45 min · 5,282 words · 16 September 1999 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 45-minute session, Venerable Margaret McAndrew introduces the Wheel of Life, which she calls “the world’s oldest flowchart.” She explains how ignorance and disturbing emotions—pig, snake, and rooster at the diagram’s center—keep us cycling through rebirth via karma. She walks through the death process and the karmic visions that activate rebirth, using vivid examples: a slaughterman haunted by trampled sheep; an official crushed under bricks of stolen tea. She then unpacks the first six of the twelve links—ignorance, compositional factors, consciousness, name and form, the six senses, and contact—each illustrated with a memorable symbol: the blind man, the potter, the monkey jumping between trees, the boat, the house with windows, and lovers kissing. Pitched at practitioners with some familiarity with Buddhist teachings.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 14 W o L 1999 09 16.mp3
UUID: 47699505-c8e5-402f-860c-faf87d6ad767
Teacher: Ven Margaret McAndrew
Collection: Evening with V M McAndrew (Ven Margaret McAndrew)
Date: 1999-09-16
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 45.5 minutes
Words: ~5,279
Okay. So as you can see, the topic tonight is the wheel. So we start by setting our motivation. So we think that we’re engaged in this activity tonight, not just only for the sake of understanding our own suffering and the underlying causes and how to bring about a stop to that by following the path. But we’re also pursuing this topic so as to be able to bring about the welfare of all sentient beings by understanding the cause of suffering, by understanding how to bring about the cessation of suffering and achieving the state of liberation, then it’s possible to achieve everlasting happiness, which is uninterrupted by any sort of suffering, by any sort of contamination of the mind.
And so we’re not just thinking of achieving that for ourselves, but we’re thinking of how closely involved we are with all the other sentient beings that are around us in this world and how most of them are helpless. They don’t know how to find happiness. Although they’re constantly looking for happiness, they don’t know how to bring about its causes. And so they need a helper. They need a guide.
And it’s our responsibility to take on that work ourselves of helping these others. And so we set that as our motivation. And this is done with understanding that we need to achieve the qualities to be able to help others. So while we’re still caught in ignorance ourselves, we can’t help the others. We have to follow the path and understand the causes.
We have to understand how to pursue the path to find the perfect state of liberation, and especially the fully perfected state of enlightenment, which is which gives the great qualities to be able to effectively help others and continue to help them. And so we have to become enlightened beings. We have to become Buddhas through following the path all the way to enlightenment. So some of you have been here for the few preceding weeks and some of you haven’t. So we’ve been going through the topics which are called the section of the medium scope practitioner.
And we’ve been looking at the how Samsāra is inevitably a state of suffering, how we’re caught up with suffering while we keep on circling in Samsāra or in cyclic existence being born again and again and having this rebirth under the force of the two things that keep us in bondage, which is karma and delusion or disturbing emotions. And while we’re under this bondage, then we’re always going to be taking rebirths that connect us with suffering again and again. So there’s a likelihood of a future fortunate rebirth, we can’t guarantee that we’re going to stay in the upper realms, but we’re always liable to fall back again into the lower realms. And we also looked at the general sufferings of the Samsāra, of how even the upper realms are unsatisfactory, how we don’t experience any real true happiness as it would be defined from the point of view of somebody who has achieved liberation, from the point of view of somebody who has gone beyond suffering, what we consider to be happiness is still mixed with suffering even when we’re enjoying ourselves. So we can’t actually attain this state of higher happiness, which is really a state of incredible bliss compared to even the best kinds of experiences that we can think of in this lifetime.
And this is a state of bliss that continues and isn’t interrupted by anything. So we’re we’ve been looking at the causes of these things, and today we’re going to look at the causes from another point of view, and we’re looking at what Samsāra means, what this cycling means, going from life to life. And it’s been depicted in this diagram, which is called the the twelve links of dependent origination, or it’s sometimes referred to by Westerners as the wheel of life. So it’s particularly referring to samsaric life to suffering. So it’s I sometimes say that it’s the world world’s oldest flowchart because it’s a diagram that explains the process that we’re involved with, and it came from ancient India.
It’s very old and was taken up by the Tibetans. And so if we can study this and understand the different points, then it’s very useful to us to understand how we’re constantly creating our own saṃsāra. So our saṃsāra isn’t a place that we all share, in a sense, where each of us in our own individual saṃsāra. In a sense, we share it because we share similar conditions, but each of us has our own saṃsāra and we each of us have to bring about the cessation of our own saṃsāra individually. And so by understanding the topic that’s illustrated by this diagram, then it it helps us a lot to understand how we’re engaged in this process and what we need to do to bring it to an end.
In other words, to understand the practice that we need to do. Does anybody have any questions? Anyway, it’s a very complicated topic, I’ll try to keep it simple because I don’t really understand the complicated parts of it myself anyway. So I’ll have to skip the complicated bits. So, anyway, before I go on to the topic, I was going to read you a poem, but I seem to have left the poem behind.
So you won’t be getting it tonight. Sorry. We’ll have to save it for another week. Okay then. So going on with the the wheel of life anyway.
So when we’re studying the medium scope, it’s concerned with the motivation of gaining individual liberation. And as you know, we have the great scope which we add to this motivation, the thought of working for the welfare of others. That during the studies and meditations on this particular topic, although we begin by setting our motivation on the thought of enlightenment, during the actual contemplation on the topic, we’re focusing on the thought of individual liberation, how the means brought about because this is something that we have to take in conjunction with the Great Scope motivation. So this is a section of study that we share with the practitioners who are aiming at individual liberation. And so we’ll be talking about it from the point of view of your own liberation, one’s own liberation.
So, there are two kinds of people who can be doing this topic, and there are those of greater intelligence and lesser intelligence. And this essentially seems to boil down to, your education. So if you’re a reasonably well educated person, then you’re capable of understanding through study this topic of interdependent origination. And for that reason, you should study it. Whereas those people who don’t have that capacity aren’t required to study this until they’ve gained that capacity.
And so it’s divided into two groups of people who described as being those of less intelligence and those of lack greater intelligence. But it doesn’t have so much to do with your IQ as, with your, with your general education. So the medium scope all of you people are capable of meditating on the medium scope topic of the twelve links. So it said that the chart was first drawn by the king of Magadha following the advice of Buddha. He was, it was suggested by Buddha that he should draw this chart in order to illustrate these twelve links.
Teaching that Buddha, gave on the twelve links is found in the Sūtra which is called the Rice Seedling Sūtra. So this means that this chart is about two thousand five hundred years old. So looking at it, you might not be able to see all the details, but I’ll be describing them as we go along. And most of you are probably familiar with the pictures. So before we get onto the actual twelve links, just to look at the circle in general, You see that right in the center you’ve got the three animals.
There’s a snake, a bird, and a pig representing hatred, attachment, and ignorance. And they’re the energy that keeps the whole thing going around. So it works like the wheel works like a a modern motor vehicle that’s got the power coming through the through the hub. And it’s not like a a horse and cart or something like that where the the power’s sort of coming along somewhere else and sort of being put onto the whim of the the rim of the wheel from the inside, but instead the power’s coming from the center. So it’s these three, poisonous minds are the the energy that keeps us cycling in saṃsāra.
And those three poisonous minds are the, the disturbing emotions that I already referred to. Last week, we went so some of you were here last week. We went in detail through the disturbing emotions last week. So because we have these disturbing emotions, we’re under the power of the disturbing emotions and we create karma. And even our good karmas are under the power of subtle ignorance.
So even our good karmas themselves can’t release us from saṃsāra. All our good karmas can do is to take us to a a good situation within saṃsāra, but until we start practicing the path and particularly practicing wisdom, wisdom, which overcomes this ignorance of understanding the true nature of existence, we can’t cut the root of saṃsāra. So we need to understand how this can be brought about. But we’re not so much looking at wisdom of emptiness today or selflessness, we’re looking at the process that’s going on as we take rebirth. Next week, we’ll be talking about the wisdom of selflessness.
So if you want to know about that about that, you’ll have to come back next week. But, anyway, that’s the center circle. And then in the next circle, you have a depiction of the six realms of Samsāra. Those are the biggest sections and they’re the gods and the asuras at the top fighting it out between each other. And the I think those are the animals.
I can’t see very well. The animals on that side. I think these are the animals, so they must be the hungry ghosts. And the the hell beings, those would be the those would be the animals, are they? Where are the human beings?
They’re where? Up there. Up this side? Oh, yes. I think I think they’re the asuras, aren’t they?
No. Okay. They’ll probably be human beings with houses and things. Okay. humans there.
Okay. Holes. Right. hungry ghosts, I think those are. Yes.
Animals. Yeah. Right. Okay. Yes.
So anyway, there’s six six realms and if you look at them from the front, you can see closely clearly enough which one are which. So anyway, the point is that we’re getting so actually, that’s the third circle. I missed the second circle. The second circle shows people on one side going up and wretched beings dropping down on the other side. So that’s a bit like Michelangelo’s pictures in the Sistine Chapel, you know, that sort of shows some people going up to heaven and other people falling down.
This is not just something that happens once, but it’s going in a circle. What it means is that we’re continually going up and down. We fall back into the lower realms, then eventually we get enough of rebirth. And then after some time, we forget to watch our karma and we fall back again to the lower realms again. And so this is what we’ve been doing since beginningless time, and this is what we want to put a stop to.
And the six realms represent the different states of rebirth that you can be born in. There’s no particular order about where you get reborn. It can be in any order, depending on what sort of karma, and I’ll be talking a bit about that. Do you have any questions? Yes?
Well, the rooster’s attachment, only that one shows a duck or something, but it’s usually a rooster. And the snake’s anger or hatred because those animals are considered to have a lot of all of those qualities. Actually, people will tell you that pigs are very intelligent. But I think from the point of view of a human being, they use their intelligence in a funny way. Because they do a lot of things that human beings wouldn’t consider to be very intelligent, such as their diet is not very inspiring, particularly in parts of the world where there’s a lot of sort of dirt and other things lying around.
So, yes. So anyway, yes, but actually, believe that pigs are actually very intelligent, this is important because it’s not just our basic IQ that counts, but the use we make of it. So this kind of ignorance that’s concerned here isn’t just like stupidity or not not knowing anything, but it’s in a sense confusion. It’s it’s a it’s a lack of understanding about the important things and hence, even though we may have a lot of intelligence, we’re misapplying it. So then the next one is the actual on on the outer ring, you’ve got the actual twelve links, which I’ll be going into.
And then holding the whole thing, you’ve got Yama, the lord of death, because while we’re in Samsāra, we inevitably have to die. And then we get born again, and we have to die again and again and again. And so, the whole thing can be seen as being in the grip of Yama. So any questions? Well, one of them is Buddha.
I can’t see the other one. I might have to get up on my feet. Anyway, this is Buddha, and you always see Buddha sometimes, you see a picture of Buddha in each of the six realms, and sometimes you just see one picture somewhere. But Buddha is to liberation for all of the beings. And quite often you see Buddha particularly depicted in the human realm because realm from which it it is possible to start the process going by which we get out of saṃsāra.
So it’s special, whereas sometimes you see Buddha depicted in all of the six realms, but Buddha can’t teach the path in most of the other realms. And in particular, human beings are the most receptive. We are not concerned anywhere here with the actual diagram. So Before we actually start looking at the twelve links, we’ll have a look at what happens when we when we’re actually dying and how our rebirth gets activated. So this is something that the twelve things are going to explain.
So what happens is that the person is dying, and we already went through this in the death process explanation. So, what happens is that at death, you might be dying because your lifespan’s run out, because the merit that you had to live for that lifetime has finished. The particular lot of karma that you were born with, so that lifespan has reached its end. Or sometimes you encounter interruptions that cause death. Anyway, you’re dying and so the time has come about.
You’re essentially finished with that particular karma that brought about your lifespan in this life. So it’s coming about that the time is due for the activation of the karma that’s going to bring about your rebirth. This is called the projecting karma. And this is very much influenced by your dying thoughts while you’re dying. And this is connected to two things, craving and grasping, which are actually presented as links in the twelve links.
So anyway, what happens is that during your dying, you’ll be experiencing various thoughts and also as the dying process goes underway, you’ll be less involved in outside events and more and more caught up in internal experiences. As your physical senses and body power and so on fades away, then the power of your internal processes becomes more overpowering. But the person at this stage, although it’s beginning to be very much caught up in their own sort of internal experiences, they’re still capable of being reached, often anyway, by external events. In the case of somebody who’s dying slowly, they’ll be getting it at this stage where the link for the next life is being activated, but they’ll still be able to hear and understand what people are around them are saying. They may still be able to speak to people and tell about their internal thoughts and visions and so on.
And so at this stage, anyway, the person is having thoughts, and it’s important at this stage to help the person to cultivate positive thoughts, to cultivate virtuous thoughts, which will help them to have a good rebirth because they’re capable of hearing, of understanding, and thinking. So either by remembering themselves to cultivate such thoughts or by being reminded and helped by others around them, it’s possible for the person to have a strong influence over what happens in their next life at this stage. So the person so the person has what’s called course recognition and their mind is still quite active. And at this stage, as the karma for the next so so during during a person’s thoughts, they’ll have various feelings arising out of those thoughts, such things as memories and thoughts about what’s going to happen to them and so on, which will produce certain feelings which can give rise to the thoughts of clinging or craving and grasping. So the person might be desiring some sort of thing.
For instance, the example that’s given is that you might feel cold, your body might feel cold and you might be craving for heat. And there can be many different sorts of cravings but they tend to lead to going on to a next to grasping at an existence. You don’t consciously grasp at another existence, but the fact that you’re grasping at something and that something is connected with the sense objects, then that will lead to to some sort of connection with the karma that’s going to ripen in your next life. And so according to whether you’ve had a good or bad karma ripening, there could be some sort of vision taking place. And sometimes these visions are described by the people who are dying, So these visions occur while the person’s still strong enough to to speak and to communicate their experiences to others.
So there there’s many examples of these karmic visions. And in the case of a a bad rebirth, it could be a horrifying vision. So one that’s often quoted is that a person who had many who killed many many sheep as a slaughter man then had the vision of being trampled by sheep at his death time. There’s another vision given in here of an official who stole many bricks of tea. In Tibet they used to have tea that was pressed into bricks and it was quite a useful item of trade.
It would be something like money in Tibet because they had a barter system, so this man managed to get into his own hands obviously, not unknown for officials to be corrupt. So he got his hands on a lot of these bricks of tea that he wasn’t entitled to, and he saw himself as being crushed under many of these bricks of tea, which sounds funny, but it wasn’t very funny for him to have this vision. And also there can be good visions such as seeing beautiful palaces or gardens and parklands in your visions, visions which give a feeling of happiness and which suggest that you’re perhaps going to be reborn in the god realms. So these are an indication of the kind of karma that’s coming about. And then eventually the rest of the death process takes place.
The consciousness eventually leaves the body and goes into the intermediate state. And I’ve talked about all these things before so I won’t go into details, but it says that the intermediate state body has a form that’s related to the form that it’s going to take in the rebirth. So, for instance, somebody who’s going to be reborn in the hell states looks like a blackened charred log of wood. And if you’re going to be reborn as an animal, then you’ve got the form of whichever particular animal it’s going to be. If you’re going to be a human being, then you have the form apparently of an eight year old child.
So it’s still possible for prayers and the intervention of lamas and so on to help people even if their rebirth doesn’t look too good at this stage, they can still be helped. So that’s why we think it’s very important to make a lot of prayers at this time because there can still be a chance for for the person to take a turn in the right direction from the intermediate state. But the best time to take care of the rebirth is is before the death. And particularly at the time of death, then having positive thoughts. If you have positive thoughts, particularly compassion or faith in the Three Jewels of refuge, then there’s no way that you can go to a bad rebirth.
Any questions? So then to go on to the actual twelve links. So the the first link is ignorance, and this is the root of saṃsāra. So it’s important to keep in mind that some of these links are not just a one off type of thing. Fundamental ignorance is always with us.
Although it’s listed as the first link, it’s actually an ongoing process. And it’s the root of our being in saṃsāra. We’re ignorant of particularly the wisdom of selflessness. And so because of that, we’re unable to cut the root of saṃsāra, and we keep on cycling. And so there are two forms of ignorance involved here.
There’s that basic ignorance, the ignorance of selflessness, or there is the ignorance which apprehends a truly existent self, in other words, and because of that we continue to cycle. And then there’s also the ignorance of cause and effect or of karma, which causes us to not use karma skillfully and to create cause for suffering. So that’s the first link. And then the second link is Sorry, is the sorry. Yes.
I should describe it. Yes. Ignorance is a blind man walking with a stick. We’re we’re like that because we can’t see where we’re going, so that represents ignorance. Then the compositional factors, ignorance so because of our ignorance, this motivates the compositional factors.
And this is really means karma. So this is represented by a potter. He’s making pots in the same way we’re making rebirths for ourselves by laying down karmic imprints all the time under the influence of karma. So these things are going on all the time during our life. We’re always under the control ignorance and we’re continually laying down a variety of karmic imprints which are capable of bringing about a number of different rebirths.
So non virtuous karma can throw us into the lower realms and whereas virtuous karma is cause for upper realm rebirth. So we have these karmas on our mind stream and they will once having been imprinted on our mind stream they will remain until they become activated and the time they become activated if it’s a projecting karma, a karma which is going to bring about a rebirth, then it will become activated at the end of a life time when it’s going to bring about the next subsequent life and it will be then activated by craving and grasping at the death time. So I haven’t got up to craving and grasping as a link yet, but, we’re still looking at the, karmic formations. So the next one is name and form and this comes about from the karma being activated, there is a rebirth which, in the case of rebirth from the womb, there will be what’s called name and form. The form is the body, and the name is the other four aggregates, which are feeling, recognition, compositional factors, and and consciousness.
And so these four, sometimes compositional factors is called volition and it’s very much related to karma. So in other words, because of the karma being activated, the rebirth comes about and all the conception comes about and there is the development of these aspects. Of course the consciousness, nonphysical aspects came from the previous life. But during the death process, the the main parts of the of the consciousness more or less became latent. It’s said that they absorb into the subtle consciousness.
The subtle consciousness goes from one life to another carrying all the karmic imprints from the previous lives. Again, as the body develops also the aggregates begin to manifest again. So during that subtle consciousness, there is not the operation of the of the other aggregates apart from just the subtle consciousness and they remain in a latent form as just latencies with that subtle consciousness and then they begin to develop again and so you end up with a different set of mental aggregates in each life really although there’s that connection from life to life you still have a different you have a set of aggregates that really pertains to your particular life your particular body for instance we have a sense of identity we have memories, we have feelings, we have ideas and wishes and aims and so on that are connected with this particular lifetime and which will leave behind us when we die and will take another body and again will develop all these sort of mental faculties with that particular life. They are all linked by this subtle consciousness but we don’t carry the coarser aspects with us but they have to develop again in each life.
Does this make sense? No. I understand they’re imprinted onto the subtle consciousness. That’s my understanding. No.
The the aggregates absorb. The the mental aggregates absorb? Yes. I think I’m not quite sure. You’d have to get a much more technical explanation of how exactly it works, but I think the imprints are my understanding, if I’ve got it right, somebody might correct me if I’m wrong, but is that actually at the time of the karma being laid down that it’s imprinted actually talking about the subtle consciousness is more from tantra than from the sūtra teachings really so what the sūtra teachings really just say is that the consciousness goes from life to life and the other aggregates absorb into the consciousness so maybe we better stick to that explanation and not worry about gross and subtle but the karmic imprints are imprinted on the consciousness and carried there but the compositional factors has a lot to do with the creation of the of the karmic imprints.
So I’m not quite sure at which point they actually get imprinted onto the subtle consciousness. But anyway, point is that the consciousness has the latency for all of these things to arise again in the next life for the other aggregates or for the other three mental aggregates to arise out of it and for the when it associates with the body and for the karmic propensities for that particular lifetime to be experienced. Okay. So we’re up to compositional which is the potter. And then there’s name and form.
Sorry. So three. Yes. So so then sorry. Then the third one was consciousness, and I didn’t tell you about consciousness.
That’s the monkey. And the monkey is jumping from one tree to another, and that’s a a depiction of what our consciousness does when it goes from one body to another or one embodied state to another or one life to the next. Usually it’s from one life with a body to another. If we’re born in the formless god realms then we have to do without a body for that lifetime but we’ll come back and take another life. So most of our lives do have bodies.
So so that’s the monkey. And then the next one is name and form. And I already got a bit ahead of myself with name and form. So that’s the boat. And it shows a number of different people in the boat with the one person rowing it, which is the the consciousness.
So name refers to the mental aggregates anyway and form of course to the body. So this refers to the developing embryo. If it’s a womb rebirth then there’s this developing embryo. And then you’ve got the six senses. So as the embryo develops, eventually, the the sense faculties or organs such as the I and the ear and so on form.
Yes. So essentially, yes, so we have like these physical senses forming and also the mind becoming more activated again as the body develops and I guess this relates to our brain cells it doesn’t say that specifically but during this body we’re sort of thinking with the brain so this these senses develop, then we begin again to have sense impressions. There’s a an arising of sense consciousnesses because as the organs become active, then they connect with impressions. They convey impressions to the consciousness that’s there to receive them. So at this stage, then there begins to be a sense.
So the that’s represented by a house with I think it has five windows or maybe six windows to show the the six sense the sixth sense faculties becoming operational. So having gained the sixth senses, then what happens, of course, is that then we do have contact with sense objects objects of the senses and that’s called contact and that’s depicted in this is depicted by a man and a woman kissing. I’m not quite sure what is there. Something like that anyway. So, anyway, that represents the the experience of contact, which gives rise to an impression on the on the sense consciousnesses.
So that sense consciousness then gives rise to the next link which is feeling. So that’s depicted by somebody with an arrow in his eye. Because once we have this link between the consciousness and the external objects, then there’s this strong impact and so this acts as a condition this this contact link acts as a condition for our experiencing feelings which can be very strong. We have three kinds of feelings either happiness, suffering or a neutral feeling or equanimity and so whatever sense object we encounter we have these feelings which are either going to be either pleasant or unpleasant in other words or neutral and so this is very much a part of our nature that just as it’s like a you know having a match and having the side as a matchbox and as soon as you bring them together and strike the match then you go and get a fire arising so you have this contact between the object of the senses and the sense consciousness via the sense organs and there’s immediately this feeling arising oh I like that oh I don’t like that And sometimes we just don’t care. So that’s neutral.
So then what happens is because we have happy feelings or pleasant feelings about some of these objects, then we have craving. We want to have those objects. We want to
Key terms in this teaching
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- individual liberation
- The liberation from cyclic existence achieved by a hearer (shravaka) or solitary realizer (pratyekabuddha), as compared with the full enlightenment of a buddha sought in the Mahayana. LYWA
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- six realms
- The general way that Buddhism divides the whole of cyclic existence; there are three lower realms (hell, hungry ghost and animal) and three upper realms (human, demigod and god). LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
- twelve links of dependent origination pratitya samutpada (Skt); ten drel yen lag chu nyi (Tib)
- Also called the twelve dependent-related limbs or branches; the twelve steps in the evolution of cyclic existence: 1) ignorance; 2) karmic formation; 3) consciousness; 4) name and form; 5) sensory fields; 6) contact; 7) feelings; 8) craving; 9) grasping... LYWA
- Yama shinchi dagje (Tib)
- The Lord of Death, seen on the Wheel of Life. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.