45 min · 4,758 words · 20 February 1991 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Opening with a Chinese proverb about heading in the wrong direction, Ven Jampa Gendun frames this 46-minute commentary on chapter six of Śāntideva’s Entering the Bodhisattva’s Way of Life around two catalysts for genuine spiritual change: anxiety about recurring suffering, and faith. He argues that patching ego-problems piecemeal is like taking a morphine shot while you have cancer — immediate relief, root cause untouched. He then surveys all six perfections as the bodhisattva’s practical curriculum, before focusing on tolerance: not suppressing distress like a dam, but training the mind so difficulty simply stops disturbing it. He closes by contrasting idiot compassion — conflict-avoidance dressed as kindness — with real compassion that, like a firm mother or honest doctor, sometimes requires uncomfortable precision.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 04 Tce 1991 02 20.mp3
UUID: 258559fd-c117-46d6-9804-34366be888e4
Teacher: Ven Jampa Gendun
Collection: Tolerance (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Date: 1991-02-20
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 45.8 minutes
Words: ~4,773
We begin by adjusting our motivation. Recommitting of ourselves and then just continue picking ourselves back up again and setting our priorities straight. Right. As a if I remember it well, there’s a Chinese expression proverb. If you if you if you remain going in the direction that you’re headed, then you shouldn’t be surprised if if you don’t arrive at your at your goal.
Now where are you headed? We have to adjust our thinking. We need to check out. There are said to be two causes for committing ourselves to the process of growth, this reorientation process. The first is anxiety and the other is faith, anxiety and faith.
Without some degree of awareness of a high degree of unmanageability in our lives, the quality of dissatisfaction, alienation, fragmentation, inauthenticity, whatever. Acknowledging we simply don’t want to have it repeat again. Way that we usually address ourselves to our problems is very much on a piecemeal level. There is the unconscious assumption that if only I can make certain adjustments about myself, if I can simply manipulate, gather gather together the right ingredients, then everything’s going to be okay. And no and no basic change has to take place.
We keep putting patchwork in our patches on the solution to pain, on the solution to the solution to the basic problem of ego. And until we begin to see that things are simply going to repeat themselves because the basic cause has never been dealt with properly. With respect to pain, There are two basic attitudes that we can take to it. We can see pain as an obstacle to one’s happiness, which is to be eliminated as quickly as possible. Or we can see it as an indicator, a indication of what needs to be done next.
This this question of anxiety, this thought, if I don’t make I don’t really begin to deal with the root of my problems, then my problems are simply going to continually be reoccurring, and we become anxious about this having to undergo involuntarily undesired experiences. Though things may be okay now, the the causes are there. Unless they’re dealt with, it’s simply a matter of time before I have to undergo another difficult situation, another problem, another experience of suffering. It’s not that it’s not that everything’s okay now. Everything the cause is still there.
As long as the cause is not dead, there is still a basis for anxiety. We still haven’t solved the real problem. So there arises a sense of weariness about having to undergo these difficulties again and again and again. And one begins to make a conscious decision to deal with the more basic causes of our problems. And this is the orientation of growth, to see seeing the difficulties, the problems outside of ourselves, and therefore the solutions to them, but beginning to see the absolute necessity for eliminating the cause within our own minds, our own attitudes.
That’s the basic necessity I have to change. I have to grow. And, you know, this this sense of anxiety, this dread at the basic human dilemma becomes the motivating force for growth. Otherwise, we’re going to be bound by the play pleasure pain principle of ego. We won’t be able to to voluntarily involve ourselves in the preferable, but only that which will bring immediate solution.
And oftentimes, the immediate solution in no way deals with the, you know, the deeper problem. You know, it’s like giving ourselves a morphine shot while we have cancer. So it relieves immediate pain. It leaves the real problem undealt with. So this basic quality of anxiety, though I might not be experiencing any difficulty at present, I know the causes are still present within within my mind.
And it’s simply a matter of time. You know, I can change my job. I can change my spouse, my geography, my income. Still the same problems are going to reoccur unless I begin to deal with them on a more basic level. And so we make this determination to begin to deal with our problems on a basic level.
And this requires some change, some adjustment. And this is the first of the two causes for going for refuge, for this recommitting ourselves to a spiritual path, to to grow. If I don’t change, if I don’t grow, then I can expect nothing more than what has gone in the past. These these sickening reoccurring compulsive patterns which bound which bind me, which which force me to undergo difficulties. I simply going to continue.
Can you hear? No. Can you hear? Can you hear now? I go for refuge until I am enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, and the highest assembly.
From the virtuous merit that I collect by practicing giving and the other perfections, may I attain the state of a Buddha to be able to benefit all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma and the highest assembly, and the virtuous merit that I collect by practicing giving and the other perfections, may I attain the state of a Buddha to be able to benefit all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma and the highest assembly. And the virtuous merit that I collect by practicing giving and the other perfections, may I attain the state of the Buddha to be able to benefit all sentient beings. Could you hear okay?
We’re we’re discussing Śāntideva’s A Bodhicaryāvatāra or Entering the Bodhisattva’s Way of Life. And specifically the chapter, the sixth chapter, there’s ten chapters altogether. Sixth chapter, which is entitled tolerance and sometimes translated as patience. And we’re talking about it’s like the a bodhisattva’s training manual. You know, what is a bodhisattva, a fully qualified bodhisattva, is someone who has developed an awakening heart, bodhicitta, the mind of enlightenment.
The altruistic aspiration to achieve highest enlightenment, awakening for the sake of all sentient beings. That’s for a fully qualified bodhisattva, someone someone who has completely opened their heart to the universal for universality of pain and own self. They strive to completely awaken themselves in their dedication to the other whole being, to the elimination of this pain and confusion. So it’s it’s a rather it’s rather heroic. In a lesser sense, if we just perhaps bring it down to something that maybe we can begin to see as relevant to ourselves.
Bodhisattva is simply a person who lives in the spirit of the vows of a bodhisattva. Now that he has has formally determined to commit himself to helping others. Made this declaration if only to himself. Committed themselves to the spirit of the Bodhisattva Vow. Essentially, the commitment to put others before ourselves, which is still quite a really goal to achieve.
You know, he is stating, or she is stating, a willingness to give up on our own well-being for the sake of others. I’m talking about the the the Bodhisattva vow. It is a real commitment based upon the realization of the suffering and confusion of ourselves and others. The only way to break the chain reaction of confusion and pain is to work our way outward into the awakened state of mind, is to take responsibility ourselves. If we do not deal with this situation of confusion, if we do not do something about it ourselves, nothing will ever happen.
You know, we cannot count on others to do it for us. It is our responsibility. And we have the tremendous power to change the course of the world’s karma. So in taking the bodhisattva vow, we are acknowledging that we are not going to be instigators of further chaos and misery in the world, but are going to be liberators, bodhisattvas, inspired to work on ourselves as well as working with other people. You know, we simply try to become human beings who are inspired to and genuinely able to help others.
We begin to to go beyond our present egocentric needs, our our parochial viewpoint. You know, our the course of our spiritual development becomes other centered. This shift is opening of our horizon, of our vision. It’s quite revolution in consciousness, the awakening heart. And committing ourselves to gentleness, committing ourselves to concern for others and to awaken for the sake of others.
Why when I said the word revolutionary, was something I think back in my revolutionary days of Che Guevara. He was a Cuban revolutionary. He said the first thing a revolutionary has to do is love the people he’s fighting for. And there’s a lot of revolution as people with great hate in their heart. A real revolutionary.
So committing ourselves to gentleness, to concern for others, and to awaken. And this this commitment practically involves practicing the six perfections, sometimes called the six transcendences. Perfection of generosity. Becoming open handed with whatever we have, whether it’s material possessions, whether it’s our time, whether it’s our energy, our knowledge, a sense of sharing what we do have. You know, I think if we look at all of these words that we’re going to hear, they have they have the connotation, the sense, the imagery of opening, of going out, of extending, moving into a vast open plane, open horizon.
Yeah. You know, it seems like ego has that exact opposite sense feeling about it, closing in, narrowing down, encapsulating, hardening, building walls. So it’s a very it’s a it’s a it’s a movement in the other direction that we have to begin to make. Know, beginning by, you know, the perfection of generosity, beginning to share, be a little more open with what we have. That’s the beginning.
I think many there’s hundreds of beggars in in India, for example. And I’ve seen many of my teachers, they carry around a bag of change. Obviously, can’t give not obviously, but it becomes difficult to give each beggar a large amount. Amount. But just just the giving to get, you know, get the arm working, you know, that’s it’s kind of a revolutionary step.
You know, generally, when we when we hear you know, I don’t know if you’ve been to India. Sometimes the beggars, they really know how to push a button. Know? It’s a bakshis. Bakshis.
Some kind it’s They want money, essentially. And then when you hear, like, begin to close down and you pull up, you feel yourself being your heart begins to shut and begin to pull away. And so you have to concentrate awareness instead of push yourself to take the other direction and open. And you give five paisa. Five paisa is what is thirteen rupees to a dollar?
So I don’t know. Three cents. What did you give? One beggar said to me, he says, I get enough get I get enough where I don’t die, but I don’t get enough where I can live. That that just to just to get into the habit of giving, of opening, of letting go of something.
Perfection of generosity, perfection of ethics. You’re developing a sense of trust in our basic sanity and others’ basic sanity that we can relate on the basis of non harm, nonviolence. The basis of ethics is simply non harm, not to harm oneself nor others, and beginning to trust that one is a nonviolent person and deepen one’s own basic sanity. This may require that we put ourselves in some discipline until we get in touch with our basic sanity because our habitual patterns might might be such going in such the opposite direction that our basic sanity is completely unavailable to us as far as the way we relate with others in ethical manners. So until that time, it may be useful to take on an artificial discipline.
But the actual perfection of ethics is believing that we are caring people, that we’re believing in our basic sanity and the way of a natural way of relating is one of non harm and non violence. Perfection of tolerance, and a beginning to create a sense of a sense of understanding, a sense of space so that we can begin to work with our own neurosis and the neurosis of others without becoming agitated, without becoming distressed that we can remain peaceful. This is you know, we’re going to talk obviously a great deal about tolerance. Tolerance, there’s many types of tolerance. Essentially, what tolerance means is to become nondistressed in the face of difficult situation.
It’s not that you it’s not like a dam that you that you just keep shoving the distress down. The actual development of tolerance is that one doesn’t become distressed, distraught, disturbed at difficult situations, difficult people, suffering, that the mind is able to work with our our own neurosis to see it and has created the space where it doesn’t disturb one any longer. And it’s able to work with others neurosis in difficult situations where it no longer disturbs one. This is tolerance. This is what we’re going to be directing our energies towards, our our attention towards.
Fourth perfection, perfection of joyous effort. And this is you know, there’s a tremendous effort, tremendous energy, and willingness to work hard for the sake of others. And we begin to you know, if we simplify the focus of our life, you know, we’re a very scattered people. We’re very we’re very fragmented people. There’s no we aren’t whole, holy.
As, you know, we begin to the central focus of our life begins to helping begins to become helping others. Inner focus of our life begin begins to become awakening. And all our energies are no longer scattered. They begin to you know, we we we no longer have all the emotional complications that we once did. We no longer have have involved in all the conceptual frivolities that once took all our energy and time.
Our our life has become very simple. Our motivation for what we’re doing has become very simple, very profound, but very single and very simple to help others, to to awaken in order to best help others. And so we out of this comes tremendous energy. We’re no longer dissipating in all other various activities and frivolousness, distracting ourselves from the from the hollowness and the meaninglessness of our present world way of life. We have found some meaning.
And so there there naturally arises the availability of all this energy. This is the perfection of joyous effort. It’s not that we it’s joy. I think that’s important too. It’s not heavy handed, forcing ourselves begrudgingly.
There’s there’s a sense of self respect. That’s feelings of self worth, self affirmation, a feeling that the goodness of oneself and the goodness of that a sense of joy about ourselves and what we’re doing and our ability to help others. Joyous effort. And the fifth perfection is the perfection of meditation. And it’s basically the practice of meditation is is our willingness to work with our neurosis, to confront our issue, to work with our speed, and to learn about ourselves.
And it’s perfection of wisdom, the six to the six perfections. So it’s it’s simply becoming really one’s very interested in learning and seeing into the way things really are, you know, beyond our our ego fantasy. One wants to learn. One wants to see for oneself the way things act the way things actually are. So these these are these are kind of the practical applications of the work in which a bodhisattva, you know, someone who really wants to help others can begin by working in these areas in a very practical way, beginning to share, beginning to practice non harm, beginning to create a space such that they simply don’t continue they’re willing to enter into situations which are hassles and work at not becoming upset, uptight.
They begin to simplify their life. They don’t need all the all the various distraction. Concentrate their energy. Begin to focus their concern on awakening and helping others. They begin to seek to learn about themselves, become aware of where things are, and they take a real interest.
They They really want to know, and they’re they’re really motivated to understand themselves and how their mind is working, the way their ego is operating. It becomes important. So these are the the practices in which, you know, we can do as ordinary people in order to develop an awakening heart, in order to really be of so that our our efforts in helping others won’t simply be adding more chaos to the world, that we have something that we can really give, that we’re inspired to help, and importantly, that we genuine genuinely are able to help, that we can do something. This becomes you know, these are the facets of a Bodhisattva’s way of life. You know, the word bodhisattva.
Bodhisattva means one who is heroic with respect to awakening. One who is heroic or a warrior. Nice image of him. With respect to awakening, bodhi, enlightenment. Above all, we Bodhisattva must be fearless.
You know, we I mentioned about this is revolutionary quality of mind. Probably, it’s not for a faint hearted people perhaps that the Bodhisattva has to become fearless. He he has to constantly make himself vulnerable to the pain of the world. On the other side of our cowardness is bravery. You know, men, especially, we all, but men especially, they we grew up with the unacknowledged feeling that we’re cowering.
And we spend a great deal of our time and energy trying to prove aren’t cowardly. And we but the feelings kind of present. They persist. No matter how many daring feats we we do, it’s still there. There remains this basic feeling of self deception that I am really a coward no matter what I do externally before the world.
Externally before the world. There’s a a text which is called the condensed words of the Buddha, which has many different sayings of the Buddha, which is important within the Tibetan tradition. This is like the the collection of the sayings of the Buddha in the Theravadan tradition. And in this, there’s a verse which says, you who conquer thousands and thousands of enemies are not the victors in battle. He who conquers himself is the true victor in battle.
So the the heroism of a Bodhisattva and a Bodhisattva is terribly heroic, involves working with neurosis, with his own and with others. And one has to be terribly heroic to take up that that task. It’s much easier to go out and kill people in the battlefield and work with your own neurosis when it comes down to it. On the other side of our cowardness, there’s some kind there’s some kind of bravery. And if if if we in going beyond our fears, there’s there’s you know, a bodhisattva is is very it’s very I think, you know, I I can just give, you know, words, images.
It’s like in going beyond a fear, there’s there’s sort of a tenderness. It’s almost like, you know, the image that comes with like like you’ve been burnt and the skin is peeled off. And just the breath of air is pain there’s a sensitivity, which is almost painful. And this is the quality of the Buddha. Before he becomes brave, he’s still shaky.
He’s still quipping. Like, there’s like a little child who who’s crying. He’s sniffling and he’s trying to get himself together. He’s trying to he sees the necessity to go beyond his fears. He’s gotta deal with the situation.
He’s gotta he can’t no longer indulge himself in his cowardice, in his something is needed to be done. He sees that clearly, but he’s still afraid. He hasn’t quite gone developed the bravery necessary to work with the situation fearlessly. So there’s still these tears, and he’s he’s sniffling. He’s quavering.
He’s quivering, shaking. And he gets on with what needs to be done, but there’s still this this quality of tenderness. The result is this is a quotation by Suzuki Roshi, a Zen master who lived in the United States, He died a number of years ago. The result is not the point. It is the effort to improve one ourselves that is valuable.
There are four Buddhist vows. These vows are, although sentient beings are innumerable, we vow to save them all. Although our evil desires are limitless, we vow to be rid of them. Although the teaching is limitless, we vow to learn it all. Although Buddhism is unattainable, we vow to attain it.
If If it is unattainable, how can we attain it? But we should. That is Buddhism. To think because it is possible, we will do it is not Buddhism. Even though it is impossible, we have to do it because our true nature wants us to.
But, actually, whether or not it is possible is not the point. If it is our inmost desire to get rid of our self centered ideas, we have to do it. When we make this effort, our inmost desire is a peace. nirvana is there. You know, in becoming a bodhisattva, it there’s no there’s no graduation diploma handed out, you know, passing out ceremony.
Now you’re a Bodhisattva. Now you can go out and do do the Bodhisattva deeds. You can be a hero. There’s no morphine shot that’s given out. We’re never quite ready to take up the bodhisattva deeds.
We’re never quite brave enough. We’re never quite skillful enough. Still, we have to do it. If we’re going to find some peace. So we begin to begin to care for ourselves in our initiative, in our practice, in our development.
But we we but we reject caring only for ourselves and the attitude of selfishness. Now as we talk about renunciation, initially, we renounce the causes of suffering, the causes of our problem. But we go on from there. We we begin to renounce anything which stands between ourselves and others. Anything which stands is an obstacle to communication, to working with us.
Anything which is a block, anything which stands renunciation of the bodhisattva. We renounce our cocoon and embrace a a wider world, a larger larger world. So in a a quotation from, a Tibetan master who lived in United States and died a number a few years ago. In order to overcome selfishness, it is necessary to be daring. It is as though you were dressed in your swimsuit standing on the diving board with a pool in front of you, and you ask yourself, now what?
The obvious answer is jump. That is theory. You might wonder if you will sink or hurt yourself if you jump. We are so accustomed to accepting what is bad for us and rejecting what is good for us. We are attached to our cocoons, our selfishness, and we are afraid of selflessness, stepping out beyond ourselves.
So in order to overcome our hesitation about giving up our privacy, in order to commit ourselves to others’ welfare, some kind of leap is necessary. You know, a a bodhisattva is is somebody who is who is interested in people, in their welfare, is concerned about people, and care is cares for people. And this this might sound romantically pleasant, but it but it is it’s not. It’s not an easy matter. And if it requires it, that we not get completely tired and put off by other people’s heavy handed.
No. Their ego dirt, their ego diarrhea, their ego puke. But instead that we are are willing to clean up after them. It is a sense of softness whereby we allow situations to take place in spite of little inconveniences. We allow situations to bother us, to to overcrowd us.
You know, in in in spite of our irritation, we we we act with good manners. We we extend hospitality. And, you know, this is not a it’s not a matter of hypocrisy. It’s an expression of our commitment to awakening. It is not has nothing to do with ego and the pleasure-pain principle, which would be the basis for hypocrisy.
When you say everything’s okay when in fact it isn’t. When you put up with things for your own self best interests ultimately. But it’s an expression of our intent to awaken, to remain hospitable, to clean up other people’s messes. You know, but the the compassion of a bodhisattva is not a not a idiot compassion. It’s not a stupid compassion.
We’re not trying to be nice guys all the time, to be likable, to always be kind, making people feel good. That’s not the job of a Bodhisattva. Sometimes it’s necessary to act with painful precision and cutting through people’s neurosis, mistakes. Another quotation by. Perhaps it is most important that in working with others, we do not develop idiot compassion, which means always trying to be kind.
Since it lacks courage and intelligence, this superficial kindness does does more harm than good. It is though a doctor, out of apparent kindness, refused to treat his patient because the tree treatment might be painful or as though a mother could not bear the discomfort of disciplining her child. Unlike idiot compassion, real compassion is not based upon simple minded avoidance of pain. It is uncompromising in its allegiance to basic sanity. There’s a great kindness of a mother toward her child.
She’s interested in the child’s ultimate welfare, and this might mean putting herself and her child in temporary discomfort, uncomfortable position, difficult situation. But she’s willing to do that because she has real compassion for the ultimate welfare of her child. Generally, we simply avoid conflict as best we can. But in doing that, we create more confusion, more chaos, and probably more difficulties for ourselves and others in the long run. So our compassion has to be an intelligent compassion.
It simply cannot be a type which is bound to be nice, bound to avoid conflict, bound to avoid discomfort and pain. So the bodhisattva’s way of life is centered around fostering caring, a caring mind, and a wise heart. And beginning to appreciate the opportunities whereby we can translate our caring mind and wise heart into a physical reality. The Bodhisattva, it is said, for example, I mean, it’s it’s hard to believe, But in a way, it’s not if we if we work at it. But when a Bodhisattva hears the word give, you know, as I mentioned before, when in India when you hear the word give, I shrink back, I pull back, I feel hardened, and I feel aversion rise.
When a bodhisattva hears the word give, he is is filled with an immense bliss which surpasses that of even, you know, the lesser vehicle’s foe destroyer. An immense unimaginable bliss simply by hearing the word give. This ability this opportunity to translate his caring heart and wise mind into a physical reality. So appreciate that it generates bliss. So this process of developing awakening heart, of caring, beginning to and this also holds true for refuge, for recommitting ourselves to growth, a realigning ourselves, a realigning our allegiance to from caring for only for ourselves to caring for others.
A realignment of our allegiance from caring only for ourselves and a few people around us to caring for all sentient beings equally. And you’re accepting this what the Dalai Lama calls universal responsibility. That kind of vision. It’s unimaginable. And this this brings you know, our life becomes integrated.
It’s no longer fragmented. We’re no longer pulled in a hundred directions. It comes centered around awakening for the sake of others so that we can be a real benefit to others. This is a this is a lifestyle, a way of living, you know, which is integrated around that vision. Śāntideva in his text, the Bodhicaryāvatāra, says of the Bodhisattva, I bow down to the body of him in whom the sacred precious mind of the awakening heart is born.
I seek refuge in that source of joy who brings happiness even to those who seek to bring him harm. And he he composed a Bodhicaryāvatāra as a training manual to help us to cultivate the seeds of sanity and the seeds of caring that we all
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.