30 min · 3,804 words · 3 April 1991 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Śāntideva’s jaundice-and-stick analogy anchors this 31-minute session by Ven Jampa Gendun on refraining from retaliation — the third dimension of tolerance. He opens by framing anger as a faulty self-correcting mechanism, then uses the demigod’s cosmic grievance (a tree rooted in their realm but fruiting in the gods’) as an image of senseless resentment. The central argument drawn from Śāntideva is that since we don’t get angry at jaundice for hurting us — it arose without volition, through causes and conditions — there is no coherent basis for anger at a person who harms us, since their anger arose the same way. Ven Jampa Gendun traces this through dependent arising and closes with a short refutation of the Sāṃkhya concept of a permanent, self-caused primordial substance to sharpen the Buddhist case.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 14 Tce 1991 04 03.mp3
UUID: 826d2c15-e25f-4ac0-9cff-670a6c4498cc
Teacher: Ven Jampa Gendun
Collection: Tolerance (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Date: 1991-04-03
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 31.0 minutes
Words: ~3,798
But our nature trying to grip, to relieve the tension from the mind, distress, unhappiness. But it doesn’t work. It’s ineffective, inappropriate. And we have to try to rely on higher orders of self correction which is dharma. That’s all.
This self correcting mechanism, coping mechanism isn’t working properly. We have to recognize that. That’s all. And there are other more skillful, more effective self correcting mechanisms that we can begin to introduce into the mind. We can avail ourselves of.
And once these become a pattern, then anger no longer is taking recourse to. Other more appropriate, more effective means of self correcting the mind will begin to take over and we will experience more desirable state. It will be more in our own self best interest to make use of it. So this is dharma. Higher orders of self correction maybe.
And then the third area, viewing our situations in terms of these more effective self correcting mechanisms, ways of viewing, relating. And then the third area which we’re trying to look at in terms of tolerance is restraining, not restraining, refraining, refraining from retaliation. Whatever we do, we’re going to have problems. Mean in ordinary mundane context. If we all become Buddhists and we don’t have problems.
I don’t know. Some people say the Buddhists have problems. They still have all these sentient beings running around suffering that they have to work with. But it’s not problematic. They don’t get upset about it.
They just get about what needs to be done. Accepting our problems, we won’t compound our suffering, our difficulties, to the distress that demands that things be other than the way they are. This is the mentality of the demigods. Simply think in the demigod realm, as I mentioned, there’s the six levels of desire that we live in, what is called the desire realm. And in this realm there’s six levels.
There’s animals, there’s hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, demigods and gods. One of the problems with the demigods is that there’s this huge tree which is rooted in their realm, in their level. But it grows up and the topmost part of the tree where the fruit is growing is up in the god realm. And so they’re always at war with the Gods. Somehow the universe shouldn’t be like that.
It shouldn’t be constructed. Here the roots are here. And it’s just not right that the roots are in my realm and the fruits up there where I can’t get at it. I mean, the universe shouldn’t be constructed like that. We’ve got to do something about that.
And this is the, you know, the, it’s just causing you distress. There’s nothing that can be done. It’s just the nature of the situation. You’re willing to begin to confront our difficulties and endure the legitimate suffering. What is That quote by you last week where all neurosis has its basis in the avoidance of legitimate suffering.
Legitimate suffering that having created the causes we experience the result. It’s appropriate. The situation is appropriate. And why compound it by saying it shouldn’t be like that or avoiding the necessity to work with the situation, to deal with the situation as if it either didn’t exist or it’s going to go away by itself. Throughout all this process there’s no room for the neurotic stress reducing pattern of anger to run when we’re working with the situation.
It’s not comfortable to deal with problems. Not comfortable to deal with conflict. No one’s saying that but that’s legitimate suffering. To avoid is neurosis and that has no end of suffering. We can solve our problems by accepting that legitimate and working through them.
The conflict avoidance simply compounds our problems and the problem remains. So in this process of working with this situation, there’s no room for anger to arise. We’re not compounding difficulties with the distress about trying to avoid or think the situation should be otherwise. So it’s like being willing to accept a little bit of suffering quite wisely as opposed to a great deal of suffering quite foolishly in the end. But it takes a little higher order, a little perspective to begin to see that in your life.
You have to begin to step back and deal with situations on perhaps a more deeper level than the superficial way we usually deal with them. And with respect to this second area of tolerance, trying to see situations in terms of Dharma, in terms of spiritual practice, in terms of higher orders of self correction. The Śāntideva now begins an explanation of tolerance, the practice of tolerance. according to the text, when I am not angry with such things as bile — we got into this a little bit, but we didn’t get very far. There was some digression.
When I am not angry with such things as bile, which are the source of great suffering, for what reason do I get angry with beings endowed with consciousness? For they too are provoked by conditions. So we’re trying to look at a situation from the point of view of dharma, from the point of view of changing our viewpoint to more effective ways of dealing with the situation such that we don’t become distressed. We are trying to create, change the significance that we give the situation, the meaning that we view the situation with. There’s two types of ways of viewing significance that we don’t get distressed.
But we have to deal with facts. We’re not saying that black is white or good is bad or bad is good. We can’t do that. But we can change the way that we view the facts. Now Śāntideva is beginning this analysis of the deluded rationale of anger.
We’re going to analyze our particular view of how we usually justify our anger. And he’s going to use a critique. And this critique is permeated by a true awareness of conditionality or dependent arising. And the heart of Buddhism is dependent arising is the Buddhist slogan. And it pervades all of Dharma, all of the self correcting mechanisms that we’re working with, this understanding of emptiness.
And we see how it works. All things whatsoever are under the power of something else. Everything is under the power of something else. Nothing is self powered. Nothing brings about itself.
Nothing is self defined. All things arise in dependence upon something other than themselves, something from other factor than themselves. On causes, for example, on causes and conditions which are not themselves. A thing cannot be its cause. The cause and effect must be different.
Things do not give rise to themselves. They are other powers. Everything is under other powers. You are under other powers. This table is other powers.
Situations are other powers. My anger is other power. My enemy’s anger is other power. The bile, the jaundice, which brings me suffering is other power. For example, Śāntideva is trying to sort out the deluded rationale, mistaken ways of viewing our present inconsistent way of viewing situations which causes distress.
You know when a person gets sick from jaundice, that person experiences suffering. What is it that gives that person suffering? It’s the disease. That person experiences physical suffering from jaundice. That which gives a person physical suffering is a disease.
Likewise, when someone hits you over the head with a stick, you experience physical suffering. What caused you that physical suffering? That person that hit you with a stick. So we’re taking a parallel case. If both situations, if physical suffering is experienced as a result of both jaundice and being hit over the head with a stick.
Why do we usually, normally, usually, okay, why do we usually get angry at the person who hits us with a stick but we usually don’t get angry. We usually don’t get angry at the jaundice. Okay? Usually we would get angry at the person who hits us a stick, we usually wouldn’t get angry at the jaundice. Though, in fact, they’re both bringing us physical suffering.
So the average individual would answer that it makes no sense to get angry at your jaundice because it didn’t decide to arise. It didn’t decide to cause you to suffer. It didn’t have volition. It had no intention to hurt you. That makes sense.
It didn’t arise out of its own power. It’s not under its own control. Certain conditions in the body occur. Maybe you drink a lot, you have bad liver, something. I don’t know all the conditions for jaundice.
But the condition is present in the body. And when those conditions and causes aggregate, come together, are present, jaundice arises. The jaundice didn’t decide to rise. It’s not up against you. It just occurred, not under its own power, under the power of cause and condition.
It’s just simply a part of the natural flow of events, way all this flux of causes and conditions. When these causes and conditions of the body, certain conditions are present, this disease is arising. It didn’t mean to arise. It didn’t want to arise. It did not want to arise.
It just didn’t have volition. It didn’t have any intention. And it doesn’t mean to hurt you. It’s not out to get you. It’s just there.
But its nature is that it hurts you when it’s there. It doesn’t mean to. That’s its nature. So if this is the rationale that we can justify for and we can use for not getting angry at jaundice, then it makes no sense to get angry at someone who harms us, this person who hits us with a stick. Because the same rationale is exactly the same as for jaundice.
Just as jaundice arises when specific conditions are present, anger arises in the other person’s mind when specific conditions are present. The person who is afflicted with jaundice is under the control of something other than themselves, some factor other than themselves. Likewise, the person who hits us with a stick is under the control of a factor other than themselves. That is, he hit us under the influence of the anger within his own mind. You know, if we’re going to get angry at anyone, we should get angry at the anger in that person’s mind.
It shouldn’t be toward that person, but the anger within their own mind, that anger which is controlling that person. That person is under the control of that anger. We are not our patterns. The person is not their anger. They have come under the control of anger.
Śāntideva goes on. Illness, for example, breaks out without wishing to do so. Likewise, emotions violently erupt, though not wishing, through no wish of their own. An illness develops, breaks out, whether we wish it to or not. Likewise, the various afflictive emotions arise in our mind and the minds of others whether we wish them to or not.
Whether we wish to get angry or wish to not get angry, still anger arises in our mind. Whether we wish to have jaundice or we wish not to have jaundice, still jaundice arises in our body. We might think there’s a difference between these two because the illness the illness and the enemy. Because the illness has no wish to hurt us while the enemy does. They’re not the same.
But what we’re trying to understand is that the enemy who wishes to harm us does so without any freedom. He does so under control of his anger. Śāntideva goes on, people suddenly get angry without first having thought, will get angry. Similarly, anger arises without first having thought, I will arise, Without considering beforehand, now I’m going to become angry, anger simply arises and takes over our mind, takes control of our mind without our choice, without our even wishing it or not wishing it. Without any control over it.
And the anger itself comes into being without first thinking, ‘Now I’m going to produce myself.’ Śāntideva goes on, whatever difficulties there are and the various kinds of evil all come about through the force of conditions. They have no power of their own. The assembled conditions have no intention to produce any thing and their products have no intention to be produced. So all of our problems, all of our difficulties and unskillful actions that we create and all of the very afflictive emotions which arise in our mind arise simply through the force of condition. They do not govern themselves.
Anger did not arise by thinking I am going to arise and give this guy a hard time. Simply when there exists certain conditions within the mind, within the situation, within the environment, a particular pattern of mind will arise. In this case, anger. It did not decide to arise. We did not wish it to arrive.
It arose simply in response to specific conditions, specific types of circumstances. For example, frustrated desire, an object preventing you from realizing your desire, and a distressed mind. Given those conditions, this pattern of mind called anger will arise. It didn’t decide to arise. The person didn’t say, I’m going to develop anger, intentionally bringing it about.
It simply arose and now it is that person’s mind. There is no mind other than that. You know when we make an analysis of the nature of the self, in terms of the conventional nature of the self, we ask questions such as, what do we mean when we say I change my mind? We use that phrase, that expression quite often. I change my mind.
What does that mean? What does it mean when we say I didn’t mean to do that? I lost my temper. I’m not myself today. You know, it seems like there’s this we have all very strange ways of speaking.
As if there’s things that sometimes, it doesn’t make, a lot of it doesn’t make any sense whatsoever. I change my mind. I change my mind. You have a mind and there’s something which changes it. That’s what we think.
And it causes a great deal of suffering. This deluded way of thinking. I was just overcome by anger. There’s a big war going on. Sometimes I lost control.
I was overcome by anger. You should overcome your anger. None of these factors govern themselves. It’s perhaps the idea of control. It’s a touchy area because it can be mistaken.
It can be easily misconstrued when we talk about the nature of what control we do have. You know, the Buddha said that suffering there is but no one has suffered. The path there is but no one who journeys it. nirvana there is but no one who attains it. So, you know, on a conventional level, on a mundane level, when we talk with one another and say, I’m not going to go tomorrow, I change my mind.
Oh, I didn’t mean to say that. I lost my head. It makes sense. But when we perhaps when we begin to analyze and probe a little deeper, we begin to see that perhaps there’s some mistaken premises upon a lot of these ways of thinking are based. And perhaps these are causing us some problems on a deeper level.
So when the assembled conditions which which bring us suffering, they have no intention to produce suffering. Anger doesn’t intend to hurt us. The resultant suffering doesn’t think I was produced by the assembled conditions. The angry person, the anger itself, and all the things in general are completely without volition, without intention. They depend solely upon causes and conditions.
Understanding this conditionality, you know, with dependent arising, the nature of all things. It will help us not to see that there is some thing which is preventing us from gaining the object of our desire. There’s no thing. It simply is not in the present situation of causes and conditions. This present context of the flux of causes and conditions is such that my desire cannot be realized at present.
It’s completely impersonal. I don’t know. Maybe that people don’t like to think that way. It’s not very sentimental. It’s not romantic.
That within the present context, this flux of causes and conditions, that they are such that my desires cannot be realized within this present context. There’s no one there’s nothing which is preventing me. There’s no one. You know, it’s not this this person over there. It’s just not in the it’s not in the nature of my present situation.
You know, why get angry at the darkness? Because it prevents you from seeing what you want to look at. We are acknowledging that the present condition is not supportive to what you desire. It’s like what? Basically, go with the flow, but at the same time, look for the light switch, something like that.
Śāntideva is pointing out that it makes no sense to become angry at constantly changing flux of causes and conditions which which have no independent nature. They have no intention to harm you. They have no intention to prevent you from gaining your desire. They have no intention at all. They did not choose to harm us, though in fact they may harm us.
No doubt, a stick hitting you on your head hurts. The stick didn’t choose. The person didn’t choose. Even the anger of that person didn’t choose. in dependence upon cause and conditions, harm arose.
So then Śāntideva goes to a few verses which are perhaps not so relevant to us. But anyway, we can take a look at them in terms of some ancient non-Buddhist schools of philosophy. Which they talking about is trying to say that everything is under the power of other factors, is under the control of other factors other than themselves. But there are some non-Buddhist schools, such as the Sāṃkhya, which they’re saying that things do have independent existence, self power. And therefore, Śāntideva is going to be thorough about his argument.
He has to refute these others, these non-Buddhist schools as to whether things can help us, you know, whether things can help us or harm us. Within the context of Christianity, have to ask the question. The position of God with respect to his creatures. If you know, Buddhism, we’re trying to see our harm and our help in terms of causes and conditions, this flux, and that we play a central part in creating those causes and in working with those conditions. So it’s very much a matter of self responsibility for whatever happens to you.
Whereas perhaps in Christianity there’s an element that perhaps it may be in certain degrees, I don’t know, out of your hands depending upon whether you’re pleasing God or you’re not displeasing God or whether God is capricious, just his choice, whatever he feels like that day. I don’t know. But, I mean, the questions have to be taken out. So here’s Śāntideva’s beginning to look at some of the non-Buddhist schools which did take this into account. The Sāṃkhya school asserts the existence of what is called a nature, or a primordial substance, or a general principle.
And this possesses certain unique characteristics. This is what it’s like there was an underlying and this is a particular view set forth by this particular religion, this philosophy. They said there was like a primordial substance. They called it the nature. And out of this stuff, everything arose.
I should have thought. Some nature, some everything in the environment arose out of this. But it in itself was permanent. It had some very unique characteristics. For example, they say this primordial substance is the cause of the environment, the beings living therein, and the objects of our senses.
But although it’s the cause of all of these various things, in itself it is causeless. The primordial substance, the nature is causeless. It’s independent. It’s permanent. And Buddhism, when we say permanent, we mean unchanging.
So there’s something from which all of these various the world around us and all the objects of my senses arises, which creates them. But in itself, it’s permanent, unchanging, independently existing. So Śāntideva points out that many contradictions in this way of in this this assertion. In the actual text, goes on to say, nor can nature this is what nature is what this primordial principle, primordial substance, a general principle or the self. There was a assertion of non-Buddhist schools that there was a self.
A self which was partless, unchanging and independent. Partless, unchanging and independent. Nor can nature or the self deliberately think, I will come into being before they actually do. For what could desire to be produced while still unproduced and non existent? So if the nature or this primordial substance were as the samkhyas assert, causeless and unproduced, then this primordial substance would not arise dependent upon the thought, now I shall produce myself.
Now I shall make myself come into existence because it’s not dependent upon causes. And the thought, I shall produce myself is a cause. So it’s not dependent upon being produced by the thought, I shall bring myself into being. Śāntideva goes on, Such a self could also never cease because it would be permanently diverted to its object. So if its nature were independent, it could not be produced, it could not produce anything.
If the self were independent, it could not utilize, utilize any objects. It would have no relationship. It would not could not be affected nor it could affect anything else. The nature of an unchanging object is that it cannot stand it cannot bring about any effects. To bring about an effect is necessary to change.
In order for a seed to grow into a flower, the seed has to go through a process of transformation. In order to build a table from trees, you have to cut down the trees. You have to plane them, saw them, glue them together. They have to go through quite a change in order to produce a table, an effect. So nothing which is unchanging can produce an effect.
It has to go through a transformation in order to bring about an effect. How can effect be produced from something that is supposedly unchanging? And if the self were permanent, again unchanging, then whatever it heard, whatever it saw, it would always see that eternally. And if something is permanent, unchanging, then once it hears something, it always hears that. Once it sees something, it always sees that.
Because it can’t change. It can’t go from one object to another, hearing different things or seeing different things.
Key terms in this teaching
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- Samkhya drang chen pa (Tib)
- Early non-Buddhist philosophical school; the so-called "enumerators," because they advocate a definite enumeration of the causes that produce existents. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.