Tolerance — 1991-03-06

1 h 23 min · 8,736 words · 6 March 1991 · Buddha House Adelaide

Tolerance (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Tolerance (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Tolerance — 1991-03-06
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Three teaching parables anchor this 84-minute talk by Ven Jampa Gendun on tolerance: a Chinese minister who refuses to wade in muddy water, a boat collision that angers only when someone is aboard, and a traveler who imagines starting a forest fire from a single match. Gendun uses them to map the two conditions and one cause of anger — frustrated desire, an identified obstacle, and an unhappy mind — arguing that anger dissolves when any one is absent. Before that analysis he revisits three types of faith (clear, longing, convincing) and the importance of wholehearted commitment over hesitant, half-hearted practice, quoting Jung’s remark that belief implies inexperience. The session’s central reversal: enemies, not friends, are the true teachers of patience. He closes by urging practitioners to see their problems as expressions of life itself rather than isolable units, and to proceed with gentle, consistent effort rather than waiting for sudden transformation.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 07 Tce 1991 03 06.mp3

UUID: e7d54667-d858-4273-a19d-c5588cf5a059

Teacher: Ven Jampa Gendun

Collection: Tolerance (Ven Jampa Gendun)

Date: 1991-03-06

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 83.9 minutes

Words: ~8,734

And last week, I was talking about the two causes for this continual process of reorientation, this continual process of reprioritizing our values, redirecting ourselves. Basically, anxiety, or we can call it dread and faith. These are the two causes which motivate us, which impel us, which assist us in perpetually, continually making effort to reorientate ourselves and setting our rudder in the right direction. You know, a rudderless ship may move in the direction that it desires, and again, may not. It’s completely at the mercy, as it were, of variables beyond its control.

But if we simply add a rudder, we add some direction, then there may be some resistance to going in that particular direction. But at least we’re eventually going to move. There’s some hope of achieving our goal, our end. I talked about these two causes of dread anxiety, and faith. We have a sense of disappointment, I think.

It’s perhaps very subtle that tomorrow we hope our expectations are going to be fulfilled. Somehow, we’re going to achieve some kind of end. Our life is going to achieve some kind of conclusion. And there’s always a sense tomorrow there will be this fulfillment which I continually have been working toward. Then that tomorrow becomes today, and that today becomes yesterday.

And we didn’t achieve fulfillment. We didn’t come to any conclusion. This perpetual struggle that we seem to be involved in was never a moment’s respite. We’re never a sense of we’ve we’ve arrived. And there’s a sense of disappointment, almost a sadness.

Maybe this sadness. Maybe, you know, that’s that’s another word, another cause. Dread, fear, anxiety. Some kind of very deep felt disappointment. And then there was faith.

And I talked about two types of faith. There was reasoned faith and believing faith. And there’s another way to categorize faith, to see it in terms of three types of faith. It’s what is termed clear faith, longing faith, and convincing faith. The one analogy that’s used quite often is that you’re out on a desert, and you’re very thirsty.

And you have an idea. It becomes clear to you what your problem is. It’s an assumption. You haven’t really experienced that there may be a solution to your problem. At this moment, it’s still assumption, but it becomes clear to you what the problem is, and you assume that there is a solution to your problem.

And then you go out and search for that solution. And you hear you hear it stream, you know, gurgling in the distance. And then and then begin to think, ah, this is this is the solution to my problem. There’s some indication that you’re you’re getting near, and there arises a longing. And then you actually arrive at the stream and you drink the water, and your thirst is, what do you say, assuaged, is alleviated.

And you become convinced out of your own experience. So there was this progression from a clear faith which began to recognize its problem, which began to assume that perhaps there was a solution to a longing faith, which saw that the solution was near, had some indication, and then finally a convincing faith where there was some actual experience of at least part of the solution of the problem. And likewise, within connection with the teachings, you you hear an explanation of the predicament of our human condition. And it’s not something divorced from your immediate experience. He or she is talking about your own life very intimately, as if they knew you well.

And they begin to talk about possible solutions, methods to solve this problem, this dilemma that we’re all involved in. And at first there’s something assumption. You know, it’s clear that they have an understanding of the problem. But and they offer some type of solution, but it’s merely an assumption. But you do develop a clear faith.

There’s a clarity because they have described your predicament as if they knew you well. And so you begin to reflect. You know, this is their solution. We have to make that solution our own solution. We have to unlock for ourselves.

The best that a teacher can do, the best that a Buddha can do is point to possible solutions and guide you and help you in finding your own solution. And so out of this we begin to reflect, to contemplate, and we begin to develop a sense of inference, I can see the logic of what they’re talking about. It starts to make sense. I haven’t experienced the solution, but at least intellectually, at least on a superficial level, becoming reasonable. And so we we feel like we’re getting close to something, and it develops a sense of a longing faith.

Maybe this is what I’m looking for. Maybe this is the answer to my problems. And then as we begin to reason, to work, to integrate the solution, to find its relevancy within our own experience, then we actually begin to experience the solution itself in our everyday experience, our everyday life. And then there’s convincing faith beyond hypotheses, beyond assumption, beyond logic, but in the very marrow of our experience. So there’s this gradual unfoldment of the types of faith, you know, from assumption to inference to direct perception.

You know, I once now I I think I’ve mentioned that don’t have to believe in anything, that Buddhism doesn’t ask you to believe in anything. It doesn’t even ask you to believe in Buddhism. It does ask you to experiment. Once, I think Carl Jung was asked if he believed in God. He says, I don’t believe in God.

I know God. To believe means that you don’t know, that you haven’t experienced. Buddhism is something to be experienced, not to be simply believed in, as if it was something which has not been integrated into ourselves. And this is the ultimate goal of convincing faith, that you have found at least the taste of the solution. And then there’s no there’s no you know, the whole process of it’s a meditation, of going for refuge, is committing ourselves to a path.

We do everything with everything in bits and pieces. We’re fragmented. We never give ourselves over to anything. We always hold back. You know, people, they enter into these days, they enter into a marriage.

And if they’re rich, they sign a contract saying, When we get our divorce, this is the way we’ll divide it up. And they’re already They’re just getting married. They’re already planning for their divorce. There’s no real commitment to one another, to the possibility of staying with it through all the ups and downs of a relationship. We never so even in the process of meditation, the process of listening, reflecting, and meditating, By the power of the wisdom arising out of listening and reflecting, we go beyond all hesitation, all doubt until we reach the point where we can wholeheartedly give ourselves over without reservation, without fear to the process we can become.

There’s a great there last week, there was a eleventh a year eleven class came, I was giving a talk about Buddhism too. And we did a short meditation. And I asked some of the boys, one boy in particular, he obviously didn’t want to meditate. And I said, you know, what was your problem? And he said, I was afraid.

He wasn’t sure. Well maybe he would go crazy just watching the breath. He wasn’t sure. He wasn’t there was some fear, a real fear. He didn’t have enough confidence to give himself over to that process.

And there’s a there’s a part of ourselves in everything that we do in our relationships, in in our practice of the Dharma, and in our meditation, in almost every facet of our life that there’s a hesitation, there’s a fear, there’s a holding back. And we never give ourselves wholeheartedly over to anything in particular. And this is the shallow aspect of our lives, that we never really feel anything to the marrow of our bones. And so the process of convincing faith is this giving over from the very marrow of our bones to a process of change, and then change will take place. The process of listening, reflecting as a means to give up, to overcome our hesitation, to overcome our doubts, to overcome our fears, so that we will give ourselves over to the process of getting used to of meditation, getting used to a new way of being rather than holding back something reserved out of fear, out of doubt, some kind of hesitation.

So it’s not something that we have to some kind of energy and No, I think many people they expect a teacher to as if give them a realization transplant, as it were. If that could have been done, it would have been done by now. You know, the Buddha said, I do not wash away sins with water. I do not remove suffering with my hands, nor do I transfer my realization to the minds of others. But by the showing of the truth, all will be made free.

A teacher can do many things, a qualified teacher, that is to say. A teacher can inspire us. They can guide us, they can give us the means, the methods to work. But it’s very much a matter of our own initiative as to whether that is going to be a means to help us to change our mind. You know, Dharma, these practices or whatever the methods, they aren’t intrinsically beneficial.

They nothing we have to find a key to open the potential of these techniques and methods of the teacher as a means for transmission, as a means to enable them to change our mind. There has to be a great deal of effort. You know, it’s said traditionally that the Buddhas are always trying to help us. There’s never a moment when they’re not trying to help us. But it’s a matter from our side, opening up to the possibility, opening up to the necessity of change.

You know, when we see it, it’s necessary to change, then change will take place. When we begin to you know, it requires some work on our side to remove our doubts, to remove this hesitation, to remove our fears. It’s simply we cannot allow it to the teachings, these various methods, the Dharma, to remain like oil on water. It just pollutes the situation. It doesn’t help it.

Think we still, even when we come to the Dharma, we still bring our habitual expectation of finding the solutions outside of our self. And we begin to and I grew up and I thought, well, if I I could I always was looking for a psychiatrist who would who wanted to do some special thesis or something, and they they could use me as experimental subject. And then I thought, well, if I find out, I’ll be okay. And then I thought, well, then I transferred that to finding the right wife. And then I transferred that to my teacher.

Now I had given up. Know the teacher student relationship is extremely profound as I talked about in the introductory Buddhism class. It’s not something it goes beyond the mere level of academia where you go to a university and you sit there and you absorb or you you swallow information from this person up there. But it you know, I mentioned this, but maybe it’s worth I don’t want to get home and get carried away. So, okay, we’ll go to that sometime.

These two facts. I mean that is to say you know, the idea of anxiety, dread, else I see, sadness, disappointment, this sense that if I don’t change, things are going to remain very much as they had been up to now. And this beginning to recognize the themes, the reoccurring patterns of our life. And developing a sense of foreboding about future possibilities unless I change. There’s no reason why things should be any different than they are now if the causes and the patterns remain intact, which they are.

There’s self it’s a negative feedback loop. They just keep self reinforcing themselves continually. We have to begin to introduce variables of liberation. This dread of repeating what has already gone before. And the faith, you know, working through these levels beyond assumption, beyond intellect, but being able to taste in the marrow of your bones.

And giving yourself over to the process. That is to say, it’s not a giving over. Can say giving over to that or being willing to take in here. Something comes together. There’s a joining, there’s a union, there’s a meeting place, there’s a transmission, there’s some change occurs.

And this has to be worked at. It doesn’t come naturally. You know, we’ve all been going for refuge our entire lives. It’s not something new. It’s not a particular Eastern trip, it were.

And many of us go for refuge to sex, drugs, alcohol, other people, money, cars. So we give ourselves over to those things. Begin to question whether they work or whether there’s another possibility, another alternative. Refuge until I am enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma and the highest assembly. When the virtuous merit that I collect by practicing giving and the other perfections, may I attain the state of a Buddha to be able to benefit all sentient beings.

I go for refuge until I am enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, and the highest assembly. From the virtuous merit that I collect by practicing giving and the other perfections may I attain the state of a Buddha to be able to benefit all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, and the highest assembly. And the virtuous merit that I collect by practicing giving and the other perfections, may I attain the state of the Buddha to be able all sentient beings. All the various afflictive emotions are the mind’s attempt not to accept what is.

Jung said that any time there is an affective element in a description or a relationship, affect by affective some sort of emotional content element. For example, there’s always going to be some projection. If describe my next door neighbor as being five foot, ten inches, one hundred and fifty pounds, brown hair, blue eyes, that’s what we call an objective description. There’s no particular emotional element, affective element in that description. The moment I say my neighbor is a nice guy, then there’s projection.

Either a greater or lesser projection. That my neighbor is now serving as a basis for my projection of what a nice guy ism, whatever that might be. He may be a nice guy. That is to say, by the standards of a worldly convention, that he’s a nice guy. You know, very much Buddhism would accept this idea, you know, that we have an ideal, what we call valid cognition or a valid cognition.

An valid cognition would perceive this person as a nice guy. This is the standard of worldly conventions, a consensus. And there are other people who are not nice people or nasty people. You know the Buddha did not say that we should see black as white or that we should see bad or good as good. The Buddha said that what I teach does not contradict what is accepted in the world.

That is, what is cannot be contradicted. You may propagandize yourself, you may brainwash yourself into believing black is white. But that still doesn’t make black white. So all the various afflictive emotions are the mind’s stubborn refusal, a misguided attempt not to accept what is for one reason or another. In the case of attachment, what is seen are the exaggerated, appealing qualities of the object, masking any type of unappealing negative qualities about it.

It’s not seen as what it is, in fact, in a balanced way. The opposite holds true for anger. What is seen are only the undesirable, negative, unappealing, unattractive, repulsive, ugly qualities about that object, masking any positive, attractive, appealing qualities. So, whatever types of activities, actions that we are motivated which are motivated out of attachment or anger, are inappropriate to to the way the situation really is. We’re not that we’re we’re distorted.

We we miss see. We misunderstand. And any action which arises out of that misunderstanding is inappropriate. And we always have to this perpetuate having to create engage in more actions to clean up the mess we made from before. It’s a never ending process of cleaning up the messes that we make out of our previous inappropriate actions.

Ultimately, any action motivated by the confused conception of ignorance, the misconception as to the nature of the I, the nature of the self, is perpetuating this process of having to again and again engage in actions to keep cleaning up the messes that we made from before. And this process, within this process, there’s no peace. There’s no rest. It is dissatisfactory. And they’re based upon the misconception of the nature of the self.

Now with conceiving a concrete, solid I, Jampa, this person over here, something which is independent of my condition, my environment, my history, my culture, my peers. Some unit, homogenous, solid, unchanging, permanent. Misconceiving, holding that type of I, we generate attachment toward anything which seems to confirm our sense of I. We want to incorporate whatever that object is as to make it a permanent part of our self, to make it a permanent part of this I. Anything which we see is which is conceived of as threatening to this misconceived I, we generate repulsion, aversion, hatred, anger.

We want to make it a permanent want to permanently be separated from that object. So all of the various afflictive emotions arise on the basis of the misconception of the nature of the ah, ignorance. They all represent inappropriate reactions to what is. And this is basically what meditation is about, getting used to what is. No matter how superficial the level it might appear, this is the way we can begin to learn about the way it is accept it.

Give ourselves over to what is. So all of the afflictive emotions are inappropriate reactions to what is. But additionally, in the case of anger, it is also not only inappropriate to what is, it is a self defeating behavior. And the Buddha likened anger to someone reaching in fire with their bare hands to take out a hot coal in order to throw it at somebody to hurt them. Inevitably, oneself is hurt in the process and without doubt.

An angry person is suffering at that very moment. Anger is a vindictive vindictive attitude, a harmful attitude. We want to hurt. It’s directed you know, it can be directed at another person. It can be directed at our own suffering.

It can be directed at a particular object. You know, it’s quite easy to see that we can become angry at an enemy. That’s no problem. We can become angry at our own illness, at our own fault, at our own inability, which we do a lot, don’t we? And we can become angry at objects.

Hit you hit your thumb with a hammer. Oh, yeah. The the good one what is that? The good one is when you you stumble you trip over a rock and you kick the rock. It’s worse than it was before.

We want we want to harm. We want to hurt. We want this object removed. Get away. I don’t want you this part of my ego identity.

It’s a threat to me. It’s an attitude which which cannot tolerate or remain undisturbed. There are two conditions and one cause for anger. Two conditions and one cause. Conditions are like, you know, I’ll give you an example of conditions and causes.

A cause would be a flower seed. It’s the substance which is in which the information, the controlling material is going to be transformed. Conditions would be water, earth, sunlight. So these coming together, these causes and conditions aggregating, coming together, give rise to anger. And I thought, you know, rather than telling you what this cause and these two conditions are, I found some paragraphs, a few paragraphs on each of them.

And maybe they will describe what each of these is. And then maybe I’ll read one and maybe you can tell me. So this first I’m going read a paragraph, a very short paragraph. And it’s one of the first conditions necessary for anger, I think. In my mind, it sort of describes this first condition necessary for anger.

It’s from a you know, it takes place in China, in ancient China. It’s about a dismissal of a minister of government in ancient China by the name of Kutsugen. Kutsugen was dismissed from office. He went to the river and sat sighing by the river. He looked like a skeleton, so pale and emaciated was he.

A fisherman seeing him there said to him, Are you not the Prime Minister? What may you be doing here? Kutsugen replied, the whole world is filthy. I alone I alone am clean. Everybody is drunk.

I alone am sober. This is the reason I was dismissed. The fisherman said, a sage is not bound to things, is not the slave of circumstances, but follows them, acts in accordance with them. If the whole world is filthy, you must jump in the mud muddy water and splash about in it. If all men are drunk, drink with them.

What is the good of meditating so profoundly and idealistically? Kutsugen said, I have heard that when a man was washed has washed himself, he dusts his hat, and when a man has bathed his body, he shakes his clothes. How can he who has purified himself put on old dirty clothes again? I would rather jump into the river and feed my body to the fishes. I will not allow my purity to be sullied by the defilements of this world.

The smiling fisherman gave a chuckle and rowed away. He sang, keeping time with his oar, If the water of sorrow is clear, I will wash the ribbon of my hat. If it is dirty, I will wash my feet in it. That said, he was gone. If the water of the soil is clear, I will wash the ribbon of my hat.

If it is dirty, I will wash my feet. So maybe, maybe this is describing the first condition of anger. Anybody have an idea? Go ahead. Pride.

Pride. Pride. If the water, if soil is clear, I will wash the ribbon of my my hat. If it is dirty, I will wash my feet in it. Anybody?

You can be wrong or you can’t it doesn’t matter. I won’t angry. So these few final words where he says, you know, if the water is muddy, if it’s clear, you know, I’ll wash I’ll wash my clothes in. If it’s if it’s muddy, then I wash my feet in. So can you carry that further?

Yeah. I think so. It’s coming. Yeah. Please.

So, I mean, his what? Anybody else? As the the most purest, soberest, undefiled human, then, therefore, the sorrow that you’re suffering must be clear, sobering, and undefiled too. Yeah. That sounds good.

Yeah. Yvonne? It’s the name of a river. Yeah. How about, you know, if I think the idea of we’re talking about what are the conditions necessary to become angry.

And if you wanted to if you insisted upon washing your ribbon, you know, if you said, I have to wash my ribbon today, and this damn river’s muddy, or, you know, I mean, you weren’t what would that indicate? You had some desire, and what? It’s frustrated. Yeah. Okay.

Maybe I’m feeding you the lines. First condition, a frustrated desire. You want to get that? Is it a movie? It’s frustrated desire.

I mean, if I insist that I want to you know, I have to have clear water to wash my ribbon, if I hang on to that, then my desire is frustrated. I really want to wash my ribbon today. And this situation isn’t appropriate. So my desire is frustrated. And that’s one of the contributing conditions to my getting angry, as having a frustrated desire.

Now, that’s the first one. Does that make sense? If we don’t have frustrated desires, won’t get angry. We’re going to talk more about frustrated desires. Okay, second condition.

Take close attention. You’re doing very well. Second second condition. If a man is crossing a river and an empty boat collides with his own skiff, even though he has a bad he is a bad tempered man, he will not become very angry. But if he sees a man in the boat, he will shout at him to steer clear.

If his shout is not heard, he will shout again, and yet again, and begin cursing. And all because there is someone in the boat. Yet if the boat were empty, he would not be shouting and angry. Okay, Scaffer. They were okay.

So it’s just we’ll stay away from rivers and we’ll be okay. But Is it just the subject meeting another subject? He doesn’t want to get his boat hit. But if there’s somebody in the boat, he’s going to get angry at that person who hits his boat. If there’s nobody in that other boat, he doesn’t get angry.

He wants to get across the river. That’s his idea. He wants to get his desire to get across the river. Yeah? But if there’s someone else in the other boat, he’s got the expectation that the board is running.

Yeah. So what does that other person represent? I didn’t this wasn’t a put up job, was it? The identification of some person or object which is preventing you from realizing your desire. If boat is empty, there’s nobody to get angry at.

It’s like there’s no one it’d be difficult to identify. There’s no person to say, Ah, get out of here. You’re the cause of my boat being hit. And we have to be able to identify some object or someone, something which is preventing you from realizing your wish. So, we have two conditions: a frustrated desire and an identification of an object which is preventing you from gaining the object of your desire.

Does that make sense? Now the cause. Yeah. Day there was a traveler in the woods in California, in the dry season when the trade winds were blowing strong. He had ridden a long way and he was tired and hungry, And he dismounted from his horse to smoke a pipe.

But when he felt in his pocket, he found but two matches. He struck the first, and it was not light. Here is a pretty state of things, said the traveler, dying for a smoke, only one match left and certain to misfire. Was there ever a creature so unfortunate? And yet, thought the traveler, suppose I light this match and smoke my pipe and shake out the dottle here in the grass.

The grass might catch on fire for it is dry like tinder. And while I snatch out the flames in front, they might evade and run behind me and seize upon the bush a poison oak before I could reach it. That would have blazed up. Over the bush I see a pine tree hum with moss. That too would fly into fire upon an instant to its topmost bough.

And the flame of that long torch, how long would the trade winds take and brandish that through the inflammable forest? I hear this dale roar in a moment with the joined voice of the wind and fire. I see myself gallop for my soul and the flying conflagration chase and flank me through this hill. I see this pleasant forest burn for days and the cattle roasted and the spring dried up and farmer’s ruined and the children cast upon the world. What a world hangs upon this moment.

With this, he struck the match. And it misfired. Thank God, said the traveler. And he put his pipe in his pocket. But anyway so, I mean, he had a desire, you know, to smoke.

There was a frustrated desire. The match, the the wind, he could have got angry at the wind, lousy matches that he was sold, but he didn’t get angry. There was something which prevented him from realizing was his desire, the smoking. He was frustrated with desire, but he didn’t get angry. Why didn’t he get angry?

Angry? He was paranoid. He fear of the consequence. Of consequence. Aware of the consequences.

And what did that what effect did that fantasy have? Well, that’s just a substitution of another desire over the previous desire. Which one was that? Well, the previous desire was to smoke, but the new desire was not to not to sort of set the world on fire. Right?

So, when the world didn’t get set on fire, that’s fine. I mean, you know, I wouldn’t get angry at a lot of things if somebody gave me a million dollars. It would be fantastic. What would prevent the anger from rising? Million dollars.

A million dollars? The main cause for anger, there are two conditions and one cause. The first condition is a frustrated desire. The second is the identification of something which prevents you from fulfilling that desire. And the third is an undistressed mind, Undistressed mind.

The lack of discontentment. The lack of unhappiness. Unhappiness is the degree of anger is proportional to the strength of our unhappiness at the situation, the degree of frustration that we feel about the situation. If we not frustrated, if we are not unhappy with the situation, we will not become angry. This man did not was not unhappy when that match didn’t light.

He was not distressed. He was not frustrated. Therefore, he did not become angry. He had to be himself a reason. Yeah, for whatever reason, he was able to he developed a coping it was a coping mechanism.

His mind did not become distraught for whatever reason. Even though his desire was frustrated, even though there was an object which prevented him from fulfilling his desire, his mind did not become unhappy. And because it did not become unhappy, he did not become angry. The stressed mind is the cause. That’s the cause.

So the coming together of these three factors: the frustrated desire, recognizing an object which prevents us from gaining our object or desire, and an unhappy mind. If any one of this is missing, we won’t become angry. The main cause is an unhappy mind. A happy person does not become angry. A contented person does not become angry.

An unfrustrated person does not become angry. We have to arise some frustration with respect to the situation, some discontentment. Situation. I don’t like it. I’m unhappy with it.

This acts as the context, the atmosphere for anger to rise. Okay, we’ll go through these. The first condition was frustrated desire. Until we eliminate ignorance from our mind, this misconception of the nature of the self, we are going to generate desire. And therefore and we cannot arrange the world according to our desires.

So we’re always going to have desires, and we have to expect that. There will always be occasions when our desires are frustrated, therefore there are always going to be occasions when this condition is going to be complete, there is a possibility to become angry. In the case of the second condition, taking a person, a person preventing us from gaining, from realizing the object of our desire. Again, as long as we have desires, as long as we have ignorance, we’re going to have desires. And there will appear people who seem to be preventing us from gaining the object of our desires, what it is we want.

But if we can change our attitude towards those individuals, if we can make a shift, we know we can if we enlarge our perspective to see that this individual is not, in fact, preventing me from gaining that which I desire, but we can transform that individual into someone who’s actually our best friend, our dearest friend. Because we begin to shift what are, in fact, objects of desire are, what is, in fact, objects of our best interests. You know, in dependence upon someone who prevents us from getting what we want, we develop tolerance. You know, you cannot develop tolerance with the Buddha. The Buddha cannot teach you tolerance, only your enemy.

Only somebody who prevents you from getting what you want can help you develop tolerance, help you develop patience. You know, it’s people who give us a hard time, show us where we really are at spiritually. It’s people who push a button. It’s who it’s difficult people who strip us of our cocoons of nice tit-for-tat relationships, who strip us of our hypocrisy, who help force us out of our stagnation, of our superficial moods of relating with people, people who make us go beyond the status quo, people who give us a hard time. Ultimately, in the training of the mind, our enemy is our best teacher.

It is taken as our the person who In the training of the mind text, it is one’s enemy who helps one to ultimate happiness more than one’s best friend, as we normally conceive them to be. You know, the people that who are kind to us. You know, it’s easy to love them, isn’t it? It’s easy to be nice to people who are kind to ourselves. You know, Christ didn’t say, love your enemy, do good to those who hate you, bless those who curse you, and pray for those who maltreat you, because he was either confused, a fool, or romantic.

But he saw it as the most effective way for spiritual growth, to become perfect as your father in heaven is perfect. If we can begin to appreciate the people who give us a hard time, who stand in our way of fulfilling our desires, We can begin to transform our attitude toward them. You know, we can begin to see that they are real sources of growth. More than that, those who we are in attached relationship with impede our growth problem, because there’s a certain inhibitory feedback system which maintains a homeostatic system. Because it’s very few that will allow their partner to grow, because that may in the end cost the nature of their present relationship.

Their relationship will have to change, have to take on new dimensions, and it’s frightening. It’s an unknown quantity. So there’s a tendency unconsciously to bring that person, draw them back into what way they were, into what has been, that which is known. The enemy in the system of mind training is appreciated because it is in dependence upon our enemy that we will change, that we are forced to develop, that we learn about ourselves and how to relate, you know, that we really learn what love is. To love an enemy, is to really love.

It’s easy to wish our friends well because they wish us well. You know, it’s important in mind training, in growth. We cannot take the standards of the world as our measure. The ways of the world are not our way. The people out there may say, My anger is justified.

This bastard did that, and blah, blah, blah. And if I took her to court, they would say, yes, you’re right. He deserves all your anger, blah blah blah. It doesn’t work. It’s of no benefit spiritually to your growth.

It may it may satisfy some anger. It may satisfy some need, some pattern, but that’s all. It will it causes your own destruction. There’s no there’s no going beyond. There’s no change.

There’s nothing new. We have to give up to some degree, which is difficult, the standards of you know to be normal in an insane society is to be unhealthy. And we are trying to be healthy. So in some ways we have to adopt perhaps initially what seems to be what almost unreasonable types of behavior, unreasonable according to the reasoning or the ill reasoning of the world. You know, to grow, you know, to to fundamentally means to begin to enlarge, to expand the horizon.

Begin to to break new ground, to expand our boundaries, to move outwardly in perspective and inwardly in-depth. And this means to grow is concomitant to a more satisfying, more fulfilling, more meaningful way of being. It would be a great mistake to think that traveling the spiritual path, that growth involves the skillful avoidance of difficult people, difficult situations. In fact, it’s just the opposite. Voluntarily taking on difficult situations, as an impetus, as a catalyst for growth, for change.

That’s very, one has to be very courageous and have a be inspired and has to have a a real perspective on what one is doing to be able to engage in that consistently. Because it’s it’s not the way of the world. The way of the world is to avoid avoid as much as possible any difficult situation, any difficult person. Ultimately, you know, those who cause us harm are seen as none other than the Buddhas themselves, our greatest teachers. Then with respect to this third factor, this cause, the you know, distressed mind, an unhappy mind.

The main cause. Why are you unhappy? Because ninety nine point nine percent of everything you think and everything you do is for yourself, and there isn’t one. So, until we eliminate ignorance, the misconception of the nature of the self, our mind will always be distressed. Okay?

As long as we continue our engaged in actions in either confirming, protecting, enhancing, fostering a misconceived self, this continual struggle that we’re involved in, the mind will never be at peace. It will always be at a lesser or greater level of distress. And therefore there will always be occasions for anger because there will always be some level of distress. But if we to use our reasoning, we can develop better coping mechanisms with working with this distress, with this discontentment. You know, we can begin to there will be fewer and fewer situations which will cause distress and therefore anger.

You know, by making use of our reason, we can change our perspective, you know, by understanding the situation at a more profound level. And by this means we will not become frustrated and therefore angry. If we begin to understand the situation, we will no longer experience frustrations. Therefore, we will become less and less occasions for our anger. You know, I don’t think in the course of practice of Dharma that it is possible that we will experience dramatic changes in our life.

You know, I don’t want you to close yourself to that possibility. It may happen, but maybe not. And I don’t think during the course of a practice we’re going to have some experience or some kind of blinding flash of realization. There was some kind of light blazes in our mind, revealing a new landscape of what was hitherto unknown, unseen. Or there would be some kind of bubble of insight which will rise up out of our depth and burst and and reveal the secrets of the world.

It could happen. I don’t know. But I kind of doubt it. Maybe not. Though it’s possible.

But probably what will happen in the course of our practice is that, you know, very much just as I had mentioned concerning growth, a gradual, gradual, almost imperceptible expanding of our horizons. A gradual, almost imperceptible deepening of our understanding. A shift in our psychological center of gravity from, for example, self centeredness to other centeredness. And we’re beginning to accept a greater world, universal responsibility. And beginning to our understanding of ourselves and our reality becomes deeper and deeper.

You know, we’re going to change. That is, the way we experience ourselves and the way we experience the world is going to change. Our world is going to change. There is going to create change. You know, we may try to interpret that change.

We may, having interpreted it, we may try to express it in terms of some view, some system of thought, some kind of theology or whatever. And whether or not we’re right or wrong, whether our expression whether the way we express our interpretation of our experience is meaningful or sensible or helpful or not. So there is the experience. We will experience change whether we are able to understand the nature of that experience or not. You know, there’s something right about ourselves.

In a sense, our self and our life are not two different things. Now here I’m talking perhaps figuratively. Our self and our life are not two different things. It’s not as if you know, we have a sense that we’re standing outside of the flow of our life, almost as observers, and we’re watching our life go by. This is the kind of the sense that we have.

And we’re watching all these various changes take place. In the course of practicing the Dharma, you may become aware that life has become a little bit easier, that there are few hassles, fewer hassles than there were before. What were once problems are no longer seen as problems. We we we kinda cheer up. I think I have this idea.

A Buddha is someone who who remains cheerful in hell. A good definition of a Buddha. You know, there’s still even through this process of it seems that life is less hassle-some. But there’s still nasty people who are doing who do unfair things to you, unjust things. And still things that you don’t want to happen happen, and things you want to happen don’t happen.

This still remains the same. But such situations don’t seem to occur as often. And when they do occur, they don’t seem to throw you off balance as much as far as they once did. And we seem to regain our poise much quicker than before. I think we have this attitude.

We see our problems as some kind of unit of thing, something isolated in space and time. And this is my problem there, and I want some remedy to that problem. This is very much our approach. We see our problem as if it’s we’re standing outside of ourselves, as if we could remove that problem just like we remove a mole or a growth. It’s extraneous to me, and it’s it’s to be gotten rid of.

There’s a quote from from a Sufi master. I’ve heard all that you have had to say to me on your problem. You ask me what to do about them. It is my view that your real problem is that you’re a member of the human race. Face that one first.

More than being problems, like these units and things which need remedy, which are to be gotten rid of, They are expressions of our life. They are not something separate. They are our life. They are they are ourselves. Our life and ourselves are not something separate.

We are not standing outside of the flow of our life. Now our problems are not separate from who we are, from our beliefs, from our feelings, from our ideas. They’re an integral part of who we are. They’re the integral part of the quality of our being. So there’s no solution standing apart outside of yourself.

It can’t be cut away. The way you live your life or the way you do not live your life, the way is your problem, is your solution. Know, maybe what we mean by dharma, it is a lifestyle, a way of living life, a way of being, a type of self. It’s all appropriate. Our problems are appropriate.

They are our problems. Just as much as my arm, just as much as my belief. They are constituent of my life. I could not live without We we, however, are not prisoners. No traps or snares are set about us, and there is nothing which should intimidate or worry us.

We are set down in life as into the element to which we best correspond. We have no reason to mistrust our world, for it is not against us. Has it terrors? They are our terrors. Has it abysses?

Those abysses belong to us. Our danger is at hand. We must try to love them. And if only we arrange our life according to that principle which counsels that we must always hold to the difficult, then that which now seems to us the most alien will become what we most trust and find most faithful. How should we be able to forget those ancient myths that are at the beginning of all peoples?

The myths about dragons that at the last moment turn into princesses. Perhaps all the dragons of our lives are princesses who are only waiting waiting to see us once beautiful and brave. Perhaps everything terrible in its deepest being is something helpless that once helped from us. We may not be able to consciously find a solution to problem X, to problem Y, to problem Z, but one day we may notice that x, y, and z are no longer a problem, that life has solved. It was never life as it were has solved that problem.

And that once what we viewed as a problem is simply no longer a problem. And it seems to go by unnoticed. That a person a person’s mind sometimes those mind are are like almost like sandpaper. They’re like taking a piece of silk cloth and running across sandpaper. Everything catches.

Like, some people’s minds are like marble. The silk just slides across. No problem. No hassle. No hooks to be caught on.

You know, I think we tend to forget how very sane we are, that how many thousands of situations that we work through in the course of one day skillfully without these situations becoming problematic. We have less problems. We have less situations which are problematic than we do problematic situations. We’re that same. As we become saner, the proportion will increase.

You know, might not be able to consciously correct our difficulty, but our way of life will solve that problem, I notice to ourselves. Practicing Dharma is like a way of life, a lifestyle, a particular approach to the human condition. Life is, if I can become philosophical for a moment, it’s not something to be figured out. It’s something to be lived. Samuel Johnson said, life is learning to play the violin while you’re giving a performance.

You know, we haven’t had time to practice everything to get it right before we go on. We can’t go back and say, let’s try it all again. Let’s do a retake. We’re stuck, and we have to keep on going. You know, we we we haven’t we can’t in a way, we can’t make mistakes.

You know, we can’t say, oh, I I I I forgot my line, or I lost I missed my cue. I didn’t come on at the right time. There’s no other way our life could have been than the way it has been. We’re doing everything. We’re playing our parts perfectly, unknowingly.

It’s very appropriate. So we have to, you know, we have to quit torturing ourselves for not having gotten it right. We did it right as far as we wrote our script, as far as all the conditioning factors, as far as all our the variables which which constituted, which brought about our situation. It was right. It was appropriate.

You know, it couldn’t have been any other way. You know, we have to forgive ourselves for perhaps not being the person that we should have been, for not doing what we should have done or or for doing what we shouldn’t have done. It was right for that time, that play, and that occasion. It was appropriate. It couldn’t have been any other way.

You know, we’ve created unskillful for action, but we can simply regret them and move on. We can begin again. Begin to to live the type of life that that we want to live. And there’s some type of life which perhaps fulfills a very deep meaning, a type of something we can believe in. The intellect operates on the basis of proof and demonstration.

But the soul, and here perhaps, you know, it’s very strange for a Buddhist to be using the word soul, but anyway, and perhaps in Jungian terms, the totality of our psyche operates on the basis of belief and meaning. Belief and meaning. You know, we choose to believe. That’s our greatest freedom freedom that we have. To follow logic, that’s no great path.

That’s no great wonder. But to choose to believe, to choose to believe in your own goodness and the goodness of life, to affirm your potential and to try to lead a type of life which realizes that potential, to choose that, to find meaning. Is our greatest freedom. If you have that kind of belief, then your problems will never overwhelm you. You can never be broken.

And you’re going to find yourself living on a higher order of being. A new boundaries will begin to open up to you. So, now we’re getting back. So I guess, you know, we’re learning about tolerance, as we were supposed to be. We’re learning about tolerance.

And we can begin with ourselves, acknowledging and accepting what is, and gently and consistently creating what can be. Gently and consistently. And having some mercy on yourself. There’s a a Japanese haiku, which I like. Oh, snail, climb Mount Fuji, but slowly, slowly, accordingly, appropriately.

That is we have to have some mercy towards ourselves. Your life is going to change appropriately to the causes that you’re creating. And with that, you know, your problems will lessen. If you just simply do this, make a gentle consistent effort, choose the path with heart, then your life will take care itself. You will have problems, but they they won’t break you.

They won’t overwhelm you. They may be even incorporated into your growth. And we look back and we see that some change has taken place. We haven’t I guess the point that I’m trying to make is that maybe we have to begin to rather than seeing our life as a series of problems, each needing unique solutions, seeing that the very your life is both your solution and your problem. These instances are particular expressions of perhaps unskillful way of life.

Dedicate the positive energy that we create. I understand. I try to share what I feel with you out of my respect for you. And sometimes it’s not clear to me. I think Wittgenstein used to there was one quote by St.

Augustine that he used to like to quote. I can’t remember the quote exactly, but it was something like there’s a certain coming against what you cannot explain. And St. Augustine said, Oh, you fool, it doesn’t matter whether it sounds absurd. You still must try to express it.

So I’m just sharing my in my foolishness with you, But maybe it’s worthwhile. May I quickly become an awakened spiritual teacher and lead each and every sentient being to enlightened realms through these skillful actions. May the supreme jewel of the awakening heart that has not arisen arise and grow. And may that which has arisen never diminish, but increase more and more. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top