Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 — 2009-03-23

2 h 1 min · 12,130 words · 23 March 2009 · Buddha House Adelaide

Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 — 2009-03-23
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. A quote from Jungian analyst Robert Johnson — that all human longing is ultimately a search for the sacred — opens this two-hour session by Ven Jampa Gendun, reframing Buddhist refuge-taking as a universal impulse rather than a sectarian formula. After a guided meditation that takes listeners systematically through body and mind in search of the “I” that cannot be found, Gendun surveys four philosophical schools (Hearer, Mind Only, Autonomy Middle Way, Consequentialist Middle Way), showing how each dissolves a subtler layer of ignorance. He then unpacks dependent arising at three levels, using a Prime Minister and an outback cabin as vivid illustrations of how nothing exists from its own side. An extended Q&A ranges across time, karma, and how subjective labelling shapes what we take to be shared reality. For practitioners already engaged with the Three Principal Aspects series.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 38 3PA 2009 03 23.mp3

UUID: 80ad529a-231c-4df6-bc90-34487b9d5e6a

Teacher: Ven Jampa Gendun

Collection: Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 (Ven Jampa Gendun)

Date: 2009-03-23

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 121.1 minutes

Words: ~12,127

How’s everybody? Good? Die hard. You guys got a lot of patience. Wow.

So we maybe I’ll share a quote a quote. I did I mean, you’ve all of you you guys have heard all this before. This is new. This is there’s one Jungian analyst by the name of Robert Johnson. American.

Don’t hold that against him, okay? Anyway, I think he was here about twelve years ago. I heard him give a talk. He’s written some good books, I think. We, He, She, It, no, not it.

We, anyway, know, talking about you know, when we talk about going for refuge, you know, where are we going to? You know, we all go for refuge to something or other, whether we call it that, whether we think of it in that way or not. And what happens when uncomfortable feelings or anxiety or difficulties arise for us? You know, what do we what do we resort to? Where do we go to find comfort and help us to resolve the difficulty?

So, you know, the question that, you know, I guess we all, you know, we all have our refuges, don’t we, one way or another? Some people go to the refrigerator and turn the turn the turn turn on the television or have sex or, you know, some people go for refuge to their family, to money, to drugs, to politics, to literature, to entertainment, arts. Anyway, I’m kind of getting away from the necessity to lead a life of self reflection and self examination, looking to ourselves. Think if we admit it, it’s quite challenging, quite difficult. I remember since I was very young, had this idea of being authentic.

I wasn’t quite sure what that meant, but it sounded pretty good. You know, finding out who it is we are beneath all the layers of social and cultural conditioning, religious indoctrination beneath all the taken for granted truths of our lives, you know, all the self constraining shoulds and ought tos, beneath all the layers of our own self deception and our own brands of self ignorance. You know, find trying to find out I think it was Joseph Campbell. He he used to use the expression, expression, find out your bliss, find your bliss. You know, what it is that makes where is what do you admire?

What kind of turns you on? What makes you feel good about yourself, your life? Makes you feel alive? Makes you feel like this whole journey is all somehow worthwhile. And just in and of itself, whatever the particulars might be.

So, you know, this quote is by Robert Johnson. Getting back to the quote. I guess that’s something that moves our heart, not just our heads. So much of our lives is spent in longing in search for what we do not know. So many of our ostensible goals, so many of the things we think we want turn out to be the masks behind which our real desire is hid.

They are symbols for the actual values and qualities for which we hunger. They are not reducible to physical or material things, not even to a physical person. They are psychological qualities love, truth, honesty, loyalty, purpose something we can feel is noble, precious, and worthy of our devotion. We try to reduce all this to something physical a house, a car, better job, or a human being, but it doesn’t work. Without realizing it, we are searching for the sacred, and the sacred is not reducible to anything else.

Sacred sacredness is, in a sense, a feeling, but a feeling that goes to the very heart of life. It is the feeling of recognition directed toward what is great and high enough to give our small lives meaning, to put our personal journeys in a greater perspective. It is a feeling of reverence. What we call the sacred is ultimately a universe of meaning against which we measure our personal efforts, our personal lives, to see whether they too have been, you know, what is it they have? You know, in some ways, I think we often give ourselves less credit than we deserve.

Many of what we take as afflictions have a positive side to them as well in our our our desires and our attachments and what, you know, our inability to to settle for anything that is less than at some level, we intuit our life might be like. And you know, what is it that we yearn for? What is it for some kind of image that kind of drives us whether we’re aware of it or not, that we’re always moving toward in one way or not. Sometimes we might get out of lose touch with it for years, maybe lifetimes at a time, but nonetheless there seems there’s some kind of movement towards some idealized possibility of what we see as the meaning of our life. And, you know, what is it that we’re always kind of reaching for?

And, you know, it’s like I think Johnson says, you know, we can mistake it for a person or a thing or some activity or a job. These kind of they they don’t quite satisfy what it is. They might distract us for a while. But in the end, we have to if we’re if we’re not to lose touch with the our central core values, we always have to feel that, well, this isn’t quite what what I thought it was. And that’s okay.

So whatever it is, you know, we we can I, you know, this this taking this time that we come together or before your practice or just going for a walk and kind of reflecting on that? And that’s maybe what the one of the real possibilities of the meaning of going for refuge. Trying to get back in touch with that image, that idea that’s that’s kind of drawing you along the kind of the inner metaphors that we want to live lives by. You know, we we sometimes, I call that a Buddha, but it doesn’t matter what we call it in a way. Just being aware of it and then reflecting and getting back on track from time to time.

I guess in living it out as best we can, even in small ways. You know, I talk about this, you know, this is a verse by the seventeenth century Ryokan who I like very much. You know, Buddha is your mind and the way goes nowhere. Don’t look for anything but this. If you point your cart north when you want to go south, how will you ever arrive?

So Buddha is your mind, you know, just getting a sense of where the person you’d like to be, you know, in terms of the psychological qualities. How it, you know, what kind of greatest meaning for yourself? And and if are you heading toward that in some way? Is your point card is your cart pointed in that direction? There’s an old saying, You know, if you keep going the same direction, you’re likely to end up where you’re headed.

Is it where you’re headed where you really want to go? So I guess it’s, you know, this idea of pausing and reflecting upon our life. It’s quite a necessary part of the journey, quite a, I guess, quite a part of the necessary examined life. And then putting into some kind of place some strategies which take us in the direction that you really want to go. Even if it’s only in small ways.

At least that’s something. It’s important. And it’s like pain honoring something which is important to you. Not discounting it, not allowing it to rot in our heart and be lost to us. In terms of our Buddhist practice, we call this going for refuge to the Buddhadharma and Sangha.

The Buddha represents this idealized image that’s driving our wanderings and the best possible story that we could tell ourselves about ourselves and what we could do and who we could be in this life. And we implement the various kind of strategies dharma, the means, know, in some small ways. And we rely upon those about us to assist us in this process. We aren’t these isolated beings who we often imagine ourselves to be. You know, one thing that perhaps we can learn from these teachings on the awakened mind is that these distinctions that we make between ourselves and others, they aren’t absolute.

They aren’t as they’re only conventional. You know, this the borderline, the boundaries between others, self and others is just a matter of speaking. That we, in some way, are inextricably bound up, interdependent with our society and our environment. And relating to those around us who are going to facilitate, who encourage us and assist us and teach us and act as examples, inspirations, and doing the same for others. And trying to raise the level of our motivation.

And maybe this is in an ongoing process of continually opening to a greater vision about what the good life looks like. So it might begin to include a greater number of others, beginning with one, but training the mind, not allowing, not being satisfied with just that. So when we say I go for refuge till I’m awakened, so what? What kind of person would you like to be five years from now, fifteen years from now, a lifetime from now. And so when we say I go for refuge, that’s why I like to I like to get back on track.

I like to rededicate, commit myself, and that deeper value within me, and doing something about it. I go for refuge until I’m awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I’m awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings.

I go for refuge until I’m awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. May all sentient beings have happiness in the causes of happiness. May all sentient beings be free from suffering in the causes of suffering. May all sentient beings be inseparable from the joy that is without suffering.

May all sentient beings abide in equanimity, free from attachment for some and aversion toward others. Thus did I hear at one time the Bhagavan was dwelling on the mass of Vulture’s Mountain in Rajgir, together with a great community of monks and a great community of Bodhisattvas. At that time the Bhagavan was absorbed in the concentration on the categories of phenomenon called profound perception. Also at that time, the Bodhisattva Mahāsattva Ārya Avalokiteśvara looked upon the very practice of the profound perfection of wisdom and beheld those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature. Then through the power of Buddha, the Venerable Shariputra said this to the Bodhisattva, Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara.

How should any son of the lineage train wishes to practice the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom? He said that in the Bodhisattva Mahāsattva Ārya Avalokiteśvara said this to the Venerable Śāriputra, any son of the lineage or daughter of the lineage who wishes to practice the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom should look upon it like this, correctly and repeatedly beholding those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature. Emptiness, form is empty, emptiness is form, emptiness is not other than form, form is also not other than emptiness. In the same way, feeling, discrimination, composition of factors, and consciousness are empty. Śāriputra, likewise, phenomena are emptiness, without characteristics, unproduced, unceased, stainless, not without stain, not deficient, not full.

Śāriputra, therefore in emptiness, there is no form, no feeling, no discrimination, no compositional factors, no consciousness, no eye, no ear, no nose, no tongue, no body, no mind, no visual form, no sound, no odor, no taste, no object of touch, and no phenomenon. There is no eye element and so on up to and including no mind element and no mental consciousness. There is no ignorance, no extinction of ignorance and so on, up to and including no aging and death, and no extinction of aging and death. Similarly, there is no suffering, origination, cessation, path. There is no exalted wisdom, no attainment and also no non attainment.

Śāriputra, therefore, because there is no attainment, bodhisattvas rely on and dwell on the perfection of wisdom, the mind without obscuration and without fear. Having completely passed beyond error, they reach the endpoint of Nirvāṇa. All the Buddhas who dwell in the three times also manifest complete awakening to unsurpassed perfectly complete enlightenment in reliance on the perfection of wisdom. Therefore, the mantra of the perfection of wisdom, the mantra of great knowledge, the unsurpassed mantra, the mantra equal to the unequaled, the mantra that thoroughly pacifies all suffering should be known as the truth since it is not false. The mantra of the perfection of wisdom is declared, Mahāsattva Avalokiteśvara should train in the profound perfection of wisdom like that.

Then the Bhagavan arose from that concentration and commended the Bodhisattva, Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara, saying, well said, well said, son of the lineage. It is like that. It is like One should practice the profound perfection of wisdom, just as you’ve indicated, even the Tathagatas rejoice. The Bhagavan, having thus spoken, the Venerable Śāriputra, the Bodhisattva, mahasattva, Ārya, Avalokiteśvara, those surrounding in their entirety along with the world of gods, humans, the asuras, and gandharvas, were rejoiced and highly praised what was spoken by the Bhagavan. So we’re going to meditate.

We’re going to meditate to our own self lessness, we’re just going to examine, investigate the nature of the self in terms of the body and mind. So I’ll lead you, I’ll lead you through that. Would you like to take a comfortable firm posture? So getting in touch with the body, starting at the crown of your head, the scalp, and feeling the wrinkles in your brow beginning to smooth out. The pressure in and around your eyes diminishing.

The muscles of the face softening, relaxing. Jaws relaxed. Bringing your awareness to the back of your neck and perhaps gently turning your head to each side a few times. Very gently loosening, stretching the muscles of the back of the neck. Relaxing the muscles of the throat.

Bringing your awareness to your upper back and shoulders and perhaps gently rotating your shoulders a few times. Just lifting them up towards your ears and allowing them to drop comfortably to the sides. And with that feeling some kind of burden or weight that perhaps we’ve been carrying around on our backs over the course of the day moving down and through your body into the ground. Like some kind of relief, a weight’s been lifted from your back. And bring your awareness all the way down to your hands.

Your hands are soft and loose. Relaxing your lower arms. Your arms, your upper arms. Chest is at ease. Relaxing throughout the heart area, the center of your chest.

And the lungs, the central region of the back, the stomach, releasing the tension that we oftentimes hold in our stomach muscles, just allowing the belly to go soft. Throughout the abdominal cavity. Keeping your back straight, your trunk erect, relax your lower back muscles. Buttocks, throughout your upper legs, thighs, and lower legs. And finally, feet soft, loose.

Bring your awareness to your body in general, just roughly scanning through the body, noticing any tightness, any tensions which might remain in the body, any areas of possible discomfort. Focusing upon those particular areas and breathing in and down into the tension. Imagine that as if you’re breathing out from that tension wherever it might be found in the body, breathing out and upward. And as you do suggest this, feeling the tension slightly diminished. Breathing in and down to the tightness wherever it might be in your body.

Imagine as if you’re breathing out from that area of tightness and with that the tightness loosening. Breathing into the tension and tightness and out from those areas. If there’s a particular area of discomfort, don’t avoid it or struggle against it, resist it. Breathing down and into those areas of discomfort, surrounding it like a mother, her her child, surrounding it with the breath of kindness, breathing out from that area of discomfort, opening, accepting, softening, just allowing it to be. It’s okay if it’s there.

Breathing into the areas of tension, tightness, and discomfort. Breathing out from those areas. And with that, the body becoming relaxed, at ease. The feeling of physical well-being pervading the body. It’s a nice place to be in your body.

So there’s nowhere to go, nothing that needs to be done, no one to please. Just for a few moments we take a break from the struggle and we can simply be the body. Nothing complicated. Just stay with the experience of the body. At ease, relaxed, at rest with the body.

Staying with the body. We’ll practice the simple breath exercise, breathing in comfortably normally, breathing out, extending the exhalation very gently, forcing all the air out of the lungs. Again, breathing in comfortably normally. Again, extending the exhalation. And then bring your mind to the breath.

The physical sensation associated with the natural breath, wherever it’s most clear and obvious. We’re going to meditate on the nature of the I, the self, and we begin with ascertaining the object of negation. So this simply means we have to get a feeling, a sense of what it is that we’re going to be searching for, what it is that we’re going to be looking for. Appear to us? And it becomes most obvious to ourselves when we have a strong emotional experience.

So either using your memory or by way of your imagination, see if you can evoke a strong emotional experience in which you are you as the I are the central figure, the central character. Maybe either imaginatively or through your memory someone called you stupid or sometime you were very afraid, sometime when you won a prize, sometime when you were overwhelmed, a sense of, ah, I can’t do this. I can’t meditate. I’m bored. I’m so afraid.

I’m hurt. What is that I? Just try to get a sense of feeling for what that I feels like. What does it look like? So try to evoke a strong emotional situation, experience, and get a sense of feeling for what that I looks like.

They’re so afraid, they’re so hurt, they’re so excited. Now we’re going to begin a systematic search for that I to see if what appears to us actually exists. So we’re going to look in the body and mind. So beginning with the body, we’re going to search throughout the body in terms of the various elements of the body, earth, water, fire and so forth. So beginning at the crown of your head, first searching through the earth element.

So the earth element is all the dense solid parts, the hard parts of the body, the bone, the organs, the muscles. So beginning at the crown of your head and as you move through the body downward to the tip of your toes, when you come across some dense solid part, muscle, organ, bone, teeth, examine is this the I that was so afraid? Is this the I that was so hurt? And we can look at the water element of the body. This is the various fluids of the body, the flowing substances within the body, the blood, the saliva, the urine, the lymph.

Again, working down from the crown of your head to the tip of your toes and as you do so, anytime that you come across some fluid, some water element, examine is this the I, the self? Perhaps it’s the fire element, the warmth of the body, the temperature of the body, is that the I, the self? The temperature, the warmth of the body. Perhaps it’s the wind energy element, the respiration, the flow of the breath, all the energies moving throughout the body, or they the I, the self. Perhaps it’s a space element, the cavities, the hollow parts in the body, not what’s in the cavities, but the cavities themselves.

The spaces in the body moving down through your body. When you come across the hollow part, the mouth, the lungs, the stomach, are those hollow places, the I, the self. Perhaps it’s not the body, maybe the mind. So let’s look through the mind. First, aggregate of feelings, pleasurable feelings, unpleasurable feelings, feelings which are neither pleasurable nor unpleasurable, neutral feelings.

Are those feelings themselves the I, the self? The feeling itself, is that the I. Maybe it’s the aggregate of discriminations. It’s the beginning of concept formation, the type of thought which simply recognizes, perceives this is a book, this is a chair, I like this, I don’t like that. Simply recognizing, perceiving this type of primitive primary concept formation, these types of concepts, mental patterns of thought, is this the I, the self.

Maybe it’s the aggregate compositional factors. So this includes all the mental activities of thinking, patterns of thought, various emotions, negative emotions, positive emotions. Complicated patterns of thought, emotions, are they the I, the self? And finally, the aggregate of consciousnesses. Eye consciousness, that which sees colors and shapes, is that the eye, the self, the knower of colors and shapes?

Ear consciousness, the knower of sounds, that which hears sounds. Nose consciousness. The tongue consciousness. The bodily consciousness. And finally, the mental consciousness, that which knows thoughts, images, Maybe the I is hiding away somewhere inside the body like a a marble in a bowl of peas.

So let’s set aside the parts of the body and mind. If we do that we should be left over with the I. So just imagine as if meant taking off your arm, your right arm, examining it. Make sure you don’t overlook the I. It might be inside there somewhere.

If you don’t find it, set it aside. Mentally dismembering the left arm and looking through the left arm so you don’t overlook the I. It might be in the fingers or it might be in the forearm or the bicep or somewhere, in the upper arm. Setting it aside. Set aside, then your right leg, looking through it, examining it.

Setting it aside, doing the same with the left leg. And same with the trunk of your body. Is in there anywhere? Some small entity which is the I, maybe in your stomach and your lungs or somewhere. In your heart.

Setting it aside, examining your head. Maybe it’s in the brain somewhere, some small entity which is the I. You can identify this is the I that was hurt, that was scared. Setting the head aside and set in the feelings aside, all the various thoughts, emotional patterns, all the various consciousnesses, eye, ear, nose, tongue, body, mental. So you completely set aside the body and mind.

Is there anything left over which you can identify as I? Something on your cushion sitting on your chair. Is there an I left over? Some entity, some thing that you could call an I. So the I appears very very solid, very vivid to ourselves, especially when we get have an emotional experience.

It appears very solid, very concrete. And we look for it, and we look for it, and we look for it. Where it appears in the body and mind, we don’t find it. We find the absence, the nonexistence of just that I. We looked and we looked, and we couldn’t find it.

We find the nonexistence of just that I. The I that appears doesn’t exist. So that understanding is the understanding of selflessness. Just hold on to that understanding. That I that appeared, I looked for it, I couldn’t find it.

It doesn’t exist. And then bring your mind back to the breath. And get in touch with your body. Perhaps the feeling of your buttocks on the chair, on the cushion, feet on the floor. Become aware of the sounds about you.

Sounds about you. In an easy and relaxed manner, become aware of your surroundings. So I I’ve already copied some copies if you like to keep them of the this text by it’s on copy that we’re making use of the three principal aspects of the path. So if you like to, we’re going to just kind of follow this along. If you remember the text we’ve been working on.

On the back page, the third verse from the top, says, But even if you were to so this is setting out the three principal aspects of the path: renunciation, the awakened heart, and the awakened mind. But even if you were to instill within you the will to awaken and the awakened heart without the wisdom realizing reality, still you have no way, still you have no way to cut the root of conditioned existence, thus work with the means of realizing dependent arising. So we’ve gone through and discussed the the means of developing the awakened mind, developing the wisdom, realizing reality. But Tsongkhapa, he says that we are to work with the means of realizing dependent arising. We worked through four stages, if you remember.

It’s been quite a journey in developing the coming, at least trying to follow my struggling efforts along the journey. We began with the Hearer stage. At the Hearer stage we accept the objective true existence of the world about us. Things exist the way they appear. They’re out there, solid concrete tables and people and so forth.

The only thing that we call into question at this stage is the nature of the self, the I. We understand that there is an appearance of an I which is characterized by being singular, unchanging, and independently existent. This is a type type of I which appears to us. And we understand that such a type of I is unfindable, just as we did in our meditation. You know, we try to get a sense of how the I appears to us and then we proceed to search for it.

And in a very systematic fashion we come to a conclusion that that I is not findable. It appears but it doesn’t exist. And with that, the conceptions which the habitual wrong conception which grasps at the existence, ignorance, is grasping at the existence of such an I, is unable to be supported in reality. And all the afflictions which are induced by that wrong conception and all the suffering associated with it dissolves into emptiness of such a type of self, of an unchanging, singular, independent self. So that was the hearer stage.

At the mind only stage we began to call into question the world out there. Know, I guess Buddhism is always asking us to question what are these taken for granted truths, these unexamined assumptions that our lives are based upon, which haven’t worked well for ourselves. You know, the Buddha was always pointing out, Well, why don’t you take a look at this? Rather rather than, you know, trying to adjust your life to snakes, why don’t you look to see if the snake exists at all? Something like that.

So at this level, we begin to the mind only stage, we begin to call into question, well, the nature of that world, that apparent world out there. And we see that the division of awareness into the perceiver and the perceived is merely a conceptual invention. It doesn’t exist in fact. It’s simply a fabrication of thought. That there is no difference in substance between the perceiving consciousness and the perceived object.

The eye consciousness apprehending the glass and the glass itself, they both arise from the same substance within the mind, a karmic seed. When that karmic seed is activated, then both subject and object arise simultaneously. With that understanding, we are no longer captivated by these external appearances. And with that understanding, a level of wrong conception which we call ignorance can no longer be maintained. And with that, all the various afflictions which are induced by that misunderstanding and the and the all the various sufferings associated with it dissolve into the emptiness of that duality between subject and object.

But we’re not finished. We went on and we went on to the Autonomy Middle Way stage. And here we call into question the true existence of the perceiving subject. And we understand this was accepted at the Mind Only stage. But we begin to see that phenomena, though they exist objectively, they do not exist independent.

They do not have any independent reality of their own as they appear. That all phenomena are posited by the force of appearing to a non defective awareness. That they exist only as appearances to the mind, though those appearances exist objectively. And again, we begin to work through a level of ignorance. And with that, the afflictions which arise on that particular level of ignorance and the sufferings associated with that particular those particular afflictions.

Okay. Then we we’ve we’ve come to the last stage, which we call the Consequentialist Middle Way stage. And this was the stage that we just went through, that we just explained. And, you know, we call in question the intrinsic existence of everything. Do things inherently exist?

Do they exist by way of their own nature? Do they objectively exist? And we begin to understand that everything is merely imputed by conceptuality and language. That nothing exists from its own side. That nothing has objective existence, inherent existence.

That we define the object. The object does not does not define itself. And the ignorance which grasped at that self defining existence, which grasped at inherent existence and so forth, is no longer with that understanding is no longer able to be maintained. Again, with that, all the various afflictions which are induced by that ignorance and all the sufferings associated with that dissolve by themselves in that emptiness. In Buddhist mental training, training, great emphasis is placed from the outset on distinguishing fantasy and valid cognition.

Indeed, the tendency of the human mind to assume the existence of things that are in fact non entities is considered to lie at the root of a broad range of unnecessary conflicts and miseries. The most basic expression of this mental distortion is the reification of oneself as an intrinsically existent personal identity. So reification means over estimating or making something more solid than it actually is. Making things more concrete, solid. One naturally also, so having reified oneself, we see ourselves as very solid concrete entities.

We’re not quite sure what the nature of it is. It’s been examined. But we hold to that that there’s an entity, an independent, solid, concrete entity which we call I, which we identify as ourselves. Having reified oneself, it is inevitable that one reifies other in the same way. And this sets up an absolute demarcation between self and other.

So what is merely a way of talking, self and other, becomes a solid boundary. There’s an unbridgeable gulf between myself over here and the world out there. And we are setting ourselves up for some struggle of one sort or another. One naturally also reifies one’s natural environment as intrinsically existent and therefore as absolutely other. When such a view is put into action, the program is set for establishing one’s own well-being as opposed to and possibly at the expense of that of other people.

And one’s environment seen like other people as unrelated to oneself, is manipulated towards one’s own end. So the centrist, the middle way view acknowledges the obvious truth that one person is different from the other and they are different from the intimate environment, but such distinctions are conventional, not an absolute nature. Tsongkhapa, in asking us to come to a realization of reality, develop an awakened mind, he says, Thus work with the means of realize dependent arising. So phenomena, dependent arising is the other side of the coin of emptiness. Phenomena are empty of independent existence because they are dependent arisings.

They are dependent arisings because they are empty of independent existence. Meaning of emptiness is the meaning of dependent arising. We understand emptiness by way of understanding dependent arising. We understand dependent arising by way of understanding emptiness of independent independent existence. So are different, so just as there are different levels of coming to this wisdom of understanding realities, are different levels of understanding dependent arising.

We’re not going to we’re just going look at dependent arising to give us a sense of what it means. We’re going to look at it in terms of the Consequentialist Middle Way school, the final thought of the Buddha, the stage that we just covered. There are three ways, let’s just kind of take the essence of dependent arising. Everything is a dependent arising. This glass is a dependent arising, this table is a dependent arising, this building is a dependent arising, I’m a dependent arising.

All phenomena are dependent arising. In what way are the dependent arises? There’s different levels of understanding of what this term dependent arising in different schools of Buddhist thought. There are three main ways in which all phenomena are said to be dependent arising. In the case of products, tables and buildings and people and so forth, they all rise in dependence upon causes and conditions.

And that is accepted in the hearer stage and the mind only stage. That’s what they mainly work with when they talk about dependent arising. Because they arise in dependence upon cause and conditions, they must truly exist. At the Autonomy Middle Way stage, the main use or meaning they use for dependent arising is that everything is dependent upon its parts, its characteristics. You know, we saw that they’re dependent upon mind, but nonetheless there’s something coming from the side of the object.

Have an inherent nature. The nature of fire is hot and burning. When that appears to the mind, it appears to a subject, then we can think with regard to that fire. So here they’re emphasizing that the fire is dependent upon its characteristic of hot and burning. There is something coming from both the side of the subject, but also from the side of the object.

So the fire is arisen independence. It’s arisen in dependence upon its very nature, its characteristics, its parts that are being hot and burning. When this appears to the mind, its existence is established. The meaning according to the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school is the most profound, is the most difficult. The meaning of dependent arising.

That all phenomena are dependent upon language and conceptuality, thought consciousness, which make use of language. Okay? And this is the meaning I want to emphasize and just go through a little bit, and so we have a sense of what dependent arising. But there are three levels of meaning of the word, the, not the word, the concept of dependent arising. One that all products are dependent upon causes and conditions.

And that all phenomena are dependent upon their parts. That all phenomena are dependent upon language and conceptuality, on being labeled, on being named. Okay? And this is one I want to talk about. Dependence, what is the word dependence in the term dependent arising?

All phenomena exist contingent upon something other than themselves. They don’t bring themselves into existence. All phenomena necessarily depend upon something other than themselves for their existence. Nothing arises independent of other phenomena. Nothing is self risen.

Every phenomenon arises through dependence, causes and condition parts and labeling language. Okay, let’s take some examples. Take for example somebody’s running for the office of President or say Prime Minister, okay? So we, they have a body, we suppose. They have a mind, we suppose.

It’s questionable sometimes, but anyway, they have a body and mind. That body arose in dependence upon the sperm and ovum of their parents, upon food and so forth, lots of causes and conditions. That mind arose in dependence upon a previous moment of mind, a cause. Are, those are the parts of this person, there’s the body and mind. But just having a body and mind is not sufficient to be Prime Minister.

There’s an initial necessary condition. The candidate has to actually run for the office and be sworn in by the, I guess, Governor General. Okay. Now just to say, they have to be, if they weren’t dependent upon running for office and being sworn in, then they would have to be the, if they were Prime Minister from their own side, they would always have to have been Prime Minister, even from birth. There was something about them which was in the nature of being Prime Minister.

But it’s not the case. They have to fulfill certain criteria. They win the vote. They run for office, win the vote, and they’re sworn in by the government general, they become a proper basis for being designated Prime Minister. So they fulfill popular and legal conventions, popular legal criteria.

By meeting those criteria, they become a proper basis for being designated, given the title Prime Minister. So they achieved the status of being Prime Minister and depended upon causes and conditions, you know, having a body which arose from their parents and eating food and so forth, a mind. And they’re dependent upon that those parts, body and mind. But they’re also dependent the Prime Minister is also dependent upon being language and conventionality, or the conceptual thought which makes us use of language. That is to say, they’re dependent on being called Prime Minister.

They’re being they’re dependent on being popularly known as Prime Minister. They become a proper basis for the title Prime Minister, in dependence upon meeting certain criteria, legal conventions, and so forth. Then we can legitimately call them Prime minister. We can give them that title. And thereby, in dependence upon that, in dependence upon body, causes and conditions, their parts, and language, and thought they become prime Minister.

So the Prime Minister is dependent upon all of those ways of relying. Everything in the universe arises in the same All phenomena come into existence. They arise dependent upon this basis of designation. The basis of designation was this body and mind, person, this individual who ran for office, received the most votes, was sworn in by the Governor General. Then they become a basis, a proper basis of being designated, given the title Prime Minister.

Everything in the universe exists in that exact same way. There’s a Okay. The point is, okay, so we get a sense of the way language is, the part language is beginning to play in what it is that we, what exists. The terms and conceptuality, the part that they play in that phenomenon depend upon language, they depend upon our thinking them as such. The Prime Minister obviously depends upon our thinking them as such.

They don’t have that nature by the way of their own side. They’re dependent upon, they arise dependent upon our thinking them as such. And but, you know, but our thinking them as such in and of itself is not sufficient. Know, it’s not as if we can call anything that we want anything. It’s not as if we can call a dog and a cat and it makes it so.

The basis that we’re designating, that we’re labeling, that we’re naming has to be a proper basis for that particular name. It has to meet a certain criteria. So in order for something to exist there are three criteria that it must fulfill in being a correct basis for being designated or named, whatever the object may be. First, it has to be renowned in the world. Okay?

This means that particular community or linguistic community must know that object by that name. You know, means is known by the name that we’re going to give it. You know, the four legged animal that barks and wags its tail is commonly known as a dog. If I’m going to name it correctly, I have to name it in agreement with the conventions of that particular community. If I say that’s a cat, I’m not, you know, it doesn’t make it a cat just because I say it’s a cat.

It’s a dog, but it’s not a dog from its own side. But it is a dog in terms of the conventions of this particular linguistic community. That which wags its tail, barks, and has four legs and so forth is known within this linguistic community they call it a dog. So that’s one condition. So it has to be consistent.

There has to be a consensus in terms of what this is commonly known as. The second, the cognition of the object, simply knowing the object, it can’t be contradicted by a valid cognition of conventionalities. What this means is you know, suppose I’m with somebody else and we’re in a field and I say, Oh, look, look, look, there’s a man over there. But in fact it’s a scarecrow, right? But I say, Oh, it’s a man.

That doesn’t make it a man. Why? Because even though it appears to be and I’m conceiving it to be a man. Because my friend over here who has better vision than I do, he said, no, no, no. That’s a scarecrow.

He said, sure. And it’s so you move closer. And upon moving closer, upon investigating the object, my my conception of that object as being a man is contradicted. It’s shown to be invalid by his by his conception of that object as being a scarecrow. In fact, it is a scarecrow.

So it has if it cannot cannot be, you know, my thinking of it as such is not sufficient. It has to be consistent with valid cognitions of that same object. Okay? So that’s the second criteria, that it is not contradicted by a valid cognition of conventionalities. Even though, you know, in dark it might appear to be a snake, it’s not a snake.

That doesn’t make it a snake. Even though I think of it as snake, it’s not a snake. It would be contradicted by a valid cognition which rightly understands that it’s a rope. The third criteria is that it’s not contradicted by a valid cognition of the ultimate. This simply means that if I would, naturally conceive of a truly existent or inherently existent I self or phenomena.

Conceiving of an inherently existent I or independently existent I or a solid concrete I or so forth, these all these conceptions are contradicted by a valid cognition that a concrete, solid, independent, inherently existent I or self or table or whatever simply doesn’t exist. So just because I conceive of it, think of it in that way doesn’t mean it exists. So all phenomena whatsoever are dependent upon the process of labeling, of designating. But this is not an arbitrary process as we can to see. In order for something to be properly labeled, it has to be consistent with the popular renown.

I can’t call a horse a cow and that makes it a cow. It can’t be contradicted by a valid cognition of conventionalities. I can’t say there’s a snake that makes it a snake because that snake would be contradicted by a valid cognition understanding conventionalities which understand that’s not a snake, that’s a rope. And it can’t be contradicted by a valid cognition of an ultimate. Even though I conceive of an I, a self which is independently existing and so forth, that’s contradicted by a valid cognition, understanding that the independent I doesn’t exist at all.

Okay, let’s let’s let’s okay. Just wanted to get across the idea when we talk about dependent arising. We can talk about dependent arising in these three ways. Phenomena arise in dependence upon cause and condition, they arise in dependence upon their parts, and they arise upon labeling, being designated as such. The most subtle and the one that we’re trying to bring out here is this third, that phenomena are dependent upon being named as such.

But they cannot be named as such simply arbitrarily just by wishing it were so. That doesn’t make it so. There are the criteria which I just pointed out which have to be met for something to be validly labeled or named as such. And then it depends upon that, it comes into existence. You know, this is like talk about beauty.

Beauty is there’s no inherent beauty in the nature within the nature of the very object. It is a matter of consensus within our culture what is beautiful and what is not beautiful. You know, this is I think Plato for example, he said there were ideal forms. There was an ideal beauty. And all artistic efforts were simply efforts, ways of trying to approach an idea of that beauty.

I don’t think, I don’t know if I rightly understand what Plato was getting at, but I don’t think Buddhism would agree. What beauty is simply a cultural convention, nothing more than that. There’s no there’s no essential essential beauty aside from what we’ve agreed upon as beautiful. And that and what is beautiful, what we agree upon beautiful changes, doesn’t it, over time? And styles change forms, you know.

So it’s a matter of linguistic convention, consensus, what a popular renown. So Tsongkhapa goes on to say, Whosoever sees the unvarying relation between a cause and its effects in all things of cyclic existence and beyond, and brings to an end holding them as real, has entered onto the path that pleases the Buddha. So cause and effect is the classical logical reason for establishing phenomena as empty of intrinsic existence. Because effects arise dependent upon causes and conditions, they cannot be independently existent. Things are empty of independent existence because they are dependent.

They are dependent upon causes and conditions. It says, Whoever sees an unvarying relation between cause and effect, there’s always an unvarying relationship of similarity of type between the cause and effect. Though things don’t define themselves, we define them, still there is things, there is a relationship between cause and effect. Like an apple tree grows from an apple seed. Peach tree doesn’t grow from an apple seed.

So the effects are determinedly defined by the nature of the cause in which they arise. This applies to all phenomena whatsoever. So there’s a you know, this has application to the law of karma, application to the law of karma. That, you know, that there is an unvarying relation between our experience as a result and the causes which create that. You know, there’s nothing our our our our experiences do not arise by no by no cause.

They do not arise by the by the under the control of a supreme deity. In order, they arise haphazardly. There is a causal relationship between the result as experience it and the causes that created that. And there is a relationship in this in terms of suffering and happiness, it’s in terms of the ethical quality of those causes. Let us say the types of action, the ethical quality of the actions which brought about those results.

So we’re simply saying that, you know, there’s no absolutes, there’s no moral judgment being made, but when we experience the experience happiness arises from a cause which is consistent in ethical quality with that result. Therefore, we call that a positive cause, a positive action. Positive actions bring about, most simply bring about happiness. Negative actions bring about suffering. That’s all we mean by that.

There’s no moral judgment being made. It’s just the law of cause and effect working itself out in terms of our felt experience. That’s all. You know, if it didn’t matter whether you were happy or suffering, it wouldn’t matter what you did. But since it probably does matter whether you’re happy or suffering, then it matters the kinds of causes that you’re creating terms of the karma reactions.

Know, so we’re saying things are empty but things are not haphazard. There are certain rules governing our universe, though these govern, though these rules even themselves do not inherently exist, do not truly exist. Where does time come into this? That’s about it. The concept of time.

Because Yeah. We talk about linguistic linguistic convention and that sort of stuff. Yeah. But that that changes over time. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. And and perception changes over time. Okay. Well, I keep keep going.

Where are you going? Well, it’s just I’m I’m just wondering because we we do have conventions that we’re we’re used to, and then some somebody may come up with a redefinition, which throws the old convention into disrepute, if you like. Sure. So everything is based on a time rather than A time. A time.

Conventions are based on a time, And that time if you if you if you in if you look at time, it’s in thirty seconds time. I might understand what you’re talking about. You know what I mean? It’s it’s so I’m just wondering how you see the concept of time in relation to these conventions. Is time inherent?

Is it is time inherent existent? So time is not absolute. Absolute. Yeah. So, I mean, time is also dependent arising.

A year depends upon its months. It depends upon its parts. It depends upon twelve months. We label year. So it’s dependent upon so it’s a dependent arising.

It’s not not inherent existence. It doesn’t exist absolute. Also, it’s dependent upon the observer. You know, time slows down as you approach the speed of light according to one one observer. Time is not inherently existent and independently existent of speed and observership and all these parts.

Okay, let’s see. So, yeah, let’s see. How are we going? I mean, okay. So you is lay on me again.

It’s depend okay. Yeah. Yeah. I’m just wondering what the interaction of time is you know, in relation to phenomena. You talk about linguistic convention.

Okay. You have a linguistic community? Yeah. Linguistic community. This is the thing.

I mean, let’s just suppose we have a a linguistic community that is a primitive society. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. See something silver flying through the air.

Yeah. They think it to be a god. Yeah. Then another linguistic community comes along at another time and they define that as aeroplane. So that shows shows it wasn’t inherently existently either.

All I’m saying is that when you make up a definition or something like that, you have a definition, it is time based. It’s contextualized. It only is what it is within a particular context. Yeah. What context?

Okay. Well, maybe time is context. Yeah. I mean, yeah. So this silver thing, they could pray to it and and and so forth.

And that’s the level of understanding at that particular moment. So they’re labeling it as a god? Is it supreme? Yeah. Well, I’m I’m just, you know, hypothesizing at that particular point.

But so where what is the space time continuum, if you like, in relation to what we’re talking about. You know? Is where does that come into it? You know? Where is that is that the journey or what?

I’m I’m I’m it just occurred to me that where does time come in? That’s all. Where does time come in? Where does time come in? Or is it a furphy?

Am I just hypothesizing something that’s just not not worth worrying about? So time is yeah. Time is I’m not I can’t nothing’s coming nothing’s coming up to it. How does time how is time involved in the fact that things are empty? Yeah.

In in terms of a philosophy or or or anything, how does what what is time? What is time? Yeah. What is time? You know?

I mean, isn’t isn’t time a developed concept, though, like, do animals realize that part? I’m just Yeah. They’re they’re Well, I’m That’s what I’m trying to that’s my question was, is it something that’s you know, the way you described it, I’m starting to believe it isn’t inherent. It’s not it’s not there. It’s just something that we use to describe our everyday existence rather than actually being rather than actually being like an you know, one of Plato’s ideals.

It’s not actually it’s just really it’s it’s more of a description, isn’t it? Yeah. It’s a description of reality rather than being actual real rather than being reality itself or rather being behind reality. Okay. Now you’re losing that.

I I don’t know. I mean, we describe time. The things if if if we don’t have a concept of time, then then I am, and that’s that’s it. There’s no no further question. Would you still be if you’d like, you don’t need time to to just to be involved in anything for it to have But if you if you if you embark on a questioning journey or any sort of journey, you have to have a concept of time, where you have come from and where you are going to or or where you are at this moment.

Maybe you don’t have a future in Yeah. In in in a quest until you get there, and you never get there. But but then there is this concept of where the journey has come from Yeah. In terms of of time. I you know, what it I don’t know.

Maybe I should just leave it hanging there and don’t worry about it. So I think time and space are probably two of the most, what do we say, primal conceptual context in which everything else is placed. We can’t imagine anything outside of time and space. But nonetheless, it’s just, you know, everything else is are are, you know, time and space are really primitive, and then everything else is within that. We go on to build up other Yeah, they exist.

Sure, yeah. Don’t exist inherently. They don’t exist independent of language, you know, and our thought about them. Nothing exists independent of that. If time were to, yeah, exist independent of its of thought, And then what?

I don’t know. I don’t know what to I mean, obviously, time doesn’t exist independent of its parts. A year is made up of months, months are made up of weeks, and weeks are made up of days and so forth. Space is made up of parts, you know. There’s a space to my right and space to my left, space above me, space below me.

So all of that is all those parts constitute space. Independent of concept. I mean, know, all word, I mean, for example, the most primitive, one of the primitive ways was that people began to have a sense of seasonal, season. Like the seasons change. So they began.

And that was dependent upon the changes in their environment and the movement and changes in weather patterns. On in dependence upon that, they said, summer is coming. Oh, this is summer. Now it’s winter here. So they labeled these various environment environment changes, weather patterns.

They labeled them summer. They labeled them winter. And there seems to be. Animals have a sense of time and they store up, you know, they go into hibernation and so forth. I don’t know.

I don’t I don’t feel very I don’t think we’re satisfying your Well, maybe not at this time. Yeah. This time. I mean, there was a time when people thought the earth was when they saw the sun rise in the east, we see the sun rise in the east, don’t we? And it sets in the west.

And that’s the way we can see about it, and many people still do, but in fact the sun does not revolve around the earth. The earth revolves around the sun. But most people can see the sun rising in east, but actually it’s the earth spinning. That’s what we believe. For Yeah.

That’s when this idea of what is a valid cognition of the conventional would come in. So really it should be called Earthrise rather than sunrise. Yeah. But that we say we have a popular convention that the sun rises in the east, and that works fine. But whether I guess you could argue with this.

It actually does actually the sun rise in the east. And over time, maybe people will begin to sleep. It’s earth rising. Maybe over time people will that convention will change. That we have an idea of what we mean by that.

Yeah, don’t know. It’s a hard one. Can I ask a question about what actually, is there any influences on the labeling process? Is there anything that that we our act or anything that we can sort of influences these labeling process, or is it purely just purely purely cause and effect of other things around us that are influencing or is there any sort of yeah. Just more No.

A lot of it. I mean, lot of it’s so it’s it’s there’s it’s on a continuum. And certain things are what we when I use the word objective, mean, a high degree of publicity, we can all say that there’s a table here. Yeah. So that’s more or less I’m scared to use the word objective.

That’s a there’s a high degree of what we call publicity. Many we have a common experience, we call it. But many things are almost completely subjective. And, you know, and these are arising from you’re labeling this person as enemy. And that’s you know, this enemy arises depending upon you labeling them as such.

And that may be stored karma. You know, the types of labels that you use. You know, it’s what you pay attention to in terms of other people. You pick up on you know, always talk about, you know, you know, it may be completely unconscious that they have a particular trait that you associate with I’ll I’ll make up a scenario. Okay?

That you associate with your father who you didn’t like. They have a certain quirk about them. And for some reason, you just don’t like this person. You see them as repulsive. So you label them repulsive.

in dependence upon what? On this quirk. And you don’t even know you’re doing it. You may be completely unconscious. So that’s very unique to you.

Nobody else will be labeling that same way. That’s very subjective. So how do we how do we intercept these sort of things? Or how do we get inside of them? I’m I’m starting I’m starting I’m thinking more of a on an objective view here on how we can influence our lives the most, you know, sort of trying to you you know, you we’re talking about, like, what what causes arising, you know, what causes our daily lives.

I wanna sort of get in there and try So you have this appearance of this repulsive person. Yeah. Yeah. And you have you you understand that it doesn’t exist from his own side as an repulsive person. And that is he’s dependent upon you.

You’re thinking him as a repulsive person. So for one thing, you might choose not to buy into that appearance, but you’ll say, well, why why do I and begin to question. You become aware. Why am I why, you know, what am I basing that conception on? And, you know, you begin to examine what you and you become aware.

Strange little quote from Fritz Perls. It’s a I must love my name my enemies because after all, I created them. Oh, that’s perfect. Yeah. So, so things don’t exist.

There are these appearances and whenever there’s an affective element, emotional element, you can be sure that it’s not a public object like this table, which has very little affective element. We don’t get emotionally aroused around tables, but maybe an antique dealer would rather than that. But anyway, so I guess don’t get so captivated by appearances and what part in my playing and and you know, there’s there’s always what part in my playing and how I experience this person or this situation. It’s what you pay attention to. They come to your reality, and that’s often unconscious unconscious habit.

Your mind is being directed by impulses, which you’re not even aware of. And it depends upon that. You know, what we label is also part of your karma. I I think also it’s my mind’s always thinking about making lateral decisions to like, lateral decisions or decisions to try and affect my reality, but really I should just focus on what on becoming more aware of what’s happening rather than actually trying to make decisions to change. Change.

Yeah. Because it’s always it’s always like, you know, now I’ve got this new understanding. What am I gonna do? And it’s always sort of thinking about, you know, that always always break away to sort of lateral thinking of of what going away from what really I’ve learned to actually of of how to look at things. And that’s sort of the trick is to sort of not not go into that sort of mindset of of of jumping into decisions to do things, to to to change things rather than let let change happen rather than try to inflict change.

Oh, I see. Yeah. That’s I know. Shit. So it’s a hobby.

And that’s when people have that, you know, of people have bad memories and bad Yeah. Experiences, lots of bad mental baggage in their minds. Yeah. And but they had never been their husband or wife or boyfriend or girlfriends or friends. And they meet someone just meet Joe Joe walks over there on the chair, and he’ll I like you.

Just they they walk or talk all time. Look look like yourself. Yeah. They say, you don’t wanna be this person. I like you.

Yeah. Well, the person on the other hand, you can say someone, let them know them, you can say, jeez, I like you. Janice, why are saying, I like you. For some reason, I just like you and I trust this and that. It’s all basically just from our our own own egos, our own minds.

It’s basically, I like you because you’re wrong with this person. I like you as you go with this person, and I I trust you. Yeah. And then our people just get just just walk into this person’s world. It’s like, I know a lot of people love mine.

Some people used to know back about America, and they had just said the gift of the gab, they could just get people to do anything they wanted them to. Yeah. It was a I used to met them. I never done this. Okay.

Yeah. Yeah. It’s just really just very funny and professional person. You can just get him to do anything you want. I messaged all the other inner mind.

So especially you’re just trying to Yeah. To react in this way, people can actually play that. A lot of good sales in the world. My brother is now in business, and he can just do that. He can he’s just a gift for the gab, he has make everyone feel relaxed, feel comfortable, feel happy around him, and he makes a little business because of that because he makes me feel like.

He basically get people to actually say, look. I trust you. I trust your business, Helen. I trust to give you all my to you. Yeah.

Yeah. So That’s quite true. Yeah. Just all purest what we will think and as truly a part of experience. And Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. That’s right. So it’s yeah. It’s interesting, isn’t it?

So some some these labels are quite shared, broadly shared, like this. But even those were it’s a matter of karma. We were taught this is water. Our mother said this is this, this is that. Conditioning our minds so that when this appeared we think water to it, and water has a certain function.

And so pretty, everybody’s, you know, this is quite shared, this conditioning factor. When that appears, it stimulates us to think water and we react in a particular way. If we’re thirsty, we pick it up and drink. But some are more are very unique to each of our particular selves, how, you know, in the case of an enemy or a friend or something. Or we could have a common enemy, a shared enemy, but we might have a very particular enemy.

That’s so it’s a matter of this community is larger or smaller. It could be very unique to ourselves. Maybe we can maybe we are now Anyway, it’s interesting, isn’t it? I this is our shared reality because we are all labeling and imputing in a common way, more or less. I mean, you’re seeing this side of the table, I’m seeing that side of the table.

This is our this is a world we’re born into a particular world of meaning, and it’s it just taught to us. It wasn’t, you know, a baby, don’t who knows what a baby is. We learn our world. Learn our world. It’s a learned experience.

It’s not out there independent of our mind. I don’t know. Maybe your thoughts. Maybe I won’t. I don’t know if I want to go into another verse.

I’ll give you one example. I think it’s quite easy and quite straightforward. This idea of dependent arising, this floor is dependent arising, this table is dependent arising, building. I’m in dependence upon this and you’re in dependence. So and the rising depends upon cause and condition, their parts and labeling process.

So for example, if you were to you know, you like to live out back in the outback. So you find this nice spot and you clear the land and you put in a you build a foundation and you get lots of your, you know, building materials together, you know, bricks and cement and you build the walls, you know, plaster, plaster board and roof and you build two identical rooms. And it’s exactly identical. It’s got to be it’s you’re building yourself a little cabin out in the outback. And you say, want one to be a kitchen and you want one to be your living quarters.

You say, that one’s got a nice view out there. I to lay back in my bed and just look out that window. I’ll make that the living quarters and I’ll make that the kitchen. And you think of them in that way, and that becomes your living quarters, that becomes your kitchen. So, you know, so so there was nothing about this room which which made it a living quarter, and this room a kitchen.

There’s nothing in it by way of their own nature which made them that. He just he just decided to call this room for one for for one reason or another, maybe good reasons, whatever. He decided to call that room your living quarters. He decided to call that room your kitchen. There was nothing in their own from their own side which made them that.

Something you just decided, named them that. So now you have a cabin with the living quarters over there and a kitchen over there. And they rose in dependence upon causes and conditions and clearing the land, all the effort that you put into it, and building all the materials, you know, on its parts, on foundation and walls, and dependence upon a roof and upon being called that. You name that. Living quarters, you name that your kitchen.

And in dependence upon all that, you’ve got a cabin, you know, it’s a dependent arising. There was nothing it it didn’t exist at all from its own side. There’s nothing inherently process, independent of cause and conditions, independent of parts, independent of being named as such. But but ignorance conceives of the very opposite of that. That there’s an I, for example, that it doesn’t depend upon causal conditions, that depend upon parts, doesn’t depend upon it being named I.

It’s just there. Ignorance believes that. I’m grasping that. And that’s what we’re trying to see through, that that mistaken belief that there is such an entity. If there was such an entity as that, there should be a cabin is such, you know, out there in the woods, which didn’t rely upon causing conditions, didn’t rely upon its parts, didn’t rely upon being called as such.

There should be if there’s such an I as that, there’s there could be just as well a cabin and and a and a living quarters and a kitchen which didn’t rely upon those either. And this is the way that we naturally see things, everything about us, as if they existed independent of all that. So maybe we’ll stop there. Maybe we’ll finish someday. So we can so, you know, we create some positive energy together.

And we can can we can give that positive energy some kind of direction so that our future the person who we become in the future, our future experiences, they don’t arise by accident or haphazardly. They don’t arise from no cause nor through the power of a supreme deity. They arise very in dependence upon just what we do here. This future person is dependent upon what we do now. What you’ve done in the past is who you are now.

What you do now is what you’ll become. It’s a dependent we are dependent arising. And so giving this dedicating this energy in these these ways that we do, acts to facilitate the kind of person that we want to become in the future. May all beings everywhere plagued by sufferings of body and mind attain an ocean of happiness and joy by virtue of my merits. May no living creatures suffer, commit evil, or fall ill.

May no one be afraid or belittled with a mind weighed down by depression. May the blinds see forms and deaf hear sounds. May those whose bodies are worn with toil be restored on finding repose. May the naked find clothing, the hungry find food. May the thirsty find water and delicious drink.

May the poor find wealth, those weak with sorrow find joy. May the forlorn find hope, constant happiness and prosperity. May there be timely rains and bountiful harvest. May all medicines be effective and wholesome prayers bear fruit. May all who are sick and ill quickly be freed from their ailments.

Whatever diseases there are in the world, may they never occur again. May the frightened cease to be afraid and those bound be freed. May the powerless find power, and may people think of benefiting each other. For as long as space remain, for as long as sentient beings remain, until then may I too remain to dispel the miseries of the world. Through these skillful actions, may I quickly become an awakened spiritual master and lead each and every living being to that awakened realm.

May the supreme jewel of the awakened heart that has not arisen arise and grow, and may that which has arisen never diminish, but increase more and more. In the land encircled by snow mountains, you are the source of all happiness and well-being. Powerful Chenrezig Tenzin Gyatso, please remain until the end of cyclic existence. Thank you. If you’d to get a cup of tea, we can sit around and have a chat.

Otherwise, take care.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Is the way we mentally label things influenced by anything, or is it purely cause and effect from the things around us?

Labeling lies on a continuum. Some things have a high degree of "publicity", meaning we share a common experience of them, such as everyone agreeing there is a table in the room. Many other things are almost completely subjective, such as labeling a person as an enemy, which arises depending on one's own labeling. This may be stored karma, and the types of labels used and what one pays attention to in others play a part. For example, someone may have a quirk that unconsciously reminds you of a father you disliked, so you label them repulsive without knowing why. Nobody else would label them that way, so it is very subjective.

Scroll to Top