1 h 45 min · 10,510 words · 26 May 2008 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Opening with a Martin Buber quote — “The decisive heart-searching is the beginning of the way” — Ven Jampa Gendun frames this 105-minute session around what we truly seek beneath social conditioning and material goals. A parable of a king who wants to pave his entire kingdom in leather, until a wise minister suggests sandals instead, anchors the argument that training our own mind is the only realistic path to peace. The bulk of the session is a guided meditation and detailed commentary on Tonglen (taking and giving): three levels of compassion and love — caring, wishing, resolving — applied to oneself, loved ones, and enemies, across present, future, and ultimate dimensions, with vivid visualizations of self-centeredness being progressively destroyed at each stage. A Q&A closes on the strong resistance practitioners feel when genuinely committing to take on another’s pain.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 12 3PA 2008 05 26.mp3
UUID: b945620d-c2e4-4f97-b8a7-7238dcf9e34a
Teacher: Ven Jampa Gendun
Collection: Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Date: 2008-05-26
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 105.3 minutes
Words: ~10,507
How is everybody? Good. Good. Good. Good.
Not too wet? Can you hear me okay in the back? Okay. I don’t know if that’s a good thing or bad. Anyway, we’ll try.
So we have to kind of reach down in ourselves and work with these minds of ours, these tough minds that don’t quite want to do what we want them to do, and change our motivation, develop. Maybe I doubt if you have a negative motivation, maybe you’re wet, maybe you’re, Why’d that come? I should have stayed home. I don’t know, maybe an indifferent motivation. So it’s, you know, it’s to our benefit if we work motivation with inside of ourselves to transform what may be an indifferent motivation to a positive motivation.
So for my little part I play, I try to create some kind of condition for that. I’m relying on you guys to do the work. This is I think it was nineteenth century. Buddhist not Buddhist, Jewish mystic, Martin Buber. The decisive heart searching is the beginning of the way in a man’s life.
It is again and again the beginning of a human way. So, know, we’re talking about beginning the path. The the path is where we are now and where that might be, where we can find ourselves. And we’re beginning to form some kind of image around the kind of person we might want to be, the goal of the path. And the path is that which connects those two, ourselves as we conceive ourselves in the present and as we would like to see ourselves in the future.
So, you know, the beginning, I think there’s a great deal of heart searching or soul searching, if you like. If Buddhism believed in her soul, we’d probably do that. At least some kind of poignant asking of ourselves, What is this all about? You know, don’t think we come to this practice or we don’t come to Buddhism voluntarily or out of curiosity, but out of some need to resolve some desperate questions which maybe aren’t even articulated within our own mind that we haven’t fully formulated. What kind of life do I truly admire?
What is my joy? What is sacred for me. So much of our lives is spent in longing, in a search for what we do not know. So many of our ostensible goals, so many of the things we think we want, turn out to be the masks behind which our real desires hide. They are symbols for the actual values and qualities for which we hunger.
They are not reducible to physical or material things, not even to a physical person. They are psychological qualities love, truth, honesty, loyalty, purpose something we can feel is noble, precious and worthy of our devotion. We try to reduce all this to something physical, a house, a car, a better job or a human being, but it doesn’t work. Without realizing it, we are searching for the sacred. And the sacred is not reducible to anything else.
Sacredness is, in a sense, a feeling, but a feeling that goes to the very heart of life. It is the feeling of recognition directed toward what is great and high enough to give our small lives meaning, to put our personal journeys in a greater perspective. It is the feeling of reverence. What we call the sacred is ultimately a universe of meaning against which we measure our personal efforts, our personal lives, to see whether they too have meaning. So, you know, I think a path in the figurative sense, in the way that we’re talking about it here, in the heart sense, with just some kind of heart searching, some questioning deep within inside of ourselves, trying to find who we are beneath all of these layers of social conditioning, our cultural conditioning, beneath all this religious indoctrination that many of us have been through in one way or another, beneath all of the taken for granted truths of our ideologies and our psychologies, beneath all these kind of these self imposed restraints of You should do that, I ought to do that, in our own individual brands of self deception and self ignorance.
Then we’re trying to tell me who you are and what it is that you are yearning for. What kind of idealized image are you reaching for? And then we really know who we are. And there are who talk to us at a party, what do you do for a living?’ what do you do?’ that’s interesting. What do you do for hobbies?’ all that’s it.
But you can tell them all of that, and they don’t know who you are at all. That’s just an outward description of social custom. If someone were to walk up to you at a party and say, What is it that you yearn for most? If you’re willing to, in that moment, to expose yourself, then they could get an idea, they could come to understanding about who you really are. What is the compelling image that arises in your mind telling us what we would have ourselves be, you know, what we would have ourselves do.
And I think it’s important. This is what, you know, in a way this is what we do, isn’t it? When we pause and we just for these few minutes before we involve ourselves in another activity, we create some kind of gap where we’re with ourselves. We stop distracting ourselves from ourselves and we check up. And our priorities, what am I really about?
What has meaning for myself? Today is Monday, isn’t it? It’s a new week and we’ve started our cycle of various activities. Outside of the practical necessity of having to make a living, forth, what has the overall direction of our day been? Has it taken us any further in the person that we want to become?
Who we’d like ourselves to be, you know, five years from now, ten years from now. If it hasn’t today, then when will it? You know, we have to ask ourselves. You know, the world that each of us comes to know, each of our individual world versions begins with just the images within our mind, the ideas which are drawn from out of our imagination, inner metaphor which each of us are unknowingly living by. There’s a verse which I like very much, which many of you have heard.
It’s by my old friend Ryokan. Ryokan was an eighteenth century Zen Buddhist monk. He kind of, in a way, he embodies. Embolizes? There’s no such word.
Embodies. Good one. Thank you. Embodies the image of who I might like to be. You know, I lived a number of years.
I guess maybe I’m getting a bit nostalgic, the rainy cold night. I lived a number of years in India, and quite often it was a rainy cold night. And there was no television, there were no distractions. Sometimes I take out my little book his poetry. It’s called One Robe, One Bowl.
And I spent a lot of time getting to know Ryokan, so he’s like an old friend. Buddha is your mind, and the way goes nowhere. Don’t look for anything but this. If you point your cart north when you’re going to go south, how will you ever arrive? So Buddha you know, we can talk about him in a rather technical sense, in a doctrinal sense, but maybe we can talk about it in another sense which maybe speaks to our hearts, perhaps in some ways is more of an immediate relevance to ourselves.
You know, Buddha represents the idealized image that is driving all our wanderings, you know, what maybe we’ve been looking for all along unknowingly, what we’ve been searching for, you know, behind the mask that we normally get hung up with, into the living solution to life’s fundamental problems and the realization of the sacred in our lives. That’s what we call Buddha. We could call it a lot of things. Maybe you can find some name that’s most meaningful for yourself. But just for this present discussion, we can call it a Buddha.
So Buddha stands for our experience, the finest story that we could possibly tell ourselves about ourselves in terms of who I might be, what I might do with this crazy life of ours that someday is going to come to an end. You know, essentially a Buddha is someone who experiences unremitting peace with inside themselves and works fearlessly and skillfully with others in order to help them to experience the same. And moreover, this Buddha is our own mind. There’s a Zen saying that I like very much: If you see the Buddha on the road, kill him. And that’s a rather radical thought, don’t tell anybody I said that, okay?
If you see the basic solutions to your life’s fundamental problems outside yourself, you’re looking in the wrong place. We have no choice the way to look where the solutions can be found if we’re ever to have any realistic hope of ever finding it. There’s a certain dishonesty in demanding that the world be other than the way it is. And this is all that Buddhism is trying to help us to do, is live in accordance with the way things are, trying to describe the way things are, help us to overcome our misconceptions, our wrong projections around the way things are, and begin to harmonize ourselves, our ways of being, our thinking, our behavior with just that reality. Then we can find some solutions.
That very harmonizing is the solution. You know, there’s a that’s a story I tell you heard a number of times. It’s about you know, the the the entire orientation of Buddhism is in terms of our mind, isn’t it? And that’s the bottom line about Buddhism. We are to please God, we are not to live for the state, we are to change our minds.
I think that’s a difficult task, but at least we have to know what it is that we’re about, you know, where we should be addressing, looking to, in order to solve our problems in terms of changing our minds. Otherwise, there’s no real hope, is there? It’s about a king who, in ancient times, you know, used to like to roam about his countryside, you know, taking walks about his kingdom. And one day he was out walking and he stepped on a thorn, and it hurt. So he went back to the castle or his palace, and he called together his ministers, and he put his royal foot up on the table.
And he said, Look, look, you’ve got to do something. You’ve got to figure out a way I can walk about my kingdom without the danger of stepping on thorns and sharp objects and so forth. And so, you know, his ministers, they thought and they thought and they thought. And finally, one of the clever ministers spoke up and said, I have an idea. We’ll cover all the roads in your kingdom with leather.
And that way, the king can walk about safely throughout his kingdom without the danger of stepping on sharp rocks and thorns and so forth. And the king said, Fantastic idea. Let’s do that. But if you’ve ever I don’t know if you’ve ever been on a committee, there’s always this one fellow or sometimes it’s not a fellow, sometimes it’s a woman who says, It can’t be done. The treasurer says, It can’t be done.
First off, there aren’t enough cattle in your kingdom to produce that much leather. Even if there were, to buy that much leather would bankrupt the treasury. It’s not practically possible. So they thought and they thought and they thought. And finally, as is often the case in these stories, there was an old wise minister.
And she said, I propose that we cut out two small pieces of leather, which are the shape of the king’s feet. And we take these two pieces of leather and we tie them to the soles of the king’s feet with leather thongs. And this would serve the same purpose. It would be as if all the roads in your kingdom were covered with leather, and the king could walk about the countryside and complete safety without the danger of stepping on thorns or sharp rocks and so forth. So this story is meant first to illustrate something which is more or less obvious, but though it may be obvious, we oftentimes overlook it.
That is, we cannot control the world. We cannot realistically order the world about us to conform to our wishes, demand that it follow our needs, that it fit with our particular personal unique agendas. But nevertheless we try, we do in in our own particular ways. And when we do, we experience either a sense of rage because the world simply doesn’t run according to our order, what we think it should, or we experience a sense of emptiness and failure because we can’t do the impossible. But additionally, this story is meant to illustrate a not so obvious fact of life.
If we can control one thing, our own mind, it is as if we control the world. And that’s all that we can realistically hope to gain control over in our life, in our world, is our own mind. And but as it turns out, that’s sufficient. That’s enough to be happy in this world, to find peace and fulfillment and meaning in our lives, our own mind. You know, the mind that’s in its place, in its way, can make a heaven of hell a hell of heaven.
It is the determinant of all things. In a way, in a way, I think, in a very real way, in truth the things and the people and the situations about us are neutral. You know, like a knife in the hand of a surgeon can be life enhancing, can be constructive. That same exact knife in the hands of a murderer can bring misery, destruction. That same knife.
So, you know, so it’s not so much, you know, the people that we interact with, the objects, the things that we make use of, the situations that we find ourselves in, have the potential potential to be either a source of well-being, a source of fulfillment, giving our life some kind of purpose, or they can be simply sources of difficulty, sources of suffering, depending on our mind’s skill or lack of skill in relating to them, or understanding our attitudes, our opinions about them. And like I think it was Shakespeare who said, There is nothing good or bad, but thinking makes it so. So it’s not so much the people, the situations, the things about us which cause us problems, but our our our own opinions, our attitudes, our our world view, which can make our world problematic. So the path begins with this kind of orientation in terms of changing our own mind. You know, we always have to keep coming back to the own mind.
We live in a materialist society. We’re bombarded with messages which say, If only you have this, you will be happy, you won’t have that problem. So it’s our society by its very nature, our economic system and our culture, to a large extent externalize ourselves in finding the problems and therefore the solutions outside of ourselves. We we our hope is hope for the wrong things. And if we ever hope to find a solution, we have to actually look where they’re to be found within our own mind.
No matter how difficult it is and it is difficult, it is, but we don’t have any choice. I think Krishnamurti said for the intelligent person there are very few choices in life. In a way, we don’t have much choice. If we’re ever to find solutions to our core problems, we have to actually look where they can be found with our own mind, no matter how difficult. It is difficult, but nonetheless we have no choice.
And it’s like someone who loses their car keys, their keys to their house along a dark unlit street, but they look for them on the corner where it’s well lit, thinking how much easier their search is going to go, you know, how much easier it is to look there. But the reality of the situation is, if they’re ever to have any realistic hope of finding what it is they’re looking for, they have to look at least where it’s to be found, no matter how difficult the search may be. We don’t have any choice. So, you know, I guess this is something that we each have to confront for ourselves in each and our own ways, beginning to question what it is that I really want and where can I find it? You know, asking these kind of questions to ourselves.
But maybe, you know, and as best we can, waiting in some kind of silence, openness for some kind of answer. But maybe, in a deeper sense, maybe the answers aren’t so important. And maybe the questions are really what’s important. Point is, this heart searching is in itself the beginning of a way when we begin to question what it’s all about. How far have I gotten in my life?
And is it where I’m taking? Is it where I want to go? You know, these deeply felt you know, the Buddha asks a question to himself: Is life just a bitch and then you die? And is this all there is? Or is there solution to the problem of suffering?
And he was willing to renounce his kingdom and his family and set off in search of an answer. And out of that burning question came a burning answer, which transformed him, which made him into a Buddha. So even in our small ways we can ask those kinds of questions and come up with, even in our small ways, some kinds of intermediate answers for ourselves. But maybe it’s not so much, you know, these questions can become our finest teachers. Maybe gradually, without even noticing it, we will live our way into the answers.
From the point of Buddhism, the answer is called awakening. So the inner focus of our life becomes Buddha. Answer to this question, the deepest, most far reaching fundamental question of human existence in terms of the human condition. But, you know, we have to help ourselves in some realistic fashion, and that we call the dharma. We know implementing the methods, finding out the truth of things.
And depending upon the Sangha, the spiritual community, those who are fellow travelers, who the social context in which this questioning and this resolution of our problems actually takes place. And we can try to raise the level of our motivation again and again and again, know, picking ourselves up again and again, readjusting, revisioning what we see as a successful life, such that it includes someone else other than our own egos, something beyond that. We can try for something more than that. Maybe we can aspire to becoming a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. There’s nothing much higher than we could ever hope.
There’s no greater meaning that we could bring to our lives than that. Just to to feel that, to have that arise in our mind, would make our life worthwhile. I go for refuge until I am awakened to the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am awakened to the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha.
Through my practice generosity and the other perfections, may become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am awakened to the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. May all sentient beings have happiness and the causes of happiness. May all sentient beings be free from suffering and the causes of suffering.
May all sentient beings be inseparable from the joy that is without sorrow. May all sentient beings abide in equanimity, free from attachment for some and aversion toward others. Reverently, I prostrate with my body, speech and mind. I present clouds of every type of offering, those actually arranged and imagined. I disclose all my negative actions accumulated during beginningless time and rejoice in all the virtues of superiors and ordinary beings.
Please remain until the end of cyclic existence and turn the wheel of Dharma for migrating beings. I dedicate all virtue, my own and that of others, to the Great awakening. So if you’d like to stand up and stretch for a moment, then we’ll meditate. So we’ll begin as we usually do in terms of just relaxing the body, getting in touch with the body, grounding ourselves in the body. And then the breath exercise, just breathing in comfortably normally, breathing but extending exhalation completely emptying the lungs and doing that six times individually.
And then we’re going to meditate on mindfulness of the breath, and then we’ll meditate on the subject that we’ve been discussing in terms of the three principal aspects of the path: awakening our heart, and more specifically, taking and giving. So we went through the first part of the meditation on taking and giving. And I thought we’d practice that in our meditation. So I’ll lead you through that, just giving a rough idea of where we’re going to go. We can begin with ourselves, or if you feel you’d rather choose someone that you like, that you love.
Generally, I suggest that you begin with yourself, but whatever works for yourself. That’s you, the author. You’re authority on yourself. So imagine yourself in front of yourself. Again, seeing yourself, it’s useful seeing the object, but it’s not the primary focus of the meditation.
And it’s not just the visualization. The feelings are more important, but the visualization can support the feelings. So it’s useful, but not necessary. Now we’re going to look at some of our present difficulties. This person, in this case ourselves.
Because we under because of having contemplated equality of self in others, we know that others are just like ourselves, and then we can understand that. We can understand them. And though in this case, it’s ourselves, we know that this person we can understand that this person is undergoing some present difficulty, maybe some mental problem in terms of loneliness or, you know, maybe things that financial problems. Some kind of worry, disappointment, frustration. There’s always something.
Or it could be something physical, you know, just something, a headache, but it could become could be something worse. Anyways, some physical or mental difficulty. And we know this person doesn’t want this. They’re just like ourselves. Even in this case, it is ourselves.
Nobody wants to suffer. Everybody wants to be happy, just like including this person in front of ourselves. We’re going to and understanding having looked at the disadvantages of other centeredness and the advantages of other centeredness, the disadvantages of self centeredness, we’re going to determine, you know, we’re going to develop three levels of compassion. So compassion is concerned with suffering. And we’re going to develop a caring compassion, a wishing compassion, and a resolution of compassion.
So with regard to this person’s suffering, this person we know doesn’t want to suffer. And we know what, you know, we’ve exchanged exchanged ourselves with others. We’re able to empathize. We would know that we would like somebody to help ourselves out when we’re having difficulty, when we’re having problems. Wouldn’t it be nice to have somebody there for you?
Well, this person is no different. They would like to have somebody there for them as well. Determining that you’re going to be there for this person in the course of developing these three levels of compassion. First, just simply a friendly, caring thought, just connecting with this person in terms of their suffering. You know, we can all do this in a genuine fashion if we work with it.
Wouldn’t it be nice if you didn’t have this problem, this mental problem or this physical difficulty, this suffering. I would like that. Just a friendly, caring attitude. If we can generate that and we try to increase the intensity of that compassion to a caring compassion, wishing compassion. I wish you didn’t have this problem.
May be free of this problem. You know, really, you know, coming to some kind of conclusion in your own mind about their difficulty. And then if we can develop that, we try to intensify that into some kind of resolution. We actually are going to get involved in this person’s life, in this person’s pain. I’m going to help you.
I’m going to take responsibility in working with your problems and freeing you from your suffering. And then remembering that having contemplated the disadvantage of the self centeredness itself, a great deal of our life’s suffering, most of our problems, our loneliness, our inability to trust, to love, frustrations, conflicts, arise out of this self-cherishing attitude, this exaggerated self concern. And we’re going to take that person’s suffering and we’re going to place it where it belongs. And if there’s one thing that we should we can have aversion for in a healthy fashion, and we can be disgusted with, it’s our own self centeredness. Imagine when self centeredness is a black egg at the center of your chest, like a, you know, a polished marble egg, something like that.
And that’s your self centeredness. You know, we’re talking images, aren’t we? This symbolizes something for you, has some kind of meaning for you. And you’re going to take this person’s suffering and you’re going to place it upon the one thing that deserves their suffering. That one thing that you want your self-centeredness doesn’t want most in this world is suffering, especially the suffering of another.
So imagine their suffering taking upon yourself in a form of thick black smoke, which rises up through your nostrils and down and eats away at the black egg of self centeredness at your heart like acid. It keeps eating it away, again and again taking the suffering. Again and again, eating away the black egg of self centeredness at your heart. Until finally their suffering is complete. This present suffering is completely removed, completely gone, and the black egg of self centeredness at your heart is completely destroyed.
But still they don’t have happiness, though you’ve taken their suffering on. So we want to develop the three levels of love. Love is concerned with happiness. Knowing that this person wants to be happy, they’re just like yourself. Developing these three levels of love, just as in case with compassion, beginning with a simple caring.
Wouldn’t it be nice? You know, just a friendly connectedness with this person. I would like if you had that positive counterpart to that previous suffering, whatever it might have been. If it was loneliness, then a beautiful, loving partner. If you were having economic difficulties, plenty of money, a nice, good job, whatever.
Whatever. You know, if you’re having physical difficulties, a healthy body. And remembering the advantages of other centeredness, how, you know, some of our greatest moments of meaning and purpose in our lives, greatest moments of fulfillment are associated with being there for others, forgetting about, you know, our habitual self centeredness and somehow stepping out of that. The advantages of other centeredness. And imagine I’m going to give it all away.
Developing these three levels of love, caring and then wishing, I’m going to help you. And then resolving, I’m going to, you know, I’m going to work with you in bringing happiness. Transforming all of your all that you want to hold on to. Just imaginatively letting it all go. In your possessions, said to be we can include your merit, what a positive energy that you’ve created over in the past, but even your own body in the form of bright white light forming at the heart area.
And you’re going to give it all away. You’re going to let go in order to bring this person happiness. Imagine that white light rising up, coming out of your nostrils, and as it approaches them, it transforms into the positive counterpart of that previous negativity, that previous suffering, whatever it might have been. Healthy body, financial, you know, well-being, loving partner, whatever would make them happy. And as it approaches them, it transforms into that, placing them into complete happiness the positive counterpart of that previous suffering that they had.
And then we simply want to rejoice in their newfound happiness, be glad for them, and share empathetically in their newfound happiness. Okay? So we’re going to work through that. So take in a comfortable firm posture. So we begin with relaxing the body, starting at the crown of the head, the scalp, and feeling the wrinkles in your brow beginning to smooth out the pressure in and around your eyes diminishing the muscles of the face softening, relaxing, your jaws relaxed.
Your awareness to the back of your neck and perhaps gently turning your head to each side a few times. Very gently stretching, loosening the muscles at the back of the neck. Relaxing muscles of the throat. Bringing your awareness to the upper back and shoulders, perhaps rotating your shoulder a few times. Lifting them, allowing them to drop comfortably to the sides.
Feeling this burden, this weight that we carry around on our backs moving down and through your body into the ground, like some burden that you’ve been carrying around all day which you weren’t even aware of. It’s just been lifted off your shoulders. And bringing your awareness all the way down to your hands. Your hands are soft and loose. Relax in your lower arms and your upper arms.
The chest is at ease. Relaxing throughout the heart area and the lungs and the middle part of the back. Stomach. Reducing the tension that we hold in our stomach muscles, just allow belly to go soft. Keeping your back straight, your trunk erect, relax your lower back muscles.
Your buttocks. Throughout the upper legs and the lower legs. And finally your feet. Bring your awareness to your body in general noticing any tightnesses, any tensions remaining in the body, any areas of discomfort. Focusing upon those areas consciously relaxing, softening, feeling the tension diminish, the tightness loosen.
If there’s some discomfort, don’t don’t struggle against it or resist it. Just surround it with a kind acceptance. It’s part of who you are at present. Be kind to yourself and allow it to be. It’s okay if it’s there.
Body becoming comfortable, at ease, feeling the physical well-being pervading every part of your body. It’s a nice place to be in your body. Nowhere to go, nothing to do but be your body. Just be your body. Stay with your body.
And we’ll practice the six part breath exercise, breathing in comfortably normally, breathing out to extend an exhalation, completely emptying the lungs, and doing this six times individually. And when you’ve completed the breath exercise, bring your mind to the breath. The easy, gentle, in that flow of the breath. If it’s helpful, use the techniques of counting and noting the breaths. Bring your mind back to the breath.
Sit up straight and tall like a mountain. Stay awake. Stay aware. Bring your mind back. So now we’re going to meditate on taking and giving.
And we’re going to begin with ourselves, if you so choose. So imagine yourself in front of yourself. Just the person that this meditation is centered around is yourself. If you can’t see yourself, it’s not so important. Getting this person in front of you is suffering in some way, some present physical or mental problem, difficulty, pain in their life.
They’re just like you. They don’t want to suffer. Nonetheless, they suffer. Wouldn’t it be nice if you didn’t have this problem, if you didn’t have this difficulty, if you didn’t have this suffering, I would like that. It would be wonderful.
See if you can think that with regard to this person. Feel that, even in this case yourself. That would be nice if you didn’t have this present difficulty. I would like that. Let’s see if we can intensify that feeling.
I don’t want you to suffer. May you be free of this difficulty, this suffering, this problem. That’s what I want. I wish it were so. Try to feel feel it.
And we try to intensify that level of compassion. I’m going to do something. I’m going to take responsibility in working with you to eliminate that suffering. I’m committed to you helping you. I’m gonna take that suffering on myself.
I’m going to put it where it belongs, on my own self centeredness. So imagine your self centeredness as a black egg at the center of your chest. This is what has caused you all your difficulties, your problems, all your conflicts, disharmony, distress, paranoia, fear your entire life. It’s there in the form of a black egg at your heart. All that’s wrong with your life.
And you’re going to take this person’s suffering and destroy it. So imagine, visualize, if you can, that this person’s present difficulty, whatever it may be, transforms into thick black smoke. And that thick black smoke moves upward, streaming upward through your nostrils and down, and again and again, eating away like acid at your own self centeredness, the egg of self centeredness at your heart. Destroy your own self centeredness Now this person is no longer experiencing their present suffering, in this case yourself. Still they aren’t happy.
I know I want to be happy. I’m sure this person does too. Wouldn’t it be wonderful if you had positive counterpart to their previous suffering? I would like that. Wish them well.
Connect up with them in a friendly, caring thought. I want you to be happy. I wish you happiness. So getting involved. Really wish that they had this happen.
I’m going to do something. I’m going to take responsibility to ensure that you find happiness. You’re my responsibility. I’m committed to you. Make a commitment to yourself, to bring yourself happiness.
And remember all the advantages of other cherishing. It’s really the most meaningful and purposeful thing we can do with our lives, our most wonderful experiences over the course of our lives, is when we’re there for others in some significant way. I’m going to give it all away. Thinking of all the various things that we want to hold on to, that we value most possessions, possessions, our merit, even our bodies. I’m going to give it all to you.
All of it transforms into a brilliant white light forming at the center of your chest. All that you want to hold on to, all that is valuable, is transformed into this brilliant white light streaming upward and out your nostrils. And as it approaches them, it transforms into the positive counterpart of their previous suffering, whatever it might have been, Bringing them happiness of body and mind. Again and again, give it all away. Again and again, bring them happiness.
You brought a smile to their face, well-being to their life. They’re happy. Just be glad for them. Rejoice Rejoice and share in their happiness. You made somebody else happy.
It was a wonderful thing to do. Be glad. And bring your mind back to the breath. Get in touch with your body. Perhaps the pressure of your buttocks on the cushion, on the chair, just some feeling sensation within the body.
And slowly become aware of your surrounding. If you’d like to stand up and stretch, you’re welcome. It’s a long long meditation. So continuing, you know, the explanation of this practice of taking and giving, you know, it just follows on very much as we just did now. We’ve described the object toward whom we’re developing these levels that we’re practicing taking and giving with.
It begins with ourselves, we develop these three levels of compassion and taking on their present suffering in the form of this thick black smoke and eating away the self centeredness in the aspect of a black egg in our heart, and then in the giving, transforming all our possessions and so forth into a brilliant white light, having generated three levels of love, this simple caring, and then strengthening that, intensifying that with a wishing in terms of happiness, then finally taking responsibility to bring this happiness and this white light flowing out, transforming into that positive counterpart of their present suffering that we’ve removed previously. Previously. So this is simply repeated again in terms of the temporal future sufferings and temporal future happinesses and then ultimate happiness. Going through this process again. It’s interesting, the idea of visualization, it has some kind of impact on the mind.
Even if we I mean, the feelings are primary, but just going through the motions of doing it I think is useful, is beneficial. So we, with regard to ourself, which we’re using as our present object, thinking about some future sufferings, okay? We’re just going to do the same, almost the exact same meditation. Slight variations in terms of visualization, follows the same formula, the same template. But now we’re going to consider some future sufferings of this person, you know, in this case ourselves.
You know, maybe the loss of a partner, it’s not very nice to think about, but it could be a possible future suffering. Maybe the loss of their health, their job, you know, for me, the loss of my memory. I can’t remember things as well as I used to. It gets to be a hassle sometimes. But of course, then there’s the suffering of our future death.
But it doesn’t have to be heavy duty, it’s really traumatic. It could be having to go to the dentist next week, having to get out of bed on a cold winter morning to go to work. So, you know, something that you can feel. It doesn’t have to be completely abstract or heavy, dramatic. Something where you get some feeling for at some level.
And then going through the three levels of compassion. Do you have a sense around these three levels of compassion? Distinguishing them? That’s, you know, getting more involved. And the first is simply this friendly, just connecting in terms of suffering.
You know, wouldn’t it be nice? I think most of us can generate that if we quite readily. I think most of us are naturally pretty caring people. We’re not hard hearted. So this level of compassion can arise quite readily if we if we we put our minds to it.
Just a friendly thought. It would be nice if you didn’t have that problem. We could almost wish that about anybody we put it. Maybe not an enemy, okay? But anyway, we can work on that later.
And then getting more involved and wishing it were so, and coming to some conclusion in your mind, what it is you’re at and really clarifying, Well, I don’t want you to suffer. Becoming more involved. And then finally, I’m going to do something. You’re really getting involved. This time, imagining, you know, in terms of their self centeredness, imagining in the form of a hunk of raw meat.
This is another this is the explanation of visualization that was taught to me, another aspect. Okay? This big hunk of raw meat that’s your self centeredness at the center of your chest. And imagine, previously imagine, you know, working through these three levels of compassion. I’m going to take on that suffering.
And this time we take it on in the form, in the aspect of ferocious animals. These are all the, like lions and tigers and jackals and wild boar, you know, whatever, all these carnivores. I know, are wild boar of carnivores? Anyway, they probably are, if they had a chance. So they’re streaming, so all this present, this future suffering, you know, whether it’s as simple as having to get out of a warm bed and go to work in the morning on a cold winter morning, or whether it’s something very much more traumatic, you know, relationship difficulties or whatever, streaming upward in the aspect.
They rise up and down and they, as they approach that hunk of meat, they rip at the shreds, they devour it, you know, really get tough, really get into this is your self centeredness, it’s torn to shreds, torn to bits, you know. Okay. Then having it again and again finally destroyed your self centeredness, completely removed that future suffering of this person, but still they don’t have future happiness. So again, developing these three levels of love with regard to this person. You know, this simple caring, wishing, then finally resolving, and resolving around the positive counterpart to that.
They had relationship difficulties, there’s a possibility they might get divorced in the future or break up in a loving relationship. They worked it out. They went to a good marriage counselor or whatever. Things are going well. So going to whatever the positive counterpart to that previous, you know, they have their office in their home, they don’t have to go outside.
It’s a holiday that day, They don’t have to get out of bed. I don’t know anything. Developing these three levels of love and, again, transforming the very same that we did before in terms of, you know, whatever it is that we want to hold up. See, a lot of this is going directly against what we call the eight worldly concerns, the eight principal preoccupations of ego, you know, the pursuit of pleasure, the avoidance of pain. These are the criteria we normally operate in, the rules of operating in the world.
Try to at all costs we pursue pleasure, at all costs we avoid pain. And here we’re doing it. This is the adverse event. We’re pursuing suffering and we’re giving away our own happiness. It’s completely antithetical, completely goes in the opposite direction of our normal habitual way of relating with the world.
You know, acts as an opponent to the eight worldly concerns. Giving away everything that we value, these are the things you normally want to hold on to. You’re going to give it away. Letting go. So our possessions, our merit, even our body, streaming up in the form of brilliant white light and approaching them and transforming into the positive counterparts of that future suffering.
This is temporal future happinesses. Okay, so we’re working with ourselves, we’ve worked at the level of the present, suffering, future, temporal happiness and suffering. But now we’re going to concern ourselves with ultimate happiness and suffering. You know, there’s nothing within cyclic existence, an approach to life which is under the control of karma and afflictive emotions, essentially most, that it’s worth having or being. There’s no state under the control of karma and afflictive emotion that is completely satisfactory, that is reliable, that is lasting.
None of it is true happiness. Having gotten some sense of what this is all about with regard to this person in front of you, that this person, no matter how smoothly things go with cyclic existence, within this ego empire. It’s not all that life could be. And so it’s suffering. It’s dissatisfactory by its very nature.
And we’ve talked about this a great deal in the past. And you’re going to take that suffering, this ultimate suffering, this very subtle suffering, upon yourself. So again, the three levels of, you know, what is the basis of that suffering? What is the basis of saṃsāra? You know, ultimate or the most fundamental dysfunctional patterns of our mind are self grasping and self centeredness, ignorance in our self centeredness.
These are fundamental, you know. This is the causes of all of our problems. I’m going to take that. Working through these three levels of compassion. Wouldn’t it be wonderful if you didn’t have self centeredness and self grasping in your mind, the very causes of suffering?
Completely gone. That would be wonderful. I would like Fantastic. Now, may you not have the causes of suffering, self centeredness, self grasping. I’m going to do something, and I’m going to take that on.
So again, imagine your self centeredness in this context, in this case, a block of granite, stone, the center of your chest. And you’re going to take on all the causes of suffering, most basically self centeredness and self grasping, and that which arises out of that, the very subjective emotions, and out of that karma. I’m going to take that. And taking it on in the aspect of weapons of war, mass destruction, fighter planes, tanks, guns, knives, bullets, come streaming upwards and down, and they begin to pulverize, you know, bombs blowing up. It’s really like World War II movies where they were there were this big block of granite that’s been, you know, pieces that were splitting off and breaking and crumbling.
And then finally, again and again, taking on this suffering in the form of these weapons. And really, you know, getting into it, you know, really getting fed up with your self centeredness, really getting heavy with it, blowing it up. So finally it’s gone again and again. But this person Okay, so now they’re not going to have these various future types of suffering ever again. They’ve gone beyond suffering, they’re at peace.
But still they haven’t realized their fullest potential, what they can become, you know, a Buddha. There’s nothing more than you could ever hope to wish for a person, that you could want for a person, than that to become a Buddha. There’s nothing finer than that. Wouldn’t it be wonderful if you could realize your fullest potential, actualize all your qualities, wisdom, loving compassion, personal power and become a Buddha. I would like that very much.
May you become a Buddha. I’m going to help you to become a Buddha. Again, thinking of the advantages of other centeredness, transforming our possessions, our body, our merit into this brilliant white light at your heart. It rises up and begins to move out toward them and transforms into a highly realized master, spiritual master, teaching them the Dharma. A Sangha, a spiritual community, who supplies all their needs, assists them in studying and meditating, all the material needs that they need to do a retreat, or that they need to progress along the path.
You know, whatever is all their support, you give all that to them again and again, until finally they realize the entire path and they become a Buddha. And now there’s nothing more that you can do for them. Your work is finished with regard to this person. And just share, you know, rejoice and share empathetically in their newfound bliss. So we work through these three levels of present sufferings, present happiness, future temporal happiness and suffering, and ultimate suffering and happiness with regard to our self.
Generating these three different levels of compassion and love correspondingly. We begin to work with other objects. First, someone that you really love, that you really they matter to you. You quite readily generate some of these feelings using them as the object, you know, and going through the same process, you know. Present suffering, present happiness, future suffering, future happiness, ultimate suffering, ultimate happiness, until you place them in Buddhahood.
And again, moving on to to another and another. You know, moving down, you have a spectrum of individuals, you know, beginning with those you are closest to, and moving those who you aren’t quite so close to. You know, again and again, you know, once you develop some facility, some degree of being able to generate these feelings, move on to another, another. And then all the various types of strangers, Australians and Russians and Chinese and Americans and Catholics, Buddhists, Protestants and Islam. All these different classifications categories that we put strangers in.
Practicing sincerely with, and then finally coming to those people you’re having some hard times with, somebody you don’t like, you don’t feel comfortable with, and then finally the enemy. And working with all these varieties of peoples, lots and lots of instances of particular peoples, then beginning to combine them, build them up, until you have a sense that you genuinely are taking up the suffering of all living beings and giving away your happiness, you know, in terms of the present, future, ultimate, in terms of these three levels of compassion, the three levels of love, again and again and again, like that. And acquainting the mind. There’s nothing that doesn’t become easier upon acquaintance, upon becoming accustomed to. Meditation in Tibetan is gom.
Gom means to accustom, familiarization. That’s all that we’re doing. Familiarizing with his process, with these states of mind, with his attitude. Remember when I said it’s not so much the people and the things and the objects about us which are problematic, but our ideas, our opinions, our attitudes about them. Here we’re working with our attitudes, developing more skillful ways relating with the people, the things around us and within us.
It’s a matter of habituation, accustoming ourselves. There’s no reason why we can’t do this. It’s just a matter of making the effort. When you gain some proficiency, you know, you feel like you’ve got it, you know, doing this very just a little bit. You don’t have to do the whole meditation if you don’t have the time, just a little bit, maybe just the present.
And maybe in the next meditation do the future, in the next meditation session do the ultimate. It takes a long time to do it well, I realize that. Doing it with lots of individuals until you get some feeling for that and you’re moving on. When you develop some proficiency with this, then it’s said that you can mount the practice upon the breath. That is, we synchronize the taking part of the practice with the natural inhalation of the breath.
And we synchronize the giving away with the natural exhalation of the breath. Breathing in, we take on suffering. Breathing out, we give away happiness. Breathing in, we open up to the pain of others and take it upon ourselves, destroying our self centeredness. Breathing out, we let go of our happiness and give it to others, developing other cherishing.
It’s said that the bodhisattva, his very breath is part of his practice. These states of mind, these attitudes become associated with the very breathing process itself. I’m going to talk about how we can do that in a very simple sense. The essence of Tonglen, practice. So Tonglen, we said, was taking and giving.
It’s a Tibetan word. Tong means to give, len means to take. The essence of Tonglen practice is that on the in breath you’re willing to feel pain. You’re willing to acknowledge of the world. From this day onward you’re going to cultivate your bravery and willingness to feel that part of the human condition.
You breathe in so that you can really understand what the Buddha meant when he said that the first noble truth is that life is suffering. What does that mean? With every in breath you try to find out by acknowledging the truth of suffering not as a mistake you made, not as a punishment, but as part of the human condition. With every in breath you explore the discomfort of the human condition which can be acknowledged and celebrated and not run away from. Tonglen puts it right on the line.
The essence of the out breath is the other part of the human condition. With every out breath you open, you connect with the feelings of joy, well-being, satisfaction, tender heartedness, anything that feels fresh and clean, wholesome and good. That’s the aspect of the human condition that we wish were the whole show. That part, the part that if we could finally clear up all our problems, we would have as our everyday diet. The menu would read, Only happiness, no pain here.
There would be all the things that you think would bring you everlasting happiness. Maybe a little bittersweetness, a few little tears, but definitely no heavy duty confusion, no dark places, no closet doors that you don’t want to open, no monsters under the bed, no ugly thoughts, no rage, no despair, no jealousy. Definitely not that. That’s breath, the part you like. You connect with that and you breathe it out so that it spreads and it can be experienced by everyone.
So, you know, as I mentioned, you know, you can begin to see how this practice of taking and giving is completely antithetical to these eight worldly concerns which we talked about previously. Our overriding preoccupation with the pursuit of pleasure, the avoidance of pain, the pursuit of gain, the avoidance of loss, the pursuit of fame, the avoidance of notoriety, the pursuit of praise, the avoidance of criticism. Know, generally we’re single mindedly trying to find chasing after happiness. That’s our criteria on how we’re going to lead our life. The other half is that we’re going to avoid suffering at all costs.
We want to be rid of it. That’s our overriding standard about how we’re going to live our life. Here we’re reversing that process. We’re inviting pain into our lives, the pain of others. God, you know, that’s something we never even thought about doing before.
And we’re going to give away happiness, altruistically. There’s nothing in it for us except real compassion and real love. It’s a real mind training, isn’t it? Of all the practices I know, the practice of Tonglen, taking and giving, is the one of the most useful and powerful. When you feel yourself locked upon yourself, Tonglen opens you to the truth of suffering of others.
When your heart is blocked, it unblocks those forces that are obstructing it. When you feel estranged from the person who is in pain before you, or bitter or despairing, it helps you to find within yourself and then to reveal the loving expansive radiance of your own true nature. No other practice I know is as effective in destroying the self grasping, self-cherishing, self absorption of the ego, which is the root of all our suffering and the root of all hardheartedness. You know, There are ways that we can adapt this, but this is the essential practice we can talk about next week, some ways that we can work with this in our everyday life so we can stay connected with the pain of the world. There’s pain out there.
And somehow we have to make that mindfulness a part of how we live our daily life, in that our life will find meaning. We’ll go beyond our present self preoccupations, self absorption, this closed mindedness which has gotten us nowhere. We can begin to live heroically. You know, this image, what it is that we’re searching for, I think a part of this is there So we can invite it into our lives. So we’ve got a few minutes.
Is there any comments that people want? Questions? Anything people like to talk about? No. Yes?
Yes. I’m not sure what term, but when we got to that third level of intention that I am going to take this pain, I well, first of all, I recognize it’s a, you know, it’s an uncomfortable state. The third, I’m going to take responsibility. Yeah. Boy, was I pulling back and thinking, this is jumping into madness.
I was amazed at my resistance. Yeah, yeah, then you’re actually feeling it, that’s a lot. That’s great. It surprised me how potent. I thought, wow, if I take that step then there’s nothing that’s going to be safe.
This will turn everything. And it did, I mean, my self interest is the basis of the foundation mostly my efforts and my thoughts. This is just and it feels like madness. Yeah, the post office is a bit mad I think. Crazy.
That was very, very strong. I was surprised how resistant I was at taking that step. Even to say I take responsibility for my own happiness? Even that? That kind of acknowledgment is kind of mind opening, I think.
Yeah. Can I ask you about once you once you get to that that thought process of taking responsibility, how do you overcome the negative mindset? My mind tends to trigger these negative mindsets that I can’t actually fix this person’s problems. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Haven’t gotten that’s yeah. But that’s that’s excellent as soon as you’re thinking. I appreciate that.
Yeah, we say, We’re going to come to Anyway, okay, we finish our meditation, we look around, nothing’s changed. Still here, and sentient beings are suffering. It was just all an imagination. But there’s a willingness to take that beyond the level of imagination, to begin to translate that intention into some kind of reality. What can I do?
Right now it’s like the blind leading the blind, isn’t it? It’s only to the degree that I develop myself that I’m actually going to be able, in fact, in some practical way, to be able to translate that wish to be able to benefit others into some kind of reality. So I have to get my own act together. It becomes the motivation ultimately for becoming a Buddha. A Buddha is in the best possible position to be able to benefit others.
Okay, I have to become a happy, healthy, loving, sane human being, really skillful. I have to know my own mind, how to work with mine, understand my situation, the nature of reality, then I can really be there for others. It’s like somebody you really want to be there for, you know. And you say, Well, I got it. You you take a first aid course.
That’s great. You can put bandages on, you can put splints bandages on, you can put splints on, but this person needs a heart bypass. What do you do? Wish you were sure you could use it? I’ll put a bandage there.
Have to study. I have to go to medical school. If I’m really taking responsibility, if that’s to have any real meaning at all. If I’m going to take responsibility, have to develop the ability to respond. Or the word responsibility doesn’t have any meaning.
I have to develop the ability to respond. Therefore it becomes the motivation for getting your own act together. You become a Buddha for the sake of others. A you become a the more I am, the more I have to give. So it becomes an incentive, you know, not doing it just for your own piece of chocolate cake, but you so you can be there more for others.
You go beyond present conceptions and limits. Know, one person is, you know, there’s only one person, but if we have to be there for a lot of, you know, somebody else with the say of all sentient beings, how much further we going to realize our potential and finally get our act together and do something? So anyway, we’re going to come to that. That’s a good question because it’s just at the level of imagination, but it all begins with imagination, working with these images and feelings. Any other comments?
We’ve got a little bit more to go, and then we’ll have to awaken our hearts. Then we have to open our minds so we can dedicate some of this positive potential that we have accumulated together in this way. Think talking about these ideas, working with ideas, meditating on it, slowly there’s change. I’m quite convinced of that over time. You know, we aren’t quite the same person we were a year ago or five years ago.
Our attitudes are shifting, our ways of thinking. Think it’s really a wonderful thing to do. We can lead a balanced life. We can work at this level, but also, you know, having some of the good things in life as well. Then it’s the kind of the best life you can lead.
May all beings everywhere plagued by suffering of body and mind and attain an ocean of happiness and joy by virtue of my merits. May no living creatures suffer, commit evil, or fall ill. May no one be afraid or belittled with a mind weighed down by depression. May the blind see forms and deaf hear sounds. May those whose bodies are worn with toil be restored on finding repose.
May the naked find clothing, the hungry find food. May the thirsty find water and delicious drink. May the poor find wealth, those weak with sorrow find joy. May the forlorn find hope, constant happiness and prosperity. May there be timely rains and bountiful harvests.
May all medicines be effective and wholesome prayers bear fruit. May all who are sick and ill quickly be freed from their ailments. Whatever diseases there are in the world, may they never occur again. May the frightened cease to be afraid and those bound be freed. May the powerless find power and may people think of benefiting each other.
For as long as space remains, for as long as sentient beings remain, until then may I too remain to dispel the miseries of the world. Through these skillful actions may I quickly become an awakened spiritual master and lead each and every living being to that awakened realm. May the supreme jewel, the awakened heart that has not arisen, arise and grow, and may that which has arisen never diminish, but increase more and more. In the land encircled by snow mountains, you are the source of all happiness and well-being. Powerful Chenrezig, Tenzin Gyatso, please remain at the end of cyclic existence.
So if you’d like to get a a cup of tea or a cup and a biscuit, you we’ll come back and have a discussion. Otherwise, have a good week.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- buddha, a sang gye (Tib)
- A fully awakened being, who has totally eliminated all obscurations veiling the mind and has fully developed all good qualities to perfection. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
- The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
- three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
- The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.