Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 — 2008-11-10

2 h 6 min · 12,823 words · 10 November 2008 · Buddha House Adelaide

Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 — 2008-11-10
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Opening with Rainer Maria Rilke’s image of dragons that “at the last moment are transformed into princesses” — perhaps everything that frightens us “wants our love” — Ven Jampa Gendun frames this 126-minute session around the choice between love and fear before leading a guided loving-kindness meditation. The doctrinal core walks through four Buddhist philosophical schools, tracing a progressive shift from a world that simply exists “out there” to one co-created by mind, language, and conceptuality. He explains the three natures — dependent, imaginary, and thoroughly established — and examines how phenomena come into existence through naming and thought, drawing on examples of a baby using a glass before knowing its name, a tree stripped of all verbal labels, and a hundred-dollar note whose value exists only by convention. Lively audience questions on children, language, and beauty run throughout.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 28 3PA 2008 11 10.mp3

UUID: 0657364b-b121-454b-bc59-7f84943543f9

Teacher: Ven Jampa Gendun

Collection: Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 (Ven Jampa Gendun)

Date: 2008-11-10

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 126.3 minutes

Words: ~12,817

How is everybody? I’ll read you I’ll read you one of my favorite quotes. You can tell me what it means. Okay? It’s by Rainer Maria Rilke, the Austrian poet.

I think we’re okay. How could we forget? Okay. Now we can’t forget. Okay.

How’s that? Is that better? Can you hear me? Yeah. Okay.

How could we forget those ancient myths that stand at the beginning of all races? The myths about dragons that at the last moment are transformed into princesses. Perhaps all the dragons in our lives are princesses who are only waiting to see us act just once with beauty and courage. Perhaps everything that frightens us is in its deepest essence something helpless that wants our love. All the dragons in our life are just our princesses just waiting for us to be for once and act with beauty and courage.

Everything that frightens us is in its deepest essence something helpless that wants our love. So that, you know, it’s coming back to that idea. You know, there’s only two emotions, love and fear, basically. Maybe everything that we fear is something that wants our love. So maybe love is perfect love casts out fear.

When I come out to to give my evening talk, there’s this quotation by the Dalai Lama next to the door there. And it says, believe the purpose of life is happiness. And the greatest degree of inner happiness comes about through love and compassion. So I guess we have a choice, don’t we? Either to stop either to continue to run away from what it is that we fear and thereby let it control our lives or to choose to love, to love ourselves and those parts of ourselves that we oftentimes would rather not see about ourselves, those dragons within ourselves.

And maybe through that process we can transform all of those aspects of ourselves that we find so within the shadow, the sordid parts of ourselves, parts of ourselves that we’d rather not identify. Maybe somehow they can all be transformed into princesses or princes. They just want our love. And we have to begin, I guess, by loving ourselves, the totality of ourselves, even those parts we don’t like so much. And if we can begin to love ourselves maybe we can truly begin to love others.

If we as Śāntideva mentions in his Bodhisattva’s way of life, if we’ve never dreamt of such an attitude even toward ourselves, how could we sincerely develop it for others? And if we’ve never really loved ourselves, had compassion for ourselves, extending that caring for ourselves, knowing the depths of our own pain, our own difficulties intimately, directly as we do. How could we ever develop such an attitude for others knowing their situations and their difficulties and so forth vicariously and directly at best. If we’re gentle with ourselves, if we’re kind with ourselves, we’ll be gentle and kind with others. Loving ourselves we can learn to love loving others we learn to love ourselves.

Maybe it’s all the separation maybe isn’t all that apparent or as absolute and as solid as it normally appears to us to be. Anyway somehow we have to learn how to love, don’t we? And kind of make that priority in our life. We have lots of priorities in our life, don’t we? Sometimes we lose track of what is most important in our life.

Sometimes the stock market going up and down becomes the most important thing. Well-being rises and falls with Dow Jones. A way of life, I don’t don’t know. Maybe it’s easy for me to say that I don’t have a family to take care of and so forth. Guess it’s easy for me to pay lip service to this notion.

But maybe somebody has to pay lip service to it once in a while to just keep reminding themselves. Above all else, whatever difficulties the planet may be in, the economic crisis, the wars, Iraq, Afghanistan, all we can do is start to love as best we can. Love ourselves and work out from there perhaps. And maybe that’s the best solution to it all. So we talk about going for refuge all the time, going for refuge to Buddhadharma and Sangha.

It can begin to sound a bit abstract and mechanical after a while and doesn’t have much feeling and meaning after a while. It’s easy. But you know, essentially I think maybe we take refuge in love and joy. There’s something very real, something very immediate. When we can, becoming mindful of that and choosing that, making that kind of choice.

I was talking in the Learn to Meditate class. You know, we talk about training mindfulness mindfulness of the breath. And, you know, there’s nothing particularly wonderful or mystical or exotic or esoteric about the breath. It’s pretty mundane. But it’s a way of training and making conscious choices, isn’t it?

Normally we’re on automatic pilot of one sort or another. We make our choices unconsciously out of habit. So if we can in developing the mindfulness practice we become aware that our mind is wandered and distracted. We’re more or less indulging in some unconscious pattern of thinking. And at that moment you have a choice.

Guess it seems as if almost hardly worth talking about kind of choice, whether to continue to indulge the distraction, the wandering, that pattern of thought, the story that we’re caught up in or whatever it might be, or to take control, to become the author of your life and make a choice simply to bring your mind back to the breath. Guess it’s a bit abstract to think of that as being significant. In a sense perhaps we have very how much choice do we have in our life? We look at the measure of control we have about our life, I think we’ll see that there isn’t all that much control. That the area of flexibility, area in which we can begin to make choices is pretty limited.

It shrinks expands on different occasions from time to time according to circumstance. So what does it mean to make a little choice bringing your your mind back to the breath? It means that at least you’re taking some kind of conscious control. And we can generalize that ability to take conscious control of making conscious choices to other areas of our life. You know, we can you know, I guess what is it?

We’re all after meaning in our life. What is it? Victor Frankl. He said human beings can undergo any what if they have a why. And he went through holocaust in concentration camps.

And people about him, many of them died. They just gave up. They weren’t actually killed, executed. They just gave up. They died out of giving up on life.

But some giving up on life. But some didn’t give up. Some of them carried on. He found it was as if they needed to find a why to live, that is to say some kind of value. Even in the concentration camp they found some meaning in there for their life, some purpose and it carried them through.

And I guess life is very much about getting in contact with what it is that each of us value. You know what is a good life for us? What is a successful life? What brings purpose and fulfillment, makes me feel good about myself in this experience? Bringing that to some degree as best we can to conscious awareness.

And then as mindful as we can, in the course of these little petty experiences which constitute most of our life, making that little choice of living out those values. When you see yourself going off into some being lost in some story, some indulgence, some sloth of the mind or of temperament or so forth. You know, when you’re lost in these compulsive patterns, these stories that keep our minds keep churning out, becoming aware and making a choice in that very moment to come back to what it is that you value. What is it that’s going to run your life, fear or love? I guess it’s trying to see how that fits into our everyday life and the little insignificant events which constitute our life.

Does love or whatever my value is, how is it interpreted in this present circumstance, this present situation? How is it expressed? Maybe Maybe it’s difficult to find that. So I think if we do that then our life becomes going for refuge. We don’t have to sort of make a big deal out of or say kind of words on paper.

Are we we are going for our life as a going for the future and what has meaning and purpose to ourselves. You know, I try to talk about these things, you know, we like, you know, in the sense that I call that which is most meaningful, I call that a Buddha. You know, we just give it some name. We could call it Christ or love or whatever, wisdom, power, strength, all those values and ways of being which seem to be make make life worthwhile when we embody them to some degree or other and going for refuge to that. So maybe this all requires some kind of training just in this practice of mindfulness.

That requires some kind of training. So we call this training the Dharma. But basically the Dharma is about changing our mind, training to bring about the best of ourselves. And hopefully we can rely upon others in this process, the Sangha. I think we’re much more influenced than we are aware or imagine about the social context in which we carry out our lives and our search for happiness.

We’re constantly being influenced for better or worse by those around us. We can’t escape that. We’re social beings. Maybe we can create a situation where those about us can help us to become the best person that we can become, to help us to develop that best story that we want to tell ourselves about ourselves. The Sangha, our spiritual community.

Hopefully, hopefully, hopefully, you know. It’d be nice to be able to create that kind of situation for ourselves, wouldn’t you? So we’re not quite alone in this endeavor as we normally see ourselves, that there’s some kind of, you know, manifest support or even just simply our good wishes of those around reminding ourselves of that. I could try to speak up. It often doesn’t work very well.

Okay. That’s too hot, yes. It’s just that my ears are not what they’re saying. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Somebody mentioned that the last class actually.

And to meditate. They said they couldn’t hear me, which sometimes is a good thing, but maybe. Chris, maybe we can should we turn the air conditioning off for a little while? Thank you. So if you’d like to recite along, kind of make this formalize this process.

I go for refuge until I am awakened to the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. Through my practice generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am awakened awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha.

Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. May all sentient beings have happiness and the causes of happiness. May all sentient beings be free from suffering and the causes of suffering. May all sentient beings be inseparable from the joy that is without sorrow. May all sentient beings abide in equanimity, free from attachment for some and aversion toward others.

Thus did I hear at one time the Bhagavan was dwelling on Vulture’s Peak, Vultures Mountain in Rajagriha together with a great community of monks and a great community of Bodhisattvas. At that time the Bhagavan was absorbed in the concentration on the categories of phenomena called profound perception. Also at that time, the bodhisattva, Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara, looked upon the very practice of the profound perfection of wisdom and beheld those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature. Then through the power of the Buddha, the Venerable Śāriputra said this to the Bodhisattva, mahasattva, How should any son of the lineage train and wishes to practice the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom? He said that in the Bodhisattva, Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara, said this to the Venerable Śāriputra, any son of the lineage or daughter of the lineage who wishes to practice the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom should look like this, correctly and repeatedly beholding those five aggregates also as an empty of inherent nature.

Form is empty, emptiness is form, emptiness is not other than form, form is also not other than emptiness. In the same way, feeling discrimination, compositional factors, consciousness are empty. Śāriputra, likewise, all phenomena are emptiness, without characteristics, unproduced, unceased, stainless, not with without stain, not deficient, not fulfilled. Śāriputra, therefore in emptiness there is no form, feeling, no discrimination, no compositional factors, no consciousness, no eye, no ear, no nose, no tongue, no body, no mind, no visual form, no sound, no odor, no taste, no object of touch, and no phenomenon. There is no visual form, no eye element, and so on, up to and including no mind element and no mental consciousness element.

There is no ignorance, no extinction of ignorance, and so on, up to and including no aging and death, and no extinction of aging and death. Similarly, there is no suffering, origination, cessation and path. There is no exalted wisdom, no attainment and also no non attainment. Śāriputra, therefore, because there is no attainment, bodhisattvas rely on and dwell in the perfection of wisdom, the mind without obscuration and without fear. Having completely passed beyond error, they reach the endpoint of nirvana.

All the Buddhas who dwell in the three times also manifestly completely awakened to unsurpassable, perfect, complete enlightenment in reliance on the perfection of wisdom. Therefore, the mantra perfection of wisdom, the mantra of great knowledge, the unsurpassed mantra, the mantra equal to the unequaled, the mantra that thoroughly pacifies all suffering should be known as the truth since it is not false. The mantra of the perfection of wisdom is declared, Tayatha Gate Gate Pāragate Pārasamgate Bodhi Svāhā. Shariputa, the Bodhisattva, Mahāsattva, should train in the profound perfection of wisdom like that. Then the Bhagavan arose from that concentration and commended the bodhisattva, Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara, saying, Well said, well said, son of the lineage.

It is like that. It is like that. One should practice the profound perfection of wisdom just as you have indicated. Even the Tathagatas rejoice. The Bhagavan, having thus spoken, the Venerable Śāriputra, the Bodhisattva, Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara, those surrounding in their entirety along with the worlds of gods, humans, the asuras, and Gandharvas were overjoyed and highly praised as spoken by the Bhagavan.

There’s no taste, no object of touch, no ear, no nose, no tongue, no body, no mind. Strange, isn’t it? So if you like to stretch, we’ll we’ll meditate. So I thought we’d meditate on loving kindness. So taking a comfortable, firm posture.

It’s a purposive, dignified. Dignified, but comfortable. First, getting in touch with the body and bringing your awareness to the crown of your head, your scalp, feeling the wrinkles in your brow, smoothing out. The pressure in and around your eyes diminishing. Muscles of the face softening, relaxing.

Jaws relaxed. Bringing awareness to the back of your neck and perhaps gently turning your head to each side a few times, gently stretching, loosening the muscles of the back of the neck. Relaxing the muscles of the throat. Bringing awareness to your upper back and shoulders. Perhaps rotating your shoulders a few times.

Lifting them up towards your ears and just allowing them to drop comfortably to the sides, relaxed and at ease, feeling some kind of burden perhaps moving down through your body into the ground. Bringing awareness all the way down to your hands. Your hands are soft and loose. Relaxing your lower arms. Your upper arms.

Chest is at ease. Relaxing throughout the heart area. The lungs. The central region of your back. Stomach.

Releasing the tension that we hold in our stomach muscles, just allowing your belly to go soft and throughout the abdominal cavity. Keeping your back straight, your trunk erect, relax your lower back muscles. Releasing the tightness, the tension in the lower back. And the buttocks. Throughout throughout the upper legs.

Lower legs. Finally your feet. Soft, loose. Bringing your awareness to your body in general, just roughly scanning through the body, noticing any tightnesses, any tensions which remain in the body especially in the neck shoulders upper back lower back any areas of discomfort that you might find. And breathing into the tightness, feeling breathing out from the tightness, feeling the tightness loosen.

Breathing into the tension wherever it might be, breathing out from that area of tension, feeling the tension diminish, breathing into the tightness and the tension, breathing out. If there’s an area of discomfort, don’t try to avoid it. Somehow struggle against it. Just like a mother and her child child is hurt. Cradle that area of discomfort with your breath, breathing into that area of discomfort, surrounding it with a caring acceptance.

Breathing out from the discomfort, opening, accepting, softening. Caring for that discomfort with your breath, a breath of kindness. Body becoming comfortable, at ease. A feeling of physical well-being pervading the entirety of your body. Just imagine as if that were the case.

It feels good to be in your body. Nowhere to go, nothing to do, no one to please. Just give yourself a break just for a few moments. Just be just be your body. Just stay with your body.

Just gently come back to your body. And then bring your mind to the breath. Just easy gentle in and out flow of the natural breath wherever the sensation is most clear and obvious to yourself. Bring your mind back to the breath. So now we’re going to meditate on loving kindness, and we’ll begin with ourselves.

Whatever you may have done in the past, the various mistakes that you feel you’ve created, you can simply develop a healthy sense of regret and you can begin again. And whatever you want to become in the future, the person that you want to become, you can become that. Just for this present moment, we want to set aside the past and the future, and simply become friends with ourselves just as we are now. Accept ourselves in our entirety. Be kind to ourselves and wish ourselves well.

So just generate some kind, caring feelings directed toward yourself. May I be happy. May all the things I wish for be true. May I not suffer. May I succeed in what I try?

Just be generous with yourself. Wish yourself all the good things of life. Wish yourself happiness. Wish yourself well. It’s the way we learn to love ourselves.

I’m thinking of someone that you care about, that you have a close, loving relationship with. Imagine that person there in front of you. And if you can’t see them, it’s not so important. Just imagine that the feelings are being directed toward this individual, this person. And remember some of the good times that you shared together, the many kindnesses that this person has shown you over the course of your relationship.

How much you really like them, how much you care for them, how much you love them. And begin to radiate out, direct out toward this person the loving, kind, caring thoughts which arise in this way. Wishing them all the good things of life. Wishing them happiness. Wish them well.

Now think of somebody who you have no particular relationship with, neither close nor distant, just a stranger, perhaps someone you see from time to time at work or on the street. You don’t know their their story. But one thing you do know about them is that they want to be happy, and they don’t want to suffer. Just like yourself. That much you do know about them, whoever they are.

So simply out of the goodness of your heart, you’re a good person. And given the right circumstances, you would wish everybody well. Simply as a basic feeling of going out to another human being. Wish them happiness. Wish them well just as you do yourself.

Just be generous with your basic goodness. Generous with your basic goodness. Now think of someone that you have some problems with, somebody you don’t like. Imagine that person there in front of you. And acknowledge the fact that they want to be happy and they don’t want to suffer just like yourself.

And perhaps their method of finding your happiness, solving their own problems, has come in conflict with your methods of finding your own happiness and solving your own problems. It’s just a conflict of self interest. And just as you have to begin to forgive yourself for the mistakes that you’ve made in the past, maybe it’s time to begin to forgive this person. So just for this present moment, set aside your hurt or your grudge, your anger, and try your best to see, you know, go beneath the present dynamics of your situation. Go beneath that superficial appearance and see somebody who is trying the best they can to find some happiness out of her life.

Oftentimes, making lots of mistakes along the way. And wish them well, just for this present moment, just for now. Set aside your hurt, your grudge, your anger. If you ever hope to be free, you’re going to have to learn how to forgive. We have to be endlessly forgiving.

And it begins with this person. Forgive them. Just let go. Open your heart for a moment and wish them well. And all the people in this room, you’re trying to take responsibility for their lives, for their happiness and their suffering, exploring other possibilities, trying to grow, to change for the better, and radiate out a wish of happiness and well-being, that they find whatever it is they’re looking for to everyone in the room.

It won’t cost you anything. And extending this wish out to all the Burnside people on the streets and cars walking along shops in their homes preparing dinner watching television. Television. Radiated a wish of happiness and well-being to everyone in Burnside. Extending this wish out to all of Adelaide, people cars and buses and trains and office buildings, department stores, factories, and their homes.

Moving out into the suburbs, out into the the towns surrounding, to all of South Australia. However ever you imagine it, just feel that. To Melbourne, Hobart, Sydney, Brisbane, Cairns, Alice Springs, Perth, Darwin, the entire country. Eastward to New Zealand, northward to East Timor, Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore. Southeast Asia, and all of Asia in Europe Africa South America North America.

It feels as if you’re taking the entire world into your heart. All the people, black, white, red, yellow, all the animals, all the insects, everything that lives on the earth is touched by your wish. That they be happy, that they not suffer. All those living beings, making all those making connection and radiating out in all the directions of space. Further and further without any limits or feelings of limitation.

And you’re finally without any boundaries, without any center, pervading all of infinite space. You wish we all be happy. May there be only happiness. May there be peace. Just come back to that vast infinite open space.

And I wish you peace. Just vast open space. Pervaded with the wish of peace. And then bring your mind back to the breath. And get in touch with your body, perhaps the the pressure of your buttocks on the cushion on the chair.

Just some feeling sensation within the body. Become aware of the sounds about you. And in a slow and easy manner, become aware of your surrounding. Please stand up and stretch if you like. Maybe we should do yoga.

We the yoga of the brain, I guess. The yoga of the mind. So we’re looking at the awakened mind. We have to develop in wisdom, it’s quite necessary, in order to develop effective compassion. Which is the consummation, which is the fruition of the path.

So we’re looking at the development of the awakened mind, understanding the deeper nature of reality, going beneath the superficial appearances that we usually work with, we react to both in positive and negative ways, but trying to see things in a deeper fashion. Ultimately, in order to overcome lots of our basic misconception with regard to the way things exist and overcome ignorance. And we’re working through that in four stages. It’s a long journey, journey, isn’t it? We began at the hearer stage.

Well, we began as what we call naive realists. Everything just accept appearances, everything is taken on face value. We just take the world for granted. And we try to make the best of a difficult situation. We work out, we work from there.

Then at the hearer stage we begin to call into question some of these various appearances about us. We call into question in terms of the I, the Self, where there is the appearance of a unitary or a partless, unchanging, independent self. We call that into question. And when we examine it, we see that it’s a mere appearance. There’s nothing which corresponds to it in reality.

On the basis of identifying with that misconception, that misconceived self, we go on to develop lots of unskillful ways of relating with the world about us. There’s me versus the world. There’s an isolated self over here, and there’s the world over there in which I’m going to have to deal with in order to alleviate the difficulties of the Self, to bring it happiness. And so there’s automatically some kind of tension brought into the relationship, even in the best situations. We go on to develop the very subjective emotions of attachment and hostility and so forth, the unskillful ways of relating, which deepen our problems, which cause us even more suffering.

When we examine, investigate that unitary, unchanging, independent self, we find there’s nothing within our lived experience which we can identify as being such a type of self. It’s just it’s all has parts, it’s all changing, it’s all dependent arising. We undermine that belief in such a type of self. We go beyond a particular level of ignorance. But at the hearer stage we do accept the world about us.

The mind is simply a passive observer reflecting a pre existing reality out there. At the mind only stage, we begin to question those appearances out there. And we discover that these appearances of external objects are are false. Just as we understood that not in the hearer stage that things can appear but not necessarily be true. That in fact the appearance of an changing independent self is false.

Likewise, at the mind only stage we come to understand that the appearance of external phenomena is a falsity. That all of the that the perceiving subject and the perceived object, the eye consciousness which sees the glass and the glass itself, they both arise from the same substance. The karmic seeds within the mind on the consciousness called the mind basis of all. Therefore, we begin to relate with those objects in a completely different way. We no longer, you know, we begin to see the reality of how they are in fact not something outside of ourselves.

So where is the striving? Where is the problem? Where is the how can we separate from those objects which we see as hostile to ourselves? It could be. It’s all built upon a notion of some kind of separateness between subject and object.

But in fact, they’re both arising from the karmic seeds and the mind bases of all within inside of ourselves. Okay, now we’re coming to the middle way. So we’re going through four stages. Here, mind only way, and now we’ve come to the middle way. So the term middle way, you know, it’s used in a very general sense that the Buddha, in his own experience, he found that after he left his palace search of his answer to the question, Is life a bitch and then you die?

Is that all there is? Is there an end to this problem of suffering? Or is it we just have to get on with it and live our life the best we can in a dissatisfactory situation? Or is there a basic solution to dissatisfaction? That was his question.

And he went on to practice aesthetics for a number of years. And he found that that didn’t work. So he found that both indulgence, indulgence in the senses, in whatever desires that come up, trying to pursue those, nor trying to suppress his desires, trying to mortify the body and so forth, practicing asceticism. Neither of those two paths brought about the solution to the question he was looking for, the answer he was looking for. So he developed what he called the middle path between indulgence and suppression, something like that.

So that’s the general meaning of middle way. But here we’re using it in a different sense, in a more philosophic sense. Here the term middle way denotes a middle way position or a centrist position between two extremes: permanence on the one hand and annihilation on the other. Permanence, there’s two extremes. There’s permanence on one hand and annihilation on the other.

So another way we can another term we can use is true existence and non existence. True existence and non existence. The middle way is concerned with finding a a path, which is divorce of those two extremes. You know, things exist, but they do not truly exist. So appearance of things, the appearance of that glass refutes their non existence.

The glass exists. I can’t deny its existence. It appears there. The emptiness of that glass refutes its true existence. The emptiness of that glass refutes its true existence.

Though it appears, though it exists, it’s not true to exist. Those are so we’re trying to find some way between denying the existence at all, on the one hand, and the other extreme, falling to the extreme of, well, if they exist, they must truly exist. They must and what this word truly exists is we’re going to have to develop a feeling of a sentient beings for that over the course explanation, about this, what true existence means. Is in coming to an understanding of the meaning of true existence that we’ll come to understand the distinction between the two middle way schools. There’s a subdivision of the middle way into the autonomy middle way school and the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school.

And they have a different interpretation of what true existence means. It’s in this coming to this understanding that we’ll be able to understand the final thought of the Buddha, which is contained within the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school. So we’re talking about a fantasized way of existing. True existence. We call this true existence.

Okay? The the hearer school assert that all phenomena truly exist. For them, existence is synonymous with true existence. Out of all the objects that appear to us, they only comment the question the appearance of this unitary, unchanging, self. That object does not truly exist.

Why? Because it doesn’t exist at all. At the mind only school, they assert that some phenomena truly exist and some phenomena do not truly exist. Okay? So they’re beginning to examine these appearances with a little more precision than we did at the hearer school.

Dependent we we talked about the three natures. Remember the three natures? Good nature, bad nature, and kind of mid I don’t know what’s that? I’m joking. The three three natures.

What are the three natures? Nature. Dependent nature, thoroughly established nature, imaginary nature. So there are all these various appearances, all these various objects. And so they are beginning to analyze them with more precision and they distinguish three natures.

Dependent natures and thoroughly established natures truly exist. They’re real. They’re fabrications of the mind. Dependent natures are the glass, arising in dependence upon causes and conditions. Before I start to think about it, before I start to conceptualize, I develop an idea, before I project my idea of glass upon that object, the glass in and of itself.

That’s called the dependent nature. What happens when begin to think about the glass? I begin to tell all kinds of stories, make up, I project all kinds associations and ideas around the nature of the glass. One of them is the most basic, at least from the point of view of the mind only scope, is that the glass exists external to the mind. That’s a story, that’s a hallucination I’m making up about the glass.

All those fabrications, these inventions of the mind itself, these are called imaginary natures. Whatever is fabricated, there are existent or imaginary natures, and there are nonexistent imaginary natures. Nonexistent imaginary natures like external objects. And it’s just like this where we see a snake when it factors only a rope. That’s imaginary nature which doesn’t exist at all.

But there are imaginary natures, fabrications of the mind which do exist, like, for example, space. Space is just we arrive at it through inference. We infer there is space there. Why? Because I can sense my arm moving, therefore there must be space.

If there wasn’t space there, I wouldn’t be able to move my arm. Space is the absence of obstructed contact. It allows for movement, so I can infer there’s space there. But it’s simply a construction of the mind, an idea of my mind. The thoroughly established is emptiness.

That means object’s, the dependent nature, this glass, is empty of my ideals about it. You know, all the associations and projections that I have about it. It’s empty of being, for example, the hallucination that it’s external to my mind. So that lack or that absence of this imaginary nature, what I’m projecting onto the glass, is the thoroughly established nature. It’s an emptiness.

The Middle Way School, so within the mind only school, some things truly exist, some things do not. Okay? Imaginary natures do not truly exist. Dependent nature and thoroughly established nature truly exist. Why?

Because they are not fabrications of the mind. Now in the middle school, both in Autonomy Middle School and the Consequence Middle School, am I I am sometimes worried. Going into too much detail, what do you think? Worry. We don’t know until we finish.

Then it’s too late. Okay. I mean, can’t go into very much detail. Don’t understand these things. So maybe just cause more confusion.

Anyway, we’ll work together on this. It’s especially interesting when we come to the final school. I think it’s interesting and useful. But we’re of loosening up our mind, getting familiar with some of these ideas and terms and so forth. The Mind Only school says, Some things truly exist.

The glass truly exists. It’s emptiness of the glass truly exists. My ideals which I project upon it don’t really exist. They’re just fabrications in my mind. At the Middle Way School, both the autonomy of Middle East and the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school, they assert that no phenomena truly exist.

So this is getting a bit strange, I think. For the middle way school, they hold that that to assert true existence is to assert that things exist independent of the mind. Yeah. That that the things exist in their own right. The mind is in no way involved in their coming into existence.

So we’re starting to move to an unquestioned acceptance about the world about us. We’re beginning to shift, we call into question that world. We’re beginning to have a sense that the mind is playing some part. The movement through these four schools is a shift toward the mind itself in bringing about our lived experience, away from, as it were, us being passive observers where the where the this world this real self existent world out there simply overwhelms my mind, impinges on my mind, and I’m forced to undergo various experiences and have these various appearances. World I’m like an isolated isolated entity and the world is kind of bringing itself down upon me.

There’s a shift from, in terms of the creator of our experience, toward the mind, until we eventually come to the consequential mental state of school and we will find that the mind is the creator of all things. And like John Milton said, the mind is in its place, in its way, can make a heaven of hell, a hell of heaven. The mind is the determinant of all things. So this shift is away from it’s an empowering in a way, isn’t it? Are we, as it were, are no longer victims of a world in which we play no part.

We we we in fact, we are the agents of our experience. We are, for better or worse, responsible for our entirety of our experience, ultimately. So there’s a tremendous empowering in that, but also comes along with it, empowering comes a responsibility for making use of that empower for for better, both for ourselves and others. So there’s a shift away from the world that the shift toward the subject of the mind. Things truly So we’re working with Okay, let’s look at the mind in order to go.

Okay, go back for a moment. Objects such as glasses, tables, books, bells. Prior to our thinking about them, before we start to tell stories, imagining, you know, this is good, this is bad, this is dirty, this is clean, this is all the various associations and mental and whatnot we have about these things, our ideals about them, what we were taught about them before we start all this kind of, you know, embellishing of what’s there, the thing in and of itself, the glass in and of itself, the table in and of itself. These are real. There’s a real glass there, a real table there.

Once we conceive, once we name it glass, the naming and we conceive it of its glass, we our idea about it, then we’re telling a story about we’re no longer seeing the glass in and of itself. We’re seeing what comes down to a mere contrivance of the mind, a fabrication of imagination. That is the imaginary nature, our ideas about the glass. And more than that, we take our ideas about something to be the something itself. More than that, we’re relating with our ideas about objects.

This is especially true in our relationships with other people, but it’s true in in perhaps a less dramatic sense about everything. We relate with our ideas order to via our idea in relating to the object itself. So there’s always this mistaken element in the way that we’re relating. We’re relating to some degree a figment of our imagination, better to say, the imaginary nature. That imagination doesn’t truly exist, it’s not real.

What we so we’re trying to get a sense of what we mean by truly exist, at these different levels. For the only school, truly exist means it’s not real. It’s just something you make into your mind, a story that you’re telling yourself about that object, about that person, and so forth. This glass truly exists. It does not depend upon my eye consciousness seeing the glass for its existence.

That glass doesn’t depend upon mine. In fact, it arises simultaneously with the eye consciousness observing the glass. The eye consciousness perceiving the glass and the glass, they arise simultaneously from the same karmic seed. That’s why they’re called the same substance. That’s why it’s said that the glass does not exist external to the perceiving consciousness.

They are both just like a flower. Both the subject and object arise from the same seed. These seeds are on the mind bases of all, a type of neutral consciousness. This is what goes on to take rebirth, this neutral consciousness which is a repository for all these karmic seeds. When these become activated, a subject and object arises, and then we mistakenly relate with those objects as if they were external.

We develop aversion and attraction. We want to either push them away or bring them to ourselves, but they’ve never been apart from ourselves. So the absence of the imaginary, our ideas about them in in in the dependent, the absence of my ideas about the glass, for example, that that glass exists exists from the mind. In the glass, the dependent is the thoroughly established. The thoroughly established is also not a fabrication of mind.

It also truly exists. The perceiving consciousness plays part in this process. Let’s look at these three natures in relation to a particular situation. Two human organisms, two people, I don’t know why it’s so long ago. Two people sit in the field.

In the distance is a tree. One says to the other, I see a tree. The situation itself is a product cause and effect. The two humans arrive in the field as a result of the intercourse of their parents and their whole life history up to that moment. Likewise, the tree is there as a result of the entire web of prior immediate causes.

The ability of the organism to perceive and to use language is also a product of cause and effect. All of this is relative dependent nature. But when one person says to the other, Tree, he is using a symbol, which applies not just to that particular tree in front of him, but to all trees. And he is using this symbol to convey a meaning to someone else. Then the word tree begins to be taken as the real thing.

We lose touch with the connection of the actual tree to its environment. Its roots go deep into the earth and draw sustenance from it. A branch is half dead and decaying where it touches the earth, blending imperceptibly with the earth. The leaves exchange gases with the atmosphere and receive sunlight from it. A seed which a moment ago was a part of the tree is now lying on the ground and already initiating the process by which it will become a seedling.

We begin to regard the tree as separate from everything just as the word tree is separate and distinct from all other words. Now why do we see everything as cut up, as entities, we divorce one from other because that’s the way we see them, that’s the way we think about them. We use a linearity of our thought, one word after another, and we see reality in one object after another. We don’t see the interdependence, the interconnect of it all. We see them as separate entities because that’s the way we think about them.

We begin to associate with the tree all kinds of conscious or unconscious qualities coming not from our perception of the actual tree, but from our web of connotations of the word tree. Finally the word I begins to take a real existence. So we can think in a way Language is tremendously powerful. It’s tremendous tool, using symbols, models. We can think about things divorced from the actual objects themselves.

You know, when you think, ‘Wow, I’m hungry, need food.’ Food has meaning, but nothing particularly appears to at that moment. A tofu burger or stir fry veg. It’s just food. You can think, ‘Wow, I need some food in your mouth. I’d like to have some good food.’ But that food is just completely divorced from any actual type of food.

And we can think about people, and we do. We think about enemy as divorce. You know, it’s like the person who says, Oh, I love humanity. I just can’t stand people. Know, for them humanity is an abstract quality which they are relating with in a very romantic sense, but it has nothing to do with real flesh and blood people, that which it’s actually being applied to.

And we begin to, you know, think of the world in terms of our ideas about the world. This is problematic. The tree standing in the field, free of all names and conceptual overlays, is the dependent nature. That is the tree in and of itself. We begin to think about it.

The tree which possesses inherent qualities associated with the tree, and we begin to separate it from its environment. We begin to cut up the ecology. We can begin to think about tree separate from the context in which it exists. We can think about human beings separate from the context in which they exist. And we do this all the time.

Dependent natures such as books and cars and people exist in their own right, from their own side, objectively, as does their thoroughly established nature, the emptiness of our imaginary, our imaginative stories that we’re telling about them. In the mind only school, dependent nature and thoroughly established natures natures truly exist. Imaginary natures do not truly exist. They’re just fabrications of the mind. Okay?

Now we’re coming to the Okay. We’re getting a sense of what we mean by true existence, you know, and how much things do and do not depend upon mind as we move through these schools. And we come to the Middle Way School. The main assertion of the Middle Way School is that nothing whatsoever truly exists. Nothing has independent reality of its own.

All phenomena, without exception, depend for their existence upon the perceiving consciousness. The conceptualizing conceptualizing and labeling process, they depend upon language, on conceptuality, on thought. There is no independent world out there independent of our minds. You know, at hearer school, the world was out there and we were passive observers like a mirror. Here we’re beginning to get a sense that the universe is a participatory universe.

We are participating in bringing forth the known world, our particular world version, our reality. What part are we playing in it? So without us there would be no world. So the central assertion of the Middle Way School is that all phenomena are brought into existence through the conceptuality, the process of conceiving them. Conceiving them.

They do not exist independently, independent of this process. They all are imputed, and we’re going to carry this to its extreme I shouldn’t say use the word extreme to its logical conclusion when we come to the consequence of Middle Way school. You this doesn’t mean, this does not mean that if you think fire is not hot, fire won’t burn you, that if you think hard enough and you stick your hand in the fire, it won’t burn you. It will. Or if we all got together and tried to imagine there were pink elephants in this room, that just because we thought there were pink elephants in this room, somehow there would actually be pink elephants in this room.

That’s not the case at all. There are definite criteria which determine what in fact exists, what is real and not. But we have to come to understand what are the criteria for existence. It’s not as we usually define, as we might think it might be, and how it is that come to determine whether things exist or not. So it’s here that we begin to distinguish between these two schools: the Autonomy Middle Way School and the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school.

Both schools assert that all phenomena do not truly exist, that they do not independently exist, since their existence relies upon being designated or being thought of. But he differed to the extent to which phenomena rely upon this labeling process, conceptuality. They both agree that thinking plays a part in bringing our lived experience into existence, that this glass is dependent upon language and conceptual. They both agree. But to the extent that it plays, that the glass relies upon that process, have a difference.

So we’re going to begin with a slight difference and then we’re going to go to the radical position of the Consequence Middle Way school. So we’re working up these four stages, aren’t we? Hearer stage, Mind Only stage, we’re on the third stage. We call this the Autonomy Middle Way. This is Svatāntrika Madhyamaka.

Denying that phenomena truly exist. They do assert that phenomena, and this is going to sound just like a bunch of words, and we’ll do the best we can, I guess? Though phenomena do not truly exist, they do naturally exist. They do inherently exist. They don’t truly exist, but they inherently exist.

So we’re to have to we’re beginning get very subtle in our precision in how we’re looking at phenomena. We’re beginning to make some kind of subtle distinction. And I hope that if I don’t confuse you too much, we can carry this off a little bit as far as my limited understanding will go. Phenomena have a self defining characteristic. I don’t define what they are.

This is what we mean by these terms: inherent existence, intrinsic existence, self defining existence. They all mean the same thing. I don’t define what they are. From their own side, there’s something coming from the side of the object and something coming from the side of subject. Those two together bring the phenomena into existence.

That’s the point we’re trying to We’re beginning to shift, aren’t we? We’re beginning to say, oh, the mind does play a part in this, but we’re still like hanging onto a log. We’re kind of floating out into the river of reality, but we’re holding on to the less vestiges of something. And that something that we’re holding on to so we don’t sink, we might drown. Is, in fact, something coming from the side of the object.

But also, it requires something from the side of the subject. There’s a combination of those two which brings from an object into existence. What is it that’s coming from the side of the object? We call it self defining, its intrinsic existence. It means existence from its own side, inherent existence.

For example, it’s due to hot and burning. It’s that which is hot and burning appearing to a non defective awareness. Hot and burning appears to the mind. in dependence upon that we think fire. Okay?

So there was something, there was an inherent characteristic which appeared to my mind. That stimulated my thought fire. in dependence upon something coming from the of the object, that inherent characteristic, and something coming from the side of the subject, the name and the concept which applies to that name, fire came into existence. That fire came into existence when it depended on something coming from the side of the object, hot and burning, and something coming from the side of the subject, the name, and the thought which applies those names. Those two together brought the fire into existence.

So here, there’s something coming both from the side. So this is what we mean by self defining existence, inherent existence. It doesn’t truly exist. To truly exist, it’s completely independent of mind. Okay?

We can’t say it truly exists because it depends upon mind. But, though it doesn’t truly exist, it inherently exists. Why? Because something the object that which defines what it is, it adheres in the object itself. It is intrinsic into the nature.

It naturally exists in the object. I’m supplying from my side, from the mind side, the name and the thought which uses that name. Is that a little bit when were working on this, aren’t you? Jampa, is it a child who sees a glass for the first time? And, of course, the mind then can’t tell the child glass or anything, but they learn glass, beaker, goblet, a whole cup.

Mhmm. And so then the mind is embedded? Is that what you’re saying? That’s real, the glass is real, but for chancing for the first time, the mind can’t grasp it. Is it a glass in dependence upon language?

Well, I’ve got a one year old who doesn’t speak. And whenever she sees a vessel like that when it’s on the ground she’ll just pick it up and go like this. So she’s already associating that that’s something that I do this with she does have language. So I don’t know. Can you answer your question?

So she’s working with symbols? Action. She sees a form and she knows an action goes with that form. So that visual form stimulates some thought in the mind. And that thought is associated with don’t know what goes on in the mind of a child, but quenching thirst.

Maybe she uses a symbol a quenching thirst is associated with that form. The symbol of quenching thirst. Oh, there’s a quenching thirst. And she knows how to make use of it. But she’s using a symbol.

Otherwise, what would be the difference between this and If she doesn’t make a difference a piece of paper and a glass of water. Well, I mean, she doesn’t know what’s a glass and what’s a lid of ironing aid. If it’s a vessel that’s shaped like this she’ll still do that, whether it’s an old glass tea tub. It’s an interesting process, the way children it’s arrived at through a process of elimination. When you know, a child sees a dog walk by and the mother says, Dog.

Yeah. So there’s a sound, a piece of language. Then it’s not sure what the child is associating with that sound, but roughly speaking maybe it’s that hairy animal moving there. And then later on it sees a cat. And he says, Dog.

And Mother says, Not dog. Not dog. Cat, not dog. So it compares. What is the difference between the cat and dog?

And whatever it sees at that moment as being not, it eliminates that. It eliminates not cat and eliminates not dog. And it sees a cow, dog. So the idea may have been associated of a dog just simply with four legs and had a tail. Has to eliminate cow, has to eliminate horse, it has to eliminate whatever is left over after we eliminate it.

That’s your idea of a dog. So the process of coming to call a generic image, meaning generality, is arrived at through a process of eliminating. We remove, we eliminate everything that’s not. That which is left over is what we call dog. And that dog can stand for big dogs, small dogs, nice dogs, bad dogs, three legged dogs, dogs without tails, blind dogs.

That dog is a generic. After we eliminate everything that’s not. That which is left over, we use as an idea about when we say dog. I can say, I’d like to have a dog. Particular breed is coming to my mind.

No particular shape, color, size. But I know what I’m talking about when I say dog. It’s everything that’s not not dog is what I’m talking about. Sounds very strange. Yeah, anyway.

I just wanted to ask that you made when you were saying the glass is there. Yes. I can see the glass is there. But I was a bit confused with the other process, and I I thought that perhaps a child for the first time wouldn’t have the imprint because you talk about the imprint around the brain, they wouldn’t know what it was. It’s taught.

You teach them and they learn That’s right. It’s only their perception, isn’t it? And is that what you meant the reality and then the perception? Doctor. Something doesn’t have to exist for us to exist.

So it’s just that everything is dependent upon language and conceptuality. For glasses and things like it’s not so we can understand it in those terms, and it’s useful, and we’ll talk more about that. But what happens when we actually apply it to something which is perhaps more meaningful in terms of beauty and ugliness, where there’s really a subjective element, you you really get emotional about it. You know, we see things as if they exist inherently, from their own side, out there. That’s the way things appear to us.

And we see to that appearance. We grasp to that appearance as being true. We see beauty as being out there intrinsic to the nature of the object. There’s something about her, just the way she moves, just the way she tilts her head. You know, it’s like there’s some kind of or he or whatever there’s some kind of desirability or attractiveness, kind of exuding.

You know, I’m talking about, you know, people falling in love, for example. And they’re just captivated. There seems to be some kind of inner nature to the object, as if it could bring its complete happiness. If I could only make that mine and draw that near to me and be able to hold on to it, I could eternally partake of that blissful nature intrinsic into that object. It’s not dependent upon my attitude.

Whatever the circumstance, just by coming in contact, it would bring me bliss. That’s the thinking that’s going on at some level. And we develop attachment, craving. Why? Because we see the beauty as an as an not my mind isn’t playing a part in the creation of that beauty.

It’s the very nature of the object itself. We don’t see how we are being conditioned by, for example, you see, by our culture, by how we define beauty. Know, beauty in one culture can be repulsive in another culture. But within that context, lose that criteria. Defined.

We see it not as a product of culture and social values and advertising and all the things that go into but it’s in the very nature of the object itself. There’s something inherent in the nature of that object itself, which is desirable, which is attractive, which will bring me happiness. And that’s what beauty is about, something that brings us happiness, visually visually or emotionally. So we want we want it’s in there. We want if you could if you could begin to see the part that your mind is playing, or if you could be mindful of the fact that this is only within a particular cultural context that it’s being it’s not in itself beautiful, it’s only relatively beautiful, it’s not absolutely so, then degree of it’s not to say that beauty doesn’t exist, but the exaggeration as to the nature of that beauty in terms of it being totally within the object itself, that would be lessened.

There would be a lessening of the craving, grasping at the object. We would say, oh, it’s a beautiful object because our culture defines it as beautiful. I like it, it’s nice. But there wouldn’t be this over there wouldn’t be this exaggeration in terms of the nature of the object and and our reaction in terms of having to have it. Right?

We want there’s this isolated self with this thick, line drawn around it. This is the you know, they we call the skin encapsulated ego. There’s a big border. You know? There’s this border around there’s this world out there and there and me in here.

And, you know, there’s this permeable membrane, which I can kinda draw things in I can suck things inside to make them mine. Or I try to or if they’re invading my territory, I try to I develop a a hostility, I try to ensure push them so they’re not impinge upon my well-being. You know, we don’t see ourselves our sense of self and other self and other do exist, but the nature of that distinction is so much more exaggerated than it actually exists. And this is one of the basis of compassion. That we don’t we don’t we we think that we can have happiness for ourselves independent of others.

We’re accepting that there’s this isolated ego self inside this capsule, and that somehow this self can experience happiness independent of my environment, independent of the people about me, my context. There’s that kind of assumption that we’re operating on, and therefore I can misuse my environment, I can misuse others, I can use others, I can objectify others. It’s all based upon a misperception, based on ignorance. Anyway, we want to get me off the point in the talk about it. And your point also about your little baby.

You know, for glass, it just depends what we call beauty is learned. Beauty is dependent upon our thinking, you know, beauty is in the eyes of the beholder. That’s an old thought, but we don’t understand the high degree of truth to that statement. Beauty is in the eyes of the beholder. We see it.

We go blank. We go into a trance, and we see the beauty not in the eyes and beholden, but in the object itself. And therefore we develop attachment. We see ugliness in the object itself, and therefore we develop hostility. It’s dependent upon language, our thinking of itself.

We think with language, with symbols, with models. More than that, we mistake our model for the thing itself, and we relate with the model. I thought about the object. So we’re trying to trying educate ourselves, aren’t we? And to not buying into this sharp distinction between over here and out there, which, you know, as if it were absolute gap.

There’s a gulf between out there. And we’re trying to get a sense that the part that my mind is playing in the process of my experience and my perceived world. And therefore, will change the way that you relate with the things and people and situations about you. It will have a real world effect on how you behave, how you feel, on your emotions. I think so.

Anyway, I think so. So I’ll just kind of round this out. We’re to make this we’re going make a distinction between the highest most school, which is the Consequence Madhyamaka and this school. So they’re saying they both say nothing truly exists. That means that things do not exist independent of the mind.

But they do make a distinction what the degree of the role mind plays in bringing about our experience, the objects themselves. At the the Autonomy Middle Way School, the school we’re looking at right now, it’s saying that there is something coming from both the side of the object. There is water definition of water. What is the definition of water? That which is wet and fluid, I think.

Wet and fluid. It doesn’t mean much, but anyway. That appears, I think, with regard to that. So that’s coming from the side of it. That’s the nature of water.

That’s its inherent nature. Therefore, if I’m going to talk about things coherently, if I’m going to be able to think communicate about things, I have to talk about them in accordance with their actual nature. Its very nature is that it’s wet and fluid. So we call that water. So that water depends upon the term water and the thought that uses it.

But we can’t just call anything anything we want. There’s something coming from the side of the object which determines if we’re going to talk about it correctly and think about it and communicate about it in a coherent fashion. Are confined to certain ways of thinking and talking about it. There is something coming from both this So they would say that there is a Yeah. So it’s a coming together of two factors.

Something from the side of the object, something from the side of the subject. It’s dependent upon language, it’s dependent upon thinking itself. But there’s also something from the side of the object. We come to as opposed to when we come to the the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school, and this is the final thought of the Buddha, the deepest nature of reality, nothing is coming from the side of the object. But that doesn’t mean just thinking makes it so.

There’s certain criteria which determine which we follow. You know? But nothing is everything is dependent upon everything is merely labeled by conceptuality and language. We’re going use that. There’s an interest in I don’t know if that’s How are we doing out there?

Pretty hard? What’s hard? Trying to identify what part of it comes from us when we can see. So I can grasp that our interpretation of it comes from our side and our classification of it, our judgement of it, and our analysis of it, and all of that comes from our thinking and our language. And therefore, useful it all.

But, yeah, you really put me into a spin now thinking back about the kids. I mean, what exists to make you? What exists to a one year old who doesn’t talk, who doesn’t have language, who doesn’t? So for something to exist, it doesn’t have to exist for you? If everything depended upon you, we’d be in difficult shape.

Mean, half the world wouldn’t exist, would it? So I’m just wondering if there’s a child who does she goes about, you know, watch her in her little world. She crawls around and she comes up, you know, sees the toys, pull some things out or something is that shape and so she does that to it. You know? And so these things, she’s exist to her but she doesn’t have language.

That’s just put me that’s very confusing. For something to exist it doesn’t have to exist for that baby. For a glass to exist, it doesn’t have to exist as a glass for the baby. It’s a glass, whether she knows the name of it or not. Yeah.

But she she made it. But but she can still make use of it. The glass exists. But the the it’s the glass’s existence is dependent upon language. Somebody called it glass.

Somebody called that beauty. Classified as that. Somebody gave it that name. Without that name glass wouldn’t exist and being thought of it. Somebody called this beautiful.

I mean, this is what art you know, they keep changing in art, fine arts, keep changing the criteria of beauty, don’t You know? With now something is beautiful, you know? Or Well, I think I don’t know if I’m right or not, but I think what you might be trying to me with the glass, it it it the glass is there. We can see it’s there. But perhaps for somebody who made the glass, they would see it as inferior superior.

They look at the craftsmanship. To perhaps a scientist, they’d see the container of a colorless liquid wet. Do you know what mean? Everyone that would look at that glass would perceive a different or have a different interpretation. Exactly.

The mind Even though it’s a glass, the mind in everyone is seeing it as different. We don’t always see the same things. No, that’s quite true. The glass exists. In what way does the glass exist?

It depends upon language and thought for its existence. Without language and thought, the glass would not exist. It doesn’t doesn’t have to exist for me to exist, but it does have to exist for one valid consciousness, the person who gave it the name glass. And then that became acceptable. Maybe, you know, something doesn’t have to be beautiful for me for something to be beautiful.

We could see the same object. Your friend might be my enemy. But you think of that person as your friend, and thereby they become your friend. They aren’t your friend completely from their own side. They have some admirable qualities.

in dependence upon those admirable qualities, you think friend. Okay? And that brings that friend into existence. A combination of admirable qualities from your point of view and that name friend that you’re applying to them. And they become friend for you.

Maybe they’re not a friend for me. I don’t see that. So something’s coming from the side of that person which is appealing to you, and you think of them, Oh, that’s my best friend, or That’s a good friend. And that good friend exists. Without being thought of as a good friend, they wouldn’t be just being a person with admirable qualities that you had a relationship with, but they wouldn’t be a good friend because you haven’t used that thought with regard to them.

I wonder if you kept getting simpler and simpler and simpler, would we all have the same interpretation of glass. Because language has made it complicated, emotions, as you said, beauty or ugliness makes it complicated. But if you could take everything away and get it to its most simple thought, we might all think the same. We might want think that’d be that’d be a terrible one. That’s what the child is doing because the child is a know or carer that it’s a glass.

The child is imitating the mother because the mother has used the glass for a useful purpose to quench its thirst. So all the child is doing is imitating the mother because that’s a practical thing to do when she feels thirst. She doesn’t need to know whether it’s a glass. Doesn’t need to know that. I mean, for it to be a glass, she doesn’t need I can make use of can make use of my computer.

I don’t have any idea how it works for it to function, for me to use it. Don’t even have to know its name. If it was a crystal goblet or or a beautiful colored glass with jewels, then how would everyone think about it? At the moment, it’s a simple glass. But then you talked about attachment and all that and beauty.

Well then, I suppose people would get very attached to something that was elaborate and want it for themselves. Yeah, it’s like that’s a good point. Like, one example which we’ll use later on is like a hundred dollar note. It’s a piece of paper with ink with a bunch of printing on it, isn’t it? And we imbue it with value.

I can take this piece of paper and I can take it in the shop and I can buy all kinds of groceries with this piece of paper. To a termite it’s just a bunch of food. Not termite, you don’t call it termites. So it’s it’s we’ve it’s this agreement we’ve come on come to, a convention that we use. We call this valuable.

This little piece of paper with a bunch of ink on it. We call it valuable. We give it it’s a it’s it’s money. Without that name, money, without the thought of as valuable and so forth, it’s just, you know, this is another piece of paper. We don’t call this valuable.

Things are dependent upon our conception and how we think about them. This is going to be, hopefully it will become a When the early Greek mathematicians said the only perfect thing was mathematics, like a a sphere, a cone. Do you think they had something? Because I because a sphere is a sphere to everyone, isn’t it? It’s got me thinking now.

A cone is a cone to everyone. So perhaps that’s what the pure thought that they were talking about when they said pure mathematics cannot be misinterpreted. Because a sphere is a sphere. Have you ever seen a sphere? Well, suppose I’ve seen something that looks like a sphere.

Once you see it, it’s not So is be perfect. Sphere is an abstraction, isn’t it? Yes. Got to be perfect in your mind, or a circle or something. So we can talk about beach balls, but that beach ball is not.

Is that beach ball’s perfect sphere? Probably not, if you measured it all up, they look good, don’t they? They look good. I wonder if that’s what they’re meaning, because they would always talk about it can’t be misinterpreted. A sphere is a sphere, and a cone is a cone.

You can’t like, a glass can be or something else. But they said pure mathematics is the only truth. But it can be misinterpreted because if you see a cone from the top, it looks like a circle. So you’re not looking at it from all sides. How do you know if it’s cone?

Well, perhaps I just meant the sphere then or or a cube. But yes. But it’s I think what it is, it’s the abstract thought, isn’t it? It’s the thought, not what you see. Is that what you mean?

Like, once you get a thought in here So it’s an idea. That’s purer than Yeah. Your idea of your lover. What’s your ideal? She’s she’s perfect.

Can I do your lover? Oh, you’re your lover? The Tibetans have a saying, A lover’s cup is never dirty. It’s pure. You’re lover.

Perfect. What do you think of that Jampa? What? The sphere? Lover?

The cube and all that. A sphere and a cube. Oh, I’ve never really thought about it. That’s perfect. I don’t know what they It would be a perfect I mean, is there a perfect dog?

Does that have any meaning to say that? I have an idea in my mind. I’d like to get a dog, a perfect dog. But when I translate that into some physical reality, there’s always going to be something, an imperfection. So I can think about these ideas of Yeah.

But then in mathematics, probably there’s no attachment or emotion involved, is it? One those interesting thoughts. Yeah. So we created a lot of positive energy together, I think. I hope I haven’t confused you too much.

I admire you for your patience. You guys must. Anyway, we can dedicate this. Dedicate this. May all beings everywhere plagued by suffering of body and mind attain an ocean of happiness and joy by virtue of my merits.

May no living creatures suffer, commit evil, or fall ill. May no one be afraid or belittled with a mind weighed down by depression. May the blind see forms and deaf hear sounds. May those whose bodies are worn with toil be restored on finding repose. May the naked find clothing, the hungry find food.

May the thirsty find water and delicious drink. May the poor find wealth, those weak with sorrow find joy. May the happiness and prosperity. May there be timely rains and bountiful harvests. May all medicines be effective and wholesome prayers bear fruit.

May all who are sick and ill quickly be freed from their ailments. Whatever diseases there are in the world, may they never occur again. May the frightened cease to be afraid, and those bound be freed. May the powerless find power, and may people think of benefiting each other. For as long as space remains, for as long as sentient beings remain, until then may I too remain to dispel the miseries of the world.

Through these skillful actions, may I quickly become an awakened spiritual master and lead each and every living being to the awakened realm. May the supreme jewel, the awakened heart that has not arisen arise and grow, and may that which has arisen never diminish, but increase more and more. In the land circled by snow mountains, you are the source of all happiness and well-being. Powerful Chenrezig, Tenzin Gyatso, please remain to the end of cyclic existence. Thank you.

Would you like to get a cup of tea? We’ll have a discussion. Good night. Take care.

Key terms in this teaching

Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
two extremes tha nyi (Tib)
Eternalism, seeing things as having an intrinsic reality, and nihilism, seeing things as having no reality at all. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top