Evening with V M McAndrew — 1998-03-04

45 min · 6,212 words · 4 March 1998 · Buddha House Adelaide

Evening with V M McAndrew (Ven Margaret McAndrew)
Evening with V M McAndrew (Ven Margaret McAndrew)
Evening with V M McAndrew — 1998-03-04
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Ven Margaret McAndrew opens this 45-minute talk with the chocolate cake metaphor, distinguishing attachment from enjoyment and showing how true renunciation means releasing clinging rather than forgoing objects. She grounds renunciation within the three principles of the path—awakening mind and wisdom—explaining how these structure the three scopes, from fortunate rebirth through enlightenment. She then walks through meditations on suffering: the eight sufferings (birth, aging, sickness, death, separation from desirable objects, meeting undesirable objects, unfulfilled desire, connection to a suffering body); the six sufferings centered on impermanence and uncertainty, illustrated by Princess Diana, Alan Bond, and a Lama Zopa sweep-ticket story; and the three kinds of suffering—gross suffering, happiness that becomes pain, and subtle pervasive suffering. She concludes by introducing the three higher trainings (conduct, concentration, wisdom) as essential practice.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 10 GPK 1998 03 04.mp3

UUID: c73bb317-607b-4c95-97d5-69228fbaa5a4

Teacher: Ven Margaret McAndrew

Collection: Evening with V M McAndrew (Ven Margaret McAndrew)

Date: 1998-03-04

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 45.4 minutes

Words: ~6,211

Because the first piece makes me feel good, then if I eat more chocolate cake, I’m going to feel good and keep on feeling good. And of course, we know that doesn’t happen. We know that the second piece isn’t as good, and if if you eat a third piece, you’ll really start to feel sick. So this is because the real cause isn’t in the chocolate cake. So the chocolate cake is simply a samsaric item, and because it’s a samsaric item, it’s going to be involved with this suffering.

But it’s not the chocolate cake itself that’s the problem, but it’s this mind of ours that has this desire and clinging attachment towards it, and wanting to get happiness from making contact with these objects of the senses. So that includes the physical senses and the mind sense. So what we have to renounce is the attachment itself, which is the cause of suffering. And it’s very important to realize that attachment and enjoyment are two different things. We can enjoy. And sometimes we do practice in a rather ascetic way, because it’s important sometimes to do these kinds of practices to help us to cut our attachment, to realize that we can give up certain things, that we can cut our attachment.

But it’s it’s important to realize that it’s not the giving up of the thing. If we give up chocolate cake and never eat another piece of chocolate cake in our lives, but we’re still craving for it, then we haven’t learned anything. Whereas if we can eat chocolate cake but avoid being attached to it, then then we have really gained something. But on the other hand, if we feel that perhaps giving up chocolate cake sometimes for a while might help us cut our attachment, then that might be a beneficial practice. But we have to realize that it’s the attachment that we’re getting at.

And it’s important to develop this ability to discriminate between harmful mental states such as attachment and other mental states which are which are not harmful to us. So if we are renouncing attachment, that’s the cause of suffering. So that’s the real meaning of renunciation, and it really means that what we’re doing is renouncing suffering. So it’s not that we’re making ourselves suffer. What we’re doing is making ourselves happy, making ourselves peaceful.

So the mind that’s attached to something is a mind that clings and gets stuck on something. It’s a very agitated grasp. It’s a mind that grasps and gets very disturbed and agitated. It’s not a happy state of mind. If we can reduce our attachment, we’ll feel more peace, and that will allow happiness to come up within ourselves naturally.

And so it’s something that’s very, very beneficial. As this inner peace and inner happiness strengthens more and more, then the external objects that we cling to will seem less attractive. They’ll they’ll seem to have less of a pull on us, and we’ll get less caught up in them. But this isn’t an easy development. It’s important to understand that attachment is very, very hard to So anger is the most harmful delusion to us, and it’s the one that causes the most damage.

But it’s not difficult. It’s comparatively not difficult to overcome, because it’s very easy to identify anger and aversion, and to see how harmful it is. With attachment, it’s very hard to identify it, and it’s very hard to really feel fully convinced of its harmfulness. And so we have to work at this. So anyway, this is the motivation.

The motivation of seeing that we’re in this state of suffering and have to get out of it, that leads to small scope to medium scope practice. And you sometimes hear renunciation talked about as one of the three principles of the path. Is anybody familiar with the three principles of the path? Okay. Do want see what they are?

Well, that’s two out of three, really, because awakened heart or awakened mind are really just two translations for the same thing. Does anybody know what the third one is? Right. Yes. Okay.

So I thought I’d bring these in here because it might be something that could create a little bit of confusion as to how the sort of renunciation comes in here and what it has to do with these three principles of the path. So renunciation, the realization of renunciation is one of the three principles. And the the other two are, as as you just heard, awakening mind or bodhicitta, which means this sort of attaining enlightenment for the welfare of all sentient beings on the basis of great love and great compassion. And the third one was wisdom realizing emptiness. So I’ll be talking about those a bit later.

So when we’re talking about realization, for these thoughts to become what’s known as realization, they have to become immensely powerful. They have to become a thought which is totally integrated into the person’s mind stream, so that the thought arises spontaneously all the time without having to be worked for. And this is quite an advanced state to achieve. And But to fit them into the scopes, the person who’s practicing on the lower scope isn’t concerned with any of these realizations at this stage, although they’re hoping in the long term to achieve realization, they’re not particularly concerned with these sorts of renouncing saṃsāra and of bodhicitta, although they might have some sort of long term intention of working towards these things. The person who’s on the who’s looking at the medium scope practice has become very, very aware of the need to attain liberation, and they realize they have to build up this motivation of renunciation.

But we’re not necessarily talking about the realization here. We’re talking about building up this motivation. So when you gain the realization, when it becomes so powerful, that is when the person actually enters what’s called the five paths, the first of the five paths, which is the path of accumulation. And so at that stage, they’re really practicing, really doing very, very serious, very, very earnest practice. But here, when we’re talking about the scopes, we can be trying to practice on these scopes, trying to build up these motivations, so that we can eventually convert them into realizations.

And the so the person who has this realization, who has this motivation of wanting to attain liberation, would be practicing the medium scope. And this is the Hīnayāna motivation of individual liberation. And this person, when they eventually realize renunciation, they enter the Hīnayāna paths. And a person who adds to that the great scope motivation of bodhicitta, of wanting to work for the welfare of all sentient beings, it’s said that eventually the two realizations, not always, but in general, are attained at the same time. You have to attain renunciate you can’t attain bodhicitta before you attain renunciation.

That’s impossible. So there are some beings who, first of all, follow the Hīnayāna path through to its end, and then, after having been arhats for a long, long time, begin to practice the Mahāyāna path. But we’re not concerned with them, but the general way that it’s explained is that you have to cultivate the two motivations together, renunciation of saṃsāra and bodhicitta or awakening mind aspiring to liberate all sentient beings, and that those two are attained together, and that person enters the Mahāyāna paths becoming a bodhisattva. Does that make sense? So the Hīnayāna motivation is concerned with the medium scope, and the Mahāyāna motivation the the great scope motivation is concerned with the Mahāyāna path, and we’re eventually going to try to put all of them together, the whole three scopes.

So the the lower scope isn’t concerned with either of these realizations, but the medium scope is particularly concerned with renunciation. The great scope is concerned with combining renunciation with bodhicitta, and where the third principle of the path, emptiness, comes in. Does anybody want to have a stab at that? Well, you know, where does it come in the three paths, in the three scopes? Well, the practice.

vajrayana? Well, it does come in vajrayana, but in actual fact, Well, vajrayana is included in the Mahāyāna. It’s not a well it can be sometimes sometimes we talk about the three paths, but where we’re talking about the three scopes, that isn’t the same as it doesn’t exactly coincide with the three paths. Because maybe we’re just confusing the issue more and more here. But the three paths are the Hīnayāna, Mahāyāna and vajrayana.

And the Hīnayāna, which is the first path, coincides with the aim of the medium scope. So the first, the lower scope, the small scope isn’t concerned with any of the paths at this stage. It’s concerned with fortunate rebirth, but it’s not concerned with liberation, except in the sense that the person does aspire to attain liberation eventually, but their main practice isn’t concerned with liberation at that stage. They’re not terribly interested in it at that stage. They just know that they have to work for it eventually.

The medium person is very, very concerned with liberation, and that is the Hīnayāna path. The great scope person is very, very concerned with enlightenment. And where vajrayana comes so that’s Mahāyāna scope, Mahāyāna motivation. And where vajrayana comes in is that it brings enlightenment more quickly. So the motivation for that is to not only want to attain enlightenment, but want to attain it as quickly as possible.

But it it it’s a subdivision of the Mahāyāna. So you can divide Mahāyāna into two sectors, Sūtra and Tantra. You often hear the these two divisions being spoken of Sūtra and Tantra. Is everybody clear or is everybody more confused than ever? The last place, wisdom and wisdom.

Okay. So wisdom realizing emptiness has to be attained by both the Hīnayāna practitioners and the Mahāyāna practitioners. Because it’s wisdom realizing emptiness which eradicates the the delusions which hold us in saṃsāra. And The middle and the great So the middle scope and the great scope, they’re both going to be concerned with emptiness. So emptiness becomes very important.

So the person on the small scope might feel that they don’t have to be terribly concerned with emptiness at this stage. They might feel that that’s all too difficult for them, they’re just going to concentrate on building up their accumulation of merit, avoiding bad karmas, and gradually building up their good qualities and so on. And that’s alright for a person at that scope. And once you get interested in the medium and great scopes, you definitely have to start taking an interest in emptiness, because it’s the means by which these scopes the goals of these scopes are going to be attained, which is liberation and enlightenment. So you need an explanation of the difference between liberation and enlightenment.

Somebody wants does somebody anybody have that in a nutshell? It’s more the other way around. That’s practically it. The only thing to add to that is that enlightenment is actually a higher state than the liberation that’s attained by the Hīnayāna arhat. So there’s a lot that can be said about that, and I’m not going to say it tonight.

It comes later. But bodhisattva who’s aiming for full enlightenment has to go past the stage which is attained by the Hīnayāna arhat and keep on they keep on coming back life after life because of the force of their compassion after they’ve already reached the point at which they don’t have to come back under the force of delusion and karma. So the Arhat, the Hīnayāna practitioner who has reached the final goal of the Hīnayāna path, doesn’t come back because of their having achieved that goal of everlasting, peaceful peace of nirvana. And according to the Mahāyāna teachings, they will eventually come back anyway because the Buddhas are going to call them back. But that’s going to be eons and eons later.

So for the present, you can say that they don’t come back. They remain in this blissful state of nirvana. And they haven’t totally achieved the full powers and qualities of a Buddha. And so the bodhisattva keeps on working for these until the final state of perfect enlightenment and omniscience is attained. Okay.

So I was going to talk a lot tonight about suffering, and I haven’t even got onto the topic yet. So maybe you won’t have to think about suffering. But anyway, in order to build towards this realization of renunciation, which means being motivated to work towards liberation, then we have to meditate on the sufferings of cyclic existence. So it’s not enough. Before, we were talking about meditating on the suffering of the lower realm, so as to be motivated to avoid the kind of actions that lead to the lower realms and to perform the sort of actions that will lead to fortunate rebirth.

And we’re not just concerned with those kinds of those kinds of sufferings now, but we’re concerned with developing renunciation with the whole of cyclic existence from the top to bottom, seeing that even the best forms of rebirth in cyclic existence have no essence, no meaning, no lasting benefits, and wanting to be rid of the whole thing. So this is a lot more difficult. It’s very easy to feel that we don’t want to get reborn in the animal realm or the lower states of suffering. But if we accept that these realms exist, then obviously we don’t wanna get reborn in them. But if we were to know about the good things and the god realms, it would be irresistible.

So it’s important to build up this understanding of how these things really have no essence. So the main thing is that even though these some of these realms, the the human realm and the two god realms, have are considered to be upper rebirths. We know that in the human realm, there’s a lot of suffering. In the god realms, there’s very little suffering. They have a very, happy life, but it doesn’t last.

They eventually will fall back again. So we have to just keep on reflecting on this, reflecting on the unsatisfactoriness of samsaric existence from a variety of different points of views until we really convince ourselves that it has no value, until we really convince ourselves that the only meaningful thing is working towards liberation. So I’ll just go in briefly through the meditation on the eight sufferings. I’ll just mention those points. You’ve probably heard them explained before, but these are remembering that we’re subject to birth, old age, sickness, and death, being separated from desirable objects, meeting undesirable objects, not finding what we desire, and being connected with this body, which is like a source of suffering to us, which is going to involve us in suffering.

So there’s a lot of details that could be explained about all of these different sufferings, and if you’re interested in these things, you can read texts such as I suggested before, Liberation in the Palm of the Hand, or there’s a great many other graduated path texts which explain these sufferings. We have to meditate on these, so it’s good to know the details, so we can bring it into our meditation. And have their own particular all of these states that I’ve mentioned have their own particular sufferings. We might wonder why birth is considered to be a suffering according to the Buddhist teachings. Birth is a very uncomfortable situation being in the womb, being born, being a newborn baby is a very uncomfortable and very unpleasant situation.

And all of the other situations, old age, sickness, death, being separated from desirable objects and so on, We all know that these things are undesirable, but we know that we have to experience them, and not only once, but again and again and again. The whole nature of saṃsāra is that it’s cyclic. It means going around in circles. We come back and again and again and again, we experience the same old things, our happiness is never lasting, we always come back to the same old problems, the same old sufferings over and over. So we want to put an end to that.

Another way of looking at it so that was the eight sufferings. We could also look at it from the point of view of six sufferings, which is the uncertainty of cyclic existence. So from one birth to another, there’s no certainty where we’re going to be born. We might have a fortunate rebirth this time, but we don’t know where we’ll go next time. And the only way to put an end to this uncertainty is to get off the wheel.

And even in this life, we can see that things are very uncertain. We can never be certain what’s going to happen to us. While things are going well, we can never be certain that something isn’t going to come along and spoil it. People who appear to be the most fortunate people with the best of of the world’s good things often come crashing down from that position. For instance, Princess Diana, for example, everybody thought that that she had all sorts of you might feel that underneath she was very unhappy, but everybody perhaps felt that she might have had everybody used to refer to her as a fairy tale princess, and she had all these wonderful things happen to her and so on.

But then it all sort of turned bad, and in the end, ended up getting killed while she was still very young. This is just a demonstration of uncertainty. Look at Alan Bond, you know, he was riding high for a while, and everybody couldn’t do too much for him. Everybody wanted to know him. Everybody wanted to socialize with him.

And and now it’s just gone to the other extreme and nobody wants to admit that they were ever his friend. So this is very much a part of cyclic existence, and we shouldn’t be too surprised when things change, when we get let down or when things turn from good to bad, because this is just the nature of things. And if we can just expect that things are going to change and accept this fact, then it’s going to make it a lot easier to deal with it. So I don’t know whether any of you have ever studied with Goenkaji. He used to tell a good story about this.

Yes. Some of you have. So I don’t know whether you’ve heard the story he tells about the there were two brothers whose father died, and one brother got all the family goods and the farm and everything, and the other brother got nothing but a ring. And the ring had a little inscription on it, and the inscription said I think it said something like, this too will pass. Yes.

This too will pass. And the brother who who got the farm and the family wealth and everything misused his opportunities and experienced a lot of suffering. Whereas the the brother who only got the ring kept on going through life, and he made he he saw this inscription, and it struck him. And so he made it his motto in life. And whether things that came to him were good or whether they were bad, he would say, this too will pass.

And so when the good things passed, he wasn’t too unhappy. And when the bad things came along, he wasn’t too upset. And he had a very peaceful, very stable sort of life, and generally his life was a happy one, whereas the other brother who got all the goods was unhappy. And this is something that’s not too difficult to put into practice. It doesn’t require a great deal of realization.

Exactly. Yes. Not to get excited. In fact, Lama Zopa Rinpoche loves to tell the story of the old Indian lady in Darjeeling who won the sweep. And he saw her he and Lama, yes.

She saw this lady running home, and she was so excited. And they found out that she was excited because she’d won some huge amount in a sweep. And he said they’d heard later on that she died of excitement that night. So so a perfect example. So if she just said this too will pass, she wouldn’t have died, probably.

So the other thing is next one is greed, and that is we’re never satisfied. No matter how many good things we have, we always want more. We’re always grasping after more and more and more. And this is a real suffering. It means that we’re always discontented.

So if we can control this greed, if we can be contented, if we can cultivate contentment and satisfaction with a reasonable amount of worldly things, It doesn’t mean we have to give up all worldly things. It just means that we have to be moderate. If we can do this, then we can be happy. The third thing is abandoning our body again and again. And this means that we have to die, and dying is a suffering.

We all feel instinctively that dying is suffering. In actual fact, if we practice that, our actual death can be very peaceful. It can be happy. But we just the thought of dying is something that causes us suffering. We don’t want to die, and we know that we’ll probably have to go through a lot of physical suffering before we die.

So we’ve had to do this again and again. And because in our past lives, we haven’t practiced Dharma, we’ve often died in a state of fear. We’ve often experienced terror and distress, and we’ve resisted the process, and this has caused our dying to be a suffering state. And often, we’ve been reborn into the lower suffering realms. Unless we can get off the wheel, we’re still going to be subject to this suffering of death.

If we die, then we have to be reborn. We have to be conceived and get born again and again into a suffering body. And as I mentioned in connection with the eight sufferings, conception and being in the womb and being born is an uncomfortable, unpleasant situation to be in. Not only that, but just the whole fact of just being born again and again means that we’re going to experience the whole sufferings of life, of aging, sickness, death, all the sufferings that are associated with being born into a body. And that’s even if we’re born into the human realm, and, of course, there are worse kinds of rebirths, much worse rebirths.

And then cycling in saṃsāra, this means that even if we manage to create good karma, purify negativities, and get good rebirth for ourselves, where we’re going to generally experience happiness, we’re not secure from falling back. As long as we’re caught up in the chain, we’re liable to fall back. We can backslide. We can stop practicing Dharma. We can start to pursue negative attitudes and follow wrong actions.

And then we’ll be just creating the cause to go back and not only go backwards, but to go back to the lower realms again. And the sixth one is lack of friends or companions. So we might think we have plenty of friends, we have relatives, we have good close families. Well, these are some of the good things of this life, and they’re not to be slighted. But the fact is that we’re born alone.

We go through the sufferings of our life alone. When we’re really suffering, then we find that we’re experiencing that alone. Other people can comfort us a little, but they can’t take the load of our suffering from us. We just have to endure it ourselves, and we have to endure it while it lasts. And when we die, we die alone, even if all our friends and relatives are gathered around us.

We have to go off into the Bardo state, into the in between state alone, and we have to go on to our next rebirth alone. And so there is this basic aloneness to us. In actual fact, we are very, very connected with others, but we find that there are certain states that we have to experience alone, and that no matter how much we love others, no matter how much they love us, they can’t protect us, and we can’t protect our loved ones from the same thing. And so this is the state of cyclic existence. And so if we want to be finished with this suffering, we have to escape from cyclic existence.

And then there’s three kinds of suffering, which cover the whole lot and which are very, very important and to understand in in this context of renunciation. Does anybody remember the the three kinds of suffering? Suffering. No. Maybe that’s I’m not sure.

That could be suffering of suffering or it could be suffering of change. This is a suffering of change sometimes. So, yes, that’s right. So they actually come in the other order, so suffering suffering of suffering, sometimes it says suffering of misery, which I think is just a way of putting it so that it doesn’t sound quite so funny. Because suffering of suffering sounds funny, doesn’t it?

It probably doesn’t sound so funny in Tibetan. And so suffering of change. So suffering of suffering, suffering of misery is one. Suffering of change and suffering of pervasiveness or extensiveness. I think I’ll say pervasiveness.

That seems to be the most frequent translation. So suffering of misery or suffering of suffering is really easy to understand because it’s what we normally think of as being suffering. And it means when we experience sickness, we experience pain, we experience unhappiness, depression, loss, grief, all of these things. Even the slight ones such as discontent and boredom, all of these things would be suffering of suffering. But anything that we recognize in our everyday course of events as suffering falls into this category.

The second one is the suffering of change. And this is more subtle. And this the suffering of change includes what we think of as being ordinary happiness. And the chocolate cake that we were talking about before is a good example of that. Think of eating chocolate cake as being happiness.

But if chocolate cake was really the cause of happiness, then we could go on eating it and we’d only feel happier and happier the more we ate. But we have to realize that the chocolate cake itself is not the cause of happiness. And in actual fact, in anything that seems to be a cause of happiness, there’s actually a very, very small seed of suffering, even in our happiness, in our worldly happiness, which grows and grows, and until the happy situation turns into suffering. So if we keep on eating chocolate cake, this is the gross example, we’ll soon start to suffer, and we’ll make ourselves feel really sick and suffering if we continue doing it. Or we might say that this is just because we’re stupid to keep on eating until our stomach is overloaded, but it’s the same of any kind of happiness.

The example is that if we’re cold, we go out into the sun and feel warmer, and we see that as being happiness. But if we remain in the sun, we’ll get too hot, and we’ll have to go into the cold into the shade again, and then we’ll see that as being happiness to be relieved from the heat. But soon we’ll start to get cold again. So our whole life is really oscillating between all these different things, and if we look at it, whatever we see as being a cause of happiness only brings us happiness for a little while, and the seed of our discontent, of our dissatisfaction is always there, and it just keeps on growing and growing until no matter how good the situation is, get sick of it and want to change it. So even when we meet a friend, we love to be with them and enjoy their company.

But after a while, we want to go off and be by ourselves or want we want to go off and be with another friend. When we’re doing something we enjoy, we enjoy it for a while. But we soon after a while we get tired of doing that particular activity and we want to go off and do something else, or we want to go and lie down and sleep. And even if we sit in a very comfortable chair and it feels very very comfortable, that position after a while will become uncomfortable. The position in itself was not comfortable, and we keep on moving.

This is just something that is through our lives, through and through, and all our worldly pleasures and enjoyments are like this, and we’re always discontented, and there’s nothing in the nature of any of these samsaric good things that brings lasting happiness or pleasure. And it’s not to say that they don’t bring happiness and pleasure, but just that they bring worldly happiness and pleasure which doesn’t last, which is very, very limited. If you think about this, it’s very much the nature of things, and it’s always going to be like that as long as we stay stuck in cyclic existence. So it’s not worthwhile getting fixated on desirable objects. We get fixated on things thinking we have to have them, getting terribly upset and frustrated if we can’t have what we want, thinking that these things are going to be the real cause of happiness for us.

And because of this fixation, we’re really just creating more unhappiness for ourselves. Of course, it’s necessary to to take care of our bodies, to take care of our worldly lives, and to work towards some of these things. But we should try to keep from being fixated on some particular ideas, some particular projection of what we have, because it only stops us being open to other possibilities. For instance, one extreme example is that if we get fixed on the idea that we have to marry a particular person, and it turns out that we can’t win that particular person, then if we’re really fixed on the idea that this is the only person for us, it keeps us from responding to all the different other people who might become our partners, who might make good partners for us. This is just one example, but we do this kind of thing all the time.

Our minds get very fixed on a particular object. And if we can just let things go a little bit, then we can respond to the situation and actually enjoy life a lot more. Because we just enjoy the good things that come to us, and we don’t get hung up about not always getting what we want. Makes sense? So in actual fact, if we want to be happy in this life, we have to stop trying to be happy in this life.

So that’s the suffering of change, and it’s a little bit subtle, but if we think about it, it does make sense. It’s not really hard to see if we start thinking about it. The third one, the suffering of pervasiveness, is quite difficult to see. And it’s the suffering which is experienced by us simply of being connected with this samsaric body, which they say is like a magnet for suffering. And to us, it’s a very, very subtle suffering.

It’s simply the suffering which pervades cyclic existence. It’s something which is felt very, very strongly by ārya beings, which means those beings who have actually attained direct insight into emptiness. But for us ordinary beings, it’s something that we’re not terribly aware of, simply because it’s so subtle and because we’re involved with much grosser levels of suffering at the moment. And for those beings who have dealt with these gross levels of suffering, who are operating on a much more subtle level, who have achieved states of happiness that we’re still unacquainted with, these beings are actually very, very aware of this subtle level of suffering. They can’t can’t stand to not keep on working until they’ve eradicated this subtle level of pervasive suffering.

So they’re very, very aware of this suffering, and they’re very, very motivated to keep on working until they’ve totally eradicated this subtle level, which is the last level suffering to be got rid of. Whereas for us, we’re often not even terribly aware of the need to get rid of our grosser levels of suffering. So if we keep on meditating on these things, we can can eventually do away with the thought that saṃsāra is something to to be worthwhile pursuing. The good things of saṃsāra are something to be chased after, and we have to just keep on thinking in this way. So I’ll just very briefly mention what we have to do.

There’s not a lot of time to talk about it, but it wouldn’t finish off the talk in a rounded sort of way if I just left it at this point. So the actual practice that has to be engaged in is following the three higher trainings. And I won’t ask you what those are because we’re running a bit short of time, so I’ll just tell you. So the three higher trainings are the higher training of conduct, of concentration, and of wisdom. So there’s actually other things that come into the medium scope too.

One of the really interesting things is the looking at the wheel of life. And we’ll be talking about that. So but what we’re going to do is look at the three higher trainings and how to engage in those. And the first one, conduct or moral conduct. We’ve already been talking about moral conduct.

So at this point, the person who’s engaged in medium scope practice has basically the same kind of conduct, but carrying it on further, refining it. So it’s not basically different, but it’s just looking at more and more subtle levels, more and more moral discipline, looking at avoiding some of the lesser mistakes that could be made. And by carrying this on further and further, they achieve a greater and greater degree of discipline. And this moral discipline is very important, not just for the avoidance of negative karma, but also for the development of mental calm and peace. The person who’s following moral discipline in a thorough way is a person who is avoiding a lot of causes for distraction and agitation.

And so this enables the mind to become more stable and peaceful. And that’s an absolute prerequisite for the other two higher trainings, which are concentration and wisdom. Concentration is when we’re talking about concentration and wisdom, we’re talking about meditation, essentially. So at this level, we’re really getting into meditation practice. It’s possible for a person to follow small scope practice without worrying too much about meditation.

But when you want to follow medium and great scope practice seriously, then you have to meditate. You have to at least start to develop meditation. And the goal of the practice of concentration is to reach the higher levels of concentration. And that involves quite fantastic levels of single pointed concentration, not only being able to remain in single pointed concentration on the object in a very, very powerful way, but to attain various levels beyond that, a state which is described, which is called Samatha, and which involves achieving a state of mental and physical ecstasy and tremendous mental power to remain concentrated on the object of concentration. So that’s explained in a lot of details in the text.

It’s quite a very, very interesting topic, easier to read about and learn about than to actually push into practice. But we can start to practice meditation now and gradually cultivate our ability to remain concentrated on a topic. And practice of wisdom, as we were talking before, involves understanding the topic of emptiness, which is a very, very profound topic and which involves understanding the true nature of all existence, both the self and external objects, but we’re particularly concerned with the nature of the self. And this involves having to study and analyze, gaining an analytical understanding of the topic of emptiness, and then having gained that understanding thoroughly, applying it, this kind of analytical meditation, combined with the ability that has also been gained of single pointed concentration, and applying the single pointed concentration to the meditation on emptiness. And the person who is able to engage in that sort of practice will eventually develop to the point where they can gain direct insight into emptiness.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
graduated path of the three capable beings kye bu sum gyi lam gyi rim pa (Tib)
The three levels of practice of the lower, middle and higher capable being, based on the motivations of trying to attain a better future rebirth, liberation or enlightenment. Also known as the three scopes. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA
three higher trainings lhagpäi lab pa sum (Tib)
The three higher trainings of ethics, concentration and wisdom when conjoined with refuge in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top