wouldn’t be doing much for others, although you can’t say that in their meditation they might possibly be connecting with others in some ways.

Generally, it just means that they’ve gone off to enter into deep meditation on emptiness, in which they’re not able to do other activities. One of the qualities of an enlightened being is that they are able to both remain in meditative equipoise on emptiness, on emptiness, and also engage in activities for others. Only fully enlightened beings can do this. Other beings, even great bodhisattvas, have to keep on alternating between the two practices. So anyway, these arhats, whatever they might be doing in their life to guide disciples, when they pass out of that life, they enter nirvana and remain after their death in this blissful meditation on nirvana.

As they’re no longer under the force of delusion and karma, they’re not compelled to take rebirth again. And so they just remain, their consciousness remains in this state of meditation. Actually, it’s said that eventually after many eons they do come back because the Buddhas keep on sending the messages to call them back. But in any case, for the time being, for a long, long, long time, they’re not going to be able to work for others. Work for others is strictly limited.

Their ability to guide others to liberation is strictly limited. So then if you look at bodhisattvas, bodhisattvas don’t remain in nirvana because of their compassionate love. The beginning of the path, they have cultivated love and compassion to a much greater degree than the Hīnayāna practitioner cultivates these attitudes. So you have to always keep in mind that the Hīnayāna practitioners don’t ignore love and compassion. They do develop these qualities, they do have these qualities.

But on the Mahāyāna path, have to develop them to a much more powerful degree. So, bodhisattvas have such tremendous love and compassion that they’re drawn back by this love and compassion to help others. And so they keep on coming back life after life. So there are different levels of bodhisattvas. Some bodhisattvas are ordinary beings.

That means they’re still under the compulsion of delusion and karma. So when we talk about becoming a bodhisattva, a person becomes a bodhisattva when they develop the realization of bodhicitta. So we’ll be talking about bodhicitta, but anyway, it’s the sort of attaining enlightenment in order to benefit all others, all other samsaric beings. And it’s developed with the thought on the basis of love and compassion, great love and compassion. And so this person has to develop so we have to start to cultivate these qualities and to develop this realization.

When the realization of bodhicitta or bodhicitta is achieved, then that person and it has to be a realization which is spontaneous and not effortful, not something that the person has to keep working on, but which comes spontaneously all the time, which is underlying all their thoughts and activities. In the same way as we talked about renunciation, the general way that it happens is that the person attains renunciation and bodhicitta simultaneously. You can’t achieve bodhicitta without renunciation. That’s impossible because if you haven’t had the thought of renouncing your own samsaric suffering, then you can’t have the thought of getting rid of other beings’ samsaric suffering. It obviously has to go together.

This person is still, although they have the thought of enlightenment, they have this attitude, this realization of bodhicitta, they’re still under the power of delusion and karma at this stage. And they go on to practice, and the bodhisattvas practices the six perfections or the six pāramitā. Eventually they go on to achieve a higher state where they’re free of being under the compulsion of delusion and karma, and they’re called the higher bodhisattva at that stage. And they keep on being reborn under the influence of their love and compassion. Eventually they will achieve enlightenment, achieve full Buddhahood, which is a much higher state than being an arhat.

So any questions about this? We don’t consider the arhat as being on the path to Buddhahood. We would say, first of all, there’s an ordinary bodhisattva, then there is a higher bodhisattva, And but that’s all divided up into stages, you know? So a person would become a higher bodhisattva from the eighth bhūmi. So, well, also there are Ārya Bodhisattvas, that’s something else again.

An Ārya Bodhisattva is a Bodhisattva who’s achieved So first of all, have the ordinary Bodhisattva who hasn’t achieved insight into emptiness. And then you have the Ārya Bodhisattva who has achieved insight into emptiness. And by developing that insight, they eventually become free of bondage to delusion and karma. And If I remember rightly, it’s on the eighth Bhumi that they achieved that freedom. That Bodhisattva is called the higher bodhisattva.

It’s actually divided up into five paths and ten bhūmis. You enter the first bhūmi when you attain the third path, which is the path of seeing, and the bodhisattva achieves direct insight into emptiness. So don’t worry about all that. It’s pretty complicated, and we’ll be going into it some more in the future. Lovely.

Wouldn’t it? Come on. Asteroid. The crown chakra.. Crown chakra is the formless yes. Well, the the golden one is somewhere top.

But oh, well, anyway, I don’t know. But yes. I think there’s different explanations too. Having a good time. Yes.

So, anyway, the whole point is that when this universe comes to an end, which they say is going to the explanation that’s given in the scriptures is that the sun’s going to become hotter and hotter and burn up the earth, something Isn’t that how it goes? So it sounds pretty much similar to what they say in astronomy. But when that happens, any sentient beings who have the karma to be sort of born as Earth beings, you know, in another realm will go off to some other well, actually, the beings really of the six realms will go off to some other universe. Yes, they’re considered to be human beings, but they’re in a better human state than we are. I mean, in the sense of being happier, having better conditions, having fewer sufferings, longer lives, no troubles, and not having to work hard to make a living and that sort of thing.

Yes. And some of them look like cows. Some of them the ones that have a come from the cow continent. I think they’re supposed to have horns and look a bit like cows, only that they’re still human beings. Something like that, anyway.

So, anyway, I don’t know I don’t know whether you can really take all this literally. Of course, if you look for these four, you’re not going to see them through a telescope. But I think the message is that there are other worlds and that there are human like existences on these other worlds. If you take human like to mean existences where we have developed intelligence and the possibility of practicing Dharma in some human worlds, not all human worlds. But of course, as that I was saying to the best thing is if you can go to a pure land.

But you won’t necessarily go there just for being hit by an asteroid. It takes a bit more than that. Well, I think that’s what they’re going to find themselves. No. I think because well, it’s hard to say.

You can’t argue. You can argue about all that, but you don’t know, don’t you? Okay. So anyway, to get back on track again I’ve lost the track. But we’re talking about, yes, bodhisattvas.

So actually, bodhisattvas keep on getting born, but once they become higher bodhisattvas free from the compulsion of delusion and karma, you shouldn’t think of them as being in saṃsāra. They’re not in saṃsāra, they’re out of saṃsāra, but they’re still taking embodied form. But saṃsāra depends on the mind. If the mind it doesn’t depend on the body. So if the mind is out of saṃsāra, then the being is out of saṃsāra.

Their choosing has come back. Or you could say that they’re compelled by their love and compassion. But you could say it’s a form of choice because they come back voluntarily. They don’t have to come back. They actually these higher bodhisattvas, you can say that they don’t remain in the blissful peace of nirvana like the arhat does, but actually they’re experiencing greater bliss than the arhat.

Because for them, helping others, even enduring hardships, gives them tremendous bliss. And their goal is the attainment of Buddhahood. So they’re working they want to achieve full enlightenment, they’re working towards that all the time. And the reason why they want to work for Buddhahood is because of a Buddha’s tremendous abilities to be able to help others. Some of these were explained in of the refuge teachings.

There we were looking at it from the context of why we should trust in Buddha as a valid guide on the path to liberation, because Buddha has these special qualities which other beings don’t have. These qualities of omniscience, perfect wisdom to be able to see all ultimate conventional phenomena. Means that the Buddha is not only perfectly liberated from even the slightest obscuration themselves you could say, their being in a state of one of single point of concentration on emptiness. But also, have a tremendous understanding of the state of mind of all sentient beings. They can see any sentient being anywhere, what their particular state of mind is, what their psychology is, what means will help them towards liberation or or towards enlightenment.

So what they see is whenever a sentient being has a moment’s sort of receptivity to the Buddha’s teaching, they also have this what’s called supreme power. So they have the power to be able to emanate they have many different powers, but in particular they have this power of being able to emanate in different forms. Bodhisattvas can also emanate in different forms, send out emanations to do extra work. A bodhisattva doesn’t have to be limited to one body, they can be working in a number of bodies. As they go up scale they can emanate more and more bodies.

A Buddha can emanate an infinite number of bodies or forms to help sentient beings and be in control of all these forms, all these manifestations at the same time. It’s a bit hard to really imagine it, but this is the sort of power that Buddhas have. These emanations can appear in whatever form is most suitable to the karma of that sentient being, whatever form is going to get through to them. For instance, it could be that somebody for a moment is receptive to a sort of generosity and the Buddha could be right there at that moment in the form of a beggar so that the person has the opportunity to work to make an act of generosity and the they said the most effective way if you’re if you’re if you have the karma to be receptive to the teachings, then obviously, the most effective way that the Buddha can help you is by appearing as a teacher and passing on the Buddha’s teachings. So they say this is the reason why we should regard the teachers, particularly the, the great teachers as being emanations of Buddha.

So if you want to follow anyway oh, and and the other qualities of the Buddhas have this perfect compassion. So this means that Buddhas not only have incredible, very powerful compassion, but it’s equal to all. There’s no partiality. It’s not a question of their having compassion for some but rejecting others. There’s nobody who is rejected by the Buddha’s compassion.

So this makes Buddha’s able to effectively help all sentient beings in in actual fact. You might wonder then why is this if if one Buddha is capable of helping all sentient beings, why should we all try to become Buddhas? Isn’t one Buddha enough? As there are already a number of Buddhas, can’t they do the work between them, and why should we have to try to attain Buddhahood? Has everybody had this thought?

I used to wonder it an awful lot. So the answer is that, in actual fact, Buddhas can help best the beings that they have karmic connections with. And it seems that those karma connections seem to be formed on the road to Buddhahood, before Buddhahood is attained. And so each of us has a special set of karma connections which will enable us to help particularly those beings that we have these strong karmic connections with. And these beings might have to wait for us to help them.

They might not have that kind of karmic connection with another enlightened being. And so it’s really important for us to particularly to gain Buddhahood so as to be able to help these beings we have karmic connections with. And of course, as we progress, as we go from life to life and become bodhisattvas, we’ll be accumulating more and more karmic connections. And bodhisattvas go about doing this in a very deliberate way. Could you just explain karmic connections?

Does anybody else want to have a go at that? Well, if you well, of course, if the prayers come from both sides, this will make very strong karmic connections. But, of course, very the strongest karmic connection of all is that between teacher and disciple. But in actual fact, we’re making karmic connections with other beings all the time. You could say we have very, very close karmic connections with the beings who are in our own family and others if we’ve had very close friendships with very close relationships of one kind or another.

The fact that we are in this relationship probably means that our karmic connection didn’t start in this life but went back. But the fact that we’ve been close in this life makes karmic connections for the future. So we make negative and positive karmic connections. And the thing about a bodhisattva is that even to have a negative connection with a bodhisattva is positive in the long term, because even though wronging a bodhisattva might send you to hells because they’re a very powerful object. At the same time, you have made this connection, so you’ll be drawn back to that bodhisattva again by the power of this karma.

Because the bodhisattva is always working and trying to draw the sentient beings to him or her in a positive way then this connection will eventually turn to a good one that you will end up being guided by that bodhisattva. And so for instance, if you anytime you encounter any being, you’re forming some sort of a karmic connection with them. And if you make prayers for them or say some mantras for them, then this is making a strong karmic connection. So for instance, if you see a dying insect and say some prayers over it, then that’s creating some sort of connection. Well, not if you practice.

Right? I’m not sure about wheel turning. Not all Buddhas are wheel turning Buddhas. Yeah. I’m not sure of the wheel turning.

I’m wondering for not doing a teaching. Yes. Yes. I think my oh, yeah. I think so.

I think my trail’s going to be will. I know a lot more than that. Yeah. It’s one. It’s many eons.

Yes. Well, gather that they just inspire beings by their presence and gives them an opportunity to create merit by making offerings to them and that sort of thing. But there doesn’t seem to be really much purpose to me, but some of them apparent I mean, they say that Śākyamūni Buddha himself wasn’t going to turn the wheel, but the gods requested him to, and so he did. But apparently it depends on the karma of the beings to receive the teachings. If the beings have the karma to be receptive to the teachings, then the Buddhas will teach them turn the wheel, in other words, set the tradition going again.

But the thing is that if a Buddha was not a wheel turning Buddha, still the connection some of those beings made with that Buddha might lead them to be receptive to the next wheel turning Buddha that came along. Yes. According to Sūtra teachings, they don’t accept female Buddhas. According to Tantra, it’s different, but we’re talking about Sūtra now. According to Tantra, of course.

It’s all quite different according to Tantra, really. I think in Tantra they wouldn’t accept that an enlightened being wouldn’t be working for sentient beings, but still they would say that on some universe, the beings in that stage wouldn’t be ready to have the wheel of Dharma turned for them, but they would say that the Buddha would still be working for them in many different emanations in that way. Another thing too is that there are these beings called Pratyekabuddhas, who apparently make an encounter with a Buddha and then go off and, rather than following the teachings of that Buddha, they go off and practice life after life, having been inspired by that Buddha. They attain realization for themselves, they don’t teach others. They just achieve a state of an arhat.

Apparently these Pratyekabuddhas can be inspired by non-wheel-turning Buddhas too, so that’s another purpose that that might be, of a wheel-turning Buddha appearing on the earth would be that they would inspire some of these beings to, to become Pratyekabuddhas.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
bhumi sa (Tib, Wyl)
Ground, or level, as in the ten bodhisattva levels. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
tantra gyü (Tib)
Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
three higher trainings lhagpäi lab pa sum (Tib)
The three higher trainings of ethics, concentration and wisdom when conjoined with refuge in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top