Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 — 2008-11-24

2 h 0 min · 11,781 words · 24 November 2008 · Buddha House Adelaide

Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 — 2008-11-24
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Three provocative death-contemplation questions anchor the meditative core of this two-hour session with Ven Jampa Gendun: What would mourners say at your funeral? How would you spend your final year? Who would you call from a collapsed building? After a motivational opening on going for refuge and a recitation of the Heart Sūtra, Gendun leads a guided body-scan and death meditation built around these questions, then turns to the main philosophical content: completing the Autonomy Middle Way school — using a magician-spell analogy and a lemon visualization to show how conceptual minds mistake mental images for reality — before introducing the Consequentialist Middle Way view that all phenomena are merely imputed by language and thought, and that reifying self and world as intrinsically existent is the deepest root of suffering.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 30 3PA 2008 11 24.mp3

UUID: a82a9bd0-6141-4b1a-aeef-3dd848683a40

Teacher: Ven Jampa Gendun

Collection: Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 (Ven Jampa Gendun)

Date: 2008-11-24

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 120.7 minutes

Words: ~11,780

How is everybody? Good. It’s pretty. So begin by adjusting our motivation, bringing ourselves to the present moment. Maybe you’ve had a busy day, like unlike me.

So you’ve had to involve yourself in various activities. And in the course of those activities, quite often we lose sight of maybe some of our more deeply held values. We lose what’s important to us, what we feel good about, what gives our life a real sense of purpose, significance. We feel alive. You know, whatever it is, you know, makes it all worth while.

Just this trip we call life. And getting perhaps back in touch with that. And beginning to see whether your overall activities have been taking you in that direction where you want to go with your life? Or maybe you’ve sort of taken some kind of sidetracked that you weren’t even aware of. We can think we can it’s so easy, isn’t it?

To get out of touch with what is important to ourselves. We get hung up on a lot of trivial matters and unimportant things, but at the time they seem terribly important. They take, they absorb, we become absorbed in them. As if that’s all there is. So it’s useful I think to step back, get some perspective on the trees of our life and see the forest.

And if we continue to keep going the same direction, that’s where we’re likely to end up. And is that where you want to end up? I don’t know. Does that make any sense? Sometimes I wonder if I just project my own neuroses upon other people.

I figure we’re not so much different. Maybe superficially shared. But we’re all struggling in one way or another trying to find the good life. It’s hard to understand that sometimes we feel it, don’t we? Sometimes it’s quite apparent we know what it is, but then we lose sight.

Get out of touch, and then we get lost. We become confused again. And time goes by. Life goes by. So in this process, you know, we it’s just a matter you know, this is what we call going for refuge, isn’t it?

I guess the notion of refuge is that there’s something we can do, some way of being, some understanding, feeling that embodies what it is that we want from our life. And we direct ourselves toward that. And we call that a Buddha. A Buddha is a way of being, isn’t it? It’s a way of like if you could if you could tell the the best possible story you could imagine about what your life could be like.

You really thought about it in terms of being, not owning or possessing or having or controlling, but who you could be and what you could do in this life. We’d call it a Buddha story. Yeah, we could get Brad Pitt to play the starring role or something. And or we could get the what’s her name? Nicole.

Nicole Kidman. Thank you. Anyway, we could play it ourselves. We could star our own movie, as it were. The Buddhist Story starring each of us.

We can we can give it a go. Yeah. So I I you might notice that sometimes when my voice goes down, it’s because I don’t know what I’m talking about. So I kind of mumble through it. It’s the volume, it’s this number two.

It’s called the is that is that getting better? Yes. It’s frightening when I can hear myself. To be no one else in a world which is night and day trying to make you everyone else is to fight the hardest battle that we have to fight. And we have to fight it every day of our life.

I think it might be a bit too yeah, just to I have to go down just a little bit. You know, I I I really I I guess we could we could have more just kind of sit around and talk about these things. I think these things are quite this idea about love and fear. And why is it that we don’t choose the life that we want? You know, even if we were to understand what that life is.

We live in so much fear, don’t we? Fear of the unknown and making choices living with the consequences and taking responsibility for the outcomes of those choices. We accept kind of a compromised life in one way or another, a kind of a substitute life in one way or another. Again, maybe I’m just sharing my neurosis, projecting my What does it mean to go for refuge? It means you are willing to forego the fear.

To be fearless doesn’t mean that you don’t have fear. It means that you simply don’t let a fear run your life anymore. You’re still afraid. But nonetheless, you work out. You move out even though one is afraid.

So that’s what we mean by going for refuge, refuge, I think, to what it is that brings us to the real meaning in our life. You know, this is what I like to inspire us all to do more. Even if it’s a little bit sooner. I’m not saying you have to do anything radical in your life or run away to the caves of the Himalayas. It’s just to be a little more loving, a little kinder, a little more generous, you know, pressing the envelope just a little bit more, trusting ourselves a little bit more, allowing our own innate sanity to find a little more expression in how we relate in our everyday life.

Living in that kind of groundless place, that we’re stepping outside of the comfort zone, just a little bit, where we don’t have as much surety and security. Maybe that’s what real Buddhism is all about, helping us to believe that we can. Did you see the movie? Young at Heart. Young at It’s a good it’s it’s a about made in the United States about this group of the singing group.

The average age is eighty two, I think. Yeah. That’s quite fun. And this one one song they sing is they sing punk rock. And this one song they sing is I can.

I can, I I can? And whenever I hear the word I can, reminds me of these people getting up there and rocking off, know, rocking and singing I can do it, I can do it. It’s quite inspiring. In the course of making the movie, preparing for the concert, two of them died. They all have their walking, what do they call them, walking frames and oxygen for care.

It’s quite inspiring. It’s nice to see. So we have to inspire one another. We have to help each other, encourage each other, not to accept a substitute or compromise in some way. Just little bits.

That’s all. Nothing radical. Radical is probably an ego trip of some sort. Just pushing, stepping out of our comfort zone just a little bit, those kind of decisions in terms of not what’s safe, but what feels right at a deeper place in our being. I guess we have to actually feel that, don’t we?

Most the time we’re probably out of touch. We don’t quite know what feels right anymore, do we? We take out other people’s words. Take on other people’s values and it doesn’t quite work for us as we might want it to. Anyway, it sounds like a true confession, I think.

We call it going for refuge to Buddha, to Buddha within inside ourselves. It’s a tremendously happy, healthy, loving, sane human being that we can all become, or at least we can try to become. We can point ourselves in that direction. You know, if you want to go north and you point your cart south, how are you ever going to arrive? Where is that you want to go in your life?

Making that clarifying that for yourself. You know Buddhism tries to help us in that. That gives us some model of sanity we can work toward, we can work into. Someone who’s wise, just knowing things directly for yourself, not taking other people’s words, having the actual experience of the way things actually are, both in the mundane but also on a deeper level. And someone who’s tremendously loving and compassionate, kind of a heart that’s kind of overflowing with unconditional generosity, wishing others to be happy, and really, you know, being willing to put oneself out to some small measure to bring that about, in fact, and having a sense of inner strength.

I can do something. I can make a difference. I can be effective. I’m just not a wimp. Believing in oneself.

That’s what we call Buddha, and how those begin to find expressions in our everyday life in terms of the transformations of this wisdom and love and compassion and personal power, find in skillful and fearless expression and benefiting others. Maybe that’s kind of shaping that final story that we can hope to tell ourselves about ourselves and what we can do with our life in terms of those qualities, giving us some guidelines on where we can find a real refuge for ourselves, where we can find a success in our life for ourselves, where we can find real meaning and purpose. Our life can feel we can find some fulfillment. Whether you succeed or not, that’s beside the point. I think it’s the trying more than anything else that is our real refuge.

Working out against those boundaries, those self imposed limits that we’ve all unknowingly set for ourselves in one way or another. Or we allow set for ourselves by others in one way or another, not settling for a second best in our life. So this is what we study. This is part of our education. How to do that.

It’s an advanced training course. So the inner focus of our life becomes Buddha, which we you know, aspiring is terribly important, isn’t it? If you believe you can, or if you believe you can’t, you’re right. So we have to believe we can. But believing is in itself not sufficient.

We have to try. We have to actually do something. And the doing is the Dharma. Trying to take these guidelines that have been compassionately set down by our teachers and try to make them a living reality for ourselves in terms of our own realizations and our own ways of being, translating them into something that we embody in our everyday lives. And we rely upon others.

It’s important to kind of create that situation, that context for ourselves where we can allow these shoots of aspiration, these seedlings of wisdom and love, all that we’re trying to cultivate and foster, some kind of environment which nourishes, protects, which enhances inner, which fosters what we want to become, which encourages and respects and supports and assists. We need that. We’re not strong enough individually. We need others in our life. To think that realization and the good life simply can be attained in isolation from others is really arrogance, I think.

It’s the extreme of individualism, to see that we think of ourselves as being separate and independent of others, and somehow we can find a good life, a meaningful life, we can find a successful life somehow isolated from others. I think it’s the misconception at best. I think it’s arrogance more than not. And we try to raise the level of motivation near the wire behind that we do what we do. And then stepping outside of our total preoccupation with ourselves, I, me, mine, our self absorption, this self imprisonment.

Know, if only one other person. Can you altruistically, by altruistically, can you set aside aside your own agenda, your own material, your own stuff, your own neurosis, for just that moment, in that kind of, for that one person, and simply want to be there for them, aside what’s in it for you. Can you love that much? I go for refuge until I’m awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings.

I until I awakened to the and Sangha my of generosity and the other perfection. May I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. Go for refuge until awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. May all sentient beings have happiness and the causes of happiness.

May all sentient beings be free from suffering and the causes of suffering. May all sentient beings be inseparable from the joy that is without sorrow. May all sentient beings abide in equanimity, free from attachment for some and aversion toward others. Thus did I hear at one time the Bhagavan was dwelling at Rajgriha at Vulture’s Peak in Rajgirah together with a great community of monks and a great community of bodhisattvas. At that time the Bhagavan was absorbed in the concentration on the categories of phenomenal profound perception.

Also at that time, the Bodhisattva Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara, looked upon the very practice of the profound perfection of wisdom and beheld those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature. Then through the power of the Buddha, the Venerable Śāriputra said this to the Bodhisattva Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara. How should any son of the lineage train wishes to practice the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom? He said that in the Bodhisattva Mahāsattva Ārya Avalokiteśvara said this to the Venerable Śāriputra. Śāriputra, any son of the lineage or daughter of the lineage who wishes to practice the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom should look upon it like this correctly and repeatedly beholding those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature.

Form is empty emptiness is form emptiness is not other than form form is also not other than emptiness. In the same way feelings, discrimination, compositional factors, and consciousnesses are empty. Śāriputra, likewise, all phenomena are emptiness, without characteristics, unproduced, unceased, stainless, not without stain, not deficient, not fulfilled. Therefore, emptiness, there is no form, no feeling, no discrimination, no compositional factors, no consciousness, no eye, no ear, no nose, no tongue, no body, no mind, no visual form, no sound, no odor, no taste, no object of touch, and no phenomenon. There is no element, no so on up to and including no mind element and no mental consciousness element.

There is no ignorance, no extinction of ignorance and so on, up to and including no aging and death, no extinction of aging and death. There is no suffering, origination, cessation, and path. There is no exalted wisdom, and also no non attainment. Śāriputra, therefore, because there is no attainment, bodhisattvas rely on and dwell in the perfection of wisdom. The mind without obscuration, without fear, having completely passed beyond error, they reach the endpoint of nirvana.

All the Buddhas who dwell in the three times also manifestly completely awaken to unsurpassable, perfect, complete enlightenment in reliance on the perfection of wisdom. Therefore, the mantra of the perfection of wisdom, the mantra of great knowledge, the unsurpassed mantra, the mantra equal to the unequaled, the mantra that thoroughly pacifies all suffering should be known as the truth, since it is not false. The mantra of the perfection of wisdom is declared, Tayata Om Gate Gate Pāragate Pārasamgate Bodhi Svāhā. Śāriputra, the Bodhisattva Mahāsattva had trained the profound perfection of wisdom like that. Then the Bhagavan arose from that concentration and commended the Bodhisattva Mahāsattva Ārya Avalokiteśvara, saying, Well said, well said, son the lineage.

It is like that. It is like that. One should practice the profound perfection of wisdom just as you have indicated. Even the Tathagatas rejoice. The Bhagavan having thus spoken, the Venerable Śāriputra, the Bodhisattva Mahāsattva Ārya Avalokiteśvara, those surrounding in their entirety along with the world of gods, humans, asuras, and gandharvas were overjoyed and highly praised what had been spoken by the Bhagavan.

We’re going to meditate. Would you like to stand up and stretch before we sit? So let me Last time we were meditating on death and we tried to to meditate on death is to help us to appreciate our life, to to live our life as fully as possible before we die. And what does it mean that we as a living being are going to stop living? Is, you know, I am not someday I’m not going to be here any longer.

The world’s just going to keep on going, but I won’t be here. And what does that mean? What is the significance significance of that for ourselves? How would that impact upon the way that we live our lives if we could be mindful of that? That’s significantly kind of abiding within the significance of that question.

So, you know, I thought we’d put some other questions to ourselves in terms of as a way of clarifying, you know, I was talking about clarifying for ourselves what is important to ourselves, what is important to your life. You know, death helps us to clarify what is important. It cuts through a lot of bullshit, doesn’t It gets down to our priorities, what really is important, has meaning. Everything else kind of pales into its significance in light of death. So it helps us in that way.

It can be kind of an ally making friends with death. It’s like a commercial, isn’t it? There’s a weekend coming up called Making Friends with Death. So that’s what it’s all about. You can be a wise advisor.

You know, when you get down and you feel life is overwhelming, then you just have to look over your shoulder at death and ask. Death will say, I haven’t come for you yet. You still are alive. When we feel life is overwhelming. So take in a comfortable, firm posture.

Beginning with the getting in contact with our body, bringing your awareness to the various parts of the body, relaxing, tension and so forth. Starting at the crown of your head, the scalp. Feeling the wrinkles in your brow beginning to smooth out. The pressure in and around your eyes diminishing. Muscles of the face softening, relaxing.

Your jaws relax. Bring your awareness to the back of your neck and perhaps gently turning your head to each side a few times. Just very gently loosening, stretching the muscles of the back of the neck. Relaxing the muscles of the throat. And bringing your awareness your upper back and shoulders, perhaps rotating your shoulders a few times.

Lifting them up towards your ears, and just allowing them to drop comfortably to the sides, and they drop down, feel some kind of weight or burden moving down through your body into the ground. As if some burden, some weight that you’ve been carrying around unknowingly on your back over the course of the has just been lifted from your shoulders, a kind of relief. Bringing your awareness all the way down to your hands. Your hands are soft and loose. Relaxing your lower arms.

And your upper arms. Just as it is. Relaxing throughout the heart area. And the lungs. The central region of the back, releasing the tension that we hold in the stomach muscles, just allowing your belly to go soft.

Relaxing throughout the abdominal cavity. Keeping your trunk erect, your back straight, relax your lower back muscles. Your buttocks. Upper legs. And your lower legs.

And finally, feet, just soft, loose. And bringing your awareness to your body in general, just roughly scanning through the body, noticing any tightnesses, any tensions within the body, any areas of discomfort. And focusing upon those areas, breathing into the tightness, breathing out from the tightness, feeling the tightness loosen, breathing into the tension, wherever it may be, breathing out from the tension, feeling it diminish. Breathing down into the tightness, into the tension, breathing out from the tightness and tension. If there’s an area of discomfort, don’t avoid it, don’t struggle against it.

Breathing into the discomfort surrounding it, just like a mother cradling her her child, cradling the discomfort with a kind caring acceptance, breathing out from the discomfort, opening, softening, accepting, breathing into the tightness, the tension, Breathing out from the tightness, the tension, the discomfort. Breathing into the body, breathing out from the body. Becoming comfortable, at ease. So there’s nothing that we need to think about. There’s nowhere to go.

Nothing no one to please. Just give yourself a break. Just stay with your body. As simple as that. Nothing complex.

Nothing difficult. Just stay with and accept your body. Just be your body for a few moments. Just rest in awareness of your body. Stay with your body.

We’ll practice the breath exercise, breathing in comfortably, normally, out, extending the exhalation, completely emptying the lungs, breathing in comfortably, normally. Again, extending the exhalation, just very gently entertain the lungs And then bring your mind to the breath. The easy, gentle, in and out flow of the breath wherever the sensation associated with the natural breath is most clear and obvious. If it’s helpful you can use the techniques of counting and noting the breaths. So now we’re going to meditate on death, and we’re going to put a few questions to ourselves as clarifying what’s important to our life.

Okay, beginning with, if you could somehow listen in on your funeral when the people you most cared about were there, what sort of things would you like to hear them say about you? What would you like them to think of the role that you played in their life? So it’s your funeral, there’s a few other people you really care about and they’re giving a eulogy, saying words about you. What would you like to hear? What kind of role would you have liked to have played in their life?

So we have another question. If you knew you only had one year to know, how would you like to be as a person? And what would you like to do during that time? So you’ve got one more year. Year.

Without any constraints, what would you like to be as a person? How would you like to live during that year? And then one last question. If you were trapped in a collapsed building, and you knew you only had a few moments left to live, but you had a mobile phone with you, who would you call? And what would you say to them?

And what does this reveal about what’s important to you? There’s a collapsed building. A few a few minutes to live. You’ve got a mobile. Who would you call and what would you say?

And what does that tell you about yourself? What is important to you? And then bring your mind back to the breath. And get in touch with your body, perhaps the pressure of your buttocks on the cushion, on the chair, just some feeling sensation within the body. And in a slow and easy manner, just become aware of your surroundings.

And then a big stretch. Would anyone like to share with the experience, what came up for them? Any thoughts around that? I wanted to show my husband that I loved him. Oh.

And I wanted him to keep on loving. Oh, that’s that’s very nice. And then I realized that for my bit of story, think it is passing on the legacy of love. That’s how loving. Wow.

That’s a beautiful thought. Passing on the legacy of love. Anybody else? Nothing to pull you up. Right?

Yeah. We’re marching through emptiness. So we’re looking at these four stages in development, understanding of emptiness, the hearer stage, the mind only stage. Tonight we’ll complete the third, the autonomy middle way stage. We’ll begin the fourth, the Consequentialist Middle Way stage.

The fourth is, know, this consequent Middle Way stage is the final thought of the Buddha and the nature of reality. It’s like the rungs of a ladder. One rung facilitates the next rung and so forth. Kind of loosening up our minds a bit. It said one of the signs that your meditation and emptiness is working is if you become afraid.

Strange, isn’t it? But that seems to be the case. Was a disciple of Tsongkhapa was giving a teaching on emptiness, and one of his students during the course of the teaching had this profound realization, and he felt as if he were going out of existence. And he grabbed on his shirt, and Tsongkhapa looked out on the audience and said, Such and such has just found emptiness on his shirt. So there’s this it’s just simply not I mean, there’s an intellectual component, that’s for sure.

Want to We want to understand the teaching and so forth. But there’s also an emotional component. And there’s a sense of resistance to the groundlessness of being, that things aren’t as substantial as we normally conceive them to be. And it’s maybe a bit scary. It said, Those who know nothing about emptiness are not afraid of emptiness.

Those who know a great deal about emptiness are not afraid of emptiness. It’s those in between. That gets a bit scary. But that’s a good sign. That’s a good sign.

Know, things just aren’t as solid as we habitually normally conceive them to be. They’re there. It’s not as if they’re not there, but they’re not quite there in the way we normally think and conceive them to be not quite as solid and concrete. You know, we’re beginning to have a sense of the mind, the role that our mind is playing in bringing forth our experience, our lived reality. So this is a gradual process.

You know, I don’t think it could be It’d be like, I think, you know, if you woke up one morning, looked in the mirror, you’d age fifty years or something, you’d freak out. But we don’t even notice that gradually. We look in the mirror every morning and we age fifty years after fifty years, we’re like, Okay. Maybe it’s not so nice, but we don’t freak out. But this is something similar, maybe just gradually, you know, working our way through and letting go of the taking for granted world out there and so forth.

So we’re looking we looked at the the the what’s called the Autonomy Middle Way School. In Sanskrit, Svatāntrika Madhyamaka. For them, we’re beginning to question the part that mind is playing in bringing about our experience, is what the world about us and our self and so forth. And we use that analogy of the magician illusion. You know, the magician has a special spell.

He casts this spell, and it affects the audience, but it also affects himself. And so there’s two individuals. One is the magician, and there’s the audience, and then there’s a latecomer who comes to the performance. And this spell has the ability to cause a stick and a pebble to appear as a horse and an elephant. Anyone who is affected by this spell, what is in fact a stick and a pebble appear as a horse and an elephant.

So we can distinguish three different types of people in this situation. The magician, who has been affected by this spell, he’s heard it himself, this mantra. And so there’s a horse and an elephant appearing toward them. But he doesn’t grasp them as being real. He knows it’s simply the effects of this mantra, this spell.

It’s only appearance. There’s nothing it’s not a real horse and elephant. So he doesn’t react as if it were a real horse and elephant. And then there’s the audience, you know, who are affected by the spell, but moreover, they grasp to that appearance as being true. At the spot on that stage where there appears a horse and elephant, they grasp to the reality of that horse and elephant and they react with various emotions, maybe fear, maybe attachment, maybe they like that horse, you know, I wish I had that horse, whatever.

They emotionally react to as if that were true. And then finally, there’s the latecomer who’s not affected by the spell at all. And for them, it’s not even the appearance of horse and elephant. What to say of grasping that that horse and elephant is true? So in this analogy, the magician is likened to someone who has an understanding, an initial understanding of emptiness.

The things appear to exist out there independent of our mind, solid, concrete, in and of themselves. But they know that’s simply an appearance to the effect of ignorance. And so, though things appear to exist out there as solid, concrete, independent of their mind, they don’t grasp to the reality as being true. Things don’t truly exist that way. And then there’s the there’s the the common person who has the appearance of things existing independent of the mind out there, solid, concrete.

You know, but by that I mean not just tables and chairs and flowers and so forth. That’s not so important. But beauty, friend, enemy, stranger. You know, things where there’s a subjective reaction, where there’s kind of an emotional overlay that we bring to. You know, the beauty exists out there in in the very nature of that object.

It’s not dependent upon my mind. And the common person reacts to that with grasping. It’s true. It truly exists as attractive. It the actual real ability to bring me bliss.

It’s in the very nature of that object. I want it. I need it. I have to have it. Have to make it mine.

So they react with attachment. With regard to the enemy, they react with their aversion. It’s the nature of the enemy to be despicable, to be despicable. And then that so that’s the common person who not only has the appearance of things truly existing, but beneath that belief, beneath that appearance, and grasps and reacts accordingly. Beautiful, ugly, you know, attractive, unattractive.

The mind is just constantly buffeted back and forth between these states. And then finally there’s the third, the latecomer. Most ordinary beings are latecomers, I think. Maybe it’s useful sometimes. Who’s not been affected by the spell, let us say, who’s no longer affected by ignorance.

They’ve developed exalted wisdom, realizing emptiness, profound ongoing realization emptiness. And for them there’s not even the appearance of true existence. They understand the way in which these appearances depend upon the mind. Things don’t exist out there, solid and concrete, so therefore there’s no grasping. There’s not even the appearance of true existence.

So the goal of the Autonomy So we’re talking about a particular level. I think, you know, I’m kind of preparing you for this, the next level, Consequentialist Middle Way School. I think this is the most interesting, the most profound. But here at the stage, the the goal is to eradicate the ignorance that conceives of true existence. You know, what this idea of what we mean by true existence, that things exist the way they appear.

If something exists the way it appears, then it is true. You know, just like this idea of of somebody who’s a phone who’s a phony. Here’s what they say and what they think are aren’t concordant, aren’t in harmony. We say they’re phony. They’re false.

They’re fake. If they’re if what they say and what they think are are accorded with one another, we say they’re, you know, they’re true blue. I don’t say that, but some people say that. They’re honest. They’re straight.

You know? Truthful. Truthful. Honest. So likewise, if what we mean by truth is, things exist the way they appear.

And we’re talking, okay? So the reason which is emphasized at the Autonomy Middle Way stage, there’s a reasoning which we can use, make use of, is called the reasoning of freedom from one or many, or lack of being one or many, or we can use different words. It’s a different translation for the same Tibetan words. Unitary or multiplicity. So things are either singular or plural.

Multiplicity or unitary and multiplicity. Are all different ways of saying the same thing, one or many. Unitary, multiple, multiplicity. We want to try to prove that objects do not exist the way they appear, and to our mental consciousness, the way that we think about them, to thought. Due to ignorance, products appear to be truly established.

So the word ‘truly established’ means established in truth. That means the way they appear and the way they exist are the same. That’s what we mean by true. But in fact, our emptiness are being established in the way they appear. This nature of emptiness is exemplified by cataracts.

Cataracts. Eye defect in the cornea, in the eye, I believe. It’s just another analogy to help us understand. If a phenomena were ultimately established, then the phenomena itself would be its own final mode of being. I know some of these expressions are kind of hard, especially when you hear them read.

It’s hard enough just to figure them out when you’re sitting there reading them. The things are not the things are things don’t establish themselves. They aren’t their own final. And what we mean by final is when we analyze, when we try to penetrate the nature of the object, what do we come to understand with regard to the table? Not whether the table exists, but we’re always talking about this I mentioned this word a long time ago.

I’ll I’ll re mention it. The the ontology. Ontology is the way things exist. This is what we’re concerned with. It matters.

And it’s just not a philosophic game. It does matter because we’re mistaken with regard to the way things exist. Maybe it doesn’t matter so much with tables, but it does with beauty, with ugliness, with friend, enemy, and stranger. You know, things which have this emotional baggage that comes along with it. They don’t exist.

What how does what is the way the friend exists? What is the way beauty exists? Is it is it in the very is beauty in the very nature of the object itself. You know, if you you see a beautiful body, and there’s something attractive. You know, there’s there’s something magnetic about it.

There’s something almost something behind that appearance which which has a sense that this body can bring you pleasure. It’s that it’s in it’s it’s in its very it’s in the very nature of that flesh, the way it’s proportioned, the way it’s colored, shape. Just the way all those qualities in that very nature of them, it has the potential. It has the ability ability to bring you pleasure. That’s in the nature of the object.

It’s coming all from the side of and, you know, if you can only bring that object to make contact with it, you can experience that that nature of the object. That’s the way it’s appearing. That’s the way we think about it. It’s interesting, isn’t it? In Buddhist psychology, all thought consciousnesses are mistaken.

But we have to understand understand why they are mistaken. Thought consciousness is very useful because we can understand things without having them present. You know, I can think about my room at home. I can have all my beds here and my desk is here. And I can have correct knowledge without having to be directly in contact with the object itself.

I can use symbols. I can use models. human beings are model builders. So we can manipulate these symbols and models, these ideas, in various ways, and we can come to new ideas, new understandings. But what happens is we take our idea of the object for the object itself.

Don’t know if we Did we do lemon thing? We’ve never Is it? It’s anyway, close your eyes for a moment. You’re in your kitchen at at the kitchen counter, and you’ve got a chopping block there, a knife, and there’s a lemon. Pick up the lemon, feel the hardness of its skin, feel the dimples, the yellowness, the bright yellow color, and bring it up to your nose.

Smelling that lemony scent, it’s nice, isn’t it? Then put that lemon down on the chopping block, cutting board, and begin to slice through it, and the juices begin to squirt out, slicing through it. And all the way cut through. And take take half of the lemon, put it in the palm of your hand, and tilt your head back. And then lift that lemon up and squeeze the juice into your mouth.

Let it slide down the tip of your tongue toward the back of your mouth. Okay. How many people’s mouths watered? Why did your mouth water? There’s no lemon there, is there?

You know there’s no lemon there. It’s just purely imagination, purely in your head. Just thoughts, just ideas. But part of your mind believes there’s a lemon there. And that belief is so strong that you actually physiologically react as if there were, in fact, a lemon there.

But you know there’s lemon there. You can tell yourself there’s something there, but you still react as if they were. So part of our mind takes the idea, the mental image, the model for the thing itself. This is what is called cognitive fusion. What we think about, the thing that we’re thinking about is taken to be the thing itself.

So we understand things through our ideas about them. I can close my eyes and I can think about the table in front of me, and I can understand that I have an image in my mind of the table. I can understand that table through my image. But normally what we do, and what we quite often do, is we begin to mix the thing itself with the image that we have of it. That’s why all conceptual consciousness are said to be mistaken.

We mistake our idea about the thing for the thing itself. This is especially true when you fall in love. That’s why people usually have to fall out of love. The reality is something else altogether, aside from your ideas about them. Then you can get on with a real relationship.

I don’t mean that cynically. Anyway, what am I going on here? I’m going on about things appear to our thought consciousness. And there is a great deal of They’re just not simple appearances. A mental image is a complex.

It has a lot of past baggage that comes with it. And when a friend appears to you, it has some of the associations from all the friends that you’ve had over the course of your life, maybe. The same way with an enemy. We dump all this on this poor person that’s in front of us, you know. All our past history gets dumped on them, the associations, the feelings, our memories.

Wow. They’re just a hook. We hang all this stuff on. What is appearing to us is not true. We take it to be the thing itself.

So whenever we’re relating, we’re relating to a larger extent filtered through our ideals about the object. Filter through our ideas, models, our symbols within this compact image, with all this emotional baggage and associations and so forth that goes with it. So when we look for the object, when we try to analyze, how does the object appear to us? So how can we know that? How can we know that?

That the way the object appears and the way the object exists is not concordant, is not in harmony. That what is appearing to us is a falsity. I’m talking about the thought consciousness. So, you know, it’s like objects appear as if they weren’t being established by our minds. How do we know that’s not true?

When the mind conceives of an object, whether it’s a person or a table or a car, whatever, the object appears partless, as a singularity, as a whole, a partless unit. You know, it’s like, I’d like to get a dog. That dog It makes sense, doesn’t it? Okay. It makes some kind of sense.

But that dog appears that’s appearing to my mind. It doesn’t have any parts. It doesn’t have any, you know, four legs, tail. There’s not any particular breed, not a particular dog, you know, with a it’s generality. It’s not a spot here, and maybe a short tail, or whatever, all the different characteristics of a specific dog.

It’s just a general reality. At the moment the parts when the whole appears to us, the parts don’t appear. When the parts appear to us, when I think about the dog, I think about, oh, I want a dog with a white spot here and long hair, long tail, whatever part. Okay? I don’t the mind is unable to conceive the whole and the parts at the same time.

When we conceive of the whole, we cannot conceive of the parts. When we conceive of the parts, we cannot conceive of the whole at the same time. We cannot think of them simultaneously. They exist simultaneously, but we cannot conceive of them simultaneously. We cannot think of them simultaneously.

One way of saying this is that we cannot posit the whole and its parts simultaneously. When we begin to analyze an object into its parts, think about it. The parts. The object of the whole, a partless unit, no longer appears to our mind. Only the parts appear.

When you think of the the wheel, the engine, the doors, the bonnet, the car as a whole doesn’t appear. When you think of whole car, you know, whole car, the parts of the the whole appears as if it were partless. The parts of the car do not appear. The appearing object is not analyzed, the objects appear as a whole, a partless unit, and its parts don’t appear. I admit this is a little bit convoluted, I think.

Whole and part appear to be different entities. Like, you know, like a dog and a cat. You know, take take example this table. There’s there’s all the parts to it, you know, the top of the table, the sides of the table, the legs of the table. Those are the parts of the table.

When we think of the whole and we think of the parts, whole and and parts appear to our thought consciousness as separate entities. Let’s just like a dog and and a cat. You you can get rid of the dog and keep the cat, or you can keep the dog and get rid of the cat. And getting rid of one doesn’t mean you necessarily get rid of the other. They’re different separate entities.

That’s the way we conceive of wholes and parts. We have a sense of we could get rid of the table and the parts, we would still have the parts. The the top the top the top, the sides, and the leg. Or we could get rid of the the parts, the top, the legs, the sides, and the top, and we would still be left with the table. This is the way the thought conscious is operating, as if they were different entities, just like a dog and a cat.

You know, whole whole is the sum of its parts, isn’t it? This is getting a bit abstract, aren’t we? And the parts are a portion of the whole. They necessarily rely upon one or the other. But we can see them as different.

That’s the way they appear to us. Just like when you thought about that lemon. You didn’t think about all its various parts, its pulp, its seeds, it was just a lemon. There wasn’t a sense of at that moment the mind was not distinguishing parts, even though a lemon necessarily has parts. Anyway, the point that Svatāntrika, that the Consequentialist School is trying to make trying to make is that when things appear to our thought consciousness, it appears to be the thing itself.

But it’s not the thing itself. That appearance is false. It is not true because the object doesn’t exist the way it appears. And one you know, we are not only laying on all this complex you know, a mental image is a complex of memory, emotions, feelings, but also visual elements, you know, all the various associations with it. Are overlaying that upon the object itself.

We take that to be the object itself. The way that we know that’s not the object itself is. Why? Because once we analyze that whole, we understand everything has parts. What is appearing to us appears not to have any parts.

I mean, I realize this, maybe you have to take my word on it now. When you conceive of something, at that moment, when you think of a car, the parts don’t appear to you at that moment. But everything has parts. Therefore, that appearance is not true. Anything that you analyze necessarily has parts.

This table has parts. Each of the parts, the leg has parts. We could analyze all the way down to atoms. Those atoms, they also have parts. They have directional parts.

You know, the part the top part, the bottom part, the part on the east, the part on the west. Everything has parts. Consciousness has parts. Comes down to mind moments. Those mind moments each have parts.

There’s the beginning of the mind moment, the middle of the mind moment, the end of the mind moment. That beginning of the mind moment has parts. The beginning of the beginning, there’s the middle of the beginning, there’s the end of the beginning. You you could go on. Everything has parts.

Even permanent phenomena have parts. You know, like unconditioned space. There’s a space in the North, there’s a space in the West, and so forth. Everything has parts. So therefore, that appearance which is appearing to our thought consciousness, when things appear to not have parts, is not true.

So we no longer quite believe in the reality of what is appearing to us in terms of our thought consciousness. We no longer take that appearance to be true. There is a false element involved. Nothing truly exists. Nothing truly exists.

When the mind So the mind doesn’t What happens? When the mind it doesn’t you know, it’s just like this due to the influence of ignorance for the spectator. They believe their appearance to be true. They completely fall for whatever appearing to them as if it existed the way it’s appearing. And they react with accordingly, with aversion or attachment and so forth.

And then we’re trying to get trying to develop a sense of that not everything that things do not quite exist the way they appear. And therefore, we we are we are no longer what we call naive realists. It’s just taking everything on face value. And therefore, not not reacting in a in we’re we’re beginning to inter inter interrupt the chain of emotional reactions, which begin with the basic assumption, the belief of ignorance, holding that things exist the way they appear. That this, from its own side, has the potential to bring me bliss, and then acceding to that, holding that to be true, and thereby reacting with attachment, enacting various activities in order to make that mind creating karma in the whole process.

So if we believe it to be a falsity, we won’t buy into that if it’s not truly existent. I think Okay, so we’re beginning to have a sense that the mind is playing a part in the process of how we’re relating with the world. In the sense that it is like here at autonomy stage, the mind is not playing such a large role. It is simply accepting those appearances. You know, just like just like the the audience due to the effects of the mantra or the spell, it just kind of accepts that appearance as being true.

Now let’s go on to now we’re going to go on to the consequence of middle way school, where the mind is going to play a greater part. You know, there’s a shift away from the object, the reality of the object in and of itself, and now there’s a greater and greater subjective element. The mind is going to play a dominant role in the bringing forth of our lived experience. The objective world plays a lesser and lesser role. Throughout this process, from the hearer stage, mind only stage, autonomy stage, now here the consequence stage, initially there was unquestioned acceptance of the appearances of things, of the self and the world about us, the objective world out there, and the reality which underlies that.

Now we’re moving toward a deeper and deeper questioning of these appearances and a greater and greater acknowledgment of the subjective elements underlying that reality. Realism assumes that objects and events in nature define themselves in ways that can be grasped by the human mind. One way, for instance, would be through the language of mathematics. Einstein expressed this view in his comment that the most incomprehensible thing about nature is that it’s comprehensible. A centrist view, that is, say, the middle way view, the middle way this is the view we’re going to we’re studying now on the other hand denies physical reality defines itself in terms of mathematics or in any other human language or concept.

In short, nature does not define itself at all. There is nothing about the object which makes it what it is. That’s pretty thoroughgoing. And how do what how are we going to come to that? What does that mean?

There’s nothing from the offside of the object which determines what it is. There’s nothing which determines that this object is beautiful from the side of the object. There’s nothing from the side of the object which determines that this is a friend from the side of the object. There’s nothing from the side of the object which determines that this is an enemy from the side of the object. human beings define the objects and events of the world that we experience.

Those things do not exist intrinsically or absolutely as we define them or conceive of them. They do not exist intrinsically at all. But this is not to say they do not exist. The entities that we identify exist in relation to us, and they perform the function that we attribute to them. Attributing the the identity to an object of a car, it functions as a car, the car exists.

But that very existence that we define as we define them is dependent upon verbal and conceptual designation. The final view that we’re trying to come to do is all phenomena whatsoever, tables, houses, buildings, cars, cells, people, and so forth, they are merely imputed by language and conceptuality. They are merely labeled. They are dependent upon language and the thoughts which use language. They don’t nothing exists independent of language and our thoughts about them.

Thus, the world that we experience is related to human language and the fact that is humanly comprehensible presents no mystery at all. On this subject, Benjamin Lee Wharf writes, the ideal unfamiliar to modern world, that nature and language are inwardly akin was for ages known to various high cultures who historically whose historical continuity on the Earth has been enormously longer than that of Western Europe. Okay, this is what do we mean? We have used when we were discussing the hearer stage, we talked about we used this analogy of, you know, it’s it’s it’s evening time, and there’s long grass, and it’s getting dark. Yeah?

And there’s a coil of striped rope in the grass. And you’re walking along, and suddenly there appears a snake. Okay? There isn’t there’s an appearance of a snake. Okay?

There is no difference. So we’re talking about, you know, due to there’s no difference at this at this autonomy, at the Consequentialist Middle Way School between the appearance of that snake and the appearance of a rope. They both are coming from the side of the mind. So you aside from the fact that the conception of a snake is incorrect, and the conception of a snake is correct, aside from there being one conception correct and the other being incorrect, the way those they come into existence is identical. So you see how much is coming from the side of the mind.

It’s not to say the snake exists, but the appearance of the the fact that the snake appears and the fact that the snake rope appears is due to language and thought. There’s nothing about that object which makes it a snake or makes it a rope. However, it’s not to say a snake exists. If we were to investigate, we would find no snake there. If we were to investigate, we would find a rope.

So this is the difficult point. How can things be merely dependent upon, merely labeled, simply projection through language and thought and still exist, not just be hallucination? Just because we want something to be that doesn’t make it that. There is no difference at the way the rope and the way the snake are being designated or projected by the mind. In both cases, the nature of the appearing object is constructed by the mind.

It’s in, is part of the perceptual process of the mind. It’s determined by the characteristics of concepts and the terms that we’re using. In other words, phenomena do not define themselves. What they are is not determined by their nature themselves. They don’t have any intrinsic nature.

Objects do not define themselves. We define them. We define them through our use of language and through our use of thought. Define language and through our use of thought. So this is the final view we’re trying to come to.

Both in scientific research and in everyday experience, we ascertain objects that are endowed with certain attributes. And it is by means of the defining characteristics of an object that we identify it. From the Middle Way perspective, we assert that entities do not determine their own defining characteristics. That is, they are not self defining. Having recognized a certain object, we say that it has the qualities by which we identify it.

So the final view that we’re trying to move to is understanding that phenomenas are not self defining. What does that mean? That things make themselves what they are. That determine their identity. At the hero stage, when we took the world out there for granted, existing objectively.

We were mirrors. The things define themselves. A table is a table by way of its own nature. And we, like mirrors, passively, simply reflected that reality which was given to us, that objective reality. Here we’re saying, no, we are engaged in world making.

It’s a participatory universe. We were involved in bringing forth that object. The very act of knowing object, brings forth the known. Things do not exist from their own side. We are drawing, are as it were, bringing them into existence through language and conceptuality through our thought.

So it’s very much the shift is coming from this from how now shifting completely from the side of the object to that of the mind. We’re not so but we’re not it’s not mind only school. We’re not in a it’s not things exist out there. They do exist externally to the mind. But way they exist is dependent upon my mind.

According to the child psychologist, Jean Piaget, the child first constructs a concept related to the world, then projects it out onto the world. The concept is externalized so that it appears to be independent of the subject’s own mental activity. As we can see from our own experience, the phenomena that we perceive in the external world appear to exist independently of our perception. That flower, that plastic flower doesn’t appear, you know, even to my eye cut, it appears out there, cut off at a distance. It doesn’t appear as in any way dependent upon my mind.

It’s as if I’m just a mirror. It’s just this appearance is just kind of coming here and overwhelming me. I come to know it. It’s like a photographic plate. That’s all I am.

That’s the way it appears, but that’s not in fact the way it exists. As we can see from our own experience, and this is this is what we have to identify with our own experience, this way of appearing. As we can see from our own experience, phenomena that we perceive in the external world appear to exist independent of our perceptions and conceptions. Here is perhaps the most fundamental reason for believing in an objective universe, independent of consciousness. That is simply how the world appears.

But it appears this way due to the process of reification. Reification, big word. It means to overestimate the existential status of objects. Overestimate. You know, we’re talking about the way things exist.

We overestimate their nature in terms of their ability to bring themselves into existence, their objective existence. We give them too much credit that we give them the we we grasp them as being more substantial than they actually are. Really solid and concrete out there, independent of our thoughts, independent of language, independent of our ideas, attitudes, independent of our culture, independent of of, you know, all these linguistic communities, social conventions, independent of all. It’s out there in its own nature, standing apart, isolated from everything around it. Everything.

Well, that’s the way it appeared. That’s that way of conceiving it is called reification. Conceiving it is called reification. So that’s a fantasy. The point is that it makes a difference, does it?

All of these schools are not simply philosophic schools. They are schools of religious training. That is to say, the Buddha was not interested in theology or philosophy as such. He was concerned with suffering and how to end suffering. And when he examined the source of suffering, he saw it was just this ignorance which misconceives the way things exist, which is the ultimate root of suffering.

So it’s simply not game. It has real practical implications for the way we experience our lives. In Buddhist mental training, great emphasis is placed apart from the outset on distinguishing between fantasy and valid cognition. Indeed, the tendency of the human mind is to assume the existence of things that are in fact nonentities is considered to lie at the root of the broad range of unnecessary conflicts and miseries. The most basic expression of this mental distortion is the reification of oneself as intrinsically existent personal identity.

In a way, there’s sense that in Buddhism that the ultimate outcome of living with fantasy is suffering, is dissatisfaction, frustration, disappointment in all its various forms. We have no choice but to live in accordance with the way things are. We know what the world is capable of of giving us. You know, to demand of the world to be other than the way it is is to live a dishonest life, is to live in a world of what I called epistemological fantasies. Epistemology Epistemology was remember that word?

The rules of world making, the ways that we make sense of our world. The world simply isn’t just given to us. We are born into a world of meaning, and we learn the rules of how to make sense of our life, how to make sense of these experiences, the sounds, the smells. Otherwise, it’s just chaos. You know?

We have to form our concepts about what things are, think about them, use language. Flowers are not just flowers in and of themselves. We have to make them into flowers. We learn how to make this stimulus, this white shape, into a flower. Flower.

It has meaning for us. It has an odor, it has smell. I like flowers. I give them to my girlfriend. It has associations, emotional connotations.

You know, we’re bringing forth, we’re learning how to what the world is. We’re in the process of world making. There are certain rules which we follow in this world making. The most basic expression of this so if we live in a distortion, then we’re in conflict with the way things are. The price of conflict is suffering.

The most basic expression of this mental distortion is the reification of oneself as intrinsically existent personal identity. Oneself is a permanent, solid, concrete I, who I am, the self identity that I hold, this isolated entity somewhere inside my body, who makes use of feelings and enjoys, who has a personality, loving, angry, whatever. That thing inside of ourselves which we identify as the real ‘I’. Having reified oneself, it is inevitable that one reifies others in the same way. There’s this thing in here who is I.

This big black line drawn around it, isolated, independent. Therefore there’s there is that independent other, absolute demarcation, this huge gulf. You know, it’s not that I and other don’t exist. We just overestimate the difference between ‘I’ and ‘other’. You know, it’s like high and low.

High doesn’t make any sense without low. Low doesn’t make any sense without high. Short doesn’t make any sense with ‘long’. Long doesn’t make any sense without ‘short’. Light doesn’t make any sense, it has no meaning without ‘dark’.

If there was no light, there’d be no dark. If you had no friends, you’d have no enemies. If there was nothing beautiful, there’d be nothing ugly. So it makes sense. But they only exist in relation.

It’s only a way of talking, isn’t it? This is light, this is short, this is long. It’s just relative. It’s only a way of talking, thinking about them. But we take them as being something much more than that, as being absolute themselves, unrelatedly different, independently different.

I am independently separate from you over there. There’s this huge gulf between me and you. And out of that gulf arises conflict. You become a resource resource for my welfare. I can use you, you know, have that sense about that.

And I can experience happiness, and you can experience suffering. I can live that kind of life. So there is this absolute demarcation between self and other. One naturally reifies oneself, one’s environment. Our environment becomes a resource for my personal pleasure, collection of goodies that I can use.

I don’t see myself as a part, as an integral part of an overall system. That this difference is only a difference between my environment, myself, you, this world, is only a way of talking. It’s only a way of speaking. It’s nothing more than that. It’s not in the least as solid as we normally think it is.

It’s not as substantial. It’s not absolute. It’s very delicate. It’s there. You know, we think about things.

Know, how do we think? We think linearly. You know, I am a man. And we take that the world, we flex our way of thinking. We chop up the ecology into bits, hunks.

There’s me, there’s this building, you know. We draw these thick black lines. We thingify everything. We draw thick black lines about every object. And they’re all separate one from another.

There’s this building, there’s this parking lot, there’s Adelaide, there’s you, there’s me, there’s this. Because that’s the way think about them. Think linearly. As I talked about that, I couldn’t express that as a Geshe-la, as one whole thing. I had to say, you know, building, parking lot, Adelaide, you, me.

I had to go through these one by one. And we think of them as being isolated entities one by one. We don’t see and we take that distinction as being absolute. We don’t see the interrelatedness of it all. We don’t have a vision of totality of it all.

We have to cut it up in order to think about it, and we take our thoughts to be that reality. The physicist David Bohm: Since our thoughts is pervaded with difference and distinction, it follows that such habits lead us to look upon these as real divisions so that the world is then seen and experienced as actually broken up into fragments. And due the very nature of our thinking process, the world to be broken up, isolated little chunks out there, independent of ourselves. And how I’m this alien in an alien land. I’m over here, there’s this world out there, and it’s me versus the world.

And how am I going to make use of the world in order to maximize my happiness, minimize my suffering? We possess, we have a sense, we have an intrinsic identity. And all of these appearances, the way that I’ve been talking these last five minutes, we accept that as being real, as true. This is the way things exist. We accept that.

And the consequences are all these various dysfunctional reactions, aversion, attachment, manipulation, objectification, devaluing. This never ending struggle that we’re involved in, to manipulate, to acquire, acquire, to maintain, to defend, to confirm, it never stops. And this entity over here, this hostile world out there, and we’re involved in this underlying anxiety. We create karma, those actions. And these actions are inevitably inappropriate.

They never quite hit the mark because because, you know, because they’re always mistaken with their final nature, way things are. You know, they’re always based upon a basic mistake of ignorance. Anything which you know, nature makes us we pay for delusion. We play we pay for mistakes in terms of suffering. So, you know, the residue of these actions, imprint on our mind, they condition our mind.

Our minds are continually being conditioned. This is what we mean this is all mean by karma. karma. The way that we think, the way we say, way we do, it conditions our mind. These conditionings predispose us to organize our reality along certain lines.

You know, we don’t we don’t I don’t organize my reality as a dog organizes their reality. I have predispositions to you know, we have similar karmas. We organize our karmas, our reality, along certain similar lines. Negative karma predisposes us to focus on and experience the world in dissatisfactory ways. We’re predisposed to experience suffering just by the very way that we are organizing our world, our reality, through the conditioning factors in our own mind.

And no matter how much we struggle to manipulate all these things, we’re never going to find what it is that we’re really looking for. We’re working from mistaken assumption as to how on the very basis of how we’re operating in this world is flawed. Positive karma predisposes us to organize our and pay attention to our world along positive lines. We we see beauty, we experience beauty, we we experience good fortune. But that’s just the way of thinking about it.

That’s just the way we see it. We’re predisposed to see it that way, pay attention to it in that way. Know, the same event can happen two people can see the same exact thing. One is repulsed, the other is attracted. One finds it pleasant, the other finds it dissatisfactory.

There’s some conditioning factors in our own mind. Anyway, so we can begin to sense that the the part our mind is playing in bringing about our lived experience, and how we can begin to undermine it and begin to not believe in these appearances to the same degree, and not be fooled by it as much, not buy into it. And so anyway, we’re going to work on this, aren’t we? All phenomena are imputed by language and conceptual thought. Any thoughts around that?

You think it’s true? Anyway, we’ll investigate it some more. So we can dedicate the positive energy that we’ve created. May beings everywhere plagued by suffering of body and mind attain an ocean of happiness and joy by virtue of my merits. May no living creature suffer, commit evil, or fall ill.

May no one be afraid or belittled with a mind weighed down, but may the blind see forms and the deaf hear sounds. May those whose bodies are worn with toil be restored on finding repose. May the naked find clothing, the hungry find food. May the thirsty find water and delicious drink. May the poor find wealth, those weak with sorrow find joy.

May the forlorn find hope, constant happiness and prosperity. May there be timely rains and bountiful harvests. May all medicines be effective and wholesome prayers bear fruit. May all who are sick and ill quickly be freed from their ailments. Whatever diseases there are in the world, may they never occur again.

May the frightened cease to be afraid and those bound be freed. May the powerless find power and may people think of benefiting each other. For as long as space remains, for as long as sentient beings remain, until then may I too remain to dispel the miseries of the world. Through these skillful actions may I quickly become an awakened spiritual master and lead each and every living being to that awakened realm. May the supreme jewel, the awakened heart that has not arisen arise and grow, and may that which has arisen never diminish, but increase more and more.

In the land encircled by snow mountains, you are the source of all happiness and well-being. Powerful Chenrezig, Tenzin Gyatso, please remain until the end of cyclic existence. Thank you. If you’d like to get a cup of tea, we’ll have a discussion. Otherwise, have a good night.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
buddha, a sang gye (Tib)
A fully awakened being, who has totally eliminated all obscurations veiling the mind and has fully developed all good qualities to perfection. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top